Influence of pH on the human prion protein: insights into the early steps of misfolding

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies, or prion diseases, are caused by misfolding and aggregation of the prion protein PrP. Conversion from the normal cellular form (PrP^C) or recombinant PrP (recPrP) to a misfolded form is pH-sensitive, in that misfolding and aggregation occur more readily at lower pH. To gain more insight into the influence of pH on the dynamics of PrP and its potential to misfold, we performed extensive molecular-dynamics simulations of the recombinant PrP protein (residues 90-230) in water at three different pH regimes: neutral (or cytoplasmic) pH (∼7.4), middle (or endosomal) pH (∼5), and low pH (<4). We present five different simulations of 50 ns each for each pH regime, amounting to a total of 750 ns of simulation time. A detailed analysis and comparison with experiment validate the simulations and lead to new insights into the mechanism of pH-induced misfolding. The mobility of the globular domain increases with decreasing pH, through displacement of the first helix and instability of the hydrophobic core. At middle pH, conversion to a misfolded (PrP^Sc-like) conformation is observed. The observed changes in conformation and stability are consistent with experimental data and thus provide a molecular basis for the initial steps in the misfolding process.     

Preferential Cu2+ coordination by His96 and His111 induces beta-sheet formation in the unstructured amyloidogenic region of the prion protein

The prion protein (PrP) is a Cu(2+) binding cell surface glycoprotein that can misfold into a beta-sheet-rich conformation to cause prion diseases. The majority of copper binding studies have concentrated on the octarepeat region of PrP. However, using a range of spectroscopic techniques, we show that copper binds preferentially to an unstructured region of PrP between residues 90 and 115, outside of the octarepeat domain. Comparison of recombinant PrP with PrP-(91-115) indicates that this prion fragment is a good model for Cu(2+) binding to the full-length protein. In contrast to previous reports we show that Cu(2+) binds to this region of PrP with a nanomolar dissociation constant. NMR and EPR spectroscopy indicate a square-planar or square-pyramidal Cu(2+) coordination utilizing histidine residues. Studies with PrP analogues show that the high affinity site requires both His(96) and His(111) as Cu(2+) ligands, rather than a complex centered on His(96) as has been previously suggested. Our circular dichroism studies indicate a loss of irregular structure on copper coordination with an increase in beta-sheet conformation. It has been shown that this unstructured region, between residues 90 and 120, is vital for prion propagation and different strains of prion disease have been linked with copper binding. The role of Cu(2+) in prion misfolding and disease must now be re-evaluated in the light of these findings.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance evidence for binding of Cu(2+) to the C-terminal domain of the murine prion protein.

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies in mammals are believed to be caused by scrapie form of prion protein (PrP(Sc)), an abnormal, oligomeric isoform of the monomeric cellular prion protein (PrP(C)). One of the proposed functions of PrP(C) in vivo is a Cu(II) binding activity. Previous studies revealed that Cu(2+) binds to the unstructured N-terminal PrP(C) segment (residues 23-120) through conserved histidine residues. Here we analyzed the Cu(II) binding properties of full-length murine PrP(C) (mPrP), of its isolated C-terminal domain mPrP(121-231) and of the N-terminal fragment mPrP(58-91) in the range of pH 3-8 with electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. We find that the C-terminal domain, both in its isolated form and in the context of the full-length protein, is capable of interacting with Cu(2+). Three Cu(II) coordination types are observed for the C-terminal domain. The N-terminal segment mPrP(58-91) binds Cu(2+) only at pH values above 5.0, whereas both mPrP(121-231) and mPrP(23-231) already show identical Cu(II) coordination in the pH range 3-5. As the Cu(2+)-binding N-terminal segment 58-91 is not required for prion propagation, our results open the possibility that Cu(2+) ions bound to the C-terminal domain are involved in the replication of prions, and provide the basis for further analytical studies on the specificity of Cu(II) binding by PrP.     

Influence of pH on NMR structure and stability of the human prion protein globular domain

The NMR structure of the globular domain of the human prion protein (hPrP) with residues 121-230 at pH 7.0 shows the same global fold as the previously published structure determined at pH 4.5. It contains three alpha-helices, comprising residues 144-156, 174-194, and 200-228, and a short anti-parallel beta-sheet, comprising residues 128-131 and 161-164. There are slight, strictly localized, conformational changes at neutral pH when compared with acidic solution conditions: helix alpha1 is elongated at the C-terminal end with residues 153-156 forming a 310-helix, and the population of helical structure in the C-terminal two turns of helix alpha 2 is increased. The protonation of His155 and His187 presumably contributes to these structural changes. Thermal unfolding monitored by far UV CD indicates that hPrP-(121-230) is significantly more stable at neutral pH. Measurements of amide proton protection factors map local differences in protein stability within residues 154-157 at the C-terminal end of helix alpha 1 and residues 161-164 of beta-strand 2. These two segments appear to form a separate domain that at acidic pH has a larger tendency to unfold than the overall protein structure. This domain could provide a "starting point" for pH-induced unfolding and thus may be implicated in endosomic PrPC to PrPSc conformational transition resulting in transmissible spongiform encephalopathies.     

Unusual property of prion protein unfolding in neutral salt solution

The unfolding of cellular prion protein and its refolding to the scrapie isoform are related to prion diseases. Studies in the literature have shown that structures of proteins, either acidic or basic, are stabilized against denaturation by certain neutral salts, for example, sulfate and fluoride. Contrary to these observations, the full-length recombinant prion protein (amino acid residues 23-231) is denatured by these protein structure stabilizing salts. Under identical concentrations of salts, the structure of the sheep prion protein, which contains a greater number of glycine groups in the N-terminal unstructured segment than the mouse protein, becomes more destabilized. In contrast to the full-length protein, the C-terminal 121-231 prion protein fragment, consisting of all the structural elements of the protein, viz., three alpha-helices and two short beta-strands, is stabilized against denaturation by these salts. We suggest that an increase in the concentration of the anions on the surface of the prion protein molecule due to their preferential interaction with the glycine residues in the N-terminal segment destabilizes the structure of the prion protein by perturbing the prion helix 1 which is the most soluble of all the protein alpha-helices reported so far in the literature. The present results could be relevant to explain the observed structural conversion of the prion protein by anionic nucleic acids and sulfated glycosaminoglycans.     

Nucleic acid induced unfolding of recombinant prion protein globular fragment is pH dependent

Nucleic acid can catalyze the conversion of α‐helical cellular prion protein to β‐sheet rich Proteinase K resistant prion protein oligomers and amyloid polymers in vitro and in solution. Because unfolding of a protein molecule from its ordered α‐helical structure is considered to be a necessary step for the structural conversion to its β‐sheet rich isoform, we have studied the unfolding of the α‐helical globular 121–231 fragment of mouse recombinant prion protein in the presence of different nucleic acids at neutral and acid pH. Nucleic acids, either single or double stranded, do not have any significant effect on the secondary structure of the protein fragment at neutral pH; however the protein secondary structure is modified by the nucleic acids at pH 5. Nucleic acids do not show any significant effect on the temperature induced unfolding of the globular prion protein domain at neutral pH which, however, undergoes a gross conformational change at pH 5 as evidenced from the lowering of the midpoint of thermal denaturation temperatures, Tm, of the protein. The extent of Tm decrease shows a dependence on the nature of nucleic acid. The interaction of nucleic acid with the nonpolar groups exposed from the protein interior at pH 5 probably contributes substantially to the unfolding process of the protein.     

Conformational dimorphism and transmembrane orientation of prion protein residues 110-136 in bicelles.

A fragment corresponding to the putative membrane-associating domain of the prion protein (residues 110-136) was analyzed in phospholipid bicelles. Prion(110-136) associated with bicelles and exhibited a lipid- and pH-dependent conformational dimorphism between unstructured (pH 4.5) and alpha-helical (pH 7.5). Mutational analysis indicated that the charge state of a single histidine residue was largely responsible for the dimorphism. Amide-lipid NOEs and amide-water chemical exchange measurements revealed that the helical conformation of prion(110-136) spanned the bilayer, and were corroborated by solid-state deuterium NMR experiments indicating that the helical axis rested at a 16 degrees angle with respect to the bilayer normal.     

Evolutionarily Conserved Proline Residues Impede the Misfolding of the Mouse Prion Protein by Destabilizing an Aggregation-competent Partially Unfolded Form

The misfolding of the prion protein has been linked to several neurodegenerative diseases. Despite extensive studies, the mechanism of the misfolding process remains poorly understood. The present study structurally delineates the role of the conserved proline residues present in the structured C-terminal domain of the mouse prion protein (moPrP) in the misfolding process. It is shown that mutation of these Pro residues to Ala leads to destabilization of the native (N) state, and also to rapid misfolding. Using hydrogen–deuterium exchange (HDX) studies coupled with mass spectrometry (MS), it has been shown that the N state of moPrP is in rapid equilibrium with a partially unfolded form (PUF2*) at pH 4. It has been shown that the Pro to Ala mutations make PUF2* energetically more accessible from the N state by stabilizing it relative to the unfolded (U) state. The apparent rate constant of misfolding is found to be linearly proportional to the extent to which PUF2* is populated in equilibrium with the N state, strongly indicating that misfolding commences from PUF2*. It has also been shown that the Pro residues restrict the boundary of the structural core of the misfolded oligomers. Overall, this study highlights how the conserved proline residues control misfolding of the prion protein by modulating the stability of the partially unfolded form from which misfolding commences.     

Misfolding of the prion protein at the plasma membrane induces endocytosis, intracellular retention and degradation

Suramin induces misfolding of the cellular prion protein (PrP(C)) and interferes with the propagation of infectious scrapie prions. A mechanistic analysis of this effect revealed that suramin-induced misfolding occurs at the plasma membrane and is dependent on the proximal region of the C-terminal domain (aa 90-158) of PrP(C). The conformational transition induces rapid internalization, mediated by the unstructured N-terminal domain, and subsequent intracellular degradation of PrP(C). As a consequence, PrP Delta N adopts a misfolded conformation at the plasma membrane; however, internalization is significantly delayed. We also found that misfolding and intracellular retention of PrP(C) can be induced by copper and that, moreover, copper interferes with the propagation of the pathogenic prion protein (PrP(Sc)) in scrapie-infected N2a cells. Our study revealed a quality control pathway for aberrant PrP conformers present at the plasma membrane and identified distinct PrP domains involved.     

Sheep prion protein synthetic peptide spanning helix 1 and beta-strand 2 (residues 142-166) shows beta-hairpin structure in solution

According to the "protein only" hypothesis, a conformational conversion of the non-pathogenic "cellular" prion isoform into a pathogenic "scrapie" isoform is the fundamental event in the onset of prion diseases. During this pathogenic conversion, helix H1 and two adjacent surface loops L2 and L3 of the normal prion protein are thought to undergo a conformational transition into an extended beta-like structure, which is prompted by interactions with the pre-existing beta-sheet. To get more insight into the interaction between the helix and one of the beta-strands in the partially unfolded prion protein, the solution structure of a synthetic linear peptide spanning helix H1 and beta-strand S2 (residues 142-166 in human numbering) was studied by circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopies. We found that, in contrast to many prion fragments studied earlier, this peptide (i) is highly soluble and does not aggregate up to a millimolar concentration range in aqueous medium and (ii) exhibits an intrinsic propensity to a beta-hairpin like conformation at neutral pH. This beta-propensity can be one of the internal driving forces of the molecular rearrangement responsible for the pathogenic conversion of the prion protein.     

Possible role of region 152-156 in the structural duality of a peptide fragment from sheep prion protein

The conformational conversion of the nonpathogenic "cellular" prion isoform into a pathogenic "scrapie" protease-resistant isoform is a fundamental event in the onset of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE). During this pathogenic conversion, helix H1 and its two flanking loops of the normal prion protein are thought to undergo a conformational transition into a beta-like structure. A peptide spanning helix H1 and beta-strand S2 (residues 142-166 in human numbering) was studied by circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopies. This peptide in aqueous solution, in contrast to many prion fragments studied earlier (1) is highly soluble and (2) does not aggregate until the millimolar concentration range, and (3) exhibits an intrinsic propensity to a beta-hairpin-like conformation at neutral pH. We found that this peptide can also fold into a helix H1 conformation when dissolved in a TFE/PB mixture. The structures of the peptide calculated by MD showed solvent-dependent internal stabilizing forces of the structures and evidenced a higher mobility of the residues following the end of helix H1. These data suggest that the molecular rearrangement of this peptide in region 152-156, particularly in position 155, could be associated with the pathogenic conversion of the prion protein.     

Copper(II) inhibits in vitro conversion of prion protein into amyloid fibrils

In recent studies, the amyloid fibrils produced in vitro from recombinant prion protein encompassing residues 89-230 (rPrP 89-230) were shown to produce transmissible form of prion disease in transgenic mice (Legname et al., (2004) Science 305, 673-676). Long incubation time observed upon inoculation of the amyloid fibrils, however, suggests that the fibrils generated in vitro have low infectivity titers. These results emphasize the need to define optimal conditions for prion conversion in vitro, under which high levels of infectivity can be generated in a cell-free system. Because copper(II) has been implicated in normal and pathological functions of the prion protein, here we investigated the effect of Cu(2+) on cell-free conversion of recombinant PrP. Our results show that at pH 7.2 and at micromolar concentrations, Cu(2+) inhibited conversion of full-length recombinant PrP (rPrP 23-230) into amyloid fibrils. This effect was most pronounced for Cu(2+), and less so for Zn(2+), while Mn(2+) had no effect on the conversion. Cu(2+)-dependent inhibition of the amyloid formation was less effective at pH 6.0, at which rPrP 23-230 displays lower Cu(2+)-binding capacity. Using rPrP 89-230, we found that Cu(2+)-dependent inhibition occurred even in the absence of octarepeat region; however, it was less effective. Our further studies indicated that Cu(2+) inhibited conversion by stabilizing a nonamyloidogenic PK-resistant form of alpha-rPrP. Remarkably, Cu(2+) also had a profound effect on preformed amyloid fibrils. When added to the fibrils, Cu(2+) induced long-range coiling of individual fibrils and enhanced their PK-resistance. It, however, produced only minor changes in their secondary structures. In addition, Cu(2+) induced further aggregation of the amyloid fibrils into large clumps, presumably, through interfibrillar coordination of copper ions by octarepeats. Taken together, our studies suggest that the role of Cu(2+) in the pathogenesis of prion diseases is complex. Because Cu(2+) may inhibit prion replication, while at the same time stabilize disease-specific isoform against proteolytic clearance, the final outcome of copper-induced effect on progression of prion disease may not be straightforward.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of human prion protein: importance of correct treatment of electrostatic interactions.

Molecular dynamics simulations have been used to investigate the dynamical and structural behavior of a homology model of human prion protein HuPrP(90-230) generated from the NMR structure of the Syrian hamster prion protein ShPrP(90-231) and of ShPrP(<90-231) itself. These PrPs have a large number of charged residues on the protein surface. At the simulation pH 7, HuPrP(90-230) has a net charge of -1 eu from 15 positively and 14 negatively charged residues. Simulations for both PrPs, using the AMBER94 force field in a periodic box model with explicit water molecules, showed high sensitivity to the correct treatment of the electrostatic interactions. Highly unstable behavior of the structured region of the PrPs (127-230) was found using the truncation method, and stable trajectories could be achieved only by including all the long-range electrostatic interactions using the particle mesh Ewald (PME) method. The instability using the truncation method could not be reduced by adding sodium and chloride ions nor by replacing some of the sodium ions with calcium ions. The PME simulations showed, in accordance with NMR experiments with ShPrP and mouse PrP, a flexibly disordered N-terminal part, PrP(90-126), and a structured C-terminal part, PrP(127-230), which includes three alpha-helices and a short antiparallel beta-strand. The simulations showed some tendency for the highly conserved hydrophobic segment PrP(112-131) to adopt an alpha-helical conformation and for helix C to split at residues 212-213, a known disease-associated mutation site (Q212P). Three highly occupied salt bridges could be identified (E146/D144<-->R208, R164<-->D178, and R156<-->E196) which appear to be important for the stability of PrP by linking the stable main structured core (helices B and C) with the more flexible structured part (helix A and strands A and B). Two of these salt bridges involve disease-associated mutations (R208H and D178N). Decreased PrP stability shown by protein unfolding experiments on mutants of these residues and guanidinium chloride or temperature-induced unfolding studies indicating reduced stability at low pH are consistent with stabilization by salt bridges. The fact that electrostatic interactions, in general, and salt bridges, in particular, appear to play an important role in PrP stability has implications for PrP structure and stability at different pHs it may encounter physiologically during normal or abnormal recycling from the pH neutral membrane surface into endosomes or lysomes (acidic pHs) or in NMR experiments (5.2 for ShPrP and 4.5 for mouse PrP).     

Impact of the tail and mutations G131V and M129V on prion protein flexibility

Within the "protein-only" hypothesis, a detailed mechanism for the conversion of a alpha-helix to beta-sheet structure is unclear. We have investigated the effects of the tail 90-123 and the point mutations G131V and M129V on prion protein conformational plasticity at neutral pH. Molecular dynamics simulations show that the dynamics of the core 124-226 is essentially independent of the tail and that the point mutation G131V does not affect PrP thermodynamic stability. Both mutations, however, enhance the flexibility of residues that participate in the two-step process for prion propagation. They also extend the short beta-sheet in the normal protein into a larger sheet at neutral pH. This finding suggests a critical role of the tail for triggering the topological change.     

β-Hairpin-Mediated Formation of Structurally Distinct Multimers of Neurotoxic Prion Peptides

Protein misfolding disorders are associated with conformational changes in specific proteins, leading to the formation of potentially neurotoxic amyloid fibrils. During pathogenesis of prion disease, the prion protein misfolds into β-sheet rich, protease-resistant isoforms. A key, hydrophobic domain within the prion protein, comprising residues 109–122, recapitulates many properties of the full protein, such as helix-to-sheet structural transition, formation of fibrils and cytotoxicity of the misfolded isoform. Using all-atom, molecular simulations, it is demonstrated that the monomeric 109–122 peptide has a preference for α-helical conformations, but that this peptide can also form β-hairpin structures resulting from turns around specific glycine residues of the peptide. Altering a single amino acid within the 109–122 peptide (A₁₁₇V, associated with familial prion disease) increases the prevalence of β-hairpin formation and these observations are replicated in a longer peptide, comprising residues 106–126. Multi-molecule simulations of aggregation yield different assemblies of peptide molecules composed of conformationally-distinct monomer units. Small molecular assemblies, consistent with oligomers, comprise peptide monomers in a β-hairpin-like conformation and in many simulations appear to exist only transiently. Conversely, larger assemblies are comprised of extended peptides in predominately antiparallel β-sheets and are stable relative to the length of the simulations. These larger assemblies are consistent with amyloid fibrils, show cross-β structure and can form through elongation of monomer units within pre-existing oligomers. In some simulations, assemblies containing both β-hairpin and linear peptides are evident. Thus, in this work oligomers are on pathway to fibril formation and a preference for β-hairpin structure should enhance oligomer formation whilst inhibiting maturation into fibrils. These simulations provide an important new atomic-level model for the formation of oligomers and fibrils of the prion protein and suggest that stabilization of β-hairpin structure may enhance cellular toxicity by altering the balance between oligomeric and fibrillar protein assemblies.     

Checking the pH-induced conformational transition of prion protein by molecular dynamics simulations: effect of protonation of histidine residues

The role of acidic pH in the conversion of human prion protein to the pathogenic isoform is investigated by means of molecular dynamics simulations, focusing the attention on the effect of protonation of histidine residues on the conformational behavior of human PrPC globular domain. Our simulations reveal a significant loss of alpha-helix content under mildly acidic conditions, due to destructuration of the C-terminal part of HB (thus suggesting a possible involvement of HB into the conformational transition leading to the pathogenic isoform) and a transient lengthening of the native beta-sheet. Protonation of His-187 and His-155 seems to be crucial for the onset of the conformational rearrangement. This finding can be related to the existence of a pathogenic mutation, H187R, which is associated with GSS syndrome. Finally, the relevance of our results for the location of a Cu2+-binding pocket in the C-terminal part of the prion is discussed.     

NMR characterization of the pH 4 beta-intermediate of the prion protein: the N-terminal half of the protein remains unstructured and retains a high degree of flexibility

Prion diseases are associated with the misfolding of the PrP (prion protein) from a largely alpha-helical isoform to a beta-sheet-rich oligomer. CD has shown that lowering the pH to 4 under mildly denaturing conditions causes recombinant PrP to convert from an alpha-helical protein into one that contains a high proportion of beta-sheet-like conformation. In the present study, we characterize this soluble pH 4 folding intermediate using NMR. (15)N-HSQC (heteronuclear single-quantum correlation) studies with mPrP (mouse PrP)-(23-231) show that a total of 150 dispersed amide signals are resolved in the native form, whereas only 65 amide signals with little chemical shift dispersion are observable in the pH 4 form. Three-dimensional (15)N-HSQC-TOCSY and NOESY spectra indicate that the observable residues are all assigned to amino acids in the N-terminus: residues 23-118. (15)N transverse relaxation measurements indicate that these N-terminal residues are highly flexible with additional fast motions. These observations are confirmed via the use of truncated mPrP-(112-231), which shows only 16 (15)N-HSQC amide peaks at pH 4. The loss of signals from the C-terminus can be attributed to line broadening due to an increase in the molecular size of the oligomer or exchange broadening in a molten-globule state.     

Kinetic intermediate in the folding of human prion protein

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with the conversion of cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a misfolded oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). Here we have examined the kinetics of folding and unfolding reactions for the recombinant human prion protein C-terminal fragment 90-231 at pH 4.8 and 7.0. The stopped-flow data provide clear evidence for the population of an intermediate on the refolding pathway of the prion protein as indicated by a pronounced curvature in chevron plots and the presence of significant burst phase amplitude in the refolding kinetics. In addition to its role in the normal prion protein folding, this intermediate likely represents a crucial monomeric precursor of the pathogenic PrP(Sc) isoform.     

Conservation of a Glycine-rich Region in the Prion Protein Is Required for Uptake of Prion Infectivity

Prion diseases are associated with the misfolding of the endogenously expressed prion protein (designated PrP^C) into an abnormal isoform (PrP^Sc) that has infectious properties. The hydrophobic domain of PrP^C is highly conserved and contains a series of glycine residues that show perfect conservation among all species, strongly suggesting it has functional and evolutionary significance. These glycine residues appear to form repeats of the GXXXG protein-protein interaction motif (two glycines separated by any three residues); the retention of these residues is significant and presumably relates to the functionality of PrP^C. Mutagenesis studies demonstrate that minor alterations to this highly conserved region of PrP^C drastically affect the ability of cells to uptake and replicate prion infection in both cell and animal bioassay. The localization and processing of mutant PrP^C are not affected, although in vitro and in vivo studies demonstrate that this region is not essential for interaction with PrP^Sc, suggesting these residues provide conformational flexibility. These data suggest that this region of PrP^C is critical in the misfolding process and could serve as a novel, species-independent target for prion disease therapeutics.     

Copper-induced structural propensities of the amyloidogenic region of human prion protein

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with the misfolding of the cellular Prion Protein (PrP^C) to an abnormal protein isoform, called scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc). The structural rearrangement of the fragment of N-terminal domain of the protein spanning residues 91–127 is critical for the observed structural transition. The amyloidogenic domain of the protein encloses two copper-binding sites corresponding to His-96 and His-111 residues that act as anchors for metal ion binding. Previous studies have shown that Cu(II) sequestration by both sites may modulate the peptide’s tendency to aggregation as it inflicts the hairpin-like structure that stabilizes the transition states leading to β-sheet formation. On the other hand, since both His sites differ in their ability to Cu(II) sequestration, with His-111 as a preferred binding site, we found it interesting to test the role of Cu(II) coordination to this single site on the structural properties of amyloidogenic domain. The obtained results reveal that copper binding to His-111 site imposes precise backbone bending and weakens the natural tendency of apo peptide to β-sheet formation.