Identification of macromolecules by quantitative polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and isoelectric focusing: a comparison of three approaches.

Identification of macromolecules by zone electrophoresis has usually been based on differences in migration distances under a single set of electrophoretic conditions. Classically, it has taken the form of coelectrophoresis on gel slabs. In “quantitative” polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), separation conditions were standardized sufficiently to allow for identification of macromolecules between experiments on the basis of their relative electrophoretic mobilities, R_f ± σ_Rf. More reliably, molecular identity or distinguishability have been based on several R_f values at several gel concentrations (%T) and the linear relationship between log R_f and %T, the Ferguson plot. The slope (retardation coefficient K_R of this plot is desoriptive of molecular size while the γ-intercept (Y₀) is a measure of net charge. The joint 95% confidence envelopes for K_R and Y₀ may be used as criteria for identification of molecules. Distinction between two molecular species depends on the size and position of the two confidence envelopes or ellipses. By pooling estimates of residual varlance (scatter areund the regression line for the Ferguson plot) for several proteins, it is possible to reduce the size of the ellipses and improve the sensitivity of the method to distinguish elesely related species. The sensitivity of this method depends on the size and reprodueibility of the 95% confidence envelopes, and on the limitatiens in the number of electrophoretic fractionations that one is reasonably willing to invest. Any molecular identification problem therefore raises the implieit question whether to base distinction on migration distance, on R_f, or on the joint 95% confidence envelopes for K_R and Y₀ and related statistical (F test) eriteria. Further, in the event of inconsistent answers to the question of molecular distinguishability from the three approaches, we need rational criteria to select the “best” answer. These problems and some solutions are illustrated by the present study which was designed to determine whether the enzymatic digestion products of human growth hormone produced by subtilisin-B are or are not the same as those obtained by digestion with plasmin. It appears that the joint 95% confidence envelopes of K_R and Y₀ provide at this time the most discriminating criteria of distinction, indicating significant differences between nearly all the products of plasmin and subtilisin digestion of hGH. However, the lower resolution provided by the R_f criteria has the advantage that it allows one to group the products of the partial hydrolysis of hGH into “families” which may be associated with different ranges of specific bioactivities.     

The molecular weight of rhodopsin and the nature of the rhodopsin-digitonin complex

The sedimentation behavior of aqueous solutions of digitonin and of cattle rhodopsin in digitonin has been examined in the ultracentrifuge. In confirmation of earlier work, digitonin was found to sediment as a micelle (D-1) with an s₂₀ of about 6.35 Svedberg units, and containing at least 60 molecules. The rhodopsin solutions sediment as a stoichiometric complex of rhodopsin with digitonin (RD-1) with an s₂₀ of about 9.77 Svedberg units. The s₂₀ of the RD-1 micelle is constant between pH 6.3 and 9.6, and in the presence of excess digitonin. RD-1 travels as a single boundary also in the electrophoresis apparatus at pH 8.5, and on filter paper at pH 8.0. The molecular weight of the RD-1 micelle lies between 260,000 and 290,000. Of this, only about 40,000 gm. are due to rhodopsin; the rest is digitonin (180 to 200 moles). Comparison of the relative concentrations of RD-1 and retinene in solutions of rhodopsin-digitonin shows that RD-1 contains only one retinene equivalent. It can therefore contain only one molecule of rhodopsin with a molecular weight of about 40,000. Cattle rhodopsin therefore contains only one chromophore consisting of a single molecule of retinene. It is likely that frog rhodopsin has a similar molecular weight and also contains only one chromophore per molecule. The molar extinction coefficient of rhodopsin is therefore identical with the extinction coefficient per mole of retinene (40,600 cm.² per mole) and the E(1 per cent, 1 cm., 500 mµ) has a value of about 10. Rhodopsin constitutes about 14 per cent of the dry weight, and 3.7 per cent of the wet weight of cattle outer limbs. This corresponds to about 4.2 x 10⁶ molecules of rhodopsin per outer limb. The rhodopsin content of frog outer limbs is considerably higher: about 35 per cent of the dry weight, and 10 per cent of the wet weight, corresponding to about 2.1 x 10⁹ molecules per outer limb. Thus the frog outer limb contains about five hundred times as much rhodopsin as the cattle outer limb. But the relative volumes of these structures are such that the ratio of concentrations is only about 2.5 to 1 on a weight basis. Rhodopsin accounts for at least one-fifth of the total protein of the cattle outer limb; for the frog, this value must be higher. The extinction (K₅₀₀) along its axis is about 0.037 cm.² for the cattle outer limb, and about 0.50 cm.² for the frog outer limb.     

Molecular weight estimation using sodium dodecyl sulfate-pore gradient electrophoresis

Pore gradient electrophoresis (PGE) in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) provides a means for high resolution fractionation of multicomponent protein systems and permits estimation of molecular weights for macromolecules ranging from 10³ to 10⁶. We have evaluated the performance of several methods used to construct calibration curves for estimation of molecular weights using SDS-PGE. A linear relationship between the logarithm of molecular weight, log (M_r), and the logarithm of the relative mobility, log (R_l), can be obtained for a 30-fold range of molecular weights. However, this range of linearity depends on the choice of the concentration gradient, the degree of crosslinking of the gel, and on the nature of the underlying relationship between the retardation coefficient, K_R, and the molecular weight. An empirical relationship, first introduced by Lambin et al. (1976, Anal. Biochem.74, 567) between log (M_r) and the logarithm of the gel concentration at the position reached by the protein, log (%T), provides better linearity over a wider molecular weight range than does the use of log (R_l). We have compared these relatienships by experimental analysis of 10 standard proteins and by a theoretical analysis of an idealized model system. A computer program has been developed which provides appropriate statistical estimation of the molecular weight for an unknown protein, together with its standard error and 95% confidence limits. A new method has also been developed for analysis of nonlinear calibration curves in terms of molecular weight versus distance migrated, based on a theoretically justifiable, physical-chemical model. This model implies that either the relationship between log (M_r) and log (R_l) or the one between log (M_r) and log (%T) will become nonlinear as the range of molecular weight is extended. We suggest that the use of a nonlinear least-squares curve-fitting procedure provides an optimal method for molecular weight estimation when sufficient data are available. Based on these findings, a general strategy is presented for estimation of molecular weights by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.     

Growth of Pseudomonas chlororaphis on apolyester–polyurethane and the purification andcharacterization of a polyurethanase–esterase enzyme

A Pseudomonas chlororaphis was found to degrade and utilize apolyester polyurethane as a sole carbon and energy source. Polyurethane utilization by P.chlororaphis followed simple Michaelis–Menten kinetics. The K_s and μ_max values were 0.802 mg·ml⁻¹ and 1.316 doublings·h⁻¹, respectively. The enzymes from P. chlororaphis responsible for polyurethanedegradation were found to be extracellular. Analysis of the polyurethane degrading proteins, usingnon-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, revealed three active protein bands with R_f values of 0.25, 0.417 and 0.917. A polyurethane degrading enzyme was purifiedand displayed esterase activity. This enzyme was inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride andhad a molecular weight of 27,000 daltons.     

Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis: estimation of protein subunit molecular weights using cationic detergents.

Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of the cationic detergent, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), has been previously used to obtain more accurate estimates of the molecular weight of certain highly charged and membrane protein subunits that exhibit anomalous electrophoretic behavior in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). The improved method reported herein is comparable to the sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) method in simplicity, time, and quality of gels, but the CTAB-PAGE method appears to have a wider range of application for diverse types of proteins. The technique may also be used for verification of molecular weight data and thus detection of possible anomalous results obtained using the anionic SDS-PAGE method. The described method eliminates the precipitates formed between ammonium persulfate and cationic detergents during gel polymerization and between cationic detergents and the protein dyes during staining that have complicated previous methods. The reliability of the technique is indicated by the high correlation coefficient (?0.97) between R_f and molecular weight. Data are presented to indicate that the method can be used to estimate the subunit molecular weight of unknown proteins with a 95% level of confidence.     

Preparation and characterization of calcium-binding and other hydrophobic proteins from synaptic membranes

A number of hydrophobic proteins have been separated and purified to varying degrees from synaptic membranes derived from bovine brain. The proteins, which have been obtained using preparative acrylamide gel electrophoresis, have been analyzed for molecular weight, amino acid composition, peptide mapping, N-terminal amino acids, and for their ability to bind calcium and ATP. A number of the proteins bound calcium, the greatest binding being associated with a component having a molecular weight of 1.5 · 10⁴, a binding capacity of 4 calcium/molecule, and a K_m of 1.5 · 10^?5 M. An acidic tryptic peptide derived from this protein was evidently responsible for the calcium-binding. ATP binding appeared to be confined largely to the higher molecular weight proteins. From the peptide mapping there appears to be a similar acidic component in a number of the proteins exhibiting calcium-binding. ATP-binding was associated mainly with the high molecular weight proteins, particularly those which consisted of numerous basic tryptic peptides.     

Mechanism and specificity of rhodopsin phosphorylation.

Partial separation of protein kinase activity from rhodopsin in isolated bovine retinal photoreceptor outer segments was accomplished by mild ultrasonic treatment followed by ultracentrifugation. Residual kinase activity in the rhodopsin-rich sediment was destroyed by chemical denaturation which did not affect the spectral properties of the rhodopsin. The retinal outer segment kinase was found to be specific for rhodopsin, since in these preparations it alone of several bovine protein kinases was capable of phosphorylating rhodopsin in the light. The phosphorylation reaction apparently requires a specific conformation of the rhodopsin molecule since it is abolished by heat denaturation of rhodopsin, and it is greatly reduced or abolished by treatment of the visual pigment protein with potassium alum after the rhodopsin has been "bleached" by light. When kinase and rhodopsin or opsin fractions were prepared from dark-adapted and bleached outer segments and the resultant fractions were mixed in various combinations of bleached and unbleached preparations, the observed pattern of light-activated phosphorylation was consistent only with the interpretation that a conformational change in the rhodopsin molecule in the light exposes a site on the visual pigment protein to the kinase and ATP. These results rule out the possibility of a direct or indirect (rhodopsin-mediated) light activation of the kinase. Finally, phosphorylation of retinal outer segment protein in monochromatic lights of various wavelengths followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indicates that both rhodopsin and the higher molecular weight visual pigment protein reported by several laboratories have the same action spectrum for phosphorylation. This result is consistent with the suggestion that the higher molecular weight species is a rhodopsin dimer.     

Microtubule reassembly in vitro of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus sperm tail outer doublet tubulin

Strongylocentrotus purpuratus outer doublet microtubules were prepared by extraction of sperm tail axonemes with 0.6 m-KCl. Sonication of the outer doublet microtubules in 5 mm-2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulphonic acid, 1 mm-ethyleneglycol-bis-(β-aminoethyl ether) N,N′-tetraacetic acid, 1 inm-MgSO₄ (pH 6.7) solubilized up to 35% of the outer doublet protein, depending on the power input, in a manner which was non-selective for either subfiber. Tubulin comprised 75 to 85% of the total solubilized protein in a 200,000 g supernatant obtained from the sonicated suspension. Colchicine-binding assays demonstrated that the tubulin was largely in a native form (K_A = 10⁶, liters mole^?; 0.74 mole of colchicine bound per mole of tubulin at infinite concentration of colchicine).Microtubule self-assembly from the 200,000 g supernatants in the absence of added seeds or glycerol was quantitated by light-scattering at 350 nm. The critical protein concentration for assembly was 0.55 mg ml^?1 at 37 °C and the reaction occurred optimally in the presence of 2 mm-GTP and 150 mm-KCl. The solubilized outer doublet tubulin formed singlet microtubules upon reassembly under our in vitro conditions. The authenticity of the microtubules was verified by both negative stain and thin-section electron microscopy. Polymerization was prevented by colchicine and podophyllotoxin, and depolymerization occurred rapidly on cooling the microtubules to 0 °C.The susceptibility of the reassembled microtubules to low temperature suggested that they could be “recycled” by the warm assembly-cold disassembly procedure developed for vertebrate brain (Borisy et al., 1974). Twice recycled outer doublet tubulin was devoid of high molecular weight microtubule-associated proteins, as judged by gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. However, trace amounts (less than 5%) of intermediate molecular weight material was visible on heavily overloaded gels. The function of this material is uncertain, but it is not chemically equivalent to the tau factor of vertebrate brain (Weingarten et al., 1975), since it cannot be separated from the tubulin by phosphocellulose adsorption. In addition, phosphocellulose-treated tubulin reassembled to the same extent as untreated tubulin, suggesting that the reassembly of outer doublet tubulin does not require the protein equivalents of brain microtubule-associated proteins or tau factor. If accessory proteins are required for the reassembly of outer doublet tubulin, they are not removed by phosphocellulose under the conditions employed, and they must comprise less than 5% of the total protein.     

Purification method of bovine rhodopsin kinase using regeneration of rhodopsin

We report a rapid and high-yield purification method of bovine retinal rhodopsin kinase. According to our method, 500 micrograms of rhodopsin kinase was purified from 100 bovine retinae within 12 h. Rhodopsin kinase bound to bleached rhodopsin was extracted effectively from rod outer segment membranes after regeneration of rhodopsin by the incubation with exogenous 11-cis-retinal. Subsequent DE52 column chromatography further purified the protein to homogeneity on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The purified rhodopsin kinase had an apparent molecular weight of 68,000 and phosphorylated rhodopsin at the rate of 10 nmol phosphate/min/mg of the enzyme.     

Characterization by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of hemoglobins in rabbit embryo, fetus, and adult

The hemoglobin species of rabbit embryo, fetus, and adult were characterized by quantitative polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). Special statistical methods, including joint confidence envelopes for the slope (K_R) and intercept (Y₀) of the Ferguson plot and analysis of covariance were utilized to identify the hemoglobin species. Five embryonic rabbit hemoglobins could be distinguished. Their relative proportions varied with developmental stage. No specific fetal hemoglobin was detected. The two previously known adult hemoglobins were characterized, prepared by isoclectric focusing on polyacrylamide gel (IFPA) and shown to differ by two amino acid substitutions in the β-chain.A general strategy for testing molecular identity by PAGE is outlined.     

Molecular weights of protein multimers from polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis

A nonlinear relationship between polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) retardation coefficients (K_R) and molecular weights has been observed during analysis of several multimeric proteins. Although the deviation from linearity over a wide range of molecular weights is slight, it can lead to significant errors in the estimation of the sizes of individual multimers. Two alternative methods of analysis of PAGE results are compared and demonstrated to yield linear relationships for multimeric proteins having molecular weights as high as 900,000.     

Purification and properties of a high specific activity protein kinase from wheat germ

A protein kinase was extensively purified to near-homogeneity from wheat germ by a procedure involving affinity chromatography on casein-Sepharose 4B, gel filtration, and repeated chromatography on carboxymethyl-Sepharose CL-6B. The protein kinase preparations have the highest specific activities (up to 656 nanomoles phosphate incorporated per minute per milligram of protein) yet reported for plant protein kinases. The major polypeptides in purified preparations were revealed as two barely-resolved bands (molecular weight 31,000) on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in subunit-dissociating conditions. The molecular size of the protein kinase as determined from gel filtration is 30,000. The protein kinase catalyzes the phosphorylation of casein, phosvitin, and the wheat germ cyclic AMP-binding protein cABPII but not of bovine serum albumin and histones nor of the wheat germ cytokinin-binding protein CBP. The protein kinase has a pH optimum of 7.9 and a K_m value for ATP of 10 micromolar. The protein kinase differs from wheat germ CBP kinase in molecular weight, differential sensitivity to inhibitors, and in substrate specificity.     

Characteristics of functioning of succinate dehydrogenase from flight muscles of the bumblebee Bombus terrestris (L.)

It was found that the succinate oxidation rate in mitochondria of flight muscles of Bombus terrestris L. increased by a factor of 2.15 after flying for 1 h. An electrophoretically homogenous preparation of succinate dehydrogenase with a specific activity of 7.14 U/mg protein and 81.55-fold purity was isolated from B. terrestris flight muscles. It is shown that this enzyme is represented in the muscle tissue by only one isoform with R _f = 0.24. The molecular weight of the native molecule and its subunits A and B was determined. The kinetic characteristics of succinate dehydrogenase (K _m = 0.33 mM) and the optimal concentration of hydrogen ions (pH 7.8) were established, and the effect of salts on the enzyme activity was studied. The role of succinate as a respiratory substrate in stress and the structural and functional characteristics of the succinate dehydrogenase system in the flight muscles of insects are discussed.     

Revised Amino-acid Sequences for Porcine and Human Adrenocorticotrophic Hormone

MEMBRANE protein of bovine rod outer segments has been studied by gel electrophoresis and amino-acid analysis. Membranes were purified in a sucrose density gradient¹ at an ionic strength below 0.001. The isolated material probably consisted of fragmented disk membranes¹. ‘Emulphogene’ solutions of rhodopsin were chromatographed on calcium phosphate²; the results for A₂₇₈: A₄₉₈ were 1.7–1.8, indicating good purity.     

The presence of two major protein components in the bovine photoreceptor disc membrane.

Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of thoroughly washed rod outer segment membrane preparations from bovine retinae revealed two major membrane-bound components and not one as has been generally thought. The higher molecular weight peak (?38500 molecular weight) contains a carbohydrate component and is covalently bound to the retinylidene chromophore. Moreover, this material is extensively phosphorylated $\text{in vitro}$ upon illumination. Therefore, this component (peak H) is rhodopsin. The nature and function of the other photoreceptor disc membrane component (peak L, ?34500 molecular weight) remains to be determined.     

Growth of Pseudomonas fluorescens on a polyester–polyurethane and the purification and characterization of a polyurethanase–protease enzyme

A Pseudomonas fluorescens was found to degrade and utilize a polyester polyurethane as a sole carbon and energy source. Polyurethane utilization by P. fluorescens. followed simple Michaelis–Menten kinetics. The K_s and μ_max values were 0.9 mg ml⁻¹ and 1.61 doublings · h⁻¹, respectively. The enzymes from P. fluorescens responsible for polyurethane degradation were found to be extracellular. Analysis of the polyurethane degrading proteins using non-denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis revealed one active protein band with an R_f value of 0.083. A polyurethane degrading enzyme was purified and displayed protease activity. This enzyme was inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride and had a molecular weight of 29,000 daltons.     

Hydrogen ion changes of rhodopsin I. Proton uptake during the metarhodopsin I 478 metarhodopsin II 308 reaction

The hydrogen ion changes resulting from the photolysis of the rod visual pigment, rhodopsin, have been investigated. Low temperature was used to isolate the metarhodopsin I₄₇₈ to II₃₈₀ reaction of rhodopsin and indicator dye was used to simultaneously measure the hydrogen ion changes of the rhodopsin solution.The results indicate that illuminated rhodopsin takes up a proton during the metarhodopsin I₄₇₈ to II₃₈₀ reaction and releases protons at later intermediate stages. The results are consistent with data indicating pK changes of rhodopsin as the basis for the R₂ phase of the early receptor potential and hydrogen ion changes of the medium or pK changes of rhodopsin as having effects on the late receptor potential.     

Purification and Characterization of a Chloroplast Outer-Envelope-Bound, ATP-Dependent Protein Kinase

An ATP-dependent protein kinase was partially purified from isolated outer envelope membranes of pea (Pisum sativum L., Progress No. 9) chloroplasts. The purified kinase had a molecular weight of 70 kilodaltons, as determined by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. It was of the cyclic nucleotide and Ca²⁺, calmodulin-independent type. The purification involved the detergent solubilization of purified outer envelopes by 0.5% cholate and 1% octylglycoside, followed by centrifugation on a linear 6 to 25% sucrose gradient. Active enzyme fractions were further purified by affinity chromatography on histone III-S Sepharose 4B and ion exchange chromatography on diethylaminoethyl cellulose. The protein kinase eluted at 100 millimolar and 50 millimolar NaCl, respectively. The protein kinase was essentially pure as judged by Western blot analysis. The enzyme has a K_M of 450 micromolar for ATP and a V_max of 25 picomoles of ³²P incorporated into histone III-S per minute per microgram. Inhibition by ADP is competitive (K_i 150 micromolar).     

Rotein Composition Cf Flasmin Preparation “Hcmclysin”

A commercial preparation of human plasmin (Homolysin), capable of catalyzing the transformation of human growth hormone (hGH) into biologically activated species, was analyzed by electrophoresis and electrofocusing on polyacrylamide gel. Each major component of the preparation was characterized with regard to molecular size (retardation coefficient, K_R). molecular net charge (y-intercept on the Ferguson plot, Y₀), apparent isoelectric point (pi') and enzyme activity. The multiple components of Homolysln revealed by staining corresponded to various aggregation states of plasmin and exhibited full serine protease activity. Pclyacrylamlde gel electrophoresis of Homolysln in the presence of sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) yielded 2 sub units which corresponded in molecular weight to the known plasmin subunits.     

Purification and properties of NADP+:Isocitrate dehydrogenase from lactating bovine mammary gland

NADP⁺:isocitrate dehydrogenase has been purified to homogeneity from lactating bovine mammary gland. Purification was achieved through the use of affinity and DEAE-cellulose chromatography. The isolated enzyme gives one band when stained for protein or enzyme activity on discontinuous alkaline gel electrophoresis. The enzyme has a molecular weight of 55,000 as estimated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-gel electrophoresis and a Stokes radius of 4.1 nm as measured by gel chromatography. The enzyme will not use NAD⁺ in place of NADP⁺ and has an absolute requirement for divalent cations. The apparent K_m values for dl-isocitrate, Mn²⁺, and NADP⁺ were found to be 8, 6, and 11 μm, respectively. The Mn²⁺-d_s-isocitrate complex is the most likely substrate for the mammary enzyme with a K_m of 3 μm. The properties of mammary NADP⁺:isocitrate dehydrogenase are compared with those of the homologous enzymes from pig heart and bovine liver, and its characteristics are discussed with respect to the function of the enzyme in lactating mammary gland.