Elastic Moduli of Collagen Gels Can Be Predicted from Two-Dimensional Confocal Microscopy

We quantitatively compare data obtained from imaging two-dimensional slices of three-dimensional unlabeled and fluorescently labeled collagen gels with confocal reflectance microscopy (CRM) and/or confocal fluorescence microscopy (CFM). Different network structures are obtained by assembling the gels over a range of concentrations at various temperatures. Comparison between CRM and CFM shows that the techniques are not equally sensitive to details of network structure, with CFM displaying higher fidelity in imaging fibers parallel to the optical axis. Comparison of CRM of plain and labeled collagen gels shows that labeling itself induces changes in gel structure, chiefly through inhibition of fibril bundling. Despite these differences, image analyses carried out on two-dimensional CFM and CRM slices of collagen gels reveal identical trends in structural parameters as a function of collagen concentration and gelation temperature. Fibril diameter approximated from either CRM or CFM is in good accord with that determined via electron microscopy. Two-dimensional CRM images are used to show that semiflexible polymer theory can relate network structural properties to elastic modulus successfully. For networks containing bundled fibrils, it is shown that average structural diameter, rather than fibril diameter, is the length scale that sets the magnitude of the gel elastic modulus.     

Fibrillogenesis in dense collagen solutions: a physicochemical study

Fibrillogenesis, the formation of collagen fibrils, is a key factor in connective tissue morphogenesis. To understand to what extent cells influence this process, we systematically studied the physicochemistry of the self-assembly of type I collagen molecules into fibrils in vitro. We report that fibrillogenesis in solutions of type I collagen, in a high concentration range close to that of living tissues (40-300 mg/ml), yields strong gels over wide pH and ionic strength ranges. Structures of gels were described by combining microscopic observations (transmission electron microscopy) with small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering analysis, and the influence of concentration, pH, and ionic strength on the fibril size and organization was evaluated. The typical cross-striated pattern and the corresponding small-angle X-ray scattering 67-nm diffraction peaks were visible in all conditions in the pH 6 to pH 12 range. In reference conditions (pH 7.4, ionic strength = 150 mM, 20 °C), collagen concentration greatly influences the overall macroscopic structure of the resultant fibrillar gels, as well as the morphology and structure of the fibrils themselves. At a given collagen concentration, increasing the ionic strength from 24 to 261 mM produces larger fibrils until the system becomes biphasic. We also show that fibrils can form in acidic medium (pH ∼ 2.5) at very high collagen concentrations, beyond 150 mg/ml, which suggests a possible cholesteric-to-smectic phase transition. This set of data demonstrates how simple physicochemical parameters determine the molecular organization of collagen. Such an in vitro model allows us to study the intricate process of fibrillogenesis in conditions of molecular packing close to that which occurs in biological tissue morphogenesis.     

Segregation of type I collagen homo- and heterotrimers in fibrils

Normal type I collagen is a heterotrimer of two α1(I) and one α2(I) chains, but various genetic and environmental factors result in synthesis of homotrimers that consist of three α1(I) chains. The homotrimers completely replace the heterotrimers only in rare recessive disorders. In the general population, they may compose just a small fraction of type I collagen. Nevertheless, they may play a significant role in pathology; for example, synthesis of 10-15% homotrimers due to a polymorphism in the α1(I) gene may contribute to osteoporosis. Homotrimer triple helices have different stability and less efficient fibrillogenesis than heterotrimers. Their fibrils have different mechanical properties. However, very little is known about their molecular interactions and fibrillogenesis in mixtures with normal heterotrimers. Here we studied the kinetics and thermodynamics of fibril formation in such mixtures by combining traditional approaches with 3D confocal imaging of fibrils, in which homo- and heterotrimers were labeled with different fluorescent colors. In a mixture, following a temperature jump from 4 to 32 °C, we observed a rapid increase in turbidity most likely caused by formation of homotrimer aggregates. The aggregates promoted nucleation of homotrimer fibrils that served as seeds for mixed and heterotrimer fibrils. The separation of colors in confocal images indicated segregation of homo- and heterotrimers at a subfibrillar level throughout the process. The fibril color patterns continued to change slowly after the fibrillogenesis appeared to be complete, due to dissociation and reassociation of the pepsin-treated homo- and heterotrimers, but this remixing did not significantly reduce the segregation even after several days. Independent homo- and heterotrimer solubility measurements in mixtures confirmed that the subfibrillar segregation was an equilibrium property of intermolecular interactions and not just a kinetic phenomenon. We argue that the subfibrillar segregation may exacerbate effects of a small fraction of α1(I) homotrimers on formation, properties, and remodeling of collagen fibers.     

A Blind Spot in Confocal Reflection Microscopy: The Dependence of Fiber Brightness on Fiber Orientation in Imaging Biopolymer Networks

We investigate the dependence of fiber brightness on three-dimensional fiber orientation when imaging biopolymer networks with confocal reflection microscopy (CRM) and confocal fluorescence microscopy (CFM). We compare image data of fluorescently labeled type I collagen networks concurrently acquired using each imaging modality. For CRM, fiber brightness decreases for more vertically oriented fibers, leaving fibers above ∼50° from the imaging plane entirely undetected. As a result, the three-dimensional network structure appears aligned with the imaging plane. In contrast, CFM data exhibit little variation of fiber brightness with fiber angle, thus revealing an isotropic collagen network. Consequently, we find that CFM detects almost twice as many fibers as are visible with CRM, thereby yielding more complete structural information for three-dimensional fiber networks. We offer a simple explanation that predicts the detected fiber brightness as a function of fiber orientation in CRM.     

Effects of decorin proteoglycan on fibrillogenesis,ultrastructure, and mechanics of type I collagen gels

The proteoglycan decorin is known to affect both the fibrillogenesis and the resulting ultrastructure of in vitro polymerized collagen gels. However, little is known about its effects on mechanical properties. In this study, 3D collagen gels were polymerized into tensile test specimens in the presence of decorin proteoglycan, decorin core protein, or dermatan sulfate (DS). Collagen fibrillogenesis, ultrastructure, and mechanical properties were then quantified using a turbidity assay, 2 forms of microscopy (SEM and confocal), and tensile testing. The presence of decorin proteoglycan or core protein decreased the rate and ultimate turbidity during fibrillogenesis and decreased the number of fibril aggregates (fibers) compared to control gels. The addition of decorin and core protein increased the linear modulus by a factor of 2 compared to controls, while the addition of DS reduced the linear modulus by a factor of 3. Adding decorin after fibrillogenesis had no effect, suggesting that decorin must be present during fibrillogenesis to increase the mechanical properties of the resulting gels. These results show that the inclusion of decorin proteoglycan during fibrillogenesis of type I collagen increases the modulus and tensile strength of resulting collagen gels. The increase in mechanical properties when polymerization occurs in the presence of the decorin proteoglycan is due to a reduction in the aggregation of fibrils into larger order structures such as fibers and fiber bundles.     

Rheology and Confocal Reflectance Microscopy as Probes of Mechanical Properties and Structure during Collagen and Collagen/Hyaluronan Self-Assembly

In this work, the gelation of three-dimensional collagen and collagen/hyaluronan (HA) composites is studied by time sweep rheology and time lapse confocal reflectance microscopy (CRM). To investigate the complementary nature of these techniques, first collagen gel formation is investigated at concentrations of 0.5, 1.0, and 1.5 mg/mL at 37°C and 32°C. The following parameters are used to describe the self-assembly process in all gels: the crossover time (t_c), the slope of the growth phase (k_g), and the arrest time (t_a). The first two measures are determined by rheology, and the third by CRM. A frequency-independent rheological measure of gelation, t_g, is also measured at 37°C. However, this quantity cannot be straightforwardly determined for gels formed at 32°C, indicating that percolation theory does not fully capture the dynamics of collagen network formation. The effects of collagen concentration and gelation temperature on k_g, t_c, and t_a as well as on the mechanical properties and structure of these gels both during gelation and at equilibrium are elucidated. Composite collagen/HA gels are also prepared, and their properties are monitored at equilibrium and during gelation at 37°C and 32°C. We show that addition of HA subtly alters mechanical properties and structure of these systems both during the gelation process and at equilibrium. This occurs in a temperature-dependent manner, with the ratio of HA deposited on collagen fibers versus that distributed homogeneously between fibers increasing with decreasing gelation temperature. In addition to providing information on collagen and collagen/HA structure and mechanical properties during gelation, this work shows new ways in which rheology and microscopy can be used complementarily to reveal details of gelation processes.     

Collagen fibrillogenesis in vitro: comparison of types I, II, and III

The self-assembly of pepsin-extracted types I, II, and III collagen was studied to determine how differences in the triple-helical structure between collagen types influence in vitro collagen fibrillogenesis. Collagen types I, II, and III were extracted and purified from bovine sources, and were studied in solution by laser light scattering, pH titration, and determination of turbidity-time curves. The molecular weights were between 280,000 and 289,000, while the translational diffusion coefficients and particle scattering factors at 175.5 degrees were consistent with those expected for single collagen molecules. Titration of collagen types I, II, and III between pH 7.0 and 2.0 using HCl indicated that type I collagen had the most titratable carboxylic groups with type II and III having significantly fewer titratable groups. The self-assembly of these collagens was studied in vitro in phosphate-buffered saline. The time course and extent of fibril formation were studied turbidimetrically, and were found to be dependent on collagen type. Apparent rate constants were determined for both the lag and growth phases of fibril formation. The rates of both phases were greater for type III than for type I collagen, with the rates for type II collagen being intermediate. The extent of fibril formation was based on the turbidity per unit concentration (specific turbidity) extrapolated to zero concentration (intrinsic turbidity), which was found to be greater for type I than for type III collagen. Type II collagen had the smallest intrinsic turbidity. The specific and intrinsic turbidity values were consistent with the relative fibril diameters seen in dermis and cartilage by transmission electron microscopy. These observations indicate that helix-helix interactions are important in the regulation of the rate and extent of collagen fibrillogenesis and may be involved in the determination of fibril structure.     

Simultaneous processing of fibril formation and cross-linking improves mechanical properties of collagen

In vitro "simultaneous processing" was investigated in which fibril formation of collagen and cross-linking occur simultaneously in the presence of 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide (EDC) as a cross-linking reagent. Fibril formation in simultaneous processing was monitored using turbidity. The EDC in simultaneous processing increased T(1/2) (time required for half of the plateau value in turbidity) and decreased the degree of the fibril formation dose dependently. The reduced fibril formation rate (T(1/2) > 60 s) suggests the introduction of intrafibrillar cross-linking during fibril formation. The collagen gels prepared using simultaneous processing had a compressive modulus that was 6-fold higher than that using sequential processing, which is an advantage of simultaneous processing. Atomic force microscopy images acquired under water on the wet gels demonstrated that the simultaneous processing provided a unique double-network structure: intrafibrillarly cross-linked collagen fibrils among which nonfibrous collagens act as interfibrillar cross-linkages.     

Anisotropic mechanical properties of magnetically aligned fibrin gels measured by magnetic resonance elastography

The anisotropic mechanical properties of magnetically aligned fibrin gels were measured by magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) and by a standard mechanical test: unconfined compression. Soft anisotropic biomaterials are notoriously difficult to characterize, especially in vivo. MRE is well-suited for efficient, non-invasive, and non-destructive assessment of shear modulus. Direction-dependent differences in shear modulus were found to be statistically significant for gels polymerized at magnetic fields of 11.7 and 4.7 T compared to control gels. Mechanical anisotropy was greater in the gels polymerized at the higher magnetic field. These observations were consistent with results from unconfined compression tests. Analysis of confocal microscopy images of gels showed measurable alignment of fibrils in gels polymerized at 11.7 T. This study provides direct, quantitative measurements of the anisotropy in mechanical properties that accompanies fibril alignment in fibrin gels.     

Thermal denaturation studies of collagen by microthermal analysis and atomic force microscopy

The structural properties of collagen have been the subject of numerous studies over past decades, but with the arrival of new technologies, such as the atomic force microscope and related techniques, a new era of research has emerged. Using microthermal analysis, it is now possible to image samples as well as performing localized thermal measurements without damaging or destroying the sample itself. This technique was successfully applied to characterize the thermal response between native collagen fibrils and their denatured form, gelatin. Thermal transitions identified at (150 ± 10)°C and (220 ± 10)°C can be related to the process of gelatinization of the collagen fibrils, whereas at higher temperatures, both the gelatin and collagen samples underwent two-stage transitions with a common initial degradation temperature at (300 ± 10)°C and a secondary degradation temperature of (340 ± 10)°C for the collagen and of (420 ± 10)°C for the gelatin, respectively. The broadening and shift in the secondary degradation temperature was linked to the spread of thermal degradation within the gelatin and collagen fibrils matrix further away from the point of contact between probe and sample. Finally, similar measurements were performed inside a bone resorption lacuna, suggesting that microthermal analysis is a viable technique for investigating the thermomechanical response of collagen for in situ samples that would be, otherwise, too challenging or not possible using bulk techniques.     

Thermodynamic characteristics of collagen fibrils reconstructed in vitro at different temperatures and concentrations

The results of a calorimetric study of type I collagen fibrillogenesis were analyzed. The dependence of the half-width of the temperature transition of a collagen solution on the concentration and temperature of collagen formation was studied. It was demonstrated that, by varying temperature and collagen concentration, one can regulate the density of packing and dimensions of cooperative fibril blocks. At temperatures below the physiological level (25 degrees C and 30 degrees C), and a relatively low concentration of collagen (0.3 mg/ml), fibrils with the lowest density of packing are formed. The degree of order does not change as the collagen concentration increases twofold but grows as the concentration increases fourfold. It was shown that, at the physiological temperature (35 degrees C), fibrils with a dense packing of molecules are formed at all collagen concentrations studied. The value of fibril formation enthalpy is minimal at a temperature of 35 degrees C, pH 7.2, an ionic strength of 0.17 M and a concentration of 1.2 mg/ml. Based on the results obtained, a conclusion was made that the packing density of fibrils formed at physiological temperature does not depend on collagen concentration over the concentration range of 0.3 - 1.2 mg/ml.     

Thermodynamic and structural characteristics of collagen fibrils formed in vitro at different temperatures and concentrations

Analysis of the results of calorimetric study of reconstituted collagen (type I) fibrils, in particular, the half-width of the temperature transition, shows that the collagen packing density in the fibrils and the size of cooperative blocks therein depend on the assembly temperature and on the initial collagen concentration. The least dense fibrils are formed at subphysiological temperatures (25° or 30°C) and low concentration (0.3 mg/ml). The extent of ordering does not change upon doubling the concentration but increases upon quadrupling it. At physiological temperature (35°C) the fibrils are densely packed regardless of collagen concentration. The enthalpy of fibril assembly is minimal at 35°C, 1.2 mg/ml, and ionic strength of 0.17 M. The influence of temperature on particular steps of fibrillogenesis and the role of water in these processes are discussed.     

Influence of monosaccharides on the fibrillogenesis of type I collagen

The in vitro self-assembly of Type I rat tail tendon collagen in the presence of monosaccharides was studied turbidimetrically. D(+)glucose and D(+)mannose delayed fibril formation significantly while D(-)fructose showed no variation. The effect of glucose was concentration dependent. Binding of glucose during fibrillogenesis was shown by the incorporation of [14C]glucose and also by SDS-polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoresis of the product. The results indicate that in vitro nonenzymatic glycosylation can take place in the short duration required for fibril formation.     

Modulation of collagen fibrillogenesis by tenascin-X and type VI collagen

Tenascin-X (TNX) is an extracellular matrix glycoprotein. We previously demonstrated that TNX regulates the expression of type VI collagen. In this study, we investigated the binding of TNX to type I collagen as well as to type VI collagen and the effects of these proteins on fibrillogenesis of type I collagen. Full-length recombinant TNX, which is expressed in and purified from mammalian cell cultures, and type VI collagen purified from bovine placenta were used. Solid-phase assays revealed that TNX or type VI collagen bound to type I collagen, although TNX did not bind to type VI collagen, fibronectin, or laminin. The rate of collagen fibril formation and its quantity, measured as increased turbidity, was markedly increased by the presence of TNX, whereas type VI collagen did not increase the quantity but accelerated the rate of collagen fibril formation. Combined treatment of both had an additive effect on the rate of collagen fibril formation. Furthermore, deletion of the epidermal growth factor-like (EGF) domain or fibrinogen-like domain of TNX attenuated the initial rate of collagen fibril formation. Finally, we observed abnormally large collagen fibrils by electron microscopy in the skin from TNX-deficient (TNX-/-) mice during development. These findings demonstrate a fundamental role for TNX and type VI collagen in regulation of collagen fibrillogenesis in vivo and in vitro.     

Actinidain-hydrolyzed Type I Collagen Reveals a Crucial Amino Acid Sequence in Fibril Formation

We investigated the ability of type I collagen telopeptides to bind neighboring collagen molecules, which is thought to be the initial event in fibrillogenesis. Limited hydrolysis by actinidain protease produced monomeric collagen, which consisted almost entirely of α1 and α2 chains. As seen with ultrahigh resolution scanning electron microscopy, actinidain-hydrolyzed collagen exhibited unique self-assembly, as if at an intermediate stage, and formed a novel suprastructure characterized by poor fibrillogenesis. Then, the N- and C-terminal sequences of chicken type I collagen hydrolyzed by actinidain or pepsin were determined by Edman degradation and de novo sequence analysis with matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-tandem time-of-flight mass spectrometry, respectively. In the C-telopeptide region of the α1 chain, pepsin cleaved between Asp¹⁰³⁵ and Phe¹⁰³⁶, and actinidain between Gly¹⁰³² and Gly¹⁰³³. Thus, the actinidain-hydrolyzed α1 chain is shorter at the C terminus by three residues, Gly¹⁰³³, Phe¹⁰³⁴, and Asp¹⁰³⁵. In the α2 chain, both proteases cleaved between Glu¹⁰³⁰ and Val¹⁰³¹. We demonstrated that a synthetic nonapeptide mimicking the α1 C-terminal sequence including GFD weakly inhibited the self-assembly of pepsin-hydrolyzed collagen, whereas it remarkably accelerated that of actinidain-hydrolyzed collagen. We conclude that the specific GFD sequence of the C-telopeptide of the α1 chain plays a crucial role in stipulating collagen suprastructure and in subsequent fibril formation.     

Trabecular meshwork's collagen network formation is inhibited by non-pigmented ciliary epithelium-derived extracellular vesicles

The present research aims to determine whether the application of non-pigmented ciliary epithelium cells derived extracellular vesicles to human trabecular meshwork cells affects the formation and secretion of collagen type I to the extracellular matrix formation. Following the extraction of non-pigmented ciliary epithelium derived extracellular vesicles by a precipitation method, their size and concentration were determined using tunable resistive pulse sensing technology. Extracellular vesicles were incubated with trabecular meshwork cells for 3 days. Morphological changes of collagen type I in the extracellular matrix of trabecular meshwork cells were visualized using confocal microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. A Sirius Red assay was used to determine the total amount of collagen. Finally, collagen type I expression levels in the extracellular matrix of trabecular meshwork cells were quantified by cell western analysis. We found that non-pigmented ciliary epithelium extracellular vesicles were very effective at preventing collagen fibres formation by the trabecular meshwork cells, and their secretion to the extracellular matrix was significantly reduced (P < .001). Morphological changes in the extracellular matrix of trabecular meshwork cells were observed. Our study indicates that non-pigmented ciliary epithelium extracellular vesicles can be used to control collagen type I fibrillogenesis in trabecular meshwork cells. These fibrils net-like structure is responsible for remodelling the extracellular matrix. Moreover, we suggest that targeting collagen type I fibril assembly may be a viable treatment for primary open-angle glaucoma abnormal matrix deposition of the extracellular matrix.     

Comparative study on the thermostability of collagen I of skin and bone: Influence of posttranslational hydroxylation of prolyl and lysyl residues

Pepsin-solubilized collagen I from skin and bone was analyzed with regard to its thermal stability as a triple helical molecule in solution and afterin vitro fibril formation. Collagen I from human control bone was compared with samples showing deficiencies or surplus in the degree of hydroxylation of lysine. The helix to coil transitions were studied by circulardichroism measurements and limited trypsin digestion. Melting of fibrils from standardizedin vitro self-assembly was investigated turbidimetrically. Human control bone collagen I has a maximum transition rate (T _m ) at 43.3°C in 0.05% acetic acid. This is 1.9°C above control skin (T _m =41.4°C), most likely, due to a higher degree of prolyl hydroxylation—0.48 in bone vs. 0.41 in skin collagen I. Lysyl overhydroxylation of human and mouse bone collagen I appears to reduce theT _m slightly (1°C). Underhydroxylated bone collagen has aT _m which is 2°C below control. Melting temperatures ofin vitro formed fibrils are an indication for higher thermostability in parallel with an increase of lysyl hydroxylation. Accordingly, the melting temperature of such fibrils from human control skin, 49.3°C, exceeds control bone by 1.4°C. The degree of lysyl hydroxylation in these samples is 0.14 and 0.10, respectively. Further underhydroxylation (0.06) reduced it down to 45.4°C, while extensive overhydroxylation did not continue to increase the thermal stability of fibrils.     

Microrheological Characterization of Collagen Systems: From Molecular Solutions to Fibrillar Gels

Collagen is the most abundant protein in the extracellular matrix (ECM), where its structural organization conveys mechanical information to cells. Using optical-tweezers-based microrheology, we investigated mechanical properties both of collagen molecules at a range of concentrations in acidic solution where fibrils cannot form and of gels of collagen fibrils formed at neutral pH, as well as the development of microscale mechanical heterogeneity during the self-assembly process. The frequency scaling of the complex shear modulus even at frequencies of ∼10 kHz was not able to resolve the flexibility of collagen molecules in acidic solution. In these solutions, molecular interactions cause significant transient elasticity, as we observed for 5 mg/ml solutions at frequencies above ∼200 Hz. We found the viscoelasticity of solutions of collagen molecules to be spatially homogeneous, in sharp contrast to the heterogeneity of self-assembled fibrillar collagen systems, whose elasticity varied by more than an order of magnitude and in power-law behavior at different locations within the sample. By probing changes in the complex shear modulus over 100-minute timescales as collagen self-assembled into fibrils, we conclude that microscale heterogeneity appears during early phases of fibrillar growth and continues to develop further during this growth phase. Experiments in which growing fibrils dislodge microspheres from an optical trap suggest that fibril growth is a force-generating process. These data contribute to understanding how heterogeneities develop during self-assembly, which in turn can help synthesis of new materials for cellular engineering.     

Does collagen microunfolding stimulate fibril formation?

The data on the effect of temperature on the kinetics of collagen fibril formation at physiological pH values and ionic strength in the temperature range 26–39°C have been analyzed. The temperature of 35°C optimal for collagen fibril formation has been defined as the point of inflection for half-maximal turbidity and collagen molecule microunfolding values, which corresponds to the temperature of the first transition on the heat absorption curve. The temperature range (32–35°C) in which collagen microunfolding stimulates fibril formation has been determined.     

The Influence of Simple Phenols on Collagen Type I Fibrillogenesis in vitro

The influence of phenolic compounds with different numbers of hydroxy groups (phenol, pyrocatechol, resorcinol, and pyrogallol) on the kinetics of in vitro fibrillogenesis of collagen and on fibril structure has been studied. It has been shown that these phenols accelerate fibril formation mainly by shortening the lag phase, presumably facilitating the formation of collagen dimers and their subsequent association to linear aggregates. The accelerating activity of phenols is proportional to the number of hydroxy groups in the molecule. It increases in the series: phenol < resorcinol < pyrogallol. Therefore, the ability of phenols to accelerate fibril formation is likely to stem from the formation of hydrogen bonds with amino-acid residues in collagen chains. The hydrogen bonds may stabilize the structure of the intermediates, facilitating their interaction during fibrillogenesis.