New insights into the ATP-dependent Clp protease: Escherichia coli and beyond

Proteolysis functions as a precise regulatory mechanism for a broad spectrum of cellular processes. Such control impacts not only on the stability of key metabolic enzymes but also on the effective removal of terminally damaged polypeptides. Much of this directed protein turnover is performed by proteases that require ATP and, of those in bacteria, the Clp protease from Escherichia coli is one of the best characterized to date. The Clp holoenzyme consists of two adjacent heptameric rings of the proteolytic subunit known as ClpP, which are flanked by a hexameric ring of a regulatory subunit from the Clp/Hsp100 chaperone family at one or both ends. The recently resolved three-dimensional structure of the E. coli ClpP protein has provided new insights into its interaction with the regulatory/chaperone subunits. In addition, an increasing number of studies over the last few years have recognized the added complexity and functional importance of ClpP proteins in other eubacteria and, in particular, in photosynthetic organisms ranging from cyanobacteria to higher plants. The goal of this review is to summarize these recent findings and to highlight those areas that remain unresolved.     

ATP-promoted interaction between Clp A and Clp P in activation of Clp protease from Escherichia coli.

Clp protease is a high relative molecular mass, ATP-dependent protease found in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. Clp protease is composed of two protein components, Clp A, which has ATPase activity, and Clp P, which has the proteolytic active site and is activated by Clp A in the presence of ATP. Clp P subunits (Mr = 21,500) are arranged in two hexagonal rings directly superimposed on each other, and under low salt conditions two dodecamers associate to form a particle with Mr approximately 440,000. Clp A (subunit Mr = 83,000) and Clp P do not associate in the absence of nucleotide, but Clp A with ATP bound associates with Clp P to form an active proteolytic complex with Mr approximately 700,000. Although adenosine 5'-[beta gamma-imido]triphosphate (AMPPNP) weakly promotes association between Clp A and Clp P, non-hydrolysable analogues of ATP do not activate proteolysis, indicating that association between the components is not sufficient to allow proteolysis. Association between Clp A and Clp P does not alter the basal ATPase activity of Clp A, but addition of protein substrates is accompanied by an increase in ATP hydrolysis by Clp A. Chemically-inactivated Clp P or inactive mutants of Clp P also associate with Clp A, but no increase in the ATPase activity of Clp A is observed, either in the presence or absence of protein substrates, when Clp P is inactive. Thus the increased ATP hydrolysis is dependent on active proteolysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The two-component, ATP-dependent Clp protease of Escherichia coli. Purification, cloning, and mutational analysis of the ATP-binding component

The ATP-binding component (Component II, hereafter referred to as ClpA) of a two-component, ATP-dependent protease from Escherichia coli has been purified to homogeneity. ClpA is a protein with subunit Mr 81,000. It has an intrinsic ATPase activity and activates degradation of protein substrates only in the presence of a second component (Component I, hereafter referred to as ClpP), Mg2+, and ATP. The amount of ClpA varies by less than a factor of 2 in cells grown in different media and at temperatures from 30 to 42 degrees C. ClpA does not appear to be a heat-shock protein since its synthesis is not dependent on htpR. Antibodies against purified ClpA were used to identify lambda transducing phage bearing the clpA gene. The cloned gene contains a DNA sequence expected to code for the first 28 amino acids of ClpA, which were determined by protein sequencing of purified ClpA. The clpA gene in the phage was mutated by insertion of delta kan defective transposons and the mutations were transferred to E. coli by homologous recombination. The clpA gene was mapped to 19 min on the E. coli chromosome. Mutant cells with insertions early in the gene produce no ClpA protein detectable in Western blots, and extracts of such mutant cells have no detectable ClpA activity. clpA- mutants grow well under all conditions tested and are not defective in turnover of proteins during nitrogen starvation nor in the turnover of such highly unstable proteins as the lambda proteins O, N, and cII, or the E. coli proteins SulA, RcsA, and glutamate dehydrogenase. The degradation of abnormal canavanine-containing proteins is defective in clpA mutants especially in cells that also have a lon- mutation. Extracts of clpA- lon- cells have ATP-dependent casein degrading activity.     

Bacteriophage Mu repressor as a target for the Escherichia coli ATP-dependent Clp Protease.

Bacteriophage Mu repressor, which is stable in its wildtype form, can mutate to become sensitive to its Escherichia coli host ATP-dependent ClpXP protease. We further investigated the determinants of the mutant repressor's sensitivity to Clp. We show the crucial importance of a C-terminal, seven amino acid long sequence in which a single change is sufficient to decrease the rate of degradation of the protein. The sequence was fused at the C-terminal end of the CcdB and CcdA proteins encoded by plasmid F. CcdB, which is naturally stable, was unaffected, while CcdA, which is normally degraded by the Lon protease, became a substrate for ClpXP while remaining a substrate for Lon. In agreement with the current hypothesis on the mechanism of recognition of their substrates by energy- dependent proteases, these results support the existence, on the substrate polypeptides, of separate motifs responsible for recognition and cleavage by the protease.     

The ATP-dependent Clp protease in chloroplasts of higher plants

The best-known proteases in plastids are those that belong to families common to eubacteria. One of the first identified was the ATP-dependent caseinolytic protease (Clp), whose structure and function have been well characterized in Escherichia coli . Plastid Clp proteins in higher plants are surprisingly numerous and diverse, with at least 16 distinct Clp proteins in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana . Multiple paralogues exist for several of the different types of plastid Clp protein, with the most extreme being five for the proteolytic subunit ClpP. Both biochemical and genetic studies have recently begun to reveal the intricate structural interactions between the various Clp proteins, and their importance for chloroplast function and plant development. Much of the recent data suggests that the function of many of the Clp proteins probably affects more specific processes within chloroplasts, in addition to the more general 'housekeeping' role previously assumed.     

A multiple-component, ATP-dependent protease from Escherichia coli

A new ATP-dependent, casein-degrading proteolytic complex has been identified and partially purified from Escherichia coli. The proteolytic complex can be isolated from wild-type cells as well as from mutants in which the gene for the ATP-dependent Lon protease is deleted. The complex consists of at least two components (components I and II) that can be separated from each other (and from wild-type Lon protease) by phosphocellulose chromatography. Neither component has casein-degrading activity when added separately to assay solutions with or without ATP. Both components must be present simultaneously for casein degradation to occur. Of the nucleotides tested, only ATP activates the proteolytic complex, and the ATP must be present continuously for degradation to occur. Component II copurifies with an ATPase activity and binds to a Type 4 ATP affinity column. ATP protects component II from heat inactivation, suggesting that component II interacts with ATP. Proteolysis was not inhibited by any serine protease inhibitors but was inhibited by reagents such as the organomercurial Neohydrin and N-ethylmaleimide, which react with sulfhydryl groups. Our data provide convincing evidence that E. coli possesses a previously undescribed proteolytic system composed of at least two complementary components and absolutely dependent on ATP.     

ATP-dependent association between subunits of Clp protease in pea chloroplasts

The chloroplast ATP-dependent Clp protease (EC 3.4.21.92) is composed of the proteolytic subunit ClpP and the regulatory ATPase, ClpC. Although both subunits are found in the stroma, the interaction between the two is dynamic. When immunoprecipitation with antibodies against ClpC was performed on stroma from dark-adapted pea (Pisum sativum L. cv. Alaska) chloroplasts, ClpC but not ClpP was precipitated. However, when stroma was supplemented with ATP, both ClpC and ClpP were precipitated. Co-immunoprecipitation was even more efficient in the presence of ATP-gamma-S, suggesting that the association between regulatory and proteolytic subunits is dependent on binding of ATP to ClpC, but not its hydrolysis. To further test this association, stroma was fractionated by column chromatography, and the presence of Clp subunits in the different fractions was monitored immunologically. When stroma depleted of ATP was fractionated on an ion-exchange column, ClpP and ClpC migrated separately, whereas in the presence of ATP-gamma-S both subunits co-migrated. Similar results were observed in size-exclusion chromatography. To further characterize the precipitated enzyme, its proteolytic activity was assayed by testing its ability to degrade beta-casein. No degradation was observed in the absence of ATP, and degradation was inhibited in the presence of phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, consistent with Clp being an ATP-dependent serine protease. The activity of the isolated enzyme was further tested using chimeric OE33 as a model substrate. This protein was also degraded in an ATP-dependent manner, supporting the suggested role of Clp protease as a major housekeeping protease in the stroma.     

The ClpX heat-shock protein of Escherichia coli, the ATP-dependent substrate specificity component of the ClpP-ClpX protease, is a novel molecular chaperone.

All major classes of protein chaperones, including DnaK (the Hsp70 eukaryotic equivalent) and GroEL (the Hsp60 eukaryotic equivalent) have been found in Escherichia coli. Molecular chaperones enhance the yields of correctly folded polypeptides by preventing aggregation and even by disaggregating certain protein aggregates. Previously, we identified the ClpX heat-shock protein of E. coli because it enables the ClpP catalytic protease to degrade the bacteriophage lambda O replication protein. Here we report that ClpX alone possesses all the properties expected of a molecular chaperone protein. Specifically, it can protect the lambda O protein from heat-induced aggregation, disaggregate preformed lambda O aggregates, and even promote efficient binding of lambda O to its DNA recognition sequence. A lambda O-ClpX specific protein-protein interaction can be detected either by a modified ELISA assay or through the stimulation of ClpX's weak ATPase activity by lambda O. Unlike the behaviour of the major DnaK and GroEL chaperones, ClpX requires the presence of ATP or its non-hydrolysable analogue ATP-gamma-S for efficient interaction with other proteins including the protection of lambda O from aggregation. However, ClpX's ability to disaggregate lambda O aggregates requires hydrolysable ATP. We propose that the ClpX protein is a bona fide chaperone, whose biological role includes the maintenance of certain polypeptides in a form competent for proteolysis by the ClpP protease. Furthermore, our results suggest that the ClpX protein also performs typical chaperone protein functions independent of ClpP.     

Role of Clp protease subunits in degradation of carbon starvation proteins in Escherichia coli.

When deprived of a carbon source, Escherichia coli induces the synthesis of a group of carbon starvation proteins. The degradation of proteins labeled during starvation was found to be an energy-dependent process which was inhibited by the addition of KCN and accelerated when cells were resupplied with a carbon source. The degradation of the starvation proteins did not require the ATP-dependent Lon protease or the energy-independent proteases protease I, protease IV, OmpT, and DegP. During starvation, mutants lacking either the ClpA or ClpP subunit of the ATP-dependent Clp protease showed a partial reduction in the degradation of starvation proteins. Strains lacking ClpP failed to increase degradation of starvation proteins when glucose was added to starving cells. The clpP mutants showed a competitive disadvantage compared with wild-type cells when exposed to repeated cycles of carbon starvation and growth. Surprisingly, the glucose-stimulated, ClpP-dependent degradation of starvation proteins did not require either the ClpA or ClpB protein. The patterns of synthesis of starvation proteins were similar in clpP+ and clpP cells. The clpP mutants had reduced rates of degradation of certain starvation proteins in the membrane fraction when a carbon source was resupplied to the starved cells.     

The chloroplast ATP-dependent Clp protease in vascular plants - new dimensions and future challenges

The ATP-dependent Clp protease is by far the most intricate protease in chloroplasts of vascular plants. Structurally, it is particularly complex with a proteolytic core complex containing 11 distinct subunits along with three potential chaperone partners. The Clp protease is also essential for chloroplast development and overall plant viability. Over the past decade, many of the important characteristics of this crucial protease have been revealed in the model plant species Arabidopsis thaliana. Despite this, challenges still remain in fully resolving certain key features, in particular, how the assembly of this multisubunit protease is regulated, the full range of native protein substrates and how they are targeted for degradation and how this complicated enzyme might have developed from simpler bacterial forms. This article focuses upon the recent advances in revealing the details underlying these important features. It also take the opportunity to speculate upon many of these findings in the hope of stimulating further investigation.     

Binding of nucleotides to the ATP-dependent protease La from Escherichia coli

A critical enzyme in protein breakdown in Escherichia coli is the ATP-hydrolyzing protease La, the lon gene product. In order to clarify the role of ATP in proteolysis, we studied ATP and ADP binding to this enzyme using rapid gel filtration to separate free from bound ligands. In the presence of Mg2+ or Mn2+ and 10 microM ATP, two molecules of ATP were bound to the tetrameric enzyme, while at 100 microM ATP (or higher), four ATP molecules were bound, both at 0 and 37 degrees C. Protease La thus has two high affinity sites (S0.5 less than 10(-7) M) for ATP and two lower affinity sites (S0.5 = 12-15 microM). Binding was reversible. In the absence of a divalent ion, ATP bound to only two sites. However, much lower Mg2+ concentrations (50 microM) were required for maximal ATPase binding than for maximal proteolytic and ATPase activity (2 mM). Decavanadate, which is a potent inhibitor of proteolysis, also blocked ATP binding, but orthovanadate had neither effect. Different ATP analogs bind to these sites in distinct ways. Adenyl-5'-yl imidodiphosphate binds to only one high affinity site, while adenyl-5'-yl methylene monophosphonate binds to two. Nevertheless, both non-metabolizable analogs can activate oligopeptide hydrolysis as well as ATP. Although binding of a single nucleotide can activate peptide hydrolysis, occupancy of all four sites appears necessary for maximal protein breakdown. The ATP molecules on all four sites are hydrolyzed rapidly. The Pi is released, but ADP remains on the enzyme. ADP binds to the same four sites, but this process does not require divalent ions. Protease La shows higher affinity for ADP than for ATP. Therefore, in vivo, ADP should inhibit ATP binding and protease La function.     

Virulence in bacteriophage Mu: a case of trans-dominant proteolysis by the Escherichia coli Clp serine protease.

The importance of proteases in gene regulation is well documented in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems. Here we describe the first example of genetic regulation controlled by the Escherichia coli Clp ATP-dependent serine protease. Virulent mutants of bacteriophage Mu, which carry a particular mutation in their repressor gene (vir mutation), successfully infect Mu lysogens and induce the resident Mu prophage. We show that the mutated repressors have an abnormally short half-life due to an increased susceptibility to Clp-dependent degradation. This susceptibility is communicated to the wild type repressor present in the same cell, which provides the Muvir phages with their trans-dominant phenotype. To our knowledge this is the first case where the instability of a mutant protein is shown to trigger the degradation of its wild type parent.     

Regulation of activity of an ATP-dependent protease, Clp, by the amount of a subunit, ClpA, in the growth of Escherichia coli cells

The activity of an ATP-dependent protease, Clp, was examined in Escherichia coli SG1110 (lon-) in various growth phases. The ATP-dependent proteolytic activity (Clp activity) in a crude extract of the cells changed with the growth phase. Cells in the early exponential growth phase showed the lowest activity, but then the activity increased dramatically with cell growth. The highest Clp activity was found in the cells in the late exponential and early stationary phases, however, the activity returned to the original level on prolonged culturing. These changes in Clp activity were closely correlated to the amount of one of the components of Clp, Clp A, which was quantitated immunochemically with antibodies against the Clp A protein. However, the amount of the other component of Clp, Clp P, did not change with the growth phase. These results suggest that the activity of Clp in the cells is regulated by the amount of Clp A in various growth phases. We next examined the effect of the cellular ATP level on Clp activity, because ATP is a cofactor for Clp protease in vitro. The addition of dinitrophenol (DNP) and sodium azide reduced the intracellular concentration of ATP, but had no effect on the Clp activity or the level of the Clp A protein when these drugs were added to the culture at the stationary phase. On the other hand, these drugs elevated both the Clp activity and the Clp A amount in exponentially growing cells, whose cellular ATP level was also reduced.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The unique sites in SulA protein preferentially cleaved by ATP-dependent Lon protease from Escherichia coli.

SulA protein is known to be one of the physiological substrates of Lon protease, an ATP-dependent protease from Escherichia coli. In this study, we investigated the cleavage specificity of Lon protease toward SulA protein. The enzyme was shown to cleave approximately 27 peptide bonds in the presence of ATP. Among them, six peptide bonds were cleaved preferentially in the early stage of digestion, which represented an apparently unique cleavage sites with mainly Leu and Ser residues at the P1, and P1' positions, respectively, and one or two Gln residues in positions P2-P5. They were located in the central region and partly in the C-terminal region, both of which are known to be important for the function of SulA, such as inhibition of cell growth and interaction with Lon protease, respectively. The other cleavage sites did not represent such consensus sequences, though hydrophobic or noncharged residues appeared to be relatively preferred at the P1 sites. On the other hand, the cleavage in the absence of ATP was very much slower, especially in the central region, than in the presence of ATP. The central region was predicted to be rich in alpha helix and beta sheet structures, suggesting that the enzyme required ATP for disrupting such structures prior to cleavage. Taken together, SulA is thought to contain such unique cleavage sites in its functionally and structurally important regions whose preferential cleavage accelerates the ATP-dependent degradation of the protein by Lon protease.     

Structural and functional insights into the chloroplast ATP-dependent Clp protease in Arabidopsis

In contrast with the model Escherichia coli Clp protease, the ATP-dependent Clp protease in higher plants has a remarkably diverse proteolytic core consisting of multiple ClpP and ClpR paralogs, presumably arranged within a dual heptameric ring structure. Using antisense lines for the nucleus-encoded ClpP subunit, ClpP6, we show that the Arabidopsis thaliana Clp protease is vital for chloroplast development and function. Repression of ClpP6 produced a proportional decrease in the Clp proteolytic core, causing a chlorotic phenotype in young leaves that lessened upon maturity. Structural analysis of the proteolytic core revealed two distinct subcomplexes that likely correspond to single heptameric rings, one containing the ClpP1 and ClpR1-4 proteins, the other containing ClpP3-6. Proteomic analysis revealed several stromal proteins more abundant in clpP6 antisense lines, suggesting that some are substrates for the Clp protease. A proteolytic assay developed for intact chloroplasts identified potential substrates for the stromal Clp protease in higher plants, most of which were more abundant in young Arabidopsis leaves, consistent with the severity of the chlorotic phenotype observed in the clpP6 antisense lines. The identified substrates all function in more general housekeeping roles such as plastid protein synthesis, folding, and quality control, rather than in metabolic activities such as photosynthesis.