UCP1: The Original Uncoupling Protein—and Perhaps the Only One? New Perspectives on UCP1, UCP2, and UCP3 in the Light of the Bioenergetics of the UCP1-Ablated Mice

The availability of a UCP1-ablated mouse has enabled critical studies of the function of UCP1,UCP2, and UCP3. Concerning UCP1, its presence in brown-fat mitochondria is associatedwith innate uncoupling, high GDP-binding capacity, and GDP-inhibitable Cl^- permeabilityand uncoupling—but the high fatty acid sensitivity found in these mitochondria is observedeven in the absence of UCP1. The absence of UCP1 leads to low cold tolerance but not toobesity. UCP1 ablation also leads to an augmented expression of UCP2 and UCP3 in brownadipose tissue, making this tissue probably the one that boasts the highest expression ofthese UCPs. However, these very high expression levels are not associated with any inherentuncoupling, or with a specific GDP-binding capacity, or with a GDP-sensitive Cl^- permeability,or with any effect of GDP on mitochondrial membrane potential, or with an increased basalmetabolism of cells, or with the presence of norepinephrine- or fatty acid-induced thermogenesisin cells, and not with a cold-acclimation recruited, norepinephrine-induced thermogenicresponse in the intact animal. Therefore, it can be discussed whether any uncoupling effect isassociated with UCP2 or UCP3 when they are endogenously expressed and, consequently,whether (loss of) uncoupling (thermogenic) effects of UCP2 or UCP3 can be invoked toexplain metabolic phenomena, such as obesity.     

The molecular and biochemical basis of nonshivering thermogenesis in an African endemic mammal, Elephantulus myurus

Uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) mediated nonshivering thermogenesis (NST) in brown adipose tissue (BAT) is an important avenue of thermoregulatory heat production in many mammalian species. Until recently, UCP1 was thought to occur exclusively in eutherians. In the light of the recent finding that UCP1 is already present in fish, it is of interest to investigate when UCP1 gained a thermogenic function in the vertebrate lineage. We elucidated the basis of NST in the rock elephant shrew, Elephantulus myurus (Afrotheria: Macroscelidea). We sequenced Ucp1 and detected Ucp1 mRNA and protein restricted to brown fat deposits. We found that cytochrome c oxidase activity was highest in these deposits when compared with liver and skeletal muscle. Consistent with a thermogenic function of UCP1 isolated BAT mitochondria showed increased state 4 respiration in the cold, as well as palmitate-induced, GDP-sensitive proton conductance, which was absent in liver mitochondria. On the whole animal level, evidence of thermogenic function was further corroborated by an increased metabolic response to norepinephrine (NE) injection. Cold acclimation (18 degrees C) led to an increased basal metabolic rate relative to warm acclimation (28 degrees C) in E. myurus, but there was no evidence of additional recruitment of NE-induced NST capacity in response to cold acclimation. In summary, we showed that BAT and functional UCP1 are already present in a member of the Afrotheria, but the seasonal regulation and adaptive value of NST in Afrotherians remain to be elucidated.     

Adrenergic regulation of the uncoupling protein expression in foetal rat brown adipocytes in primary culture

The adrenergic and T3 modulation of UCP expression in non-proliferative foetal brown adipocyte primary cultures were studied. The UCP in the cultured cells was determined by immunological detection of the protein and by quantification of the mitochondrial GDP-binding. Our results showed a relative increase of 65-75% in UCP levels and 60-80% in the mitochondrial GDP-binding capacity under beta-adrenergic stimulatory conditions, while neither alpha 1-adrenergic agonists nor T3 showed an effect.     

Brown adipose tissue activity in hypocaloric-diet fed lactating rats

Hypocaloric diet feeding reduced the mitochondrial protein content and whole tissue GDP-binding in interscapular brown adipose tissue from both virgin and lactating rats. A reduction in brown fat lipoprotein lipase activity was also detected in underfed virgin and lactating animals. These results indicate that lactation in the rat, even though it produces a reduction in brown fat activity, does not impair the capacity of the tissue to respond to a diminished caloric intake by lowering its activity further.     

Ontogeny and perinatal modulation of gene expression in rat brown adipose tissue. Unaltered iodothyronine 5'-deiodinase activity is necessary for the response to environmental temperature at birth

We have performed a sequential study on the abundance of the mRNA for uncoupling protein (UCP), subunit II of cytochrome-c oxidase (COII) and lipoprotein lipase in brown adipose tissue during the fetal and postnatal periods. Moreover, we have determined whether these parameters can be modulated by ambient temperature in the early hours after birth, and at which point in development this sensitivity first appears. UCP gene expression in the fetal and neonatal period has particular features when compared with overall mitochondriogenesis (COII mRNA expression) or with the expression of lipoprotein lipase mRNA. There is a specific induction of UCP gene expression between days 18 and 19 of pregnancy followed by a specific increase of UCP gene expression in utero and a further increase after birth. The acquisition of the physiological apparatus capable of the response to UCP and lipoprotein lipase gene expression to the environmental temperature is not achieved until the last day of fetal development. This result suggests that mechanisms of beta-adrenergic modulation of gene expression in brown fat are already established at birth. From an experiment on iopanoic acid treatment of pregnant mothers, it was concluded that iodothyronine 5'-deiodinase activity is not necessary for the expression of the mRNAs for UCP, COII and lipoprotein lipase in the fetus whereas it is necessary for the acquisition of temperature sensitivity to these parameters at birth.     

Rapid postnatal changes in F1-ATPase proteins and in the uncoupling protein in brown adipose tissue mitochondria of the newborn rat

Changes in F1-ATPase and UCP protein contents and in the activity of respiratory complexes I, II and IV of brown adipose tissue mitochondria are reported during the first 0-6 hours of life in the rat. Mitochondrial UCP/F1-ATPase protein ratio is used to define the onset of thermogenic differentiation of brown adipose tissue mitochondria. It is concluded that mitochondrial differentiation occurs soon after birth and that the process is accelerated by hypothermic conditions.     

On the mechanism of mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 function

Native uncoupling protein 1 (UCP 1) was purified from rat mitochondria by hydroxyapatite chromatography and identified by peptide mass mapping and tandem mass spectrometry. Native and expressed UCP 1 were reconstituted into liposomes, and proton flux through UCP 1 was shown to be fatty acid-dependent and GDP-sensitive. To investigate the mechanism of action of UCP 1, we determined whether hydrophilic modification of the omega-carbon of palmitate effected its transport function. We show that proton flux was greater through native UCP 1-containing proteoliposomes when facilitated by less hydrophilically modified palmitate (palmitate > omega-methoxypalmitate > omega-hydroxypalmitate with little or no proton flux due to glucose-O-omega-palmitate or undecanesulfonate). We show that non-proton-dependent charge transfer was greater when facilitated by less hydrophilically modified palmitate (palmitate/undecanesulfonate > omega-methoxypalmitate > omega-hydroxypalmitate, with no non-proton-dependent charge transfer flux due to glucose-O-omega-palmitate). We show that the GDP-inhibitable oxygen consumption rate in brown adipose tissue mitochondria was reversed by palmitate (as expected) but not by glucose-O-omega-palmitate. Our data are consistent with the model that UCP 1 flips long-chain fatty acid anions and contradict the "cofactor" model of UCP 1 function.     

Synergy of fatty acid and reactive alkenal activation of proton conductance through uncoupling protein 1 in mitochondria

The kinetics of proton transport through mammalian UCP1 (uncoupling protein 1) expressed in yeast mitochondria were measured. There was little or no UCP1 activity in the absence of added palmitate, but significant activity in its presence. The activator 4-HNE (4-hydroxy-2-nonenal) had little effect when added alone, but significantly enhanced proton conductance in the presence of added palmitate. Activation of the proton conductance of UCP1 was synergistic: proton conductance in the presence of both palmitate and 4-HNE was significantly greater than the sum of the individual effects. Mitochondria from control yeast transformed with empty vector showed no such synergy, showing that synergy is a property of UCP1. Activation by the 4-HNE analogue trans-cinnamate showed essentially the same characteristics as activation by 4-HNE. Mitochondria from brown adipose tissue also showed synergistic activation of GDP-sensitive proton conductance by palmitate and 4-HNE. These results show that reactive alkenals activate the proton conductance of UCP1 more strongly when fatty acids are also added, with implications for both mechanistic and physiological models of UCP1 activation.     

The bioenergetics of brown fat mitochondria from UCP1-ablated mice. Ucp1 is not involved in fatty acid-induced de-energization ("uncoupling").

The bioenergetics of brown fat mitochondria isolated from UCP1-ablated mice were investigated. The mitochondria had lost the high GDP-binding capacity normally found in brown fat mitochondria, and they were innately in an energized state, in contrast to wild-type mitochondria. GDP, which led to energization of wild-type mitochondria, was without effect on the brown fat mitochondria from UCP1-ablated mice. The absence of thermogenic function did not result in reintroduction of high ATP synthase activity. Remarkably and unexpectedly, the mitochondria from UCP1-ablated mice were as sensitive to the de-energizing ("uncoupling") effect of free fatty acids as were UCP1-containing mitochondria. Therefore, the de-energizing effect of free fatty acids does not appear to be mediated via UCP1, and free fatty acids would not seem to be the intracellular physiological activator involved in mediation of the thermogenic signal from the adrenergic receptor to UCP1. In the UCP1-ablated mice, Ucp2 mRNA levels in brown adipose tissue were 14-fold higher and Ucp3 mRNA levels were marginally lower than in wild-type. The Ucp2 and Ucp3 mRNA levels were therefore among the highest found in any tissue. These high mRNA levels did not confer on the isolated mitochondria any properties associated with de-energization. Thus, the mere observation of a high level of Ucp2 or Ucp3 mRNA in a tissue cannot be taken as an indication that mitochondria isolated from that tissue will display innate de-energization or thermogenesis.     

Uncoupling Protein 1 Decreases Superoxide Production in Brown Adipose Tissue Mitochondria

In thermogenic brown adipose tissue, uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) catalyzes the dissipation of mitochondrial proton motive force as heat. In a cellular environment of high oxidative capacity such as brown adipose tissue (BAT), mitochondrial uncoupling could also reduce deleterious reactive oxygen species, but the specific involvement of UCP1 in this process is disputed. By comparing brown adipose tissue mitochondria of wild type mice and UCP1-ablated litter mates, we show that UCP1 potently reduces mitochondrial superoxide production after cold acclimation and during fatty acid oxidation. We address the sites of superoxide production and suggest diminished probability of “reverse electron transport” facilitated by uncoupled respiration as the underlying mechanism of reactive oxygen species suppression in BAT. Furthermore, ablation of UCP1 represses the cold-stimulated increase of substrate oxidation normally seen in active BAT, resulting in lower superoxide production, presumably avoiding deleterious oxidative damage. We conclude that UCP1 allows high oxidative capacity without promoting oxidative damage by simultaneously lowering superoxide production.     

Role of UCP3 in state 4 respiration during contractile activity-induced mitochondrial biogenesis.

In an effort to better characterize uncoupling protein-3 (UCP3) function in skeletal muscle, we assessed basal UCP3 protein content in rat intermyofibrillar (IMF) and subsarcolemmal (SS) mitochondrial subfractions in conjunction with measurements of state 4 respiration. UCP3 content was 1.3-fold (P < 0.05) greater in IMF compared with SS mitochondria. State 4 respiration was 2.6-fold greater (P < 0.05) in the IMF subfraction than in SS mitochondria. GDP attenuated state 4 respiration by approximately 40% (P < 0.05) in both subfractions. The UCP3 activator oleic acid (OA) significantly increased state 4 respiration in IMF mitochondria only. We used chronic electrical stimulation (3 h/day for 7 days) to investigate the relationship between changes in UCP3 protein expression and alterations in state 4 respiration during contractile activity-induced mitochondrial biogenesis. UCP3 content was increased by 1.9- and 2.3-fold in IMF and SS mitochondria, respectively, which exceeded the concurrent 40% (P < 0.05) increase in cytochrome-c oxidase activity. Chronic contractile activity increased state 4 respiration by 1.4-fold (P < 0.05) in IMF mitochondria, but no effect was observed in the SS subfraction. The uncoupling function of UCP3 accounted for 50-57% of the OA-induced increase in state 4 respiration in IMF mitochondria, which was independent of the induced twofold difference in UCP3 content due to chronic contractile activity. Thus modifications in UCP3 function are more important than changes in UCP3 expression in modifying state 4 respiration. This effect is evident in IMF but not SS mitochondria. We conclude that UCP3 at physiological concentrations accounts for a significant portion of state 4 respiration in both IMF and SS mitochondria, with the contribution being greater in the IMF subfraction. In addition, the contradiction between human and rat training studies with respect to UCP3 protein expression may partly be explained by the greater than twofold difference in mitochondrial UCP3 content between rat and human skeletal muscle.     

Brown adipose tissue dynamics in wild-type and UCP1-knockout mice: in vivo insights with magnetic resonance

We used noninvasive magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and magnetic resonance spectroscopy to compare interscapular brown adipose tissue (iBAT) of wild-type (WT) and uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1)-knockout mice lacking UCP1-mediated nonshivering thermogenesis (NST). Mice were sequentially acclimated to an ambient temperature of 30°C, 18°C, and 5°C. We detected a remodeling of iBAT and a decrease in its lipid content in all mice during cold exposure. Ratios of energy-rich phosphates (ATP/ADP, phosphocreatine/ATP) in iBAT were maintained stable during noradrenergic stimulation of thermogenesis in cold- and warm-adapted mice and no difference between the genotypes was observed. As free fatty acids (FFAs) serve as fuel for thermogenesis and activate UCP1 for uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation, brown adipose tissue is considered to be a main acceptor and consumer of FFAs. We measured a major loss of FFAs from iBAT during noradrenergic stimulation of thermogenesis. This mobilization of FFAs was observed in iBAT of WT mice as well as in mice lacking UCP1. The high turnover and the release of FFAs from iBAT suggests an enhancement of lipid metabolism, which in itself contributes to the sympathetically activated NST and which is independent from uncoupled respiration mediated by UCP1. Our study demonstrates that MRI, besides its potential for visualizing and quantification of fat tissue, is a valuable tool for monitoring functional in vivo processes like lipid and phosphate metabolism during NST.     

Uncoupling protein 2, but not uncoupling protein 1, is expressed in the female mouse reproductive tract

Uncoupling proteins (UCPs) are transporters of the inner mitochondrial membrane. Whereas UCP1 is uniquely present in brown adipose tissue where it uncouples respiration from ATP synthesis and activates respiration and heat production, UCP2 is present in numerous tissues, and its exact function remains to be clarified. Two sets of data provided the rationale for this study: (i) the intriguing report that UCP1 is present in uterus of mice (Nibbelink, M., Moulin, K., Arnaud, E., Duval, C., Penicaud, L., and Casteilla, L. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 47291-47295); and (ii) an observation that Ucp2(-/-) female mice (homozygous matings) have smaller litters compared with Ucp2(+/+) animals (S. Rousset and A.-M. Cassard-Doulcier, unpublished observations). These data prompted us to examine the expression of UCP1 and UCP2 in the reproductive tract of female mice. Using wild type, Ucp1(-/-) mice, and Ucp2(-/-) mice, we were unable to detect UCP1 in uterus of mice with appropriate antibodies, and we conclude that the signal assigned to UCP1 by others was neither UCP1 nor UCP2. Using a polyclonal antibody against UCP2 and tissues from Ucp2(-/-) mice as controls, UCP2 was detected in ovary, oviduct, and uterus. Expression of Ucp2 mRNA was also observed in ovary and uterus using in situ hybridization analysis. Bone marrow transplantation experiments revealed that the UCP2 signal of the ovary was restricted to ovarian cells. UCP2 level in ovary decreased during follicular growth and increased during the pre-ovulatory period, during which aspects of an inflammatory process are known to exist. Because UCP2 down-regulates reactive oxygen species, a role in the regulation of inflammatory events linked to the preparation of ovulation is suggested.     

Fenofibrate activates the biochemical pathways and the de novo expression of genes related to lipid handling and uncoupling protein-3 functions in liver of normal rats

Fibrates (anti-hyperlipidemic agents) enhance the mRNA expression of uncoupling protein 2 (UCP2) in the liver and that of uncoupling protein 3 (UCP3) in skeletal muscle in standard-diet-fed rats and induce a de novo expression of UCP3 (mRNA and protein) in the liver of high-fat-fed rats. Here, we report that in the liver of normal rats, fenofibrate induces a de novo expression of UCP3 and a 6-fold increase in UCP2 mRNA, whereas UCP2 protein was not detectable. Indeed, we evidenced an ORF in UCP2 exon 2 potentially able to inhibit the expression of the protein. Fenofibrate increases the expression and activity of hepatic enzymes and cofactors involved in lipid handling and UCP3 activity and, as is the case for UCP3, induces other muscle-specific genes (e.g., Carnitine palmitoyl transferase 1b and Ubiquinone biosynthesis protein COQ7 homolog). In addition, we demonstrated that in mitochondria from fenofibrate-treated rats a palmitoyl-carnitine-induced GDP-sensitive uncoupling takes place, involving UCP3 rather than other uncouplers (i.e., UCP2 and Adenine Nucleotide Translocase). Thus, the liver of fenofibrate-treated standard-diet- fed rat is a useful model for investigations of the biochemical functions of UCP3 and allowed us to demonstrate that fenofibrate programs a gene-expression pattern able to modulate lipid handling and UCP3 activation.     

Uncoupling protein mRNA, mitochondrial GTP-binding, and T4 5′-deiodinase activity of brown adipose tissue in Daurian ground squirrel during hibernation and arousal

The mRNA level of uncoupling protein (UCP) specific for brown adipose tissue (BAT) in Daurian ground squirrel, was detected by using a [32P]-labeled oligonucleotide probe. The UCP concentration in mitochondria was indirectly determined by titration with its specific ligand [H3]-labeled GTP. Type II T4 5'-deiodinase of BAT was assayed concomitantly. We found two species of mRNA for UCP with lengths of about 1.9 and 1.5 kb, respectively, both occurring in almost the same concentration. UCP mRNA content was elevated significantly during hibernation, but the UCP concentration did not change compared with that of nonhibernating controls kept at room temperature. When hibernating squirrels were aroused, the UCP mRNA remained at the elevated level as during hibernation, but the UCP concentration increased in comparison with that of nonhibernating controls or during hibernating. Changes in T4 5'-deiodinase activity in BAT were similar to the variations of the UCP mRNA level. These results suggest that the activation of T4 5'-deiodinase in BAT may be an important factor for the up-regulation and maintenance of UCP mRNA content needed for the synthesis of sufficient UCP to acquire the thermogenic capacity for arousal from hibernation.     

An ancient look at UCP1

Brown adipose tissue serves as a thermogenic organ in placental mammals to defend body temperature in the cold by nonshivering thermogenesis. The thermogenic function of brown adipose tissue is enabled by several specialised features on the organ as well as on the cellular level, including dense sympathetic innervation and vascularisation, high lipolytic capacity and mitochondrial density and the unique expression of uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1). This mitochondrial carrier protein is inserted into the inner mitochondrial membrane and stimulates maximum mitochondrial respiration by dissipating proton-motive force as heat. Studies in knockout mice have clearly demonstrated that UCP1 is essential for nonshivering thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue. For a long time it had been presumed that brown adipose tissue and UCP1 emerged in placental mammals providing them with a unique advantage to survive in the cold. Our subsequent discoveries of UCP1 orthologues in ectotherm vertebrates and marsupials clearly refute this presumption. We can now initiate comparative studies on the structure-function relationships in UCP1 orthologues from different vertebrates to elucidate when during vertebrate evolution UCP1 gained the biochemical properties required for nonshivering thermogenesis.     

An ancient look at UCP1

Brown adipose tissue serves as a thermogenic organ in placental mammals to defend body temperature in the cold by nonshivering thermogenesis. The thermogenic function of brown adipose tissue is enabled by several specialised features on the organ as well as on the cellular level, including dense sympathetic innervation and vascularisation, high lipolytic capacity and mitochondrial density and the unique expression of uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1). This mitochondrial carrier protein is inserted into the inner mitochondrial membrane and stimulates maximum mitochondrial respiration by dissipating proton-motive force as heat. Studies in knockout mice have clearly demonstrated that UCP1 is essential for nonshivering thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue. For a long time it had been presumed that brown adipose tissue and UCP1 emerged in placental mammals providing them with a unique advantage to survive in the cold. Our subsequent discoveries of UCP1 orthologues in ectotherm vertebrates and marsupials clearly refute this presumption. We can now initiate comparative studies on the structure–function relationships in UCP1 orthologues from different vertebrates to elucidate when during vertebrate evolution UCP1 gained the biochemical properties required for nonshivering thermogenesis.