Characterization of non-host resistance in broad bean to the wheat stripe rust pathogen

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Non-host resistance (NHR) confers plant species immunity against the majority of microbialpathogens and represents the most robust and durable form of plant resistance in nature. Asone of the main genera of rust fungi with economic and biological importance, Puccinia infects almost all cereals but is unable to cause diseases on legumes. Little is known about themechanism of this kind of effective defense in legumes to these non-host pathogens. RESULTS: In this study, the basis of NHR in broad bean (Vicia faba L.) against the wheat stripe rustpathogen, Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici (Pst), was characterized. No visible symptomswere observed on broad bean leaves inoculated with Pst. Microscopic observations showedthat successful location of stomata and haustoria formation were significantly reduced in Pstinfection of broad bean. Attempted infection induced the formation of papillae, cell wallthickening, production of reactive oxygen species, callose deposition and accumulation ofphenolic compounds in plant cell walls. The few Pst haustoria that did form in broad beancells were encased in reactive oxygen and callose materials and those cells elicited cell death.Furthermore, a total of seven defense-related genes were identified and found to be upregulatedduring the Pst infection. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that NHR in broad bean against Pst results from a continuum of layereddefenses, including basic incompatibility, structural and chemical strengthening of cell wall,posthaustorial hypersensitive response and induction of several defense-related genes,demonstrating the multi-layered feature of NHR. This work also provides useful informationfor further determination of resistance mechanisms in broad bean to rust fungi, especially theadapted important broad bean rust pathogen, Uromyces viciae-fabae, because of strongsimilarities and association between NHR of plants to unadapted pathogens and basalresistance of plants to adapted pathogens.     

Nonhost resistance of rice to rust pathogens

Rice is atypical in that it is an agricultural cereal that is immune to fungal rust diseases. This report demonstrates that several cereal rust species (Puccinia graminis f. sp tritici, P. triticina, P. striiformis, and P. hordei) can infect rice and produce all the infection structures necessary for plant colonization, including specialized feeding cells (haustoria). Some rust infection sites are remarkably large and many plant cells are colonized, suggesting that nutrient uptake occurs to support this growth. Rice responds with an active, nonhost resistance (NHR) response that prevents fungal sporulation and that involves callose deposition, production of reactive oxygen species, and, occasionally, cell death. Genetic variation for the efficacy of NHR to wheat stem rust and wheat leaf rust was observed. Unlike cereal rusts, the rust pathogen (Melampsora lini) of the dicotyledenous plant flax (Linum usitatissimum) rarely successfully infects rice due to an apparent inability to recognize host-derived signals. Morphologically abnormal infection structures are produced and appressorial-like structures often don't coincide with stomata. These data suggest that basic compatibility is an important determinate of nonhost infection outcomes of rust diseases on cereals, with cereal rusts being more capable of infecting a cereal nonhost species compared with rust species that are adapted for dicot hosts.     

Loss of actin cytoskeletal function and EDS1 activity,in combination,severely compromises non-host resistance in Arabidopsis against wheat powdery mildew

Plant immunity against the majority of the microbial pathogens is conveyed by a phenomenon known as non-host resistance (NHR). This defence mechanism affords durable protection to plant species against given species of phytopathogens. We investigated the genetic basis of NHR in Arabidopsis against the wheat powdery mildew fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici (Bgt). Both primary and appressorial germ tubes were produced from individual Bgt conidia on the surface of the Arabidopsis leaves. Attempted infection occasionally resulted in successful penetration, which led to the development of an abnormal unilateral haustorium. Inoculation of a series of Arabidopsis defence-related mutants with Bgt resulted in the attenuation of reactive oxygen intermediate (ROI) production and salicylic acid (SA)-dependent defence gene expression in eds1, pad4 and nahG plants, which are known to be defective in some aspects of host resistance. Furthermore, Bgt often developed bilateral haustoria in the mutant Arabidopsis lines that closely resembled those formed in wheat. A similar decrease in NHR was observed following treatment of the wild-type Arabidopsis plants with cytochalasin E, an inhibitor of actin microfilament polymerisation. In eds1 mutants, inhibition of actin polymerisation severely compromised NHR in Arabidopsis against Bgt. This permitted completion of the Bgt infection cycle on these plants. Therefore, actin cytoskeletal function and EDS1 activity, in combination, are major contributors to NHR in Arabidopsis against wheat powdery mildew.     

Hypersensitive lignification response as the mechanism of non-host resistance of wheat against oat crown rust

Seven-day-old seedlings of the near-isogenic wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.) lines Prelude and Prelude-Sr5, susceptible and resistant to wheat stem rust, respectively, were inoculated with uredospores of the oat crown rust fungus Puccinia coronata Cda. f. sp. avenae Fraser & Led. Fluorescence microscopy revealed that the majority of colonies developed intercellular infection structures including haustorial mother cells and haustoria after penetration of wheat mesophyll cells. All penetrated cells became necrotic, and exhibited bright yellow autofluorescence. This autofluorescence was not extractable with alkali, and fluorescent cells stained positively with phloroglucinol/HCI, suggesting that hypersensitive cell death was correlated with cellular lignification. Accordingly, the lignin biosynthetic enzymes phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (EC4.3.1.5). 4-coumarate:CoA ligase (EC6.2.1.12), cinnamyl-alcohol dehydrogenase (EC1.1.1.149), and peroxidases (EC1.11.1.7) increased in activity during the expression of resistance. The induced pattern of peroxidase iso/ymes closely resembled that observed for highly incompatible wheat/wheat stem rust interactions. Furthermore, an elieitor was extracted from oat crown rust germlings. which induces lignification when injected into the intercellular space of wheat leaves. This elieitor appears to be functionally similar to that isolated from wheat stem rust germlings. The results suggest that the non-host resistance of wheat to the xenopara-site oat crown rust closely resembles the race/cullivar-speeific resistant mechanism of highly resistant wheat varieties to wheat stem rust.     

Characterization of nonhost resistance of Arabidopsis to the Asian soybean rust

Asian soybean rust (ASR), caused by Phakopsora pachyrhizi, is a devastating disease of soybean. We report the use of the nonhost plant Arabidopsis thaliana to identify the genetic basis of resistance to P. pachyrhizi. Upon attack by P. pachyrhizi, epidermal cells of wild-type Arabidopsis accumulated H2O2, which likely orchestrates the frequently observed epidermal cell death. However, even when epidermal cell death occurred, fungal hyphae grew on and infection was terminated at the mesophyll boundary. These events were associated with expression of PDF1.2, suggesting that P. pachyrhizi, an ostensible biotroph, mimics aspects of a necrotroph. Extensive colonization of the mesophyll occurred in Arabidopsis pen mutants with defective penetration resistance. Although haustoria were found occasionally in mesophyll cells, the successful establishment of biotrophy failed, as evidenced by the cessation of fungal growth. Double mutants affected in either jasmonic acid or salicylic acid signaling in the pen3-1 background revealed the involvement of both pathways in nonhost resistance (NHR) of Arabidopsis to P. pachyrhizi. Interestingly, expression of AtNHL10, a gene that is expressed in tissue undergoing the hypersensitive response, was only triggered in infected pen3-1 mutants. Thus, a suppression of P. pachyrhizi-derived effectors by PEN3 can be inferred. Our results demonstrate that Arabidopsis can be used to study mechanisms of NHR to ASR.     

Microscopy and proteomic analysis of the non-host resistance of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oryza sativa</Emphasis> to the wheat leaf rust fungus, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Puccinia triticina</Emphasis> f. sp. <Emphasis Type="Italic">tritici</Emphasis>

Rice (Oryza sativa) cv. Nipponbare expresses non-host resistance (NHR) to the wheat leaf rust fungus, Puccinia triticina f. sp. tritici (Ptt). When the leaves of cv. Nipponbare were inoculated with Ptt, approx 93% of the urediniospores germinated on the leaf surface, but only 10% of the germinated spores formed appressoria over the stomata at one day post inoculation (1 dpi). Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) accumulated in host cells around the appressoria at 3 dpi. Approx. 3% of the appressoria produced short hyphae inside the leaf, and fluorescence was observed in tissue invaded by the hyphae by 7 dpi. At 22 dpi, 0.2% of the sites with appressoria formed branching infection hypha in mesophyll cells, but no substomatal vesicles, haustorial mother cells or haustoria were observed. Proteins were extracted from leaves 3 dpi and analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE). A total 33 spots were reproducibly up-regulated and 9 were down-regulated by infection compared to the water inoculated control. Of these, 30 were identified by MALDI-TOF Mass Spectrometry. The identified proteins participate in defense/stress responses, energy/carbohydrate metabolism, oxidation–reduction processes, protein folding/turnover/cleavage/degradation, signal transduction and cell death regulation. The results indicates that NHR of rice to Ptt is consistent with a shift in protein and energy metabolism, increased antimicrobial activities, possibly including phytoalexin accumulation and cell wall reinforcement, increased cell repair, antioxidive and detoxification reactions, and enhanced prevention of plant cell death. Nearly half of the up-regulated identified proteins were associated with chloroplast and mitochondrial physiology suggesting important roles for these organelles during NHR.     

Cytological studies on rust fungi. (vi) fine structures of infection process of Kuehneola japonica (diet.) dietel

The behavior of rust fungi in their host plants has been elucidated by electron microscopy. However, most of the ultrastructural studies on rust fungi have focused on the uredial stage. In order to elucidate the features of the sporidial stage, we studied the fine structure of Kuehneola japonica, a short-cycle rust, in rose leaves. Infection pegs arising from appressoria penetrated the host walls. Papillae formed at the time of penetration against the outer epidermal cell walls. The papillae which had formed at the penetration sites grew extensively and partially surrounded the intracellular hyphae which were connected with the infection pegs. The intracellular hyphae in the epidermal cells developed further and entered adjacent parenchyma cells. Walls of parenchyma cells either invaginated or thin papillae formed at penetration sites and the invaginated walls or papillae surrounded the necks of the intracellular hyphae. Intracellular hyphae in both epidermal and parenchyma cells were not enveloped by the sheath before 20 days after inoculation. In specimens prepared 20 days after inoculation, some of the intracellular hyphae were enveloped by a sheath in both palisade and spongy parenchyma cells. The sheathed hyphae resembled haustoria of other rust fungi which had been described previously. Teliospore initials were formed in mycelial masses in intercellular spaces between the epidermal cells and palisade parenchyma cells 20 days after inoculation. Uninucleate teliospores developed from teliospore initials 30 days after inoculation.Contribution No. 32.     

Haustorium Formation and Cell Wall Appositions in Susceptible and Partially Resistant Wheat and Barley Seedlings Infected with Wheat Leaf Rust

Phase contrast light microscopy observations of wheat and barley seedlings infected with wheat leaf rust spores suggested that cell wall appositions are structural barriers against haustorium formation leading to abortion of infection structures. Nearly equal numbers of cell wall appositions per infection structure were detected in seedlings of susceptible and partially resistant wheat genotypes. Differences between susceptible and partially resistant genotypes became evident after the first haustorium had been formed. This again indicates the presence of a post-haustorial effect of partial resistance. Some factors influencing nutrient uptake are discussed. Wheat leaf rust colonies hardly formed haustoria in barley seedlings, the few not aborted infection structures were accompanied by cell collapse. The mechanisms of partial resistance in wheat and barley to their respective leaf rust fungi seem different, but their non-host reactions appear similar.     

The involvement of reactive oxygen species in defense of wheat lines with the genes introgressed from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Agropyron</Emphasis> species contributing the resistance against brown rust

The role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the defense of nearly isogenic lines of common wheat (Triticum aestivum L., cv. Thatcher) with the genes of resistance to brown rust introgressed from Agropyron species was studied using light microscopy. This disease is induced by the fungus Puccinia triticina Erikss. The presence of superoxide anion in the sites of infection was detected with the dye nitro blue tetrazolium. In addition, we studied fungus development on plants treated with the inhibitor of Ca²⁺-channels, verapamil, disturbing penetration into the cells of Ca²⁺ required for ROS generation. During fungus development in the immune line with the Lr38 resistance gene (from A. intermedium (Host) Beuv.), oxidative burst developed at the sites of contacts of appressoria with stomata and exerted a fungicidic effect. When ROS generation was suppressed, the fungus developed haustoria in the mesophyll cells. In plants with the Lr19 gene (from A. elongatum (Host) Beuv.), only moderate amount of superoxide anion accumulated on the cell walls of stomatal guard cells and in the infection structures when the fungus penetrated into the substomatal cavity and in mesophyll cells. In plants with the Lr24 gene (from A. elongatum), superoxide anion was detected only around haustoria. Suppression of ROS generation in plants harboring the Lr19 and Lr24 genes did not affect fungus entrance into the substomatal cavity but facilitated penetration of haustoria into the mesophyll cells. At the same time, in the lines with the Lr1 gene (from T. aestivum), cytological examination did not detect O ₂ ^? accumulation in plant cells, whereas treatment with verapamil enhanced mycelium development. In all lines, the suppression of oxidative burst slowed the development of hypersensitive response.     

An investigation into the involvement of defense signaling pathways in components of the nonhost resistance of Arabidopsis thaliana to rust fungi also reveals a model system for studying rust fungal compatibility

Seventeen accessions of Arabidopsis thaliana inoculated with the cowpea rust fungus Uromyces vignae exhibited a variety of expressions of nonhost resistance, although infection hypha growth typically ceased before the formation of the first haustorium, except in Ws-0. Compared with wild-type plants, there was no increased fungal growth in ndr1 or eds1 mutants defective in two of the signal cascades regulated by the major class of Arabidopsis host resistance genes. However, in the Col-0 background, infection hyphae of U. vignae and two other rust fungi were longer in sid2 mutants defective in an enzyme that synthesizes salicylic acid (SA), in npr1 mutants deficient in a regulator of the expression of SA-dependent pathogenesis related (PR) genes, and in NahG plants containing a bacterial salicylate hydroxylase. Infection hyphae of U. vignae and U. appendiculatus but not of Puccinia helianthi were also longer in jar1 mutants, which are defective in the jasmonic acid defense signaling pathway. Nevertheless, haustorium formation increased only for the Uromyces spp. and only in sid2 mutants or NahG plants. Rather than the hypersensitive cell death that usually accompanies haustorium formation in nonhost plants, Arabidopsis typically encased haustoria in calloselike material. Growing fungal colonies of both Uromyces spp., indicative of a successful biotrophic relationship between plant and fungus, formed in NahG plants, but only U. vignae formed growing colonies in the sid2 mutants and cycloheximide-treated wild-type plants. Growing colonies did not develop in NahG tobacco or tomato plants. These data suggest that nonhost resistance of Arabidopsis to rust fungi primarily involves the restriction of infection hypha growth as a result of defense gene expression. However, there is a subsequent involvement of SA but not SA-dependent PR genes in preventing the Uromyces spp. from forming the first haustorium and establishing a sufficient biotrophic relationship to support further fungal growth. The U. vignae-Arabidopsis combination could allow the application of the powerful genetic capabilities of this model plant to the study of compatibility as well as nonhost resistance to rust fungi.     

Attachment of bean rust cell wall material to host and non-host plant tissue

A preparation of bean rust (Uromyces phaseoli) germ tube walls, consisting of short, filamentous particles, was labeled with fluorescein iso-thiocyanate. Freeze sections of host and non-host tissue were incubated in the labeled preparation. Maximum staining was observed in host plant tissue (Phaseolus vulgaris), in which bean rust regularly forms haustoria. In tissue of the non-host plantsVigna sinensis andPhaseolus lunatus, where fewer haustoria were formed, staining was only weak. However, no staining was observed in the non-host tissue ofPhaseolus aureus, Helianthus annuus, Brassica oleracea andHordeum vulgare in which the infection hypha did not form haustoria. This would appear to indicate that formation of haustoria is induced by a specific attachment of the hyphal wall to the host wall. The possibility that elicitors attach in a similar way, is discussed.Abbreviations FITC Fluorescein iso-thiocyanate - cv cultivar     

Effect of Host Plant Resistance on Haustorium Formation in Cereal Rust Fungi

Haustoria of Puccinia triticina (wheat leaf rust fungus) and P. hordei (barley leaf rust fungus) were isolated from susceptible and partially resistant wheat lines, and susceptible, hypersensitive and partially resistant barley lines. Haustoria were counted and measured. The size of haustoria was similar in the partially resistant and susceptible genotypes but haustoria were smaller in the hypersensitive barley line L94+Pa7. The number of haustoria was reduced in both partially and hypersensitive lines when compared with susceptible ones. Therefore it seems that the reduction in the number of haustoria is a consequence of the resistance that can be attributable either to early abortion of infection units or reduced colony growth. The reduction of the number of haustoria was more pronounced in the adult plant stage.     

三裂叶豚草锈菌侵染寄主叶片的显微和超微观察

【背景】三裂叶豚草是我国重要的外来入侵植物之一,其传播速度快,已给我国造成巨大的经济损失。近年来发现的三裂叶豚草锈菌是一种对其具有生物防治潜力的病原菌。【方法】本文利用显微技术研究了三裂叶豚草锈菌的侵染过程及其对寄主结构的影响。【结果】三裂叶豚草锈菌菌丝可从多处侵入同一个叶肉细胞,胞间菌丝与叶肉细胞相接触可使部分细胞壁增厚。锈菌侵染使三裂叶豚草叶脉末梢导管分枝增多,造成三裂叶豚草水分代谢失调;叶片细胞内膜系统破碎化,细胞器结构受到不同程度的破坏,导致细胞内膜系统紊乱,细胞器结构稳定性降低。【结论与意义】豚草锈菌侵染破坏了三裂叶豚草叶片的细胞结构。本研究为深入研究豚草锈菌的致病机理奠定了基础。     

Influence of carbohydrates on the induction of haustoria of the cowpea rust fungusin vitro

Rust fungi are obligate plant parasites whose successful parasitism appears to depend on the formation of haustoria within living plant cells. To test the hypothesis that the lack of haustorium formation in the absence of a living cell reflects a need for a simple “signal” released during attempted invasion, various carbohydrates were applied toin vitro-formed infection structures ofUromyces vignae just prior to haustorial mother cell (HMC) formation. Up to 6% of HMCs formed haustoria after treatment with arabinose, mannose, xylose, sucrose, or xylan. Other monosaccharides, oligosaccharides, and polysaccharides were less or not effective. Sugar mixtures induced haustorium frequencies of up to 10%. Timing of the application of inducing chemicals was critical. The data indicate that haustorium formation does not require the presence of a living plant cell and may be triggered by plant products at the time of penetration peg development.     

Histological and cytological characterization of adult plant resistance to wheat stripe rust

Wheat cultivar Xingzi 9104 (XZ) possesses adult plant resistance (APR) to stripe rust caused by Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici (Pst). In this study, histological and cytological experiments were conducted to elucidate the mechanisms of APR in XZ. The results of leaf inoculation experiments indicated that APR was initiated at the tillering stage, gradually increased as the plant aged and highly expressed after boot stage. The histology and oxidative burst in infected leaves of plants at seedling, tillering and boot stages were examined using light microscopic and histochemical methods. Subcellular changes in the host–pathogen interactions during the seedling and boot stages were analyzed by transmission electron microscopy. The results showed that haustorium formation was retarded in the adult plants and that the differentiation of secondary intercellular hyphae was significantly inhibited, which decreased the development of microcolonies in the adult plants, especially in plants of boot stage. The expression of APR to stipe rust during wheat development was clearly associated with extensive hypersensitive cell death of host cells and localized production of reactive oxygen species, which coincided with the restriction of fungal growth in infection sites in adult plants. At the same time, cell wall-related resistance in adult plants prevented ingression of haustorial mother cells into plant cells. Haustorium encasement was coincident with malformation or death of haustoria. The results provide useful information for further determination of mechanisms of wheat APR to stripe rust. Key message The expression of APR to stipe rust in wheat cultivar Xingzi 9104 (XZ) was clearly associated with extensive hypersensitive cell death of host cells and the localized production of reactive oxygen species.     

Histological Observations on Uromyces phaseoli and Puccinia recondita Infection in Allopurinol-treated Susceptible Plants

The development of rust after administering allopurinol, a specific inhibitor of xanthine oxidoreductase, via roots was studied at the histological level in leaves of susceptible‘Pinto 111’bean plants inoculated with Uromyces phaseoli and‘Thatcher',‘Mentana’and‘Leopardo’wheat plants challenged with Puccinia recondita. A marked reduction and delay in fungal growth was observed in allopurinol-treated plants starting between 24 h and 48 h post-inoculation, i.e. after differentiation of the first haustoria (onset of the biotrophic plant-parasite relationship). Infection hyphae often grew twisted and convoluted in treated hosts, sometimes producing small, irregularly shaped colonies. Differentiation of subepidermal stromata in fungal colonies was delayed and restricted by the treatment and uredospore yield severely reduced. Allopurinol administration also tended to increase the proportion of haustoria which became embedded in thick translucent sheaths during the late stages of infection. These results support the view that plant xanthine oxidoreductase activity is necessary for biotrophic development of rust fungi and suggest that the inhibition of this enzyme, which impairs the pathogen metabolism, may favour some natural host responses to attack such as haustorial sheath formation.     

冠盘二胞Marssonina coronaria侵染不同抗性苹果叶片的组织病理学研究

利用光学和电子显微镜,从组织细胞学水平系统研究了冠盘二胞Marssonina coronaria在苹果抗、感病品种叶片上的侵染过程及侵染后寄主细胞的超微结构特征。结果表明：冠盘二胞的侵入和定殖过程可以分为6个阶段：孢子萌发与芽管形成、附着胞形成、侵入细胞角质层、在叶肉细胞内产生吸器、菌丝在叶肉细胞间和细胞内扩展、分生孢子盘形成。随着菌丝扩展,受侵寄主细胞出现细胞壁加厚,细胞壁降解,质壁分离,叶绿体内淀粉粒、嗜饿颗粒积累,叶绿体基粒片层瓦解,线粒体空泡化等现象。在不同抗性的苹果品种上,分生孢子萌发率差别不明     

Cytochemical Detection of Cell Wall Bound Peroxidase in Rust Infected Broad Bean Leaves*

Cell wall bound peroxidase activity, cytochemically detected by 3,3-diaminobenzidine (DAB), appears unevenly distributed in areolae of broad bean (cv. Aguadulce) leaves infected by the rust fungus Uromyces viciae-fahae (Pers.) Schroet. DAB positivity is not significantly traceable at the periphery of the areola and close to the site of uredinium formation; heavy DAB deposits occur on walls of haustoria containing mesophyll cells. Induction of localized peroxidase activity appears strictly related to the haustorium mother cell differentiation, i.e. to the incipient parasitic phase; it does not, however, counteract the intracellular growth of the haustorium.     

Induced Systemic Resistance in Tomato Plants against Phytophthora infestans

Infection of lower leaves of tomato plants with Phytophthora infestans followed by a period unfavourable to disease development increased the general resistance of the plants against the pathogen. Induced resistance to a second infection of upper leaves was expressed in the development of necrotic lesions that were sharply defined and reduced in size. Sporulation of the pathogen was suppressed. Lesions on unprotected plants expanded with a sporulating zone passing gradually to the healthy tissue under the same conditions. Induced resistance delayed and reduced penetration of the pathogen into the epidermis and subsequent colonisation of the mesophyll by formation of papillae in epidermal cells and hypersensitive-like reactions of penetrated, mesophyll cells.     

Chitin deacetylase activity of the rust Uromyces viciae-fabae is controlled by fungal morphogenesis

Abstract The broad bean rust fungus Uromyces viciae-fabae exhibits chitin only on surfaces of those infection structures which in nature are formed on the plant cuticle, but not on those differentiated in the intercellular space of the host leaf. Chitin deacetylase, an enzyme which converts chitin to chitosan, has been studied during in vitro differentiation of rust infection structures. Radiometrie and gel electrophoretic analyses of crude extracts and extracellular washing fluids have shown that chitin deacetylase activity massively increases when the fungus starts to penetrate through the stomata, and that formation of the enzyme is strictly differentiation-specifically controlled. The extracellular portion of chitin deacetylase activity was about 53% in 24-h-old differentiated infection structures. Five isoforms with apparent molecular masses of 48.1, 30.7, 25.2, 15.2 and 12.7 kDa were detectable after substrate SDS-PAGE. The enzyme is temperature-sensitive and has a pH optimum of 5.5-6.0.