Phorbol esters inhibit chondrogenesis in limb mesenchyme by mechanisms independent of PGE2 or cyclic AMP1

Effects of the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) on chondrogenesis and concentrations of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and cyclic AMP (cAMP) were investigated in micromass cultures of chick limb mesenchyme derived from the distal tip of stage 25 limb buds. TPA completely inhibited chondrogenesis during the first 4 days of culture; however, a few small cartilage nodules formed by day 6. Relative to control cultures, both PGE2 and cAMP concentrations were altered by TPA treatment during the 6-day period of cell culture. Concentrations of both compounds increased in control cells during the first 24 h of culture and then declined during the remaining 5 days. In TPA-treated cells both PGE2 and cAMP levels increased progressively during the 6 days of days of cell culture, each being elevated at day 6 by twofold over control cells. The results suggest the presence of regulatory pathways important in chondrogenesis which occur independent of those initiated by PGE2 and the cAMP system.     

Inhibition of limb chondrogenesis by a Veratrum alkaloid: temporal specificity in vivo and in vitro

It has been demonstrated that jervine, a steroidal alkaloid derived from plants of the genus Veratrum, exerts teratogenic effects in several animal species. Defects were restricted to structures which depend upon normal chondrogenesis for their development. Here we report studies of the temporal specificity of cellular sensitivity using limb bud mesenchyme cells obtained from Day 10 mouse embryos. These cells, when grown as high-density "spot" cultures, undergo chondrogenesis in vitro. Prior to differentiation, exposure of limb cell cultures to jervine suppressed subsequent accumulation of cartilage proteoglycans. Treatment after differentiation had no significant effect. Additionally, there was a genetic component to jervine sensitivity: C57BL/6J mice were sensitive, whereas NIH Swiss-Webster mice were insensitive. This strain-dependent difference was observed both in vivo and in vitro, supporting the validity of limb mesenchyme spot cultures as a model for jervine-induced teratogenicity. Our studies indicate that jervine acts specifically during an early phase of the differentiation of mesenchyme into cartilage. It is likely that a specific stem cell population is the target tissue of this compound.     

Effect of TGF-beta 1, TGF-beta 2, and bFGF on chick cartilage and muscle cell differentiation

In insulin containing defined medium TGF-beta 1, TGF-beta 2, and bFGF all stimulate chondrogenic differentiation in high-density micromass cultures of distal limb bud mesenchyme cells of chick embryos. In addition bFGF inhibits myogenic differentiation, while TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2 appear to have no effect. TGF-beta 1 and bFGF together act additively to enhance chondrogenesis, while TGF-beta blocks the bFGF inhibitory action on myoblasts, thus allowing them to differentiate. In the absence of insulin, the inhibitory effect of bFGF on muscle cell differentiation is reduced; cartilage differentiation in the presence of the above growth factors is also slightly reduced.     

High density micromass cultures of embryonic limb bud mesenchymal cells: An in vitro model of endochondral skeletal development

Summary To study the mechanisms regulating endochondral skeletal development, we examined the characteristics of long-term, high density micromass cultures of embryonic chicken limb bud mesenchymal cells. By culture Day 3, these cells underwent distinct chondrogenesis, evidenced by cellular condensation to form large nodules exhibiting cartilage-like morphology and extracellular matrix. By Day 14, extensive cellular hypertrophy was seen in the core of the nodules, accompanied by increased alkaline phosphatase activity, and the limitation of cellular proliferation to the periphery of the nodules and to internodular areas. By Day 14, matrix calcification was detected by alizarin red staining, and calcium incorporation increased as a function of culture time up to 2 to 3 wk and then decreased. X-ray probe elemental analysis detected the presence of hydroxyapatite. Analogous to growth cartilage developing in vivo, these cultures also exhibited time-dependent apoptosis, on the basis of DNA fragmentation detected in situ by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate (dUTP) nick end labeling (TUNEL), ultrastructural nuclear morphology, and the appearance of internucleosomal DNA degradation. These findings showed that cellular differentiation, maturation, hypertrophy, calcification, and apoptosis occurred sequentially in the embryonic limb mesenchyme micromass cultures and indicate their utility as a convenient in vitro model to investigate the regulatory mechanisms of endochondral ossification.     

Exogenous glycosaminoglycans modulate chondrogenesis, cyclic AMP level and cell growth in limb bud mesenchyme cultures

Effects of hyaluronate, heparin and chondroitin-6-sulfate were studied on micromass cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme (Hamburger and Hamilton stages 23-24). Histochemical, electron microscopical, biochemical and radiochemical investigations of day 4 cultures revealed dose-dependent inhibitory effects of these glycosaminoglycans on chondrogenesis, cyclic AMP level and growth of cells. In addition, hyaluronate with 100 micrograms/ml dose caused a displacement of newly formed proteoglycan from cultures into the medium. It is supposed that exogenous glycosaminoglycans influence ionic equilibrium in the immediate vicinity of cells and disturb the organization of the prechondrogenic extracellular matrix resulting in alterations of cell membrane--cytoskeleton associations. These alterations may provoke a reduction in cyclic AMP level and DNA synthesis. It is suggested that a reduction in cyclic AMP level preceding the expression of cartilage phenotype results in the inhibition of chondrogenesis.     

Transient expression of a cell surface heparan sulfate proteoglycan (syndecan) during limb development

Syndecan is an integral membrane proteoglycan that contains both heparan sulfate and chondroitin sulfate chains and that links the cytoskeleton to interstitial extracellular matrix components, including collagen and fibronectin. Immunohistochemistry with a monoclonal antibody directed to the core protein of the syndecan ectodomain has been used to analyze the distribution of this proteoglycan in the developing mouse limb bud and in high-density cultures of limb mesenchyme cells. By Day 9 of gestation when the limb buds are just apparent, syndecan is detected on cells throughout the limb region, including both ectodermal and mesenchymal components. This distribution does not change as the limb bud elongates along its proximodistal axis, except for its reduction in the apical ectodermal ridge. By Day 11, the intensity of immunofluorescence in the central core decreases relative to other regions. By Day 13 immunostaining is lost in the regions destined for chondrogenesis and myogenesis but persists in the limb ectoderm and peripheral and distal mesenchyme. In the limb mesenchyme cell cultures, syndecan is initially undetected, but is found throughout the culture by 24 hr. With further culture the antigen becomes reduced in chondrogenic foci and in association with myogenic cells. When chick limb ectoderm is placed on the high-density cultures, immunoreactivity in the mouse mesenchyme is enhanced suggesting that epithelial-mesenchymal interactions modulate syndecan expression in the limb bud. Based on analysis of 35S-labeled syndecan from the cultures, syndecan from limb mesenchyme cells contains more glycosaminoglycan chains and is larger in size than the previously described polymorphic forms of syndecan from various epithelia. The high affinity of syndecan for components of the extracellular matrix and its distribution in the early limb bud are consistent with a role in maintaining the morphologic integrity of the limb bud during the period of initiation and rapid outgrowth, and in preventing the onset of chondrogenesis.     

Proliferation of cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro

Continuous exposure of chicken embryo limb bud mesenchyme cells undergoing chondrogenesis in vitro to [3H] thymidine thymidine [(3H]TdR) revealed that more than 90% of the cells synthesized DNA at least once during 120 h of culture. When cells were exposed to [3H]TdR for 24 h beginning at various times throughout the culture period, the percentage of cells which incorporated [3H]TdR during each period was approximately 92%. However, when the period for incorporation of radioisotope was limited to two hours, the number of cells which incorporated [3H]TdR was found to decline during chondrogenesis in vitro. This decline was coincident with the appearance of extracellular matrix material and occurred in those cells which had, and had not, expressed the cartilage phenotype. We conclude from these studies that (1) practically all of the cells continue to proliferate while chondrogenesis is occurring in vitro, (2) there is an increase in the length of the cell cycle during chondrogenesis in vitro, and (3) withdrawal from the cell cycle is not required for differentiation of mesenchyme into cartilage.     

Polyionic regulation of cartilage development: promotion of chondrogenesis in vitro by polylysine is associated with altered glycosaminoglycan biosynthesis and distribution.

The development of cartilage nodules in cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme (Hamburger-Hamilton stages 23/24) is significantly promoted when the culture medium is supplemented with (poly-L-lysine (PL) (M(r) greater than or equal to 14K) (San Antonio and Tuan, 1986. Dev. Biol. 115: 313). Here we present findings consistent with the hypothesis that PL may promote chondrogenesis by interacting electrostatically with sulfated glycosaminoglycans (GAGs): (1) poly-L-ornithine, poly-L-histidine, poly-D,L-lysine, and lysine-containing heteropolypeptides stimulate chondrogenesis in proportion to their contents of cationic residues; (2) the effects of PL are diminished when limb mesenchyme cultures are supplemented with exogenous GAGs, including heparin, dermatan sulfate, and chondroitin sulfate; (3) in high density cultures of limb bud mesenchyme, the release of sulfated macromolecules, but not of proteins in general, into the culture medium was significantly inhibited by PL (398K M(r)) treatment, and a net increase in total GAG content of the PL-treated cultures was observed; and (4) in monolayer cultures of cells derived from other chick embryonic tissues, including liver, skeletal muscle, and calvaria, PL treatment promoted the cell layer-associated retention of sulfated GAG. These effects were not observed using the nonstimulatory, low M(r) PL (4K). Based on the above findings and those from previous studies, it is proposed that PL may promote chondrogenesis by interacting electrostatically with cartilage GAGs, thus trapping the extracellular matrix around the newly emerging cartilage nodules and thereby stabilizing their growth and differentiation.     

Platelet-derived growth factor A modulates limb chondrogenesis both in vivo and in vitro

Cartilage formation in the chick limb follows rapid proliferation, condensation and differentiation of limb mesenchyme. The control of these early events is poorly understood. Platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha (PDGFR-alpha) is present throughout the mesenchyme of early chick limb buds, while its ligand, PDGF-A, is expressed in the surrounding epithelium. PDGFR-alpha is down-regulated in areas that will not give rise to cartilage and is then lost from cartilage forming areas after they begin to differentiate. PDGF-A increases chondrogenesis in micromass cultures of stage-20-24 limb buds, but not stage 25, where it inhibits chondrogenesis. Ectopic PDGF-A in the chick wing can lead to either a localized increase in cartilage formation, or an inhibition. Inhibition of PDGF signalling in the chick limb results in the loss of cartilage. These data demonstrate that PDGF-A functions to promote chondrogenesis at early stages of limb development and suggest that it inhibits chondrogenesis at later stages.     

Chondrogenesis of limb bud mesenchyme in vitro: stimulation by cations

To analyze the nature of cell-cell interactions in chondrogenesis, two cations that influence these interactions, calcium and poly-L-lysine (PL), were tested for their effects on chondrogenesis in vitro. High density cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme (Hamilton-Hamburger stages 23/24), were exposed to culture media containing calcium (0.6-3.3 mM) or PL (1-10 micrograms/ml). Both cations stimulated chondrogenesis in a dose-dependent manner, and also promoted cartilage formation in normally non-chondrogenic, low cell density cultures. Chondrogenesis was assayed based on cartilage nodule number, [35S]sulfate incorporation, and expression of type II collagen as detected by immunohistochemistry. The calcium effect was not mimicked by other divalent cations (Cd, Co, Ni, Mg, Mn, and Sr). The effect of PL was dependent on its Mr (greater than or equal to 14K) and charge, and was mimicked by poly-D-lysine but not by lysine or other analogs of PL or lysine (epsilon-amino caproic acid, lysozyme, poly-L-arginine, and spermidine). Calcium and PL probably act by different mechanisms since their effects were additive, and required their presence on different days of culture: calcium acted on Day 1, and PL on Day 2. It is proposed that calcium may play a role in the cell aggregation phase of chondrogenesis whereas PL, or a naturally occurring polypeptide of similar nature, may promote chondrogenesis by crosslinking specific anionic components of the cell surface or extracellular matrix.     

Chondrogenesis from single limb mesenchyme cells

It is believed that cell-cell interaction between mesenchyme cells is involved in the initiation of chondrogenesis, based largely on the inability of limb mesenchyme cells to differentiate into cartilage unless cultures are inoculated at densities greater than confluency. The present study describes a culture situation in which single limb mesenchyme cells either in or on type I collagen gels are shown to differentiate into cartilage, as defined by the appearance of a pericellular alcian blue staining matrix, intracellular type II collagen (demonstrated by indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibody), and clonable cartilage cells. Because the differentiation of cartilage cells from single mesenchyme cells occurs only when the cells are in a round configuration, it is proposed that cell shape changes are one factor that can mediate effects of cell-cell interaction on differentiation.     

Ethanol Exposure Stimulates Cartilage Differentiation by Embryonic Limb Mesenchyme Cells

Studies of neural, hepatic, and other cells have demonstrated thatin vitroethanol exposure can influence a variety of membrane-associated signaling mechanisms. These include processes such as receptor-kinase phosphorylation, adenylate cyclase and protein kinase C activation, and prostaglandin production that have been implicated as critical regulators of chondrocyte differentiation during embryonic limb development. The potential for ethanol to affect signaling mechanisms controlling chondrogenesis in the developing limb, together with its known ability to promote congenital skeletal deformitiesin vivo,prompted us to examine whether chronic alcohol exposure could influence cartilage differentiation in cultures of prechondrogenic mesenchyme cells isolated from limb buds of stage 23–25 chick embryos. We have made the novel and surprising finding that ethanol is a potent stimulant ofin vitrochondrogenesis at both pre- and posttranslational levels. In high-density cultures of embryonic limb mesenchyme cells, which spontaneously undergo extensive cartilage differentiation, the presence of ethanol in the culture medium promoted increased Alcian-blue-positive cartilage matrix production, a quantitative rise in³⁵SO₄incorporation into matrix glycosaminoglycans (GAG), and the precocious accumulation of mRNAs for cartilage-characteristic type II collagen and aggrecan (cartilage proteoglycan). Stimulation of matrix GAG accumulation was maximal at a concentration of 2% ethanol (v/v), although a significant increase was elicited by as little as 0.5% ethanol (approximately 85 mM). The alcohol appears to directly influence differentiation of the chondrogenic progenitor cells of the limb, since ethanol elevated cartilage formation even in cultures prepared from distal subridge mesenchyme of stage 24/25 chick embryo wing buds, which is free of myogenic precursor cells. When limb mesenchyme cells were cultured at low density, which suppresses spontaneous chondrogenesis, ethanol exposure induced the expression of high levels of type II collagen and aggrecan mRNAs and promoted abundant cartilage matrix formation. These stimulatory effects were not specific to ethanol, since methanol, propanol, and tertiary butanol treatments also enhanced cartilage differentiation in embryonic limb mesenchyme cultures. Further investigations of the stimulatory effects of ethanol onin vitrochondrogenesis may provide insights into the mechanisms regulating chondrocyte differentiation during embryogenesis and the molecular basis of alcohol's teratogenic effects on skeletal morphogenesis.     

Epithelial effects on limb chondrogenesis involve extracellular matrix and cell shape

Collagen gel cultures of limb bud mesenchymal cells are normally permissive for chondrogenesis but become inhibitory for chondrogenesis when they are preconditioned by limb ectoderm. This inhibition is specific for cartilage differentiation, inasmuch as myoblast differentiation is unaffected and flattened, fibroblastic cells are more numerous on conditioned gels. The antichondrogenic effect of ectoderm-conditioned gels is not blocked by agents that elevate intracellular cyclic AMP levels and that promote chondrogenesis under other conditions. In contrast, the inhibitory effect of the ectoderm is alleviated when cultures are treated with cytochalasin D, a cytoskeleton-disrupting agent that causes the cells to remain spherical. These results suggest that ectoderm-conditioned collagen gels inhibit chondrogenesis through an effect on cell shape.     

Limb development in chick embryos: cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase activity, cyclic AMP, and prostaglandin concentrations during cytodifferentiation and morphogenesis

The effects of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) on cyclic AMP (cAMP) concentrations of chick limb bud cells obtained from limbs at various stages of development were investigated. In addition, endogenous concentrations of PGE2 were examined in whole limbs from comparable stages. Prior to either chondrogenesis or myogenesis (stages 20-23), cells were more responsive to PGE2, in terms of cAMP levels, than those of differentiated phenotypes, obtained at stages 25-28. This greater responsiveness to PGE2 of undifferentiated cells was correlated with endogenous concentrations of PGE2 which were significantly higher in undifferentiated limbs than in limbs containing differentiated cartilage and muscle. Cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) activity was detectable in cell homogenates at each stage examined and did not appear to change in cAMP dependency at any stage. The majority (80-85%) of total enzyme activity was localized in soluble fractions of cell homogenates while the residual activity was localized to membrane-enriched, particulate fractions. The results demonstrate that both responsiveness of limb mesenchyme to PGE2 and endogenous concentrations of PGE2 are maximal prior to cytodifferentiation of limb tissues. The presence of cAMP-dependent protein kinase in these undifferentiated cells supports a regulatory role for both PGE2 and a cAMP-protein phosphorylation system in the differentiation of limb tissues.     

Alterations in the spatiotemporal expression pattern and function of N-cadherin inhibit cellular condensation and chondrogenesis of limb mesenchymal cells in vitro

Cartilage formation in the embryonic limb is presaged by a cellular condensation phase that is mediated by both cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions. N-Cadherin, a Ca(2+)-dependent cell-cell adhesion molecule, is expressed at higher levels in the condensing mesenchyme, followed by down-regulation upon chondrogenic differentiation, strongly suggesting a functional role in the cellular condensation process. To further examine the role of N-cadherin, we have generated expression constructs of wild type and two deletion mutants (extracellular and intracellular) of N-cadherin in the avian replication-competent, RCAS retrovirus, and transfected primary chick limb mesenchymal cell cultures with these constructs. The effects of altered, sustained expression of N-cadherin and its mutant forms on cellular condensation, on the basis of peanut agglutinin (DNA) staining, and chondrogenesis, based on expression of chondrocyte phenotypic markers, were characterized. Cellular condensation was relatively unchanged in cultures overexpressing wild type N-cadherin, compared to controls on all days in culture. However, expression of either of the deletion mutant forms of N-cadherin resulted in decreased condensation, with the extracellular deletion mutant demonstrating the most severe inhibition, suggesting a requirement for N-cadherin mediated cell-cell adhesion and signaling in cellular condensation. Subsequent chondrogenic differentiation was also affected in all cultures overexpressing the N-cadherin constructs, on the basis of metabolic sulfate incorporation, the presence of the cartilage matrix proteins collagen type II and cartilage proteoglycan link protein, and alcian blue staining of the matrix. The characteristics of the cultures suggest that the N-cadherin mutants disrupt proper cellular condensation and subsequent chondrogenesis, while the cultures overexpressing wild type N-cadherin appear to condense normally, but are unable to proceed toward differentiation, possibly due to the prolonged maintenance of increased cell-cell adhesiveness. Thus, spatiotemporally regulated N-cadherin expression and function, at the level of both homotypic binding and linkage to the cytoskeleton, is required for chondrogenesis of limb mesenchymal cells.     

Responsiveness of adenylate cyclase to PGE2 and forskolin in isolated cells from micromass cultures of chick limb mesenchyme during chondrogenesis

Exogenous PGE2 stimulation of adenylate cyclase (AC) in intact and enzymatically dissociated micromass cultures of mesenchymal cells derived from the distal tip of stage 25 chick limb buds was examined over a six day period of culture. Responsiveness to PGE2 was measured in both dissociated and intact cell layers in an effort to determine if an inhibitory interaction occurred between PGE2 receptors and the extracellular matrix synthesized by differentiating chondrocytes. PGE2 responsiveness was maximal in both dissociated and intact prechondrogenic mesenchyme after 24 hours in culture and declined significantly as chondrocyte differentiation occurred on days 3 and 6. Equivalent activation of AC activity by PGE2 at each time point examined was noted in both cell groups. In contrast to the decreased responsiveness of differentiating chondrocytes to PGE2, stimulation of AC by forskolin resulted in increased levels of activity in differentiating chondrocytes of both cell groups between days 3-6. The results of the present study demonstrate that the decline in PGE2 responsiveness of differentiating chondrocytes most likely involves specific changes in the PGE2 receptor complex and not in either the interaction of the receptor with extracellular matrix components or a reduction in the available pool of AC present.     

Characterization of bone-derived chondrogenesis-stimulating activity on embryonic limb mesenchymal cells in vitro

Demineralized bone matrix contains factors which stimulate chondrogenesis and osteogenesis in vivo. A water-soluble extract of bone has been shown to stimulate chondrogenesis in vitro in embryonic limb mesenchymal cells (Syftestad, Lucas & Caplan, 1985). The aim of this study was to analyse the cellular mechanism of the bone-derived chondrogenesis-stimulating activity, with particular attention on how normal requirements for chondrogenesis may be altered. The effects of bovine bone extract (BBE) on chondrogenesis in vitro were studied using micromass cultures of chick limb bud mesenchyme isolated from embryos at Hamburger-Hamilton (HH) stage 23/24, an experimental system which is capable of undergoing chondrogenic differentiation. Bovine diaphyseal long bones were demineralized and extracted with guanidine-HCl to prepare BBE (Syftestad & Caplan, 1984). High-density mesenchyme cultures (30 x 10(6) cells/ml) were exposed to different doses of BBE (0.01-1.0 mg ml-1) and chondrogenesis was quantified based on cartilage nodule number and [35S]sulphate incorporation. BBE was tested on micromass cultures of varying plating densities (2-30 x 10(6) cells/ml), on cultures of 'young' limb bud cells (HH stage 17/18), and on cultures enriched with chondroprogenitor cells obtained from subridge mesoderm. Since poly-L-lysine (PL) has recently been shown (San Antonio & Tuan, 1986) to promote chondrogensis, PL and BBE were introduced together in different doses, in the culture medium, to determine if their actions were synergistic. Our results show that BBE stimulates chondrogenesis in a dose-dependent manner and by a specific, direct action on the chondroprogenitor cells but not in normally non-chondrogenic, low density or 'young' limb bud cell cultures. The effects of PL and BBE are additive and these agents appear to act by separate mechanisms to stimulate chondrogenesis; PL primarily enhances nodule formation, and BBE appears to promote nodule growth.