Combined dissolved oxygen tension and online viscosity measurements in shake flask cultivations via infrared fluorescent oxygen-sensitive nanoparticles

Oxygen supply is one of the most critical process parameters in aerobic cultivations. To assure sufficient oxygen supply, shake flasks are usually used in combination with orbital shaking machines. In this study, a measurement technique for the dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) in shake flask cultures with viscosity changes is presented. The movement of the shaker table is monitored by means of a Hall effect sensor. For DOT measurements, infrared fluorescent oxygen-sensitive nanoparticles are added to the culture broth. The position of the rotating bulk liquid needs to be determined to assure measurements inside the liquid. The leading edge of the bulk liquid is detected based on the fluorescence signal intensity of the oxygen-sensitive nanoparticles. Furthermore, online information about the viscosity of the culture broth is acquired due to the detection of the position of the leading edge of the bulk liquid relative to the direction of the centrifugal force, as described by Sieben et al. (2019. Sci. Rep., 9, 8335). The DOT measurement is combined with a respiration activity monitoring system which allows for the determination of the oxygen transfer rate (OTR) in eight parallel shake flasks. Based on DOT and OTR, the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient (k_La) is calculated during cultivation. The new system was successfully applied in cultivations of Escherichia coli, Bacillus licheniformis, and Xanthomonas campestris.     

Effect of bioreactor configuration on substrate uptake by cell suspension cultures of the plant Eschscholtzia californica

Summary The uptake of carbohydrates and oxygen by cell suspension cultures of the plant Eschscholtzia californica (California poppy) was studied in relation to biomass production in shake flasks, a 1-1 stirred-tank bioreactor and a 1-1 pneumatically agitated bioreactor. The sequence of carbohydrate uptake was similar in all cases, with sucrose hydrolysis occurring followed by the preferential uptake of glucose. The uptake of fructose was found to be affected by the oxygen supply rate. Carbohydrate utilization occurred at a slower rate in the bioreactors. Apparent biomass yields, Y _X/S, ranged from 0.42 to 0.50 g biomass/g carbohydrate, while true biomass yields, Y _X/S, were about 0.69 g/g. The maintenance coefficient for carbohydrate, m _S, ranged between 0.002 and 0.008 g/dry weight (DW) per hour. The maximum measured specific oxygen uptake rate was 0.56 mmol O₂/g DW per hour and occurred early in the growth stage. The decline in specific uptake rate coincided with a decline in cell viability. The oxygen uptake rate was faster in shake flasks, corresponding to the higher growth rate obtained. The true growth yield on oxygen, YX/O₂, was calculated to range from 0.83 to 1.23 g biomass/g O₂, while the maintenance coefficient, mO₂, ranged from 0.15 to 0.25 mmol O₂/g DW per hour. The growth yields for oxygen determined from the stoichiometry of an elemental balance were within 10% of those calculated from experimental data. Offprint requests to: Raymond L. Legge     

Oxygen limitation is a pitfall during screening for industrial strains

Oxygen supply is a key parameter in aerobic fermentation processes like the industrial production of amino acids. Although the oxygen transfer rate (OTR; or the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient k_La) is routinely analyzed by engineers during stirred tank fermentations, it is often not taken into account by biologists conducting screening experiments in shake flasks. To show the importance of knowing how to avoid oxygen transfer limitations during primary screenings, Corynebacterium glutamicum ATCC 13032 (wild-type strain) and DSM 12866 (lysine-producing strain) were cultivated in shake flasks with different culture liquid volumes and under different shaking conditions. With the Respiration Activity Monitoring System, the OTR was determined quasi-continuously. Optical density as well as concentrations of lysine and byproducts (lactate, acetate, succinate) were determined off-line and correlated with the OTR signal. From the results, design criteria for improved screening in shaken bioreactors that help to avoid selection of suboptimal strains during early process development steps can be derived. Finally, the suitability of DSM 12866 as a strain for industrial processes with a high space–time yield is discussed.     

Dissolved oxygen as principal parameter for conidia production of biocontrol fungi Trichoderma viride in non-Newtonian wastewater

Dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration was selected as a principal parameter for translating results of shake flask fermentation of Trichoderma viride (biocontrol fungi) to a fermenter scale. All fermentations were carried out in a 7.5 l automated fermenter with a working volume of 4 l. Fermentation performance parameters such as volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient (k _L a), oxygen uptake rate (OUR), rheology, conidia concentration, glucose consumption, soluble chemical oxygen demand, entomotoxicity and inhibition index were measured. The conidia concentration, entomotoxicity and inhibition index were either stable or improved at lower DO concentration (30%). Variation of OUR aided in assessing the oxygen supply capacity of the fermenter and biomass growth. Meanwhile, rheological profiles demonstrated the variability of wastewater during fermentation due to mycelial growth and conidiation. In order to estimate power consumption, the agitation and the aeration requirements were quantified in terms of area under the curves, agitation vs. time (rpm h), and aeration vs. time (lpm h). This simple and novel strategy of fermenter operation proved to be highly successful which can be adopted to other biocontrol fungi.     

Ethylene Production and Mycelium Growth of the Tulip Strain of Fusarium oxysporum as Influenced by Shaking of and Oxygen Supply to the Culture Medium

The fungus Fusarium oxysporum Schlecht f. sp. tulipae Apt. can produce ethylene abundantly in vitro when grown in Pratt's liquid medium with glucose as the only organic substrate. This production starts after a lag phase of about 4 days, and peak production occurs when mycelium weight has reached its maximum value. For several days the rate of production is more or less linearly dependent on pO₂. The total production is also dependent on the oxygen concentration, but pure oxygen inhibits the total production by about 50% as compared with 21% oxygen. The high production in shake cultures, as compared with the low production in stagnant cultures, is probably the result of a better oxygen supply in the culture medium. The mycelium weight proved not to be a valid referential basis for the production of ethylene.     

The effects of the oxygen transfer coefficient and substrate concentration on the xylose fermentation by Debaryomyces hansenii

Relevant production of xylitol by Debaryomyces hansenii requires semiaerobic conditions since in aerobic conditions the accumulated reduced adenine dinucleotide coenzyme is fully reoxidized leading to the conversion of xylitol into xylulose. For oxygen transfer coefficient values from 0.24 to 1.88 min^-1, in shake flasks experiments, biomass formation increased proportionally to the aeration rate as shown in the oxygen transfer coefficient and xylose concentration isoresponse contours. The metabolic products under study, xylitol and ethanol were mainly growth associated. However, for oxygen transfer coefficient above 0.5 min^-1 higher initial xylose concentration stimulated the rate of production of xylitol. This fact was less evident for ethanol production. The direct relationship between increased biomass and products formation rate, indicated that the experimental domain in respect to the aeration rate was below the threshold level before the decreasing in metabolic production rates reported in literature for xylose-fermenting yeasts. The fact that ethanol was produced, albeit in low levels, throughout the experimental design indicated that the semiaerobic conditions were always attained. Debaryomyces hansenii showed to be an important xylitol producer exhibiting a xylitol/ethanol ratio above four and a carbon conversion of 54% for xylitol.Abbreviations K_La oxygen transfer coefficient - DO(T) dissolved oxygen (tension) - OUR oxygen uptake rate - NAD(H) oxidised (reduced) nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide - NADP(H) oxidised (reduced) nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate - CRC catabolic reduction charge - C oxygen concentration in the culture medium - C^* oxygen concentration at saturation conditions - Y_i response from experiment i - parameters of the polynomial model - x experimental factor level (coded units) - R² coefficient of multiple determination - t time     

Hydroxyethylation of Comenic Acid

A small jar fermentor was developed in order to investigate the effect of oxygen supply on hydrocarbon fermentation. Several indices to oxygen transfer were examined with this small jar fermentor. Conditions for suitable oxygen supply were examined in l-glutamic acid fermentation from hydrocarbon by use of shaking flasks and these small jar fermentors. The data indicated that the rate of oxygen transfer ought to be more than 14.3 × 10^?7 mole/ml·min in order to obtain satisfactory results. The coefficient of oxygen transfer rate (K_La/H) decreased as the fermentation went on, so the supply of oxygen enriched gas mixture was effective to increase the production of l-glutamic acid.     

A shaken disposable bioreactor system for controlled insect cell cultivations at milliliter‐scale

While wave‐mixed and stirred bag bioreactors are common devices for rapid, safe insect cell culture‐based production at liter‐scale, orbitally shaken disposable flasks are mainly used for screening studies at milliliter‐scale. In contrast to the two aforementioned bag bioreactor types, which can be operated with standard or disposable sensors, shaker flasks have not been instrumented until recently. The combination of 250 mL disposable shake flasks with PreSens's Shake Flask Reader enables both pH and dissolved oxygen to be measured, as well as allowing characterization of oxygen mass transfer. Volumetric oxygen transfer coefficients (k_La‐values) for PreSens 250 mL disposable shake flasks, which were determined for the first time in insect cell culture medium at varying culture volumes and shaker frequencies, ranged between 4.4 and 37.9/h. Moreover, it was demonstrated that online monitoring of dissolved oxygen in shake flasks is relevant for limitation‐free growth of insect cells up to high cell densities in batch mode (1.6×10⁷ cells/mL) and for the efficient expression of an intracellular model protein.     

Effects of dissolved oxygen concentration on lipase production by Rhizopus delemar

Summary The influence of the concentration of oxygen on lipase production by the fungus Rhizopus delemar was studied in different fermenters. The effect of oxygen limitation ( 47 mol/l) on lipase production by R. delemar is large as could be demonstrated in pellet and filamentous cultures. A model is proposed to describe the extent of oxygen limitation in pellet cultures. Model estimates indicate that oxygen is the limiting substrate in shake flask cultures and that an optimal inoculum size for oxygen-dependent processes can occur.Low oxygen concentrations greatly negatively affect the metabolism of R. delemar, which could be shown by cultivation in continuous cultures in filamentous growth form (D_optimal=0.086 h^-1). Continuous cultivations of R. delemar at constant, low-oxygen concentrations are a useful tool to scale down fermentation processes in cases where a transient or local oxygen limitation occurs.Symbols and Abbreviations CO Oxygen concentration in the gas phase at time = 0 (kg·m^-3) - C_{O 2i} Oxygen concentration at the pellet liquid interface (kg·m^-3) - C_{O 2i} Oxygen concentration in the bulk (kg·m^-3) - D Dilution rate (h^-1) - ID_{O 2} Diffusion coefficient for oxygen (m²·s^-1) - dw Dry weight of biomass (kg) - f Conversion factor (rs _{O 2} to oxygen consumption rate per m³) (-) - k Radial growth rate (m·s^-1) - K Constant - kla Volumetric mass transfer coefficient (s^-1) - klA Oxygen transfer rate (m^-3·s^-1) - kl Mass transfer coefficient (m·s^-1) - K _{O 2} Affinity constant for oxygen (mol·m^-3) - K _w Cotton plug resistance (m^-3·s^-1) - M Henry coefficient (-) - NV Number of pellets per volume (m^-3) - R Radius (m) - RO Radius of oxygen-deficient core (m) - RQ Respiration quotient (mol CO₂/mol O₂) - rs _{O 2} Specific oxygen consumption rate per dry weight biomass (kg O₂·s^-1[kg dw]^-1) - rX Biomass production rate (kg·m^-3·s^-1) - SG Soytone glucose medium (for shake flask experiments) - SG ₄ Soytone glucose medium (for tower fermenter and continuous culture experiments) - V Volume of medium (m^-3) - X Biomass (dry weight) concentration (kg·m^-3) - XR _o Biomass concentration within RO for a given X (kg·m^-3) - Y _{O 2} Biomass yield calculated on oxygen (kg dw/kg O₂) - Thiele modulus - Efficiency factor =1-(RO/R)³ (-) - Growth rate (m^-1·s^-1·kg^1/3) - Dry weight per volume of pellet (kg·m^-3)     

Microbial Conversion of Petro-sulfur Compounds

In order to enhance the efficiency converting dibenzothiophene (DBT) into water-soluble compounds by DBT-utilizing bacteria, the following subjects were studied: comparison of activities of isolated strains, their mixed cultivation, DBT dosing, nitrogen sources, substrate concentration, pH, temperature, and oxygen supply. Light oil solution of DBT (5%) was used as substrate. The conversion efficiency was calculated by the amount of sulfur accumulated in the aqueous layer of culture broth.

The conversion ratio of 40% was attained by the mixed culture of Pseudomonas abikonensis and Ps. jianii under the following conditions; medium, DBT 4.6 g dissolved in 87.8 g of light oil, meat extract 4.0 g, Na₂HPO₄·12H₂O 9.5 g, KH₂PO₄ 1.4 g, MgCl₂·6H₂O 0.2 g, distilled water 1000 ml; pH, 6.9 to 7.3 (m/30 phosphate buffer); oxygen supply, 50 ml broth 500 ml flask, shake culture at 220 rpm; inoculum size, 10%; temperature, 28°C; and period of cultivation, 3 days.     

Enhancement of mass transfer characteristics and phenanthrene degradation in a two-phase partitioning bioreactor equipped with internal static mixers

Oxygen and substrate supply have always been considered physical constraints for the performance and operation of two-phase partitioning bioreactors (TPPB), widely used for the degradation of hydrophobic substrates. In this regard, the potential advantages of static mixers in upgrading the oxygen transfer and liquid-liquid dispersions in TPPB have been highlighted. In the present paper, the concomitant influence of static mixers on the gas-liquid mass transfer coefficient k _L a and on substrate bioavailability was examined in TPPB. The static method based on conventional forms was developed to estimate the oxygen volumetric mass transfer coefficient. Over a broad range of liquid and air flow rates, the presence of static mixers was found to significantly enhance k _L a relative to a mixer-free mode of operation. For identical conditions, static mixers improved the k _L a threefold. In the presence of external aeration supply, the boost in the k _L a was associated with an increase of 16% in the phenanthrene biodegradation rate due to bubble break up accomplished by the static mixers. On the other hand, static mixers were efficient in enhancing substrate bioavailability by improving the liquid-liquid interfacial area. This effect was reflected by a threefold increase in the degradation rate in the bioreactors with no external supply of air when equipped with static mixers.     

Scale translation from shaken to diffused bubble aerated systems for lycopene production by Blakeslea trispora under stimulated conditions

This study deals with the scale up of Blakeslea trispora culture from the successful surface-aerated shake flasks to dispersed-bubble aerated column reactor for lycopene production in the presence of lycopene cyclase inhibitor 2-methyl imidazole. Controlling the initial volumetric oxygen mass transfer coefficient (k_La) via airflow rate contributes to increasing cell mass and lycopene accumulation. Inhibitor effectiveness seems to decrease in conditions of high cell mass. Optimization of crude soybean oil (CSO), airflow rate, and 2-methyl imidazole was arranged according to central composite statistical design. The optimized levels of factors were 110.5 g/L, 2.3 vvm, and 29.5 mg/L, respectively. At this optimum setting, maximum lycopene yield (256 mg/L) was comparable or even higher to those reported in shake flasks and stirred tank reactor. 2-Methyl imidazole use at levels significantly lower than those reported for other inhibitors in the literature was successful in terms of process selectivity. CSO provides economic benefits to the process through its ability to stimulate lycopene synthesis, as an inexpensive carbon source and oxygen vector at the same time.

     

Oxygen transfer and mycelial growth in a tubular loop fermentor

A 22 m long. 20 liter tubular loop fermentor (TLF) has been tested for oxygen transfer characteristics and as a reactor for mycelial growth. Model calculations show that the flow pressure drop has an important influence on the axial oxygen profiles. A design model that accounts for this influence is presented. Using the model, K_L a values are calculated from the results of sulfite oxidation experiments. These are correlated with power consumption and aeration rates. The K_L a dependence on aeration rate was found to be less than found with tank reactors. The growth kinetics of three metabolite-producing mycelial organisms in the TLF are presented: a Streptomyces, a Fusarium, and a Acrophialophora. In order to determine the influence of reactor type on the growth and product formation, these cultures have been grown in tanks and shake flasks. The antibiotic, product spectrum of Streptomyces is compared on the basis of inhibition tests and it is shown that the distribution of products is reactor dependent. The Fusarium culture produced a previously unknown metabolite, whose concentration in the loop fermentor was four times higher than in a shake flask. The Acrophialophora culture grew twice as fast in the loop fermentor, but produced essentially none of the specific product. Power Consumptions of up to 8 kW/m³ in the tubular fermentor did not appear to harm the mycelia.     

Economical parallel protein expression screening and scale-up in Escherichia coli

A novel microfermentation and scale-up platform for parallel protein production in Escherichia coli is described. The vertical shaker device Vertiga, which generates low-volume high density (A₆₀₀ ∼ 20) Escherichia coli cultures in 96-position deep-well plates without auxiliary oxygen supplementation, has been coupled to a new disposable shake flask design, the Ultra Yield^TM flask, that allows for equally high cell culture densities to be obtained. The Ultra Yield^TM flask, which accommodates up to 1 l in culture volume, has a baffled base and a more vertical wall construction compared to traditional shake flask designs. Experimental data is presented demonstrating that the Ultra Yield^TM flask generates, on average, an equivalent amount of recombinant protein per unit cell culture density as do traditional shake flask designs but at a substantially greater amount per unit volume. The combination of Vertiga and the Ultra Yield^TM flask provides a convenient and scalable low-cost solution to parallel protein production in Escherichia coli.     

From field sampling to pneumatic bioreactor mycelia production of the ectomycorrhizal mushroom Laccaria trichodermophora

In order to increase survival rates of greenhouse seedlings destined for restoration and conservation programs, successful mycorrhization of the seedlings is necessary. To reforest forest ecosystems, host trees must be inoculated with ectomycorrhizal fungi and, in order to guarantee a sufficient supply of ectomycorrhizal inoculum, it is necessary to develop technologies for the mass production of ectomycorrhizal fungi mycelia. We selected the ectomycorrhizal fungus Laccaria trichodermophora, due to its ecological traits and feasible mycelia production in asymbiotic conditions. Here, we report the field sampling of genetic resources, as well as the highly productive nutritional media and cultivation parameters in solid cultures. Furthermore, in order to achieve high mycelial production, we used strain screening and evaluated pH, carbon source concentration, and culture conditions of submerged cultures in normal and baffled shake flasks. The higher productivity culture conditions in shake flasks were selected for evaluation in a pneumatic bioreactor, using modified BAF media with a 10 g/L glucose, pH 5.5, 25 °C, and a volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient (K_La) of 36 h⁻¹. Under those conditions less biomass (12–37 %) was produced in the pneumatic bioreactor compared with the baffled shake flasks. This approach shows that L. trichodermophora can generate a large biomass concentration and constitute the biotechnological foundation of its mycelia mass production.     

Oxygen transfer rate,respiration and yields in batch and chemostat cultures ofKlebsiella aerogenes

The effect was studied of oxygen supply on the changes in total and specific rate of oxygen consumption by the cells, oxygen transfer rate, saturation concentrations of dissolved oxygen and the yields of batch and continuous cultivations. Experiments were done on the microorganismKlebsiella aerogenes CCM 2318 growing on synthetic glucose medium. Continuous cultivations were carried out at dilution rates of 0.96 and 0.178 h⁻¹. The rate of oxygen transfer was determined by the sulphite method and the coefficient K_La was assessed using the dynamic method with a correction for changes in the saturations of dissolved oxygen. A lowered oxygen supply in batch cultivations caused deformations in the course of cell respiration. Comparison of results of batch and continuous cultivations showed that the highest yields Y_x/s and Y_x/o are attained at low dilution rates without oxygen limitation. Batch cultivations, on the other hand, exhibit the lowest yields and the highest cell respiration levels. In both types of cultivations, a respiration peak was ascertained under the conditions of growth limitation by oxygen.     

Two-compartment method for determination of the oxygen transfer rate with electrochemical sensors based on sulfite oxidation

The dissolved oxygen concentration is a crucial parameter in aerobic bioprocesses due to the low solubility of oxygen in water. The present study describes a new method for determining the oxygen transfer rate (OTR) in shaken-culture systems based on the sodium sulfite method in combination with an electrochemical oxygen sensor. The method replaces the laborious titration of the remaining sulfite by an on-line detection of the end point of the reaction. This method is a two-step procedure that can be applied in arbitrary flasks that do not allow the insertion of electrodes. The method does not therefore depend on the type of vessel in which the OTR is detected. The concept is demonstrated by determination of the OTR for standard baffled 1-L shake flasks and for opaque Ultra Yield™ flasks. Under typical shaking conditions, k_La values in the standard baffled flasks reached values up to 220 h^-1, whereas the k_La values of the Ultra Yield flasks were significantly higher (up to 422 h^-1).     

Use of the glucose oxidase system to measure oxygen transfer rates

This investigation used the glucose oxidase system to simulate oxygen transfer rate in fermentation broths. It was demonstrated that the fungal preparation contained sufficient lactonase activity so that D -glucono-δ-lactone did not accumulate and that the rate of production of gluconic acid was proportional to the oxygen uptake rate. Enzyme concentrations of 1.5–2 g/1 were found adequate to determine oxygen absorption rates in shake flasks while maintaining the dissolved oxygen concentration of low levels. The apparent Michaelis constant for oxygen, K_m(O₂), was found to be 27% saturation with air; this value along with experimentally determined uptake rates could be used to calculate dissolved oxygen concentration in lieu of using a dissolved oxygen probe. Enzyme concentrations of 5 g/l were sufficient to give linear acid production and low dissolved oxygen concentrations in a bench-scale fermenter with no foaming or enzyme deactivation. The method is considered more valid and easier to employ than previously utilized techniques such as sulfite oxidation. Extension of the system to evaluating aeration effectiveness and scaleup of fermentation equipment is discussed.