The structure of the complexes of DNA with chromosomal protein HMGB1 and histone H1 in the presence of manganese ions. I. Circular dicroism spectroscopy

The mechanisms of interaction of the non-histone chromosomal protein HMGB1 and linker histone H1 with DNA have been studied using circular dichroism and absorption spectroscopy. Both of the proteins are located in the inter-nucleosomal regions of chromatin. It was demonstrated that properties of the DNA-protein complexes depend on the protein content and can not be considered as a simple summing up of the effects of individual protein components. Interaction of HMGB1 and H1 proteins is shown to be co-operative rather than competitive. Lysine-rich histone H1 facilitates the binding of the HMGB1 with DNA by screening the negatively charged groups of the sugar-phosphate backbone of DNA and dicarboxylic amino-acid residues in the C-terminal domain of the HMGB1 protein. The observed joint action of the and H1 proteins stimulates DNA condensation with formation of the anisotropic DNA-protein complexes with typical psi-type CD spectra. Structural organization of the complexes depends not only on the DNA-protein interactions, but also on the interaction between HMGB1 and H1 protein molecules bound to DNA. Manganese ions significantly modify the character of interactions between the components in the triple DNA-HMGB1-H1 complex. Binding of Mn2+ ions causes the weakening of the DNA-protein interactions and strengthening the protein-protein interactions, which promote DNA condensation and formation of large DNA-protein particles in solution.     

Fourier transform infrared/vibrational circular dichroism spectroscopy as an informative tool for the investigation of large supramolecular complexes of biological macromolecules

A combination of ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) absorption and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy was applied to investigate the structure and formation of large supramolecular DNA-protein complexes. This combination of techniques was used to overcome limitations of UV-CD (electronic, or ECD) spectroscopy due to considerable light scattering in such solutions. Based on the analysis of FTIR and UV-CD spectra, the interaction of DNA with nonhistone chromatin protein HMGB1 and linker histone H1 was studied. The data obtained showed that under the conditions of the experiment (15 mM NaCl, protein/DNA ratio r < 1 w/w) the proteins did not reveal any AT or GC specificity in binding to DNA. In the presence of both proteins, mainly interactions in the DNA minor groove were observed, which were attributed to HMGB1 binding. Histone H1 facilitated binding of HMGB1 to DNA by interacting with the negatively charged groups of the sugar-phosphate backbone and binding of aspartic and glutamic amino acid residues of HMGB1. Acting together, HMGB1 and H1 stimulated the assemblage of supramolecular DNA-protein structures. The structural organization of the ternary complexes depended not only on the properties of the protein-DNA interactions but also on the interactions between HMGB1 and H1 molecules.     

Structure of DNA complexes with chromosomal protein HMGB1 and histone H1 in the presence of manganese ions: 2. Vibrational circular dichroism spectroscopy

DNA complexes with nonhistone HMGB1 chromatin protein and histone H1 in the presence of manganese ions were studied using methods of absorption and circular dichroism spectroscopy in the infrared region. It was demonstrated that the method provides good results, even for solutions that contain large particles, which cause scattering in UV region. It was determined that manganese ions in the complex are able to coordinate not only to different chemical groups in DNA, but also to dicarboxylic acid residues of the HMGB1 protein, which stimulates DNA condensation and slightly weakens DNA-protein interactions in the complex.     

The effect of manganese(II) on the structure of DNA/HMGB1/H1 complexes: electronic and vibrational circular dichroism studies

The interactions were studied of DNA with the nonhistone chromatin protein HMGB1 and histone H1 in the presence of manganese(II) ions at different protein to DNA and manganese to DNA phosphate ratios by using absorption and optical activity spectroscopy in the electronic [ultraviolet (UV) and electronic circular dichroism ECD)] and vibrational [infrared (IR) and vibrational circular dichroism (VCD)] regions. In the presence of Mn2+, the protein-DNA interactions differ from those without the ions and cause prominent DNA compaction and formation of large intermolecular complexes. At the same time, the presence of HMGB1 and H1 also changed the mode of interaction of Mn2+ with DNA, which now takes place mostly in the major groove of DNA involving N7(G), whereas interactions between Mn2+ and DNA phosphate groups are weakened by histone molecules. Considerable interactions were also detected of Mn2+ ions with aspartic and glutamic amino acid residues of the proteins.     

The structure of the complexes of DNA with non-histone chromosomal protein HMGB1 in the presence of manganese ions

The complexes of DNA - HMGB1 protein - manganese ions have been studied using circular dichroism (CD) technique. It was shown that in such three-component system the interactions of both the protein and metal ions with DNA differ from those in two-component complexes. The manganese ions do not affect the CD spectrum of free HMGB1 protein. However, Mn2+ ions induce considerable changes in the CD spectrum of free DNA in the spectral range of 260-290 nm. The presence of Mn2+ ions prevents formation of the ordered supramolecular structures specific for the HMGB1-DNA complexes. The interaction of manganese ions with DNA has a marked influence on the local DNA structure changing the properties of protein-binding sites. This results in the serious decrease in cooperativity of the DNA-protein binding. Such changes in the mode of the DNA-protein interactions occur at concentrations as small as 0.01 mM Mn2+. Moreover, the changes in local DNA structure induced by manganese ions promote the appearance of new HMGB1 binding sites on the DNA double helix. At the same time interactions with HMGB1 protein induce alterations in the structure of the DNA double helix which increase with a growth of the protein/DNA ratio. These alterations make the DNA/protein complex especially sensitive to manganese ions. Under these conditions the Mn2+ ions strongly affect the DNA structure that reflects in abrupt changes of the CD spectra of DNA in the complex in the range of 260-290 nm. Thus, structural changes of the DNA double helix in the three-component DNA-HMGB1-Mn2+ complexes come as a result of the combined and interdependent interactions of DNA with Mn2+ ions and the molecules of HMGB1.     

Structure of DNA Complexes with Nonhistone Chromosomal Protein HMGB1 in the Presence of Manganese Ions

The complexes of DNA–HMGB1 protein–manganese ions have been studied using the circular dichroism (CD) technique. It was shown that the interactions of both the protein and metal ions with DNA in this three-component system differ from those in two-component complexes. The manganese ions did not affect the CD spectrum of the free HMGB1 protein. However, Mn²⁺ ions induced considerable changes in the CD spectrum of free DNA in the spectral range of 260–290 nm. The presence of Mn²⁺ ions prevented the formation of the ordered supramolecular structures typical of HMGB1–DNA complexes. The interaction of manganese ions with DNA had a marked influence on the local DNA structure, changing the properties of protein-binding sites and resulting in a marked decrease in cooperativity of HMGB1–DNA binding. Such changes in the mode of protein–DNA interactions occurred at concentrations as small as 0.01 mM Mn²⁺. Moreover, the changes in local DNA structure induced by the manganese ions promoted the appearance of new HMGB1 binding sites in the DNA double helix. At the same time, interactions with the HMGB1 protein induced alterations in the structure of the DNA double helix, which increased with an increase in the protein-to-DNA ratio. These alterations made the DNA–protein complex especially sensitive to manganese ions. Under these conditions the Mn²⁺ ions strongly affected the DNA structure, which was reflected in abrupt changes in the CD spectra of DNA in the complex in the range of 260–290 nm. Thus, structural changes in the DNA double helix in three-component DNA–HMGB1–Mn²⁺ complexes result from the combined and interdependent interactions of DNA with Mn²⁺ ions and HMGB1 molecules.     

Structural organization of DNA complexes with proteins HMGB1 and HMGB1-(A+B)

The interaction between DNA and the nonhistone proteins HMGB1 and HMGB1-(A+B) has been studied using circular dichroism and scanning force microscopy. The recombinant protein HMGB1-(A+B) has no negatively charged C-terminal domain characteristic for HMGB1. Our earlier suggestion about the structural interaction of tandem HMGB1-domains of the recombinant protein with DNA was confirmed. It was shown that the C-terminal part modulates the interactions of HMGB1-domains with DNA. Without the C-terminal sequence, the HMGB1-(A+B) protein forms DNA-protein complexes with the ordered supramolecular structure.     

Histone H1--DNA interaction. On the mechanism of DNA strands crosslinking by histone H1.

Crosslinking of DNA fibers by histone H1 or phosphorylated on Ser-37 histone H1, and by the individual fragments of the H1 polypeptide chain was studied by the method of turbidimetry. The dependence of the turbidity of DNA-protein complexes on the ionic strength in solution suggests that the condensation of H1.DNA complexes in vitro is apparently due to both specific histone-DNA interactions with the contribution of hydrogen and/or hydrophobic bonds and the formation of polycationic "bridges" fastening the DNA fibers. The effectiveness of the condensation is postulated to be a function of a proportion between the two mechanisms which in turn can be controlled by slight changes in ionic surroundings. The sharp dependence of shrinkage of H1.DNA complexes on ionic strength at "physiological" salt concentrations could provide a mechanism to regulate density and consequently the total activity of chromatin in the cell nuclei. The phosphorylation of histone H1 on Ser-37 by a specific histone kinase does not noticeably affect the pattern of DNA crosslinking by the H1.     

Nucleosome linker proteins HMGB1 and histone H1 differentially enhance DNA ligation reactions

We previously reported that HMGB1, which originally binds to chromatin in a manner competitive with linker histone H1 to modulate chromatin structure, enhances both intra-molecular and inter-molecular ligations. In this paper, we found that histone H1 differentially enhances ligation reaction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). Histone H1 stimulated exclusively inter-molecular ligation reaction of DSB with DNA ligase IIIbeta and IV, whereas HMGB1 enhanced mainly intra-molecular ligation reaction. Electron microscopy of direct DNA-protein interaction without chemical cross-linking visualized that HMGB1 bends and loops linear DNA to form compact DNA structure and that histone H1 is capable of assembling DNA in tandem arrangement with occasional branches. These results suggest that differences in the enhancement of DNA ligation reaction are due to those in alteration of DNA configuration induced by these two linker proteins. HMGB1 and histone H1 may function in non-homologous end-joining of DSB repair and V(D)J recombination in different manners.     

The Effect of Ca2+ Ions on DNA Compaction in the Complex with HMGB1 Nonhistone Chromosomal Protein

The analysis of absorption and circular dichroism spectra in UV and IR regions showed that Ca²⁺ ions interact with the phosphate groups of DNA and the HMGB1 protein. Not only the negatively charged C-terminal part of the protein molecule, but also its DNA-binding domains participate in the interaction with metal ions. The latter leads to a change in the mode of protein–DNA interaction. The presence of Ca²⁺ ions prevents the formation of ordered supramolecular structures specific for the HMGB1–DNA complexes but promotes intermolecular aggregation. The structure of DNA complexes with the HMGB1 protein lacking the C-terminal tail appeared to be the most sensitive to the presence of Ca²⁺ ions. These data indicate that Ca²⁺ ions play no structural role in the HMGB1–DNA complexes, and their presence is not necessary for DNA compaction in such systems.     

The interaction of HMGB1 and linker histones occurs through their acidic and basic tails

H1 and HMGB1 bind to linker DNA in chromatin, in the vicinity of the nucleosome dyad. They appear to have opposing effects on the nucleosome, H1 stabilising it by "sealing" two turns of DNA around the octamer, and HMGB1 destabilising it, probably by bending the adjacent DNA. Their presence in chromatin might be mutually exclusive. Displacement/replacement of one by the other as a result of their highly dynamic binding in vivo might, in principle, involve interactions between them. Chemical cross-linking and gel-filtration show that a 1:1 linker histone/HMGB1 complex is formed, which persists at physiological ionic strength, and that complex formation requires the acidic tail of HMGB1. NMR spectroscopy shows that the linker histone binds, predominantly through its basic C-terminal domain, to the acidic tail of HMGB1, thereby disrupting the interaction of the tail with the DNA-binding faces of the HMG boxes. A potential consequence of this interaction is enhanced DNA binding by HMGB1, and concomitantly lowered affinity of H1 for DNA. In a chromatin context, this might facilitate displacement of H1 by HMGB1.     

Interaction of maize chromatin-associated HMG proteins with mononucleosomes: role of core and linker histones

Two groups of plant chromatin-associated high mobility group (HMG) proteins, namely the HMGA family, typically containing four A/T-hook DNA-binding motifs, and the HMGB family, containing a single HMG-box DNA-binding domain, have been identified. We have examined the interaction of recombinant maize HMGA and five different HMGB proteins with mononucleosomes (containing approx. 165 bp of DNA) purified from micrococcal nuclease-digested maize chromatin. The HMGB proteins interacted with the nucleosomes independent of the presence of the linker histone H1, while the binding of HMGA in the presence of H1 differed from that observed in the absence of H1. HMGA and the HMGB proteins bound H1-containing nucleosome particles with similar affinity. The plant HMG proteins could also bind nucleosomes that were briefly treated with trypsin (removing the N-terminal domains of the core histones), suggesting that the histone N-termini are dispensable for HMG protein binding. In the presence of untreated nucleosomes and trypsinised nucleosomes, HMGB1 could be chemically crosslinked with a core histone, which indicates that the trypsin-resistant part of the histones within the nucleosome is the main interaction partner of HMGB1 rather than the histone N-termini. In conclusion, these results indicate that specific nucleosome binding of the plant HMGB proteins requires simultaneous DNA and histone contacts.     

Interaction of superhelical DNA with the nonhistone protein HMG1

The interaction between nonhistone chromosomal protein HMG1 and plasmid DNA was studied by optical and hydrodynamical methods. The recombinant protein HMG1 produced by yeast Pichia pastoris strain was used. We have shown that according to the CD spectra local conformational changes in DNA helix occur in the region of DNA-protein interaction. These changes are most significant at r < 3 (w/w). Both gel-shift assay and ultracentrifugation, as well as CD data, indicate that protein-protein interactions between HMG1 molecules play a major role in the formation of DNA-protein complexes. It is suggested that the protein C-terminus may affect HMG1-DNA binding not only by a direct interaction with DNA helix, but also by protein-protein interactions.     

Protein/DNA interactions involving ATF/AP1-, CCAAT-, and HiNF-D-related factors in the human H3-ST519 histone promoter: cross-competition with transcription regulatory sites in cell cycle controlled H4 and H1 histone genes.

Protein/DNA interactions of the H3-ST519 histone gene promoter were analyzed in vitro. Using several assays for sequence specificity, we established binding sites for ATF/AP1-, CCAAT-, and HiNF-D related DNA binding proteins. These binding sites correlate with two genomic protein/DNA interaction domains previously established for this gene. We show that each of these protein/DNA interactions has a counterpart in other histone genes: H3-ST519 and H4-F0108 histone genes interact with ATF- and HiNF-D related binding activities, whereas H3-ST519 and H1-FNC16 histone genes interact with the same CCAAT-box binding activity. These factors may function in regulatory coupling of the expression of different histone gene classes. We discuss these results within the context of established and putative protein/DNA interaction sites in mammalian histone genes. This model suggests that heterogeneous permutations of protein/DNA interaction elements, which involve both general and cell cycle regulated DNA binding proteins, may govern the cellular competency to express and coordinately control multiple distinct histone genes.     

Cooperative recruitment of HMGB1 during V(D)J recombination through interactions with RAG1 and DNA

During V(D)J recombination, recombination activating gene (RAG)1 and RAG2 bind and cleave recombination signal sequences (RSSs), aided by the ubiquitous DNA-binding/-bending proteins high-mobility group box protein (HMGB)1 or HMGB2. HMGB1/2 play a critical, although poorly understood, role in vitro in the assembly of functional RAG–RSS complexes, into which HMGB1/2 stably incorporate. The mechanism of HMGB1/2 recruitment is unknown, although an interaction with RAG1 has been suggested. Here, we report data demonstrating only a weak HMGB1–RAG1 interaction in the absence of DNA in several assays, including fluorescence anisotropy experiments using a novel Alexa488-labeled HMGB1 protein. Addition of DNA to RAG1 and HMGB1 in fluorescence anisotropy experiments, however, results in a substantial increase in complex formation, indicating a synergistic binding effect. Pulldown experiments confirmed these results, as HMGB1 was recruited to a RAG1–DNA complex in a RAG1 concentration-dependent manner and, interestingly, without strict RSS sequence specificity. Our finding that HMGB1 binds more tightly to a RAG1–DNA complex over RAG1 or DNA alone provides an explanation for the stable integration of this typically transient architectural protein in the V(D)J recombinase complex throughout recombination. These findings also have implications for the order of events during RAG–DNA complex assembly and for the stabilization of sequence-specific and non-specific RAG1–DNA interactions.     

Interaction of the non-histone protein PS1 with some chromatin components

The binding of non-histone protein from mouse spleen chromatin located in the sites highly sensitive to micrococcal nuclease and DNA-ase I, to DNA and histones was studied. The binding of the DNA-protein complexes to nitrocellulose filters demonstrated the absence of protein binding to DNA. A highly selective binding of protein PS1 to histones H1 and H2A and to one of the non-histone proteins (presumably HMG 14) was revealed. It is concluded that protein PS1 is incorporated into chromatin by the protein-protein interactions.     

Determinants of HMGB proteins required to promote RAG1/2-recombination signal sequence complex assembly and catalysis during V(D)J recombination

Efficient assembly of RAG1/2-recombination signal sequence (RSS) DNA complexes that are competent for V(D)J cleavage requires the presence of the nonspecific DNA binding and bending protein HMGB1 or HMGB2. We find that either of the two minimal DNA binding domains of HMGB1 is effective in assembling RAG1/2-RSS complexes on naked DNA and stimulating V(D)J cleavage but that both domains are required for efficient activity when the RSS is incorporated into a nucleosome. The single-domain HMGB protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Nhp6A, efficiently assembles RAG1/2 complexes on naked DNA; however, these complexes are minimally competent for V(D)J cleavage. Nhp6A forms much more stable DNA complexes than HMGB1, and a variety of mutations that destabilize Nhp6A binding to bent microcircular DNA promote increased V(D)J cleavage. One of the two DNA bending wedges on Nhp6A and the analogous phenylalanine wedge at the DNA exit site of HMGB1 domain A were found to be essential for promoting RAG1/2-RSS complex formation. Because the phenylalanine wedge is required for specific recognition of DNA kinks, we propose that HMGB proteins facilitate RAG1/2-RSS interactions by recognizing a distorted DNA structure induced by RAG1/2 binding. The resulting complex must be sufficiently dynamic to enable the series of RAG1/2-mediated chemical reactions on the DNA.     

HMG1 domains: the victims of circumstance

The method of circular dichroism (CD) was used to compare DNA behavior during its interaction with linker histone H1 and with non-histone chromosomal protein HMG1 at different ionic strength and at different protein content in the system. The role of negatively charged C-terminal fragment of HMG1 was analyzed using recombinant protein HMG1-(A + B), which lacks the C terminal amino acid sequence. The psi-type CD spectra were common for DNA interaction with histone H1, but no spectra of this type were observed in HMG1-DNA systems even at high ionic strength. The CD spectrum of the truncated recombinant protein at high salt concentration somewhat resembled the psi-type spectrum. Two very intense positive bands were located near 215 nm and near 273 nm, and the whole CD spectrum was positive. The role of C-terminal tail of HMG1 in formation of the ordered DNA-protein complexes is discussed.