Proton-coupled electron transfer: a unifying mechanism for biological charge transport, amino acid radical initiation and propagation, and bond making/breaking reactions of water and oxygen

Redox-driven proton pumps, radical initiation and propagation in biology, and small-molecule activation processes all involve the coupling of electron transfer to proton transport. A mechanistic framework in which to interpret these processes is being developed by examining proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in model and natural systems. Specifically, PCET investigations are underway on the following three fronts: (1) the elucidation of the PCET reaction mechanism by time-resolved laser spectroscopy of electron donors and acceptors juxtaposed by a proton transfer interface; (2) the role of amino acid radicals in biological catalysis with the radical initiation and transport processes of E. coli ribonucleotide reductase (RNR) as a focal point; and (3) the application of PCET towards small-molecule activation with emphasis on biologically relevant bond-breaking and bond-making processes involving oxygen and water. A review of recent developments in each of these areas is discussed.     

Theory and simulation of proton-coupled electron transfer, hydrogen-atom transfer, and proton translocation in proteins

A theory of proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) is reviewed with application to charge transfer steps in the photosystem II oxygen-evolving complex (PSII/OEC). The relation between PCET when it is a concerted electron proton transfer (ETPT) process and hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) reactions is discussed. Signatures expected for HAT reactions in terms of the size of the kinetic isotope effect and overall magnitude of the rate constant are discussed in the context of PSII/OEC. The formal similarity of ETPT to proton transfer and translocation is used to introduce a combined quantum mechanical (for the transferring protons) and molecular dynamics for the heavy-atom degrees of freedom approach. The method is used to examine double proton transfer in cytochrome c oxidase where two waters and a glutamate (Glu286) that is implicated in the proton translocation mechanism form a cyclic hydrogen bonded structure. Protonation of the glutamate is found to occur in agreement with experimental results.     

Proton-coupled electron transfer: the mechanistic underpinning for radical transport and catalysis in biology

Charge transport and catalysis in enzymes often rely on amino acid radicals as intermediates. The generation and transport of these radicals are synonymous with proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET), which intrinsically is a quantum mechanical effect as both the electron and proton tunnel. The caveat to PCET is that proton transfer (PT) is fundamentally limited to short distances relative to electron transfer (ET). This predicament is resolved in biology by the evolution of enzymes to control PT and ET coordinates on highly different length scales. In doing so, the enzyme imparts exquisite thermodynamic and kinetic controls over radical transport and radical-based catalysis at cofactor active sites. This discussion will present model systems containing orthogonal ET and PT pathways, thereby allowing the proton and electron tunnelling events to be disentangled. Against this mechanistic backdrop, PCET catalysis of oxygen-oxygen bond activation by mono-oxygenases is captured at biomimetic porphyrin redox platforms. The discussion concludes with the case study of radical-based quantum catalysis in a natural biological enzyme, class I Escherichia coli ribonucleotide reductase. Studies are presented that show the enzyme utilizes both collinear and orthogonal PCET to transport charge from an assembled diiron-tyrosyl radical cofactor to the active site over 35A away via an amino acid radical-hopping pathway spanning two protein subunits.     

Models for Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in Photosystem II

The coupling of proton and electron transfers is a key part of the chemistry of photosynthesis. The oxidative side of photosystem II (PS II) in particular seems to involve a number of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) steps in the S-state transitions. This mini-review presents an overview of recent studies of PCET model systems in the authors’ laboratory. PCET is defined as a chemical reaction involving concerted transfer of one electron and one proton. These are thus distinguished from stepwise pathways involving initial electron transfer (ET) or initial proton transfer (PT). Hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) reactions are one class of PCET, in which H⁺ and e ⁻ are transferred from one reagent to another: AH+B→A+BH, roughly along the same path. Rate constants for many HAT reactions are found to be well predicted by the thermochemistry of hydrogen transfer and by Marcus Theory. This includes organic HAT reactions and reactions of iron-tris(α-diimine) and manganese-(μ-oxo) complexes. In PS II, HAT has been proposed as the mechanism by which the tyrosine Z radical (Y_Z) oxidizes the manganese cluster (the oxygen evolving complex, OEC). Another class of PCET reactions involves transfer of H⁺ and e ⁻ in different directions, for instance when the proton and electron acceptors are different reagents, as in AH–B+C⁺→A–HB⁺+C. The oxidation of Y_Z by the chlorophyll P680 + has been suggested to occur by this mechanism. Models for this process – the oxidation of phenols with a pendent base – are described. The oxidation of the OEC by Y_Z could also occur by this second class of PCET reactions, involving an Mn–O–H fragment of the OEC. Initial attempts to model such a process using ruthenium-aquo complexes are described. An erratum to this article can be found at     

Electron-Transfer-Induced Acidity/Basicity and Reactivity Changes of Purine and Pyrimidine Bases. Consequences of Redox Processes for Dna Base Pairs

Changes in the oxidation state of the DNA bases, induced by oxidation (ionization) or by reduction (electron capture), have drastic effects on the acidity or basicity, respectively, of the molecules. Since in DNA every base is connected to its complementary base in the other strand, any change of the electric charge status of a base in one DNA strand that accompanies its oxidation or reduction may affect also the other strand via proton transfer across the hydrogen bonds in the base pairs. The free energies for electron transfer to or from a base can be drastically altered by the proton transfer processes that accompany the electron transfer reactions. Electron-transfer (ET) induced proton transfer sensitizes the base opposite to the ET-damaged base to redox damage, i.e., damage produced by separation of charge (ionization) has an increased change of being trapped in a base pair. Of the two types of base pair in DNA, A-T and C-G, the latter is more sensitive to both oxidative and reductive processes than the former.

Proton transfer induced by ET does not only occur between the heteroatoms (o and N) of the base pairs (intra-pair proton transfer), but also to and from adjacent water molecules in the hydration shell of DNA (extra-pair proton transfer). These proton transfers can involve carbon and as such are likely to be irreversible. It is the A-T pair which appears to be particularly prone to such irreversible reactions.     

Mimicking the photosynthetic system with strong hydrogen bonds to promote proton electron concerted reactions

A Copper(2+) complex with a Cu^II–C bond containing sp³ configuration was used to investigate the role of strong hydrogen bonds in proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions. The only example of a Cu^II–C system realized so far is that using tris-(pyridylthio)methyl (tptm) as a tetradentate tripodal ligand. Using this ligand, [CuF(tptm)] and [Cu(tptm)(OH)] have been prepared. The former complex forms supra-molecular arrays of layers of the complex between which hydroquinone is intercalated in the crystalline phase. This hydroquinone intercalation crystal was prepared via the photochemical conversion of quinone during the crystallization process. This conversion reaction probably involves a proton coupled electron transfer process. The nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic analysis of the reaction mixture shows the presence of Cu(III) during the conversion reaction. These results strongly suggest the presence of the molecular aggregate of the [CuF(tptm)] complex, water and quinone in the solution phase during the quinone to hydroquinone conversion. The presence of this type of aggregate requires a strong hydrogen bond between the [CuF(tptm)] complex and water. The presence of this particular hydrogen bond is a unique character of such a complex that has the Cu^II–C bond. This complex is used as a model for photosynthetic water splitting since the photoconversion of quinone to hydroquinone also involves the production of oxygen from water.     

Theoretical studies of proton-coupled electron transfer reactions

A theoretical formulation for proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) is described. This theory allows the calculation of rates and kinetic isotope effects and provides insight into the underlying fundamental principles of PCET reactions. Applications of this theory to PCET reactions in iron bi-imidazoline complexes, oxoruthenium polypyridyl complexes, osmium-benzoquinone systems, amidinium-carboxylate salt bridges, DNA-acrylamide complexes, and ruthenium polypyridyl-tyrosine systems are summarized. The mechanistic insight gained from theoretical calculations on these model systems is relevant to PCET in more complex biological processes such as photosynthesis and respiration.     

Ultrafast transient absorption studies on Photosystem I reaction centers from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. 1. A new interpretation of the energy trapping and early electron transfer steps in Photosystem I

The energy transfer and charge separation kinetics in core Photosystem I (PSI) particles of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii has been studied using ultrafast transient absorption in the femtosecond-to-nanosecond time range. Although the energy transfer processes in the antenna are found to be generally in good agreement with previous interpretations, we present evidence that the interpretation of the energy trapping and electron transfer processes in terms of both kinetics and mechanisms has to be revised substantially as compared to current interpretations in the literature. We resolved for the first time i), the transient difference spectrum for the excited reaction center state, and ii), the formation and decay of the primary radical pair and its intermediate spectrum directly from measurements on open PSI reaction centers. It is shown that the dominant energy trapping lifetime due to charge separation is only 6-9 ps, i.e., by a factor of 3 shorter than assumed so far. The spectrum of the first radical pair shows the expected strong bleaching band at 680 nm which decays again in the next electron transfer step. We show furthermore that the early electron transfer processes up to approximately 100 ps are more complex than assumed so far. Several possibilities are discussed for the intermediate redox states and their sequence which involve oxidation of P700 in the first electron transfer step, as assumed so far, or only in the second electron transfer step, which would represent a fundamental change from the presently assumed mechanism. To explain the data we favor the inclusion of an additional redox state in the electron transfer scheme. Thus we distinguish three different redox intermediates on the timescale up to 100 ps. At this level no final conclusion as to the exact mechanism and the nature of the intermediates can be drawn, however. From comparison of our data with fluorescence kinetics in the literature we also propose a reversible first charge separation step which has been excluded so far for open PSI reaction centers. For the first time an ultrafast 150-fs equilibration process, occurring among exciton states in the reaction center proper, upon direct excitation of the reaction center at 700 nm, has been resolved. Taken together the data call for a fundamental revision of the present understanding of the energy trapping and early electron transfer kinetics in the PSI reaction center. Due to the fact that it shows the fastest trapping time observed so far of any intact PSI particle, the PSI core of C. reinhardtii seems to be best suited to further characterize the electron transfer steps and mechanisms in the reaction center of PSI.     

Coupling of electron and proton transfer in oxidative water cleavage in photosynthesis

This minireview addresses questions on the mechanism of oxidative water cleavage with special emphasis on the coupling of electron (ET) and proton transfer (PT) of each individual redox step of the reaction sequence and on the mode of O-O bond formation. The following topics are discussed: (1) the multiphasic kinetics of Y(Z)(ox) formation by P680(+*) originate from three different types of rate limitations: (i) nonadiabatic electron transfer for the "fast" ns reaction, (ii) local "dielectric" relaxation for the "slow" ns reaction, and (iii) "large-scale" proton shift for the micros kinetics; (2) the ET/PT-coupling mode of the individual redox transitions within the water oxidizing complex (WOC) driven by Y(Z)(ox) is assumed to depend on the redox state S(i): the oxidation steps of S(0) and S(1) comprise separate ET and PT pathways while those of S(2) and S(3) take place via proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) analogous to Jerry Babcock's hydrogen atom abstractor model [Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1458 (2000) 199]; (3) S(3) is postulated to be a multistate redox level of the WOC with fast dynamic equilibria of both redox isomerism and proton tautomerism. The primary event in the essential O-O bond formation is the population of a state S(3)(P) characterized by an electronic configuration and nuclear geometry that corresponds with a complexed hydrogen peroxide; (4) the peroxidic type S(3)(P) is the entatic state for formation of complexed molecular oxygen through S(3) oxidation by Y(Z)(ox); and (5) the protein matrix itself is proposed to exert catalytic activity by functioning as "PCET director". The WOC is envisaged as a supermolecule that is especially tailored for oxidative water cleavage and acts as a molecular machine.     

Net proton uptake is preceded by multiple proton transfer steps upon electron injection into cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX), the last enzyme of the respiratory chain of aerobic organisms, catalyzes the reduction of molecular oxygen to water. It is a redox-linked proton pump, whose mechanism of proton pumping has been controversially discussed, and the coupling of proton and electron transfer is still not understood. Here, we investigated the kinetics of proton transfer reactions following the injection of a single electron into the fully oxidized enzyme and its transfer to the hemes using time-resolved absorption spectroscopy and pH indicator dyes. By comparison of proton uptake and release kinetics observed for solubilized COX and COX-containing liposomes, we conclude that the 1-μs electron injection into Cu(A), close to the positive membrane side (P-side) of the enzyme, already results in proton uptake from both the P-side and the N (negative)-side (1.5 H(+)/COX and 1 H(+)/COX, respectively). The subsequent 10-μs transfer of the electron to heme a is accompanied by the release of 1 proton from the P-side to the aqueous bulk phase, leaving ～0.5 H(+)/COX at this side to electrostatically compensate the charge of the electron. With ～200 μs, all but 0.4 H(+) at the N-side are released to the bulk phase, and the remaining proton is transferred toward the hemes to a so-called "pump site." Thus, this proton may already be taken up by the enzyme as early as during the first electron transfer to Cu(A). These results support the idea of a proton-collecting antenna, switched on by electron injection.     

Bis-semiquinone (bi-radical) formation by photoinduced proton coupled electron transfer in covalently linked catechol-quinone systems: Aviram's hemiquinones revisited

The structure and reactivity of a covalently linked catechol-ortho-benzoquinone (hemiquinone) is studied by UV-Vis and IR absorption spectroscopy. Nanosecond transient absorption spectroscopy of the hemiquinone reveals the formation of bi-radical state consisting of two semiquinone units. It is a long-lived state resulting from proton coupled electron transfer (PCET).     

Hybrid Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting Systems: From Interface Design to System Assembly

Photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting has attracted increasing attention due to its potential to mitigate energy and environmental issues. Hybrid PEC systems containing semiconductor photosensitizers and molecular catalysts are reported to be highly active and stable for water splitting with great potential for facilitating clean fuels production. In this review, following a showcasing of the fundamental details of hybrid PEC systems for water splitting, semiconductor/molecular catalyst interface designs are highlighted, with a focus on interfacial physicochemical interactions and binding, and interfacial energetics and dynamics for efficient charge transfer. Recent advances in hybrid system assemblies for PEC water splitting are also briefly introduced. Finally, future challenges and directions in the field of hybrid PEC water splitting for solar energy conversion are reviewed. The current review provides state‐of‐the‐art strategies for optimized interface design for creating highly active and stable PEC water splitting assemblies.     

Density-functional investigation on the mechanism of H-atom abstraction by lipoxygenase

Using experimentally calibrated density functional calculations on models of the active site of soybean lipoxygenase 1 (SLO-1), insight has been obtained into the coordination flexibility of the iron active site and its molecular mechanism of catalysis. The ferrous form of SLO-1 shows a variation in coordination number in solution that is related to a weakly coordinating Asn694 ligand. From the calculations it is determined that the weak Fe-O(694) bond associated with this coordination flexibility is due to a sideways tilted geometry of Asn694 that is imposed on the site by the protein. Release of this constraint (by altering the hydrogen bonding network) leads to a pure six-coordinate site. In contrast, the ferric form of the enzyme stays five-coordinate. In this case, deprotonation of a coordinated water gives a strong hydroxo donor in the cis position to Asn694, weakening the Fe-O(694) bond. Hence, Asn694 is a stronger ligand to the reduced relative to the oxidized site. Using these experimentally calibrated models, the reaction energy for H-atom transfer in SLO-1 has been calculated to be about -18 kcal/mol. The observed change in coordination number going from five-coordinate in ferric to six-coordinate in ferrous SLO-1 increases the reduction potential of the iron active site. Hence, the protein adjusts the active site for optimal reactivity. Analysis of the electronic structure along the reaction coordinate shows that the H-atom transfer in SLO-1 actually corresponds to a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). The transferred electron does not localize on the proton, but tunnels directly from the substrate to the ferric active site in a concerted proton tunneling-electron tunneling (PTET) process. The covalently linked Fe-O-H-C bridge in the transition state lowers the energy barrier and provides an efficient superexchange pathway for this tunneling. The thermal barrier for the PTET process is estimated from the calculations to be about +15 kcal/mol including zero-point energy corrections. This corresponds to a thermal reaction rate of k(therm) approximately 1 s(-1). In comparison, the rate of proton tunneling can be as high as 2 x 10(9) s(-1) under these conditions.     

Design of molecular switching and signaling based on proton transfer in 2-hydroxy Schiff bases: a computational study

The present work aims to exploit the possibility of using the tautomerism in 2-hydroxy Schiff bases for molecular switching. The enol imine (E)? enaminone (K) tautomerization in a series of 2-hydroxy Schiff bases have been investigated theoretically at the DFT/B3LYP/6-311G** level of theory. The intramolecular proton transfer processes have been explored, transition structures have been located and characterized. The kinetics and thermodynamics of the proton transfer process, and its time scale have been computed and discussed in the framework of the suitability as molecular switches. Substituent effects have been computed and its effect on the enthalpy changes (?H*) and activation energies (?G*) have been analyzed and discussed. Nonspecific solvent effects have also been taken into account by using the polarized continuum model (IPCM) of two different solvent. The tautomerization energies are decreased and hence the endothermic nature of the enol imine ? enaminone tautomerization. The potential energy barriers, on the other hand, are increased due to the relative destabilization of the transition states. The NBO charge populations show that there is a high positive charge on the hydrogen atom during the process in all cases, which confirms that the proton transfer proceeds through a three-center interaction. The proton transfer processes, in all cases studied are kinetically allowed. The low potential energy barrier suggests that interconversion between the two tautomeric forms is spontaneous and the two forms may coexist.     

Charge transfer in green fluorescent protein.

Charge transfer reactions that contribute to the photoreactions of the wild type green fluorescent protein (GFP) do not occur in the isolated p-hydroxybenzylidene-imidazolidinone chromophore, demonstrating the role of the protein environment. The high quantum efficiency of the fluorescence photocycle that includes excited state proton transfer and the suppression of non-radiative pathways by the protein environment have been correlated with structural dynamics in the chromophore environment. A low quantum efficiency competing phototransformation reaction of GFP is accompanied by both proton and electron transfer, and closely mimics the charge redistribution that is occurring in the fluorescence photocycle. The protein response to this destabilising event has been demonstrated by cryo-trapping of early products in the reaction pathway and is found to be strong even at 100 K, including displacements of chromophore, protein, solvent and a photogenerated CO2 molecule derived from the decarboxylated Glu 222 side chain. We discuss the ramifications of the observation of strong conformational perturbations below the protein dynamical transition at approximately 200 K, in view of low temperature work on other light sensitive proteins such as myoglobin and bacteriorhodopsin. The proton and electron transfer in the phototransformation pathway mimics the proton and charge transfer which occurs during the fluorescence cycle, which leads to common structural responses in both photoreactions as shown by ultrafast spectroscopy. We review and discuss literature on light-induced and thermal charge transfer events, focusing on recent findings addressing conformational dynamics and implications for thermodynamic properties.     

Reductive activation of the heme iron–nitrosyl intermediate in the reaction mechanism of cytochrome c nitrite reductase: a theoretical study

Cytochrome c nitrite reductase catalyzes the six-electron, seven-proton reduction of nitrite to ammonia without release of any detectable reaction intermediate. This implies a unique flexibility of the active site combined with a finely tuned proton and electron delivery system. In the present work, we employed density functional theory to study the recharging of the active site with protons and electrons through the series of reaction intermediates based on nitrogen monoxide [Fe(II)-NO(+), Fe(II)-NO·, Fe(II)-NO(-), and Fe(II)-HNO]. The activation barriers for the various proton and electron transfer steps were estimated in the framework of Marcus theory. Using the barriers obtained, we simulated the kinetics of the reduction process. We found that the complex recharging process can be accomplished in two possible ways: either through two consecutive proton-coupled electron transfers (PCETs) or in the form of three consecutive elementary steps involving reduction, PCET, and protonation. Kinetic simulations revealed the recharging through two PCETs to be a means of overcoming the predicted deep energetic minimum that is calculated to occur at the stage of the Fe(II)-NO· intermediate. The radical transfer role for the active-site Tyr(218), as proposed in the literature, cannot be confirmed on the basis of our calculations. The role of the highly conserved calcium located in the direct proximity of the active site in proton delivery has also been studied. It was found to play an important role in the substrate conversion through the facilitation of the proton transfer steps.     

Charge transfer in the K proton pathway linked to electron transfer to the catalytic site in cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase couples electron transfer from cytochrome c to O 2 to proton pumping across the membrane. In the initial part of the reaction of the reduced cytochrome c oxidase with O 2, an electron is transferred from heme a to the catalytic site, parallel to the membrane surface. Even though this electron transfer is not linked to proton uptake from solution, recently Belevich et al. [(2006) Nature 440, 829] showed that it is linked to transfer of charge perpendicular to the membrane surface (electrogenic reaction). This electrogenic reaction was attributed to internal transfer of a proton from Glu286, in the D proton pathway, to an unidentified protonatable site "above" the heme groups. The proton transfer was proposed to initiate the sequence of events leading to proton pumping. In this study, we have investigated electrogenic reactions in structural variants of cytochrome c oxidase in which residues in the second, K proton pathway of cytochrome c oxidase were modified. The results indicate that the electrogenic reaction linked to electron transfer to the catalytic site originates from charge transfer within the K pathway, which presumably facilitates reduction of the site.     

Local Charge Distribution Engineered by Schottky Heterojunctions toward Urea Electrolysis

Urea electrooxidation with favorable thermodynamic potential offers great promise for decoupling H₂/O₂ evolution from sluggish water splitting, and simultaneously mitigating the problem of urea‐rich water pollution. However, the intrinsically slow kinetics of the six‐electron transfer process impels one to explore efficient catalysts in order to enable widespread use of this catalytic system. In response, taking CoS₂/MoS₂ Schottky heterojunctions as the proof‐of‐concept paradigm, a catalytic model to modulate the surface charge distribution for synergistically facilitating the adsorption and fracture of chemical group in urea molecule is proposed and the mechanism of urea electrooxidation at the molecular level is elucidated. Based on density functional calculations, the self‐driven charge transfer across CoS₂/MoS₂ heterointerface would induce the formation of local electrophilic/nucleophilic region, which will intelligently adsorb electron‐donating/electron‐withdrawing groups in urea molecule, activate the chemical bonds, and thus trigger the decomposition of urea. Benefiting from the regulation of local charge distribution, the constructed Schottky catalyst of CoS₂‐MoS₂ exhibits superior urea catalytic activities with a potential of 1.29 V (only 0.06 V higher than the thermodynamic voltage of water decomposition) to attain 10 mA cm^?2 as well as robust durability over 60 h. This innovational manipulation of charge distribution via Schottky heterojunction provides a model in exploring other highly efficient electrocatalysts.     

Mechanisms for regulating electron transfer in multi-centre redox proteins.

Protein-mediated electron transfer is a key process in nature. Many of the proteins involved in such electron transfers are complex and contain a number of redox-active cofactors. The very complexity of these multi-centre redox proteins has made it difficult to fully understand the various electron transfer events they catalyse. This is sometimes because the electron transfer steps themselves are gated or coupled to other processes such as proton transfer. However, with the molecular structures of many of these proteins now available it is possible to probe these electron transfer reactions at the molecular level. It is becoming apparent that many of these multi-centre redox proteins have rather subtle and elegant ways for regulating electron transfer. The purpose of this article is to illustrate how nature has used different approaches to control electron transfer in a number of different systems. Illustrative examples include: thermodynamic control of electron transfer in flavocytochromes b(2) and P450 BM3; a novel control mechanism involving calmodulin-binding-dependent electron transfer in neuronal nitric oxide synthase; the probable gating of electron transfer by ATP hydrolysis in nitrogenase; conformational gating of electron transfer in cytochrome cd(1); the regulation of electron transfer by protein dynamics in the cytochrome bc(1) complex; and finally the coupling of electron transfer to proton transfer in cytochrome c oxidase.     

Car-Parrinello and path integral molecular dynamics study of the hydrogen bond in the acetic acid dimer in the gas phase

In the paper are described studies of the double proton transfer (DPT) processes in the cyclic dimer of acetic acid in the gas phase using Car-Parrinello (CPMD) and path integral molecular dynamics (PIMD). Structures, energies and proton trajectories have been determined. The results show the double proton transfer in 450 K. In the classical dynamics (CPMD) a clear process mechanism can be identified, where asynchronized DPT arises due to coupling between the O-H stretching oscillator and several low energy intermolecular vibrational modes. The DPT mechanism is also asynchronic when quantum tunneling has been allowed in the simulation. It has been found that the calculated values of barrier height for the proton transfer depends very strongly on the used approaches. Barrier received from the free-energy profile at the CPMD level is around 4.5 kcal mol^-1 whereas at the PIMD level is reduced to 1 kcal mol^-1. The nature of bonding in acetic acid dimer and rearrangement of electron density due to the proton movement has been also studied by the topological analysis of Electron Localization Function and Electron Localizability Indicator function.