Measuring genetic stability in bacteria of potential use in genetic engineering

Four commonly used conjugation techniques, colony cross streak (CCS), broth mating (BM), combined spread plate (CSP), and membrane filtration (MF), were compared with each other regarding reliability, sensitivity, and complexity in evaluating the transfer of conjugative plasmids. Five plasmids representing several incompatibility groups plus a variety of laboratory and environmental isolates were used as mating pairs. The suitability of each method was evaluated for use in a routine assessment of the genetic stability of genetically engineered microorganisms. By the CSP and MF techniques with laboratory strains such as Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas species as recipients, transconjugants were usually produced in 100% of the mating trials. However, when environmental strains isolated from plants and soil were used as recipients, transconjugants were detected in 100% of some crosses and in as little as 30% in other crosses depending on the plasmid and recipient used. In general, differences in the percentage of successful matings between the CSP and MF techniques compared with the BM and CCS techniques were not statistically significant at the P less than or equal to 0.05 level. Occasionally, certain mating pairs consistently produced transconjugants by CCS or BM but not by CSP or MF. Since any single conjugation mating technique is not completely reliable in detecting transconjugants, we have developed a combined mating technique which integrates the CCS, CSP, BM, and MF methods as a single procedure to assess the mobility of plasmid DNA of genetically engineered microorganisms.     

Influence of lipopolysaccharide and protein in the cell envelope on recipient capacity in conjugation of Salmonella typhimurium.

In crosses of Salmonella typhimurium FfinP301 lac+ to F- strains of S. typhimurium in broth, recipient strains which were rough mutants affected in the outer core region of the lipopolysaccharide gave an average of 1.4 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell and over 50% of the donor and recipient cells in mating aggregates, whereas smooth recipient strains gave 0.08 Lac+ transconjugants and few cells in mating aggregates. Strains with mutations affecting the inner core of the lipopolysaccharide were usually poor recipients. When cells were mated on Millipore membrane filters, both smooth and rough strains gave ca. 1.0 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell. Plasmids in Inc groups FI, FII, M, J, and I beta gave more transconjugants with rough than smooth strains, but there were no difference in crosses with plasmids in Inc groups T, L, P, N, and W. Strains with mutations in the ompA gene (deficient in Omp Ap = 33K = II* = conjugation protein) yielded only 0.02 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell and few cells in mating aggregates. There was no indication of a deficiency of Omp Ap in smooth strains compared with rough strains. Reduced fertility of smooth recipients may occur because the O side chains of the lipopolysaccharide shield the recipient and reduce the frequency of stabilization of mating aggregates. However, gradient-of-transmission experiments indicated that once these mating aggregates are stabilized, they are equally stable in both smooth and rough recipients. Fertility was high in crosses of S. typhimurium Flac+ to Escherichia coli K-12 F- (0.75 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell; over 50% of the cells in mating aggregates). In crosses of E. coli K-12 Flac+ to S. typhimurium smooth F-, ca. 10(-5) Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell were obtained; in crosses to rough recipient strains, fertility was increased 14-fold, and when the recipient was defective in the SA and LT host restriction systems, fertility was increased in additional 100-fold. Thus, both the lipopolysaccharide and the protein in the cell envelope of S. typhimurium were shown to be important in the recipient function in F-mediated conjugation.     

Effect of Genomic Location on Horizontal Transfer of a Recombinant Gene Cassette Between Pseudomonas Strains in the Rhizosphere and Spermosphere of Barley Seedlings

The use of genetically engineered bacteria in natural environments constitutes a risk of transfer of recombinant DNA to the indigenous bacteria. However, chromosomal genes are believed to be less likely to transfer than genes on mobilizable and conjugative plasmids. To study this assumption, horizontal transfer of a recombinant gene cassette inserted into the chromosome of a Pseudomonas stutzeri strain, into a mobilizable plasmid (pAGM42), and into a conjugative plasmid (pKJK5) isolated from barley rhizosphere was investigated. Horizontal transfer efficiencies of the gene cassette inserted into a conjugative plasmid was 8.20 × 10⁻³ transconjugants/(donors × recipients)^1/2 in the rhizosphere and 4.57 × 10⁻² transconjugants/(donors × recipients)^1/2 in the spermosphere. Mobilization of the plasmid pAGM42 by the plasmids RP4 and pKJK5 was also detected at high levels in the microcosms, transfer efficiencies were up to 4.36 × 10⁻³ transconjugants/(donors × recipients)^1/2. Transfer of chromosomal encoded genes could not be detected in the microcosms by conjugation or transformation. However, transformation did occur by using the same bacterial strains under laboratory conditions. The rhizosphere and especially the spermosphere thus proved to be hot spot environments providing favorable conditions for gene transfer by mobilization and conjugation, but these environments did not support transformation at a detectable level. Received: 21 July 2000 / Accepted: 21 August 2000     

Mobilization transfer of the pUB110 plasmid between gram-positive bacteria]

The three factor crosses between the donor strain Bacillus subtilis 168 harbouring the plasmid pUB102-4, Bacillus thuringiensis strain carrying the mobilizing plasmid pAM beta 1 and recipient strain Lactobacillus fermenti were conducted in order to elaborate the optimal conditions of the plasmid pUB102-4 mobilization for transfer into gram-positive microorganisms and to elucidate the possible expression of endogluconase genes in a lactobacillus strain. The Lactobacillus fermenti transconjugants carrying the pUB102-4 plasmid were obtained in the three factor reciprocal crosses with the streptococcus recipient strain and Bacillus subtilis recipients. The presence of the plasmids in transconjugants was confirmed by colony hybridization with the [32P]-labelled plasmid DNA and KMC-ase activity in transconjugant cells. The proposed system of crosses using the high copy number plasmid derivatives of pUB110 mobilized with high frequency by the pAM beta 1 plasmid demonstrates the possibility to increase the circle of gram-positive host bacteria avoiding time and labour consuming operations.     

Transfer and properties of some natural and suicide replicons in Pasteurella multocida

We tested the transfer of several plasmids and transposons from Escherichia coli to Pasteurella multocida by filter mating. Two plasmids, pRKTV5 (pRK2013::Tn7) and pUW964 (pRKTV5::Tn5), were derived from pRK2013--a narrow-host-range plasmid with the broad-host-range IncP conjugation genes. Most P. multocida transconjugants obtained with pRKTV5 had Tn7 insertions in the chromosome but some had insertions of the whole plasmid. By contrast, all the transconjugants obtained with pUW964 had insertions of this plasmid or a deleted variant. pUW964 mediated low-frequency transfer of Tn7 or chromosomal markers between P. multocida strains. Broad-host-range IncP plasmid RP4 (RK2) did not yield selectable transconjugants in P. multocida but two plasmids derived by Tn5 insertion into a kanamycin-sensitive derivative of RP4 did yield transconjugants. pSUP1011, a narrow-host-range p15A replicon with the RP4 mob region allowing mobilization by the IncP conjugation genes also yielded transconjugants while several other plasmids tested did not transfer markers to P. multocida.     

Partial characterization of the genetic basis for sucrose metabolism and nisin production in Streptococcus lactis

We attempted to identify the genetic loci for sucrose-fermenting ability (Suc+), nisin-producing ability (Nip+), and nisin resistance (Nisr) in certain strains of Streptococcus lactis. To obtain genetic evidence linking the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype to a distinct plasmid, both conjugal transfer and transformation were attempted. A conjugation procedure modified to protect the recipients against the inhibitory action of nisin allowed the conjugal transfer of the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker from three Suc+ Nip+ Nisr donors to various recipients. The frequency of transfer ranged from 1.7 x 10(-4) to 5.6 x 10(-8) per input donor, depending on the mating pair. However, no additional plasmid DNA was apparent in these transconjugants. Transformation of S. lactis LM0230 to the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype by using the plasmid pool of S. lactis ATCC 11454 was not achieved, even though other plasmids present in the pool were successfully transferred. However, two results imply the involvement of plasmid DNA in coding for the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype. The Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker was capable of conjugal transfer to a recipient deficient in host-mediated homologous recombination (Rec-), and the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker exhibited bilateral plasmid incompatibility with a number of lactose plasmids found in S. lactis. Although our results indicate that the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype is plasmid encoded, no physical evidence linking this phenotype to a distinct plasmid was obtained.     

Partial characterization of the genetic basis for sucrose metabolism and nisin production in Streptococcus lactis.

We attempted to identify the genetic loci for sucrose-fermenting ability (Suc+), nisin-producing ability (Nip+), and nisin resistance (Nisr) in certain strains of Streptococcus lactis. To obtain genetic evidence linking the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype to a distinct plasmid, both conjugal transfer and transformation were attempted. A conjugation procedure modified to protect the recipients against the inhibitory action of nisin allowed the conjugal transfer of the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker from three Suc+ Nip+ Nisr donors to various recipients. The frequency of transfer ranged from 1.7 x 10(-4) to 5.6 x 10(-8) per input donor, depending on the mating pair. However, no additional plasmid DNA was apparent in these transconjugants. Transformation of S. lactis LM0230 to the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype by using the plasmid pool of S. lactis ATCC 11454 was not achieved, even though other plasmids present in the pool were successfully transferred. However, two results imply the involvement of plasmid DNA in coding for the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype. The Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker was capable of conjugal transfer to a recipient deficient in host-mediated homologous recombination (Rec-), and the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr marker exhibited bilateral plasmid incompatibility with a number of lactose plasmids found in S. lactis. Although our results indicate that the Suc+ Nip+ Nisr phenotype is plasmid encoded, no physical evidence linking this phenotype to a distinct plasmid was obtained.     

Genetic properties of the Salmonella enteritidis R404 plasmid aggregate. IV. Reconstruction in R404 plasmid aggregate and separation of twelve genetically distinct derivative forms.

R404 plasmid aggregate is composed of two conjugative and two nonconjugative plasmids. Plasmid aggregate reconstructed from separated plasmids had the same genetic properties as the original R404 plasmid aggregate. It was found that plasmids of R404 factor could be transferred in conjugation in twelve different sets. These twelve genetically distinct classes of transconjugants formed only six groups differing in phenotypic characters.     

Conjugal transfer of R68.45 and FP5 between Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains in a freshwater environment

Recent concern over the release of genetically engineered organisms has resulted in a need for information about the potential for gene transfer in the environment. In this study, the conjugal transfer in Pseudomonas aeruginosa of the plasmids R68.45 and FP5 was demonstrated in the freshwater environment of Fort Loudoun Resevoir, Knoxville, Tenn. When genetically well defined plasmid donor and recipient strains were introduced into test chambers suspended in Fort Loudoun Lake, transfer of both plasmids was observed. Conjugation occurred in both the presence and absence of the natural microbial community. The number of transconjugants recovered was lower when the natural community was present. Transfer of the broad-host-range plasmid R68.45 to organisms other than the introduced recipient was not observed in these chambers but was observed in laboratory simulations when an organism isolated from lakewater was used as the recipient strain. Although the plasmids transferred in laboratory studies were genetically and physically stable, a significant number of transconjugants recovered from the field trials contained deletions and other genetic rearrangements, suggesting that factors which increase gene instability are operating in the environment. The potential for conjugal transfer of genetic material must be considered in evaluating the release of any genetically engineered microorganism into a freshwater environment.     

Conjugal transfer of R68.45 and FP5 between Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains in a freshwater environment.

Recent concern over the release of genetically engineered organisms has resulted in a need for information about the potential for gene transfer in the environment. In this study, the conjugal transfer in Pseudomonas aeruginosa of the plasmids R68.45 and FP5 was demonstrated in the freshwater environment of Fort Loudoun Resevoir, Knoxville, Tenn. When genetically well defined plasmid donor and recipient strains were introduced into test chambers suspended in Fort Loudoun Lake, transfer of both plasmids was observed. Conjugation occurred in both the presence and absence of the natural microbial community. The number of transconjugants recovered was lower when the natural community was present. Transfer of the broad-host-range plasmid R68.45 to organisms other than the introduced recipient was not observed in these chambers but was observed in laboratory simulations when an organism isolated from lakewater was used as the recipient strain. Although the plasmids transferred in laboratory studies were genetically and physically stable, a significant number of transconjugants recovered from the field trials contained deletions and other genetic rearrangements, suggesting that factors which increase gene instability are operating in the environment. The potential for conjugal transfer of genetic material must be considered in evaluating the release of any genetically engineered microorganism into a freshwater environment.     

Mobilization of nonconjugative antibiotic resistance plasmids in Haemophilus ducreyi.

A clinical isolate of Haemophilus ducreyi was found to harbor three plasmids: a 23.5-megadalton (Mdal) phenotypically cryptic plasmid, a 7.0-Mdal ampicillin resistance plasmid, and a 4.0-Mdal sulfonamide resistance plasmid. The two smaller plasmids were transferable by conjugation to Haemophilus recipients, but only if the donor cell harbored the 23.5-Mdal plasmid as well, indicating that this large plasmid had mobilizing capabilities. Transfer was also possible to Escherichia coli recipients. Haemophilus influenzae transconjugants which had acquired both the 23.5-Mdal plasmid and one of the R-plasmids could subsequently retransfer the R-plasmid to other Haemophilus recipients at higher frequencies. A derivative of the 23.5 Mdal plasmid was isolated which was shown by restriction endonuclease analysis to contain an ampicillin resistance transposon and to have retained its conjugative ability.     

Transposition of a beta-lactamase locus from RP1 into Pseudomonas putida degradative plasmids.

The beta-lactamase gene from the RP1 plasmid transposes into at least two Pseudomonas putida degradative plasmids. Donor strains that carry RP1 (bla+ tet+ aphA+) and a degradative plasmid yield transconjugants that have only the bla+ marker of RP1. This occurs in up to 80% of all bla+ transconjugants. Segregation of the bla+ marker requires the presence of a degradative plasmid in the donor and is only observed in transconjugants that have received degradative markers. The bla+ tet aphA transconjugants show 100% linkage of bla+ to degradative markers in conjugation,transduction, and transformation crosses. A transduction cross of an (RP1), (SAL) donor shows that 8% of all SAL plasmids also carry the transposed bla+ marker. Tn401 is the name we assign to the bla+ transposon from RP1 observed in Pseudomonas. Its identity with the RP1 bla+ transposon observed in Escherichia coli is not known. In four cases, Tn401 has inserted into the camphor genes of the CAM-OCT plasmid.     

Plasmid associated with diplococcin production in Streptococcus

The ability to produce diplococcin (Dip+) was transferred by conjugation from Streptococcus cremoris 346 to two plasmid-free S. cremoris recipients at a high frequency (10(-1) per donor). Dip+ transconjugants from each mating gained a 54-megadalton plasmid. Spontaneous loss of this plasmid restored the Dip- phenotype.     

Plasmid associated with diplococcin production in Streptococcus.

The ability to produce diplococcin (Dip+) was transferred by conjugation from Streptococcus cremoris 346 to two plasmid-free S. cremoris recipients at a high frequency (10(-1) per donor). Dip+ transconjugants from each mating gained a 54-megadalton plasmid. Spontaneous loss of this plasmid restored the Dip- phenotype.     

Recombinant DNA transfer to Escherichia coli of human faecal origin in vitro and in digestive tract of gnotobiotic mice

Abstract The role of helper elements in the mobilisation of pBR recombinant plasmids ( tra ⁻, mob ⁻, ori T⁺ and tra ⁻, mob ⁻, ori T⁻) from genetically engineered Escherichia coli K12 strains to other K12-strains and to wild-type E. coli strains of human faecal origin was examined. Transfer experiments were done in the digestive tract of axenic (germ free) and gnotobiotic mice, associated with human faecal flora, HFF. The kinetics of implantation of donors, recipients and transconjugants were determined. Mobilisation of ori T⁺ pBR-type plasmids, by trans-complementation with the products of tra and mob genes was obtained with E. coli K12, in the digestive tract of axenic mice and the resulting transconjugants became established together with the recipient and donor strains. Such mobilisation was only observed sporadically with one E. coli of human origin in axenic mice, but did not occur in gnotobiotic HFF mice. The E. coli strains of human origin were able to promote transfer of an ori T⁻ pBR-type plasmid in vitro but not in axenic or gnotobiotic mice. Transconjugants of wild-type strains obtained in in vitro mating experiments and inoculated into gnotobiotic HFF mice were eliminated as rapidly as the recombinant K12 strains. This work indicates that ≥ 50% of wild-type E. coli strains were able to promote transfer of pBR ori T⁻ plasmids in vitro.     

Self-transmissible plasmid in Zymomonas mobilis carrying antibiotic resistance.

The cryptic plasmid pRUT41 from Zymomonas mobilis was examined for its biological properties. This plasmid was found to be conjugally transferred from Z. mobilis CP4 to Escherichia coli BM21 and to carry genes for antibiotic resistance (gentamicin, kanamycin, and streptomycin). Covalently closed circular plasmid DNA was isolated from eight transconjugants of E. coli BM21. These plasmids were identical in mobility on agarose gels and exhibited the same restriction patterns as the native pRUT41 plasmid isolated from Z. mobilis. The plasmid location of the antibiotic resistance genes was further confirmed by transforming E. coli BM21 with isolated pRUT41 plasmid from strain CP4 and with plasmids from the transconjugants of BM21. Resistance to streptomycin, kanamycin, and gentamicin was tightly linked and transferred together in all cases.     

A microcosm for measuring survival and conjugation of genetically engineered bacteria in rhizosphere environments

A microcosm is described to evaluate and measure bacterial conjugation in the rhizosphere of barley and radish with strains ofPseudomonas cepacia. The purpose was to describe a standard method useful for evaluating the propensity of genetically engineered microorganisms (GEMs) to transfer DNA to recipient bacteria. Results demonstrated the formation of transconjugants from the rhizosphere of each plant 24 h after inoculation. Transconjugant populations peaked at 1.8 × 10² colony forming units (CFU)/g root and associated soil in barley and 2.0×10² CFU/g root and associated soil in radish; they then declined over the next five days of the experiment. No significant differences were found in the survival of transconjugant populations monitored from the two plant species. The microcosm was also used to document the formation of false positive transconjugants, which resulted from donor and recipientP. cepacia mating on the surface of selective agar plates instead of in microcosms. Transconjugants resulting from such plate mating occurred in substantial numbers during the first 5 days of the experiment but declined to undetectable numbers by day 7. The use of nalidixic acid was investigated to determine the magnitude of plate mating. The number of transconjugants detected from radish rhizosphere was reduced by two orders of magnitude by including nalidixic acid in the plating medium; this indicated that 99% of the transconjugants were a result of plate mating.     

Self-transmissible plasmid in Zymomonas mobilis carrying antibiotic resistance

The cryptic plasmid pRUT41 from Zymomonas mobilis was examined for its biological properties. This plasmid was found to be conjugally transferred from Z. mobilis CP4 to Escherichia coli BM21 and to carry genes for antibiotic resistance (gentamicin, kanamycin, and streptomycin). Covalently closed circular plasmid DNA was isolated from eight transconjugants of E. coli BM21. These plasmids were identical in mobility on agarose gels and exhibited the same restriction patterns as the native pRUT41 plasmid isolated from Z. mobilis. The plasmid location of the antibiotic resistance genes was further confirmed by transforming E. coli BM21 with isolated pRUT41 plasmid from strain CP4 and with plasmids from the transconjugants of BM21. Resistance to streptomycin, kanamycin, and gentamicin was tightly linked and transferred together in all cases.     

Survival of Pseudomonas putida UWC1 containing cloned catabolic genes in a model activated-sludge unit

The possibility of the accidental or deliberate release of genetically engineered microorganisms into the environment has accentuated the need to study their survival in, and effect on, natural habitats. In this study, Pseudomonas putida UWC1 harboring a non-self-transmissible plasmid, pD10, encoding the breakdown of 3-chlorobenzoate was shown to survive in a fully functioning laboratory-scale activated-sludge unit (ASU) for more than 8 weeks. The ASU maintained a healthy, diverse protozoal population throughout the experiment, and the introduced strain did not adversely affect the functioning of the unit. Although plasmid pD10 was stably maintained in the host bacterium, the introduced strain did not enhance the degradation of 3-chlorobenzoate in the ASU. When reisolated from the ASU, derivatives of strain UWC1 (pD10) were identified which were able to transfer plasmid pD10 to a recipient strain, P. putida PaW340, indicating the in situ transfer of mobilizing plasmids from the indigenous population to the introduced strain. Results from plate filter matings showed that bacteria present in the activated-sludge population could act as recipients for plasmid pD10 and actively expressed genes carried on the plasmid. Some of these activated-sludge transconjugants gave higher rates of 3-chlorobenzoate breakdown than did strain UWC1(pD10) in batch culture.     

Survival of Pseudomonas putida UWC1 containing cloned catabolic genes in a model activated-sludge unit.

The possibility of the accidental or deliberate release of genetically engineered microorganisms into the environment has accentuated the need to study their survival in, and effect on, natural habitats. In this study, Pseudomonas putida UWC1 harboring a non-self-transmissible plasmid, pD10, encoding the breakdown of 3-chlorobenzoate was shown to survive in a fully functioning laboratory-scale activated-sludge unit (ASU) for more than 8 weeks. The ASU maintained a healthy, diverse protozoal population throughout the experiment, and the introduced strain did not adversely affect the functioning of the unit. Although plasmid pD10 was stably maintained in the host bacterium, the introduced strain did not enhance the degradation of 3-chlorobenzoate in the ASU. When reisolated from the ASU, derivatives of strain UWC1 (pD10) were identified which were able to transfer plasmid pD10 to a recipient strain, P. putida PaW340, indicating the in situ transfer of mobilizing plasmids from the indigenous population to the introduced strain. Results from plate filter matings showed that bacteria present in the activated-sludge population could act as recipients for plasmid pD10 and actively expressed genes carried on the plasmid. Some of these activated-sludge transconjugants gave higher rates of 3-chlorobenzoate breakdown than did strain UWC1(pD10) in batch culture.