Small-angle X-ray scattering studies of enzymes

Enzyme function requires conformational changes to achieve substrate binding, domain rearrangements, and interactions with partner proteins, but these movements are difficult to observe. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a versatile structural technique that can probe such conformational changes under solution conditions that are physiologically relevant. Although it is generally considered a low-resolution structural technique, when used to study conformational changes as a function of time, ligand binding, or protein interactions, SAXS can provide rich insight into enzyme behavior, including subtle domain movements. In this perspective, we highlight recent uses of SAXS to probe structural enzyme changes upon ligand and partner-protein binding and discuss tools for signal deconvolution of complex protein solutions.     

Comparison of ligand-induced conformational changes and domain closure mechanisms, between prokaryotic and eukaryotic dehydroquinate synthases

Dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS) is a potential target for the development of novel broad-spectrum antimicrobial drugs, active against both prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes. Structures have been reported for Aspergillus nidulans DHQS (AnDHQS) in complexes with a range of ligands. Analysis of these AnDHQS structures showed that a large-scale domain movement occurs during the normal catalytic cycle, with a complex series of structural elements propagating substrate binding-induced conformational changes away from the active site to distal locations. Compared to corresponding fungal enzymes, DHQS from bacterial species are both mono-functional and significantly smaller. We have therefore determined the structure of Staphylococcus aureus DHQS (SaDHQS) in five liganded states, allowing comparison of ligand-induced conformational changes and mechanisms of domain closure between fungal and bacterial enzymes. This comparative analysis shows that substrate binding initiates a large-scale domain closure in both species' DHQS and that the active site stereochemistry, of the catalytically competent closed-form enzyme thus produced, is also highly conserved. However, comparison of AnDHQS and SaDHQS open-form structures, and analysis of the putative dynamic processes by which the transition to the closed-form states are made, shows a far lower degree of similarity, indicating a significant structural divergence. As a result, both the nature of the propagation of conformational change and the mechanical systems involved in this propagation are quite different between the DHQSs from the two species.     

Targeted molecular dynamics simulation studies of binding and conformational changes in E. coli MurD

Enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of bacterial peptidoglycan, an essential cell wall polymer unique to prokaryotic cells, represent a highly interesting target for antibacterial drug design. Structural studies of E. coli MurD, a three-domain ATP hydrolysis driven muramyl ligase revealed two inactive open conformations of the enzyme with a distinct C-terminal domain position. It was hypothesized that the rigid body rotation of this domain brings the enzyme to its closed active conformation, a structure, which was also determined experimentally. Targeted molecular dynamics 1 ns-length simulations were performed in order to examine the substrate binding process and gain insight into structural changes in the enzyme that occur during the conformational transitions into the active conformation. The key interactions essential for the conformational transitions and substrate binding were identified. The results of such studies provide an important step toward more powerful exploitation of experimental protein structures in structure-based inhibitor design.     

Substrate-induced double sided H-bond network as a means of domain closure in 3-phosphoglycerate kinase

Closure of the two domains of 3-phosphoglycerate kinase, upon substrate binding, is essential for the enzyme function. The available crystal structures cannot provide sufficient information about the mechanism of substrate assisted domain closure and about the requirement of only one or both substrates, since lattice forces may hinder the large scale domain movements. In this study the known X-ray data, obtained for the open and closed conformations, were probed by solution small-angle X-ray scattering experiments. The results prove that binding of both substrates is essential for domain closure. Molecular graphical analysis, indeed, reveals formation of a double-sided H-bond network, which affects substantially the shape of the main molecular hinge at beta-strand L, under the concerted action of both substrates.     

Stability domains, substrate-induced conformational changes, and hinge-bending motions in a psychrophilic phosphoglycerate kinase. A microcalorimetric study

The cold-active phosphoglycerate kinase from the Antarctic bacterium Pseudomonas sp. TACII18 exhibits two distinct stability domains in the free, open conformation. It is shown that these stability domains do not match the structural N- and C-domains as the heat-stable domain corresponds to about 80 residues of the C-domain, including the nucleotide binding site, whereas the remaining of the protein contributes to the main heat-labile domain. This was demonstrated by spectroscopic and microcalorimetric analyses of the native enzyme, of its mutants, and of the isolated recombinant structural domains. It is proposed that the heat-stable domain provides a compact structure improving the binding affinity of the nucleotide, therefore increasing the catalytic efficiency at low temperatures. Upon substrate binding, the enzyme adopts a uniformly more stable closed conformation. Substrate-induced stability changes suggest that the free energy of ligand binding is converted into an increased conformational stability used to drive the hinge-bending motions and domain closure.     

Epitopic regions recognized by monoclonal antibodies against rat brain hexokinase: association with catalytic and regulatory function.

Using direct and competitive epitope mapping methods, 23 monoclonal antibodies (Mabs) against rat brain hexokinase (ATP:D-hexose 6-phosphotransferase, EC 2.7.1.1) were divided into nine groups, each recognizing epitopes within defined surface regions of the N- or C-terminal domains; the latter have been associated with regulatory or catalytic functions, respectively. Reactivity of Mabs with the isolated domains was also studied. Based on the effect of various ligands on immunoreactivity, specific regions involved in ligand-induced conformational changes were identified. Adjacent epitopic regions, designated Regions F and G and located in the N- and C-terminal domains, respectively, were selectively affected by inhibitory hexose 6-phosphates (or analogs), marking these regions as being involved in transmission of the conformational signal from the regulatory N-terminal domain to the catalytic C-terminal domain. Consistent with this, the Ki for inhibition of the enzyme by the glucose 6-phosphate analog, 1,5-anhydroglucitol-6-phosphate, was markedly increased by Mabs binding in these regions, but unaffected by Mabs binding elsewhere in the molecule. Reactivity with Mabs recognizing conformationally sensitive epitopes in Region H of the C-terminal domain was greatly decreased by binding of substrate hexoses that induce closure of a cleft in the catalytic domain; selective recognition of the "open cleft" conformation, thereby preventing closure of the cleft required for progression of the catalytic cycle, can account for the marked decrease in Vmax that results from binding of these Mabs. Reactivity with Mabs binding to Region H was also decreased in the presence of inhibitory hexose 6-phosphates, implying that cleft closure was also induced by the latter; this is consistent with the suggestion that limitation of access to the C-terminal ATP binding site, resulting from cleft closure, is a factor in inhibition of the enzyme.     

Conformational transitions in adenylate kinase. Allosteric communication reduces misligation

Large conformational changes in the LID and NMP domains of adenylate kinase (AKE) are known to be key to ligand binding and catalysis, yet the order of binding events and domain motion is not well understood. Combining the multiple available structures for AKE with the energy landscape theory for protein folding, a theoretical model was developed for allostery, order of binding events, and efficient catalysis. Coarse-grained models and nonlinear normal mode analysis were used to infer that intrinsic structural fluctuations dominate LID motion, whereas ligand-protein interactions and cracking (local unfolding) are more important during NMP motion. In addition, LID-NMP domain interactions are indispensable for efficient catalysis. LID domain motion precedes NMP domain motion, during both opening and closing. These findings provide a mechanistic explanation for the observed 1:1:1 correspondence between LID domain closure, NMP domain closure, and substrate turnover. This catalytic cycle has likely evolved to reduce misligation, and thus inhibition, of AKE. The separation of allosteric motion into intrinsic structural fluctuations and ligand-induced contributions can be generalized to further our understanding of allosteric transitions in other proteins.     

Ligand-induced conformational changes and a mechanism for domain closure in Aspergillus nidulans dehydroquinate synthase

In order to investigate systematically substrate and cofactor-induced conformational changes in the enzyme dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS), eight structures representing a series of differently liganded states have been determined in a total of six crystal forms. DHQS in the absence of the substrate analogue carbaphosphonate, either unliganded or in the presence of NAD or ADP, is in an open form where a relative rotation of 11-13 degrees between N and C-terminal domains occurs.Analysis of torsion angle difference plots between sets of structures reveals eight rearrangements that appear relevant to domain closure and a further six related to crystal packing. Overlapping 21 different copies of the individual N and C-terminal DHQS domains further reveals a series of pivot points about which these movements occur and illustrates the way in which widely separated secondary structure elements are mechanically inter-linked to form "composite elements", which propagate structural changes across large distances.This analysis has provided insight into the basis of DHQS ligand-initiated domain closure and gives rise to the proposal of an ordered sequence of events involving substrate binding, and local rearrangements within the active site that are propagated to the hinge regions, leading to closure of the active-site cleft.     

Conformational changes upon ligand binding in the essential class II fumarase Rv1098c from Mycobacterium tuberculosis

rv1098c, an essential gene in Mycobacterium tuberculosis, codes for a class II fumarase. We describe here the crystal structure of Rv1098c in complex with l-malate, fumarate or the competitive inhibitor meso-tartrate. The models reveal that substrate binding promotes the closure of the active site through conformational changes involving the catalytic SS-loop and the C-terminal domain, which likely represents a general feature of this enzyme superfamily. Analysis of ligand-enzyme interactions as well as site-directed mutagenesis suggest Ser318 as one of the two acid-base catalysts.     

The transducer domain is important for clamp operation in human DNA topoisomerase IIalpha

DNA topoisomerase II is a multidomain homodimeric enzyme that changes DNA topology by coupling ATP hydrolysis to the transport of one DNA helix through a transient double-stranded break in another. The process requires dramatic conformational changes including closure of an ATP-operated clamp, which is comprised of two N-terminal domains from each protomer. The most N-terminal domain contains the ATP-binding site and is directly involved in clamp closure, undergoing dimerization upon ATP binding. The second domain, the transducer domain, forms the walls of the N-terminal clamp and connects the clamp to the enzyme core. Although structurally conserved, it is unclear whether the transducer domain is involved in clamp mechanism. We have purified and characterized a human topoisomerase II alpha enzyme with a two-amino acid insertion at position 408 in the transducer domain. The enzyme retains both ATPase and DNA cleavage activities. However, the insertion, which is situated far from the N-terminal dimerization area, severely disrupts the function of the N-terminal clamp. The clamp-deficient enzyme is catalytically inactive and lacks most aspects of interdomain communication. Surprisingly, it seems to have retained the intersubunit communication, allowing it to bind ATP cooperatively in the presence of DNA. The results show that even distal parts of the transducer domain are important for the dynamics of the N-terminal clamp and furthermore indicate that stable clamp closure is not required for cooperative binding of ATP.     

Structures of N-acetylornithine transcarbamoylase from Xanthomonas campestris complexed with substrates and substrate analogs imply mechanisms for substrate binding and catalysis

N-acetyl-L-ornithine transcarbamoylase (AOTCase) is a new member of the transcarbamoylase superfamily that is essential for arginine biosynthesis in several eubacteria. We report here crystal structures of the binary complexes of AOTCase with its substrates, carbamoyl phosphate (CP) or N-acetyl-L-ornithine (AORN), and the ternary complex with CP and N-acetyl-L-norvaline. Comparison of these structures demonstrates that the substrate-binding mechanism of this novel transcarbamoylase is different from those of aspartate and ornithine transcarbamoylases, both of which show ordered substrate binding with large domain movements. CP and AORN bind to AOTCase independently, and the main conformational change upon substrate binding is ordering of the 80's loop, with a small domain closure around the active site and little movement of the 240's loop. The structures of the complexes provide insight into the mode of substrate binding and the mechanism of the transcarbamoylation reaction.     

Domain motion and interdomain hot spots in a multidomain enzyme

The aim of this article is to analyze conformational changes by comparing 10 different structures of Pseudomonas aeruginosa phosphomannomutase/phosphoglucomutase (PMM/PGM), a four‐domain enzyme in which both substrate binding and catalysis require substantial movement of the C‐terminal domain. We focus on changes in interdomain and active site crevices using a method called computational solvent mapping rather than superimposing the structures. The method places molecular probes (i.e., small organic molecules containing various functional groups) around the protein to find hot spots. One of the most important hot spots is in the active site, consistent with the ability of the enzyme to bind both glucose and mannose phosphosugar substrates. The protein has eight additional hot spots at domain‐domain interfaces and hinge regions. The locations and nature of six of these hot spots vary between the open, half‐open, and closed conformers of the enzyme, in good agreement with the ligand‐induced conformational changes. In the closed structures the number of probe clusters at the hinge region significantly depends on the position of the phosphorylated oxygen in the substrate (e.g., glucose 1‐phosphate versus glucose 6‐phosphate), but the protein remains almost unchanged in terms of the overall RMSD, indicating that computational solvent mapping is a more sensitive approach to detect changes in binding sites and interdomain crevices. Focusing on multidomain proteins we show that the subresolution conformational differences revealed by the mapping are in fact significant, and present a general statistical method of analysis to determine the significance of rigid body domain movements in X‐ray structures.     

Cross-monomer substrate contacts reposition the Hsp90 N-terminal domain and prime the chaperone activity

The ubiquitous molecular chaperone Hsp90 plays a critical role in substrate protein folding and maintenance, but the functional mechanism has been difficult to elucidate. In previous work, a model Hsp90 substrate revealed an activation process in which substrate binding accelerates a large open/closed conformational change required for ATP hydrolysis by Hsp90. While this could serve as an elegant mechanism for conserving ATP usage for productive interactions on the substrate, the structural origin of substrate-catalyzed Hsp90 conformational changes is unknown. Here, we find that substrate binding affects an intrinsically unfavorable rotation of the Hsp90 N-terminal domain (NTD) relative to the middle domain (MD) that is required for closure. We identify an MD substrate binding region on the interior cleft of the Hsp90 dimer and show that a secondary set of substrate contacts drives an NTD orientation change on the opposite monomer. These results suggest an Hsp90 activation mechanism in which cross-monomer contacts mediated by a partially structured substrate prime the chaperone for its functional activity.     

Luminescence resonance energy transfer investigation of conformational changes in the ligand binding domain of a kainate receptor

The apo state structure of the isolated ligand binding domain of the GluR6 subunit and the conformational changes induced by agonist binding to this protein have been investigated by luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) measurements. The LRET-based distances show that agonist binding induces cleft closure, and the extent of cleft closure is proportional to the extent of activation over a wide range of activations, thus establishing that the cleft closure conformational change is one of the mechanisms by which the agonist mediates receptor activation. The LRET distances also provide insight into the apo state structure, for which there is currently no crystal structure available. The distance change between the glutamate-bound state and the apo state is similar to that observed between the glutamate-bound and antagonist UBP-310-bound form of the GluR5 ligand binding domain, indicating that the cleft for the apo state of the GluR6 ligand binding domain should be similar to the UBP-310-bound form of GluR5. This observation implies that te apo state of GluR6 undergoes a cleft closure of 29-30 degrees upon binding full agonists, one of the largest observed in the glutamate receptor family.     

Three clusters of conformational states in p450cam reveal a multistep pathway for closing of the substrate access channel

Conformational changes in the substrate access channel have been observed for several forms of cytochrome P450, but the extent of conformational plasticity exhibited by a given isozyme has not been completely characterized. Here we present crystal structures of P450cam bound to a library of 12 active site probes containing a substrate analogue tethered to a variable linker. The structures provide a unique view of the range of protein conformations accessible during substrate binding. Principal component analysis of a total of 30 structures reveals three discrete clusters of conformations: closed (P450cam-C), intermediate (P450cam-I), and fully open (P450cam-O). Relative to P450cam-C, the P450cam-I state results predominantly from a retraction of helix F, while both helices F and G move in concert to reach the fully open P450cam-O state. Both P450cam-C and P450cam-I are well-defined states, while P450cam-O shows evidence of a somewhat broader distribution of conformations and includes the open form recently seen in the absence of substrate. The observed clustering of protein conformations over a wide range of ligand variants suggests a multistep closure of the enzyme around the substrate that begins by conformational selection from an ensemble of open conformations and proceeds through a well-defined intermediate, P450cam-I, before full closure to the P450cam-C state in the presence of small substrates. This multistep pathway may have significant implications for a full understanding of substrate specificity, kinetics, and coupling of substrate binding to P450 function.     

Correlation between conformational stability of the ternary enzyme-substrate complex and domain closure of 3-phosphoglycerate kinase

3-phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) is a typical two-domain hinge-bending enzyme with a well-structured interdomain region. The mechanism of domain-domain interaction and its regulation by substrate binding is not yet fully understood. Here the existence of strong cooperativity between the two domains was demonstrated by following heat transitions of pig muscle and yeast PGKs using differential scanning microcalorimetry and fluorimetry. Two mutants of yeast PGK containing a single tryptophan fluorophore either in the N- or in the C-terminal domain were also studied. The coincidence of the calorimetric and fluorimetric heat transitions in all cases indicated simultaneous, highly cooperative unfolding of the two domains. This cooperativity is preserved in the presence of substrates: 3-phosphoglycerate bound to the N domain or the nucleotide (MgADP, MgATP) bound to the C domain increased the structural stability of the whole molecule. A structural explanation of domain-domain interaction is suggested by analysis of the atomic contacts in 12 different PGK crystal structures. Well-defined backbone and side-chain H bonds, and hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions between side chains of conserved residues are proposed to be responsible for domain-domain communication. Upon binding of each substrate newly formed molecular contacts are identified that firstly explain the order of the increased heat stability in the various binary complexes, and secondly describe the possible route of transmission of the substrate-induced conformational effects from one domain to the other. The largest stability is characteristic of the native ternary complex and is abolished in the case of a chemically modified inactive form of PGK, the domain closure of which was previously shown to be prevented [Sinev MA, Razgulyaev OI, Vas M, Timchenko AA & Ptitsyn OB (1989) Eur J Biochem180, 61-66]. Thus, conformational stability correlates with domain closure that requires simultaneous binding of both substrates.     

Conformational changes at the agonist binding domain of the N-methyl-D-aspartic acid receptor

The conformational changes in the agonist binding domain of the glycine-binding GluN1 and glutamate-binding GluN2A subunits of the N-methyl D-aspartic acid receptor upon binding agonists of varying efficacy have been investigated by luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) measurements. The LRET-based distances indicate a cleft closure conformational change at the GluN1 subunit upon binding agonists; however, no significant changes in the cleft closure are observed between partial and full agonists. This is consistent with the previously reported crystal structures for the isolated agonist binding domain of this receptor. Additionally, the LRET-based distances show that the agonist binding domain of the glutamate-binding GluN2A subunit exhibits a graded cleft closure with the extent of cleft closure being proportional to the extent of activation, indicating that the mechanism of activation in this subunit is similar to that of the glutamate binding α-amino-5-methyl-3-hydroxy-4-isoxazole propionate and kainate subtypes of the ionotropic glutamate receptors.     

A conserved surface loop in type I dehydroquinate dehydratases positions an active site arginine and functions in substrate binding

Dehydroquinate dehydratase (DHQD) catalyzes the third step in the biosynthetic shikimate pathway. We present three crystal structures of the Salmonella enterica type I DHQD that address the functionality of a surface loop that is observed to close over the active site following substrate binding. Two wild-type structures with differing loop conformations and kinetic and structural studies of a mutant provide evidence of both direct and indirect mechanisms of involvement of the loop in substrate binding. In addition to allowing amino acid side chains to establish a direct interaction with the substrate, closure of the loop necessitates a conformational change of a key active site arginine, which in turn positions the substrate productively. The absence of DHQD in humans and its essentiality in many pathogenic bacteria make the enzyme a target for the development of nontoxic antimicrobials. The structures and ligand binding insights presented here may inform the design of novel type I DHQD inhibiting molecules.     

Substrate directs enzyme dynamics by bridging distal sites: UDP-galactopyranose mutase

UDP-Galactopyranose mutase (UGM) is a flavoenzyme that catalyzes interconversion of UDP-galactopyranose (UDP-Galp) and UDP-galactofuranose (UDP-Galf); its activity depends on FAD redox state. The enzyme is vital to many pathogens, not native to mammals, and is an important drug target. We have probed binding of substrate, UDP-Galp, and UDP to wild type and W160A UGM from K. pneumoniae, and propose that substrate directs recognition loop dynamics by bridging distal FAD and W160 sites; W160 interacts with uracil of the substrate and is functionally essential. Enhanced Trp fluorescence upon substrate binding to UGM indicates conformational changes remote from the binding site because the fluorescence is unchanged upon binding to W70F/W290F UGM where W160 is the sole Trp. MD simulations map these changes to recognition loop closure to coordinate substrate. This requires galactose-FAD interactions as Trp fluorescence is unchanged upon substrate binding to oxidized UGM, or binding of UDP to either form of the enzyme, and MD show heightened recognition loop mobility in complexes with UDP. Consistent with substrate-directed loop closure, UDP binds 10-fold more tightly to oxidized UGM, yet substrate binds tighter to reduced UGM. This requires the W160-U interaction because redox-switched binding affinity of substrate reverses in the W160A mutant where it only binds when oxidized. Without the anchoring W160-U interaction, an alternative binding mode for UDP is detected, and STD-NMR experiments show simultaneous binding of UDP-Galp and UDP to different subsites in oxidized W160A UGM: Substrate no longer directs recognition loop dynamics to coordinate tight binding to the reduced enzyme.     

The effect of hinge mutations on effector binding and domain rotation in Escherichia coli D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase

D-3-phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.95) from Escherichia coli contains two Gly-Gly sequences that have been shown previously to have the characteristics of hinge regions. One of these, Gly(336)-Gly(337), is found in the loop between the substrate binding domain and the regulatory domain. Changing these glycine residues to valine affected the sensitivity of the enzyme to inhibition by L-serine but not the extent of inhibition. The decrease in sensitivity was caused primarily by a decrease in the affinity of the enzyme for L-serine. These mutations also affected the domain rotation of the subunits in response to L-serine binding. A major conclusion of this study was that it defines a minimal limit on the necessary conformational changes leading to inhibition of enzyme activity. That is, some of the conformational differences seen in the native enzyme upon L-serine binding are not critical for inhibition, whereas others are maintained and may play important roles in inhibition and cooperativity. The structure of G336V demonstrates that the minimal effect of L-serine binding leading to inhibition of enzyme activity requires a domain rotation of approximately only 6 degrees in just two of the four subunits of the enzyme that are oriented diagonally across from each other in the tetramer. Moreover the structures show that both pairs of Asn190 to Asn190 hydrogen bonds across the subunit interfaces are necessary for activity. These observations are consistent with the half-the-sites activity, flip-flop mechanism proposed for this and other similar enzymes and suggest that the Asn190 hydrogen bonds may function in the conformational transition between alternate half-the-site active forms of the enzyme.