Quantitative aspects of hormone-receptor interactions of high affinity: Effect of receptor concentration and measurement of dissociation constants of labeled and unlabeled hormones

It is demonstrated that because of limitations in the magnitude of the specific activity of radiolabeled hormone derivatives, direct binding studies of hormone-receptor interactions of high affinity (10^?9–10^?11 M, depending on whether ³H- or ¹²³I-labeled hormones are used) will be subject to artifactual distortions due to the need to utilize high concentrations of the receptor. If the concentration of the receptor is not ten times lower than the true affinity constant, the apparent dissociation constant obtained from direct concentration binding curves will vary as a linear function of the receptor concentration. In addition, at high receptor concentrations saturability becomes difficult to demonstrate experimentally and the binding data yield apparently non-hyperbolic, sigmoidal curves which can be mistakenly interpreted to depict cooperative interactions. Similar artifacts related to receptor concentration are predicted for measurements of the hormone concentration dependence of biological processes (e.g. activation of adenylate cyclase, transport processes, etc.). Methods for detecting these effects, and correctly measuring affinities for labeled and unlabeled hormones under these conditions, are described. The implications for measuring the binding properties of hormone-receptor interactions are discussed, especially in reference to studies of the comparative analysis of receptor function in altered metabolic states and to studies relating the biological and binding properties of hormones.     

The mobile receptor hypothesis and "cooperativity" of hormone binding. Application to insulin.

The mobile receptor hypothesis has been proposed to describe the process by which hormone receptor binding initiates a biological response; it states that receptors, which can diffuse independently in the plane of the membrane, reversibly associate with effectors to regulate their activity. The affinity for effector is greater when the receptor is occupied by hormone. A mathematical expression of the mobile receptor hypothesis is used to show that: (1) The predicted kinetics of hormone receptor binding may be indistinguishable from "negative cooperativity." (2) Receptor occupancy and biological response may be coupled in a non-linear fashion. By choosing specific parameters, most of the existing data on insulin binding and biological responses can be explained in terms of the mobile receptor hypothesis. Thus, the following are easily explained: (1) A single homogeneous receptor may appear kinetically to be composed of two classes (of high and low affinity) of receptors. (2) Occupancy of the apparent class of high affinity receptors is related linearly to the biological response. (3) The same receptor in different tissues may appear to have different affinity. (4) The binding of different biologically active insulin analogues may exhibit different degrees of "cooperativity." These considerations may also be pertinent to interpretations of other hormone-receptor systems and of various ligand-macromolecule interactions.     

Practical considerations in analyzing radioreceptor assays by Scatchard analysis and capacity determination in irreversible hormone receptor interactions

The Scatchard plot in a radioreceptor assay depends upon the definition of specific binding and the quality of the iodinated hormone used. Iodination of protein hormones may alter it so that it no longer binds to the receptor and methods are available to measure the extent of this inactivation. When appropriate corrections are made for specific binding and the amount of inactive iodinated hormone in an assay, both qualitative and quantitative differences were observed in estimates of binding capacity and affinity in some well characterised hormone receptor systems. Theoretical predictions derived from Scatchard analysis of irreversible unimolecular hormone-receptor interactions were applicable, both qualitatively and quantitatively to two irreversible hormone-receptor systems. A method described permits a more accurate estimate of capacity from radioreceptor assay data.     

Partial agonism in the glucagon receptor system is a consequence of the two-state rat hepatic receptor

We have previously demonstrated that the glucagon receptor binds hormone to form a low affinity complex which, by a time- and temperature-dependent mechanism, is converted to a high affinity complex (Horwitz, E.M., Jenkins, W.T., Hoosein, N.M., and Gurd, R.S. (1985) J. Biol. Chem. 260, 9307-9315). In this report we have investigated the effects of agonist concentration, potency, and intrinsic activity on the characteristics of the two, interconvertible states of the glucagon receptor. As the glucagon concentration is increased from 0.02 to 0.50 nM, the initial velocity of binding increases. The conversion of a low affinity to a high affinity complex is the rate-limiting step in the overall binding reaction and approaches its maximal velocity as the hormone concentration exceeds 0.20 nM. At equilibrium, 87-90% of the hormone-receptor complexes are in the high affinity state at all hormone concentrations examined. [S-methyl-Met27]glucagon, a full agonist with reduced potency, binds to the two-state system in a manner analogous to that of native glucagon. The binding of N alpha-biotinyl-N epsilon-acetimidoglucagon, a partial agonist with reduced potency, effects a two-state system where the high affinity state accounts for only 35% of the total hormone-receptor complexes at equilibrium. We conclude that the formation of the high affinity complex is the rate-limiting step involved in glucagon binding; reduction in binding potency with full agonism is due to a reduction in the affinity of the ligand for the unoccupied receptor and not to an alteration of the interconversion of the two states, and decreased intrinsic activity is due to a quantitative decrease in conversion of the low to high affinity state.     

The mobile receptor hypothesis and “cooperativity” of hormone binding. Application to insulin

The mobile receptor hypothesis has been proposed to describe the process by which hormone receptor binding initiates a biological response; it states that receptors, which can diffuse independently in the plane of the membrane, reversibly associate with effectors to regulate their activity. The affinity for effector is greater when the receptor is occupied by hormone.A mathematical expression of the mobile receptor hypothesis is used to show that: (1) The predicted kinetics of hormone receptor binding may be indistinguishable from “negative cooperativity”. (2) Receptor occupancy and biological response may be coupled in a non-linear fashion.By choosing specific parameters, most of the existing data on insulin binding and biological responses can be explained in terms of the mobile receptor hypothesis. Thus, the following are easily explained: (1) A single homogeneous receptor may appear kinetically to be composed of two classes (of high and low affinity) of receptors. (2) Occupancy of the apparent class of high affinity receptors is related linearly to the biological response. (3) The same receptor in different tissues may appear to have different affinity. (4) The binding of different biologically active insulin analogues may exhibit different degrees of “cooperatively.” These considerations may also be pertinent to intepretations of other hormone-receptor systems and of various ligand-macromolecule interactions.     

Independence of Glucagon Receptors and Glucagon Inactivation in Liver Cell Membranes

THERE is increasing evidence that receptors for polypeptide hormones are localized on the cell membrane. Hormone-receptor interactions have been studied primarily by measuring the bmding of ¹²⁵I-labelled hormones to intact¹ or broken-cell preparations^2–6. Peptide hormones, however, are often inactivated after exposure to the cell extract and numerous enzymes reported as specific hormone-degrading have been described. With some hormones, such as insulin^1,6,7, biologically significant receptor interactions have been demonstrated in the absence of hormone degradation, but with other hormones, such as glucagon, it has not been possible to dissociate the processes of specific receptor binding and of hormone inactivation³, which suggests that these two processes may be functionally or structurally related. Until this question is resolved, it will not be possible to characterize properly the kinetics of the hormone-receptor interaction or to isolate and purify the receptor.     

Inhibition of insulin receptor binding by dimethyl sulfoxide.

Little is known of the effects of the solvent on hormone-receptor interactions. In the present study the effect of the polar solvent dimethyl sulfoxide on the binding of insulin to its surface receptors on cultured human lymphocytes of the IM-9 line was investigated. At concentrations exceeding 0.1% (v/v), dimethyl sulfoxide produced a dose-related inhibition of 125-I-labeled insulin binding. Insulin binding was totally abolished in 20% dimethyl sulfoxide. This inhibition was immediately present and was totally reversible. Analysis of the data of binding at steady state indicated that the decrease in binding of 125I-labeled insulin was due to a reduced affinity of the insulin receptor without noticeable change in the concentration of receptor sites. Kinetic studies showed that the decreased affinity could largely be accounted for by a decreased association rate constant; effects on dissociation and negative cooperativity of the insulin receptor was affected to a much lesser extent.     

Thyrotropin binding to and adenylate cyclase activity of porcine thyroid plasma membranes.

Plasma membranes have been purified from porcine thyroid gland homogenate by discontinuous sucrose gradient centrifugation. The preparations contained specific binding sites for thyrotropin but not for luteinizing hormone or the beta subunits of thyrotropin and luteinizing hormone. Optimum conditions of 125I-labeled thyrotropin binding were pH 6.0-6.5 and 37 degrees C. Thyrotropin binding was reduced by divalent (Ca2+, Mg2+) and monovalent cations (Na+, K+, Li+), 50% inhibition being obtained at 10 mM and 50 mM respectively. Displacement curves of 125I-labeled bovine or porcine thyrotropin by the unlabeled hormone from three species was in the order of increasing concentrations (bovine greater than porcine greater than human) which is the order of decreasing biological activity of these hormone preparations in the assay in vivo in the mouse. The validity of the results was established by controlling that porcine membranes bound the native and the 125I-labeled hormones with equal affinity. A single type of high-affinity (Kd = 0.28 nM) binding sites was detected for bovine and porcine thyrotropins. In contrast, porcine plasma membranes bound human thyrotropin with a lower affinity (Kd = 70 nM). A good correlation was found at equilibrium and in the conditions of the cyclase assay, between receptor occupancy and adenylate cyclase activation for the three hormones.     

Beta-Adrenergic receptor interactions. Direct comparison of receptor interaction and biological activity.

Iodohydroxybenzylpindolol (I-HYP) is a chemically defined, high affinity, high specific activity beta-adrenergic antagonist that interacts with a single site on the turkey erythrocyte membrane. Study of the interaction of agonists, antagonists, and congeners with this site and concomitant alterations in adenylate cyclase activity have been carried out in the presence of high or low concentrations of guanine nucleotide. The results help clarify the relationship between binding and activation or inhibition of adenylate cyclase and the role of guanine nucleotides in modulating this interaction. There is a close correlation between binding constants (KD) for inhibitors determined by analysis of competitive displacement of 125I-HYP from receptor, and apparent affinities (Ki) for inhibition of adenylate cyclase. For activators, however, there is up to a 10-fold difference between KD and apparent affinity (KDapp) for adenylate cyclase activation at low guanine nucleotide concentration (10(-6) M guanylylimidodiphosphate). This difference is virtually abolished by employing higher nucleotide concentrations (10(-5) M guanylylimidodiphosphate) without significantly altering receptor affinity. This suggests that guanine nucleotides act by modulating receptor-enzyme interactions rather than hormone-receptor interactions. Moreover, several beta-adrenergic analogs previously shown to have no effect on adenylate cyclase in the absence of nucleotide, are partial agonists in the presence of 10(-5) M guanylylimidodiphosphate. Parallel analyses for a series of agonists and antagonists for adenylate cyclase activation and receptor interaction show affinities for levorotatory isomers generally 100-fold greater than for dextrorotatory isomers. Thus stereoconfiguration at the beta carbon clearly influences affinity of agonists or antagonists. Affinity is also importantly influenced by the nature of the aromatic ring as well as the N-alkyl group. The complexity of structure-function relationships for these compounds requires a redefinition of structural requirements for beta-adrenergic activity.     

Calcitonin-sensitive adenylate cyclase in rat renal tubular membranes.

1. Renal tubular membranes from rat kidneys were prepared, and adenylate cyclase activity was measured under basal conditions, after stimulation by NaF or salmon calcitonin. Apparent Km value of the enzyme for hormone-linked receptor was close to 1 x 10(-8) M. 2. The system was sensitive to temperature and pH. pH was found to act both on affinity for salmon calcitonin-linked receptor and maximum stimulation, suggesting an effect of pH on hormone-receptor binding and on a subsequent step. 3. KCl was without effect areas whereas CoCl and CaCl2 above 100 muM and MnCl2 above 1 muM inhibited F- -and salmon calcitonin-sensitive adenylate cyclase activities. The Ca2+ inhibition of the response reflected a fall in maximum stimulation and not a loss of affinity of salmon calcitonin-linked receptor for the enzyme. 4. The measurement of salmon calcitonin-sensitive adenylate cyclase activity as a function of ATP concentration showed that the hormone increases the maximum velocity of the adenylate cyclase. GTP, ITP and XTP at 200 muM did not modify basal, salmon calcitonin- and parathyroid hormone-sensitive adenylate cyclase activities. 5. Basal, salmon calcitonin- and F- -sensitive adenylate cyclase activities decreased at Mg2+ concentrations below 10 mM. High concentrations of Mg2+ (100 mM) led to an inhibition of the F- -stimulated enzyme. 6. Salmon calcitonin-linked receptor had a greater affinity for adenylate cyclase than human or porcine calcitonin-linked receptors. There was no additive effect of these three calcitonin peptides whereas parathyroid hormone added to salmon calcitonin increased adenylate cyclase activity, thus showing that both hormones bound to different membrane receptors. Human calcitonin fragments had no effect on adenylate cyclase activity. 7. Salmon calcitonin-stimulated adenylate cyclase activity decreased with the preincubation time. This was due to progressive degradation of the hormone and not to the rate of binding to membrane receptors.     

Solubilization, gel filtration and sedimentation behaviour of prolactin receptors from human ovarian tissue

Receptors for 125I-labelled human prolactin have been identified in the crude membrane fraction isolated from human ovarian tissue. The non-ionic detergent Triton X-100, has been used to solubilize the membrane fraction. The presence of the receptor in the detergent extract was demonstrated by gel filtration and sucrose density gradient centrifugation. The binding was time-temperature dependent, being maximal at 23 degrees C after 15 h of incubation. Large amounts of other peptide hormones did not inhibit the binding of 125I-labelled human prolactin. The binding Scatchard analysis demonstrated that the affinity of the soluble receptor (Ka 1.13 +/- 0.15 X 10(10) M-1) for the labelled hormone was slightly greater than that of the crude membrane fraction (Ka 0.91 +/- 0.12 X 10(10) M-1). The binding capacity of the solubilized receptor was also significantly greater than that seen in the particulate before solubilization. The apparent Stokes radius of the solubilized receptor was estimated to be 57 A and that the hormone-receptor complex 60 A. The sedimentation coefficient of the solubilized receptor was 7.0 +/- 0.1 s, whereas that of the hormone-receptor complex was 7.5 +/- 0.2 s.     

Identification of a novel V1-type AVP receptor based on the molecular recognition theory.

BACKGROUND: The molecular recognition theory predicts that binding domains of peptide hormones and their corresponding receptor binding domains evolved from complementary strands of genomic DNA, and that a process of selective evolutionary mutational events within these primordial domains gave rise to the high affinity and high specificity of peptide hormone-receptor interactions observed today in different peptide hormone-receptor systems. Moreover, this theory has been broadened as a general hypothesis that could explain the evolution of intermolecular protein-protein and intramolecular peptide interactions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Applying a molecular cloning strategy based on the molecular recognition theory, we screened a rat kidney cDNA library with a vasopressin (AVP) antisense oligonucleotide probe, expecting to isolate potential AVP receptors. RESULTS: We isolated a rat kidney cDNA encoding a functional V1-type vasopressin receptor. Structural analysis identified a 135 amino acid-long polypeptide with a single transmembrane domain, quite distinct from the rhodopsin-based G protein-coupled receptor superfamily. Functional analysis of the expressed V1-type receptor in Cos-1 cells revealed AVP-specific binding, AVP-specific coupling to Ca2+ mobilizing transduction system, and characteristic V1-type antagonist inhibition. CONCLUSIONS: This is the second AVP receptor cDNA isolated using AVP antipeptide-based oligonucleotide screening, thus providing compelling evidence in support of the molecular recognition theory as the basis of the evolution of this peptide hormone-receptor system, as well as adds molecular complexity and diversity to AVP receptor systems.     

Receptor binding properties of four-helix-bundle growth factors deduced from electrostatic analysis

Hormones of the hematopoietin class mediate signal transduction by binding to specific transmembrane receptors. Structural data show that the human growth hormone (hGH) forms a complex with a homodimeric receptor and that hGH is a member of a class of hematopoietins possessing an antiparallel 4-α-helix bundle fold. Mutagenesis experiments suggest that electrostatic interactions may have an important influence on hormone-receptor recognition. In order to examine the specificity of hormone-receptor complexation, an analysis was made of the electrostatic potentials of hGH, interleukin-2 (IL-2), interleukin-4 (IL-4), granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF), granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and the hGH and IL-4 receptors. The binding surfaces of hGH and its receptor, and of IL-4 and its receptor, show complementary electrostatic potentials. The potentials of the hGH and its receptor display approximately 2-fold rotational symmetry because the receptor subunits are identical. In contrast, the potentials of GM-CSF and IL-2 lack such symmetry, consistent with their known high affinity for hetero-oligomeric receptors. Analysis of the electrostatic potentials supports a recently proposed hetero-oligomeric model for a high-affinity IL-4 receptor and suggests a possible new receptor binding mode for G-CSF; it also provides valuable information for guiding structural and mutagenesis studies of signal-transducing proteins and their receptors.     

Aurintricarboxilic acid as a tool for investigating the template-bound and unbound forms of RNA polymerase I in permeabilized cells

Several polypeptide hormones of apparently diverse structure and function have a number of similarities which suggest that there may be common features in their mechanism of action. These hormones are all composed of a single linear sequence of about 30 amino acids; their hydrophobic amino acids are regularly spaced at every third or fourth amino acid residue, allowing them to form amphipathic structures which can interact with phospholipids; a fragment at or near their N-terminus is required for biological activity. These hormones include glucagon, beta-endorphin, parathyroid hormone and calcitonin. A model is proposed in which all regions of the hormone bind to the receptor with comparable affinity except for a small segment which, when intact, triggers a conformational change in the receptor resulting in a further stabilization of the hormone-receptor complex. The activity of partial sequences and chemically modified forms of beta-endorphin, parathyroid hormone and glucagon are discussed in relation to this model.     

The hinge region of human thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) receptor operates as a tunable switch between hormone binding and receptor activation

The mechanism by which the hinge regions of glycoprotein hormone receptors couple hormone binding to activation of downstream effecters is not clearly understood. In the present study, agonistic (311.62) and antagonistic (311.87) monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against the TSH receptor extracellular domain were used to elucidate role of the hinge region in receptor activation. MAb 311.62 which identifies the LRR/Cb-2 junction (aa 265-275), increased the affinity of TSHR for the hormone while concomitantly decreasing its efficacy, whereas MAb 311.87 recognizing LRR 7-9 (aa 201-259) acted as a non-competitive inhibitor of Thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) binding. Binding of MAbs was sensitive to the conformational changes caused by the activating and inactivating mutations and exhibited differential effects on hormone binding and response of these mutants. By studying the effects of these MAbs on truncation and chimeric mutants of thyroid stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR), this study confirms the tethered inverse agonistic role played by the hinge region and maps the interactions between TSHR hinge region and exoloops responsible for maintenance of the receptor in its basal state. Mechanistic studies on the antibody-receptor interactions suggest that MAb 311.87 is an allosteric insurmountable antagonist and inhibits initiation of the hormone induced conformational changes in the hinge region, whereas MAb 311.62 acts as a partial agonist that recognizes a conformational epitope critical for coupling of hormone binding to receptor activation. The hinge region, probably in close proximity with the α-subunit in the hormone-receptor complex, acts as a tunable switch between hormone binding and receptor activation.     

Relationship between the affinity and proteolysis of the insulin receptor. Evidence that higher affinity receptors are preferentially degraded

125I-Insulin binding to rat liver plasma membranes initiated two processes that occurred with similar time courses: an increase of receptor affinity for hormone and degradation of the Mr 135,000 alpha subunit of the insulin receptor to a fragment of Mr 120,000. Inhibitors of serine proteinases prevented alpha subunit degradation without affecting the affinity change. This shows that the change of affinity is not produced by receptor proteolysis and that the intact alpha subunit of the insulin receptor can exist as a higher or lower affinity species. Hormone binding was much more rapid than receptor proteolysis and the initial rate of alpha subunit degradation was independent of the concentration of occupied lower affinity receptors. Only persistent hormone binding and the accumulation of higher affinity insulin-receptor complexes led to significant receptor proteolysis. As the incubation time between 125I-insulin and membranes increased, the rate at which hormone dissociated from Mr 135,000 complexes diminished, whereas hormone dissociated from Mr 120,000 complexes slowly after brief or extended incubations. These observations suggest that 125I-insulin binds to membranes to form low affinity complexes that are not substrates for proteolysis. A slow conformational change produces higher affinity hormone-receptor complexes that are selectively degraded. Thus, the conversion between states of affinity may play a role in the regulation of receptor proteolysis and, consequently, insulin action in cells.     

Glucagon receptors on isolated hepatocytes and hepatocyte membrane vesicles. Discrete populations with ligand- and environment-dependent affinities

Analysis of glucagon and deshistidine glucagon binding to isolated canine hepatocytes and to hepatocyte membrane vesicles (formed by budding of hepatocytes in hypotonic medium) reveals two separate populations of hormone binding sites. Mathematical modeling further shows that the high affinity population represents 1% of the total in all four cases. Although calculated dissociation constants for hormone binding range from 0.2 to 400 nM, whether considering glucagon or deshistidine glucagon binding, or binding to the high affinity or low affinity receptor populations, receptor affinity increases 2- to 100-fold in the environment of the membrane vesicle; concomitant with this alteration in receptor affinity, receptor selectivity for the structure of the native hormone decreases 1.5- to 40-fold in hepatocyte-derived vesicles. Consideration of receptor affinity in relation to receptor number suggests that hepatocyte glucagon binding is distributed about equally between high and low affinity receptor populations at typical portal hormone levels. Nevertheless, consideration of receptor binding in relation to biological activity suggests that the activity of glucagon in inhibiting carbohydrate flux into glycogen is attributable to occupancy of the high affinity receptor population.     

Glucocorticoid-receptor interaction and induction of murine mammary tumor virus.

The relationship between the cellular uptake of glucocorticoid hormones, the binding of these hormones to specific in vitro receptors, and the induction of mouse mammary tumor viruses in an established mouse mammary tumor cell line was highly correlated. These results suggest that the induction of mouse mammary tumor virus by glucocorticoid hormones is a physiological process acting through a mechanism of high affinity, saturable steroid-receptors. A temperature-sensitive or salt-dependent step following glucocorticoid-receptor interaction was required for nuclear uptake of the steroid. Induction studies with different adrenocorticoids indicate that the synthetic glucocorticoid, dexamethasone (1,4-pregnadiene-9-fluor-16alpha-methyl-11beta,17alpha,21-triol-3,20-dione), is the most potent inducer of mouse mammary tumor viruses and all steroids which caused significant induction were glucocorticoids. Other glucocorticoids appear to stimulate murine mammary tumor virus production by a mechanism similar to that of dexamethasone; for example, corticosterone competes with dexamethasone for binding to the glucocorticoid receptor and blocks the uptake of dexamethasone into cells. Progesterone also blocks the cellular uptake of dexamethasone and can bind to the glucocorticoid receptor at low concentrations (10-7 to 10-8 M) but progesterone does not consistently induce virus at hormone concentrations even as high as 10-4 M. Thus, in this system, binding to a cytoplasmic receptor is necessary but not sufficient for induction by glucocorticoids. Estrogens and androgens interfere with receptor binding and cellular uptake of dexamethasone but only at much higher concentration (10-4 M) than progesterone, and do not induce mammary tumor virus production. Although there was a positive correlation between steroid structure, binding, and biologic induction, other factors clearly affect the physiological manifestations of steroid actions. Mouse cells with comparable cytoplasmic receptor levels and comparable nuclear uptake differed absolutely in their degree of murine mammary tumor virus induction following hormone treatment. Although all mouse cells examined contain comparable levels of murine mammary tumor virus DNA, only cells producing constitutive levels of murine mammary tumor virus RNA could be induced to higher levels by a variety of glucocorticoids.