Notochordal stimulation of in vitro somite chondrogenesis before and after enzymatic removal of perinotochordal materials.

In the present investigation, evidence is presented directly implicating proteoglycans produced by the embryonic notochord in the control of somite chondrogenesis. It has been demonstrated by several histochemical techniques that during the period of its interaction with somites, the notochord synthesizes perinotochordal proteoglycans, and these proteoglycans have been shown to contain chondroitin 4-sulfate (40%), chondroitin 6-sulfate (40%), and heparan sulfate (20%). Dissection of notochords from embryos with the aid of a brief treatment with trypsin results in the removal of perinotochordal extracellular matrix materials including proteoglycans, while dissection of notochords without the aid of enzyme treatment or with a low concentration of collagenase results in their retention. There is a considerable increase in the rate and amount of cartilage formation and a corresponding 2 to 3-fold increase in the amount of sulfated glycosaminoglycan accumulated by somites cultured in association with notochords dissected under conditions in which perinotochordal materials are retained. Treatment of collagenase-dissected or freely dissected notochords with highly purified enzymes (chondroitinase ABC, AC, and testicular hyaluronidase) which specifically degrade proteoglycans causes a loss of histochemically detectable perinotochordal proteoglycans. These notochords are considerably impaired in their ability to support in vitro somite chondrogenesis. In addition, when trypsin-treated notochords are cultured (“precultured”) for 24 hr on nutrient agar (in the absence of somites), perinotochordal material reaccumulates. Somites cultured in association with such “precultured” notochords exhibit considerable increase in the amount of cartilage formed and a 2- to 3-fold increase in the amount of sulfated glycosaminoglycan accumulated as compared to somites cultured in association with trypsin-treated notochords which have not been “precultured.” This observation indicates that trypsin-treated notochords reacquire their ability to maximally stimulate in vitro somite chondrogenesis by resynthesizing and accumulating perinotochordal material. Finally, “precultured” notochords treated with chondroitinase to remove perinotochordal proteoglycans are considerably impaired in their ability to support in vitro somite chondrogenesis. These observations are consonant with the concept that proteoglycans produced by the embryonic notochord play an important role in somite chondrogenesis.     

Environmental enhancement of in vitro chondrogenesis. IV. Stimulation of somite chondrogenesis by exogenous chondromucoprotein

Proteoglycan complex extracted from embryonic cartilage (chondromucoprotein) with 4.0 M guanidinium chloride greatly stimulates in vitro somite chondrogenesis. In the presence of exogenous chondromucoprotein (CMP) which consists predominantly of proteochondroitin sulfate, there is a large increase in the amount of differentiating cartilage which can be detected visually in somite explants. There is a 2–3-fold increase in the amount of sulfated glycosaminoglycans (including chondroitin 4- and 6-sulfate) accumulated by somite explants supplied with exogenous CMP complex. These results are of potential significance, since during the period of interaction between the notochord or spinal cord and somitic mesoderm, the notochord and spinal cord synthesize and secrete proteoglycan.     

Somite Chondrogenesis in vitro: Differential Induction by Modified Matrix- a Biochemical and Morphological Study*

The stimulation of somite chondrogenesis by extracellular matrix components was studied by monitering the synthesis of cartilage-specific large proteoglycan aggregates. Chick embryonic sternal proteoglycans were separated into various components: monomers, hyaluronic acid, link protein and glycosaminoglycan side chains. The effects of these components, either individually or in various combinations, on somite chondrogenesis was examined. Proteoglycan monomers, alone or in a mixture with other components, induced chondrogenesis. The other components did not have any stimulating effect of their own. The results of these induction studies were also observed on a Sepharose CL–2B column and correlated using electron microscopy. Stimulation of somites resulted in an increase in the amount of proteoglycan aggregation (material excluded from the column) and was in agreement with the morphological appearance of the matrix in that there was increased accumulation of large proteoglycan granules. A matrix mixture of collagen and proteoglycans showed significant stimulation. When the matrix environment of the somites was altered to be unfavorable to the explants (medium containing hyaluronic acid) there was altered synthesis of cartilage-specific molecules. The results presented in this report strongly suggest that the composition of the extracellular matrix material is critical for somite chondrogenesis.     

Inhibition of "spontaneous," notochord-induced, and collagen-induced in vitro somite chondrogenesis by cyclic AMP derivatives and theophylline.

The present study represents a first step in investigating the possible involvement of cyclic AMP in the stimulation of somite chondrogenesis elicited by extracellular matrix components produced by the embryonic notochord. Dibutyryl cyclic AMP (db-cAMP) at 1.0 mM severely impairs “spontaneous” somite chondrogenesis, i.e., inhibits the formation of the small amount of cartilaginous matrix normally formed by embryonic somites in vitro in the absence of inducing tissues. This inhibition of cartilaginous matrix formation is reflected in a 30–40% reduction in sulfated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) accumulation. 8-Bromo-cyclic AMP also severely inhibits cartilage formation and sulfated GAG accumulation by somite explants. This impairment is limited to cyclic AMP derivatives; dibutyryl cyclic GMP, 5′-AMP, and 2′,3′-AMP have no effect. The inhibitory effect of cyclic AMP derivatives is mimicked by the cyclic AMP-phosphodiesterase inhibitor, theophylline, and potentiated by the addition of both db-cAMP and theophylline. Dibutyryl cyclic AMP and/or theophylline also inhibit the stimulation of cartilaginous matrix formation and sulfated GAG accumulation normally elicited by the embryonic notochord, reducing accumulation to a level similar to that found in somite explants without notochord. The inhibition of chondrogenesis by cyclic AMP in notochord-somite explants appears to result from an inability of somites to respond and not from an effect on the inductive capacity of the notochord, since db-cAMP has no detectable effect on the synthesis of molecules (sulfated GAG and collagen) by the notochord that have been implicated in its inductive activity. Finally, db-cAMP and/or theophylline inhibit the stimulation of somite chondrogenesis normally elicited by purified Type I collagen substrates. Dibutyryl cyclic AMP and theophylline reduce sulfated GAG accumulation by somites cultured on collagen to a level even below that accumulated by somites cultured in the absence of collagen, i.e., on Millipore filters.     

SOMITE CHONDROGENESIS : A Structural Analysis

Light and electron microscopy are used in this study to compare chondrogenesis in cultured somites with vertebral chondrogenesis These studies have also characterized some of the effects of inducer tissues (notochord and spinal cord), and different nutrient media, on chondrogenesis in cultured somites Somites from stage 17 (54–60 h) chick embryos were cultured, with or without inducer tissues, and were fed nutrient medium containing either horse serum (HS) and embryo extract (EE), or fetal calf serum (FCS) and F12X Amino acid analyses were also utilized to determine the collagen content of vertebral body cartilage in which the fibrils are homogeneously thin (ca. 150 Å) and unbanded. These analyses provide strong evidence that the thin unbanded fibrils in embryonic cartilage matrix are collagen. These thin unbanded collagen fibrils, and prominent 200–800 Å protein polysaccharide granules, constitute the structured matrix components of both developing vertebral cartilage and the cartilage formed in cultured somites Similar matrix components accumulate around the inducer tissues notochord and spinal cord. These matrix components are structurally distinct from those in embryonic fibrous tissue The synthesis of matrix by the inducer tissues is associated with the inductive interaction of these tissues with somitic mesenchyme. Due to the deleterious effects of tissue isolation and culture procedures many cells die in somitic mesenchyme during the first 24 h in culture. In spite of this cell death, chondrogenic areas are recognized after 12 h in induced cultures, and through the first 2 days in all cultures there are larger accumulations of structured matrix than are present in equivalently aged somitic mesenchyme in vivo. Surviving chondrogenic areas develop into nodules of hyaline cartilage in all induced cultures, and in most non-induced cultures fed medium containing FCS and F12X There is more cell death, less matrix accumulation, and less cartilage formed in cultures fed medium containing HS and EE. The inducer tissues, as well as nutrient medium containing FCS and F12X, facilitate cell survival, the synthesis and accumulation of cartilage matrix, and the formation of cartilage nodules in cultured somites.     

Inhibition of "spontaneous," notochord-induced, and collagen-induced in vitro somite chondrogenesis by the calcium lonophore, A23187.

The present study represents a first step in investigating the possible involvement of calcium (Ca2+) in the stimulation of somite chondrogenesis elicited by extracellular matrix components produced by the embryonic notochord. The ionophore, A23187, a drug that facilitates Ca2+ uptake leading to elevation of cytoplasmic Ca2+ levels, at concentrations of 0.25-1.0 microgram/ml severely impairs "spontaneous" somite chondrogenesis, i.e., inhibits the formation of the small amount of cartilaginous matrix normally formed by embryonic somites in vitro in the absence of inducing tissues. This inhibition is reflected in a considerable reduction in sulfated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) accumulation by A23187-treated somite explants. Furthermore, A23187 inhibits the striking stimulation of cartilaginous matrix formation and sulfated GAG accumulation normally elicited by the embryonic notochord and collagen substrates. In fact, 1.0 microgram/ml of A23187 reduces sulfated GAG accumulation by somites cultured in association with notochord or on collagen to a level even below that accumulated by somites cultured in the absence of these inductive agents. Although these results must be interpreted with caution, they provide incentive for considering a possible regulatory role for Ca2+ in the chondrogenic response of somites to extracellular matrix components produced by the embryonic notochord.     

Somite chondrogenesis in vitro: 2. Changes in the hyaluronic acid synthesis

The role of hyaluronic acid in limb morphogenesis (chondrogenesis) has been well defined. In the present study, we found that hyaluronic acid synthesis in somite explants steadily increased until day 6, then decreased, and inclusion of notochord did not accelerate the rate of synthesis. Analysis of hyaluronidase activity in the somite explants indicated an increase in the enzyme level in day-6 cultures. Again, inclusion of notochord did not alter this pattern. The decrease in hyaluronic acid after day 6 and the increase in sulfated proteoglycan synthesis from day 6 resemble the pattern described during limb development. Subsequent studies showed that, with time, the size of the hyaluronic acid synthesized by somites increased and, again, inclusion of notochord did not influence this pattern. The results indicate that unstimulated somites are capable of synthesizing cartilage-specific proteoglycans in a relatively restricted manner, and the inclusion of notochord resulted in accelerated synthesis of stable proteoglycan aggregates typical of differentiated chondrocytes. Metabolic events in somites related to hyaluronic acid are not influenced by the notochord.     

Analysis of perinotochordal materials. I. Studies on proteoglycans synthesis

Perinotochordal proteoglycans have been shown to influence somite chondrogenic differentiation. However, information concerning the composition of the proteoglycan molecules synthesized by the notochord, or the exact type of molecule necessary for the induction of somite chondrogenesis is not known. The results of the present study indicate that the proteoglycan extracted from the 8 day old notochord culture consists of predominantly small proteoglycans, while the large aggregates form less than 30% of the total. The chondroitin sulfate composition also shows a cartilage type of proteoglycan molecules synthesized by the notochord.     

Ultrastructural aspects of the production of extracellular matrix components by the chick embryonic notochord in vitro

The morphology of extracellular matrix (ECM) components and of the cell organelles, particularly the Golgi complex and its derived structures, implicated in the production of ECM in the chick embryonic notochord have been studied by transmission electron microscopy. Isolated notochordal fragments were cultured in suspension in liquid medium. Native striated collagen fibrils with a period of 540 A were observed in the perinotochordal sheath. Fine granular and filamentous materials suggestive of proteoglycans have been observed in intercellular spaces and under the basal lamina of the notochordal sheath. Golgi mature vesicles with structures resembling the previously described segment-long-spacing (SLS)-like aggregates and secretory vesicles probably containing proteoglycans or condensed collagen precursors have also been observed.     

In vitro chondrogenesis and cell viability

Anterior somites cultured with (NSA) or without (SA) notochord, and posterior somites cultured with (NSP) or without notochord (SP) were compared with respect to changes in their DNA content, their potential to synthesize the active sulfate principle phosphoadenosine phosphosulfate (PAPS), and their ability to accumulate ³⁵S-sulfate.Chondrogenesis was observed in the NSA, NSP, and SP explants, but was rarely noted in the SA explants. A decrease in DNA content during the initial 48 hr of culture was common to all explants. After this initial decrease, DNA content increased most in those explants forming cartilage. The synthesis of PAPS by cell-free extracts of each type of somite explant also decreased during the initial period of culture. Only extracts of those explants undergoing chondrogenesis showed increases in PAPS synthesis with continued culture. Each type of somite explant accumulated ³⁵S-sulfate into chondroitin sulfate during the first hours of culture. The non-chondrogenic SA explants accumulated little ³⁵S-sulfate during the period of culture. At varying times after 24 hr the chondrifying explants (NSA, SP, and NSP) initiated an increased rate of accumulation of ³⁵S-sulfate.Cartilage nodules, increases in DNA content, PAPS synthesis and ³⁵S-sulfate accumulation occurred within the same 24 hr period, during the 2nd day in NSP explants, the 3rd day in NSA explants, and between the 3rd and 4th day for SP explants. A hypothesis of in vitro somite chondrogenesis based on differential cell viability is presented.     

Morphogenesis of sclerotome and neural crest in avian embryos

Summary The distribution of sclerotome and neural crest cells of avian embryos was studied by light and electron microscopy. Sclerotome cells radiated from the somites towards the notochord, to occupy the perichordal space. Neural crest cells, at least initially, also entered cell-free spaces. At the cranial somitic levels they moved chiefly dorsal to the somites, favouring the rostral part of each somite. These cells did not approach the perichordal space. More caudally (i.e. trunk levels), neural crest cells initially moved ventrally between the somites and neural tube. Adjacent to the caudal half of each somite, these cells penetrated no further than the myosclerotomal border, but opposite the rostral somite half, they were found next to the sclerotome almost as far ventrally as the notochord. However, they did not appear to enter the perichordal space, in contrast to sclerotome cells.When tested in vitro, sclerotome cells migrated towards notochords co-cultured on fibronectin-rich extracellular material, and on collagen gels. In contrast, neural crest cells avoided co-cultured notochords. This avoidance was abolished by inclusion of testicular hyaluronidase and chondroitinase ABC in the culture medium, but not by hyaluronidase from Streptomyces hyalurolyticus. The results suggest that sclerotome and neural crest mesenchyme cells have a different distribution with respect to the notochord, and that differential responses to notochordal extracellular material, possibly chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan, may be responsible for this.     

Ultrastructure of the rostral notochord of the 35-day rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta) embryo

The notochords of three normal, 35-day Macaca mulatta embryos were examined ultrastructurally. Notochordal cells had numerous polysomes and ribosomes, and some rough endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria, Golgi complexes, coated vesicles, and secretory granules. A discontinuous basal lamina surrounded the notochord. Intercellular channels and the perinotochordal sheath contained fibrils. It was found that the ultrastructure of the rhesus monkey notochord at stage 17 resembles that of the chick and mouse.     

Forskolin- and dibutyryl cyclic AMP-mediated inhibition of chondrogenesis

The regulatory role of cyclic AMP in various cellular activities is well known. It has been documented that both the notochord and extracellular matrix materials (ECM) induce somite chrondrogenesis. We believe that the ECM modulates the intracellular cAMP level during chondrogenic differentiation. The studies indicated that notochordal induction, which resulted in somite chondrogenesis (reflected by increased sulfated glycosaminoglycan synthesis) reduced the intracellular cAMP level in somites. Addition of forskolin and dibutyryl cAMP resulted in increased intracellular cAMP levels and decreased synthesis of sulfated glycosaminoglycans (decreased chondrogenesis). In the case of dibutyryl cAMP, the inhibition of sulfated glycosaminoglycan synthesis was related to the length of exposure time. Thus, the inverse relationship between cAMP content and enhanced chondrogenesis supports the theory that, in somites, a decrease in the intracellular cAMP level may be necessary to trigger chondrogenic differentiation.     

Nonuniformity within Embryonic Somites: Differental Response to Retinoic Acid in Vitro

Recent studies have shown that in the developing chick embryo, at physiological level retinoic acid (RA) causes mirror-image duplication of limb skeletal elements. This has led to the suggestion that RA could be the endogenous morphogen or isgnal substance. In this study, in order to explore the effect of RA on somite chondrogenesis, we have standardized a serum-free chemically defined medium that supports the growth of somite explants in vitro. The results indicate that in somites RA at 10 ng/ml level induces cell proliferation, DNA and sulfated proteoglycan synthesis, and at higher concentrations is toxic. The results further show that RA induced stimulation of somite chondrogenesis is sclerotomal specific and the dermamyotemal portion of the somites does not exihibit a similar response. Retinoic acid also increases heparan sulfate synthesis and aggregation of isolated sclerotomal cells in culture. These results thus suggest that in amplifying chondrogenesis, RA acts at all phases such as cell proliferation (may increase cell viability) and aggregation, increased DNA synthesis and increased synthesis of matrix components. In otherwords, RA seems to initiate a chain of inter-related events.     

Epaxial-adaxial-hypaxial regionalisation of the vertebrate somite: evidence for a somitic organiser and a mirror-image duplication

During vertebrate neural tube formation, the initially lateral borders between the neural and epidermal ectoderm fuse to form the definitive dorsal region of the embryo, while the initially dorsally located notochord-floor plate complex is being internalised. Along the definitive dorso-ventral body axis, one can distinguish an epaxial (dorsal to the notochord) and a hypaxial (ventral to the notochord) body region. The mesodermal somites on both sides of the notochord and neural tube give rise to the trunk skeleton and skeletal muscle. Muscle forms from the somite-derived dermomyotomes and myotomes that elongate dorsally and ventrally. Based on gene expression patterns and comparative embryology, it is proposed here that the epaxial (dermo)myotome region in amniote embryos is subdivided into a dorsalmost and a centrally intercalated subregion. The intercalated subregion abuts to the hypaxial (dermo)myotome region that elongates ventrally via the hypaxial somitic bud. The dorsalmost subregion elongates towards the dorsal neural tube and is proposed to derive from an epaxial somitic bud. The dorsalmost and hypaxial somite derivatives share specific gene expression patterns which are distinct from those of the intercalated somite derivatives. The intercalated somite derivatives develop adaxially, i.e. at the level of the notochord-floor plate complex. Thus, the dorsalmost and intercalated (dermo)myotome subregions may be influenced preferentially by signals from the dorsal neural tube and from the notochord-floor plate complex, respectively. These (dermo)myotome subregions are sharply delimited from each other by molecular boundary markers, including Engrailed and Wnts. It thus appears that the molecular network that polarises borders in Drosophila and vertebrate embryogenesis is redeployed during subregionalisation of the (dermo)myotome. It is proposed here that cells within the amniote (dermo)myotome establish polarised borders with organising capacity, and that the epaxial somitic bud represents a mirror-image duplication of the hypaxial somitic bud along such a border. The resulting epaxial-intercalated/adaxial-hypaxial regionalisation of somite derivatives is conserved in vertebrates although the differentiation of sclerotome and myotome starts heterochronically in embryos of different vertebrate groups.     

Establishment of clonal cell lines of hamster chondrocytes maintaining their phenotypic traits

Chondrogenic cells from hamster sternal cartilage were obtained as established cell lines, and have maintained the phenotypic traits of chondrocytes for about one year. In mass cultures, their extracellular matrix, staining metachromatically with toluidine blue, increased markedly in the confluent state. This extracellular material was confirmed to be cartilage matrix containing chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan, by digestion with various enzymes. In clonal cell cultures, the chondrocytes grew to form well differentiated colonies, and chondrogenesis in vitro in the central regions of the colonies was easily recognized under a phase-contrast microscope. This chondrogenesis in vitro was examined by light microscopy, and scanning and transmission electron microscopy.     

Somite chondrogenesis: alterations in cyclic AMP levels and proteoglycan synthesis

Cyclic AMP (cAMP) levels have been shown to have a positive influence on chondrogenesis in limb buds and pelvic cartilage. In the present study the level of cAMP was measured during somite chondrogenesis in vitro and found to decrease from 1.38 pmol/micrograms DNA on day 0 to 0.9 pmol/micrograms DNA on day 6. Inclusion of notochord with somites caused a marked reduction, with levels decreasing from 1.41 pmol/micrograms DNA on day 0 to 0.36 pmol/micrograms DNA on day 6. Concurrently, the incorporation of radioactive sulfate into sulfated glycosaminoglycans increased from day 3 to day 6 by 38% in somite and 77% in somite-notochord explants. The aggregation of proteoglycans was analyzed by gel chromatography and found to increase with a corresponding decrease in cAMP levels. The results indicate that a decrease in cAMP levels may be necessary for chondrogenic expression in somites.     

Low temperature scanning electron microscopy of the superficial envelope of canine chondrocytes in culture

Low temperature scanning electron microscopy (LTSEM) has been employed to examine the surface morphology of chondrocyte cultures on ceramic granules. Well-established cultures on porous hydroxyapatite consist of ceramic cores overlaid and interspersed with a cellular matrix of collagen and proteoglycan (Cheung, 1985); of especial interest is the superficial layer of cells. These cells are believed, on the basis of immuno-light microscopy (Gardner et al., 1987), to be coated by an hydrated porous envelope of collagen/proteoglycan which is likely to obscure cell outlines. This relationship is confirmed by enzymic digestion of the superficial material. Post-digestion LTSEM examination of the fully hydrated preparations establishes the existence of arrays of rounded structures identified as superficial cells.     

Abnormal development of the notochord and perinotochordal sheath in duplicitas posterior, patch and tail-short mice

Interest in developmental interactions involving the notochord and perinotochordal sheath led to a comparative investigation of these structures in three mouse mutants. Alcian blue or periodic acid-Schiff staining of 9 1/2-13 days' gestational age embryos revealed a supernumerary notochordal-like mass of cells or a deflected notochord in association with duplication of the neural tube in mice of the duplicitas posterior stock. The perinotochordal sheath and basement membrane of the accessory notochordal masses were frequently defective. Patch and Tail-short embryos were also utilized for study by means of light microscopy using Alcian blue staining. In Patch embryos, although the notochord was sometimes compressed dorso-ventrally, it had an intact perinotochordal sheath and a defined, but undulated, basement membrane. Mesenchymal cells between the notochord and neural tube were occasionally replaced by cell-free space. In contrast, in Tail-short embryos a poorly formed, lightly staining or totally absent notochordal sheath was revealed. Indeed, it was sometimes difficult to distinguish the notochord from surrounding mesenchymal cells. In both the Patch and Tail-short embryos the notochord was also deflected from its medial position. In the three mutants studied, the direct or indirect effect of gene action appeared to be on the notochord and perinotochordal sheath, and the important role of these structures in abnormal axial development was established.     

Cell intercalation during notochord development in Xenopus laevis

Morphometric data from scanning electron micrographs (SEM) of cells in intact embryos and high-resolution time-lapse recordings of cell behavior in cultured explants were used to analyze the cellular events underlying the morphogenesis of the notochord during gastrulation and neurulation of Xenopus laevis. The notochord becomes longer, narrower, and thicker as it changes its shape and arrangement and as more cells are added at the posterior end. The events of notochord development fall into three phases. In the first phase, occurring in the late gastrula, the cells of the notochord become distinct from those of the somitic mesoderm on either side. Boundaries form between the two tissues, as motile activity at the boundary is replaced by stabilizing lamelliform protrusions in the plane of the boundary. In the second phase, spanning the late gastrula and early neurula, cell intercalation causes the notochord to narrow, thicken, and lengthen. Its cells elongate and align mediolaterally as they rearrange. Both protrusive activity and its effectiveness are biased: the anterioposterior (AP) margins of the cells advance and retract but produce much less translocation than the more active left and right ends. The cell surfaces composing the lateral boundaries of the notochord remain inactive. In the last phase, lasting from the mid- to late neurula stage, the increasingly flattened cells spread at all their interior margins, transforming the notochord into a cylindrical structure resembling a stack of pizza slices. The notochord is also lengthened by the addition of cells to its posterior end from the circumblastoporal ring of mesoderm. Our results show that directional cell movements underlie cell intercalation and raise specific questions about the cell polarity, contact behavior, and mechanics underlying these movements. They also demonstrate that the notochord is built by several distinct but carefully coordinated processes, each working within a well-defined geometric and mechanical environment.