Revealing the amino acid composition of proteins within an expanded genetic code

The genetic code can be manipulated to reassign codons for the incorporation of non-standard amino acids (NSAA). Deletion of release factor 1 in Escherichia coli enhances translation of UAG (Stop) codons, yet may also extended protein synthesis at natural UAG terminated messenger RNAs. The fidelity of protein synthesis at reassigned UAG codons and the purity of the NSAA containing proteins produced require careful examination. Proteomics would be an ideal tool for these tasks, but conventional proteomic analyses cannot readily identify the extended proteins and accurately discover multiple amino acid (AA) insertions at a single UAG. To address these challenges, we created a new proteomic workflow that enabled the detection of UAG readthrough in native proteins in E. coli strains in which UAG was reassigned to encode phosphoserine. The method also enabled quantitation of NSAA and natural AA incorporation at UAG in a recombinant reporter protein. As a proof-of-principle, we measured the fidelity and purity of the phosphoserine orthogonal translation system (OTS) and used this information to improve its performance. Our results show a surprising diversity of natural AAs at reassigned stop codons. Our method can be used to improve OTSs and to quantify amino acid purity at reassigned codons in organisms with expanded genetic codes.     

In vitro selection of RNA aptamer against Escherichia coli release factor 1

A pool of 84-nt RNAs containing a randomized sequence of 50 nt was selected against gel-immobilized Escherichia coli release factor 1 (RF-1) responsible for translation termination at amber (UAG) stop codon. The strongest aptamer (class II-1) obtained from 43 clones bound to RF-1, but not to UAA/UGA-targeting RF-2, with Kd = 30+/-6 nM (SPR). A couple of unpaired hairpin domains in the aptamer were suggested as the sites of attachment of RF-1. By binding to and hence inhibiting the action of RF-1 specifically or bio-orthogonally, aptamer class II-1 enhanced the amber suppression efficiency in the presence of an anticodon-adjusted (CUA) suppressor tRNA without practically damaging the protein translation machinery of the cell-free extract of E. coli, as confirmed by the translation of amber-mutated (gfp(amber141) or gfp(amber178)) and wild-type (gfp(wild)) genes of GFP.     

Termination of protein synthesis

One of three mRNA codons — UAA, UAG and UGA — is used to signal to the elongating ribosome that translation should be terminated at this point. Upon the arrival of the stop codon at the ribosomal acceptor(A)-site, a protein release factor (RF) binds to the ribosome resulting in the peptidyl transferase centre of the ribosome switching to a hydrolytic function to remove the completed polypeptide chain from the peptidyl-tRNA bound at the adjacent ribosomal peptidyl(P)-site. In this review recent advances in our understanding of the mechanism of termination in the bacteriumEscherichia coli will be summarised, paying particular attention to the roles of 16S ribosomal RNA and the release factors RF-1, RF-2 and RF-3 in stop codon recognition. Our understanding of the translation termination process in eukaryotes is much more rudimentary with the identity of the single eukaryotic release factor (eRF) still remaining elusive. Finally, several examples of how the termination mechanism can be subverted either to expand the genetic code (e.g. selenocysteine insertion at UGA codons) or to regulate the expression of mammalian retroviral or plant viral genomes will be discussed.     

Translation termination in pyrrolysine-utilizing archaea

Although some data link archaeal and eukaryotic translation, the overall mechanism of protein synthesis in archaea remains largely obscure. Both archaeal (aRF1) and eukaryotic (eRF1) single release factors recognize all three stop codons. The archaeal genus Methanosarcinaceae contains two aRF1 homologs, and also uses the UAG stop to encode the 22nd amino acid, pyrrolysine. Here we provide an analysis of the last stage of archaeal translation in pyrrolysine-utilizing species. We demonstrated that only one of two Methanosarcina barkeri aRF1 homologs possesses activity and recognizes all three stop codons. The second aRF1 homolog may have another unknown function. The mechanism of pyrrolysine incorporation in the Methanosarcinaceae is discussed.     

Lack of peptide-release activity responding to codon UGA in Mycoplasma capricolum.

In Mycoplasma capricolum, a relative of Gram-positive eubacteria with a high genomic AT-content (75%), codon UGA is assigned to tryptophan instead of termination signal. Thus, in this bacterium the release factor 2 (RF-2), that recognizes UAA and UGA termination codons in eubacteria such as Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis, would be either specific to UAA or deleted. To test this, we have constructed a cell-free translation system using synthetic mRNA including codon UAA [mRNA(UAA)], UAG [mRNA(UAG)] and UGA [mRNA(UGA)] in-frame. In the absence of tryptophan, the translation of mRNA(UGA) ceased at UGA sites without appreciable release of the synthesized peptides from the ribosomes, whereas with mRNA(UAA) or mRNA(UAG) the bulk of the peptides was released. Upon addition of the E.coli S-100 fraction or B.subtilis S-100 fraction to the translation system, the synthesized peptides with mRNA(UGA) were almost completely released from the ribosomes, presumably because of the presence of RF-2 active to UGA in the added S-100 fraction. These data suggest that RF-2 is deleted or its activity to UGA is strongly weakened in M.capricolum.     

Processive Selenocysteine Incorporation during Synthesis of Eukaryotic Selenoproteins

Selenoproteins are a family of proteins that share the common feature of containing selenocysteine, the “twenty-first” amino acid. Selenocysteine incorporation occurs during translation of selenoprotein messages by redefinition of UGA codons, which normally specify termination of translation. Studies of the eukaryotic selenocysteine incorporation mechanism suggest that selenocysteine insertion is inefficient compared with termination. Nevertheless, selenoprotein P and several other selenoproteins are known to contain multiple selenocysteines. The production of full-length (FL) protein from these messages would seem to demand highly efficient selenocysteine incorporation due to the compounding effect of termination at each UGA codon. We present data demonstrating that efficient incorporation of multiple selenocysteines can be reconstituted in rabbit reticulocyte lysate translation reactions. Selenocysteine incorporation at the first UGA codon is inefficient but increases by approximately 10-fold at subsequent downstream UGA codons. We found that ribosomes in the “processive” phase of selenocysteine incorporation (i.e., after decoding the first UGA codon as selenocysteine) are fully competent to terminate translation at UAG and UAA codons, that ribosomes become less efficient at selenocysteine incorporation as the distance between UGA codons is increased, and that efficient selenocysteine incorporation is not dependent on cis-acting elements unique to selenoprotein P. Furthermore, we found that the percentage of ribosomes decoding a UGA codon as selenocysteine rather than termination can be increased by 3- to 5-fold by placing the murine leukemia virus UAG read-through element upstream of the first UGA codon or by providing a competing messenger RNA in trans. The mechanisms of selenocysteine incorporation and selenoprotein synthesis are discussed in light of these results.     

Use of tRNA suppressors to probe regulation of Escherichia coli release factor 2

It has been suggested that Escherichia coli release factor 2 (RF-2) translation is autoregulated. Mature RF-2 protein can terminate its own nascent synthesis at an intragenic, in-phase UGA codon, or alternatively, a +1 frameshift can occur that leads to completion of the RF-2 polypeptide. Translational termination presumably increases with RF-2 concentration, providing negative regulatory feedback. We now show, in lacZ/RF-2 fusions, that translation of a UAG codon at the position of the UGA competes with frameshifting, which proves one postulate of the translational autoregulatory model. We also identify a nearby sequence that is required for high-frequency frameshifting and suggest a constraint for the codon preceding the shift point. Both these sequences are incorporated into a model for frameshifting. Our measurements allow us to compute the relative rates in vivo of these reactions: release factor action, frameshifting and tRNA selection at an amber codon.     

Reduced action of polypeptide release factors induces mRNA cleavage and tmRNA tagging at stop codons in Escherichia coli

Certain C-terminal sequences of nascent peptide cause an efficient protein tagging by tmRNA system at stop codons in Escherichia coli. Here, we demonstrate that both mRNA cleavage and tmRNA tagging occur at UAG stop codon recognized specifically by polypeptide release factor 1 (RF-1) when the activity of RF-1 is reduced by a mutation in the prfA gene without requirement of particular C-terminal sequences of nascent peptide. The tmRNA tagging and mRNA cleavage in the prfA mutant were eliminated when the wild-type RF-1 but not RF-2 was supplied from plasmid. In addition, depletion of either RF-1 or RF-2 induces endonucleolytic cleavage and tmRNA tagging at UAG or UGA stop codons respectively. We conclude that ribosome stalling at the cognate stop codon caused by reduced activity or expression of RF-1 or RF-2 is responsible for mRNA cleavage. The present data along with our previous studies strongly suggest that ribosome stalling leads to endonucleolytic cleavage of mRNA in general resulting in non-stop mRNA and that the 3' end of non-stop mRNA is probably only target for the tmRNA system.     

On the role of the termination factor RF-2 and the 16S RNA in protein synthesis

In the translational termination step of protein synthesis the three termination codons UAA, UAG or UGA are recognized by so-called release or termination factors. The release factor RF-1 interacts with UAG and UAA whereas RF-2 is specific for UGA and UAA. Two mechanisms concerning the termination event have been discussed so far: recognition of the termination codon by the protein in a tRNA-like manner or double-strand formation between the codon and the 3' end of the 16S rRNA which is stabilized by the termination factor. Using equilibrium dialysis we show that 40% of the ribosomes can bind UGAA in an RF-2-dependent manner. The stability with the correct combination RF-2-UGA is tenfold higher as compared to the wrong termination codon UAG. We confirm prior findings that the termination factor RF-2 is bound to the A-site of the ribosome. In addition to the ribosomal proteins L2, L10, L7/L12 and L20 of the large subunit and S6 and S18 of the small subunit, the 16S rRNA became labelled when radioactive UGA was crosslinked to the ribosome in the presence of RF-2. Our data support a mechanism of termination in which a double strand between the termination codon and the 3' end of the 16S rRNA is formed as the starting event. The resulting RNA-RNA double strand in turn may be recognized and stabilized by the termination factor.     

ArfA Recruits RF2 into Stalled Ribosomes

During translation in Escherichia coli, the ribosome rescue factor YaeJ and the alternative ribosome rescue factor (ArfA, previously called YhdL) can release stalled ribosomes from mRNA. Here, I used a reconstituted cell-free protein synthesis system to examine YaeJ- and ArfA-dependent recycling of stalled ribosomes, in which mRNA lacks in-frame stop codons. It is shown that YaeJ alone could recycle the ribosome but that ArfA required the presence of release factor 2 (RF2). Furthermore, I show that RF2 binds to stalled ribosomes only in the presence of ArfA, demonstrating that ArfA recruits RF2 into the A site of the ribosome to facilitate peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. It is also demonstrated that the efficiency of the ArfA-dependent process decreases rapidly with an increase in mRNA length downstream of the A site of the ribosome whereas YaeJ function is maintained on mRNA with sufficient length. From the results, I discuss differences of in vivo roles of these two systems in addition to the well-known tmRNA-dependent trans-translation system.     

Specificity of Pyrrolysyl-tRNA Synthetase for Pyrrolysine and Pyrrolysine Analogs

Pyrrolysine, the 22nd amino acid, is encoded by amber (TAG = UAG) codons in certain methanogenic archaea and bacteria. PylS, the pyrrolysyl-tRNA synthetase, ligates pyrrolysine to tRNA^Pyl for amber decoding as pyrrolysine. PylS and tRNA^Pyl have potential utility in making tailored recombinant proteins. Here, we probed interactions necessary for recognition of substrates by archaeal PylS via synthesis of close pyrrolysine analogs and testing their reactivity in amino acid activation assays. Replacement of the methylpyrroline ring of pyrrolysine with cyclopentane indicated that solely hydrophobic interactions with the ring-binding pocket of PylS are sufficient for substrate recognition. However, a 100-fold increase in the specificity constant of PylS was observed with an analog, 2-amino-6-((R)-tetrahydrofuran-2-carboxamido)hexanoic acid (2Thf-lys), in which tetrahydrofuran replaced the pyrrolysine methylpyrroline ring. Other analogs in which the electronegative atom was moved to different positions suggested PylS preference for a hydrogen-bond-accepting group at the imine nitrogen position in pyrrolysine. 2Thf-lys was a preferred substrate over a commonly employed pyrrolysine analog, but the specificity constant for 2Thf-lys was 10-fold lower than for pyrrolysine itself, largely due to the change in K_m. The in vivo activity of the analogs in supporting UAG suppression in Escherichia coli bearing genes for PylS and tRNA^Pyl was similar to in vitro results, with l-pyrrolysine and 2Thf-lys supporting the highest amounts of UAG translation. Increasing concentrations of either PylS substrate resulted in a linear increase in UAG suppression, providing a facile method to assay bioactive pyrrolysine analogs. These results illustrate the relative importance of the H-bonding and hydrophobic interactions in the recognition of the methylpyrroline ring of pyrrolysine and provide a promising new series of easily synthesized pyrrolysine analogs that can serve as scaffolds for the introduction of novel functional groups into recombinant proteins.     

Requirement for ribosome-releasing factor for the release of ribosomes at the termination codon.

With the use of 3H-labeled R 17 amB2 phage RNA having an UAG codon at the seventh triplet of the coat cistron, release of the RNA from ribosomes at the termination codon was studied. The ribosome-releasing factor previously described was shown to stimulate the process of mRNA release at the termination factor (RF-1). GTP was required for this process and guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-methylene)triphosphate could not replace GTP. No apparent change of size of R 17 RNA was observed during the release of the R 17 RNA from the ribosomes. The ribosome-releasing factor is distinct from the known termination codon-specific factor such as RF-1.     

Priority of light/dark entrainment over temperature in setting the circadian rhythms of the prokaryote Synechococcus RF-1

Light/dark (L/D) and temperature are two major factors in the entrainment of circadian rhythms. The input pathways of these two environmental factors for the entrainment of circadian rhythms in Synechococcus RF-1 are different since the overt rhythms in mutant CR-1, one of the circadian-rhythm mutants of Synechococcus RF-1, could be established by temperature cycles but not by L/D. Therefore, it was of interest to investigate the phases of Synechococcus RF-1 cells entrained simultaneously by L/D and temperature. The circadian rhythms of nitrogenase activity and protein synthesis in RF-1 cells entrained by L/D, and by lowered or raised temperatures differed in their peaks of activity. Comparison of the phases of RF-1 cells entrained by L/D and temperature independently, and by L/D and temperature simultaneously indicated that L/D entrainment has priority over the temperature effect. Received: 8 February 1999 / Accepted: 1 April 1999     

Cloning of the Mycoplasma capricolum gene encoding peptide-chain release factor

In Mycoplasma capricolum (Mc), a relative of Gram⁺ eubacteria with a high genomic A+T-content, the UGA codon is assigned to Trp instead of being a stop codon. We previously showed the lack of peptide-chain release factor (RF) activity in vitro responding to the UGA codon in this bacterium [Inagaki et al., Nucleic Acids Res. 21 (1993) 1335–1338]. To obtain more information on the translation termination mechanism of Mc, we isolated and sequenced the gene encoding RF. The deduced amino-acid sequence has no RF-2-specific + 1 frameshift site and shows 50 and 36% identity to Escherichia coli RF-1 and RF-2, respectively. We conclude that this gene encodes the putative RF-1 which would possess the conserved ‘five-domain’ structure of RF family found in various organisms     

Frameshifting at the internal stop codon within the mRNA for bacterial release factor-2 on eukaryotic ribosomes

A translational frameshift is necessary in the synthesis of Escherichia coli release factor 2 (RF-2) to bypass an in-frame termination codon within the coding sequence. High-efficiency frameshifting around this codon can occur on eukaryotic ribosomes as well as prokaryotic ribosomes. This was determined from the relative efficiency of translation of RF-2 RNA compared with that for the other release factor RF-1, which lacks the in-frame premature stop codon. Since the termination product is unstable an absolute measure of the efficiency of frameshifting has not been possible. A gene fusion between trpE and RF-2 was carried out to give a stable termination product as well as the frameshift product, thereby allowing a direct determination of frameshifting efficiency. The extension of RF-2 RNA near its start codon with a fragment of the trpE gene, while still allowing high efficiency frameshifting on prokaryotic ribosomes, surprisingly gives a different estimate of frameshifting on the eukaryotic ribosomes than that obtained with RF-2 RNA alone. This paradox may be explained by long distance context effects on translation rates in the frameshift region created by the trpE sequences in the gene fusion, and may reflect that pausing and translation rate are fundamental factors in determining the efficiency of frameshifting.     

How does <Emphasis Type="Italic">Euplotes</Emphasis> translation termination factor eRF1 fail to recognize the UGA stop codon?

Class 1 eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1) recognizes all three stop codons (UAA, UAG, and UGA) in standard-code organisms. In some ciliates with variant genetic codes, one or two stop codons are used to encode amino acids and are not recognized by eRF1; e.g., UAA and UAG are reassigned to Gln in Stylonychia and UGA is reassigned to Cys in Euplotes. Stop codon recognition is due to the N-terminal domain of eRF1 in standard-code organisms. Since variant-code ciliates most likely originate from universal-code ancestors, the N-domain sequence of their eRF1 was assumed to harbor the residues that are responsible for the changes in stop codon recognition specificity. To identify the N-domain regions determining the UGA-only specificity of Euplotes aediculatus eRF1, chimeric proteins were constructed by swapping various N-domain fragments of the E. aediculatus for their human counterparts; the MC domain was from human eRF1. Functional analysis of the chimeric eRF1 in vivo revealed two regions (residues 38–50 and 123–145) restricting the E. aediculatus eRF1 specificity to UAR. The change in stop codon recognition specificity of eRF1 was regarded as the first step in the origin of the variant genetic code in ciliates.