Mutation probe of gene structure in E. coli: suppressor mutations in the seven-tRNA operon

Summary Cells defective in uracil-DNA glycosylase (ung:: Tn10) were used in two ways to reveal differences in select point mutations (GC to AT transitions) within the seven-tRNA operon of E. coli. The mutations were indicated as de novo or converted glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations in the genes glnU and/or glnV: (1) the kinetics of photoenzymatic monomerization of pyrimidine dimers quantitated by ung-dependent UV mutagenesis indicated more rapid repair of dimers at sites for converted suppressor mutation than of dimers at sites for de novo suppressor mutation, and (2) spontaneous deamination of cytosine was considerably more frequent at sites for converted suppressor mutation than at sites for de novo suppressor mutation. To explain these results we suggest the physical structure of the DNA in vivo is different at different sites in the seven-tRNA operon. The non-transcribed strand including specifically the anticodon region of the site for converted suppressor mutation may frequently be looped out in a single strand so that a T=C dimer is more accessible to DNA photolyase or a free cytosine residue of non-irradiated DNA is in an aqueous environment conducive to deamination. In addition, we analysed the spontaneous de novo suppressor mutation data to determine an estimate for the in vivo rate of cytosine deamination in double strand DNA of 3.2×10¹³/sec.     

Loss of photoreversibility for UV mutation in E. coli using 405 nm or near-UV challenge

E. coli mutagenized with germicidal ultraviolet light (UV) were incubated to allow for development of mutation-fixation processes. Fixation was estimated from the effects on mutation frequency of photoreactivation challenge during the first 60 min post-UV. Two different light sources were used for photoreactivation, one providing effective light primarily at 405 nm and another providing a broad range of near-UV around 365 nm. Kinetics for the loss of photoreversibility (LOP) were determined. The times for completion of LOP in wild-type cells indicated one fixation process for back mutation and another for de novo or converted suppressor mutation regardless of the light source. Using 405-nm light for photoreactivation, the LOP kinetics for back mutation and de novo suppressor mutation in uvrA cells were similar. Hence, classical observations were confirmed here. Immediately post-UV all mutation frequencies were more sensitive to near-UV than 405-nm light. Experiments with rel cells supported the idea that growth delay and inhibition of induced lexA-coordinated responses may be responsible for this early, pronounced sensitivity to photoreactivation by near UV. For back mutation and de novo suppressor mutation, the sensitivity to 405-nm light was initially small and actually increased for 10-15 min. Possibly genome conformation changes are induced by UV and this affects the efficiency of photoenzymatic monomerization of 405-nm light during the first 10-15 min after irradiation.     

Thermal resistance of UV-mutagenesis to photoreactivation in E. coli B/r uvrA ung: estimate of activation energy and further analysis

Summary Ultraviolet light (UV) induced mutations in the glnU and glnV ^utRNA genes in Escherichia coli are thought to be targeted by UV photoproducts. In a previous study with a uracil-DNA glycosylase deficient strain, UV-induced glnU ^oand glnV ^otRNA suppressor mutations became resistant to photoreactivation (PR) following thermal treatment. It was proposed that deamination of cytosine in the cytosine-containing cyclobutyl dimers at the sites of these suppressor mutations produced uracil residues in sequence upon PR. In the absence of glycosylase, the C U conversion yielded the requisite G:C A:T transitions. In the present study, this thermal resistance of UV-mutagenesis to PR is characterized. It is dependent on the initial UV-fluence and temperature of holding but not on the UmuC⁺ gene product. The data obtained yield an estimate of an activation energy of 17±3 kcal/mol for the deamination of cytosines contained in dimers. This compares to 29 kcal/mol for unaffected cytosines in DNA. In addition, an estimate of the probability of cyclobutyl dimer formation at the target sites for glnU ^oand glnV ^osuppressor mutations indicate that these lesions can not entirely account for the mutation frequencies recovered in the absence of PR. This is interpreted as an indication that, in addition to thyminecytosine cyclobutyl dimers, other UV-induced lesions, possibly Thy(6-4)Cyt photoproducts, may also target glnU ^oand glnV ^osuppressor mutations.     

UV light-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers are mutagenic in mammalian cells.

We used a simian virus 40-based shuttle vector plasmid, pZ189, to determine the role of pyrimidine cyclobutane dimers in UV light-induced mutagenesis in monkey cells. The vector DNA was UV irradiated and then introduced into monkey cells by transfection. After replication, vector DNA was recovered from the cells and tested for mutations in its supF suppressor tRNA marker gene by transformation of Escherichia coli carrying a nonsense mutation in the beta-galactosidase gene. When the irradiated vector was treated with E. coli photolyase prior to transfection, pyrimidine cyclobutane dimers were removed selectively. Removal of approximately 90% of the pyrimidine cyclobutane dimers increased the biological activity of the vector by 75% and reduced its mutation frequency by 80%. Sequence analysis of 72 mutants recovered indicated that there were significantly fewer tandem double-base changes and G X C----A X T transitions (particularly at CC sites) after photoreactivation of the DNA. UV-induced photoproducts remained (although at greatly reduced levels) at all pyr-pyr sites after photoreactivation, but there was a relative increase in photoproducts at CC and TC sites and a relative decrease at TT and CT sites, presumably due to a persistence of (6-4) photoproducts at some CC and TC sites. These observations are consistent with the fact that mutations were found after photoreactivation at many sites at which only cyclobutane dimers would be expected to occur. From these results we conclude that UV-induced pyrimidine cyclobutane dimers are mutagenic in DNA replicated in monkey cells.     

UV mutagenesis in E. coli with excision repair initiated by uvrABC or denV gene products

Mutation frequency responses produced by ultraviolet light are compared in 4 closely related strains of E. coli B/r having the same tyr(Oc) allele and different excision-repair capabilities: uvr+ (excision repair initiated by wild-type UvrABC activity), uvrA (excision repair defective), uvrA/pdenV-7 (excision repair initiated by endonuclease V of bacteriophage T4, DenV activity), and uvr+/pdenV-7 (excision repair initiated by UvrABC and DenV activities). The production of Tyr+ prototrophic mutants is classified into back-mutations and de novo or converted glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations to indicate different mutation events. Cells transformed with the plasmid pdenV-7 require larger exposures than the parent strains to produce comparable mutation frequency responses, indicating that DenV activity can repair mutagenic photoproducts. When damage reduction by UvrABC or DenV is compared for each of the specific categories of mutation, the results are consistent with the idea that pyrimidine dimers infrequently or never target back-mutations of this allele, frequently target the de novo suppressor mutations, and extensively or exclusively target the converted suppressor mutations. This analysis is based on the distinction that UvrABC-initiated excision repair recognizes dimer and non-dimer (pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone) photoproducts but that DenV-initiated repair recognizes only pyrimidine dimers.     

Mutation frequency decline in Escherichia coli B/r after mutagenesis with ethyl methanesulfonate

Nonsense-defective auxotrophic strains of Escherichia coli B/r were used to study mutation frequency decline (MFD) after mutagenesis with ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS). The mutation frequencies for prototrophic revertants that were either converted or de novo glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations declined as treated auxotrophic parental cells were incubated with glucose but without required amino acids (a condition typically producing MFD). The decline for converted suppressor mutations was more rapid than the decline for de novo suppressor mutations after low or moderate EMS treatment, but both suppressor mutation types showed the same slow decline after extensive treatment. The declines for both types of suppressor mutation were eliminated in uvrA-defective cells, and the rapid decline seen for converted suppressor mutations appeared as a slow decline in mfd-defective cells. The results are interpreted that true MFD (the rapid process) affects only the EMS-induced converted glutamine tRNA suppressor mutations. This would account for the rapid decline that is blocked in cells with an mfd defect and in cells with deficient excision repair activity (uvrA or excessive DNA damage). In addition, a second non-specific antimutation mechanism is proposed that is dependent on excision repair only and accounts for the slow decline seen with converted suppressor mutations in some instances and with de novo suppressor mutations at all times. The true MFD mechanism may consist of a physiologically dependent facilitated excision repair specifically for premutational residues located in the transcribed strand of the target DNA sequence (for O6-ethylguanine in cells treated with ethyl methanesulfonate or pyrimidine-pyrimidine photoproducts after UV irradiation).     

Thermal resistance to photoreactivation of ultraviolet light induced mutations in the lacI gene of E. coli ung

Ultraviolet light (UV) induced mutations in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli are thought to be targeted by DNA photoproducts. A number of reports suggest that both cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers and pyrimidine (6−4) pyrimidone photoproducts may be involved. To investigate the potential contribution of each of these DNA photoproducts to mutagenesis in the lacI gene, we held UV-irradiated cells at a temperature of 44°C for 75 min and then exposed them to photoreactivating light (PR). This protocol is expected to preferentially deaminate specifically those cytosines that are contained in cyclobutyl dimers and subsequently monomerize the dimers to yield uracils in the DNA. In a strain deficient for uracil-DNA glycosylase (Ung⁻), these uracils would not be removed and a G : C → A : T transition would result at the site of the dimer. This protocol resulted in the enhancement of amber nonsense mutations that result from transitions at potential cytosine-containing dimer sites. The enhanced mutation frequencies resulting from this procedure were used to estimate the probability of dimer formation at the individual sites. A comparison of the dimer distribution with the mutation frequencies following UV alone suggests that both cyclobutyl dimers and (6−4) photoproducts contribute to UV-mutagenesis in the lacI gene. In addition, we conclude that the frequency of mutation at any particular site not only reflects the occurrence of DNA damage, but also the action of metabolic processes that are responsible for DNA repair and mutagenesis.     

Photoreactivation of UV induced cell killing, chromosome aberrations, sister chromatid exchanges, mutations and pyrimidine dimers in Xenopus laevis fibroblasts

Summary Fibroblasts from Xenopus laevis, which possess photoreactivating enzyme were used to study the influence of photoreactivating light on the frequency of pyrimidine dimers in DNA, chromosomal aberrations, sister chromatid exchanges, cell killing and the induction of gene mutations (ouabain-resistance) induced by 254 nm ultraviolet irradiation. The frequency of all biological endpoints studied were reduced following exposure to photoreactivating light parallel to the reduction in the frequencies of pyrimidine dimers (determined as endonuclease sensitive sites). However there was not always an absolute quantitative relationship between the reduction in the frequency of pyrimidine dimers and the reduction in the biological effects. This probably reflects a fast fixation process for the biological effects prior to removal of the dimers by photoreactivation.Abbreviations UV ultraviolet - PR photoreactivating - ESS endonuclease sensitive site - SCE sister chromatid exchanges - BrdUrd 5-brothodeoxyuridine     

Photoreactivation reverses ultraviolet radiation induced premutagenic lesions leading to frameshift mutations in Escherichia coli

Summary The effect of photoreactivation of the ultraviolet radiation induced reversion of a trpE9777 frameshift mutation was studied in a uvrA6 derivative of Escherichia coli K12. Two different photoreactivation treatments were used, one providing a single flash of photoreactivating light and another providing 10 min of light from fluorescent lamps. The reversion frequency of the trpE9777 frameshift mutation was strongly reduced when subsequently exposed to visible light. The dose modification factor (the ratio of equally effective doses), for cells challenged with single-flash photoreactivation, for survival and induction of reversion to Trp⁺ was 3.6 and 3.4, respectively. UV induction of RecA protein synthesis was not reversed by a single flash of photoreactivation. The dose modification factor for 10 min of fluorescent lamp photoreactivation for survival and for induction of reversion to Trp⁺ was 6.5 and 6.3, respectively. The dose modification factor for 10 min of photoreactivation for induction of RecA protein was 1.7–2.5. Photoreactivation decreased the reversion of trpE9777 and increased survival to the same extent. We concluded that cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers are the premutagenic lesions of UV mutagenesis of the trpE9777 allele in a uvrA6 background.     

Pyrimidine Dimers in the DNA of Paramecium aurelia

The production and fate of thymine-containing pyrimidine dimers in Paramecium aurelia DNA was investigated in three experimental series: production of dimers by UV irradiation, fate of dimers in the dark, and “loss of photoreactivability of dimers.” It is shown that cyclobutyl dimers are made by UV irradiation of Paramecium DNA in vivo, that because of cytoplasmic absorption the number of dimers made in DNA irradiated in vivo is much lower than in DNA irradiated in vitro, that dimers are lost from animals incubated in the dark after irradiation, and that all the dimers that remain in the animals can be destroyed by photoreactivating illumination. Since mutation induction is photoreactivable, these and previous photoreactivation data suggest that pyrimidine dimers are important in mutation induction in P. aurelia.     

Differential repair of premutational UV-lesions at tRNA genes in E. coli.

Summary Ultraviolet radiation produces bacterial revertants that frequently are the result of suppressor mutation. When irradiated cells are incubated under conditions unfavorable for protein synthesis there may be a large decrease in the frequency of observed mutants (mutation frequency decline, or MFD). MFD occurs only in excision-proficient strains and is inhibited by inhibitors of pyrimidine dimer excision. It has therefore been interpreted as enhanced excision of some premutational lesions. Potential de novo UAG suppressor mutation is very susceptible to MFD. Potential conversion mutation, the conversion of a UAG to a UAA suppressor, is at least ten times less susceptible to MFD. A base pair transition at a GC target in a particular tRNA gene is suggested for both de novo suppressor mutation and for conversion mutation. We interpret these results as indicating differential repair of premutational UV photoproducts at two closely spaced sites in the same tRNA gene. The significant difference between these two types of mutation may be the orientation of this target base pair in double helical DNA. The C would be in the transcribed strand of DNA when a nucleic acid alteration produces de novo suppressor mutation. The C would be in the nontranscribed strand, two base pairs removed, when a mutagenic alteration produces suppressor conversion. A model involving facilitated incision by hybridization of the transcribed strand of DNA to its cognate tRNA, under conditions promoting MFD, is described to explain this differential repair.     

Determination of Pyrimidine Dimers in Escherichia coli and Cryptosporidium parvum during UV Light Inactivation, Photoreactivation, and Dark Repair

UV inactivation, photoreactivation, and dark repair of Escherichia coli and Cryptosporidium parvum were investigated with the endonuclease sensitive site (ESS) assay, which can determine UV-induced pyrimidine dimers in the genomic DNA of microorganisms. In a 99.9% inactivation of E. coli, high correlation was observed between the dose of UV irradiation and the number of pyrimidine dimers induced in the DNA of E. coli. The colony-forming ability of E. coli also correlated highly with the number of pyrimidine dimers in the DNA, indicating that the ESS assay is comparable to the method conventionally used to measure colony-forming ability. When E. coli were exposed to fluorescent light after a 99.9% inactivation by UV irradiation, UV-induced pyrimidine dimers in the DNA were continuously repaired and the colony-forming ability recovered gradually. When kept in darkness after the UV inactivation, however, E. coli showed neither repair of pyrimidine dimers nor recovery of colony-forming ability. When C. parvum were exposed to fluorescent light after UV inactivation, UV-induced pyrimidine dimers in the DNA were continuously repaired, while no recovery of animal infectivity was observed. When kept in darkness after UV inactivation, C. parvum also showed no recovery of infectivity in spite of the repair of pyrimidine dimers. It was suggested, therefore, that the infectivity of C. parvum would not recover either by photoreactivation or by dark repair even after the repair of pyrimidine dimers in the genomic DNA.     

Mutagenesis after exposure of bacteria to ultraviolet light and delayed photoreversal

Summary The induction of mutations by ultraviolet light and delayed photoreversal in bacteria defective for SOS mutagenesis is discussed in terms of two models: the two-step misincorporation and bypass model, and the model involving simple deamination of cytosine-containing dimers. In phage S13 the latter appears to be the predominant mechanism. In Escherichia coli there is little evidence that the simple deamination mechanism is of any significance except in ung strains lacking uracil glycosylase where uracils left after photoreversal are not removed. Deamination might, however, occur during the operation of translesion synthesis via the two-step model and if it did, subsequent photoreversal would lead to the mutation being extended from one to both strands by uracil glycosylase repair rather than being removed.     

A comparative study of the effects of UV irradiation upon diploid cultures of yeast defective at the rad 3 locus

Summary Therad 3 gene ofSaccharomyces cerevisiae appears to code for one of the enzymes involved in the repair of UV induced pyrimidine dimers. Haploid and diploid yeast cultures carrying different mutant alleles of therad 3 gene show considerable variation in their responses to both UV inactivation and post UV modifying treatments such as liquid holding in basal medium and photoreactivation. Positive liquid holding recovery was shown only by those diploid cultures containing alleles which conferred the highest levels of UV resistance. The results indicate that liquid holding recovery in yeast requires the activity of the excision-repair pathway for expression.     

Reversions of the two missense and one nonsense trp-mutations induced by UV-light or methyl methanesulfonate in E. coli wild type and its polAi and uvrE502 mutants.

Two missense mutations, trpA58 and trpA78, and one nonsense mutation-trp-ochre, were used to determine the types of base-pair substitution caused by ultra, violet irradiation and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) in Escherichia coli. UV irradiation of the wild-type bacteria led to the formation of revertants mainly arising as a result of GC yields AT transitions (suppressor revertants of the trpA58 mutant). True revertants of the trp- mutant (arising via transitions of AT pairs) and 5-methyl tryptophan-sensitive (MT-s) Trp+ of the trpA78 mutant (arising via unidentified transversions) occurred at a lower frequency. The polAI mutation did not change the frequency of the UV-induced transitions GC yields AT or that of the substitutions of the AT pairs. The uvrE502 mutation significantly increased the frequency of the UV-induced revertants arising via the transition GC yields AT. Treatment of the wild-type bacteria with MMS resulted in the formation of revertants mainly due to the GC yields AT substitution, and with a lower frequency to the AT yields GC transitions. MMS also induced, with a low frequency, some transversions. The frequency of the MMS-induced GC yields AT transitions was enhanced in the uvrE502 mutant. On the other hand, the uvrE502 mutation eliminated or significantly lowered MMS-induced revertants arising as a result of AT yields GC transitions or transversions.     

Pyrimidine dimers are not the principal pre-mutagenic lesions induced in lambda phage DNA by ultraviolet light

Experiments were performed to examine the role of cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers in the process of mutagenesis by ultraviolet (u.v.) light. Lambda phage DNA was irradiated with u.v. and then incubated with an Escherichia coli photoreactivating enzyme, which monomerizes cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers upon exposure to visible light. The photoreactivated DNA was packaged into lambda phage particles, which were used to infect E. coli uvr- host cells that had been induced for SOS functions by ultraviolet irradiation. Photoreactivation removed most toxic lesions from irradiated phage, but did not change the frequency of induction of mutations to the clear-plaque phenotype. This implies that cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers can be lethal, but usually do not serve as sites of mutations in the phage. The DNA sequences of mutants derived from photoreactivated DNA showed that almost two-thirds (16/28) were transitions, the same fraction found for u.v. mutagenesis without photoreactivation. These results show that in this system, the lesion inducing transitions (the major type of u.v.-induced mutation) is not the cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimer; a strong candidate for a mutagenic lesion is the Pyr(6-4)Pyo photoproduct. On the other hand, photoreactivation of SOS-induced host cells before infection with u.v.-irradiated phage reduced mutagenesis substantially. In this case, photoreversal of cyclobutyl dimers serves to reduce expression of the SOS functions that are required in the process of targeted u.v. mutagenesis.     

The spectra of base substitutions induced by the impCAB, mucAB and umuDC error-prone DNA repair operons differ following exposure to methyl methanesulfonate

We have used the lacZ reversion assay to study the mutation spectra induced by the Escherichia coli chromosomal umuDC operon and of its two plasmid-borne analogues impCAB and mucAB following exposure of cells to UV light and methyl methane-sulfonate (MMS). We have shown that the impCAB, mucAB and umuDC operons all produce a similar response to UV light which results almost exclusively in AT GC transitions. However, we found that the three operons produced different responses to alkylating agents. We found that with MMS the chromosomal umuDC operon produced almost exclusively AT GC transitions, whilst both mucAB and impCAB produced predominantly transversions. In the case of the impCAB operon the mutation spectrum contained more AT TA than GC TA transversions; this balance was reversed with mucAB. The effect of the copy number of the error-prone DNA repair operons upon the mutagenic spectra was also studied. The results obtained suggest that the copy number of the imp operon does not greatly affect the specificity of base substitutions observed. However, an increase in the copy number of the umuDC operon greatly affected the specificity of base substitution, such that virtually no transitions were produced and the spectrum was dominated by GC/AT TA transversions. It appears that the three error-prone DNA repair operons impCAB, mucAB and umuDC, despite showing strong structural and functional homologies, can display major differences in the spectrum of base changes induced during mutagenesis. We propose that the type of misincorporation/chain extension which DNA polymerase III is allowed to synthesize on a damaged DNA template is extremely sensitive to both the amount and type of error-prone repair proteins present. The modulation of these events by the different proteins can result in widely different mutagenic changes in the repaired DNA.     

DNA Repair in Potorous tridactylus

The DNA synthesized shortly after ultraviolet (UV) irradiation of Potorous tridactylis (PtK) cells sediments more slowly in alkali than that made by nonirradiated cells. The size of the single-strand segments is approximately equal to the average distance between 1 or 2 cyclobutyl pyrimidine dimers in the parental DNA. These data support the notion that dimers are the photoproducts which interrupt normal DNA replication. Upon incubation of irradiated cells the small segments are enlarged to form high molecular weight DNA as in nonirradiated cells. DNA synthesized at long times (~ 24 h) after irradiation is made in segments approximately equal to those synthesized by nonirradiated cells, although only 10-15% of the dimers have been removed by excision repair. These data imply that dimers are not the lesions which initially interrupt normal DNA replication in irradiated cells. In an attempt to resolve these conflicting interpretations, PtK cells were exposed to photoreactivating light after irradiation and before pulse-labeling, since photoreactivation repair is specific for only one type of UV lesion. After 1 h of exposure ~ 35% of the pyrimidine dimers have been monomerized, and the reduction in the percentage of dimers correlates with an increased size for the DNA synthesized by irradiated cells. Therefore, we conclude that the dimers are the lesions which initially interrupt DNA replication in irradiated PtK cells. The monomerization of pyrimidine dimers correlates with a disappearance of repair endonuclease-sensitive sites, as measured in vivo immediately after 1 h of photoreactivation, indicating that some of the sites sensitive to the repair endonuclease (from Micrococcus luteus) are pyrimidine dimers. However, at 24 h after irradiation and 1 h of photoreactivation there are no endonuclease-sensitive sites, even though ~ 50% of the pyrimidine dimers remain in the DNA. These data indicate that not all pyrimidine dimers are accessible to the repair endonuclease. The observation that at long times after irradiation DNA is made in segments equal to those synthesized by nonirradiated cells although only a small percentage of the dimers have been removed suggests that an additional repair system alters dimers so that they no longer interrupt DNA replication.     

Effect of a lexA41(Ts) mutation on DNA repair in recA(Def) derivatives of Escherichia coli K-12

Summary Derivatives of Escherichia coli K-12 carrying a deletion of the recA gene survive exposure to UV (254 nm) better if they also contain the lexA41 mutation which codes for a labile LexA protein. This effect of the lexA41 mutation is not observed in comparable strains carrying a uvr A6 mutation. Using two independent methods to detect pyrimidine dimers we found that UV irradiated RecA deficient cells removed dimers from their DNA more rapidly if they contained the lexA41 mutation than if the contained the wild-type lexA gene. Our results are consistent with the idea that a relatively high level of UvrABC incision nuclease resulting from inefficient repression of the corresponding genes by the labile LexA41 protein facilitates excision of pyrimidine dimers from the DNA of UV irradiated cells.