Medium-dependent control of the bacterial growth rate

By combining results from previous studies of nutritional up-shifts we here re-investigate how bacteria adapt to different nutritional environments by adjusting their macromolecular composition for optimal growth. We demonstrate that, in contrast to a commonly held view the macromolecular composition of bacteria does not depend on the growth rate as an independent variable, but on three factors: (i) the genetic background (i.e. the strain used), (ii) the physiological history of the bacteria used for inoculation of a given growth medium, and (iii) the kind of nutrients in the growth medium. These factors determine the ribosome concentration and the average rate of protein synthesis per ribosome, and thus the growth rate. Immediately after a nutritional up-shift, the average number of ribosomes in the bacterial population increases exponentially with time at a rate which eventually is attained as the final post-shift growth rate of all cell components. After a nutritional up-shift from one minimal medium to another minimal medium of higher nutritional quality, ribosome and RNA polymerase syntheses are co-regulated and immediately increase by the same factor equal to the increase in the final growth rate. However, after an up-shift from a minimal medium to a medium containing all 20 amino acids, RNA polymerase and ribosome syntheses are no longer coregulated; a smaller rate of synthesis of RNA polymerase is compensated by a gradual increase in the fraction of free RNA polymerase, possibly due to a gradual saturation of mRNA promoters. We have also analyzed data from a recent publication, in which it was concluded that the macromolecular composition in terms of RNA/protein and RNA/DNA ratios is solely determined by the effector molecule ppGpp. Our analysis indicates that this is true only in special cases and that, in general, medium adaptation also depends on factors other than ppGpp.     

Control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli at increased rrn gene dosage. Role of guanosine tetraphosphate and ribosome feedback.

The effects of extra, plasmid-borne rRNA genes on the synthesis rate of rRNA in Escherichia coli were examined by measuring the fraction of total RNA synthesis that is rRNA and tRNA (rs/rt), the cytoplasmic concentration of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), and the absolute rates of RNA and protein synthesis. Experiments were carried out in different growth media and with two different strains of E. coli, B/r and K-12. The results indicated: 1) increased rrn gene dosage from either intact or defective rrn genes reduced bacterial growth rates and ribosome activity (protein synthesis rate/average ribosome), and increased rs/rt. 2) Extra intact, but not extra defective, plasmid-borne rrn genes caused the level of ppGpp to be increased in comparison to the pBR322-carrying control strain. 3) As a function of ppGpp, rs/rt was increased with either intact or defective rrn genes. 4) The rRNA synthesis rate/rrn gene was reduced in the presence of extra rrn genes; this reduction in gene activity was greater with intact than with defective rrn genes. An analysis of these results showed that they are consistent with the ppGpp hypothesis of rRNA control but not with a feedback effector role of translating ribosomes.     

Feedback control of ribosome function in Escherichia coli

We have previously proposed that the rate of ribosome function during balanced growth in E. coli, expressed as the rate of peptide chain elongation, is adjusted by a feedback mechanism: whenever that rate is submaximal (i.e. below 22 amino acid residues polymerized per active ribosome at 37 degrees C), the feedback signal ppGpp is generated by an activation of the ppGpp synthetase expressed from the spoT gene. The accumulation of ppGpp reduces the synthesis of additional ribosomes and thereby reduces the consumption of amino acids which, in turn, allows the remaining ribosomes to function at a higher rate. Here we have described with supporting evidence the proposed feedback loop in greater detail and provided a mathematical analysis which predicts that the SpoT ppGpp synthetase activity should be highest when the ribosomes function at their half-maximal rate. This prediction is consistent with reported observations and is independent of the particular (unknown) mechanism by which the rate of translation controls the ppGpp synthetase activity of SpoT.     

Regulation of the Escherichia coli rrnB P2 promoter

The seven rRNA operons in Escherichia coli each contain two promoters, rrn P1 and rrn P2. Most previous studies have focused on the rrn P1 promoters. Here we report a systematic analysis of the activity and regulation of the rrnB P2 promoter in order to define the intrinsic properties of rrn P2 promoters and to understand better their contributions to rRNA synthesis when they are in their natural setting downstream of rrn P1 promoters. In contrast to the conclusions reached in some previous studies, we find that rrnB P2 is regulated: it displays clear responses to amino acid availability (stringent control), rRNA gene dose (feedback control), and changes in growth rate (growth rate-dependent control). Stringent control of rrnB P2 requires the alarmone ppGpp, but growth rate-dependent control of rrnB P2 does not require ppGpp. The rrnB P2 core promoter sequence (-37 to +7) is sufficient to serve as the target for growth rate-dependent regulation.     

Stringent and growth control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli are both mediated by ppGpp

Weak stringent or relaxed responses were induced in Escherichia coli (relA+), using mild amino acid starvation or treatment with chloramphenicol at low concentrations, respectively, such that the growth rate was barely reduced. In this manner, the intracellular concentration of the nucleotide guanosine tetraphosphate, ppGpp, could be varied in any desired range between 0 and 1000 pmol of ppGpp per OD460 unit of culture mass. At the same time, the rate of synthesis of stable RNA (rs; rRNA and tRNA) was measured, relative to the total instantaneous rate of RNA synthesis (rt). The correlation between the cytoplasmic concentration of ppGpp and stable RNA gene activity (rs/rt) was the same as that observed previously with relA+ and relA strains growing exponentially at different rates in different media. This suggests that the distinction between growth control and stringent control of stable RNA synthesis is arbitrary, and that both kinds of control reflect the same ppGpp-dependent phenomenon. By increasing the stable RNA gene dosage, using high copy number plasmids carrying an rrn gene, we have tested the idea that ppGpp partitions the bacterial RNA polymerase into two forms with different probabilities to initiate at stable RNA and mRNA promoters. The relaxed response was not significantly altered, but the extent of the stringent response was reduced by the presence of extra rrn genes. The results agree with quantitative predictions derived from the RNA polymerase partitioning hypothesis.     

Physiological characterization of Escherichia coli rpoB mutants with abnormal control of ribosome synthesis.

We have previously reported the isolation of Escherichia coli rpoB mutants in which the control of ribosome synthesis by the nucleotide effector guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) is altered, owing to a 20-fold increased sensitivity of the mutant RNA polymerases to ppGpp. In these mutants, the level of ppGpp during exponential growth is decreased about 10-fold, relative to that of rpoB+ wild-type strains, such that a near normal partitioning of RNA polymerase occurs with respect to stable RNA (rRNA and tRNA) gene activity. Here, the physiological effects of two different rpoB alleles in a relA+ and relA background were analyzed in greater detail by comparison with their isogenic rpoB+ wild-type parents. For a given growth medium, the rpoB mutations were found to affect four parameters which resulted in a reduction of growth rate. The results reinforce a previous conclusion that a key element in control of the bacterial growth rate is a mutual relationship between control of ribosome synthesis by ppGpp and control of relA-independent ppGpp metabolism by the concentration and function of ribosomes.     

In vivo stability, maturation and relative differential synthesis rates of individual ribosomal proteins in Escherichia coli B/r

The relative differential synthesis rates² of individual ribosomal proteins (r-proteins) were determined for Escherichia coli B/r growing in succinate medium (growth rate, μ = 0.65 doublings per hour), glucose medium (μ = 1.36) and glucose-amino acids medium (μ = 1.90). These differential synthesis rates were found to increase co-ordinately with increasing bacterial growth rates; this implies that ribosomes from bacteria growing at different rates are homogeneous with respect to their protein composition (i.e. the stoichiometric amounts of the different r-proteins per ribosome are constant and independent of the bacterial growth rate). Following incorporation into ribosomes, the bulk of the r-proteins were found to be as stable as total protein. Only two r-proteins, S6 and S21, were less stable than total protein; their decay half-lives, measured in succinate and glucose-amino acids cultures, were estimated to be approximately 500 minutes. In addition, post-translational modification of proteins S18, L6 and L11 was observed and the possible relations between modification and in vivo ribosome assembly are discussed. Finally, evidence is presented suggesting that the coordinate production of r-proteins may result, in part, from a mechanism that degrades excess r-proteins that are not rapidly incorporated into ribosomal particles.     

The rates of macromolecular chain elongation modulate the initiation frequencies for transcription and translation inEscherichia coli

Here we show that most macromolecular biosynthesis reactions in growing bacteria are sub-saturated with substrate. The experiments should in part test predictions from a previously proposed model (Jensen & Pedersen 1990) which proposed a central role for the rates of the RNA and peptide chain elongation reactions in determining the concentration of initiation competent RNA polymerases and ribosomes and thereby the initiation frequencies for these reactions. We have shown that synthesis of ribosomal RNA and the concentration of ppGpp did not exhibit the normal inverse correlation under balanced growth conditions in batch cultures when the RNA chain elongation rate was limited by substrate supply. The RNA chain elongation rate for the polymerase transcribinglacZ mRNA was directly measured and found to be reduced by two-fold under conditions of high ppGpp levels. In the case of translation, we have shown that the peptide elongation rate varied at different types of codons and even among codons read by the same tRNA species. The faster translated codons probably have the highest cognate tRNA concentration and the highest affinity to the tRNA. Thus, the ribosome may operate close to saturation at some codons and be unsaturated at synonymous codons. Therefore, not only translation of the codons for the seven amino acids, whose biosynthesis is regulated by attenuation, but also a substantial fraction of the other translation reactions may be unsaturated. Recently, we have obtained results which indicate that also many ribosome binding sites are unsaturated with their substrate, i.e. with ribosomes. This observation affects the interpretation of many results obtained by use of reporter genes, because the expression from such genes is strongly influenced by the general physiology of the cell.     

The inefficiency of ribosomes functioning in Escherichia coli growing at moderate rates

It is generally agreed that ribosomes function with reduced efficiency (i.e. a smaller proportion is actually engaged in protein synthesis) in bacteria growing at low growth rates (doubling times greater than 2 h). This paper examines whether the efficiency is constant in bacteria growing at various rates corresponding to doubling times of less than 2 h. Because isotopic methods cannot be used in very rich media, turbidimetric methods have been extended to follow the kinetics of growth immediately following the shift-up of cultures of Escherichia coli ML308 growing in glucose minimal medium or succinate minimal medium into a very rich medium supporting a balanced doubling time of 17.4 min. It is concluded that the efficiency of ribosome participation in protein synthesis is higher in the very rich medium than in the two minimal media, which support doubling times of 43 and 65 min, respectively, at 37 degrees C.     

Escherichia coli ppGpp synthetase II activity requires spoT

Escherichia coli has two enzymes catalyzing the synthesis of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), designated ppGpp synthetase I (PSI = RelA) and II (PSII), whose activities are regulated differently. Until now, the gene for PSII had not been identified. Here, an E. coli relA1 strain that expresses lacZ from an rrnB P1 promoter was used to screen mutants with increased beta-galactosidase activity on 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indoyl beta-D-galactoside indicator plates at 30 degrees C. About 15% of the mutants obtained in this manner had reduced levels of ppGpp at 30 degrees C and no detectable ppGpp at 43 degrees C. These mutants did not form colonies at 42 degrees C on minimal medium plates and had elevated ribosome concentrations and higher growth rates at 30 degrees C. Genetic mapping by phage P1 transduction and complementation analyses showed that the mutations were located in spoT and that they were recessive. Specific inhibition of SpoT-dependent ppGpp degradation activity with picolinic acid showed that two of the mutants tested were deficient in ppGpp synthesis activity. These results indicate that spoT is required for PSII activity, suggesting that spoT encodes both ppGpp degradation and synthesis activities and that these two functions can be affected independently by mutation.     

Regulatory state of ribosomal genes and physiological changes in the concentration of free ribonucleic acid polymerase in Escherichia coli.

The concept of promoter efficiency is introduced as frequency of RNA chain initiation at a given promoter normalized to the intracellular concentration of free (but functional) RNA polymerase. Previous observations from this laboratory on the synthesis of ribosomes and beta-galactosidase are used to show that during a nutritional shift-up from succinate minimal to glucose-amino acids medium (3-fold increase in steady-state growth rate) the concentration of free (active) RNA polymerase decreases to one-quarter of the pre-shift value and the promoter efficiencies of the genes for ribosomal RNA and ribosomal proteins increase 9- and 6-fold respectively. This extent of control of ribosomal genes is much greater than expected on the basis of the increase in the rate of ribosome synthesis (3-fold).     

Rho and Ribosome Mutation Interaction: Lethality of rho-15 in rpsL or rpsE Strains, and rho-15 Methionine Auxotrophy in rps+ Strains of ESCHERICHIA COLI

The phenotype of Escherichia coli K-12 carrying rho-15 in the genetic background DW319 ilv lacZ::IS1 is described. Seventy-eight percent (70/90) of Ilv+ transductants acquired the following phenotype: temperature-sensitive growth on minimal salts medium, Ts+ growth on complex medium and suppression of the lac polar mutation. At 42 degrees on minimal medium, the rho-15 transductants were cross-fed by a substance diffusing from Rho+ transductants or controls. The requirement for this substance was satisfied by methionine or cystathionine, but not by any other single amino acid or combination of amino acids, by spermidine, or by mono- or divalent cationic salts.--Transduction of rho-15 into four other Ilv- recipients revealed two phenotypic patterns. Recipients with rpsL or rpsE ribosomes yielded rho-15 transductants that were Ts on all media, or Ts on minimal medium whether or not methionine was present. The effect of the ribosome on expression of rho-15 was confirmed by transduction of appropriate rps alleles into DW319, followed by co-transduction of rho-15 with Ilv+. The growth rate of double rho-15 rpsL or rho-15 rpsE strains was severely reduced at 42 degrees in comparison with strains carrying any of these single mutations. Models for rho and ribosome interaction are presented.