Role of nontoxic components of serotype D botulinum toxin complex in permeation through a Caco-2 cell monolayer, a model for intestinal epithelium

Botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) is produced as a large toxin complex (TC) associated with nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and three hemagglutinin subcomponents (HA-70, -33 and -17). To assess the role of nontoxic components in the oral intoxication of botulinum TCs, we investigated the permeability of serotype D strain 4947 BoNT and its various TC species through cultured Caco-2 cell monolayers. The L-TC species (complexes composed of BoNT, NTNHA, HA-70, HA-33 and HA-17) showed potent permeability through the cell layer, whereas free BoNT, M-TC (BoNT and NTNHA complexes) and M-TC/HA-70 showed little or no permeability. Cell binding tests demonstrated that HA-33/HA-17 complexes bound to cells, whereas other components did not. These findings suggest that BoNT in the 650-kDa L-TC permeates into the cell mainly in an HA-33/HA-17-mediated manner, although free BoNT can permeate into the cell. As free BoNT and M-TC were susceptible to digestion with gastrointestinal juice, it is likely that L-TC species containing HA-33 caused higher oral toxicity in mice than others. We conclude that the HA-33 subcomponent plays a critical role in the permeation of TCs into intestinal epithelium, and that other HA subcomponents protect BoNT against gastrointestinal digestion.     

Reversible Association of the Hemagglutinin Subcomplex,HA-33/HA-17 Trimer,with the Botulinum Toxin Complex

Botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) associates with nontoxic proteins, either a nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) or the complex of NTNHA and hemagglutinin (HA), to form M- or L-toxin complexes (TCs). Single BoNT and NTNHA molecules are associated and form M-TC. A trimer of the 70-kDa HA protein (HA-70) attaches to the M-TC to form M-TC/HA-70. Further, 1–3 arm-like 33- and 17-kDa HA molecules (HA-33/HA-17 trimer), consisting of 1 HA-17 protein and 2 HA-33 proteins, can attach to the M-TC/HA-70 complex, yielding 1-, 2-, and 3-arm L-TC. In this study, the purified 1- and 2-arm L-TCs spontaneously converted into another L-TC species after acquiring the HA-33/HA-17 trimer from other TCs during long-term storage and freezing/thawing. Transmission electron microscopy analysis provided evidence of the formation of detached HA-33/HA-17 trimers in the purified TC preparation. These findings provide evidence of reversible association/dissociation of the M-TC/HA-70 complex with the HA-33/HA-17 trimers, as well as dynamic conversion of the quaternary structure of botulinum TC in culture.     

HA-33 facilitates transport of the serotype D botulinum toxin across a rat intestinal epithelial cell monolayer

A large size botulinum toxin complex (L-TC) is composed of a single neurotoxin (BoNT), a single nontoxic nonhaemagglutinin (NTNHA) and a haemagglutinin (HA) complex. The HA complex is comprised of three HA-70 molecules and three arm structures of HA-33/HA-17 that consist of two HA-33 and a single HA-17. In addition to the mature L-TC, smaller TCs are present in cultures: M-TC (BoNT/NTNHA), M-TC/HA-70 and immature L-TCs with fewer HA-33/HA-17 arms than mature L-TC. Because L-TC displays higher oral toxicity than pure BoNT, it was presumed that nontoxic proteins are critical for food poisoning. In this study, the absorption of TCs across intestinal epithelial cells was assessed by examining the cell binding and monolayer transport of serotype D toxins in the rat intestinal epithelial cell line IEC-6. All TCs, including pure BoNT, displayed binding and transport, with mature L-TC showing the greatest potency. Inhibition experiments using antibodies revealed that BoNT, HA-70 and HA-33 could be responsible for the binding and transport. The findings here indicate that all TCs can transport across the cell layer via a sialic acid-dependent process. Nonetheless, binding and transport markedly increased with number of HA-33/HA-17 arms in the TC. We therefore conclude that the HA-33/HA-17 arm is not necessarily required for, but facilitates, transport of botulinum toxin complexes.     

Building-block architecture of botulinum toxin complex: Conformational changes provide insights into the hemagglutination ability of the complex

Clostridium botulinum produces the botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT). Previously, we provided evidence for the “building-block” model of botulinum toxin complex (TC). In this model, a single BoNT is associated with a single nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA), yielding M-TC; three HA-70 molecules are attached and form M-TC/HA-70, and one to three “arms” of the HA-33/HA-17 trimer (two HA-33 and one HA-17) further bind to M-TC/HA-70 via HA-17 and HA-70 binding, yielding one-, two-, and three-arm L-TC. Of all TCs, only the three-arm L-TC caused hemagglutination. In this study, we determined the solution structures for the botulinum TCs using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). The mature three-arm L-TC exhibited the shape of a “bird spreading its wings”, in contrast to the model having three “arms”, as revealed by transmission electron microscopy. SAXS images indicated that one of the three arms of the HA-33/HA-17 trimer bound to both HA-70 and BoNT. Taken together, these findings regarding the conformational changes in the building-block architecture of TC may explain why only three-arm L-TC exhibited hemagglutination.     

Characterization of Toxin Complex Produced by a Unique Strain of Clostridium botulinum Serotype D 4947

A unique strain of Clostridium botulinum, serotype D 4947 (D-4947), produces a considerable amount of a 650 kDa toxin complex (L-TC) and a small amount of a 280 kDa M-TC, a 540 kDa TC, and a 610 kDa TC. The complexes are composed of only un-nicked components, including neurotoxin (NT), nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and hemagglutinin subcomponents (HA-70, HA-33 and HA-17). Unlike other NTs from all serotype strains, separation of D-4947 NT from L-TC, except for M-TC, during chromatography required highly alkaline conditions around pH 8.8. The separated NT and NTNHA/HAs complex can be reconstituted to L-TC that is indistinguishable from the parent L-TC with respect to toxicity, hemagglutination activity and gel filtration profile. The isoelectric points of NT and NTNHA/HAs were close together depending on the number of HA-33/17 molecules. We have established a new method to separate the unique D-4947 NT from the complex, which will yield valuable information on structure of botulinum toxin.     

Complete subunit structure of the Clostridium botulinum type D toxin complex via intermediate assembly with nontoxic components

Clostridium botulinum serotype D strains usually produce two types of stable toxin complex (TC), namely, the 300 kDa M (M-TC) and the 660 kDa L (L-TC) toxin complexes. We previously proposed assembly pathways for both TCs [Kouguchi, H., et al. (2002) J. Biol. Chem. 277, 2650-2656]: M-TC is composed by association of neurotoxin (NT) and nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA); conjugation of M-TC with three auxiliary types of hemagglutinin subcomponents (HA-33, HA-17, and HA-70) leads to the formation of L-TC. In this study, we found three TC species, 410, 540, and 610 kDa TC species, in the culture supernatant of type D strain 4947. The 540 and 610 kDa TC species displayed banding patterns on SDS-PAGE similar to that of L-TC but with less staining intensity of the HA-33 and HA-17 bands than those of L-TC, indicating that these are intermediate species in the pathway to L-TC assembly. In contrast, the 410 kDa TC species consisted of M-TC and two molecules of HA-70. All of the TC species, except L-TC, demonstrated no hemagglutination activity. When the intermediate TC species were mixed with an isolated HA-33/17 complex, every TC species converted to 650 kDa L-TC with full hemagglutination activity and had the same molecular composition of L-TC. On the basis of titration analysis with the HA-33/17 complex, the stoichiometry of the HA-33/17 complex molecules in the L-TC, 610 kDa, and 540 kDa TC species was estimated as 4, 3, and 2, respectively. In conclusion, the complete subunit composition of mature L-TC is deduced to be a dodecamer assembled by a single NT, a single NTNHA, two HA-70, four HA-33, and four HA-17 molecules.     

Clostridium botulinum serotype D neurotoxin and toxin complex bind to bovine aortic endothelial cells via sialic acid

Botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) is produced as a large toxin complex (L-TC) associated with nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and three hemagglutinin subcomponents (HA-70, -33 and -17). The binding properties of BoNT to neurons and L-TC to intestinal epithelial cells are well documented, while those to other tissues are largely unknown. Here, to obtain novel insights into the pathogenesis of foodborne botulism, we examine whether botulinum toxins bind to vascular endothelial cells. BoNT and 750 kDa L-TC (a complex of BoNT, NTNHA and HAs) of Clostridium botulinum serotype D were incubated with bovine aortic endothelial cells (BAECs), and binding to the cells was assessed using sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blot. Both BoNT and L-TC bound to BAECs, with L-TC showing stronger binding. Binding of BoNT and L-TC to BAECs was significantly inhibited by N-acetyl neuraminic acid in the cell culture medium or by treatment of the cells with neuraminidase. However, galactose, lactose or N-acetyl galactosamine did not significantly inhibit toxin binding to the cells. This is the first report demonstrating that BoNT and L-TC bind to BAECs via sialic acid, and this mechanism may be important in the trafficking pathway of BoNT in foodborne botulism.     

In vitro reconstitution of the Clostridium botulinum type D progenitor toxin.

Clostridium botulinum type D strain 4947 produces two different sizes of progenitor toxins (M and L) as intact forms without proteolytic processing. The M toxin is composed of neurotoxin (NT) and nontoxic-nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA), whereas the L toxin is composed of the M toxin and hemagglutinin (HA) subcomponents (HA-70, HA-17, and HA-33). The HA-70 subcomponent and the HA-33/17 complex were isolated from the L toxin to near homogeneity by chromatography in the presence of denaturing agents. We were able to demonstrate, for the first time, in vitro reconstitution of the L toxin formed by mixing purified M toxin, HA-70, and HA-33/17. The properties of reconstituted and native L toxins are indistinguishable with respect to their gel filtration profiles, native-PAGE profiles, hemagglutination activity, binding activity to erythrocytes, and oral toxicity to mice. M toxin, which contained nicked NTNHA prepared by treatment with trypsin, could no longer be reconstituted to the L toxin with HA subcomponents, whereas the L toxin treated with proteases was not degraded into M toxin and HA subcomponents. We conclude that the M toxin forms first by assembly of NT with NTNHA and is subsequently converted to the L toxin by assembly with HA-70 and HA-33/17.     

Characterization and reconstitution of functional hemagglutinin of the Clostridium botulinum type C progenitor toxin.

The purified progenitor toxin of Clostridium botulinum type C strain 6814 (C-6814) forms a large complex composed of 150-kDa neurotoxin (NT), 130-kDa nontoxic-nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA), and hemagglutinin (HA) components. The HA component consisted of a mixture of several subcomponents with molecular masses of 70, 55, 33, 26-21 and 17 kDa. We isolated the HA subcomponents from the progenitor toxin by chromatography in the presence of denaturants. The isolated HA subcomponents, designated as i-HA-33, i-HA-55, i-HA-70 and i-HA-33/17, were nearly homogeneous on SDS/PAGE, but the HA-17 and HA-26-21 components were not purified. Some HA subcomponents, designated as f-HA-33 and f-HA-33/17 complex, existed free of the progenitor toxin in the culture medium and they were separately purified. Every HA subcomponent so far isolated shows binding activity to erythrocytes. The hemagglutination activities of each HA subcomponent had a titer of 25 for the f-HA-33/17 complex, and below 23 for the other f- and i-HA subcomponents, while the parent progenitor L toxin was 28. The reconstitution of various combinations of f- and i-HA subcomponents was attempted via mixing and tested for hemagglutination activity. When the i-HA-33/17 complex and i-HA-55 were mixed, the hemagglutination activity was recovered to a titer of 29, which was slightly higher than that of the parent toxin. These data imply that a combination of at least HA-33, -17 and -55 subcomponents is required for full hemagglutination activity of the botulinum progenitor toxin, but each single HA subcomponent shows weak or no aggregation of erythrocytes.     

The structure of the neurotoxin-associated protein HA33/A from Clostridium botulinum suggests a reoccurring beta-trefoil fold in the progenitor toxin complex

The hemagglutinating protein HA33 from Clostridium botulinum is associated with the large botulinum neurotoxin secreted complexes and is critical in toxin protection, internalization, and possibly activation. We report the crystal structure of serotype A HA33 (HA33/A) at 1.5 A resolution that contains a unique domain organization and a carbohydrate recognition site. In addition, sequence alignments of the other toxin complex components, including the neurotoxin BoNT/A, hemagglutinating protein HA17/A, and non-toxic non-hemagglutinating protein NTNHA/A, suggests that most of the toxin complex consists of a reoccurring beta-trefoil fold.     

Purification and Characterization of Nontoxic Protein Complex from Serotype D 4947 Botulinum Toxin Complex

The large-sized botulinum toxin complex (L-TC) is composed of botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) and nontoxic proteins, e.g. nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and three types of hemagglutinins (HAs; HA-33, HA-17 and HA-70). The nontoxic proteins play a critical role in L-TC oral toxicity by protecting the BoNT in the digestive tract, and facilitating absorption of the L-TC across the intestinal wall. Under alkaline conditions, the L-TC separates into BoNT and the nontoxic protein complex (NC). In this study, we established a two-step procedure to yield highly pure NC from the L-TC produced by Clostridium botulinum serotype D strain 4947 in which the NC was isolated from the L-TC by gel filtration under alkaline conditions followed by immunoprecipitation with an anti-BoNT antibody to remove contaminating BoNT from the NC fraction. Western blotting and electrophoretic analysis showed that the highly purified NC fraction had only very slight or no BoNT contamination. In addition, the purified NC fraction showed no intraperitoneal (ip) toxicity to mice at a dose of 38?ng per animal whereas the L-TC exhibited an ip median lethal dose of 0.38?ng per mouse. The highly purified NC displayed the same hemagglutination titer as the L-TC. The NC, as well as the L-TC, demonstrated cell binding and monolayer transport in the rat intestinal epithelial cell line IEC-6. Consequently, the highly purified NC can function as a ??delivery vehicle?? even without the BoNT.     

Small-angle X-ray scattering reveals structural dynamics of the botulinum neurotoxin associating protein, nontoxic nonhemagglutinin

In cell culture supernatants, the botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) exists as part of a toxin complex (TC) in which nontoxic nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and/or hemagglutinins (HAs) are assembled onto the BoNT. A series of investigations indicated that formation of the TC is vital for delivery of the toxin to nerve cells through the digestive tract. In the assembly process, BoNT binds to NTNHA yielding M-TC, and it then matures into L-TC by further association with the HAs via NTNHA in the M-TC. Here, we report a crystal structure of the NTNHA from Clostridium botulinum serotype D strain 4947. Additionally, we performed small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) analysis of the NTNHA and the M-TC to elucidate the solution structure. The crystal structure of D-4947 NTNHA revealed that BoNT and NTNHA share a closely related structure consisting of three domains. The SAXS image indicated that, even though the N-terminal two-thirds of the NTNHA molecule had an apparently similar conformation in both the crystal and solution structures, the C-terminal third of the molecule showed a more extended structure in the SAXS image than that seen in the crystallographic image. The discrepancy between the crystal and solution structures implies a high flexibility of the C-terminal third domain of NTNHA, which is involved in binding to BoNT. Structural dynamics of the NTNHA molecule revealed by SAXS may explain its binding to BoNT to form the BoNT/NTNHA complex.     

Sugar-induced conformational change found in the HA-33/HA-17 trimer of the botulinum toxin complex

Large-sized botulinum toxin complex (L-TC) is formed by conjugation of neurotoxin, nontoxic nonhemagglutinin and hemagglutinin (HA) complex. The HA complex is formed by association of three HA-70 molecules and three HA-33/HA-17 trimers, comprised of a single HA-17 and two HA-33 proteins. The HA-33/HA-17 trimer isolated from serotype D L-TC has the ability to bind to and penetrate through the intestinal epithelial cell monolayer in a sialic acid-dependent manner, and thus it plays an important role in toxin delivery through the intestinal cell wall. In this study, we determined the solution structure of the HA-33/HA-17 trimer by using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). The SAXS image of HA-33/HA-17 exhibited broadly similar appearance to the crystal image of the complex. On the other hand, in the presence of N-acetylneuraminic acid, glucose and galactose, the solution structure of the HA-33/HA-17 trimer was drastically altered compared to the structure in the absence of the sugars. Sugar-induced structural change of the HA-33/HA-17 trimer may contribute to cell binding and subsequent transport across the intestinal cell layer.     

Structural Basis of the pH-Dependent Assembly of a Botulinum Neurotoxin Complex

Botulinum neurotoxins (BoNTs) are among the most poisonous biological substances known. They assemble with non-toxic non-hemagglutinin (NTNHA) protein to form the minimally functional progenitor toxin complexes (M-PTC), which protects BoNT in the gastrointestinal tract and releases it upon entry into the circulation. Here we provide molecular insight into the assembly between BoNT/A and NTNHA-A using small-angle X-ray scattering. We found that the free form BoNT/A maintains a pH-independent conformation with limited domain flexibility. Intriguingly, the free form NTNHA-A adopts pH-dependent conformational changes due to a torsional motion of its C-terminal domain. Once forming a complex at acidic pH, they each adopt a stable conformation that is similar to that observed in the crystal structure of the M-PTC. Our results suggest that assembly of the M-PTC depends on the environmental pH and that the complex form of BoNT/A is induced by interacting with NTNHA-A at acidic pH.     

Characterization of sugar recognition by the toxin complex produced by the Clostridium botulinum serotype C variant strain Yoichi

Clostridium botulinum serotype C strains produce a neurotoxin (BoNT) along with nontoxic proteins, including nontoxic nonhemagglutinin and three hemagglutinin subcomponents, HA-70, HA-33 and HA-17, to form a large toxin complex (L-TC). While L-TCs produced by serotype C strains usually exhibit hemagglutination (HA) activity via HA-33 binding to sialic acid on erythrocytes, serotype C strain Yoichi (C-Yoichi) L-TC exhibited neither HA nor binding activity towards erythrocytes, probably due to a C-terminal truncation of the HA-33 protein. However, here, we demonstrate that C-Yoichi L-TC newly showed full HA and binding activity towards neuraminidase-treated erythrocytes that was completely inhibited in the presence of galactose (Gal) or lactose (Lac). Binding of C-Yoichi L-TC to rat small intestine epithelial cells (IEC-6) treated with neuraminidase was also significantly enhanced compared with untreated IEC-6 cells. Similarly, the HA-33/HA-17 complex isolated from C-Yoichi L-TC also bound to neuraminidase-treated IEC-6 cells. The binding activity of both L-TC and HA-33/HA-17 was inhibited in the presence of Gal or Lac. Additionally, C-Yoichi L-TC adsorbed tightly to a lactose-affinity gel column. These results strongly suggest that the unusual recognition of the Gal moiety on the cells could be due to a variation and/or a truncation in the C-terminal-half of the unique C-Yoichi HA-33 protein.     

Analysis of the neurotoxin complex genes in Clostridium botulinum A1-A4 and B1 strains: BoNT/A3, /Ba4 and /B1 clusters are located within plasmids

Background

Clostridium botulinum and related clostridial species express extremely potent neurotoxins known as botulinum neurotoxins (BoNTs) that cause long-lasting, potentially fatal intoxications in humans and other mammals. The amino acid variation within the BoNT is used to categorize the species into seven immunologically distinct BoNT serotypes (A–G) which are further divided into subtypes. The BoNTs are located within two generally conserved gene arrangements known as botulinum progenitor complexes which encode toxin-associated proteins involved in toxin stability and expression.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Because serotype A and B strains are responsible for the vast majority of human botulism cases worldwide, the location, arrangement and sequences of genes from eight different toxin complexes representing four different BoNT/A subtypes (BoNT/A1-Ba4) and one BoNT/B1 strain were examined. The bivalent Ba4 strain contained both the BoNT/A4 and BoNT/bvB toxin clusters. The arrangements of the BoNT/A3 and BoNT/A4 subtypes differed from the BoNT/A1 strains and were similar to those of BoNT/A2. However, unlike the BoNT/A2 subtype, the toxin complex genes of BoNT/A3 and BoNT/A4 were found within large plasmids and not within the chromosome. In the Ba4 strain, both BoNT toxin clusters (A4 and bivalent B) were located within the same 270 kb plasmid, separated by 97 kb. Complete genomic sequencing of the BoNT/B1 strain also revealed that its toxin complex genes were located within a 149 kb plasmid and the BoNT/A3 complex is within a 267 kb plasmid.

Conclusions/Significance

Despite their size differences and the BoNT genes they contain, the three plasmids containing these toxin cluster genes share significant sequence identity. The presence of partial insertion sequence (IS) elements, evidence of recombination/gene duplication events, and the discovery of the BoNT/A3, BoNT/Ba4 and BoNT/B1 toxin complex genes within plasmids illustrate the different mechanisms by which these genes move among diverse genetic backgrounds of C. botulinum.     

Expression and stability of the nontoxic component of the botulinum toxin complex

Clostridium botulinum produces botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) as a large toxin complex associated with nontoxic-nonhemagglutinin (NTNHA) and/or hemagglutinin components. In the present study, high-level expression of full-length (1197 amino acids) rNTNHA from C. botulinum serotype D strain 4947 (D-4947) was achieved in an Escherichia coli system. Spontaneous nicking of the rNTNHA at a specific site was observed during long-term incubation in the presence of protease inhibitors; this was also observed in natural NTNHA. The rNTNHA assembled with isolated D-4947 BoNT with molar ratio 1:1 to form a toxin complex. The reconstituted toxin complex exhibited dramatic resistance to proteolysis by pepsin or trypsin at high concentrations, despite the fact that the isolated BoNT and rNTNHA proteins were both easily degraded. We provide definitive evidence that NTNHA plays a crucial role in protecting BoNT, which is an oral toxin, from digestion by proteases common in the stomach and intestine.     

Characterization of the Genes Encoding the Botulinum Neurotoxin Complex in a Strain of Clostridium botulinum Producing Type B and F Neurotoxins

The organization of the clusters of genes encoding proteins of the botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) progenitor complex was elucidated in a strain of Clostridium botulinum producing type B and F neurotoxins. With PCR and sequencing strategies, the type B BoNT-gene cluster was found to be composed of genes encoding BoNT/B, nontoxic nonhemagglutinin component (NTNH), P-21, and the hemagglutinins HA-33, HA-17, and HA-70, whereas the type F BoNT-gene cluster has genes encoding BoNT/F, NTNH, P-47, and P-21. Comparative sequence analysis showed that BoNT/F in type BF strain 3281 shares highest homology with BoNT/F of non-proteolytic (group II) C. botulinum whereas NTNH and P-21 in the type F cluster of strain 3281 are more similar to the corresponding proteins in proteolytic (group I) type F C. botulinum. These findings indicate diverse evolutionary origins for genes encoding BoNT/F and its associated non-toxic proteins, although the genes are contiguous. By contrast, sequence comparisons indicate that genes encoding BoNT/B and associated non-toxic proteins in strain 3281 possess a similar evolutionary origin. It was demonstrated that the genes present in the BoNT/B gene cluster of this type BF strain show exceptionally high homology with the equivalent genes in the silent BoNT/B gene cluster of C. botulinum type A(B), possibly indicating their common ancestry. Received: 30 March 1998 / Accepted: 21 May 1998