Reproductive biology and relative male and female fitness in a trioecious cactus,Pachycereus pringlei (Cactaceae)

We describe the breeding system of an autotetraploid trioecious cactus, Pachycereus pringlei, provide estimates of the fitnesses of males and females relative to that of hermaphrodites, and discuss the role played by pollinators in the maintenance of three sexual morphs. Relatively high frequencies of females (45%) and males (26%) exist in coastal desert populations around Bahia Kino, Sonora, Mexico. They differ from hermaphrodites in flower size (females only), initiation of the flowering season, number of flowers produced per night and per season, sucrose content of nectar, and, in females, number of fruits produced per season under open pollination and in response to hand-pollination. Major similarities between the sex classes include overall plant size, nectar volume per flower, percent fruit set in open-pollinated flowers of females and hermaphrodites, seed mass and number of seeds per fruit, and pollen mass per flower in males and hermaphrodites. Hermaphrodites are self-compatible, and the selfing rate is high (65%). Levels of inbreeding depression in selfed fruits and seeds appear to be low. Fruit set is strongly pollinator-dependent in females but much less so in hermaphrodites. Relative fitness of males and females, as measured by annual production of pollen or seeds, is at least 1.5 times higher than that of the corresponding sex function in hermaphrodites. Given the high selfing rate and apparent lack of inbreeding depression, these fitness differences are insufficient to explain the occurrence of trioecy in this species.     

Selection in plant populations of effectively infinite size. V. Biallelic models of trioecy

A one-locus two-allele model of trioecy (presence of hermaphrodites, males and females in one population) is considered, in order to study the conditions for the persistence of this system. All possible assignments of the three sex types to the three genotypes are considered. This leads to three different modes of inheritance of trioecy, namely (a) females heterozygous, (b) males heterozygous and (c) hermaphrodites heterozygous, where in each mode each of the remaining two sex types is homozygous for one of the alleles. For mode (c) trioecy is always persistent, and the dependence of the sex ratio (for the three sex types) on the ovule and pollen fertilities and on the hermaphrodite selfing rate is specified. For the other two modes, (a) and (b), trioecy is not protected, i.e., it may not persist for any fertilities, viabilities or selfing rates. Thus, in this situation it is important to study the conditions under which the "marginal" systems of sexuality of trioecy, i.e., hermaphroditism, dioecy and gynodioecy in mode (a), and hermaphroditism, dioecy and androdioecy in mode (b), may become established. The results show that each marginal system may evolve from each other via trioecy. The evolution of dioecy is easier in mode (a) than in (b), so that female heterogamety would be expected to occur more often than male heterogamety in the present model. Under some conditions the breeding system obtained in equilibrium populations may depend on the initial genotype frequencies.—The necessity of considering modes of inheritance for sexual polymorphisms is demonstrated by comparing our results with those obtained from an evolutionary stable strategy (ESS) analysis of a purely phenotypic model.     

'Inconstant males' and the maintenance of labile sex expression in subdioecious plants

* Here, we evaluate the role of pollen limitation and selfing in the maintenance of labile sex expression in subdioecious plant species. * We used a literature survey to explore which factors correlated with a significant occurrence of hermaphrodites in dioecious species. We developed models to explore the selective maintenance of labile sex expression. The models had similar ecological assumptions but differed in the genetic basis of sex lability. * We found that a significant frequency of hermaphrodites was associated with animal pollination, and that hermaphrodites were 'inconstant' males with perfect flowers, suggesting evolution through the gynodioecious pathway. Models showed that a modifier converting pure males into inconstant males could be maintained under a wide range of reduction in both male and female fitness. Pollen limitation and self-fertilization facilitated invasion of the modifier. Depending on the genetics of sex determination, we found pure dioecy, stable subdioecy (trioecy), and situations where inconstant males coexisted with either pure females or pure males. Under selfing and pollen limitation, certain conditions selected for inconstant males which will drive populations to extinction. * We discuss our results in relation to the evolution towards, and the breakdown of, dioecy, and the ecological and evolutionary implications of labile sex expression.     

Reproductive implications of combined and separate sexes in a trioecious population of Opuntia robusta (Cactaceae)

Opuntia robusta has hermaphroditic, dioecious, and trioecious populations. To enhance our understanding of this breeding system diversity, we compared the reproductive output of males, females, and hermaphrodites in a trioecious population using field evaluations, controlled crosses, and progeny tests. Unisexuals were fully sterile in one sex function. Hermaphrodites were fully fertile for both functions. Consistent with the sex-allocation theory, unisexuality increased the quality and quantity (in males) of the gametes of the functional sex, relative to those of hermaphrodites, probably explained by maternal and paternal effects. The increase was higher in males than in females, suggesting a more expensive female function. Theoretically, this disproportional increase is required for unisexuals to invade a hermaphroditic population with prior selfing, negligible pollen discounting, and undetectable inbreeding depression, features found in O. robusta, therefore helping to explain dioecious populations. However, in the study population, the actual seed output of females was lower and had a higher variance than that of hermaphrodites, which also reproduce through pollen. Unisexuals are unlikely to be maintained by their actual reproductive output in this pollen-limited environment. Hermaphrodites may persist in this population by producing their seeds autonomously and by reducing interspecific fertilization by prior selfing and ovule discounting.     

Density-dependent self-fertilization and male versus hermaphrodite siring success in an androdioecious plant

Models of mating-system evolution emphasize the importance of frequency-dependent interactions among mating partners. It is also known that outcross siring success and the selfing rate in self-compatible hermaphrodites can be density dependent. Here, we use array experiments to show that the mating system (i.e., the outcrossing rate) and the siring success of morphs with divergent sex allocation strategies are both density dependent and frequency dependent in androdioecious populations of the wind-pollinated, annual plant Mercurialis annua. In particular, the outcrossing rate is a decreasing function of the mean interplant distance, regulated by a negative exponential pollen fall-off curve. Our results indicate that pollen dispersed from a male inflorescence are over 60% more likely to sire outcrossed progeny than equivalent pollen dispersed from hermaphrodites, likely due to the fact that males, but not hermaphrodites, disperse their pollen from erect inflorescence stalks. Because of this difference, and because males of M. annua produce much more pollen than hermaphrodites, the presence of males in the experimental arrays reduced both the selfing rate and the outcross siring success of hermaphrodites. We use our results to infer a density threshold below which males are unable to persist with hermaphrodites but above which they can invade hermaphroditic populations. We discuss our findings in the context of a metapopulation model, in which males can only persist in well-established populations but are excluded from small, sparse populations, for example, in the early stages of colonization.     

Density-dependent regulation of the sex ratio in an annual plant

Sex ratios are subject to strong frequency-dependent selection regulated by the mating system and the relative male versus female investment. In androdioecious plant populations, where males co-occur with hermaphrodites, the sex ratio depends on the rate of self-fertilization by hermaphrodites and on the relative pollen production of males versus hermaphrodites. Here, we report evolutionary changes in the sex ratio from experimental mating arrays of the androdioecious plant Mercurialis annua. We found that the progeny sex ratio depended strongly on density, with fewer males in the progeny of plants grown under low density. This occurred in part because of a plastic adjustment in pollen production by hermaphrodites, which produced more pollen when grown at low density than at high density. Our results provide support for the prediction that environmental conditions govern sex ratios through their effects on the relative fertility of unisexual versus hermaphrodite individuals.     

Sex expression and reproductive biology in a tree species, Fraxinus excelsior L

We investigated Fraxinus excelsior breeding system using field data collected in a natural population and in a seed orchard. First, we attested functional trioecy (co-occurrence of males, hermaphrodites and females), with males producing pollen, hermaphrodites producing both pollen and seeds simultaneously, and females producing seeds. Second, we found that the reproductive system of F. excelsior was not labile, as sex expression seemed to be stable through time. Third, gender is genetically determined since different trees belonging to the same clone in the orchard exhibit similar sexual phenotypes.     

ECOLOGICAL GENETICS OF GYNODIOECY IN SILENE VULGARIS: RELATIVE FITNESS OF FEMALES AND HERMAPHRODITES DURING THE COLONIZATION PROCESS

Recent theoretical models have addressed the influence of metapopulation dynamics on the fitness of females and hermaphrodites in gynodioecious plants. In particular, selection is thought to favor hermaphrodites during population establishment because that sex should be less prone to pollen limitation, especially if self-fertilization is possible. However, inbreeding depression could limit this advantage. In this experimental study of Silene vulgaris, a weedy gynodioecious plant, the fitness of females and hermaphrodites was estimated from seed production in both mixed-sex populations and for individuals isolated from these populations by 20, 40, 80, or 160 m. In mixed populations females display statistically significant greater per capita seed production owing to higher capsule production and higher rates of seed germination. The fitness of both sexes declines with increasing isolation, but at different rates, such that in the 160-m treatment hermaphrodites are by far the more fit sex. Allozyme studies suggest that this differential decline is because the selfing rate in hermaphrodites increases as a function of isolation, at least partially compensating for a decline in the availability of outcross pollen. Overall, the negative effects of pollen limitation on females far outweighs the negative effects of inbreeding depression following selfing in hermaphrodites. Thus, extinction/recolonization dynamics would appear to favor hermaphrodites as long as seed dispersal events exceed some critical distance.     

Males outcompete hermaphrodites for seed siring success in controlled crosses in the polygamous Fraxinus excelsior (Oleaceae)

Polygamy (including trioecy and subdioecy), the co-occurrence of males, hermaphrodites, and females in natural populations, is a rare and poorly studied breeding system expressed in Fraxinus excelsior L. (Oleaceae), a wind-pollinated tree. Here we investigate siring ability of pollen from male vs. hermaphrodite individuals to better understand this sex polymorphism. We conducted single-donor and two-donor pollination experiments and compared both fruit set and seed siring success, assessed with polymorphic microsatellite markers, of male and hermaphrodite individuals. Single pollen donor crosses allowed us to verify the male function of hermaphrodites. However, pollen from hermaphrodites was much less proficient than male pollen, with males siring 10 times as many fruits in single donor pollination treatments. This result was strengthened by the surprisingly low reproductive success of hermaphrodites in pollen competition conditions: of the 110 seedlings analyzed three were selfed and only one was sired by the hermaphrodite donor. The remaining 106 were sired by the male pollen donor. These results raise the question of the maintenance of male fertility in hermaphrodites in Fraxinus excelsior. Male function of hermaphrodites in this species now needs to be assessed under field conditions.     

Geographic variation in the breeding system and the evolutionary stability of trioecy in Pachycereus pringlei (Cactaceae)

The Sonoran Desert columnar cactus Pachycereus pringlei has a geographically variable, non-hermaphroditic breeding system. It is trioecious (separate males, females and hermaphrodites) in the northern two-thirds of its range in Sonora, Mexico, and in the southern three-quarters of its range in Baja California, Mexico, and is gynodioecious (separate females and hermaphrodites) elsewhere. Trioecy occurs near known maternity roosts of its major pollinator, the nectar-feeding bat Leptonycteris curasoae; gynodioecy occurs>50km from known bat roosts. The observed geographic patterns cannot be explained by limited gene flow or by the geographic distributions of diurnal avian pollinators. Our field observations plus a theoretical analysis suggest that the abundance of chiropteran pollinators plays an important role in the maintenance of trioecy in this plant. Under pollinator limitation, trioecy can be a stable breeding system in this species. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Genetic structure of dioecious and trioecious <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salix myrsinifolia</Emphasis> populations at the border of geographic range

Gene flow in plant populations is heavily affected by species sexual systems. In order to study the effect of sexual systems on genetic structure, we examined plastid and nuclear DNA of 12 dioecious (males and females) and 18 trioecious (males, females and hermaphrodites) populations of Salix myrsinifolia—a boreal shrub with slow range expansion. Populations were located along latitudinal gradients across submarginal and marginal parts of the range. Individuals of each sex morph were all hexaploid. We identified 10 chloroplast DNA haplotypes and scored 205 polymorphic bands with amplified fragment length polymorphism. We found dioecious populations that differed from trioecious populations via the presence of four unique haplotypes and significant difference in Nei’s gene diversity index (0.119 vs. 0.116) and down-weighed marker value (1.17 vs. 1.02). The latter parameter, together with haplotype and nucleotide diversity, significantly decreased with latitude similar to the expansion front. Also, we found that 89% of hermaphrodite individuals belong to one distinct in tree parsimony network haplotype. This frequency significantly decreased with latitude towards the expansion front. We suspect that the presence of hermaphrodites in trioecious populations may represent a trade-off between the possibility of producing progeny by single hermaphrodites and genetic variability loss through autogamy. S. myrsinifolia benefits from trioecious sexual systems under colonization events. This phenomenon is no longer a gain closer to the core of the species range.     

Seedling performance in a trioecious cactus,Pachycereus pringlei: Effects of maternity and paternity

We studied seed germination and the growth and survivorship of seedlings of females and hermaphrodites ofPachycereus pringlei (cardon), a Mexican columnar cactus whose geographically variable breeding system includes trioecy and gynodioecy. Results of a two-year field experiment conducted near Bahia Kino, Sonora, Mexico and a ten-month laboratory experiment were similar and did not support the hypothesis that seedlings of females outperform those of hermaphrodites. In the field, percent seed germination and 2-yr seedling survivorship averaged 66% and 95%, respectively and did not differ among six treatment classes. Seedlings of hermaphrodites generally were larger than those of females at the end of both experiments. Selfed seedlings of hermaphrodites did not grow more slowly than outcrossed seedlings of hermaphrodites or females. Hermaphrodite seedlings performed best when pollinated with hermaphrodite pollen; female seedlings performed best with male pollen. We conclude that superior seedling performance cannot explain why females are able to coexist with hermaphrodites in populations of this cactus. Instead, we postulate that greater annual seed production, which averaged 1.6 times higher in females than in hermaphrodites in two years, may be sufficient to allow females to co-occur with hermaphrodites in this large, longlived plant, especially if sex determination involves cytoplasmic-nuclear inheritance.     

When is it worth being a self-compatible hermaphrodite? Context-dependent effects of self-pollination on female advantage in gynodioecious Silene nutans

In gynodioecious plant species with nuclear‐cytoplasmic sex determination, females and hermaphrodites plants can coexist whenever female have higher seed fitness than hermaphrodites. Although the effect of self fertilization on seed fitness in hermaphrodites has been considered theoretically, this effect is far from intuitive, because it can either increase the relative seed fitness of the females (if it leads hermaphrodites to produce inbred, low quality offspring) or decrease it (if it provides reproductive assurance to hermaphrodites). Hence, empirical investigation is needed to document whether relative seed fitness varies with whether pollen is or is not limiting to seed production. In the current study, we measured fruit set and seed production in both females and hermaphrodites and the selfing rate in hermaphrodites in two experimental patches that differed in sex ratios in the gynodioecious plant Silene nutans. We found an impact of plant gender, patch, and their interaction, with females suffering from stronger pollen limitation when locally frequent. In the most pollen‐limited situation, the selfing rate of hermaphrodites increased and provided hermaphrodites with a type of reproductive assurance that is not available to females. By integrating both the beneficial (reproductive assurance) and costly effects (through inbreeding depression) of self‐pollination, we showed that whether females did or did not exhibit higher seed fitness depended on the degree of pollen limitation on seed production.     

EVOLUTION OF UNISEXUALITY IN THE HAWAIIAN FLORA: A TEST OF MICROEVOLUTIONARY THEORY

The evolution of separate sexes as a means of avoiding self-fertilization requires the controversial coexistence of large inbreeding depression and high selfing rate in the ancestral hermaphrodite population. Fitness components of adult females and hermaphrodites in nature, of their open-pollinated progeny, and of experimental selfs and outcrosses onto hermaphrodites were compared in endemic Hawaiian Bidens sandvicensis, all of whose known populations are gynodioecious, consisting of a mixture of females and hermaphrodites. Multilocus selfing rates of hermaphrodites were also estimated, and sex morph ratio monitored over four seasons in three populations of B. sandvicensis and one population of gynodioecious B. cervicata. Total mean inbreeding depression in seed set (in the glasshouse), germination rate (in an open-air nursery on Kauai), and first year survivorship and fecundity in the field were estimated as 0.94 (SE 0.04), and occurred primarily in drought months. Lower survivorship and fecundity of selfs were partially explained by their consistently smaller size. Open-pollinated seed of females had significantly lower germination rate, proportion flowering, and fecundity than outcrossed progeny of hermaphrodites, suggesting moderate biparental inbreeding in females and a lack of any non-outcrossing advantage to progeny of females. In all fitness components, open-pollinated progeny of hermaphrodites were inferior to those of females and to outcrosses, and in most components were superior to selfs. Total performance of open-pollinated progeny of females relative to those of hermaphrodites was calculated as 2.3 (SE = 0.4), but since inflorescences of females also set 20% to 50% more seed than those of hermaphrodites, their total relative ovule success was estimated as 3.2 (SE = 0.5). If inheritance of male sterility is nuclear, this superiority is sufficient to maintain females in frequencies over 20% in populations, whose actual frequencies ranged from 14% to 33%. In four populations, selfing rates of hermaphrodites, assayed in seedlings, were 0.50, 0.45, 0.25, and 0.30, but since substantial inbreeding depression occurred prior to germination, the mean selfing rate of hermaphrodite ovules exceeded 0.57. Female frequencies were significantly higher in the two populations with higher hermaphrodite selfing rate. These results suggest that inbreeding depression can exert a profound influence on the mating system of self-compatible plants on Hawaii and perhaps other oceanic islands, and can be sufficiently strong to electively favor the elimination of the male function.     

Environmental stress maintains trioecy in nematode worms

Sex is determined by chromosomes in mammals but it can be influenced by the environment in many worms, crustaceans, and vertebrates. Despite this, there is little understanding of the relationship between ecology and the evolution of sexual systems. The nematode Auanema freiburgensis has a unique sex determination system in which individuals carrying one X chromosome develop into males while XX individuals develop into females in stress-free environments and self-fertile hermaphrodites in stressful environments. Theory predicts that trioecious populations with coexisting males, females, and hermaphrodites should be unstable intermediates in evolutionary transitions between mating systems. In this article, we study a mathematical model of reproductive evolution based on the unique life history and sex determination of A. freiburgensis. We develop the model in two scenarios, one where the relative production of hermaphrodites and females is entirely dependent on the environment and one based on empirical measurements of a population that displays incomplete, “leaky” environmental dependence. In the first scenario environmental conditions can push the population along an evolutionary continuum and result in the stable maintenance of multiple reproductive systems. The second “leaky” scenario results in the maintenance of three sexes for all environmental conditions. Theoretical investigations of reproductive system transitions have focused on the evolutionary costs and benefits of sex. Here, we show that the flexible sex determination system of A. freiburgensis may contribute to population-level resilience in the microscopic nematode's patchy, ephemeral natural habitat. Our results demonstrate that life history, ecology, and environment may play defining roles in the evolution of sexual systems.     

Floral dimorphism, pollination, and self-fertilization in gynodioecious GERANIUM RICHARDSONII (Geraniaceae)

The selective maintenance of gynodioecy depends on the relative fitness of the male-sterile (female) and hermaphroditic morphs. Females may compensate for their loss of male fitness by reallocating resources from male function (pollen production and pollinator attraction) to female function (seeds and fruits), thus increasing seed production. Females may also benefit from their inability to self-fertilize if selfing and inbreeding depression reduce seed quality in hermaphrodites. We investigated how differences in floral resource allocation (flower size) between female and hermaphroditic plants affect two measures of female reproductive success, pollinator visitation and pollen receipt, in gynodioecious populations of Geranium richardsonii in Colorado. Using emasculation treatments in natural populations, we further examined whether selfing by autogamy and geitonogamy comprises a significant proportion of pollen receipt by hermaphrodites. Flowers of female plants are significantly smaller than those of hermaphrodites. The reduction in allocation to pollinator-attracting structures (petals) is correlated with a significant reduction in pollinator visitation to female flowers in artificial arrays. The reduction in attractiveness is further manifested in significantly less pollen being deposited on the stigmas of female flowers in natural populations. Autogamy is rare in these protandrous flowers, and geitonogamy accounts for most of the difference in pollen receipt between hermaphrodites and females. Female success at receiving pollen was negatively frequency dependent on the relative frequency of females in populations. Thus, two of the prerequisites for the maintenance of females in gynodioecious populations, differences in resource allocation between floral morphs and high selfing rates in hermaphrodites, occur in G. richardsonii.     

Maternal sex and mate relatedness affect offspring quality in the gynodioecious Silene acaulis

In gynodioecious species, females sacrifice fitness by not producing pollen, and hence must have a fitness advantage over hermaphrodites. Because females are obligately outcrossed, they may derive a fitness advantage by avoiding selfing and inbreeding depression. However, both sexes are capable of biparental inbreeding, and there are currently few estimates of the independent effects of maternal sex and multiple levels of inbreeding on female advantage. To test these hypotheses, females and hermaphrodites from six Alaskan populations of Silene acaulis were crossed with pollen from self (hermaphrodites only), a sibling, a random plant within the same population, and a plant from a different population. Germination, survivorship and early growth revealed inbreeding depression for selfs and higher germination but reduced growth in sib-crosses, relative to outcrosses. Independent of mate relatedness, females germinated more seeds that grew faster than offspring from hermaphrodites. This indicates that inbreeding depression as well as maternal sex can influence breeding system evolution. The effect of maternal sex may be explained by higher performance of female genotypes and a greater abundance of female genotypes among the offspring of female mothers.     

Sex ratios and genetic variation in a functionally androdioecious species,Schizopepon bryoniaefolius (Cucurbitaceae)

Androdioecy, coexistence of hermaphrodites and males, is an extremely rare breeding system in angiosperms. In the present study, Schizopepon bryoniaefolius (Cucurbitaceae) was confirmed to be functionally androdioecious based on observations of floral and pollen morphology and bagging experiments. Six out of the 11 studied populations consisted of only hermaphrodites, while the other five populations were androdioecious and the frequencies of males were consistently lower than those of hermaphrodites (5.5–28.3%). To understand the consequences of an androdioecious breeding system, genetic variation was estimated using four polymorphic allozyme loci. The degree of genetic differentiation among 11 populations was high (G_ST = 0.688). Inbreeding coefficients (F_IS) for all loci significantly deviated from zero. In particular, the F_IS values averaged across the polymorphic loci in hermaphrodite populations were close to unity, suggesting that hermaphrodites are predominantly selfing in the absence of males. A significant negative correlation was found between the frequencies of males and inbreeding coefficients, indicating that outcrossing rates depend on the population sex ratio.     

BREAKDOWN OF DIOECY: MODELS WHERE MALES ACQUIRE COSEXUAL FUNCTIONS

We have reanalyzed models of the breakdown of dioecy involving modified males to investigate female frequencies in the resulting gynodioecious populations. We extend and simplify previous treatments to deal with biologically relevant factors including pollen limitation, partial selfing of modified males, and inbreeding depression, to highlight the different empirically detectable advantages that may be gained by modified males that can reproduce as cosexes (i.e., can produce some seeds); these include “inconstant males,” which can sometimes display some female function. Males reproducing wholly or occasionally as cosexual phenotypes can gain the transmission advantage of selfing, if partial self‐fertilization is possible, and from reproductive assurance when pollen is limiting. If, because of resource limitation, such cosexual phenotypes produce fewer ovules than females, their nonselfed ovules will require a lower pollen pool size for full seed‐set, compared with females. We investigate the conditions for these benefits to allow modified males to invade dioecious populations. Sometimes, such invasion leads to replacement of dioecy by the cosexual type, but sometimes the breakdown populations remain sexually polymorphic. When competition occurs between genotypes in the pollen load on a flower, high female frequencies can arise when Y chromosome‐bearing pollen competes poorly with X pollen.     

FEMALE FREQUENCIES IN GYNODIOECIOUS POPULATIONS CORRELATED WITH SELFING RATES IN HERMAPHRODITES

Gynodioecious populations consist of separate hermaphroditic and female individuals. Females are at a selective disadvantage because they contribute genes to the next generation only through ovules, while hermaphrodites contribute genes through ovules and pollen. For females to be maintained in populations they must have some compensating selective advantage. The outcrossing hypothesis postulates that females are maintained because their progeny result from obligate outcrossing, whereas some of the progeny of hermaphrodites result from self-fertilization and are less fit because of inbreeding depression. If correct, the frequency of females should be positively correlated with selfing rates of hermaphrodites in populations. We found a strong positive correlation between female frequency and selfing rates of hermaphrodites (r = 0.91, P < 0.01) in eight gynodioecious populations of Hawaiian species of Bidens. Our results confirm that the obligate outcrossing of females is a major factor maintaining females in gynodioecious populations. However, the observed selfing rates are insufficient by themselves to account for the frequency of females in these populations.