Comparison of colorimetric methods for the quantification of model proteins in aqueous two-phase systems

In the current study, the quantification of different model proteins in the presence of typical aqueous two-phase system components was investigated by using the Bradford and bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assays. Each phase-forming component above 1 and 5 wt% had considerable effects on the protein quantification in both assays, respectively, resulting in diminished protein recoveries/absorption values by increasing poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)/salt concentration and PEG molecular weight. Therefore, a convenient dilution of both components (up to 1 and 5 wt%) before protein quantification is recommended in both assays, respectively, where the BCA assay is favored in comparison with the Bradford assay.     

Evaluating the compatibility of three colorimetric protein assays for two-dimensional electrophoresis experiments

To evaluate compatibility of commonly used colorimetric protein assays for 2-DE experiments, we investigated the interfering mechanisms of major 2-DE component(s) in the Lowry-based assay, the Bradford assay and the bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assay. It was found that some 2-DE components did not directly interfere with the assays' color development reaction, but possibly influenced the quantitation results by interacting with proteins. Generally, simultaneous presence of 2-DE components in the samples demonstrated a cooperative rather than additive interference. Interference by reductants in the Lowry-based assay and the BCA assay were too prominent and could not be completely eliminated by either the reported alkylation procedure or the water dilution procedure. The Bradford assay however, presented a more suitable method for quantitating 2-DE samples because it was less interfered by most 2-DE components. Furthermore, despite slightly compromising protein solubility, utilization of reductant free 2-DE sample buffers conferred application of the Lowry-based and BCA assays in the 2-DE experiments.     

A Comparison of Protein Quantitation Assays for Biopharmaceutical Applications

Dye-based protein determination assays are widely used to estimate protein concentration, however various reports suggest that the response is dependent on the composition and sequence of the protein, limiting confidence in the resulting concentration estimates. In this study a diverse set of model proteins representing various sizes of protein and covalent modifications, some typical of biopharmaceuticals have been used to assess the utility of dye-based protein concentration assays. The protein concentration assays (Bicinchoninic acid (BCA), Bradford, 3-(4-carboxybenzoyl)quinoline-2-carboxaldehyde (CBQCA), DC, Fluorescamine and Quant-i) were compared to the 'gold standard' assay, quantitative amino acid analysis (AAA). The assays that displayed the lowest variability between proteins, BCA and DC, also generated improved estimates when BSA was used as a standard, when compared to AAA derived concentrations. Assays read out by absorbance tended to display enhanced robustness and repeatability, whereas the fluorescence based assays had wider quantitation ranges and lower limits of detection. Protein modification, in the form of glycosylation and PEGylation, and the addition of excipients, were found to affect the estimation of protein concentration for some of the assays when compared to the unmodified protein. We discuss the suitability and limitations of the selected assays for the estimation of protein concentration in biopharmaceutical applications.     

Interferences of suspended clay fraction in protein quantitation by several determination methods

Seven current methods of protein quantitation, Bradford (standard, micro, and 590/450 nm ratio), Lowry, bicinchoninic acid (BCA), UV spectrophotometry at 280 nm, and Quant-iT fluorescence-based determination, were compared with regard to their susceptibility to interferences due to the presence of suspended and not easily detectable clay particles. Bovine serum albumin (BSA) and Na-Wyoming montmorillonite were selected as model protein and reference clay, respectively. Protein-clay suspension mixtures were freshly prepared for each assay to simulate supernatants not completely centrifuged in batch sorption/kinetic experiments. Seven fixed increasing levels of clay (0.0, 0.00725, 0.0145, 0.029, 0.058, 0.145, 0.435 mg ml⁻¹) were mixed with different levels of BSA in an appropriate range for each assay. To ascertain the interfering effect of different levels of clay, the theoretical concentrations of BSA were plotted against the estimated BSA concentrations of the samples, as obtained from the calibration curve of each method. A correct quantitation of the BSA concentration not influenced by clay would be described by a regression line with slope (b) not significantly different from 1 and an intercept (a) not significantly different from zero. At the lowest clay levels (0.00725 mg ml⁻¹) a significant interference was evident for Bradford micro, Bradford 590/450, UV, and fluorescence. The three methods (Bradford standard, Lowry, and BCA) that seemed to show the better performances in the presence of clay after this first screening step also underwent an ANCOVA analysis, with the measured BSA concentrations as dependent variable and the clay concentrations as covariate. The Bradford standard and BCA methods were affected by a clay-dependent interference on BSA quantitation. The Lowry assay was the only method that gave correct estimates of BSA concentrations in the presence of any of the clay levels tested.     

Comparisons of protein extraction procedures and quantification methods for the proteomic analysis of Gram-positive <Emphasis Type="Italic">Paenibacillus</Emphasis> sp. strain D9

Four protein extraction methods and three protein quantification techniques were compared with Paenibacillus sp. whole cells. Proteins were extracted using conventional cell disruption techniques encompassing: sonication and glass bead vortexing, as well as BugBuster Master Mix extraction and Total Protein Kit extraction. The Bradford assay, Folin-Lowry assay and UV absorbance at 280 nm were used for protein quantification methods. Differences in protein profiles were examined by 2D-PAGE and subsequently analysed using PDQuest Advanced 2D Analysis software. All extraction methods revealed proteins over broad molecular weight range. UV absorbance at 280 nm using the NanoDrop™1000 and the Bradford assay yielded best quantification results. Rapid and effective disruption and quantification of Paenibacillus sp. strain D9 cells was successfully achieved using the combination of Total Protein Extraction Kit-UV280 followed by BugBuster Master-UV280.     

Adaptation of the Bradford protein assay to membrane-bound proteins by solubilizing in glucopyranoside detergents

A procedure was developed for the quantitation of solubilized proteins using the Bradford assay in the presence of glucopyranoside detergents. These detergents solubilized membrane-bound proteins with minimal background absorbance at 595 nm. Absorbance at 650 nm was also low, indicating that these detergents do not significantly stabilize the neutral species of Coomassie brilliant blue G-250 that produces interference in the presence of other detergents. Hexyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside produced less absorbance than did larger glucopyranosides, and the increase in its absorbance at 595 nm in the presence of dye reagent was related linearly to its concentration from 0 to 2%. Absorbance produced by membrane-bound protein was increased by the presence of up to 0.2% hexyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside (final concentration in dye reagent) and then remained stable up to 1%, indicating that these concentrations of this detergent allowed membrane-bound proteins to react completely with the dye reagent. Standard curves of several proteins were similar in the absence or presence of 0.1-0.5% hexyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside. The quantitation of both soluble and membrane-bound proteins by the Bradford assay was similar in the presence of 0.2% hexyl-, heptyl-, and octyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside. Estimates of membrane-bound protein by this assay agreed with estimates obtained with the Lowry assay and with quantitative amino acid analysis. This procedure requires no extra steps; thus, it is as rapid and convenient as the original Bradford protein assay.     

Site-specific methylation of a strategic lysyl residue in aspartate aminotransferase

Conditions for reductive methylation of amine groups in proteins using formaldehyde and cyanoborohydride can be chosen to modify selectively the active site lysyl residue of aspartate aminotransferase among the 19 lysyl residues in each subunit of this protein. Apoenzyme must be treated, under mildly acidic conditions (pH = 6), at a relatively low molar ratio of formaldehyde to protein (40:1); and, upon reduction with sodium cyanoborohydride, 85% of the formaldehyde is incorporated at Lysine 258 and 15% at the amino-terminal alanyl residue. The modified protein, characterized after tryptic hydrolysis, separation of the peptides by high performance liquid chromatography procedures and subsequent amino acid analysis, shows that lysine 258 is preferentially modified as a dimethylated derivative. Modified apoenzyme can accept and tightly bind added coenzyme pyridoxal phosphate, as measured by circular dichroism procedures. The methylated enzyme is essentially catalytically inactive when measured by standard enzymatic assays. On the other hand, addition of the substrate, glutamate, produces the characteristic absorption spectral shifts for conversion of the active site-bound pyridoxal form of the coenzyme (absorbance at 400 nm) to its pyridoxamine form (absorbance at 330 nm). Such a half-transamination-like process occurs as in native enzyme, albeit at several orders of magnitude lower rate. This event takes place even though the characteristic internal holoenzyme Schiff's base between Lys-258 and aldehyde of bound pyridoxal phosphate does not exist in methylated, reconstituted holoenzyme. It is concluded that this chemically transformed enzyme can undergo a half-transamination reaction with conversion of active site-bound coenzyme from a pyridoxal to a pyridoxamine form, even when overall catalytic turnover transamination cannot be detected.     

Review of methods to assign the nuclear magnetic resonance peaks of reductively methylated proteins

Reductive methylation of lysyl side-chain amines has been a successful tool in the advancement of high-resolution structural biology. The utility of this method has continuously gained ground as a protein chemical modification, first as a tool to aid protein crystallization and later as a probe in protein nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. As an isotope-labeling strategy for NMR studies, reductive methylation has contributed to the study of protein–protein interactions and global conformational changes. Although more detailed structural studies using this labeling strategy are possible, the hurdle of assigning the NMR peaks to the corresponding reductively methylated amine hinders its use. In this review, we discuss and compare strategies used to assign the NMR peaks of reductively methylated protein amines.     

The highly abundant urinary metabolite urobilin interferes with the bicinchoninic acid assay

Estimation of total protein concentration is an essential step in any protein- or peptide-centric analysis pipeline. This study demonstrates that urobilin, a breakdown product of heme and a major constituent of urine, interferes considerably with the bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assay. This interference is probably due to the propensity of urobilin to reduce cupric ions (Cu²⁺) to cuprous ions (Cu¹⁺), thus mimicking the reduction of copper by proteins, which the assay was designed to do. In addition, it is demonstrated that the Bradford assay is more resistant to the influence of urobilin and other small molecules. As such, urobilin has a strong confounding effect on the estimate of total protein concentrations obtained by BCA assay and thus this assay should not be used for urinary protein quantification. It is recommended that the Bradford assay be used instead.     

Quantification of protein concentration by the Bradford method in the presence of pharmaceutical polymers

We investigated how the Bradford assay for measurements of protein released from a drug formulation may be affected by a concomitant release of a pharmaceutical polymer used to formulate the protein delivery device. The main result is that polymer-caused perturbations of the Coomassie dye absorbance at the Bradford monitoring wavelength (595 nm) can be identified and corrected by recording absorption spectra in the region of 350–850 mm. The pharmaceutical polymers Carbopol and chitosan illustrate two potential types of perturbations in the Bradford assay, whereas the third polymer, hydroxypropylmethylcellulose (HPMC), acts as a nonperturbing control. Carbopol increases the apparent absorbance at 595 nm because the polymer aggregates at the low pH of the Bradford protocol, causing a turbidity contribution that can be corrected quantitatively at 595 nm by measuring the sample absorbance at 850 nm outside the dye absorption band. Chitosan is a cationic polymer under Bradford conditions and interacts directly with the anionic Coomassie dye and perturbs its absorption spectrum, including 595 nm. In this case, the Bradford method remains useful if the polymer concentration is known but should be used with caution in release studies where the polymer concentration may vary and needs to be measured independently.     

The inactivation of plasma alpha 1-proteinase inhibitor by nitrous acid

Exposure of alpha 1-PI to nitrous acid resulted in a complete inactivation of either of its elastase or trypsin inhibitors activities. Amino acid analyses of the nitrous acid treated inhibitor revealed only losses of one tryphanyl and three lysyl residues. Reductive methylation of alpha 1-PI offered no protection against loss of activity by nitrous acid. Since no further loss of lysyl residues was observed upon exposure of fully active reductively methylated alpha 1-PI to nitrous acid, modification of one tryptophanyl residue appears to be responsible for the inhibitor's sensitivity to nitrous acid. Absorption spectral studies of the nitrous acid treated alpha 1-PI indicated that the tryptophanyl residue was modified to its N-nitroso derivative.     

Interference of N-hydroxysuccinimide with bicinchoninic acid protein assay

We report here substantial interference from N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS) in the bicinchoninic acid (BCA) protein assay. NHS is one of the most commonly used crosslinking agents in bioanalytical sciences, which can lead to serious potential errors in the BCA protein assay based protein estimation if it is present in the protein analyte solution. It was identified to be a reducing substance, which interferes with the BCA protein assay by reducing Cu²⁺ in the BCA working reagent. The absorbance peak and absorbance signal of NHS were very similar to those of bovine serum albumin (BSA), thereby indicating a similar BCA reaction mechanism for NHS and protein. However, the combined absorbance of NHS and BSA was not additive. The time–response measurements of the BCA protein assay showed consistent single-phase kinetics for NHS and gradually decreasing kinetics for BSA. The error in protein estimation due to the presence of NHS was counteracted effectively by plotting additional BCA standard curve for BSA with a fixed concentration of NHS. The difference between the absorbance values of BSA and BSA with a fixed NHS concentration provided the absorbance contributed by NHS, which was then subtracted from the total absorbance of analyte sample to determine the actual absorbance of protein in the analyte sample.     

A rapid ion exchange procedure that facilitates spectrophotometric assays of phosphorylated metabolites in potato extracts

A variety of metabolites are routinely assayed after perchloric acid extraction of plant tissues. A common technique uses coupled enzyme assays that produce or consume pyridine nucleotides together with spectrophotometric detection at 340 nm. Because of the presence of pigments in plant tissues, the high absorbance of such extracts usually limits the amount of extract that can be assayed spectrophotometrically. Here, we show that after batch adsorption with AG50WX8 (H⁺ form), the absorbance of potato root perchloric acid extracts at 340 nm is significantly reduced. This clean up procedure does not interfere with the assay or the recovery of anionic metabolites such as hexose phosphates. It therefore facilitates spectrophotometric assays of metabolites in plant extracts with high absorbance.     

Drug interference in the Bradford and 2,2'-bicinchoninic acid protein assays.

The interference of a range of drugs and related substances has been investigated in the Bradford Coomassie brilliant blue (CBB) protein dye-binding assay and the 2,2'-bicinchoninic acid (BCA) protein assays. Chlorpromazine was the only substance to interfere in the CBB assay but the interference was slight. In contrast, the BCA reagent interacted strongly with chlorpromazine, the penicillins, vitamin C, and paracetamol and the mode of interference varied with the test substance. The chlorpromazine produced turbidity and an atypical color. The penicillins show a slow but normal color response while vitamin C and paracetamol gave an immediate and intense response.     

Differences in lysine pKa values may be used to improve NMR signal dispersion in reductively methylated proteins

Reductive methylation of lysine residues in proteins offers a way to introduce ¹³C methyl groups into otherwise unlabeled molecules. The ¹³C methyl groups on lysines possess favorable relaxation properties that allow highly sensitive NMR signal detection. One of the major limitations in the use of reductive methylation in NMR is the signal overlap of ¹³C methyl groups in NMR spectra. Here we show that the uniform influence of the solvent on chemical shifts of exposed lysine methyl groups could be overcome by adjusting the pH of the buffering solution closer to the pKa of lysine side chains. Under these conditions, due to variable pKa values of individual lysine side chains in the protein of interest different levels of lysine protonation are observed. These differences are reflected in the chemical shift differences of methyl groups in reductively methylated lysines. We show that this approach is successful in four different proteins including Ca²⁺-bound Calmodulin, Lysozyme, Ca²⁺-bound Troponin C, and Glutathione S-Transferase. In all cases significant improvement in NMR spectral resolution of methyl signals in reductively methylated proteins was obtained. The increased spectral resolution helps with more precise characterization of protein structural rearrangements caused by ligand binding as shown by studying binding of Calmodulin antagonist trifluoperazine to Calmodulin. Thus, this approach may be used to increase resolution in NMR spectra of ¹³C methyl groups on lysine residues in reductively methylated proteins that enhances the accuracy of protein structural assessment. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assay in low volume

The BCA assay is a colorimetric method for estimating protein concentration. In 96-well plates, the relationship between protein content and absorbance is nearly linear over a wide range; however, performance is reduced in lower volume. To overcome this limitation, we performed the BCA assays in opaque, white 384-well plates. These plates emit fluorescence between 450–600 nm when excited at 430 nm; thus, their fluorescence is quenched by the BCA chromophore (λ_max 562 nm). This arrangement allowed accurate determination of protein content using only 2 μL of sample. Moreover, soluble flourescein could replace the white plates, creating a homogenous format.     

Sulfo-N-hydroxysuccinimide interferes with bicinchoninic acid protein assay

This study revealed a major interference from sulfo-N-hydroxysuccinimide (sulfo-NHS) in the bicinchoninic acid (BCA) protein assay. Sulfo-NHS, a common reagent used in bioconjugation and analytical biochemistry, exhibited absorbance signals and absorbance peaks at 562 nm, comparable to bovine serum albumin (BSA). However, the combined absorbance of sulfo-NHS and BSA was not strictly additive. The sulfo-NHS interference was suggested to be caused by the reduction of Cu²⁺ in the BCA Kit’s reagent B (4% cupric sulfate) in a manner similar to that of the protein.     

Determination of myrosinase (thioglucoside glucohydrolase) activity by a spectrophotometric coupled enzyme assay

The hexokinase/glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase coupled enzyme system was used to assay for plant thioglucoside glucohydrolase (myrosinase, EC 3.2.3.1) by measuring the rate of glucose released during hydrolysis of glucosinolates. This coupled assay was compared with two other assays for myrosinase: a pH-stat assay that measures the rate of acid released during glucosinolate hydrolysis, and a spectrophotometric assay in which the decrease in the absorbance at 227.5 nm is used to measure the disappearance of the substrate, 2-propenylglucosinolate (DSA assay). The coupled and pH-stat assays were found to give comparable activities and were linear with enzyme concentration over the range 0 to 30 micrograms. The DSA assay gave lower myrosinase activity in comparison to the coupled and pH-stat assays. This is due to the lower concentrations of substrate and activator (ascorbate) which must be used in the assay. The DSA assay was found to give a nonlinear relationship with enzyme concentration over the range 2 to 30 micrograms. For these reasons this assay was found to be unsatisfactory. The coupled assay was found to be more sensitive and more widely applicable than the pH-stat assay as a routine continuous assay for myrosinase activity.     

Rapid method for protein quantitation by Bradford assay after elimination of the interference of polysorbate 80

Bradford assay is one of the most common methods for measuring protein concentrations. However, some pharmaceutical excipients, such as detergents, interfere with Bradford assay even at low concentrations. Protein precipitation can be used to overcome sample incompatibility with protein quantitation. But the rate of protein recovery caused by acetone precipitation is only about 70%. In this study, we found that sucrose not only could increase the rate of protein recovery after 1 h acetone precipitation, but also did not interfere with Bradford assay. So we developed a method for rapid protein quantitation in protein drugs even if they contained interfering substances.     

Homogeneous noncompetitive assay of protein via Förster-resonance-energy-transfer with tryptophan residue(s) as intrinsic donor(s) and fluorescent ligand as acceptor

Homogeneous noncompetitive assay of a protein in biological samples based on Förster-resonance-energy-transfer (FRET) was proposed by using its tryptophan residues as intrinsic donors and its specific fluorescent ligand as the FRET acceptor that was defined as an analytical FRET probe. Conjugate of a suitable fluorophore, which should have an excitation peak around 340 nm but an excitation valley around 280 nm, with a moiety binding to a protein of interest gave an analytical FRET probe to the protein. To test this method, N-biotinyl-N′-(1-naphthyl)-ethylenediamine (BNEDA) was used as an analytical FRET probe for homogeneous noncompetitive assay of streptavidin (SAV). The occurrence of FRET between the bound BNEDA and tryptophan residues was supported by the modeled geometry of the complex. By excitation at 280 nm, free BNEDA produced negligible fluorescence at 430 nm, but the bound BNEDA produced much higher stable fluorescence at 430 nm after 2 min of binding reaction. The competitive binding between BNEDA and biotin gave the dissociation constant of (16 ± 3) fM for BNEDA (n = 3). By excitation at 280 nm, fluorescence at 430 nm of reaction mixtures containing 32.0 nM BNEDA responded linearly to SAV subunit concentrations ranging from 0.40 to 30.0 nM with the desirable resistance to common interferences in biological samples. Therefore, by using tryptophan residue(s) in a protein of interest as intrinsic donor(s) and its fluorescent ligand as the corresponding FRET acceptor, this homogeneous noncompetitive assay of the protein in biological samples was effective and advantageous.