Comparative binding study of the interaction of quinacrine and ethidium bromide with DNA and nucleohistone

The degree of binding of quinacrine dihydrochloride and ethidium bromide to DNA and nucleohistone has been determined by direct and indirect methods.The results obtained by the equilibrium dialysis experiments have been analyzed in terms of various theoretical models and have led us to propose for the interaction of the dyes with DNA at low ionic strength a structural scheme where the external binding sites are next to the intercalative ones.The equilibrium dialysis results were used to check those obtained by the indirect methods, i.e. absorption and fluorescence titrations, and to identify the origin of the discrepancies.The comparative study of the binding of these dyes to DNA and nucleohistone has shown that the accessible part of DNA in the nucleoprotein is to some extent different from free DNA itself.     

Comparative viscometric analysis of the interaction of chloroquine and quinacrine with superhelical and sonicated DNA.

Unwinding angles for the structurally related antimalarial drugs chloroquine and quinacrine have been determined with superhelical Col E1 plasmid DNA by applying the quantitative method developed by Vinograd and co-workers (Revet, B.M., Schmir, M. and Vinograd, J. (1971) Nat. New Biol. 229, 10). The value for chloroquine, 8.6 degrees, calculated assuming an unwinding angle of 26 degrees for ethidium bromide, is significantly lower than the value for quinacrine, 22.5 degrees, calculated in the same manner. Viscometric titrations with sonicated calf thymus DNA were quantitated using available binding constants for the two drugs and indicated that chloroquine also causes significantly smaller DNA length increases on intercalation relative to quinacrine. The conclusion from these experiments is that chloroquine does not bind to DNA by the classical intercalation mechanism typical of quinacrine and ethidium.     

Connection of ethidium bromide with single-stranded DNA

The interaction of ethidium bromide with single-stranded synthetic and natural polynucleotides at high temperatures (t = 70 degrees C) and low pH values (pH 3.0) was studied. The isotherms of adsorption of ethidium bromide on single-stranded DNA were obtained. Two modes of binding of single-stranded DNA, strong and weak, were revealed. The values of the corresponding constants of interaction of this ligand and the number of bases per one binding site were determined.     

Binding of ethidium bromide and quinacrine hydrochloride to nucleic acids and reconstituted nucleohistones

Studies of binding of ethidium bromide and quinacrine hydrochloride to native DNA at low ionic strength indicate that for both compounds the binding is selective, with about one binding site for about four nucleotides. Annealing of unfractionated histones to DNA by a salt-gradient dialysis method slightly decreases the binding of the dyes to DNA. Similar observations made with reconstituted preparations by using individual histone fractions reveal that the arginine-rich histones (histones H3 and H4) are most effective in decreasing the binding. The binding studies with ethidium bromide at high ionic strength and with denatured DNA show that strong dye binding to DNA is strongly dependent on the ionic strength and on the secondary structure of DNA. The histones are not effective in decreasing the dye binding under conditions of high ionic strength. The results are consistent with the observations [Oliver & Chalkley (1974) Biochemistry13, 5093-5098; Axel, Melchoir, Sollner-Web & Felsenfield (1974) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.71, 4101-4105] that histones form some kind of surface structures on DNA through non-specific interactions and [Kornberg & Thomas (1974) Science184, 865-868; Kornberg (1974) Science184, 868-871; D'Anna & Isenberg (1974) Biochemistry13, 4992-4997; Vandegrift, Serra, Marve & Wagner (1974) Biochemistry13, 5087-5092] that the tendency of arginine-rich histones to aggregate may be an important factor in determining the structure of chromatin.     

Stacking interactions of ethidium bromide bound to a polyphosphate and phage DNA in situ

Ethidium bromide forms spectroscopically detectable aggregates in aqueous solution and at a high dye concentration larger than 1 × 10^?3 moles/ρ. At moderate concentration in the order of 1 × 10^?4 moles/ρ the dye interacts with inorganic polyphosphate Graham salt and with phage sd DNA in situ by formation of stacking complexes. Maximal stacking was found at a phosphate to dye ratio, P/D, of approximately 1 for Graham salt and 1.5–2 for phages. In going to a higher P/D ratio Graham salt dye complex dissociates again and free dye reappears, while phage dye binding changes from stacking (type II complex) to intercalation (type I complex). Stacking is accompanied by a decrease and intercalation by an increase of relative fluorescence intensity with respect to free dye. However, both binding types lead to hypechromism and a red shift of the dye absorption band in the visible spectral region. Thus spectral behavior of ethidium aggregates deviate clearly from that known for other dyes, i.e., acridines.     

Thermodynamic analysis of complex formation of ethidium bromide with DNA in water solutions

A thermodynamic analysis of two types of binding of ethidium bromide with DNA: intercalation and binding to the outer surface of a biopolymer has been performed by spectrophotometry. It has been shown that the dominant contribution to the energy of external binding of the ligand to DNA is made by hydrophobic interactions, which lead to less negative values of enthalpy and entropy and more severe negative changes in the heat capacity of complex formation as compared with the intercalation type of binding.     

Renaturation of DNA in the presence of ethidium bromide

The rate of renaturation of T2 DNA has been studied as a fuction of ethidium bound per nucleotide of denatured DNA. The Binding constants and number of binding sites for ethidium have been determined by spectral titration for denatured DNA at 55, 65, and 75°C and for native DNA at 65°C in 0.4M Na⁺. The rate of renaturation of T2 DNA was found to be independentof ethidium binding up to 0.03 moles per mole of nucleotide. Above 0.03 moles, the rate drops off precipitously approaching zero at 0.08 and 0.06 moles bound ethidium per nucleotide at 65°C respectively. A study was also made of the use of bound ethidium fluorescence as a probe for monitoring DNA renaturation reactions.     

Interaction of ethidium bromide with DNA. Optical and electrooptical study

The binding of ethidium bromide to DNA has been studied by various optical methods. From fluorescence polarization studies, and film, electric linear dichroism, and circular dichroism spectra, we propose assignments of the absorption bands of the dye, which are discussed in connection with wave-mechanical calculations recently reported. The optical activity induced in the dye absorption bands upon binding to DNA was attributed to various origins depending on the electronic transition considered. The visible absorption band displayed a circular dichroism due to the asymmetry of the binding site and independent of the amount of binding. The transition identified at 378 nm from the circular dichroism and electric dichroism observations was thought to be due to a magnetic-dipole transition. It remained constant with increasing amounts of dye bound. The main ultraviolet band showed circular dichroism characteristics corresponding to exciton interactions between dye molecules bound to neighboring sites. The electric dichroism observed for the strongly bound dye molecules indicated that the phenanthridinium ring of ethidium bromide was probably not perfectly parallel to the DNA base planes. When the amount of dye bound to DNA exceeded the maximum amount compatible with the exclusion of adjacent binding sites, the electric dichroism decreased owing to the appearance of externally bound dye molecules with no contribution to the dichroism. Sonicated DNA was used to study the lengthening of the DNA molecule upon complexation. Although the viscosity of the complexes increased with the amount of binding, the rotational diffusion coefficient measured by the electric birefringence relaxation was not detectably affected. The absence of variation in the electric birefringence with the binding indicated that the DNA base stacking remained unaltered.     

Fluorescence lifetime analysis of DNA intercalated ethidium bromide and quenching by free dye

The fluorescence characteristics of ethidium bromide (Eb) complexed to calf thymus DNA have been examined using fluorescence lifetime analysis for a range of DNA (effective nucleotide concentration) to Eb molar ratios. Control of both temperature and ion concentration is necessary for reproducible analyses. Eb complexed to double stranded DNA has a maximum fluorescence lifetime of 23 ns and is easily distinguishable from a fluorescence lifetime value of 1.67 ns corresponding to unbound Eb. In a solution of calf thymus DNA containing excess Eb a binding equilibrium is reached, and this corresponds to one Eb molecule for every five nucleotides. With increasing amounts of unbound Eb, the fluorescence lifetime of the DNA-Eb complex decreases with a concomitant drop in the steady state fluorescence intensity, without a change in the amount of Eb bound to DNA. It is concluded that unbound Eb, acting via a quenching mechanism, shortens the fluorescence lifetime of bound Eb and consequently decreases the overall fluorescence intensity. This means that a different approach is necessary: time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy directly distinguishes between a decrease in fluorescence intensity due to quenching by an excess of unbound Eb from that due to a decrease in Eb binding to double-stranded DNA. These studies suggest that techniques which measure total steady state fluorescence intensity of bound Eb in order to infer relative amounts of double-stranded DNA must be interpreted with caution. For such assays to be valid it is essential that no unbound Eb be present; otherwise a variable correction factor is required to account for unbound Eb.     

Interaction of the dye ethidium bromide with DNA containing guanine repeats.

DNA containing one or more copies of the motifs repeated in telomere sequences has unusual conformational properties. The isolated sequence from the protozoan Oxytricha, dT4G4 has the potential to form tetramers in the presence of sodium or potassium ions. We report here that these tetramers bind ethidium tightly, with an interaction that fulfills several criteria for an intercalative mechanism in the G sequence. By contrast, the 4-fold tandem repeat of this subunit, d(T4G4)4, does not interact specifically with ethidium in the presence of Na+. This difference might have a simple structural basis: the tetramer of dT4G4 forms a stack of four G-quartets in the presence of Na+ or K+, whereas the constraint imposed by the T4 "tethers" in the repeat d(T4G4)4 allows only two layers to form in the presence of Na+. In the presence of sufficient K+, the latter can partially form a four-layer G-quartet structure, which interacts with ethidium. This idea is supported by analysis of a "relaxed" sequence, dT4G4(T7G4)3, which allows formation of four G-quartets and binds ethidium in the presence of Na+ as well as K+. Ethidium (and intercalators generally) should thus be able to retard or inhibit the action of telomerase in the presence of K+.     

Influence of the amino substituents in the interaction of ethidium bromide with DNA

A key step in the rational design of new DNA binding agents is to obtain a complete thermodynamic characterization of small molecule-DNA interactions. Ethidium bromide has served as a classic DNA intercalator for more than four decades. This work focuses on delineating the influence(s) of the 3- and 8-amino substituents of ethidium on the energetic contributions and concomitant fluorescent properties upon DNA complex formation. Binding affinities decrease by an order of magnitude upon the removal of either the 3- or 8-amino substituent, with a further order-of-magnitude decrease in the absence of both amino groups. The thermodynamic binding mechanism changes from enthalpy-driven for the parent ethidium to entropy-driven when both amino groups are removed. Upon DNA binding, fluorescence enhancement is observed in the presence of either or both of the amino groups, likely because of more efficient fluorescence quenching through solvent interactions of free amino groups than when buried within the intercalation site. The des-amino ethidium analog exhibits fluorescence quenching upon binding, consistent with less efficient quenching of the chromophore through interactions with solvent than within the intercalation site. Determination of the quantum efficiencies suggests distinct differences in the environments of the 3- and 8-amino substituents within the DNA binding site.     

The complex of ethidium bromide with genomic DNA: structure analysis by polarized Raman spectroscopy

Structural properties of the complex formed between genomic DNA and the intercalating drug ethidium bromide (EtBr) have been determined by use of a Raman microscope equipped with near-infrared laser excitation. The polarized spectra, which were obtained from oriented fibers of the EtBr:DNA complex, are interpreted in terms of the relative orientations of the phenanthridinium ring of EtBr and bases of DNA. Quantification of structure parameters of EtBr and DNA in the complex were assessed using Raman tensors obtained from polarized Raman analyses of oriented specimens of EtBr (single crystal) and DNA (hydrated fiber). We find that the phenanthridinium plane is tilted by 35+/-5 degrees from the plane perpendicular to the fiber (DNA helix) axis. Assuming coplanarity of the phenanthridinium ring and its immediate base neighbors at the intercalation site, such bases would have a tilt angle closer to that of A-DNA (20 degrees) than to that of B-DNA (6 degrees). The average base tilt in stretches of DNA between intercalation sites remains that of B-DNA.     

The thermodynamics of drug-DNA interactions: ethidium bromide and propidium iodide

We report the first calorimetrically-derived characterization of the thermodynamics of ethidium bromide (EB) and propidium iodide (PI) binding to a series of nucleic acid host duplexes. Our spectroscopic and calorimetric measurements yield the following results: 1) At low salt (16mM Na+) and 25 degrees C. PI binds more strongly than EB to a given host duplex. The magnitude of this PI preference depends only marginally on base sequence, with AT base pairs showing a greater PI preference than GC base pairs. 2) The enhanced binding of PI relative to EB at low salt and 25 degrees C reflects a more favorable entropic driving force for PI binding. 3) The PI binding preference diminishes at higher salt concentrations (216mM). In other words, the binding preference is electrostatic in origin. 4) The salt dependence of the binding constants (delta lnKb/delta ln[Na+]) reveal that PI binds as a dication while EB binds as a monocation. 5) PI and EB both exhibit impressive enthalpy-entropy compensations when they bind to the deoxy homopolymers poly dA.poly dT and poly dA.poly dU. We have observed a similar enthalpy-entropy compensation for netropsin binding to the poly dA.poly dT homopolymer duplex. We therefore conclude that the compensation phenomenon is an intrinsic property of the host duplex rather than reflecting a property of the binding ligand. 6) When either PI or EB bind to the corresponding ribo homopolymer (poly rA.poy rU) we do not observe the enthalpy-entropy compensation that characterizes the binding to the deoxy homopolymer. 7) EB and PI both bind more strongly to poly d(AT).poly d(AT) than to poly d(AU).poly d(AU). Specifically, the absence of the thymine methyl group in poly d(AU).poly d(AU) reduces the binding constant of both drugs by a factor of four. This reduction in binding is due to a less favorable entropy change. In this paper we present and discuss possible molecular origins for our observed thermodynamic and extra-thermodynamic data. In particular, we evoke solvent effects involving both the drugs and the host duplexes when we propose molecular interpretations which are consistent with our thermodynamic data.     

The EcoRI restriction endonuclease, covalently closed DNA and ethidium bromide.

The reactions of the EcoRI restriction endonuclease on the covalently closed DNA of plasmid pMB9 were studied in the presence of ethidium bromide. At the concentrations of ethidium bromide tested, which covered the range over which the DNA is changed from negatively to positively supercoiled, the dye caused no alteration to the rate at which this enzyme cleaved the covalently closed DNA to yield the open-circle form, but the rate at which these open circles were cleaved to the linear product could be inhibited. The fluorescence change, caused by ethidium bromide binding with different stoichiometries to covalently closed and open-circle DNA, provided a direct and sensitive signal for monitoring the cleavage of DNA by this enzyme. This method was used for a steady-state kinetic analysis of the reaction catalysed by the EcoRI restriction enzyme. Reaction mechanisms where a complex between DNA and Mg2+ is the substrate for this enzyme were eliminated, and instead DNA and Mg2+ must bind to the enzyme in separate stages. The requisite controls for this fluorimetric assay in both steady-state and transient kinetics studies, and its application to other enzymes that alter the structure of covalently closed DNA, are described.     

Accuracy and reliability of flow cytometric DNA analysis using a simple, one-step ethidium bromide staining protocol

Sources of variation and error were investigated for a simple flow cytometric analysis of DNA content of detergent-isolated nuclei stained with ethidium bromide. Using the ploidy classes of mouse liver nuclei, deviations from linearity were assessed for three different instruments. In more extreme settings, the maximum deviations for a FACS instrument were up to 6 to 9%, but in general deviations were around 1% or lower for all instruments. As biological DNA standards, human peripheral lymphocytes and trout erythrocytes appeared to be suitable and easy to store frozen. The erythrocytes had dye-binding characteristics similar to those of human lymphocytes and a 20% lower fluorescence, thus being well suited as an internal standard, as was demonstrated in tumor ploidy analyses performed with varied tissue concentration. Staining homogeneity was improved when staining time was extended to 24 h, at which time male and female lymphocytes were completely separated with an average difference in DNA content of 1.9%. A small difference in fluorescence between mitogen-stimulated and unstimulated lymphocytes was reduced to less than 1% after 24 h of staining. In general, the manipulations of the conditions for the analysis resulted in maximum variations of around 1%, indicating the robustness and reliability of the technique.