Common and distinct roles of juvenile hormone signaling genes in metamorphosis of holometabolous and hemimetabolous insects

Insect larvae metamorphose to winged and reproductive adults either directly (hemimetaboly) or through an intermediary pupal stage (holometaboly). In either case juvenile hormone (JH) prevents metamorphosis until a larva has attained an appropriate phase of development. In holometabolous insects, JH acts through its putative receptor Methoprene-tolerant (Met) to regulate Krüppel-homolog 1 (Kr-h1) and Broad-Complex (BR-C) genes. While Met and Kr-h1 prevent precocious metamorphosis in pre-final larval instars, BR-C specifies the pupal stage. How JH signaling operates in hemimetabolous insects is poorly understood. Here, we compare the function of Met, Kr-h1 and BR-C genes in the two types of insects. Using systemic RNAi in the hemimetabolous true bug, Pyrrhocoris apterus, we show that Met conveys the JH signal to prevent premature metamorphosis by maintaining high expression of Kr-h1. Knockdown of either Met or Kr-h1 (but not of BR-C) in penultimate-instar Pyrrhocoris larvae causes precocious development of adult color pattern, wings and genitalia. A natural fall of Kr-h1 expression in the last larval instar normally permits adult development, and treatment with an exogenous JH mimic methoprene at this time requires both Met and Kr-h1 to block the adult program and induce an extra larval instar. Met and Kr-h1 therefore serve as JH-dependent repressors of deleterious precocious metamorphic changes in both hemimetabolous and holometabolous juveniles, whereas BR-C has been recruited for a new role in specifying the holometabolous pupa. These results show that despite considerable evolutionary distance, insects with diverse developmental strategies employ a common-core JH signaling pathway to commit to adult morphogenesis.     

Broad-complex functions in postembryonic development of the cockroach Blattella germanica shed new light on the evolution of insect metamorphosis

Background

Insect metamorphosis proceeds in two modes: hemimetaboly, gradual change along the life cycle; and holometaboly, abrupt change from larvae to adult mediated by a pupal stage. Both are regulated by 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E), which promotes molts, and juvenile hormone (JH), which represses adult morphogenesis. Expression of Broad-complex (BR-C) is induced by 20E and modulated by JH. In holometabolous species, like Drosophila melanogaster, BR-C expression is inhibited by JH in young larvae and enhanced in mature larvae, when JH declines and BR-C expression specifies the pupal stage.

Methods

Using Blattella germanica as a basal hemimetabolous model, we determined the patterns of expression of BR-C mRNAs using quantitative RT-PCR, and we studied the functions of BR-C factors using RNA interference approaches.

Results

We found that BR-C expression is enhanced by JH and correlates with JH hemolymph concentration. BR-C factors appear to be involved in cell division and wing pad growth, as well as wing vein patterning.

Conclusions

In B. germanica, expression of BR-C is enhanced by JH, and BR-C factors appear to promote wing growth to reach the right size, form and patterning, which contrast with the endocrine regulation and complex functions observed in holometabolous species.

General significance

Our results shed new light to the evolution from hemimetaboly to holometaboly regarding BR-C, whose regulation and functions were affected by two innovations: 1) a shift in JH action on BR-C expression during young stages, from stimulatory to inhibitory, and 2) an expansion of functions, from regulating wing development, to determining pupal morphogenesis.     

Some old concepts and new findings on hormonal control of insect morphogenesis

By means of the artificially induced heterochronic developmental deviations represented by local prothetelies and metathetelies it has been possible to investigate the individual developmental fates of ontogenetically different tissues, such as larval, pupal, and adult epidermal cells, in one and the same body and under the identical concentration of juvenile hormone (JH) in the haemolymph.In contrast to the widely accepted hormonal theories which claim that the kind of morphogenesis is determined by large, intermediate, and low titres of JH, the heterochronic character of the tissues never developed into a uniform population of homomorphic epidermal cells. Instead, in the presence of effective amounts of JH the heterochronic pattern has been fully preserved and carried on into the next developmental instar. Moreover, in the absence of the effective JH amounts the ontogenetically different tissues, such as larval and pupal epidermal cells, simultaneously undergo their respective morphogenetic developments, i.e. larval-pupal and pupal-adult morphogenesis in the same hormonal milieu. It is concluded that the selective factor in determination of the kind of morphogenetical changes is not an altered JH titre but the extant, previously attained degree of ontogenetic structural differentiation. It has been demonstrated that JH can temporarily and reversibly inhibit the morphogenetic progress at quite different ontogenetic levels but it cannot cause a ‘reversal of metamorphosis’ at any of these levels.Under specific experimental conditions the larval epidermal cells can undergo pupal and adult morphogenesis without secreting the pupal cuticle. However, the pupal morphogenetic interstage, whether with the cuticle or without the pupal cuticle, constitutes an obligatory developmental step. Further, it appears that an absence of JH may represent an important condition but not a real cause of insect metamorphosis, as presumed in some other hormonal concepts. Thus, chromosomal duplications or cellular divisions in the absence of JH have not committed the cells to morphogenesis unless provided by an additional stimulus of endogenous prothoracic gland hormone or exogenous ecdysterone. An important factor in understanding the hormonal control of insect morphogenesis is the critical timing of the respective morphogenetic steps. This corresponds closely with the duration of the pharate phases in insect development. Possible hormonal mechanisms concerned in the regulation of morphogenesis in endopterygote insects have been outlined.     

Hormonal regulation and patterning of the broad-complex in the epidermis and wing discs of the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta

Expression of Manduca Broad-Complex (BR-C) mRNA in the larval epidermis is under the dual control of ecdysone and juvenile hormone (JH). Immunocytochemistry with antibodies that recognize the core, Z2, and Z4 domains of Manduca BR-C proteins showed that BR-C appearance not only temporally correlates with pupal commitment of the epidermis on day 3 of the fifth (final) larval instar, but also occurs in a strict spatial pattern within the abdominal segment similar to that seen for the loss of sensitivity to JH. Levels of Z2 and Z4 BR-C proteins shift with Z2 predominating at pupal commitment and Z4 dominant during early pupal cuticle synthesis. Both induction of BR-C mRNA in the epidermis by 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E) and its suppression by JH were shown to be independent of new protein synthesis. For suppression JH must be present during the initial exposure to 20E. When JH was given 6 h after 20E, suppression was only seen in those regions that had not yet expressed BR-C. In the wing discs BR-C was first detected earlier 1.5 days after ecdysis, coincident with the pupal commitment of the wing. Our findings suggest that BR-C expression is one of the first molecular events underlying pupal commitment of both epidermis and wing discs.     

Steroid receptor co-activator is required for juvenile hormone signal transduction through a bHLH-PAS transcription factor, methoprene tolerant

Metamorphosis in insects is regulated by juvenile hormone (JH) and ecdysteroids. The mechanism of 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E), but not of JH action, is well understood. A basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH)-Per-Arnt-Sim (PAS) family member, methoprene tolerant (Met), plays an important role in JH action. Microarray analysis and RNA interference (RNAi) were used to identify 69 genes that require Met for their hydroprene-regulated expression in the red flour beetle, Tribolium castaneum. Quantitative real time PCR analysis confirmed microarray data for 13 of the 16 hydroprene-response genes tested. The members of the bHLH-PAS family often function as heterodimers to regulate gene expression and Met is a member of this family. To determine whether other members of the bHLH-PAS family are required for the expression of JH-response genes, we employed RNAi to knockdown the expression of all 11 members of the bHLH-PAS family and studied the expression of JH-response genes in RNAi insects. These studies showed that besides Met, another member of this family, steroid receptor co-activator (SRC) is required for the expression of 15 JH-response genes tested. Moreover, studies in JH responsive Aag-2 cells revealed that Aedes aegypti homologues of both Met and SRC are required for the expression of the JH-response gene, kr-h1, and SRC is required for expression of ecdysone-response genes. These data suggest the steroid receptor co-activator plays key roles in both JH and 20E action suggesting that this may be an important molecule that mediates cross-talk between JH and 20E to prevent metamorphosis.     

Mechanisms of midgut remodeling: juvenile hormone analog methoprene blocks midgut metamorphosis by modulating ecdysone action

In holometabolous insects such as mosquito, Aedes aegypti, midgut undergoes remodeling during metamorphosis. Insect metamorphosis is regulated by several hormones including juvenile hormone (JH) and 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E). The cellular and molecular events that occur during midgut remodeling were investigated by studying nuclear stained whole mounts and cross-sections of midguts and by monitoring the mRNA levels of genes involved in 20E action in methoprene-treated and untreated Ae. aegypti. We used JH analog, methoprene, to mimic JH action. In Ae. aegypti larvae, the programmed cell death (PCD) of larval midgut cells and the proliferation and differentiation of imaginal cells were initiated at about 36h after ecdysis to the 4th instar larval stage (AEFL) and were completed by 12h after ecdysis to the pupal stage (AEPS). In methoprene-treated larvae, the proliferation and differentiation of imaginal cells was initiated at 36h AEFL, but the PCD was initiated only after ecdysis to the pupal stage. However, the terminal events that occur for completion of PCD during pupal stage were blocked. As a result, the pupae developed from methoprene-treated larvae contained two midgut epithelial layers until they died during the pupal stage. Quantitative PCR analyses showed that methoprene affected midgut remodeling by modulating the expression of ecdysone receptor B, ultraspiracle A, broad complex, E93, ftz-f1, dronc and drice, the genes that are shown to play key roles in 20E action and PCD. Thus, JH analog, methoprene acts on Ae. aegypti by interfering with the expression of genes involved in 20E action resulting in a block in midgut remodeling and death during pupal stage.     

Mispatterning in the ommatidia of Apis mellifera pupae treated with a juvenile hormone analogue

To further understand the function of morphogenetic hormones in honeybee eye differentiation, the alterations in ommatidial patterning induced by pyriproxyfen, a juvenile hormone (JH) analogue, were studied by scanning and transmission electron microscopy. Prepupae of prospective honeybee workers were treated with pyriproxyfen and the effects on ommatidial differentiation were described at the end of the pupal development. The results show that the entire ommatidia, i.e., the dioptric as well as the receptor systems, were affected by the JH analogue. The wave of ommatidial differentiation, which progresses from the posterior to the anterior region of the pupal eyes, was arrested. In treated pupae, the rhabdomeres only differentiated at the apical axis of the retinula, the secondary and tertiary pigment cells did not develop their cytoplasm protrusions, and the cone cell quartet did not pattern correctly. Simultaneously, an intense vacuolization was observed in cells forming ommatidia. In a previous study we showed that pyriproxyfen exerts an inhibition on pupal ecdysteroid secretion. In this sense, the arrested ommatidial differentiation in pyriproxyfen-treated pupae could be due to a secondary effect resulting from an alteration in pupal ecdysteroid titers.     

Patterning during pupal commitment of the epidermis in the butterfly, Precis coenia: the role of intercellular communication

The commitment of cells to pupal development in the larvae of holometabolous insects can be prevented by treatment with juvenile hormone (JH) or a JH mimic during a critical period early in the last larval instar. By treating larvae of different ages with a JH mimic, pupal commitment of the epidermis of the butterfly, Precis coenia, was found to occur in a strict temporal and spatial progression, which was serially homologous and occurred independently in each segment. The mechanism underlying this sequence of pupal commitment was examined by cauterizing regions of the epidermis to observe the effects of local ablation on the pattern of pupal commitment revealed by treatment with the JH mimic. Cautery of the segmental site of origin of pupal commitment, the dorsal midline, suppressed pupal commitment in the rest of the operated segment, indicating that the midline has a special effect on commitment of the rest of the segment. Cautery off the midline produced asymmetries in the pattern of pupal commitment; when placed close to the midline, such cauteries prevented pupal commitment in the region "downstream" of the cautery, suggesting that a signal (diffusible or transducible) emanates from the midline. Finally, cautery of a circle around the midline inhibited pupal commitment only outside the circle, showing that cautery could act as a barrier to the passage of a signal coming from the midline. These results suggest that inductive as well as hormonal signals are involved in the regulation of pupal commitment in the epidermis of the lepidopteran, P. coenia.     

Action de l'hormone juvenile et de certains mimetiques sur l'epithelium intestinal chez Galleria mellonella

We have investigated the influence of juvenile hormone (JH) on the intestinal epithelium of G. mellonella, in vivo and in vitro. The larvae undergoing a supernumerary instar present a typical larval epithelium with columnar (CL) and globlet (CF) cells; the spinning period is characterized by a delay and a loss of synchronism in the process of differentiation of intermediates cells (Ci) typical of the pharate pupa. The larval-pupal intermediates show true mosaïcs in which Ci and CF are juxtaposed; however, the ratio of Ci in the epithelium progressively increases.The injection of JH at the beginning of spinning induces the appearance of CF just as Ci should normally grow. Hormone administration during the second half of the spinning period modifies the differentiation of epithelial cells: they become taller. We consider them to be cells engaged in pharate pupal differentiation, and which have then been partially oriented toward larval differentiation.These results show that the intestinal epithelium is a competent tissue, the sensibility of which to JH, is higher than that of the epidermis. The basal cell plasticity is very important and the action of JH on their differentiation may lead to CL or CF, to tall cells, and to Ci, depending on hormonal rate. In vitro, the experiments show that the action of JH is probably direct on the target tissue. The fact that JH can act very late as a modifier of the differentiation of the growing epithelial cells exclude the possibility that the hormone exercises its control through DNA replication.     

Relation between cell number and pupal development of wing disks in Bombyx mori

The effects of JH and ecdysone on pupal differentiation of the wing disk of Bombyx mori were studied in vivo and in vitro. JH prevents pupal differentiation during larval life by stopping a particular stage of the cell cycle. Immediately after allatectomy, a cell cycle sets in without ecdysone, but afterwards wing disks obtain the competence to differentiate to the pupal type in response to ecdysterone. Disks older than 2 days after allatectomy can develop to the pupal type with an abrupt increase of mitosis in a certain concentration of ecdysterone in vitro. Once the disks have gained such competence and begun pupal development, JH no longer exhibits the effect that prevents DNA synthesis, which is enhanced by ecdysterone. It is therefore suggested that there are two phases in DNA synthesis: one which is important for achieving competence and is inhibited by JH and relatively independent of ecdysone; and another which is important for morphogenetic development and depends on ecdysone but is not inhibited by JH.     

Juvenile hormone acid and ecdysteroid together induce competence for metamorphosis of the Verson's gland in Manduca sexta

In the last larval instar of Lepidoptera, ecdysteroid in the absence of juvenile hormone (JH) is believed to cause the shift from larval to pupal development. In Manduca sexta, tissues such as the Verson's gland and crochet epidermis become pupally committed before the earliest pulse of ecdysteroid that occurs on day 2. What causes the change in commitment in these tissues? First it was necessary to determine at what stage these tissues become competent to express the pupal program. Last instar larvae of different ages were induced to molt prematurely by feeding the ecdysteroid analog RH5992 and Verson's gland proteins were analyzed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Glands became competent to make pupal proteins between 24 and 32 h after the last larval ecdysis. Next, hormonal regulation of competence was examined in ligated abdomens of 12h last instar larvae. Treatment with JH II acid or methoprene acid plus a low dose (1/50th of the molt inducing dose) of RH5992 induced competence, whereas RH5992 alone, methoprene acid alone or methoprene plus RH5992 did not. Verson's glands maintained in vitro produced pupal proteins in response to methoprene acid together with RH5992 but not with RH5992 alone. Likewise, crochet epidermis lost the ability to make crochets (metamorphic change) only in isolated abdomens treated with JH II acid or methoprene acid and low doses of RH5992. In conclusion, JH acid in the presence of basal levels of ecdysteroid induces tissue competence for metamorphosis. Metamorphic competence is followed by commitment, induced by a small pulse of ecdysteroid in the absence of JH, and finally by expression caused by a high titer of ecdysteroid. It is proposed that JH acid is an essential metamorphic hormone.     

Developmental expression and hormonal regulation of different isoforms of the transcription factor E75 in the tobacco hornworm Manduca sexta

E75A and E75B, isoforms of the E75 orphan nuclear receptor, are sequentially up-regulated in the abdominal epidermis of the tobacco hornworm Manduca sexta by 20-hydroxyecdysone (20E) during larval and pupal molts, with E75A also increasing at pupal commitment (Zhou et al., Dev. Biol. 193, 127-138, 1998). We have now cloned E75C and show that little is expressed in the epidermis during larval life with trace amounts seen just before ecdysis. Instead, E75C is found in high amounts during the development of the adult wings as the ecdysteroid titer is rising, and this increase was prevented by juvenile hormone (JH) that prevented adult development. By contrast, E75D is expressed transiently during the larval and pupal molts as the ecdysteroid titer begins to decline and again just before ecdysis, but in the developing adult wings is expressed on the rise of 20E. Removal of the source of JH had little effect on either E75C or E75D mRNA expression during the larval and pupal molts. At the time of pupal commitment, in vitro experiments show that 20E up-regulates E75D and JH prevents this increase. Neither E75A nor E75D mRNA was up-regulated by JH alone. Thus, E75C is primarily involved in adult differentiation whereas E75D has roles both during the molt and pupal commitment.