The influence of mRNA secondary structure on expression of endoglucanase inBacillus subtilis

Summary A gene for endoglucanase ofBacillus subtilis has been inserted into a Bacillus expression plasmid containing a strong BJ27 promoter and a synthetic ribosome binding site. Secondary structure analysis of mRNA showed the presence of a strong hairpin loop burying the SD sequence and the initiation codon. Alteration of secondary structure at this site by deletion analysis revealed a correlation between endoglucanase expression and accessibility of the ribosome binding site. Elimination of secondary structures increased endoglucanase expression over five-fold to a level at which endoglucanase occupied 60% of total protein which was secreted into culture medium.     

Quantitative correlation between mRNA secondary structure around the region downstream of the initiation codon and translational efficiency in Escherichia coli

Translational efficiency in Escherichia coli is known to be strongly influenced by the secondary structure around the ribosome‐binding site and the initiation codon in the translational‐initiation region of the mRNA. Several quantitative studies have reported that translational efficiency is attributable to effects on ribosome accessibility predominantly caused by the secondary structure surrounding the ribosome‐binding site. However, the influence of mRNA secondary structure around regions downstream of the initiation codon on translational efficiency after ribosome‐binding step has not been quantitatively studied. Here, we quantitatively analyzed the relationship between secondary structure of mRNA surrounding the region downstream of the initiation codon, referred to as the downstream region (DR), and protein expression levels. Modified hairpin structures containing the initiation codon were constructed by site‐directed mutagenesis, and their effects on expression were analyzed in vivo. The minimal folding free energy (ΔG) of a local hairpin structure was found to be linearly correlated with the relative expression level over a range of fourfold change. These results demonstrate that expression level can be quantitatively controlled by changing the stability of the secondary structure surrounding the DR. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 611–616 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Structured mRNAs regulate translation initiation by binding to the platform of the ribosome

Gene expression can be regulated at the level of initiation of protein biosynthesis via structural elements present at the 5' untranslated region of mRNAs. These folded mRNA segments may bind to the ribosome, thus blocking translation until the mRNA unfolds. Here, we report a series of cryo-electron microscopy snapshots of ribosomal complexes directly visualizing either the mRNA structure blocked by repressor protein S15 or the unfolded, active mRNA. In the stalled state, the folded mRNA prevents the start codon from reaching the peptidyl-tRNA (P) site inside the ribosome. Upon repressor release, the mRNA unfolds and moves into the mRNA channel allowing translation initiation. A comparative structure and sequence analysis suggests the existence of a universal stand-by site on the ribosome (the 30S platform) dedicated for binding regulatory 5' mRNA elements. Different types of mRNA structures may be accommodated during translation preinitiation and regulate gene expression by transiently stalling the ribosome.     

Translation of the psbA mRNA of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii requires a structured RNA element contained within the 5' untranslated region

Translational regulation is a key modulator of gene expression in chloroplasts of higher plants and algae. Genetic analysis has shown that translation of chloroplast mRNAs requires nuclear-encoded factors that interact with chloroplastic mRNAs in a message-specific manner. Using site-specific mutations of the chloroplastic psbA mRNA, we show that RNA elements contained within the 5' untranslated region of the mRNA are required for translation. One of these elements is a Shine- Dalgarno consensus sequence, which is necessary for ribosome association and psbA translation. A second element required for high levels of psbA translation is located adjacent to and upstream of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence, and maps to the location on the RNA previously identified as the site of message-specific protein binding. This second element appears to act as a translational attenuator that must be overcome to activate translation. Mutations that affect the secondary structure of these RNA elements greatly reduce the level of psbA translation, suggesting that secondary structure of these RNA elements plays a role in psbA translation. These data suggest a mechanism for translational activation of the chloroplast psbA mRNA in which an RNA element containing the ribosome-binding site is bound by message- specific RNA binding proteins allowing for increased ribosome association and translation initiation. These elements may be involved in the light-regulated translation of the psbA mRNA.     

Translational stimulation: RNA sequence and structure requirements for binding of Com protein.

Translation of the bacteriophage Mu mom gene is positively regulated by the phage Com protein. We report here that purified Com protein specifically stimulates mom gene expression in vitro. Furthermore, Com is shown to bind a site in the mom translational initiation region (TIR) in a sequence-specific manner. In vitro RNA footprint experiments have been used to define the Com-binding site and to study mRNA secondary structure in the mom TIR. Com binding is shown to correlate with a conformational change in the mom TIR both in vivo and in vitro. The role of secondary structure was further examined by testing the effects of mutations in the TIR on translation and stimulation. The results support a model for translational stimulation in which Com binding induces a conformational change in the mom mRNA, thereby enhancing ribosome binding.     

Use of synthetic ribosome binding site for overproduction of the 5B protein of insertion sequence IS5.

Insertion sequence IS5 is a bacterial transposable element which contains three open reading frames designated 5A, 5B and 5C. Although there was no detectable expression from the 5B open reading frame when it was preceded by the native promoter and ribosome binding site or by a tac promoter and the native ribosome binding site, we have overproduced a 5B protein both in vitro and in Escherichia coli cells by using a tac promoter and a specially-designed synthetic ribosome binding site. beta-galactosidase fusion studies suggested that the synthetic binding site is at least 150-fold more efficient than the native binding site. The 5B protein amounted to 80-85% of the total protein made in vitro and 20-25% of the total protein pulse-labelled in whole cells. It is stable in vitro but rapidly degraded in vivo. Thus expression of the 5B gene appears to be limited by both poor translation initiation and protein degradation.     

A 5 S rRNA-like secondary structure in the 7 SL RNA may define a ribosomal binding site of the signal recognition particle

A new secondary structure model for parts of the 7 SL RNA is proposed which indicates for a stretch of at least 40 bases a strong structural homology to the ribosomal protein L5 binding site of eukaryotic 5 S rRNA. It is suggested that the 5 S rRNA-like structural part of 7 SL RNA mediates binding of the signal recognition particle near to the peptidyl transferase center of the ribosome.     

In polycistronic Q�� RNA, single-strandedness at one ribosome binding site directly affects translational initiations at a distal upstream cistron

In Qβ RNA, sequestering the coat gene ribosome binding site in a putatively strong hairpin stem structure eliminated synthesis of coat protein and activated protein synthesis from the much weaker maturation gene initiation site, located 1300 nucleotides upstream. As the stability of a hairpin stem comprising the coat gene Shine–Dalgarno site was incrementally increased, there was a corresponding increase in translation of maturation protein. The effect of the downstream coat gene ribosome binding sequence on maturation gene expression appeared to have occurred only in cis and did not require an AUG start codon or initiation of coat protein synthesis. In all cases, no structural reorganization was predicted to occur within Qβ RNA. Our results suggest that protein synthesis from a relatively weak translational initiation site is greatly influenced by the presence or absence of a stronger ribosome binding site located elsewhere on the same RNA molecule. The data are consistent with a mechanism in which multiple ribosome binding sites compete in cis for translational initiations as a means of regulating protein synthesis on a polycistronic messenger RNA.     

Evidence for allosteric coupling between the ribosome and repressor binding sites of a translationally regulated mRNA

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S4 is a translational repressor regulating the expression of four ribosomal genes in the alpha operon. In vitro studies have shown that the protein specifically recognizes an unusual mRNA pseudoknot secondary structure which links sequences upstream and downstream of the ribosome binding site for rpsM (S13) [Tang, C. K., & Draper, D. E. (1989) Cell 57, 531]. We have prepared fusions of the rpsM translational initiation site and lacZ that allows us to detect repression in cells in which overproduction of S4 repressor can be induced. Twenty-five mRNA sequence variants have been introduced into the S13-lacZ fusions and the levels of translational repression measured. Sets of compensating base changes confirm the importance of the pseudoknot secondary structure for translational repression. An A residue in a looped, single-stranded sequence is also required for S4 recognition and may contact S4 directly. Comparison of translational repression levels and S4 binding constants for the set of mRNA mutations show that nine mutants are repressed much more weakly than predicted from their affinity for S4; in extreme cases no repression can be detected for variants with unchanged S4 binding. We suggest that the mRNA contains functionally distinct ribosome and repressor binding sites that are allosterically coupled. Mutations can relieve translational repression by disrupting the linkage between the two sites without altering S4 binding. This proposal assigns to the mRNA a more active role in mediating translational repression than found in other translational repression systems.     

Selective destabilization of short-lived mRNAs with the granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor AU-rich 3'' noncoding region is mediated by a cotranslational mechanism.

The 3' noncoding region element (AUUUA)n specifically targets many short-lived mRNAs for degradation. Although the mechanism by which this sequence functions is not yet understood, a potential link between facilitated mRNA turnover and translation has been implied by the stabilization of cellular mRNAs in the presence of protein synthesis inhibitors. We therefore directly investigated the role of translation on mRNA stability. We demonstrate that mRNAs which are poorly translated through the introduction of stable secondary structure in the 5' noncoding region are not efficiently targeted for selective destabilization by the (AUUUA)n element. These results suggest that AUUUA-mediated degradation involves either a 5'-->3' exonuclease or is coupled to ongoing translation of the mRNA. To distinguish between these two possibilities, we inserted the poliovirus internal ribosome entry site, which promotes internal ribosome initiation, downstream of the 5' secondary structure. Translation directed by internal ribosome binding was found to fully restore targeted destabilization of AUUUA-containing mRNAs despite the presence of 5' secondary structure. This study therefore demonstrates that selective degradation mediated by the (AUUUA)n element is coupled to ribosome binding or ongoing translation of the mRNA and does not involve 5'-to-3' exonuclease activity.     

A variation of the translation attenuation model can explain the inducible regulation of the pBC16 tetracycline resistance gene in Bacillus subtilis

Expression of the tet resistance gene from plasmid pBC16 is induced by the antibiotic tetracycline, and induction is independent of the native promoter for the gene. The nucleotide sequence at the 5' end of the tet mRNA (the leader region) is predicted to assume a complex secondary structure that sequesters the ribosome binding site for the tet gene. A spontaneous, constitutively expressed tet gene variant contains a mutation predicted to provide the tet gene with a nonsequestered ribosome binding site. Lastly, comparable levels of tet mRNA can be demonstrated in tetracycline-induced and uninduced cells. These results are consistent with the idea that the pBC16 tet gene is regulated by translation attenuation, a model originally proposed to explain the inducible regulation of the cat and erm genes in gram-positive bacteria. As with inducible cat and erm genes, the pBC16 tet gene is preceded by a translated leader open reading frame consisting of a consensus ribosome binding site and an ATG initiation codon, followed by 19 sense codons and a stop codon. Mutations that block translation of cat and erm leaders prevent gene expression. In contrast, we show that mutations that block translation of the tet leader result in constitutive expression. We provide evidence that translation of the tet leader peptide coding region blocks tet expression by preventing the formation of a secondary-structure complex that would, in the absence of leader translation, expose the tet ribosome binding site. Tetracycline is proposed to induce tet by blocking or slowing leader translation. The results indicate that tet regulation is a variation of the translation attenuation model.     

High-level expression of porcine liver cytochrome P-450 reductase catalytic domain in Escherichia coli by modulating the predicted local secondary structure of mRNA

A direct expression system for the solubilized catalytic domains of NADPH-cytochrome P-450 reductase (sCPR) from rat (RsCPR) and porcine (PsCPR) in Escherichia coli cells was constructed using the expression plasmid pCWori(+). PsCPR was minimally expressed, whereas RsCPR was highly expressed. Replacement of the nucleotides encoding Thr(60)Ser(61)Ser(62) in PsCPR with those for Ala(60)Pro(61)Pro(62) in RsCPR markedly increased the expression level of the protein. The local secondary structures of the mRNAs, which were predicted with the prediction program GeneBee (http://www.genebee.msu.su), suggested that the intramolecular double strand between the ribosome binding site (RBS) and the Thr(60)Ser(61)Ser(62) codons in PsCPR, and/or the base-pairing at the initiation codon of the mRNAs significantly affected protein expression. Silent mutations were systematically introduced into the codons for Thr(58) and Thr(60)Ser(61) in PsCPR to modulate the local secondary structure of the mRNA. The expression level of the silently mutated PsCPR suggests that the expression level of PsCPR depends on the stability of the local structure at the RBS in the mRNA. A high-level expression system for wild-type PsCPR was constructed by introducing silent mutations at the codons for Thr(60)Ser(61) in PsCPR. The purified PsCPR showed the characteristic absorption spectral changes of sCPR after reduction with NADPH. The yield of purified PsCPR from 1 liter of culture fluid was 45.8 mg. These results substantiate that the introduction of silent mutations in the section of the gene encoding the N-terminal region of the protein based on the predicted local secondary structure of the mRNA at the RBS is a useful approach to control and increase the expression level of heterologous proteins in E. coli cells.     

Leader peptides of inducible chloramphenicol resistance genes from gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria bind to yeast and Archaea large subunit rRNA.

catA86 is the second gene in a constitutively transcribed, two-gene operon cloned from Bacillus pumilus . The region that intervenes between the upstream gene, termed the leader, and the catA86 coding sequence contains a pair of inverted repeat sequences which cause sequestration of the catA86 ribosome binding site in mRNA secondary structure. As a consequence, the catA86 coding sequence is untranslatable in the absence of inducer. Translation of the catA86 coding sequence is induced by chloramphenicol in Gram-positives and induction requires a function of the leader coding sequence. The leader-encoded peptide has been proposed to instruct its translating ribosome to pause at leader codon 6, enabling chloramphenicol to stall the ribosome at that site. Ribosome stalling causes destabilization of the RNA secondary structure, exposing the catA86 ribosome binding site, allowing activation of its translation. A comparable mechanism of induction by chloramphenicol has been proposed for the regulated cmlA gene from Gram-negative bacteria. The catA86 and cmlA leader-encoded peptides are in vitro inhibitors of peptidyl transferase, which is thought to be the basis for selection of the site of ribosome stalling. Both leader-encoded peptides have been shown to alter the secondary structure of Escherichia coli 23S rRNA in vitro. All peptide-induced changes in rRNA conformation are within domains IV and V, which contains the peptidyl transferase center. Here we demonstrate that the leader peptides alter the conformation of domains IV and V of large subunit rRNA from yeast and a representative of the Archaea. The rRNA target for binding the leader peptides is therefore conserved across kingdoms.     

Specific interactions of the L10(L12)4 ribosomal protein complex with mRNA, rRNA, and L11

Large ribosomal subunit proteins L10 and L12 form a pentameric protein complex, L10(L12) 4, that is intimately involved in the ribosome elongation cycle. Its contacts with rRNA or other ribosomal proteins have been only partially resolved by crystallography. In Escherichia coli, L10 and L12 are encoded from a single operon for which L10(L12) 4 is a translational repressor that recognizes a secondary structure in the mRNA leader. In this study, L10(L12) 4 was expressed from the moderate thermophile Bacillus stearothermophilus to quantitatively compare strategies for binding of the complex to mRNA and ribosome targets. The minimal mRNA recognition structure is widely distributed among bacteria and has the potential to form a kink-turn structure similar to one identified in the rRNA as part of the L10(L12) 4 binding site. Mutations in equivalent positions between the two sequences have similar effects on L10(L12) 4-RNA binding affinity and identify the kink-turn motif and a loop AA sequence as important recognition elements. In contrast to the larger rRNA structure, the mRNA apparently positions the kink-turn motif and loop for protein recognition without the benefit of Mg (2+)-dependent tertiary structure. The mRNA and rRNA fragments bind L10(L12) 4 with similar affinity ( approximately 10 (8) M (-1)), but fluorescence binding studies show that a nearby protein in the ribosome, L11, enhances L10(L12) 4 binding approximately 100-fold. Thus, mRNA and ribosome targets use similar RNA features, held in different structural contexts, to recognize L10(L12) 4, and the ribosome ensures the saturation of its L10(L12) 4 binding site by means of an additional protein-protein interaction.     

An antisense/target RNA duplex or a strong intramolecular RNA structure 5' of a translation initiation signal blocks ribosome binding: the case of plasmid R1.

Antisense RNAs in prokaryotic systems often inhibit translation of mRNAs. In some cases, this involves sequestration of Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequences and start codons. In other cases, antisense/target RNA duplexes do not overlap these signals, but form upstream. We have performed toeprinting analyses on repA mRNA of plasmid R1, both free and in duplex with the antisense RNA, CopA. An intermolecular RNA duplex 2 nt upstream of the tap SD prevents ribosome binding. An intrastrand stem-loop at this location yields the same inhibition. Thus, stable secondary structures immediately upstream of the tap SD sequence inhibit translation, as shown by toeprinting in vitro and repA-lacZ expression in vivo. Previous work showed that repA (initiator protein) expression requires tap (leader peptide) translation. Toeprinting data confirm that the tap ribosome binding site (RBS) is accessible, whereas the repA RBS, which is sequestered by a stable stem-loop, is weakly recognized by the ribosome. Truncated CopA RNA (CopI) is unable to pair completely with target RNA, but proceeds normally to a kissing intermediate. This mutant RNA species inhibits repA expression in vivo. By a kinetic toeprint inhibition protocol, we have shown that the structure of the kissing complex is sufficient to sterically prevent ribosome binding. These results are discussed in comparison with the effect of RNA structures elsewhere in the ribosome-binding region of an mRNA.