Hydrogen exchange kinetics of nucleic acids: Double and triple helices with Hoogsteen-type basepairs

The kinetics of hydrogen-tritium exchange reaction have been followed by a Sephadex technique of a double-helical poly(ribo-2-methylthio-adenylic acid)·poly(ribouridylic acid) complex with the Hoogsteen-type basepair. Only one hydrogen in every 2-methylthio-adenine·uracil basepair has been found to exchange at a measurably slow rate, 0.023 s^?1 (at 0°C), which is, however, much greater than that for a double-helix with the Watson-Crick type A·U pair. The kinetics of hydrogen-tritium exchange were also examined by triple-helical poly(rU)·poly(rA)·poly(rU) which involves both the Watson-Crick and Hoogsteen basepairings. Here, three hydrogens in every U·A·U base triplet have been found to exchange at a relatively slow rate, 0.0116 s^?1 (at 0°C). The kinetics of hydrogen-deuterium exchange reactions of these polynucleotide helices have also been followed by a stopped-flow ultraviolet absorption spectrophotometry at various temperatures. On the basis of these experimental results, the mechanism of the hydrogen exchange reactions in these helical polynucleotides was discussed. In the triple helix, the rate-determining process of the slow exchange of the three (one uracil-imide and two adenine-amino) hydrogens is considered to be the opening of the Watson-Crick part of the U·A·U triplet. This opening is considered to take place only after the opening of the Hoogsteen part of the triplet.     

Proton exchange and base-pair kinetics of poly(rA).poly(rU) and poly(rI).poly(rC)

Proton exchange of poly(rA).poly(rU) and poly(rI).poly(rC) has been studied by nuclear magnetic resonance line broadening and saturation transfer from H2O. Five exchangeable peaks are observed. They are assigned to the imino, amino and 2'-OH ribose protons. The aromatic spectrum is also assigned. Contrary to previous observations, we find that the exchange of the imino proton is strongly buffer sensitive. This property is used to derive the base-pair lifetime, which is in the range of milliseconds at 27 degrees C, 100 times smaller than published values. The enthalpy for the base-opening reaction (-86 kJ/mol) and the insensitivity of the reaction to magnesium suggest that the open state involves a small number of base-pairs. The similarities in the exchange from the two duplexes indicate that the same open state is responsible for exchange of purine and pyrimidine imino protons. For the lifetime of the open state and for the base-pair dissociation constant, we obtain only lower limits. At 27 degrees C they are three microseconds and 10(-3), respectively. The analysis that yields the much larger values published previously is based on the assumption that amino protons exchange only from open base-pairs. But theory and preliminary experiments indicate that it may occur from the closed duplex. The exchange of amino protons is slower than that of the imino protons. Exchange of the 2'-OH protons from the duplexes is much slower than from single-stranded poly(rU), and it is accelerated by magnesium. This could indicate hydrogen-bonding to backbone phosphate. Discrepancies between our results and those of previous studies are discussed.     

Lattice vibrational modes of poly(rU)-poly(rA). A coupled single-helical approach

The eigenvalues and eigenvectors of 11-fold double-helical poly(rU)·poly(rA) have been calculated. The vibrational potential energy of the double-helical structure is initially considered to be a sum of the vibrational potential energy of the single-helical structures poly(rU) and poly(rA). Coupling between the single helices is introduced by including a stretch force constant for each hydrogen bond between the uracil and adenine base residues. In addition, a model is presented for nonbonded interactions between nearest neighbor base pairs, which is consistent with a previous model for such interactions in the single helices. Because of the simple structural relationship between the uncoupled single helices and the double helix we are able to cast the secular equation for poly(rU)·poly(rA) in a form suitable for the use of perturbation theory using the previously calculated normal modes for the single helices as the unperturbed modes. Perturbation theory was found to be inapplicable for the region of the spectrum ?450 cm^?1. In this region an exact Green function technique is used to calculate the strongly coupled modes. We explicitly display one aspect of these double-helical normal modes. The stretching motions of the hydrogen bonds in the region of the spectrum <450 cm^?1 have been plotted as bar graphs for each mode.     

Phase equilibrium in poly(rA).poly(rU) complexes with Cd2+ and Mg2+ ions, studied by ultraviolet, infrared, and vibrational circular dichroism spectroscopy

Ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) absorption and vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) spectroscopy were used to study conformational transitions in the double-stranded poly(rA). poly(rU) and its components-single-stranded poly(rA) and poly(rU) in buffer solution (pH 6.5) with 0.1M Na+ and different Mg2+ and Cd2+ (10(-6) to 10(-2) M) concentrations. Transitions were induced by elevated temperature that changed from 10 up to 96 degrees C. IR absorption and VCD spectra in the base-stretching region were obtained for duplex, triplex, and single-stranded forms of poly(rA) . poly(rU) at [Mg2+],[Cd2+]/[P] = 0.3. For single-stranded polynucleotides, the kind of conformational transition (ordering --> disordering --> compaction, aggregation) is conditioned by the dominating type of Me2+-polymer complex that in turn depends on the ion concentration range. The phase diagram obtained for poly(rA) . poly(rU) has a triple point ([Cd2+] approximately 10(-4)M) at which the helix-coil (2 --> 1) transition is replaced with a disproportion transition 2AU --> A2U + poly(rA) (2 --> 3) and the subsequent destruction of the triple helix (3 --> 1). The 2 --> 1 transitions occur in the narrow temperature interval of 2 degrees -5 degrees . Unlike 2 --> 1 and 3 --> 1 melting, the disproportion 2 --> 3 transition is a slightly cooperative one and observed over a wide temperature range. At [Me2+] approximately 10(-3) M, the temperature interval of A2U stability is not less than 20 degrees C. In the case of Cd2+, it increases with the rise of ion concentration due to the decrease of T(m) (2-->3). The T(m) (3-->1) value is practically unchanged up to [Cd2+] approximately 10(-3)M. Differences between diagrams for Mg(2+) and Cd2+ result from the various kinds of ion binding to poly(rA).poly-(rU) and poly(rA).     

Determination of the kinetics of deuteration of DNA.RNA hybrids by ultraviolet spectroscopy

The kinetics of the hydrogen-deuterium exchange reactions of poly(dA).poly(rU) and poly(rA).poly(dT) has been examined, at pH 7.0 and at various temperatures in the 15-35 degrees C range, by stopped-flow ultraviolet spectrophotometry. For comparison, the deuteration kinetics of poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)] and poly(rA).poly(rU) has been reexamined. At 20 degrees C, the imino deuteration (NH----ND) rates of the two hybrid duplexes were found to be 1.5 and 1.8 s-1, respectively. These are nearly equal to the imino deuteration rates of poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)] (1.1 s-1) and poly(rA).poly(rU) (1.5 s-1) but appreciably higher than that of poly(dA).poly(dT) (0.35 s-1). It has been suggested that a DNA.RNA hybrid, an RNA duplex, and the AT-alternating DNA duplex have in general higher base-pair-opening reaction rates than the ordinary DNA duplex. The amino deuteration (NH2----ND2) rates, on the other hand, have been found to be 0.25, 0.28, and 0.33 s-1, respectively, for poly(dA).poly(rU), poly(rA).poly(dT), and poly[d(A-T)].poly[d(A-T)], at 20 degrees C. These are appreciably higher than that for poly(rA).poly(rU) (0.10 s-1). In general, the equilibrium constants (K) of the base-pair opening are considered to be greatest for the DNA.RNA hybrid duplex (0.05 at 20 degrees C), second greatest for the RNA duplex (0.02 at 20 degrees C), and smallest for the DNA duplex (0.005 at 20 degrees C), although the AT-alternating DNA duplex has an exceptionally great K (0.07 at 20 degrees C). From the temperature effect on the K value, the enthalpy of the base-pair opening was estimated to be 3.0 kcal/mol for the DNA.RNA hybrid duplex.     

Vibrational CD study of the thermal denaturation of poly(rA) · poly(rU)

The vibrational cd (VCD) of a double-stranded RNA, poly(rA) - poly(rU), at pH 7 and moderate added salt concentration (0.1M) has been measured in both the base-stretching and phosphate-stretching regions of the ir as a function of temperature. The data in both cases show two distinct phase transitions. The first is from double- to a triple-stranded form, and the second is from triple- to single-stranded forms, which still retain substantial local order even up to 80°C. The nature of these transitions has been identified by comparison of the VCD and ir absorption spectra of the initially double-stranded samples with those of single-stranded poly(rA) and poly(rU) and with triple-stranded poly-(rA) -poly-(rU) poly (rU). The large differences in the VCD band shapes allows positive identification of the intermediate and final states. Thus under VCD-concentration conditions, a simple helix-to-coil transition can be eliminated for poly (rA ) - poly (rU) while such a two-step transition can be seen at low salt conditions. All of these observations are consistent with previous studies of the phase transitions of poly (rA) - poly (rU) under various salt conditions. Additionally, the VCD is indicative of premelting for all the triple-, double-, and single-strand complexes studied. The triple-strand complex did not show disproportionation to double strand on heating under these added salt conditions. The unusual VCD pattern for low temperature poly (rA) - poly (rU), as compared to high G? C content RNAs and DNAs, is qualitatively, but not quantitatively, explained using exciton coupling of localized dipolar transitions in each type of base within the strand. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Comparative Studies of Duplex and Triplex Formation of 2′-5′ and 3′-5′ Linked Oligoribonucleotides

Abstract

We have studied double and triple helix formation between 2′–5′ or 3–5′ linked oligoriboadenylates and oligoribouridylates with chain length 7 or 10 by CD spectrometry. The complex formation depends on the type of linkage of oligoribonucleotides, chain length, concentration and molar ratio of the strands, temperature and the cationic concentration. Mixture of any linkage isomers of oligo(rA) and oligo(rU) in 1:1 molar ratio form duplex at 0.1 M NaCl. The duplex stability largely depends on the type of the linkages and is in the following order; [35′] oligo(rA)·[3′-5′] oligo(rU) > [2′-5′] oligo(rA)'[3′-5′] oligo(rU) > [3′-5′] oligo(rA)·[2′-5′] oligo(rU) > [2–5′] oligo(rA)*[2′-5′] oligo(rU). The higher cationic concentrations, 0.5 M MgCl₂, stabilize the complex and either duplex or triplex is formed depending on the input strand ratio and the type of linkage. Thermodynamic parameters, DH and DS, for the complex formation between linkage isomers of oligo(rA) and oligo(rU) showed a linear relationship indicating an enthalpy-entropy compensation phenomena. The duplex and triplex composed of [2′-5′] oligo(rA) and [2′-5′] oligo(rU) exhibit different CD spectra compared to those of any others containing 3–5′ linkage, suggesting that the fully 2–5′ duplex and triplex may possess a unique conformation. We describe prebiological significance of the linkage isomers of RNA and selection of the 3–5′ linkage against 2′-5 linkage.     

Poly(rA).poly(rU) with Ni(2+) ions at different temperatures: infrared absorption and vibrational circular dichroism spectroscopy

Phase transitions were studied of the sodium salt of poly(rA).poly(rU) induced by elevated temperature without Ni(2+) and with Ni(2+) in 0.07 M concentration in D(2)O (approximately 0.4 [Ni]/[P]). The temperature was varied from 20 degrees C to 90 degrees C. The double-stranded conformation of poly(rA).poly(rU) was observed at room temperature (20 degrees C-23 degrees C) with and without Ni(2+) ions. In the absence of Ni(2+) ions, partial double- to triple-strand transition of poly(rA).poly(rU) occurred at 58 degrees C, whereas only single- stranded molecules existed at 70 degrees C. While poly(rU) did not display significant helical structure, poly(rA) still maintained some helicity at this temperature. Ni(2+) ions significantly stabilized the triple-helical structure. The temperature range of the stable triple-helix was between 45 degrees C and 70 degrees C with maximum stability around 53 degrees C. Triple- to single-stranded transition of poly(rA).poly(rU) occurred around 72 degrees C with loss of base stacking in single-stranded molecules. Stacked or aggregated structures of poly(rA) formed around 86 degrees C. Hysteresis took place in the presence of Ni(2+) during the reverse transition from the triple-stranded to the double-stranded form upon cooling. Reverse Hoogsteen type of hydrogen-bonding of the third strand in the triplex was suggested to be the most probable model for the triple-helical structure. VCD spectroscopy demonstrated significant advantages over infrared absorption or the related electronic CD spectroscopy.     

Fluorescence studies on the complex formation between poly(rA) containing 1,N6-ethenoadenosine and poly(rU)

The interaction of the 1,N6-etheno derivatives of poly(rA) (poly(epsilon rA] with poly(rU) has been studied by absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. The stoichiometry of the interaction is found to be 1 epsilon A:1 rU and 1 epsilon A:2 rU as well as in the case of poly(rA)-poly(rU) interaction. The fluorescence properties, including the intensity and polarization of fluorescence, respond to the conformational transition of poly(epsilon rA)-poly(rU) complexes. The introduction of epsilon A groups into poly(rA) results in a marked decrease in the melting temperature, suggesting that epsilon A may destabilize the helical structure. The three-exponential decay law obtained with poly(epsilon rA)-poly(rU) complexes indicates the existence of at least three different stacked conformational states.     

Premelting and the hydrogen-exchange open state in synthetic RNA duplexes

Here we attempt to relate equilibrium temperature-dependent spectral changes in two synthetic RNA homopolymer duplexes—poly(rA) · poly(rU) and poly(rI) · poly(rC)—to the conformational opening detected in stopped-flow hydrogen–deuterium exchange experiments on these molecules. We are concerned with changes in several spectral properties that occur well below onset of the thermally induced helix-coil “melting” transition in these systems. These are known as “premelting” transitions, and can be detected in uv CD spectra as well as in vibrational bands of the bases in the ir. Both CD and ir spectra exhibit isoelliptic or isosbestic points consistent with a well-defined two-state premelting process. Application of a least-squares analysis to two-state models for premelting using data from different bands in the CD and ir shows that the enthalpies are substantially greater than that of the hydrogen-exchange opening. Thus the hydrogen-exchange open state represents only one premelting reaction among several that lead to equilibrium changes in helix geometry or base vibrational modes. The latter include processes that occur on a rapid time scale, including potential base-pair openings not productive for the exchange reaction. It appears that the former, and not the hydrogen-exchange opening, dominates the premelting alterations monitored by ir and CD spectroscopy.     

The binding of poly(rA) and poly(rU) to denatured DNA. I. Model studies with homopolymers.

We have compared the properties of the poly(rA).oligo(dT) complex with those of the poly(rU).oligo(dA)n complex. Three main differences were found. First, poly(rA) and oligo(dT)n do not form a complex in concentrations of CsCl exceeding 2 M because the poly(rA) is insoluble in high salt. If the complex is made in low salt, it is destabilized if the CsCl concentration is raised. Complexes between poly(rU) and oligo(dA)n, on the other hand, can be formed in CsCl concentrations up to 6.6 M. Second, complexes between poly(rA) and oligo(dT)n are more rapidly destabilized with decreasing chain length than complexes between poly(rU) and oligo(dA)n. Third, the density of the complex between poly(rA) and poly(dT) in CsCl is slightly lower than that of poly(dT), whereas the density of the complex between poly(rU) and poly(dA) in CsCl is at least 300 g/cm3 higher than that of poly(dA). These results explain why denatured natural DNAs that bind poly(rU) in a CsCl gradient usually do not bind poly(rA).     

The binding of poly (rA) and poly (rU) to denatured DNA. II. Studies with natural DNAs.

We have studied the interaction of poly(rA) and poly(rU) with natural DNAs containing (dA.dT)n sequences. The results indicate that hybridization of poly(rA) to denatured DNA can be used to estimate the size and frequency of large (dA.dT)n tracts, whereas hybridization with poly(rU) does not give reliable information on these points. In 6.6 M CsCl, poly(rU) can form stable complexes with denatured DNA containing short (dA)n tracts (n less than or equal to 6), whereas binding of poly(rA) to denatured DNA under these conditions requires much larger (dT)n tracts (estimated n greater than 13). Moreover, binding of poly(rA) requires pre-hybridization in low salt, because free poly(rA) precipitates in 6.6 M CsCl.     

Open states in native polynucleotides. II. Hydrogen-exchange study of cytosine-containing double helices.

Hydrogen-exchange studies of I · C and G · C double helices were carried out to test the generality of conclusions reached previously in studies of adenine-containing polymers (preceding paper). The cytosine amino group shows hydrogen-exchange behavior similar to the analogous group in adenine; a pH-independent pathway and a parallel general catalysis pathway require prior separation of the base-pair and pre-equilibrium protonation at the ring N. The cytosine amino group does, however, display greater sensitivity to specific and to general catalysis than found for adenine. In the G · C helix, the ring NH proton of guanine exchanges at the opening-limited rate, as does the analogous proton in A · U and A · T pairs, while the guanine amino protons exchange without a prior opening of structure. From the observed exchange rates and the known chemistry for the pH-independent reaction, one can calculate equilibrium opening constants of 4 × 10⁻³ for poly(rI) · poly(rC) and perhaps one tenth of that for poly(rG) · poly(rC). Also the opening rate constant for the G · C helix is 0.01 s⁻¹.These results, when applied to published exchange curves for DNA, indicate an equilibrium opening constant of 0.005, an opening rate constant of 0.04 s⁻¹, and a closing rate constant of 10 s⁻¹. (All values refer to studies at 0 °C.) These values point to the same kind of traveling-loop model for base-pair opening discussed previously for the opening reactions in adenine-containing double helices.     

The vibrational spectra and structure of poly(rA-rU)-poly(rA-rU)

Infrared and Raman spectra of aqueous poly(rA-rU)·poly(rA-rU), the double-helical complex containing strands of alternating riboadenylate and ribouridylate residues, display significant differences from one another and from corresponding spectra of poly(rA)·poly(rU), the double-helical complex of riboadenylate and ribouridylate homopolymers. Parallel studies on the copolymer and homopolymer complexes by cesium sulfate density gradient centrifugation, ultraviolet absorption spectroscopy, hydrogenion titration, 1-N oxidation of adenine residues by monoperphthalic acid and X-ray diffraction reveal, however, that the geometry of base pairing between adenine and uracil is closely similar in each complex and apparently of the Watson-Crick type. Therefore the differences observed between vibrational spectra of poly (rA-rU)·poly (rA-rU) and poly(rA)·poly(rU) are not due to different base-pairing schemes but may be attributed to differences in vibrational coupling between vertically stacked bases. Vibrational coupling may also account for the differences between infrared and Raman spectra of the same complex. Thus, the present results indicate that infrared and Raman frequencies of RNA in the region 1750–1550 cm^?1 should be dependent on the base sequence.     

Poly(rA) • Poly(rU) with Ni2+ Ions at Different Temperatures: Infrared Absorption and Vibrational Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy

Abstract

Phase transitions were studied of the sodium salt of poly(rA) ?poly(rU) induced by elevated temperature without Ni²⁺ and with Ni²⁺ in 0.07 M concentration in D₂O (～0.4 [Ni]/[P]). The temperature was varied from 20° C to 90° C. The double-stranded conformation of poly(rA)?poly(rU) was observed at room temperature (20° C—23° C) with and without Ni²⁺ ions. In the absence of Ni²⁺ ions, partial double- to triple-strand transition of poly(rA) ?poly(rU) occurred at 58° C, whereas only single-stranded molecules existed at 70° C. While poly(rU) did not display significant helical structure, poly(rA) still maintained some helicity at this temperature. Ni²⁺ ions significantly stabilized the triple-helical structure. The temperature range of the stable triple-helix was between 45° C and 70° C with maximum stability around 53° C. Triple-to single-stranded transition of poly(rA) ?poly(rU) occurred around 72° C with loss of base stacking in single-stranded molecules. Stacked or aggregated structures of poly(rA) formed around 86° C. Hysteresis took place in the presence of Ni²⁺ during the reverse transition from the triple-stranded to the double-stranded form upon cooling. Reverse Hoogsteen type of hydrogen-bonding of the third strand in the triplex was suggested to be the most probable model for the triple-helical structure. VCD spectroscopy demonstrated significant advantages over infrared absorption or the related electronic CD spectroscopy.     

Triple helical polynucleotidic structures: sugar conformations determined by FTIR spectroscopy.

Fourier Transform Infrared Spectra of triple stranded polynucleotides containing homopurine dA or rA and homopyrimidine dT or rU strands have been obtained in H2O and D2O solutions as well as in hydrated films at various relative humidities. The spectra are interpreted by comparison with those of double stranded helixes with identical base and sugar composition. The study of the spectral domain corresponding to in-plane double bond stretching vibrations of the bases shows that whatever the initial duplex characterized by a different IR spectrum (A family form poly rA.poly rU, heternomous form poly rA.poly dT, B family form poly dA.poly dT), the triplexes present a similar IR spectrum reflecting similar base interactions. A particular attention is devoted to the 950-800 cm-1 region which contains marker bands of the sugar conformation in the nucleic acids. In solution the existence of only N (C3'endo-A family form) type of sugar pucker is detected in poly rU.poly rA.poly rU and poly dt.poly rA.poly rU. On the contrary absorption bands characteristic of both N (C3'endo-A family form) and S (C2'endo-B family form) type sugars are detected for poly rU.poly rA.poly dT, poly rU.poly dA.poly dT and poly dT.poly rA.poly dT. Finally mainly S (C2'endo-B family form) type sugars are observed in poly dT.poly dA.poly dT.     

A proton NMR spin-lattice relaxation study of the imino proton exchange kinetics in calf-thymus DNA

The results of semiselective ¹H-nmr inversion recovery experiments on sonicated calf thymus DNA fragments are reported. The measurements were conducted in aqueous solutions containing 85% D₂O, in order to reduce the dipolar contribution to the observed relaxation rates. In solutions containing 0.2M NaCl, 0.4 mM EDTA, and 10 mM cacodylate at pH = 7.0, the exchange rates of the imino protons in A-T base pairs confirm values published earlier in the literature, extrapolating to 0.25 s^?1 at 25°C. Corresponding values for the G-C base pairs are published for the first time, and are about sixfold slower. The addition of up to 0.1M Tris buffer (pH = 7.3 at 25°C), caused a striking increase in the measured exchange rates for both the A-T and G-C imino protons, resembling the effect recently observed for poly(rA)-poly(rU) and poly(rI)-poly(rC), and suggesting that the exchange rates measured for nucleic acid duplexes in low buffer concentrations at neutral pH do not reflect base-pair opening rates as assumed in the past. Lower limits to the base-pair opening rates could be estimated from extrapolation of the experimental data to infinite buffer concentration, and are 1 × 10³ s^?1 for the A-T, and 50 s^?1 for the G-C, base paris at 62°C.     

Destabilization of the secondary structure of RNA by ribosomal protein S1 from escherichia coli

S1 is an acidic protein associated with the 3′ end of 16S RNA; it is indispensable for ribosomal binding of natural mRNA. We find that S1 unfolds single stranded stacked or helical polynucleotides (poly rA, poly rC, poly rU). It prevents the formation of poly (rA + rU) and poly (rI + rC) duplexes at 10–25 mM NaCl but not at 50–100 mM NaCl. Partial, salt reversible denaturation is also seen with coliphage MS2 RNA, $\text{E. coli}$ rRNA and tRNA. Generally, only duplex structures with a Tm greater than about 55° are formed in the presence of S1. The protein unfolds single stranded DNA but not poly d(A·T).     

The poly dA strand of poly dA.poly dT adopts an A-form in solution: a UV resonance Raman study.

The study by resonance Raman spectroscopy with a 257 nm excitation wave-length of adenine in two single-stranded polynucleotides, poly rA and poly dA, and in three double-stranded polynucleotides, poly dA.poly dT, poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT) and poly rA.poly rU, allows one to characterize the A-genus conformation of polynucleotides containing adenine and thymine bases. The characteristic spectrum of the A-form of the adenine strand is observed, except small differences, for poly rA, poly rA.poly rU and poly dA.poly dT. Our results prove that it is the adenine strand which adopts the A-family conformation in poly dA.poly dT.     

An ethidium-induced double helix of poly(dA)-poly(rU).

Equilibrium dialysis, relaxation kinetic, melting, and continuous variation mixing experiments on complexes of poly(dA) and poly(rU) demonstrate that ethidium induces conversion of a 1:1 mixture of these homopolymers (at one molar salt and 19 degrees C) from a three stranded to a two stranded helix. This is the first demonstration of a double helix of poly(dA)-poly(rU) in solution.