Metal-ion-dependent catalysis and specificity of CCA-adding enzymes: a comparison of two classes

The CCA-adding enzymes [ATP(CTP):tRNA nucleotidyl transferases] catalyze synthesis of the conserved and essential CCA sequence to the tRNA 3' end. These enzymes are divided into two classes of distinct structures that differ in the overall orientation of the head to tail domains. However, the catalytic core of the two classes is conserved and contains three carboxylates in a geometry commonly found in DNA and RNA polymerases that use the two-metal-ion mechanism for phosphoryl transfer. Two important aspects of the two-metal-ion mechanism are tested here for CCA enzymes: the dependence on metal ions for catalysis and for specificity of nucleotide addition. Using the archaeal Sulfolobus shibabae enzyme as an example of the class I, and the bacterial Escherichia coli enzyme as an example of the class II, we show that both enzymes depend on metal ions for catalysis, and that both use primarily Mg2+ and Mn2+ as the "productive" metal ions, but several other metal ions such as Ca2+ as the "nonproductive" metal ions. Of the two productive metal ions, Mg2+ specifically promotes synthesis of the correct CCA, whereas Mn2+ preferentially accelerates synthesis of the noncognate CCC and poly(C). Thus, despite evolution of structural diversity of two classes, both classes use metal ions to determine catalysis and specificity. These results provide critical insights into the catalytic mechanism of CCA synthesis to allow the two classes to be related to each other, and to members of the larger family of DNA and RNA polymerases.     

Studies on Escherichia coli RNase P RNA with Zn2+ as the catalytic cofactor

We demonstrate, for the first time, catalysis by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P (RNase P) RNA with Zn2+ as the sole divalent metal ion cofactor in the presence of ammonium, but not sodium or potassium salts. Hill analysis suggests a role for two or more Zn2+ ions in catalysis. Whereas Zn2+ destabilizes substrate ground state binding to an extent that precludes reliable Kd determination, Co(NH3)6(3+) and Sr2+ in particular, both unable to support catalysis by themselves, promote high-substrate affinity. Zn2+ and Co(NH3)6(3+) substantially reduce the fraction of precursor tRNA molecules capable of binding to RNase P RNA. Stimulating and inhibitory effects of Sr2+ on the ribozyme reaction with Zn2+ as cofactor could be rationalized by a model involving two Sr2+ ions (or two classes of Sr2+ ions). Both ions improve substrate affinity in a cooperative manner, but one of the two inhibits substrate conversion in a non-competitive mode with respect to the substrate and the Zn2+. A single 2'-fluoro modification at nt -1 of the substrate substantially weakened the inhibitory effect of Sr2+. Our results demonstrate that the studies on RNase P RNA with metal cofactors other than Mg2+ entail complex effects on structural equilibria of ribozyme and substrate RNAs as well as E*S formation apart from the catalytic performance.     

A single metal ion plays structural and chemical roles in an aminoacyl-transferase ribozyme.

Catalytically active RNA molecules rely on metal ions for structural and/or catalytic functions. Our in vitro selected aminoacyl-transferase ribozyme is no exception, as it employs a single fully hydrated Mg2+ ion for catalysis [Suga, H., et al. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 10118-10125]. Here we report the essential catalytic residues of the ribozyme and their spatial arrangement in the relation to the metal binding site. Evidence obtained using a combination of Pb2+ and Tb3+ hydrolytic cleavage assays on wild type and mutant ribozymes revealed a cooperative metal binding site that consists of the tandem G:U wobble pairs in P1 and consecutive G:U and U:A pairs in P3. The formation of this concerted Mg2+ binding site positions the P1 and P3 helices in a parallel manner, placing the L3 tetraloop in close proximity to the internal guide sequence (IGS, substrate binding site), which is adjacent to P1. Certain monovalent metal ions inhibit catalysis at low concentrations but support catalysis at high concentrations. These analyses imply that the Mg2+ ion plays both structural and chemical roles and that it brings about the significant rate acceleration in aminoacyl-transfer in concert with the L3-IGS long-range interaction.     

Three metal ions participate in the reaction catalyzed by T5 flap endonuclease

Protein nucleases and RNA enzymes depend on divalent metal ions to catalyze the rapid hydrolysis of phosphate diester linkages of nucleic acids during DNA replication, DNA repair, RNA processing, and RNA degradation. These enzymes are widely proposed to catalyze phosphate diester hydrolysis using a "two-metal-ion mechanism." Yet, analyses of flap endonuclease (FEN) family members, which occur in all domains of life and act in DNA replication and repair, exemplify controversies regarding the classical two-metal-ion mechanism for phosphate diester hydrolysis. Whereas substrate-free structures of FENs identify two active site metal ions, their typical separation of > 4 A appears incompatible with this mechanism. To clarify the roles played by FEN metal ions, we report here a detailed evaluation of the magnesium ion response of T5FEN. Kinetic investigations reveal that overall the T5FEN-catalyzed reaction requires at least three magnesium ions, implying that an additional metal ion is bound. The presence of at least two ions bound with differing affinity is required to catalyze phosphate diester hydrolysis. Analysis of the inhibition of reactions by calcium ions is consistent with a requirement for two viable cofactors (Mg2+ or Mn2+). The apparent substrate association constant is maximized by binding two magnesium ions. This may reflect a metal-dependent unpairing of duplex substrate required to position the scissile phosphate in contact with metal ion(s). The combined results suggest that T5FEN primarily uses a two-metal-ion mechanism for chemical catalysis, but that its overall metallobiochemistry is more complex and requires three ions.     

Effects of metal ions and catalytic loop sequences on the complex formation of a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate

A deoxyribozyme is a catalytic DNA that catalyzes a site-specific RNA cleavage activity and requires various divalent cations. Earlier we have reported that by downsizing the catalytic loop of a deoxyribozyme from 15-mer to 11-mer it resulted in a short and novel Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme. In this paper, we investigate the complex formation of deoxyribozymes with their RNA substrates by using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) in order to determine quantitatively the effect of Ca2+ or Mg2+ on the recognition step between a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate. The results indicate that both the association and dissociation rate constants (k(a) and k(d)) for the deoxyribozyme-RNA complex depends on metal ions as well as the loop size of the deoxyribozyme. Metal ions with high RNA cleavage activity induced an increase in k(a) and a decrease in k(d). On the basis of the results, we propose that Ca2+ ions may play a role in the rearrangement of the 11-mer catalytic loop of the short Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme.     

Metal ion binding sites in a group II intron core

Group II introns are catalytic RNA molecules that require divalent metal ions for folding, substrate binding, and chemical catalysis. Metal ion binding sites in the group II core have now been elucidated by monitoring the site-specific RNA hydrolysis patterns of bound ions such as Tb(3+) and Mg(2+). Major sites are localized near active site elements such as domain 5 and its surrounding tertiary interaction partners. Numerous sites are also observed at intron substructures that are involved in binding and potentially activating the splice sites. These results highlight the locations of specific metal ions that are likely to play a role in ribozyme catalysis.     

Structural basis for different substrate specificities of two ADP-ribose pyrophosphatases from Thermus thermophilus HB8

ADP-ribose (ADPR) is one of the main substrates of Nudix proteins. Among the eight Nudix proteins of Thermus thermophilus HB8, we previously determined the crystal structure of Ndx4, an ADPR pyrophosphatase (ADPRase). In this study we show that Ndx2 of T. thermophilus also preferentially hydrolyzes ADPR and flavin adenine dinucleotide and have determined its crystal structure. We have determined the structures of Ndx2 alone and in complex with Mg2+, with Mg2+ and AMP, and with Mg2+ and a nonhydrolyzable ADPR analogue. Although Ndx2 recognizes the AMP moiety in a manner similar to those for other ADPRases, it recognizes the terminal ribose in a distinct manner. The residues responsible for the recognition of the substrate in Ndx2 are not conserved among ADPRases. This may reflect the diversity in substrate specificity among ADPRases. Based on these results, we propose the classification of ADPRases into two types: ADPRase-I enzymes, which exhibit high specificity for ADPR; and ADPRase-II enzymes, which exhibit low specificity for ADPR. In the active site of the ternary complexes, three Mg2+ ions are coordinated to the side chains of conserved glutamate residues and water molecules. Substitution of Glu90 and Glu94 with glutamine suggests that these residues are essential for catalysis. These results suggest that ADPRase-I and ADPRase-II enzymes have nearly identical catalytic mechanisms but different mechanisms of substrate recognition.     

Unified two-metal mechanism of RNA synthesis and degradation by RNA polymerase

In DNA-dependent RNA polymerases, reactions of RNA synthesis and degradation are performed by the same active center (in contrast to DNA polymerases in which they are separate). We propose a unified catalytic mechanism for multisubunit RNA polymerases based on the analysis of its 3'-5' exonuclease reaction in the context of crystal structure. The active center involves a symmetrical pair of Mg(2+) ions that switch roles in synthesis and degradation. One ion is retained permanently and the other is recruited ad hoc for each act of catalysis. The weakly bound Mg(2+) is stabilized in the active center in different modes depending on the type of reaction: during synthesis by the beta,gamma-phosphates of the incoming substrate; and during hydrolysis by the phosphates of a non-base-paired nucleoside triphosphate. The latter mode defines a transient, non-specific nucleoside triphosphate-binding site adjacent to the active center, which may serve as a gateway for polymerization of substrates.     

Stepwise analyses of metal ions in RNase H catalysis from substrate destabilization to product release

In two-metal catalysis, metal ion A has been proposed to activate the nucleophile and metal ion B to stabilize the transition state. We recently reported crystal structures of RNase H-RNA/DNA substrate complexes obtained at 1.5-2.2 Angstroms. We have now determined and report here structures of reaction intermediate and product complexes of RNase H at 1.65-1.85 Angstroms. The movement of the two metal ions suggests how they may facilitate RNA hydrolysis during the catalytic process. Firstly, metal ion A may assist nucleophilic attack by moving towards metal ion B and bringing the nucleophile close to the scissile phosphate. Secondly, metal ion B transforms from an irregular coordination in the substrate complex to a more regular geometry in the product complex. The exquisite sensitivity of Mg(2+) to the coordination environment likely destabilizes the enzyme-substrate complex and reduces the energy barrier to form product. Lastly, product release probably requires dissociation of metal ion A, which is inhibited by either high concentrations of divalent cations or mutation of an assisting protein residue.     

Mapping divalent metal ion binding sites in a group II intron by Mn(2+)- and Zn(2+)-induced site-specific RNA cleavage.

The function of group II introns depends on positively charged divalent metal ions that stabilize the ribozyme structure and may be directly involved in catalysis. We investigated Mn2+- and Zn2+-induced site-specific RNA cleavage to identify metal ions that fit into binding pockets within the structurally conserved bI1 group II intron domains (DI-DVI), which might fulfill essential roles in intron function. Ten cleavage sites were identified in DI, two sites in DIII and two in DVI. All cleavage sites are located in the center or close to single-stranded and flexible RNA structures. Strand scissions mediated by Mn2+/Zn2+ are competed for by Mg2+, indicating the existence of Mg2+ binding pockets in physical proximity to the observed Mn2+-/Zn2+-induced cleavage positions. To distinguish between metal ions with a role in structure stabilization and those that play a more specific and critical role in the catalytic process of intron splicing, we combined structural and functional assays, comparing wild-type precursor and multiple splicing-deficient mutants. We identified six regions with binding pockets for Mg2+ ions presumably playing an important role in bI1 structure stabilization. Remarkably, assays with DI deletions and branch point mutants revealed the existence of one Mg2+ binding pocket near the branching A, which is involved in first-step catalysis. This pocket formation depends on precise interaction between the branching nucleotide and the 5' splice site, but does not require exon-binding site 1/intron binding site 1 interaction. This Mg2+ ion might support the correct placing of the branching A into the 'first-step active site'.     

Site-specific recombination and topoisomerization by Tn21 resolvase: role of metal ions.

The resolvase from the transposon Tn21 catalyses site-specific recombination between the two res sites on its DNA substrate both in the absence and presence of Mg2+ ions. This contrasts with reports on the resolvase from gamma-delta (Tn1000) and on other recombinational proteins that are homologous to Tn21 resolvase but which need Mg2+ for their activity. Magnesium ions could enhance the activity of Tn21 resolvase, as did a number of other cations but some metal ions such as Ni2+ inhibit recombination. The metal ions are not directly involved in the catalytic process but probably affect recombination by altering the conformation of the DNA. Tn21 resolvase relaxes its DNA substrate in the presence and in the absence of Mg2+, and also in ionic conditions that inhibit recombination. Hence, the topoisomerization reflects an activity of resolvase that is distinct from recombination. However, the two activities are functions of the same DNA-protein complex. The complex contains about 6 molecules of the resolvase dimer per molecule of DNA.     

Evidence that binding of C5 protein to P RNA enhances ribozyme catalysis by influencing active site metal ion affinity

The RNA subunit (P RNA) of the bacterial RNase P ribonucleoprotein is a ribozyme that catalyzes the Mg-dependent hydrolysis of pre-tRNA, but it requires an essential protein cofactor (P protein) in vivo that enhances substrate binding affinities and catalytic rates in a substrate dependent manner. Previous studies of Bacillus subtilis RNase P, containing a Type B RNA subunit, showed that its cognate protein subunit increases the affinity of metal ions important for catalysis, but the functional role of these ions is unknown. Here, we demonstrate that the Mg2+ dependence of the catalytic step for Escherichia coli RNase P, which contains a more common Type A RNA subunit, is also modulated by its cognate protein subunit (C5), indicating that this property is fundamental to P protein. To monitor specifically the binding of active site metal ions, we analyzed quantitatively the rescue by Cd2+ of an inhibitory Rp phosphorothioate modification at the pre-tRNA cleavage site. The results show that binding of C5 protein increases the apparent affinity of the rescuing Cd2+, providing evidence that C5 protein enhances metal ion affinity in the active site, and thus is likely to contribute significantly to rate enhancement at physiological metal ion concentrations.     

Essential roles of innersphere metal ions for the formation of the glutamine binding site in a bifunctional ribozyme.

Numerous studies on naturally occurring ribozymes have shown that the functional roles of metal ions in promoting RNA catalysis are diverse. Earlier studies performed on the in vitro selected aminoacyl-transferase ribozyme (ATRib) have revealed that a fully hydrated Mg2+ ion plays an essential role in catalysis [Suga, H., Cowan, J. A., and Szostak, J. W. (1998) Biochemistry 28, 10118-10125]. More recently, we have evolved this ATRib into a bifunctional ribozyme, called AD02 [Lee, N., et al. (2000) Nat. Struct. Biol. 7, 28-33]. This new ribozyme consists of two catalytic domains, the original ATRib domain and a new glutamine-recognition (QR) domain, and exhibits a function of charging glutamine to tRNA. Here we elucidate crucial roles of metal ions involved in the QR domain, that are distinct from those in the ATRib domain. The metal ions in the QR domain require innersphere coordinations, and both Mg2+ and Ca2+ can support catalysis. Extensive Tb3+-Mg2+ and Tb3+-Co(NH3)6(3+) competition cleavage experiments have shown that the QR domain has high and low affinity metal binding sites, which are involved in the Mg2+-dependent structural alteration to form the glutamine binding site [Lee, N., and Suga, H. (2001) RNA 7, 1043-1051]. Kinetic studies in the presence of divalent and monovalent ions have suggested that the essential role of the metal ions in the QR domain is most likely structural.     

Catalytic core structure of the trans-acting HDV ribozyme is subtly influenced by sequence variation outside the core

The human pathogenic hepatitis delta virus (HDV) employs a unique self-cleaving catalytic RNA motif, the HDV ribozyme, during double-rolling circle replication. Fluorescence spectroscopy, circular dichroism, terbium(III) footprinting, and X-ray crystallography of precursor and product forms have revealed that a conformational change accompanies catalysis. In addition, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) has previously been used on a trans-acting HDV ribozyme to demonstrate surprisingly significant catalytic and global conformational effects of substrate analogues with varying 5' sequences, which reside as dangling overhangs outside the catalytic core. Here, we use the fluorescent guanine analogue 2-aminopurine (AP) in nucleotide position 76, immediately downstream of the catalytically involved C75, to monitor the relative structural effects of these substrate analogues on the ribozyme's trefoil turn of the catalytic core. Steady-state and time-resolved AP fluorescence spectroscopies show that the binding of each substrate analogue induces a unique local conformation with a specific AP76 stacking equilibrium. Binding of the 3' product results in a relative increase in AP fluorescence, suggesting that AP76 becomes more unstacked upon catalysis. These local conformational changes are kinetically concomitant with global conformational changes monitored by FRET. Finally, the rate constant of the local conformational change upon 3' product binding is fast and independent of 3' product concentration yet Mg2+ dependent. Our results demonstrate that the trefoil turn of the HDV ribozyme catalytic core is in a state of dynamic equilibrium not captured by static crystal structures and is highly sensitive to the identity of the 5' sequence and Mg2+ ions.     

Ca(2+)-mediated site-specific DNA cleavage and suppression of promiscuous activity of KpnI restriction endonuclease

The characteristic feature of type II restriction endonucleases (REases) is their exquisite sequence specificity and obligate Mg(2+) requirement for catalysis. Efficient cleavage of DNA only in the presence of Ca(2+) ions, comparable with that of Mg(2+), is previously not described. Most intriguingly, KpnI REase exhibits Ca(2+)-dependent specific DNA cleavage. Moreover, the enzyme is highly promiscuous in its cleavage pattern on plasmid DNAs in the presence of Mn(2+) or Mg(2+), with the complete suppression of promiscuous activity in the presence of Ca(2+). KpnI methyltransferase does not exhibit promiscuous activity unlike its cognate REase. The REase binds to oligonucleotides containing canonical and mapped noncanonical sites with comparable affinities. However, the extent of cleavage is varied depending on the metal ion and the sequence. The ability of the enzyme to be promiscuous or specific may reflect an evolutionary design. Based on the results, we suggest that the enzyme KpnI represents an REase evolving to attain higher sequence specificity from an ancient nonspecific nuclease.     

Simple fluorescent sensors engineered with catalytic DNA 'MgZ' based on a non-classic allosteric design

Most NAE (nucleic acid enzyme) sensors are composed of an RNA-cleaving catalytic motif and an aptameric receptor. They operate by activating or repressing the catalytic activity of a relevant NAE through the conformational change in the aptamer upon target binding. To transduce a molecular recognition event to a fluorescence signal, a fluorophore-quencher pair is attached to opposite ends of the RNA substrate such that when the NAE cleaves the substrate, an increased level of fluorescence can be generated. However, almost all NAE sensors to date harbor either NAEs that cannot accommodate a fluorophore-quencher pair near the cleavage site or those that can accept such a modification but require divalent transition metal ions for catalysis. Therefore, the signaling magnitude and the versatility of current NAE sensors might not suffice for analytical and biological applications. Here we report an RNA-cleaving DNA enzyme, termed 'MgZ', which depends on Mg(2+) for its activity and can accommodate bulky dye moieties next to the cleavage site. MgZ was created by in vitro selection. The selection scheme entailed acidic buffering and ethanol-based reaction stoppage to remove selfish DNAs. Characterization of MgZ revealed a three-way junction structure, a cleavage rate of 1 min(-1), and 26-fold fluorescence enhancement. Two ligand-responsive NAE sensors were rationally designed by linking an aptamer sequence to the substrate of MgZ. In the absence of the target, the aptamer-linked substrate is locked into a conformation that prohibits MgZ from accessing the substrate. In the presence of the target, the aptamer releases the substrate, which induces MgZ-mediated RNA cleavage. The discovery of MgZ and the introduction of the above NAE sensor design strategy should facilitate future efforts in sensor engineering.     

Human recombinant thiamine triphosphatase: purification, secondary structure and catalytic properties

Thiamine triphosphate (ThTP) is found in most living organisms and it may act as a phosphate donor for protein phosphorylation. We have recently cloned the cDNA coding for a highly specific mammalian 25 kDa thiamine triphosphatase (ThTPase; EC 3.6.1.28). As the enzyme has a high catalytic efficiency and no sequence homology with known phosphohydrolases, it was worth investigating its structure and catalytic properties. For this purpose, we expressed the untagged recombinant human ThTPase (hThTPase) in E. coli, produced the protein on a large scale and purified it to homogeneity. Its kinetic properties were similar to those of the genuine human enzyme, indicating that the recombinant hThTPase is completely functional. Mg2+ ions were required for activity and Ca2+ inhibited the enzyme by competition with Mg2+. With ATP as substrate, the catalytic efficiency was 10(-4)-fold lower than with ThTP, confirming the nearly absolute specificity of the 25 kDa ThTPase for ThTP. The activity was maximum at pH 8.5 and very low at pH 6.0. Zn2+ ions were inhibitory at micromolar concentrations at pH 8.0 but activated at pH 6.0. Kinetic analysis suggests an activator site for Mg2+ and a separate regulatory site for Zn2+. The effects of group-specific reagents such as Woodward's reagent K and diethylpyrocarbonate suggest that at least one carboxyl group in the active site is essential for catalysis, while a positively charged amino group may be involved in substrate binding. The secondary structure of the enzyme, as determined by Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, was predominantly beta-sheet and alpha-helix.     

The structural and biochemical characterization of human RNase H2 complex reveals the molecular basis for substrate recognition and Aicardi-Goutières syndrome defects

RNase H2 cleaves RNA sequences that are part of RNA/DNA hybrids or that are incorporated into DNA, thus, preventing genomic instability and the accumulation of aberrant nucleic acid, which in humans induces Aicardi-Goutières syndrome, a severe autoimmune disorder. The 3.1 Å crystal structure of human RNase H2 presented here allowed us to map the positions of all 29 mutations found in Aicardi-Goutières syndrome patients, several of which were not visible in the previously reported mouse RNase H2. We propose the possible effects of these mutations on the protein stability and function. Bacterial and eukaryotic RNases H2 differ in composition and substrate specificity. Bacterial RNases H2 are monomeric proteins and homologs of the eukaryotic RNases H2 catalytic subunit, which in addition possesses two accessory proteins. The eukaryotic RNase H2 heterotrimeric complex recognizes RNA/DNA hybrids and (5′)RNA-DNA(3′)/DNA junction hybrids as substrates with similar efficiency, whereas bacterial RNases H2 are highly specialized in the recognition of the (5′)RNA-DNA(3′) junction and very poorly cleave RNA/DNA hybrids in the presence of Mg²⁺ ions. Using the crystal structure of the Thermotoga maritima RNase H2-substrate complex, we modeled the human RNase H2-substrate complex and verified the model by mutational analysis. Our model indicates that the difference in substrate preference stems from the different position of the crucial tyrosine residue involved in substrate binding and recognition.     

Diverse roles of metal ions in acyl-transferase ribozymes

The dependence on metal ions for catalysis is one of the hallmark characteristics of ribozymes. Yet despite this universal reliance, the functional role of divalent ions in promoting RNA catalysis is manifold. In this study we elucidate some different roles metal ions play as catalytic cofactors, by comparing two functionally co-evolved acyl-transferase ribozymes. Earlier studies performed on the in vitro selected acyl-transferase ribozyme, E18 [Suga, H., Cowan, J. A., and Szostak, J. W. (1998) Biochemistry 28, 10118-10125], revealed the requirement of a fully hydrated (outer-sphere) Mg2+ ion for catalytic activity. Interestingly, one class of acyl-transferase ribozymes isolated from the same RNA pool as E18 displays a unique metal dependency and is believed to be interacting with inner-sphere coordinated Mg2+ ions. New results show that one of these inner-sphere coordinating ribozymes, HS01, assumes a cloverleaf secondary structure closely resembling E18, yet apparently facilitates a distinct catalytic mechanism. Furthermore, the nature of the RNA-metal interaction(s) in HS01 seems to be dictating a unique reaction mechanism that exhibits a titratable moiety at a near-neutral pK(a). In light of the critical role metal ions play in biochemistry and the proper function of RNAs, these results compare two distinct manners by which metals serve to promote the catalysis of the same reaction.