Distribution of style and pollen polygalacturonases among distylous and homostylous Turnera and Piriqueta spp. (Turneraceae)

We explore the distribution of a style and pollen polygalacturonase in a number of distylous and homostylous species of Turnera, and two species of Piriqueta (Turneraceae). We show, using immunoblotting with antibodies made against these proteins, that the style polygalacturonase is specific to styles of short-styled plants of all the six distylous species of Turnera we have investigated. Styles of a somatic homostylous mutant derived from a short-styled plant do not possess the style polygalacturonase. Distylous P. caroliniana did not appear to possess this protein. We show that the pollen polygalacturonase, while associated with the short-styled morph in three species, is polymorphic among short-styled plants of T. krapovickasii, and absent from T. joelii, T. grandiflora and P. caroliniana. These data support a role for the style polygalacturonase in distyly, possibly in the incompatibility system, but cast doubt on any role for the pollen polygalacturonase. In concert with the predictions for the mode of origin, and the response of styles of homostylous species to pollen from long- and short-styled plants, we find that none of the homostylous species possess the style polygalacturonase. The pollen polygalacturonase does occur in some homostylous species, but not in others. It is not clear that the pollen polygalacturonase, however, provides a marker for the mode of origin of homostyly.     

Breeding system variation, genetics and evolution in the Turneraceae

We review the genetics and evolution of breeding systems in the Turneraceae. Distyly occurs in seven of 10 genera and 81% of species. The remaining species are homostylous. Polyploid evolution has been significant in Turnera. Approximately 60% of species are polyploid ranging from diploid through decaploid. No relationship between breeding system and polyploidy is evident. The genetics of distyly involves a one-locus two-allele system (S and s). Evidence from crosses with homostylous species and mutants is consistent with the possibility that a "Primula-type" supergene underlies distyly but does not prove this to be the case. A polygalacturonase, and an alpha-dioxygenase specific to the transmitting tissue of short-styled plants both exhibit morph-limited expression in concert with predictions from an evolutionary model. The function of the proteins in distyly, if any, is unknown. We have begun constructing a fine-scale genetic map of Turnera. Two genetic markers lie within 0.2 cm of the distyly locus. This should provide a starting point for positional cloning of the distyly locus and reveal the genetic architecture and molecular basis of distyly.     

Pollen and stigma size changes during the transition from tristyly to distyly in Oxalis alpina (Oxalidaceae)

• Pollen and stigma size have the potential to influence male fitness of hermaphroditic plants, particularly in species presenting floral polymorphisms characterised by marked differences in these traits among floral morphs. In this study, we take advantage of the evolutionary transition from tristyly to distyly experienced by Oxalis alpina (Oxalidaceae), and examined whether modifications in the ancillary traits (pollen and stigma size) respond to allometric changes in other floral traits. Also, we tested whether these modifications are in accordance with what would be expected under the hypothesis that novel competitive scenarios (as in distylous‐derived reproductive system) exert morph‐ and whorl‐specific selective pressures to match the available stigmas.
• We measure pollen and stigma size in five populations of O. alpina representing the tristyly–distyly transition.
• A general reduction in pollen and stigma size occurred along the tristyly–distyly transition, and pollen size from the two anther levels within each morph converged to a similar size that was characterised by whorl‐specific changes (increases or decreases) in pollen size of different anthers in each floral type.
• Overall, results from this study show that the evolution of distyly in this species is characterised not only by changes in sexual organ position and flower size, but also by morph‐specific changes in pollen and stigma size. This evidence supports the importance of selection on pollen and stigma size, which increase fitness of remaining morphs following the evolution of distyly, and raises questions to explore on the functional value of pollen size in heterostylous systems under pollen competition.

     

Immunocytochemical distribution of polygalacturonase and pectins in styles of distylous and homostylous Turneraceae

Distyly is a plant breeding system in which two self-incompatible, but cross-compatible, floral morphs occur within populations. The morphs differ in having a reciprocal arrangement of styles and anthers. Little or nothing is known of the proteins involved in self-incompatibility for any distylous species. Here we show that a 35 kDa putative polygalacturonase is specific to the transmitting tissue of short-styled plants of five species in series Turnera. The polygalacturonase was not detected in styles of long-styled plants, or in styles of five homostylous self-compatible species in this series of the genus. It is also absent from two X-ray generated mutants and a spontaneous somatic homostylous mutant that arose on a short-styled plant and whose style does possess this polygalacturonase. Three more distantly related species in the Turneraceae were investigated. Turnera weddelliana (series Salicifoliae) does possess the polygalacturonase; however, T. diffusa (series Microphyllae), and Piriqueta caroliniana, showed no evidence of possessing this polygalacturonase using immunocytochemistry. Polygalacturonase assays revealed activity in styles of long- and short-styled plants, but showed no activity of the 35 kDa style polygalacturonase. The distribution of pectins in styles and pollen tubes revealed no difference between the long- and short-styled morphs. Methyl-esterified pectins occur throughout the style tissues, except in the transmitting tissue. The transmitting tissue possesses unesterified pectins that could provide a substrate for polygalacturonase activity. We propose that the style polygalacturonase might act in a complementary manner, allowing pollen of long-styled plants to grow through short styles or, alternatively, oligogalacturonide products of polygalacturonase activity might play a role in signalling compatible responses.     

Distyly and pollen dimorphism in<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Damnacanthus</Emphasis> (Rubiaceae)

We document distyly in Damnacanthus (Rubiaceae) and investigate pollen morphology in the genus. Within nine taxa in Japan (four species, four varieties and one form), five show distyly. Non-distylous taxa of Damnacanthus always have a long style and short stamens. We examined the pollen morphology of all taxa of Damnacanthus in Japan. The pollen grains of Damnacanthus are 3- to 5-orthocolporate or sometimes loxocolporate. Polymorphic pollen is sometimes observed even within a single flower. Pollen dimorphism is associated with distyly; pollen grains from short-styled (thrum) flowers are significantly larger than those from long-styled (pin) flowers, and the muri are smooth in pin flowers whereas the pollen grains of thrum flowers have minute granules on the top and/or on the sides. In non-distylous taxa, in which the style is longer than stamens, the muri are always provided with minute granules. Interestingly, the pollen grains with granules in the non-distylous taxa contrast with the pollen of the distylous taxa, because granulate pollen grains are found only in thrum flowers. Although Damnacanthus is a stenopalynous genus, the number of colpi is useful for delimiting taxa. Based on palynological characters, we conclude that Damnacanthus should be revised. Electronic Publication     

Breeding system and floral morphometry of distylous Psychotria L. species in the Atlantic rain forest, SE Brazil

General patterns of floral morphology and incompatibility mechanisms have been described for many distylous plants. The absence of these patterns in typically distylous groups, as observed especially in tropical environments, is interpreted as atypical distyly, or as a new reproductive strategy derived from it. Data are presented here on the morphological and compatibility relations between floral morphs of four Psychotria dimorphic species in the Atlantic rain forest in SE Brazil: Psychotria jasminoides, P. birotula, P. mapourioides, and P. pubigera. When significant differences were found, floral parts were larger in thrum flowers. Results of controlled crosses showed that most incompatible pollen tubes were arrested in the stigma, and only in a low proportion in the upper parts of the style. We conclude that, at the study site, the majority and most important morphological and mating features of typical distyly seem to be conserved in P. jasminoides and P. mapourioides, which presented reciprocal herkogamy, self and intramorph incompatibility, and a balanced morph ratio in the population. Typical distyly in P. birotula is supported by floral morphology, pollen tube data and morph ratio and, in P. pubigera, only by floral morphology and pollen tube data.     

Pollen flow in a population of Primula vulgaris Huds.

A British population of Primula vulgaris was visited four times between 1971 and 1976 for study of the nature and functioning of distyly. The stainability and production of pollen from pins exceeded those of thrums. About 20% of pin pollen and 48% of thrum pollen was removed from anthers by insect visitors. Pins and thrums were present in a 1:1 ratio in 1971 but pins outnumbered thrums in 1976. Thrums produced more seeds per flower than pins though the number of ovules produced by each was similar. Two methods for collecting stigmas from open flowers and analyzing them for pollen loans produced somewhat different results. For pin stigmas, the pollen load consisted of 2–23% thrum pollen; for thrum stigmas, the pollen load consisted of 0–71% pin pollen with most stigmas having less than 50% pin pollen. In general, intermorph pollen flow is less than would be expected if pollen flow were random. It is probable that most intramorph pollen on stigmas is a result of self- or geitonogamous pollination. The extensive literature concerning the natural pollinators of the primrose is reviewed. Although Darwin's hypothesis concerning the functional significance of distyly in promoting intermorph pollination was never quantified, the pollen flow patterns observed in P. vulgaris are unexpectedly deviant and are similar to those patterns observed in several unrelated heterostylous species in other plant families.     

Morph-Specific Proteins in Pollen and Styles of Distylous Turnera (Turneraceae)

We used nondenaturing isoelectric focusing (IEF) in a survey of plants from 11 populations to identify style and pollen proteins unique to the short-styled morph of Turnera scabra, T. subulata and T. krapovickasii. Three protein bands [approximately isoelectric points (pIs) 6.1, 6.3 and 6.5] were found only in styles and stigmas of short-styled plants while two bands (approximately pIs 6.7 and 6.8, M(r) 56 and 59 kD) occur only in pollen of short-styled plants. Some of these bands appear very late in development, within 24 hr before flowering. Two isozyme loci were mapped to an 8.7 cM region spanning the distyly locus. Using these isozyme markers we identified progeny exhibiting recombination adjacent to the distyly locus. No recombinants between the distyly locus and the locus or loci controlling the presence of the short-styled morph-specific proteins were obtained. This suggests that the loci encoding these proteins are either extremely tightly linked to the distyly locus and in complete disequilibrium with the S allele or exhibit morph-limited expression. Crosses to a plant showing an unusual style protein phenotype demonstrated that an additional unlinked locus is required for full expression of the style proteins. The function of the morph-specific proteins is unknown.     

The evolution of distyly in Primula vulgaris

Experiments on pollen flow and seed production were performed in populations of P. vulgaris in order to examine the roles of selection for reduced self-pollination in a partially self-fertile morph, selection for reduced stigma clogging, selection for a pollen saving effect, and selection for disassortative pollination in the evolution of morphological distyly (reciprocal herkogamy). Selection for reduced self-pollination and disassortative pollination were shown to have a plausible role in the evolution of this dimorphism. Selection for reduced stigma clogging and pollen saving appeared to have no obvious role in the evolution of morphological distyly.     

Heterostyly in the Lamiaceae: The case ofSalvia brandegeei

Heterostyly rarely occurs in families with strongly zygomorphic flowers. For this reason Darwin (1877) doubted whether heterostyly would occur in the Lamiaceae and recent reviews have not reported the floral polymorphism in this family. Here we describe distyly in a rare species ofSalvia restricted to bluffs and seaward canyons on Santa Rosa Island (Santa Barbara Co., California) and northwestern Baja California (Mexico).Salvia brandegeei is morphologically distylous with populations composed of equal frequencies of long-and short-styled morphs differing reciprocally in stigma and anther position. Controlled hand pollinations demonstrated no significant differences in the seed set of self, intramorph or intermorph pollinations. Unlike most heterostylous species investigated,S. brandegeei does not possess diallelic incompatibility or ancillary polymorphisms of pollen and stigmas. We propose that the evolution of distyly inS. brandegeei may have been associated with an ecological shift to a new environment in which protandry failed to prevent increased levels of geitonogamy. Heterostyly was then selected because it increased the proficiency of cross-pollination. The origin of distyly in self-compatibleS. brandegeei is consistent with Lloyd and Webb's theoretical model for the evolution of distyly.     

Pollen–ovule ratios are strongly correlated with floral reciprocity,in addition to sexual system,in Mussaenda (Rubiaceae)

Heterostyly is a floral polymorphism that increase inter‐morph pollen transfer and promote disassortative mating. Breakdown of heterostyly has happened many times, either leading to dioecy or monomorphism. Mussaenda is a genus with diverse sexual systems including distyly, dioecy, floral monomorphism, and homostyly, making it an ideal system to study the evolution of floral traits and their relationship with sexual system shifts. Here, floral traits and pollen–ovule (P/O) ratios were estimated and used to test hypotheses about the relationships among P/O ratios, floral trait evolution, and sexual system shifts. Our results revealed that there is no significant difference of reciprocity in upper level sexual organs between species with different sexual systems. The reciprocity indices of the lower level sexual organs, however, are smaller in species with functional dioecy than in those with distyly. P/O ratios in dimorphic Mussaenda species were relatively lower than in monomorphic outcrossing species, but did not differ significantly between species with distyly and functional dioecy. Populational P/O ratios were negatively correlated with reciprocity index in the dimorphic species. We suggest that the loss of function in lower level organs in species with functional dioecy has resulted from less strict reciprocity. The relationship between P/O ratios and reciprocity indices strongly support that efficient disassortative pollination of distylus flowers may have promoted evolution towards low P/O ratios.     

簇枝补血草花的二态性及繁育系统研究

白花丹科被列为异型花柱较多的科,该文以补血草属簇枝补血草为材料,通过对野外居群的花部特征、花期物候和繁育系统等研究,探讨花部形态多态性及其对生殖的影响。簇枝补血草具有两种类型植株,具玉米状柱头和A型花粉的植株称为C型植株;具乳头状柱头和B型花粉的植株称为P型植株,且A/B型花粉的大小、外壁纹饰不同。单花发育过程中两型植株的花萼、雌蕊大小差异明显,随着花的成熟差异逐渐消失。两型植株都为雌蕊高于雄蕊,柱头探出式雌雄异位;C型植株的花期较P型植株长约2 d。一天当中,A型花粉活力高峰期为13:00,B型花粉在11:00和15:00都表现为高峰期;玉米状柱头可授性最强时期在13:00～15:00,乳头状柱头则在15:00。两型花粉可育性在盛花期最高,终花期时B型花粉可育性明显高于A型。荧光染色观察发现花粉萌发和花粉管的生长速度都为:异型授粉＞同型授粉,B型花粉在乳头状柱头上不能完成受精。此外,人工授粉实验也表明异型授粉结实率显著高于同型,P型植株经同型授粉结实现象并不明显,存在少量无融合生殖。研究表明簇枝补血草花部具二态性,繁育系统为兼性异交,其中乳头状柱头对A型花粉亲和,对B型花粉不亲和,但玉米状柱头却对A/B型花粉都亲和,这打破了该科的异型自交不亲和的例证。     

FEATURES OF POLLEN FLOW IN DIMORPHIC SPECIES OF LYTHRUM SECTION EUHYSSOPIFOLIA

The North American Lythrum lineare L., L. alatum Pursh, L. curtissii Fernald, and L. californicum T. & G. have distylous flowers that differ in a number of traits. In the two species examined, pins have a stronger incompatibility system than thrums. Pins outnumber thrums in natural populations, but the ratio of the two may change radically during the course of a year, probably as a result of sexual reproduction. Exotic honeybees visiting L. californicum exhibited preferential collection of pin pollen over thrum pollen. The relative proportion of pin and thrum pollen grains transferred to stigmas is not dependent upon the proportion in which these pollen grains are produced in a population. Analyses of stigmatic pollen loads of L. lineare and L. californicum indicate very high levels of intramorph pollen flow. Although distyly is likely derived from tristyly in Lythrum, pollen flow patterns in trimorphic species seem to operate more “efficiently” than in dimorphic ones. It is probable that distyly has evolved from tristyly several times in the Lythraceae, but comparisons between pollen flow patterns in distylous species and those in a tristylous species provide no clear insights into the selective pressures that have led to this fundamental change in floral morphology and reproductive system.     

The distyly in Primula elatior (L.) Hill (Primulaceae), with a study of flowering phenology and pollen flow

Flowers of Primula elatior exhibit all the dimorphic traits typical of distyly. The difference in pollen production between pin and thrum flowers is not thought to be caused by the pollen size dimorphism. The percentage of pin pollen which is probably viable exceeds that of thrum pollen. In the population studied the morph ratio is 1:1, and plants are randomly dispersed with regard to morph type. Bumblebees are the main pollinators, and analysis of the stigmatic pollen load in naturally |xjllinated flowers shows that pin stigmas receive many more pollen grains than thrum stigmas. Intramorph pollination is considerable in pins, while thrums are subject to some differential pollination. Emasculation experiments have shown that intraflower pollination in the thrum morph is negligible. Aging of pin flowers has a reducing effect on their total pollen loads, while in thrums there is no change in total pollen load after the first days of anthesis.     

Pollen grain size, stigma depth, and style length: the relationships revisited

I examine data and review information in the literature to test hypotheses proposed by Delpino and Darwin to explain the source of nutrients utilized by pollen tubes. In 1867, Delpino, in his discussion of distyly, suggested that the positive relationship between pollen grain size and style length was based on the pollen grains containing sufficient nutrients to sustain the growth of their pollen tubes through their respective styles. Darwin (The different forms of flowers on plants of the same species, 2nd edn. J. Murray, London, 1884) rejected Delpino’s suggestion based on his examination of distylous species whose morphs produced pollen grains whose sizes were not proportionate to the lengths of their respective styles. Darwin then proposed that pollen tubes first grow autotrophically, i.e., through the stigma, then heterotrophically in the style. This should result in a positive relationship between pollen grain size and stigma depth, if pollen tubes grow autotrophically through the stigma. I examined 15 species in Fabaceae and 20 species in Proteaceae to test the two hypotheses. Pollen grain size was correlated with stigma depth among the Fabaceae, i.e., consistent with Darwin’s hypothesis, and was not correlated with style length in either family, i.e., inconsistent with Delpino’s proposal. Comparisons of related species, in general, were consistent with Darwin’s hypothesis. In addition, information in the literature provided no evidence that pollen tubes obtain resources on or in the stigma, i.e., pollen tube growth from the stigmatic surface to the style was autotrophic. In contrast, pollen tubes obtain an array of resources from the transmission tissue, thus there is little reason for pollen grains to contain those resources. In addition, I suggest that positive correlations between pollen grain size and style/pistil length may be a result of both being correlated with stigma depth.     

Pollen donation patterns in a tropical distylous shrub (PSYCHOTRIA SUERRENSIS; RUBIACEAE)

Selection on male function has been invoked to explain various floral features, including number of flowers, flower size, and flower color. Here I describe two experiments designed to examine the efficiency of distyly in promoting male floral function, as measured by successful pollen dispersal to stigmas. In both experiments, I performed emasculations to control the type of pollen locally available in a natural population of Psychotria suerrensis, a tropical shrub. In the “natural-recipients” experiment, I allowed each floral morph to donate pollen on alternate days to emasculated flowers of each morph. In the “paired-recipients” experiment, I attached paired cuttings of each morph to individual donor plants. The results of both methods were consistent. Pollen borne on low anthers (from pin plants) was transferred most efficiently to low stigmas (on thrum plants). Pollen borne on high anthers (from thrum plants) was dispersed in equal amounts to flowers of both morphs. The results suggest that distyly is only partially effective in achieving efficient pollen donation. Male function of pins is enhanced by the polymorphism, but male function of thrums is not. A supplemental pollination experiment illustrates that seed set in this species is predominantly pollen limited, reducing the importance of male function, in comparison with species where seed set is primarily resource limited.     

Isolation and characterization of a polygalacturonase gene highly expressed in Brassica napus pollen

A cDNA clone, Sta 44-4, corresponding to a mRNA highly expressed in Brassica napus cv. Westar stamens, was isolated by differential screening and characterized. Northern blot and in situ analyses demonstrated that Sta 44-4 is synthesized in pollen beginning at the late uninucleate stage and reaches a maximum in trinucleate microspores. Sta 44-4 displayed significant sequence similarity to known pollen polygalacturonase genes. The B. napus pollen polygalacturonase gene was shown to be part of a small gene family and to display some polymorphism among different cultivars.     

Heterostyly and Pollen-tube Interactions in Luculia gratissima (Rubiaceae)

Observations on the floral biology of Luculia gratissima (Rubiaceae)showed that this species is distylous with complementary positioningof anthers and stigmas in the two floral forms. Unusual featuresof distyly in this species include the larger size of the corolla,the stigma surface and the stigmatic papillae in the thrum flowerscompared to the pin ones. Stigmatic surfaces have similar secretionsbut they appear more copious in thrum than pin. The floral dimorphismwas accompanied by a very effective self-incompatibility systemand no seed was set on selfing. Seed number per capsule on crossingwas significantly greater in thrum flowers compared to pin.Incompatible pollen tubes were inhibited within 24 h at thebase of the stigma/top of the style in both morphs. Amputationof this region of the gynoecium removed the self-incompatibilityreaction in thrum but not pin flowers. Pollination with a mixtureof compatible and incompatible pollen and sequential pollinationwith self followed by cross pollen showed that there were interactionsbetween the two types of pollen tube. The presence of compatibletubes was found to cause the excessive swelling of the pollen-tubetip of the incompatible ones. The incompatible tubes did notappear to have any effect on the growth of compatible ones. Luculia gratissima, distyly, floral biology, self-incompatibility, pollen-tube interactions     

Inheritance of spontaneous mutant homostyles in Turnera subulata x krapovickasii and in autotetraploid T. scabra (Turneraceae)

To explore the genetic architecture of distyly in Turnera spp., we determined the inheritance and compatibility behaviour of two spontaneous homostyled mutants. A long-homostyled mutant shoot arose on an otherwise short-styled plant that was an artificial hybrid (Turnera subulata x T. krapovickasii) between two diploid distylous species. The mutation appears to be an allele, SH, of the distyly locus with the dominance relationships, S>SH>s, where S confers the short-styled phenotype, SH confers homostyly in SHSH and SHs genotypes, and ss genotypes are long-styled. Aberrant segregation ratios were observed among some crosses and might be the result of pollen competition. Compatibility relationships are consistent with the hypothesis that a gene complex determines distyly. Infrequently, revertant short-styled flowers have appeared on cuttings of the T. subulata x T. krapovickasii mutant and on occasion, short-styled progeny have appeared in crosses where none were expected. A second mutant homostyle was discovered in autotetraploid T. scabra. The mutation is inherited as above, however, tetrasomic inheritance occurs at the locus. This homostyled mutant carries two copies of the SH allele and has the duplex genotype SHSHss. Compatibility relationships were as observed above. The occurrence of homostyled mutants is consistent with the hypothesis that a linked gene complex underlies the inheritance of distyly in Turnera but we cannot discount the hypothesis that an allelic series is responsible.     

Differential expression of a polygalacturonase gene family in Arabidopsis thaliana

By systematic sequencing of a flower bud cDNA library from Arabidopsis thaliana, we have identified four cDNAs encoding polygalacturonase. The corresponding genes, together with seven other A. thaliana genes present in the databases, form a small gene family. Sequence comparisons of the deduced polypeptides within the gene family or with other plant polygalacturonases allow classification of the genes into different clades. Five polygalacturonases, including all those isolated from the flower buds, are closely related to the enzyme in pollen. Of the six remaining polygalacturonases, three are more closely related to the abscission-specific type of enzyme and two others to the fruit polygalacturonase. The last one is more distantly related to the others and might correspond to a new type of polygalacturonase. Expression of the different genes was analysed on Northern blots and by a PCR-based strategy. Results indicate that if, as expected, the cDNAs isolated from the flower bud library are strongly expressed in pollen, other genes are expressed at a low level in young developing tissues, such as in seedlings and roots, suggesting that they could be implicated in the cell wall modifications observed during cell elongation and/or expansion which occur in these tissues.