Mutations within Four Distinct Gag Proteins Are Required To Restore Replication of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 after Deletion Mutagenesis within the Dimerization Initiation Site

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genomic RNA segments at nucleotide (nt) positions +240 to +274 are thought to form a stem-loop secondary structure, termed SL1, that serves as a dimerization initiation site for viral genomic RNA. We have generated two distinct deletion mutations within this region, termed BH10-LD3 and BH10-LD4, involving nt positions +238 to +253 and +261 to +274, respectively, and have shown that each of these resulted in significant diminutions in levels of viral infectiousness. However, long-term culture of each of these viruses in MT-2 cells resulted in a restoration of infectiousness, due to a series of compensatory point mutations within four distinct proteins that are normally cleaved from the Gag precursor. In the case of BH10-LD3, these four mutations were MA1, CA1, MP2, and MNC, and they involved changes of amino acid Val-35 to Ile within the matrix protein (MA), Ile-91 to Thr within the capsid (CA), Thr-12 to Ile within p2, and Thr-24 to Ile within the nucleocapsid (NC). The order in which these mutations were acquired by the mutated BH10-LD3 was MNC > CA1 > MP2 > MA1. The results of site-directed mutagenesis studies confirmed that each of these four substitutions contributed to the increased viability of the mutated BH10-LD3 viruses and that the MNC substitution, which was acquired first, played the most important role in this regard. Three point mutations, MP2, MNC, and MA2, were also shown to be sequentially acquired by viruses that had emerged in culture from the BH10-LD4 deletion. The first two of these were identical to those described above, while the last involved a change of Val-35 to Leu. All three of these substitutions were necessary to restore the infectiousness of mutated BH10-LD4 viruses to wild-type levels, although the MP2 mutation alone, but neither of the other two substitutions, was able to confer some viability on BH10-LD4 viruses. Studies of viral RNA packaging showed that the BH10-LD4 deletion only marginally impaired encapsidation while the BH10-LD3 deletion caused a severe deficit in this regard.     

Deletion Mutagenesis within the Dimerization Initiation Site of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Results in Delayed Processing of the p2 Peptide from Precursor Proteins

Previous work has shown that deletions of genomic segments at nucleotide (nt) positions +238 to +253, i.e., construct BH10-LD3, or nt positions +261 to +274, i.e., construct BH10-LD4, within the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) dimerization initiation site (DIS) destroyed DIS secondary structure and dramatically reduced viral replication capacity. Surprisingly, two point mutations located within the viral peptide 2 (p2) and nucleocapsid (NC) protein termed MP2 and MNC, respectively, were able to compensate for this defect. Since the MP2 mutation involves an amino acid substitution near the cleavage site between p2 and NC, we investigated the effects of the above-mentioned deletions on the processing of Gag proteins. Immunoprecipitation assays performed with monoclonal antibodies against viral capsid (CA) (p24) protein showed that p2 was cleaved from CA with less efficiency in viruses that contained the LD3 and LD4 deletions than in wild-type viruses. The presence of the two compensatory mutations, MP2 and MNC, increased the efficiency of the cleavage of p2 from CA, but neither mutation alone had this effect or was sufficient to compensate for the observed impairment in infectiousness. A virus that contained both of the above-mentioned deletions within the DIS was also impaired in regard to processing and infectiousness, and it could likewise be compensated by the MP2 and MNC point mutations. These results suggest that the DIS region of HIV-1 RNA plays an important role in the processing of Gag proteins.     

Effects of a single amino acid substitution within the p2 region of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 on packaging of spliced viral RNA

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 encapsidates two copies of viral genomic RNA in the form of a dimer. The dimerization process initiates via a 6-nucleotide palindrome that constitutes the loop of a viral RNA stem-loop structure (i.e., stem loop 1 [SL1], also termed the dimerization initiation site [DIS]) located within the 5' untranslated region of the viral genome. We have now shown that deletion of the entire DIS sequence virtually eliminated viral replication but that this impairment was overcome by four second-site mutations located within the matrix (MA), capsid (CA), p2, and nucleocapsid (NC) regions of Gag. Interestingly, defective viral RNA dimerization caused by the DeltaDIS deletion was not significantly corrected by these compensatory mutations, which did, however, allow the mutated viruses to package wild-type levels of this DIS-deleted viral RNA while excluding spliced viral RNA from encapsidation. Further studies demonstrated that the compensatory mutation T12I located within p2, termed MP2, sufficed to prevent spliced viral RNA from being packaged into the DeltaDIS virus. Consistently, the DeltaDIS-MP2 virus displayed significantly higher levels of infectiousness than did the DeltaDIS virus. The importance of position T12 in p2 was further demonstrated by the identification of four point mutations,T12D, T12E, T12G, and T12P, that resulted in encapsidation of spliced viral RNA at significant levels. Taken together, our data demonstrate that selective packaging of viral genomic RNA is influenced by the MP2 mutation and that this represents a major mechanism for rescue of viruses containing the DeltaDIS deletion.     

Effects of Defined Mutations in the 5′ Nontranslated Region of Rubella Virus Genomic RNA on Virus Viability and Macromolecule Synthesis

The 5′ end of the genomic RNA of rubella virus (RUB) contains a 14-nucleotide (nt) single-stranded leader (ss-leader) followed by a stem-and-loop structure [5′(+)SL] (nt 15 to 65), the complement of which at the 3′ end of the minus-strand RNA [3′(−)SL] has been proposed to function as a promoter for synthesis of genomic plus strands. A second intriguing feature of the 5′ end of the RUB genomic RNA is the presence of a short (17 codons) open reading frame (ORF) located between nt 3 and 54; the ORF encoding the viral nonstructural proteins (NSPs) initiates at nt 41 in an alternate translational frame. To address the functional significance of these features, we compared the 5′-terminal sequences of six different strains of RUB, with the result that the short ORF is preserved (although the coding sequence is not conserved) as is the stem part of both the 5′(+)SL and 3′(−)SL, while the upper loop part of both structures varies. Next, using Robo302, an infectious cDNA clone of RUB, we introduced 31 different mutations into the 5′-terminal noncoding region, and their effects on virus replication and macromolecular synthesis were examined. This mutagenesis revealed that the short ORF is not essential for virus replication. The AA dinucleotide at nt 2 and 3 is of critical importance since point mutations and deletions that altered or removed both of these nucleotides were lethal. None of the other mutations within either the ss-leader or the 5′(+)SL [and accordingly within the 3′(−)SL], including deletions of up to 15 nt from the 5′(+)SL and three different multiple-point mutations that lead to destabilization of the 5′(+)SL, were lethal. Some of the mutations within both ss-leader and the 5′(+)SL resulted in viruses that grew to lower titers than the wild-type virus and formed opaque and/or small plaques; in general mutations within the stem had a more profound effect on viral phenotype than did mutations in either the ss-leader or upper loop. Mutations in the 5′(+)SL, but not in the ss-leader, resulted in a significant reduction in NSP synthesis, indicating that this structure is important for efficient translation of the NSP ORF. In contrast, viral plus-strand RNA synthesis was unaffected by the 5′(+)SL mutations as well as the ss-leader mutations, which argues against the proposed function of the 3′(−)SL as a promoter for initiation of the genomic plus-strand RNA.     

Transmissible Gastroenteritis Coronavirus Genome Packaging Signal Is Located at the 5′ End of the Genome and Promotes Viral RNA Incorporation into Virions in a Replication-Independent Process

Preferential RNA packaging in coronaviruses involves the recognition of viral genomic RNA, a crucial process for viral particle morphogenesis mediated by RNA-specific sequences, known as packaging signals. An essential packaging signal component of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus (TGEV) has been further delimited to the first 598 nucleotides (nt) from the 5′ end of its RNA genome, by using recombinant viruses transcribing subgenomic mRNA that included potential packaging signals. The integrity of the entire sequence domain was necessary because deletion of any of the five structural motifs defined within this region abrogated specific packaging of this viral RNA. One of these RNA motifs was the stem-loop SL5, a highly conserved motif in coronaviruses located at nucleotide positions 106 to 136. Partial deletion or point mutations within this motif also abrogated packaging. Using TGEV-derived defective minigenomes replicated in trans by a helper virus, we have shown that TGEV RNA packaging is a replication-independent process. Furthermore, the last 494 nt of the genomic 3′ end were not essential for packaging, although this region increased packaging efficiency. TGEV RNA sequences identified as necessary for viral genome packaging were not sufficient to direct packaging of a heterologous sequence derived from the green fluorescent protein gene. These results indicated that TGEV genome packaging is a complex process involving many factors in addition to the identified RNA packaging signal. The identification of well-defined RNA motifs within the TGEV RNA genome that are essential for packaging will be useful for designing packaging-deficient biosafe coronavirus-derived vectors and providing new targets for antiviral therapies.     

Partial Restoration of Replication of Simian Immunodeficiency Virus by Point Mutations in either the Dimerization Initiation Site (DIS) or Gag Region after Deletion Mutagenesis within the DIS

We used the simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) molecular clone SIVmac239 to generate a deletion construct, termed SD2, in which we eliminated 22 nucleotides at positions +398 to +418 within the putative dimerization initiation site (DIS) stem. This SD2 deletion severely impaired viral replication, due to adverse effects on the packaging of viral genomic RNA, the processing of Gag proteins, and viral protein patterns. However, long-term culture of SD2 in either C8166 or CEMx174 cells resulted in restoration of replication capacity, due to two different sets of three compensatory point mutations, located within both the DIS and Gag regions. In the case of C8166 cells, both a K197R and a E49K mutation were identified within the capsid (CA) protein and the p6 protein of Gag, respectively, while the other point mutation (A423G) was found within the putative DIS loop. In the case of CEMx174 cells, two compensatory mutations were present within the viral nucleocapsid (NC) protein, E18G and Q31K, in addition to the same A423G substitution as observed with C8166 cells. A set of all three mutations was required in each case for restoration of replication capacity, and either set of mutations could be substituted for the other in both the C8166 and CEMx174 cell lines.     

Dimer initiation signal of human immunodeficiency virus type 1: its role in partner selection during RNA copackaging and its effects on recombination

Frequent human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) recombination occurs during DNA synthesis when portions of the two copackaged RNAs are used as templates to generate a hybrid DNA copy. Therefore, the frequency of copackaging of genomic RNAs from two different viruses (heterozygous virion formation) affects the generation of genotypically different recombinants. We hypothesized that the selection of copackaged RNA partners is largely determined by Watson-Crick pairing at the dimer initiation signal (DIS), a 6-nucleotide palindromic sequence at the terminal loop of stem-loop 1 (SL1). To test our hypothesis, we examined whether heterozygous virion formation could be encouraged by manipulation of the DIS. Three pairs of viruses were generated with compensatory DIS mutations, designed so that perfect DIS base pairing could only occur between RNAs derived from different viruses, not between RNAs from the same virus. We observed that vector pairs with compensatory DIS mutations had an almost twofold increase in recombination rates compared with wild-type viruses. These data suggest that heterozygous virion formation was enhanced in viruses with compensatory DIS mutations (from 50% to more than 90% in some viral pairings). The role of the SL1 stem in heterozygous virion formation was also tested; our results indicated that the intermolecular base pairing of the stem sequences does not affect RNA partner selection. In summary, our results demonstrate that the Watson-Crick pairing of the DIS is a major determinant in the selection of the copackaged RNA partner, and altering the base pairing of the DIS can change the proportion of heterozygous viruses in a viral population. These results also strongly support the hypothesis that HIV-1 RNA dimers are formed prior to encapsidation.     

Role of the hepatitis C virus core+1 open reading frame and core cis-acting RNA elements in viral RNA translation and replication

Four conserved RNA stem-loop structures designated SL47, SL87, SL248, and SL443 have been predicted in the hepatitis C virus (HCV) core encoding region. Moreover, alternative translation products have been detected from a reading frame overlapping the core gene (core+1/ARFP/F). To study the importance of the core+1 frame and core-RNA structures for HCV replication in cell culture and in vivo, a panel of core gene silent mutations predicted to abolish core+1 translation and affecting core-RNA stem-loops were introduced into infectious-HCV genomes of the isolate JFH1. A mutation disrupting translation of all known forms of core+1 and affecting SL248 did not alter virus production in Huh7 cells and in mice xenografted with human liver tissue. However, a combination of mutations affecting core+1 at multiple codons and at the same time, SL47, SL87, and SL248, delayed RNA replication kinetics and substantially reduced virus titers. The in vivo infectivity of this mutant was impaired, and in virus genomes recovered from inoculated mice, SL87 was restored by reversion and pseudoreversion. Mutations disrupting the integrity of this stem-loop, as well as that of SL47, were detrimental for virus viability, whereas mutations disrupting SL248 and SL443 had no effect. This phenotype was not due to impaired RNA stability but to reduced RNA translation. Thus, SL47 and SL87 are important RNA elements contributing to HCV genome translation and robust replication in cell culture and in vivo.     

Possible role of dimerization in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genome RNA packaging

The dimer initiation site/dimer linkage sequence (DIS/DLS) region in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA genome is suggested to play important roles in various steps of the virus life cycle. However, due to the presence of a putative DIS/DLS region located within the encapsidation signal region (E/psi), it is difficult to perform a mutational analysis of DIS/DLS without affecting the packaging of RNA into virions. Recently, we demonstrated that duplication of the DIS/DLS region in viral RNA caused the production of partially monomeric RNAs in virions, indicating that the region indeed mediated RNA-RNA interaction. We utilized this system to assess the precise location of DIS/DLS in the 5' region of the HIV-1 genome with minimum effect on RNA packaging. We found that the entire lower stem of the U5/L stem-loop was required for packaging, whereas the region important for dimer formation was only 10 bases long within the lower stem of the U5/L stem-loop. The R/U5 stem-loop was required for RNA packaging but was completely dispensable for dimer formation. The SL1 lower stem was important for both dimerization and packaging, but surprisingly, deletion of the palindromic sequence at the top of the loop only partially affected dimerization. These results clearly indicated that the E/psi of HIV-1 is much larger than the DIS/DLS and that the primary DIS/DLS is completely included in the E/psi. Therefore, it is suggested that RNA dimerization is a part of RNA packaging, which requires multiple steps.     

Leader sequences downstream of the primer binding site are important for efficient replication of simian immunodeficiency virus

Simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) infection of macaques is remarkably similar to that of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in humans, and the SIV-macaque system is a good model for AIDS research. We have constructed an SIV proviral DNA clone that is deleted of 97 nucleotides (nt), i.e., construct SD, at positions (+322 to +418) immediately downstream of the primer binding site (PBS) of SIVmac239. When this construct was transfected into COS-7 cells, the resultant viral progeny were severely impaired with regard to their ability to replicate in C8166 cells. Further deletion analysis showed that a virus termed SD1, containing a deletion of 23 nt (+322 to +344), was able to replicate with wild-type kinetics, while viruses containing deletions of 21 nt (+398 to +418) (construct SD2) or 53 nt (+345 to +397) (construct SD3) displayed diminished capacity in this regard. Both the SD2 and SD3 viruses were also impaired with regard to ability to package viral RNA, while SD1 viruses were not. The SD and SD3 constructs did not revert to increased replication ability in C8166 cells over 6 months in culture. In contrast, long-term passage of the SD2 mutated virus resulted in a restoration of replication capacity, due to the appearance of four separate point mutations. Two of these substitutions were located in leader sequences of viral RNA within the PBS and the dimerization initiation site (DIS), while the other two were located within two distinct Gag proteins, i.e., CA and p6. The biological relevance of three of these point mutations was confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis studies that showed that SD2 viruses containing each of these substitutions had regained a significant degree of viral replication capacity. Thus, leader sequences downstream of the PBS, especially the U5-leader stem and the DIS stem-loop, are important for SIV replication and for packaging of the viral genome.     

Infectious Molecular Clones with the Nonhomologous Dimer Initiation Sequences Found in Different Subtypes of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Can Recombine and Initiate a Spreading Infection In Vitro

Recombinant forms of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) have been shown to be of major importance in the global AIDS pandemic. Viral RNA dimer formation mediated by the dimerization initiation sequence (DIS) is believed to be essential for viral genomic RNA packaging and therefore for RNA recombination. Here, we demonstrate that HIV-1 recombination and replication are not restricted by variant DIS loop sequences. Three DIS loop forms found among HIV-1 isolates, DIS (CG), DIS (TA), and DIS (TG), when introduced into deletion mutants of HIV-1 recombined efficiently, and the progeny virions replicated with comparable kinetics. A fourth DIS loop form, containing an artificial AAAAAA sequence disrupting the putative DIS loop-loop interactions [DIS (A6)], supported efficient recombination with DIS loop variants; however, DIS (A6) progeny virions exhibited a modest replication disadvantage in mixed cultures. Our studies indicate that the nonhomologous DIS sequences found in different HIV-1 subtypes are not a primary obstacle to intersubtype recombination.     

HIV controls the selective packaging of genomic, spliced viral and cellular RNAs into virions through different mechanisms

In addition to genomic RNA, HIV-1 particles package cellular and spliced viral RNAs. In order to determine the encapsidation mechanisms of these RNAs, we determined the packaging efficiencies and specificities of genomic RNA, singly and fully spliced HIV mRNAs and different host RNAs species: 7SL RNA, U6 snRNA and GAPDH mRNA using RT-QPCR. Except GAPDH mRNA, all RNAs are selectively encapsidated. Singly spliced RNAs, harboring the Rev-responsible element, and fully spliced viral RNAs, which do not contain this motif, are enriched in virions to similar levels, even though they are exported from the nucleus by different routes. Deletions of key motifs (SL1 and/or SL3) of the packaging signal of genomic RNA indicate that HIV and host RNAs are encapsidated through independent mechanisms, while genomic and spliced viral RNA compete for the same trans-acting factor due to the presence of the 5′ common exon containing the TAR, poly(A) and U5-PBS hairpins. Surprisingly, the RNA dimerization initiation site (DIS/SL1) appears to be the main packaging determinant of genomic RNA, but is not involved in packaging of spliced viral RNAs, suggesting a functional interaction with intronic sequences. Active and selective packaging of host and spliced viral RNAs provide new potential functions to these RNAs in the early stages of the virus life cycle.     

HIV-1 viral RNA is selected in the form of monomers that dimerize in a three-step protease-dependent process; the DIS of stem-loop 1 initiates viral RNA dimerization

We have characterized the viral RNA conformation in wild-type, protease-inactive (PR-) and SL1-defective (DeltaDIS) human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), as a function of the age of the viruses, from newly released to grown-up (>or=24 h old). We report evidence for packaging HIV-1 genomic RNA (gRNA) in the form of monomers in PR- virions, viral RNA rearrangement (not maturation) within PR- HIV-1, protease-dependent formation of thermolabile dimeric viral RNAs, a new form of immature gRNA dimer at about 5 h post virion release, and slow-acting dimerization signals in SL1-defective viruses. The rates of gRNA dimer formation were >or=3-fold and >or=10-fold slower in DeltaDIS and PR- viruses than in wild-type, respectively. Thus, the DIS, i.e. the palindrome in the apical loop of SL1, is a dimerization initiation signal, but its role can be masked by one or several slow-acting dimerization site(s) when grown-up SL1-inactive virions are investigated. Grown-up PR- virions are not flawless models for immature virions because gRNA dimerization increases with the age of PR- virions, indicating that the PR- mutation does not "freeze" gRNA conformation in a nascent primordial state. Our study is the first on gRNA conformation in newly released mutant or primate retroviruses. It shows for the first time that the packaged retroviral gRNA matures in more than one step, and that formation of immature dimeric viral RNA requires viral protein maturation. The monomeric viral RNAs isolated from budding HIV-1, as modeled by newly released PR- virions, may be seen as dimers that are much more fragile than thermolabile dimers.     

Identification of cis-Acting Nucleotides and a Structural Feature in West Nile Virus 3′-Terminus RNA That Facilitate Viral Minus Strand RNA Synthesis

The 3′-terminal nucleotides (nt) of West Nile virus (WNV) genomic RNA form a penultimate 16-nt small stem-loop (SSL) and an 80-nt terminal stem-loop (SL). These RNA structures are conserved in divergent flavivirus genomes. A previous in vitro study using truncated WNV 3′ RNA structures predicted a putative tertiary interaction between the 5′ side of the 3′-terminal SL and the loop of the SSL. Although substitution or deletion of the 3′ G (nt 87) within the SSL loop, which forms the only G-C pair in the predicted tertiary interaction, in a WNV infectious clone was lethal, a finding consistent with the involvement in a functionally relevant pseudoknot interaction, extensive mutagenesis of nucleotides in the terminal SL did not identify a cis-acting pairing partner for this SSL 3′ G. However, both the sequence and the structural context of two adjacent base pairs flanked by symmetrical internal loops in the 3′-terminal SL were shown to be required for efficient viral RNA replication. Nuclear magnetic resonance analysis confirmed the predicted SSL and SL structures but not the tertiary interaction. The SSL was previously reported to contain one of three eEF1A binding sites, and G87 in the SSL loop was shown to be involved in eEF1A binding. The nucleotides at the bottom part of the 3′-terminal SL switch between 3′ RNA-RNA and 3′-5′ RNA-RNA interactions. The data suggest that interaction of the 3′ SL RNA with eEF1A at three sites and a unique metastable structural feature may participate in regulating structural changes in the 3′-terminal SL.     

SHAPE analysis of the FIV Leader RNA reveals a structural switch potentially controlling viral packaging and genome dimerization

Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) infects many species of cat, and is related to HIV, causing a similar pathology. High-throughput selective 2' hydroxyl acylation analysed by primer extension (SHAPE), a technique that allows structural interrogation at each nucleotide, was used to map the secondary structure of the FIV packaging signal RNA. Previous studies of this RNA showed four conserved stem-loops, extensive long-range interactions (LRIs) and a small, palindromic stem-loop (SL5) within the gag open reading frame (ORF) that may act as a dimerization initiation site (DIS), enabling the virus to package two copies of its genome. Our analyses of wild-type (wt) and mutant RNAs suggest that although the four conserved stem-loops are static structures, the 5' and 3' regions previously shown to form LRI also adopt an alternative, yet similarly conserved conformation, in which the putative DIS is occluded, and which may thus favour translational and splicing functions over encapsidation. SHAPE and in vitro dimerization assays were used to examine SL5 mutants. Dimerization contacts appear to be made between palindromic loop sequences in SL5. As this stem-loop is located within the gag ORF, recognition of a dimeric RNA provides a possible mechanism for the specific packaging of genomic over spliced viral RNAs.     

Randomization and in vivo selection reveal a GGRG motif essential for packaging human immunodeficiency virus type 2 RNA

The packaging signal (ψ) of human immunodeficiency virus type 2 (HIV-2) is present in the 5′ noncoding region of RNA and contains a 10-nucleotide palindrome (pal; 5′-392-GGAGUGCUCC) located upstream of the dimerization signal stem-loop 1 (SL1). pal has been shown to be functionally important in vitro and in vivo. We previously showed that the 3′ side of pal (GCUCC-3′) is involved in base-pairing interactions with a sequence downstream of SL1 to make an extended SL1, which is important for replication in vivo and the regulation of dimerization in vitro. However, the role of the 5′ side of pal (5′-GGAGU) was less clear. Here, we characterized this role using an in vivo SELEX approach. We produced a population of HIV-2 DNA genomes with random sequences within the 5′ side of pal and transfected these into COS-7 cells. Viruses from COS-7 cells were used to infect C8166 permissive cells. After several weeks of serial passage in C8166 cells, surviving viruses were sequenced. On the 5′ side of pal there was a striking convergence toward a GGRGN consensus sequence. Individual clones with consensus and nonconsensus sequences were tested in infectivity and packaging assays. Analysis of individuals that diverged from the consensus sequence showed normal viral RNA and protein synthesis but had replication defects and impaired RNA packaging. These findings clearly indicate that the GGRG motif is essential for viral replication and genomic RNA packaging.