Conformational alterations detected by circular dichroism induced in the normal ras p21 protein by activating point mutations at position 12, 59, or 61

Activation of the oncogenic potential of ras oncogenes occurs by point mutations at codons 12, 13, 59, 61, and 63 of the sequences that codify for its product, a 21-kDa protein designated as p21. This activation has been postulated by computer models as modifiers of the structure of the protein, which may alter its biochemical and biological activities. We have expressed in bacteria the normal ras p21 and five mutated p21 proteins with mutations at positions 12, 59, 61, 12 plus 59, and 12 plus 61. Purification was carried out by solubilization from bacterial pellets in 7 M urea and chromatography through a Sephadex G-100 column to obtain greater than 95% purified proteins. Circular dichroic (CD) spectra showed that the normal protein and that activated by substitution of Ala59 to Thr59 are very similar in their overall structure. By contrast, point mutations affecting either 12 or 61 residues substantially altered the structure of the proteins. When the parameters of Chen et al. [Biochemistry II, 4120-4131 (1972)] were applied to the CD spectra, both normal and thr59-mutated ras proteins showed a less organized structure than mutated proteins at position 12 or 61. Since the Thr59 mutant has more similar transforming activity than other activated proteins, but a GTPase activity similar to that of the normal protein, our results support the hypothesis that there is more than one mechanism of activation of the ras p21 protein. One of these mechanisms involves important structural alterations by point mutations at position 12 or 61 which reduce the GTPase activity of the protein. Another mechanism will be that induced by a substitution of Ala59 to Thr59 which does not substantially alter the protein conformation. A putative alternative mechanism for the activation of this mutant is discussed.     

Hydrolysis of GTP by the alpha-chain of Gs and other GTP binding proteins

The functions of G proteins--like those of bacterial elongation factor (EF) Tu and the 21 kDa ras proteins (p21ras)--depend upon their abilities to bind and hydrolyze GTP and to assume different conformations in GTP- and GDP-bound states. Similarities in function and amino acid sequence indicate that EF-Tu, p21ras, and G protein alpha-chains evolved from a primordial GTP-binding protein. Proteins in all three families appear to share common mechanisms for GTP-dependent conformational change and hydrolysis of bound GTP. Biochemical and molecular genetic studies of the alpha-chain of Gs (alpha s) point to key regions that are involved in GTP-dependent conformational change and in hydrolysis of GTP. Tumorigenic mutations of alpha s in human pituitary tumors inhibit the protein's GTPase activity and cause constitutive elevation of adenylyl cyclase activity. One such mutation replaces a Gln residue in alpha s that corresponds to Gln-61 of p21ras; mutational replacements of this residue in both proteins inhibit their GTPase activities. A second class of GTPase inhibiting mutations in alpha s occurs in the codon for an Arg residue whose covalent modification by cholera toxin also inhibits GTP hydrolysis by alpha s. This Arg residue is located in a domain of alpha s not represented in EF-Tu or p21ras. We propose that this domain constitutes an intrinsic activator of GTP hydrolysis, and that it performs a function analogous to that performed for EF-Tu by the programmed ribosome and for p21ras by the recently discovered GTPase-activating protein.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The structure of Ras protein: a model for a universal molecular switch.

X-ray crystallography has revealed the molecular architecture of the cellular and oncogenic forms of p21Ha-ras, the protein encoded by the human Ha-ras gene, in both its active (GTP-bound) and in its inactive (GDP-bound) forms. From comparison of these two structures, a mechanism is suggested for the GTPase hydrolysis reaction that triggers the conformational change necessary for signal transduction. The structures have also allowed identification of the structural consequences of point mutations and the way in which they interfere with the intrinsic GTPase activity of p21ras. The p21ras structure is similar to that of the G-domain of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) from Escherichia coli, suggesting that p21ras can serve as a good model for other guanine nucleotide binding proteins.     

Activation of Ha-ras p21 by substitution, deletion, and insertion mutations.

The transforming activity of naturally arising ras oncogenes results from point mutations that affect residue 12 or 61 of the encoded 21-kilodalton protein (p21). By use of site-directed mutagenesis, we showed that deletions and insertions of amino acid residues in the region of residue 12 are also effective in conferring oncogenic activity on p21. Common to these various alterations is the disruption that they create in this domain of the protein, which we propose results in the inactivation of a normal function of the protein.     

Prognostic significance of p16INK4a alterations and 9p21 loss of heterozygosity in locally advanced laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma

The p16INK4a gene, localized within chromosome 9p21, has been identified as a cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor and may negatively regulate the cell cycle acting as a tumor suppressor. Genetic alterations involving the 9p21 region are common in human cancers. A consecutive series of 64 untreated patients (median of follow up 53 months) undergoing surgical resection for locally advanced laryngeal squamous-cell carcinomas (LSCCs) has been studied prospectively. Our purpose was to investigate p16 alterations (9p21 allelic loss, hypermethylation and point mutations) and their possible association with clinico-pathological data and flow cytometric variables (DNA-ploidy and S-phase fraction (SPF)), and to determine the possible prognostic role of this gene in these tumors. PCR-based techniques were used for investigating 9p21 loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and methylation promoter status of the p16 gene. p16 mutations were detected by PCR-SSCP (single strand conformation polymorphism) and sequencing. 9p21 LOH was detected in 16/62 (26%) informative tumors, point mutations in 5% (3/64) and hypermethylation in 9% (6/64) of the cases. p16 alterations were significantly associated with high SPF and DNA-aneuploidy. By univariate analysis, poor histologic differentiation, stage IV, DNA-aneuploidy and p16 point mutations proved to be significantly related to quicker relapse, whereas these same factors, and in addition high SPF, 9p21 LOH and any p16 alterations were significantly related to shorter overall survival. By Cox proportional hazards analysis only histologic grade (G3) and p16 point mutations were independently related to both disease relapse and death. Our study has identified p16 point mutations as important biomolecular indicators in LSCCs.     

Biochemical and biological activity of phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated ras p21 mutants.

In contrast to all cellular ras oncogenes which carry a single activating mutation at codon 12, 13 or 61, all known retroviral ras oncogenes have two mutations at codons 12 and 59. To understand the role of the mutation at codon 59, we have constructed plasmids containing genes for Harvey ras: p21(Gly-12,Thr-59) and p21(Val-12,Thr-59). Escherichia coli expressed proteins and their respective phosphorylated (Pi) and non-phosphorylated (non-Pi) proteins were purified to 95% homogeneity by ion-exchange chromatography and gel filtration. GTPase, autophosphorylation and nucleotide exchange activities of the mutants were studied. When the mutants were microinjected into Xenopus oocytes, the non-phosphorylated forms of p21(Gly-12,Thr-59) and p21(Val-12,Thr-59) showed high activity. Surprisingly, their phosphorylated forms were inactive. These results suggest that threonine at position 59 endows the protein with transforming activity but that phosphorylation of the residue inhibits biological activity. A structural interpretation of the observation is presented.     

Use of the two-hybrid system to identify protein-protein interaction temperature-sensitive mutants: application to the CDK2/p21Cip1 interaction.

We describe the application of the two-hybrid system to the identification of protein-protein interaction temperature-sensitive mutants. We applied this strategy to the interaction between the human CDK2 cell cycle regulator and the p21Cip1 regulatory subunit. A library of randomly generated CDK2 mutant proteins was screened for interaction with p21Cip1 at different temperatures. This approach resulted in the isolation of single point mutations in CDK2 causing temperature-sensitive interaction with p21Cip1. Our results demonstrate that the two-temperature two-hybrid screen is an efficient approach for the rational design and screening of protein-protein interaction conditional mutations.     

Inhibition of the ras p21 GTPase-activating protein-stimulated GTPase activity of c-Ha-ras p21 by smg p21 having the same putative effector domain as ras p21s

ras p21 GTPase-activating protein (GAP) has been proposed to interact with the putative effector domain of ras p21s, and smg p21, a ras p21-like guanine nucleotide binding protein (G protein), has been shown to have the same amino acid sequence as ras p21s in this region. In the present studies, we examined the effects of ras p21 GAP on the GTPase activity of smg p21 purified from human platelets, of smg p21 on the ras p21 GAP-stimulated GTPase activity of c-Ha-ras p21 purified from Escherichia coli, and of c-Ha-ras p21 on the smg p21 GAP1- or -2-stimulated GTPase activity of smg p21. ras p21 GAP stimulated the GTPase activity of c-Ha-ras p21 but not that of smg p21. The GTP-bound form of smg p21, however, inhibited the ras p21 GAP-stimulated GTPase activity of c-Ha-ras p21 in a dose-dependent manner. The half-maximum inhibition by smg p21 was obtained at 0.4 microM which was more potent than previously observed for ras p21 (2-200 microM). The GDP-bound form also inhibited the ras p21 GAP-stimulated GTPase activity of c-Ha-ras p21, but the efficiency was 40-50% that of the GTP-bound form. smg p21 GAP1 and -2 stimulated the GTPase activity of smg p21 but not that of c-Ha-ras p21. c-Ha-ras p21 did not inhibit the smg p21 GAP1- or -2-stimulated GTPase activity of smg p21. These results indicate that ras p21 GAP interacts with smg p21 without the subsequent stimulation of its GTPase activity.     

Potentiation of cysteine proteinase-inhibitor activity of full-length Ha-ras oncogene products by denaturation-renaturation

We have investigated protease-inhibitory activity against cathepsin L of human and murine Ha-ras oncogene products (p21s) produced by Escherichia coli. The inhibitory activity of full-length p21s was much weaker than that of truncated p21s, however, the inhibitory activity was potentiated after denaturation with 8 M urea and 2 M NaCl followed by renaturation. These suggest that p21 can be folded into multiple three-dimensional conformations which have different protease-inhibitory activities.     

Structural significance of the GTP-binding domain of ras p21 studied by site-directed mutagenesis.

Point mutations of p21 proteins were constructed by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of the v-rasH oncogene, which substituted amino acid residues within the nucleotide-binding consensus sequence, GXG GXGK. When the glycine residue at position 10, 13, or 15 was substituted with valine, the viral rasH product p21 lost its GTP-binding and autokinase activities. Other substitutions at position 33, 51, or 59 did not impair its binding activity. G418-resistant NIH 3T3 cell lines were derived by transfection with constructs obtained by inserting the mutant proviral DNA into the pSV2neo plasmid. Clones with a valine mutation at position 13 or 15 were incapable of transforming cells, while all other mutants with GTP-binding activity were competent. A mutant with a substitution of valine for glycine at position 10 which had lost its ability to bind GTP and its autokinase activity was fully capable of transforming NIH 3T3 cells. These cells grew in soft agar and rapidly formed tumors in nude mice. The p21 of cell lines derived from tumor explants still lacked the autokinase activity. These findings suggest that the glycine-rich consensus sequence is important in controlling p21 activities and that certain mutations may confer to p21 its active conformation without participation of ligand binding.     

A polymorphism but no mutations in the GADD45 gene in breast cancers

The p53 gene product is part of a pathway regulating growth arrest at the G₁ checkpoint of the cell cycle. Mutation of other components of this pathway, including the products of the ataxia telangiectasia (AT), GADD45, mdm2, and p21^WAF1/CIP1 genes may have effects comparable to mutations in the p53 gene. The GADD45 gene is induced by ionizing radiation and several DNA-damaging xenobiotics. Induction requires the binding of wild-type p53 to an evoulutionarily highly conserved putative intronic p53 binding site in intron 3 of GADD45. We recently analyzed the entire coding region of the p53 gene in primary breast cancers of Midwestern white women and found 21 mutations among 53 tumors (39,6%). We now have shown by direct sequencing that there are no mutations in the intronic p53 binding site of the GADD45 gene in any of the 53 primary breast cancers and no mutations in the entire coding region of the GADD45 gene in a subset of 26 consecutive tumors (12 with p53 mutation and 14 without p53 mutation). The only sequence variation detected was a common polymorphism in intron 3. The absence of mutations in the GADD45 gene, including the putative p53-binding intronic site, suggests that this gene is not a frequent target of mutations in breast cancer. Although mutations of the p53 gene have been studied in a wide spectrum of human cancers, GADD45 has not been examined in any tumor or cell line to the best of our knowledge. Our results raise the possibility that mutation of the GADD45 gene alone is not functionally equivalent to loss of wild-type p53 activity. Received: 14 September 1995     

H-ras mutants lacking the epitope for the neutralizing monoclonal antibody Y13-259 show decreased biological activity and are deficient in GTPase-activating protein interaction.

We have generated deletion mutants of the H-ras p21 protein which lack residues 58 to 63 or 64 to 68 and contain either the normal glycine or an activating mutation, arginine, at position 12. None of the deleted proteins were recognized by monoclonal antibody Y13-259, and those mutants with activating mutations showed at least a 100-fold reduction in their transforming activities compared with the activities of their nondeleted counterparts. Alterations observed in the in vitro GTPase or GTP interchange properties of the deletion mutants were not consistent with the decrease in their transforming activities. Moreover, each mutant showed normal membrane localization, which is essential for its biological activity. Recently, a newly identified protein, designated GTPase-activating protein (GAP), was found to markedly increase GTPase activity of the normal ras p21 but not of p21 mutants bearing activating lesions (H. Adari, D. R. Lowy, B. M. Willumsen, C. J. Der, and F. McCormick, Science 240:518-521, 1988). We showed that GAP had no effect on the in vitro GTPase activity of the deletion mutants of the normal p21 protein. Since similar deletions in mutants with activating lesions at position 12 or 59 or both showed decreased transforming activity, our results suggest that the recognition site for Y13-259 within the ras p21 molecule influences directly or indirectly the interaction of ras p21 with GAP and that this interaction is critical for biological activity of ras proteins.     

Biochemical properties of Ha-ras encoded p21 mutants and mechanism of the autophosphorylation reaction

Kinetic studies performed on p21H guanine nucleotide complexes with and without Mg2+ show that point mutations at positions 12, 59, and 61 each have a different effect on the rate of nucleotide dissociation. Double mutants with a combination of these amino acid substitutions reveal that the effects of each mutation on these kinetics are interactive (nonadditive) for positions 12 and 59 and approximately additive for the positions 12 and 61. The magnitude and direction of the effects seen are dependent on the nature of the nucleotide and whether or not the complexes contain Mg2+. All the mutants have reduced GTPase activity. It is also shown that the autophosphorylation reaction velocity is of first order with respect to the protein concentration and that this reaction is an intramolecular one, which takes place as a side reaction of the GTPase reaction. The autophosphorylation is not reversible under the experimental conditions. The covalently bound phosphate does not decrease the nucleotide-binding ability of the protein nor does it change the relative affinity of the protein for GTP versus GDP. The results are discussed in terms of the structural model and function of p21H.     

Identification of the domains in cyclin A required for binding to, and activation of, p34cdc2 and p32cdk2 protein kinase subunits.

The binding of cyclin A to p34cdc2 and p32cdk2 and the protein kinase activity of the complexes has been measured by cell-free translation of the corresponding mRNA in extracts of frog eggs, followed by immunoprecipitation. A variety of mutant cyclin A molecules have been constructed and tested in this assay. Small deletions and point mutations of highly conserved residues in the 100-residue "cyclin box" abolish binding and activation of both p34cdc2 and p32cdk2. By contrast, large deletions at the N-terminus have no effect on kinase binding and activation, until they remove residues beyond 161, where the first conserved amino acids are found in all known examples of cyclin A. At the C-terminus, removal of 14 or more amino acids abolishes activity. We also demonstrate that deletion of, or point mutations, in the cyclin A homologue of the 10-residue "destruction box," previously described in cyclin B (Glotzer et al., 1991) abolish cyclin proteolysis at the transition from M-phase to interphase.     

Inhibition of cathepsin L-induced degradation of epidermal growth factor receptors by c-Ha-ras gene products

The inhibitory activities of c-Ha-ras gene products (p21s) toward several cysteine proteinases have been investigated. The activity of cathepsin L was inhibited by p21s most effectively while those of cathepsin B and papain were slightly inhibited by p21s. p21s did not show any inhibitory activity toward cathepsin H. In order to connect the protease-inhibitor activity of p21s with cell growth, the degradation of epidermal growth factor receptors (EGF-receptors) was investigated. EGF-receptors were preferentially cleaved by cathepsin L but not by cathepsin B or H. The cleavage of EGF-receptors by cathepsin L was inhibited by p21s dose-dependently. These results raise the possibility that p21s can suppress the degradation of growth-related proteins such as EGF-receptors and thereby affect cell growth.     

Functional interaction between p21rap1A and components of the budding pathway in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The rap1A gene encodes a 21-kDa, ras-related GTP-binding protein (p21rap1A) of unknown function. A close structural homolog of p21rap1A (65% identity in the amino-terminal two-thirds) is the RSR1 gene product (Rsr1p) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Although Rsr1p is not essential for growth, its presence is required for nonrandom selection of bud sites. To assess the similarity of these proteins at the functional level, wild-type and mutant forms of p21rap1A were tested for complementation of activities known to be fulfilled by Rsr1p. Expression of p21rap1A, like multicopy expression of RSR1, suppressed the conditional lethality of a temperature-sensitive cdc24 mutation. Point mutations predicted to affect the localization of p21rap1A or its ability to cycle between GDP and GTP-bound states disrupted suppression of cdc24ts, while other mutations in the 61-65 loop region improved suppression. Expression of p21rap1A could not, however, suppress the random budding phenotype of rsr1 cells. p21rap1A also apparently interfered with the normal activity of Rsrlp, causing random budding in diploid wild-type cells, suggesting an inability of p21rap1A to interact appropriately with Rsr1p regulatory proteins. Consistent with this hypothesis, we found an Rsr1p-specific GTPase-activating protein (GAP) activity in yeast membranes which was not active toward p21rap1A, indicating that p21rap1A may be predominantly GTP bound in yeast cells. Coexpression of human Rap1-specific GAP suppressed the random budding due to expression of p21rap1A or its derivatives, including Rap1AVal-12. Although Rap1-specific GAP stimulated the GTPase of Rsr1p in vitro, it did not dominantly interfere with Rsr1p function in vivo. A chimera consisting of Rap1A1-165::Rsr1p166-272 did not exhibit normal Rsr1p function in the budding pathway. These results indicated that p21rap1A and Rsr1p share at least partial functional homology, which may have implications for p21rap1A function in mammalian cells.     

Effector domain mutations dissociate p21ras effector function and GTPase-activating protein interaction.

The GTPase activity of p21ras is stimulated by GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs) such as p120GAP and the product of the neurofibromatosis 1 gene, which may negatively regulate p21 function. GAPs are also proposed effectors of ras. We have sought activating substitutions in c-H-ras in the region encoding the effector domain, on the rationale that such mutations would dissociate effector function from negative regulation by GAP. One such activating mutation, Pro-34-->Arg, encodes protein that is substantially bound to GTP in vivo. In vitro, this protein is not stimulated by GAPs, and its binding to p120GAP is grossly impaired. The results support the idea that the p21 structural requirements for effector function and GAP interaction are quite different and suggest that some molecule(s) other than p120GAP serves as the ras effector. In contrast to the results obtained with p120GAP, the Pro-34-->Arg p21 species is effectively coupled to the raf-1 product, as judged from electrophoretic mobility shifts of the Raf-1 phosphoprotein.