HlyC, the internal protein acyltransferase that activates hemolysin toxin: role of conserved histidine, serine, and cysteine residues in enzymatic activity as probed by chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis

HlyC is an internal protein acyltransferase that activates hemolysin, a toxic protein produced by pathogenic Escherichia coli. Acyl-acyl carrier protein (ACP) is the essential acyl donor. Separately subcloned, expressed, and purified prohemolysin A (proHlyA), HlyC, and [1-14C]myristoyl-ACP have been used to study the conversion of proHlyA to HlyA [Trent, M. S., Worsham, L. M., and Ernst-Fonberg, M. L. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 4644-4655]. HlyC and hemolysin belong to a family of at least 13 toxins produced by Gram-negative bacteria. The homologous acyltransferases of the family show a number of conserved residues that are possible candidates for participation in acyl transfer. Specific chemical reagents and site-directed mutagenesis showed that neither the single conserved cysteine nor the three conserved serine residues were required for enzyme activity. Treatment with the reversible histidine-modifying diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC) inhibited acyltransferase activity, and acyltransferase activity was restored following hydroxylamine treatment. The substrate myristoyl-ACP protected HlyC from DEPC inhibition. These findings and spectral absorbance changes suggested that histidine, particularly a histidine proximal to the substrate binding site, was essential for enzyme activity. Site-directed mutageneses of the single conserved histidine residue, His23, to alanine, cysteine, or serine resulted in each instance in complete inactivation of the enzyme.     

Thermodynamics of a protein acylation: activation of Escherichia coli hemolysin toxin

HlyC, hemolysin-activating lysine-acyltransferase, catalyses the acylation (from acyl-acyl carrier protein [ACP]) of Escherichia coli prohemolysin (proHlyA) on the epsilon-amino groups of specific lysine residues, 564 and 690 of the 1024 amino acid primary structure, to form hemolysin (HlyA). Isothermal titration calorimetry was used to measure the thermodynamic properties of the protein acylation of proHlyA-derived structures, altered by substantial deletions and separation of the acylation sites into two different peptides and site directed mutation analyses of acylation sites. Acylation of proHlyA-derived proteins catalyzed by HlyC was overall an exothermic reaction driven by a negative enthalpy. The reaction, whose kinetics are compatible to a ping-pong mechanism, is composed of two partial reactions. The first, the formation of an acyl-HlyC intermediate, was entropically driven, most likely by noncovalent complex formation between acyl-ACP and HlyC; enthalpy-driven acyl transfer followed, resulting in acyl-HlyC and ACPSH product formation. The second partial reaction was an energetically unfavorable acyl transfer from acyl-enzyme intermediate to the final acyl acceptor, a proHlyA derivative. Overall the acylation of proHlyA-derived proteins catalyzed by HlyC was driven by the energetics of the acyl enzyme intermediate reaction. Of the two acylation sites, intactness of the site equivalent to proHlyA K564 was more important for acylation reaction thermodynamic stability.     

Insights into the catalytic mechanism of HlyC, the internal protein acyltransferase that activates Escherichia coli hemolysin toxin.

Hemolysin, a toxic protein secreted by pathogenic Escherichia coli, is converted from nontoxic prohemolysin, proHlyA, to toxic hemolysin, HlyA, by an internal protein acyltransferase, HlyC. Acyl-acyl carrier protein (ACP) is the essential acyl donor. The acyltransferase reaction proceeds through two partial reactions and entails formation of a reactive acyl-HlyC intermediate [Trent, M. S., Worsham, L. M., and Ernst-Fonberg, M. L. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 9541-9548]. The ping pong kinetic mechanism implied by these findings was validated using two different acyl-ACP substrates, thus verifying the independence of the previously demonstrated two partial reactions. Assessments of the stability of the acyl-HlyC intermediate revealed an increased stability at pH 8.6 compared to more acidic pHs. Mutations of a single conserved histidine residue essential for catalysis gave minimal activity when substituted with a tyrosine residue and no activity with a lysine residue. Unlike numerous other His23 mutants, however, the H23K enzyme showed significant acyl-HlyC formation although it was unable to transfer the acyl group from the proposed amide bond intermediate to proHlyA. These findings are compatible with transient formation of acyl-His23 during the course of HlyC catalysis. The effects of several other single site-directed mutations of conserved residues of HlyC on different portions of the reaction progress were examined using a 39 500 kDa fragment of proHlyA which was a more effective substrate than intact proHlyA.     

Escherichia coli alpha-hemolysin (HlyA) is heterogeneously acylated in vivo with 14-, 15-, and 17-carbon fatty acids

alpha-Hemolysin (HlyA) is a secreted protein virulence factor observed in certain uropathogenic strains of Escherichia coli. The active, mature form of HlyA is produced by posttranslational modification of the protoxin that is mediated by acyl carrier protein and an acyltransferase, HlyC. We have now shown using mass spectrometry that these modifications, when observed in protein isolated in vivo, consist of acylation at the epsilon-amino groups of two internal lysine residues, at positions 564 and 690, with saturated 14- (68%), 15- (26%), and 17- (6%) carbon amide-linked side chains. Thus, HlyA activated in vivo consists of a heterogeneous family of up to nine different covalent structures, and the substrate specificity of the HlyC acyltransferase appears to differ from that of the closely related CyaC acyltransferase expressed by Bordetella pertussis.     

An ordered reaction mechanism for bacterial toxin acylation by the specialized acyltransferase HlyC: formation of a ternary complex with acylACP and protoxin substrates

The 110 kDa haemolysin protoxin (proHlyA) is activated in the Escherichia coli cytosol by acyl carrier protein-dependent fatty acylation of two internal lysine residues, directed by the co-synthesized protein HlyC. Using an in vitro maturation reaction containing purified protoxin peptides and acylACP, we show unambiguously that HlyC possesses an apparently unique acyltransferase activity fully described by Michaelis-Menten analysis. The Vmax of HlyC at saturating levels of both substrates was approximately 115 nmol acyl group min-1 mg-1 with KMacylACP of 260 nM and KMproHlyA of 27 nM, kinetic parameters sufficient to explain why in vivo HlyC is required at a concentration equimolar to proHlyA. HlyC bound the fatty acyl group from acylACP to generate an acylated HlyC intermediate that was depleted in the presence of proHlyA, but enriched in the presence of proHlyA derivatives lacking acylation target sites. HlyC was also able to bind in vivo 4'-phosphopantetheine. Substitution of conserved amino acids that could act as putative covalent attachment sites did not prevent binding of the fatty acyl or 4'-phosphopantetheine groups. These data and substrate variation analyses suggest that the unique acylation reaction does not involve covalent attachment of fatty acid to the acyltransferase, but rather that it proceeds via a sequential ordered Bi-Bi reaction mechanism, requiring the formation of a non-covalent ternary acylACP-HlyC-proHlyA complex.     

A simple in vitro acylation assay based on optimized HlyA and HlyC purification

HlyA is a toxin secreted by uropathogenic Escherichia coli strains. HlyA belongs to the repeats in the toxin protein family and needs (i) a posttranslational, fatty acylation at two internal lysines by the acyltransferase HlyC and (ii) extracellular ion binding to achieve its active conformation. Both processes are not fully understood and experiments are often limited due to the low amounts of protein available. Here, we present an optimized purification protocol for the proteins involved in HlyA activation as well as a quick and nonradioactive assay for in vitro HlyA acylation. These may simplify future experiments, e.g., activity scanning and characterization of HlyA or HlyC mutants as demonstrated with single and double HlyA lysine mutants.     

HlyC, the internal protein acyltransferase that activates hemolysin toxin: roles of various conserved residues in enzymatic activity as probed by site-directed mutagenesis.

Hemolysin, a toxic protein produced by pathogenic Escherichia coli, is one of a family of homologous toxins and toxin-processing proteins produced by Gram-negative bacteria. HlyC, an internal protein acyltransferase, converts it from nontoxic prohemolysin to toxic hemolysin. Acyl-acyl carrier protein is the essential acyl donor. The acyltransferase reaction progresses through formation of a binary complex between acyl-ACP and HlyC to a reactive acyl-HlyC intermediate [Trent, M. S., Worsham, L. M., and Ernst-Fonberg, M. L. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 4644-4655]. The homologous acyltransferases of the family have a number of conserved amino acid residues that may be catalytically important. Experiments to illuminate the reaction mechanism were done. The formation of an acyl-enzyme intermediate suggested that the reaction likely proceeded through two partial reactions. The reversibility of the first partial reaction was shown by using separately subcloned, purified, and expressed substrates and enzyme. The effects of single site-directed mutations of conserved residues of HlyC on different portions of reaction progress (binary complex formation, acyl-enzyme formation, and enzyme activity, including kinetic parameters) were determined. Mutations of His23, the only residue essential for activity, formed normal binary complexes but were unable to form acyl-HlyC. The same was seen with S20A, a mutant with greatly impaired activity. Mutation of two conserved tyrosines separately to glycines results in greatly impaired binary complex and acyl-HlyC formation, but mutation of those residues to phenylalanines restored behavior to wild-type.     

Activation of hemolysin toxin: relationship between two internal protein sites of acylation

HlyC, hemolysin-activating lysine acyltransferase, catalyzes the acylation (from acyl-ACP) of Escherichia coli prohemolysin (proHlyA) on the epsilon-amino groups of specific lysine residues, Lys564 and Lys690 of the 1024-amino acid primary structure, to form hemolysin (HlyA). The amino acid sequences flanking the two acylation sites are not homologous except that each has a glycine residue immediately preceding the lysine which is acylated; there are, however, numerous GK sequences throughout proHlyA that are not acylation sites. The substrate specificity of acylation was examined. ProHlyA-derived structures, altered by substantial deletions and separation of the acylation sites into two different peptides and site-directed mutation analyses of acylation sites, often served as internal protein acylation substrates, and the kinetics of the acylations were measured. The two sites of acylation of proHlyA functioned independently of one another with HlyC; there did not appear to be a common HlyC binding site or processivity of the enzyme between the sites. Acyl-HlyC was likely the enzyme form that interacted with the final acylation substrate. In a variety of constructs, the two acylation sites had similar K(m) values, but their V(max) values and catalytic efficiencies as substrates differed. Internal protein acylation was inhibited by specific small peptides mimicking the primary structure of each acylation site except that the crucial lysines were replaced with arginines; similar small peptides containing the crucial lysine, however, were not acylated.     

Analysis of the in vivo activation of hemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli.

Hemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli containing the hlyCABD operon separated from the nonhemolytic pro-HlyA upon two-dimensional (2-D) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The migration distance indicated a net loss of two positive charges in HlyA as a result of the HlyC-mediated activation (modification). HlyA activated in vitro in the presence of [U-14C]palmitoyl-acyl carrier protein comigrated with in vivo-activated hemolysin on 2-D gels and was specifically labelled, in agreement with the assumption that the activation is accomplished in vitro and in vivo by covalent fatty acid acylation. The in vivo-modified amino acid residues were identified by peptide mapping and 2-D polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of mutant and truncated HlyA derivatives, synthesized in E. coli in the presence and absence of HlyC. These analyses indicated that the internal residues Lys-564 and Lys-690 of HlyA, which have recently been shown by others to be fatty acid acylated by HlyC in vitro, are also the only modification sites in vivo. HlyA activated in E. coli was quantitatively fatty acid acylated at both sites, and the double modification was required for wild-type hemolytic activity. Single modifications in mutant and truncated HlyA derivatives suggested that both lysine residues are independently fatty acid acylated by a mechanism requiring additional sequences or structures flanking the corresponding acylation site. The intact repeat domain of HlyA was not required for the activation. The pore-forming activities of pro-HlyA and singly modified HlyA mutants in planar lipid bilayer membranes suggested that the activation is not essential for transmembrane pore formation but rather required for efficient binding of the toxin to target membranes.     

Incomplete activation of Escherichia coli hemolysin (HlyA) due to mutations in the 3' region of hlyC.

Mutational analysis of the carboxy-terminal region of Escherichia coli HlyC was performed by site-directed mutagenesis. Replacement of residue Val-127 or Lys-129 reduced the activity of HlyC to about 30 or 60%, respectively, of that of the wild type, while replacement of Gly-128 reduced the activity to less than 1% of the wild-type level. Complete inactivation of HlyC was caused by a double mutation, replacement of Gly-128 with valine and of Lys-129 with isoleucine. Analysis of culture supernatants from mutants with reduced hemolytic activity by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis revealed the production and simultaneous secretion of nonacylated, monoacylated, and fully acylated HlyA forms, demonstrating impairment of the acylation reaction, possibly due to a decreased affinity of HlyC for the individual HlyA acylation sites.     

Amino acid residues of Escherichia coli acyl carrier protein involved in heterologous protein interactions

Acyl carrier protein (ACP) is a small, highly conserved protein with an essential role in a myriad of reactions throughout lipid metabolism in plants and bacteria where it interacts with a remarkable diversity of proteins. The nature of the proper recognition and precise alignment between the protein moieties of ACP and its many interactive proteins is not understood. Residues conserved among ACPs from numerous plants and bacteria were considered as possibly being crucial to ACP's function, including protein-protein interaction, and a method of identifying amino acid residue clusters of high hydrophobicity on ACP's surface was used to estimate residues possibly involved in specific ACP-protein interactions. On the basis of this information, single-site mutation analysis of multiple residues, one at a time, of ACP was used to probe the identities of potential contact residues of ACPSH or acyl-ACP involved in specific interactions with selected enzymes. The roles of particular ACP residues were more precisely defined by site-directed fluorescence analyses of various myristoyl-mutant-ACPs upon specific interaction with the Escherichia coli hemolysin-activating acyltransferase, HlyC. This was done by selectively labeling each mutated site, one at a time, with an environmentally sensitive fluoroprobe and observing its fluorescence behavior in the absence and presence of HlyC. Consequently, a picture of the portion of ACP involved in selected macromolecular interaction has emerged.     

Structural comparison of acyl carrier protein in acylated and sulfhydryl forms by two-dimensional 1H NMR spectroscopy

Sequence-specific assignments of 1H NMR resonances are obtained for the backbone protons of Escherichia coli acyl carrier protein, acylated with an eight-carbon chain covalently attached to the prosthetic group thiol (octanoyl-ACP). Comparison of 1H-1H sequential connectivities in the NOESY spectra of octanoyl-ACP and the unacylated protein (ACPSH) indicates that secondary structure is largely conserved on acylation. Changes in resonance positions observed for certain groups of residues are interpreted in terms of a model that describes the spatial reorientation of secondary structural elements in the protein resulting from introduction of the acyl chain.     

E. coli hemolysin interactions with prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell membranes.

The hemolysin toxin (HlyA) is secreted across both the cytoplasmic and outer membranes of pathogenic Escherichia coli and forms membrane pores in cells of the host immune system, causing cell dysfunction and death. The processes underlying the interaction of HlyA with the bacterial and mammalian cell membranes are remarkable. Secretion of HlyA occurs without a periplasmic intermediate and is directed by an uncleaved C-terminal targetting signal and the HlyB and HlyD translocator proteins, the former being a member of a transporter superfamily central to import and export of a wide range of substrates by prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. The separate process by which HlyA is targetted to mammalian cell membranes is dependent upon fatty acylation of a non-toxic precursor, proHlyA. This is achieved by a novel mechanism directed by the activator protein HlyC, which binds to an internal proHlyA recognition sequence and provides specificity for the transfer of fatty acid from cellular acyl carrier protein.     

Independent interaction of the acyltransferase HlyC with two maturation domains of the Escherichia coli toxin HlyA

The apparently unique fatty acylation mechanism that underlies activation (maturation) of Escherichia coli haemolysin and related toxins is further clarified by investigation of the interaction of protoxin with the specific acyltransferase HlyC. Using deleted protoxin variants and protoxin peptides as substrates in an in vitro maturation reaction dependent upon HlyC and acyl-acyl carrier protein, two independent HlyC recognition domains were identified on the 1024-residue protoxin, proA, and they were shown to span the two target lysine residues K₅₆₄ (KI) and K₆₉₀ (KII) that are fatty acylated. Each domain required 15–30 amino acids for basal recognition and 50–80 amino acids for wild-type acylation. The two domains (FAI and FAII) competed with each other in cis and in trans for HlyC. The affinity of FAI for HlyC is approximately four times greater than that of FAII resulting in an overall 80% acylation at KI and 20% acylation at KII in both whole toxin and peptide derivatives. No other proA sequences were required for toxin maturation, and excess Ca²⁺ prevented acylation of both lysines. The lack of primary sequence identity between FAI and FAll domains in proA and among corresponding sites on related protoxins currently precludes an explanation of the basis of HlyC recognition by proA.     

Acyl chains are responsible for the irreversibility in the Escherichia coli alpha-hemolysin binding to membranes

Hemolysin (HlyA) is an extracellular protein secreted by uropathogenic strains of Escherichia coli. The mature HlyA is able to bind to mammalian target cell membranes including those of the immune system, causing lysis. The lytic activity is absolutely dependent upon the Hlyc-dependent acylation of Prohemolysin. In this paper we show, through Trp fluorescence studies and denaturation in Guanidine hydrochloride, that the acylation is responsible for the loose conformation of the active protein, necessary to transform it from soluble to membrane-bound form. Previous studies showed that toxin binding to the bilayers occurs in, at least two ways, a reversible adsorption and irreversible insertion. We demonstrated that the irreversibility is due to the acyl chains in the HlyA, as shown by the protein transfer from multilamellar liposomes composed of palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) to large unilamellar vesicles containing POPC-doxyl as protein fluorescence quencher.     

Identification and preliminary characterization of temperature-sensitive mutations affecting HlyB,the translocator required for the secretion of haemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli

We have carried out a genetic analysis of Escherichia coli HlyB using in vitro(hydroxylamine) mutagenesis and regionally directed mutagenesis. From random mutagenesis, three mutants, temperature sensitive (Ts) for secretion, were isolated and the DNA sequenced: Glyl0Arg close to the N-terminus, Gly408Asp in a highly conserved small periplasmic loop region PIV, and Pro624Leu in another highly conserved region, within the ATP-binding region. Despite the Ts character of the Gly10 substitution, a derivative of HlyB, in which the first 25 amino acids were replaced by 21 amino acids of the λ Cro protein, was still active in secretion of HlyA. This indicates that this region of HlyB is dispensable for function. Interestingly, the Gly408Asp substitution was toxic at high temperature and this is the first reported example of a conditional lethal mutation in HlyB. We have isolated 4 additional mutations in PIV by directed mutagenesis, giving a total of 5 out of 12 residues substituted in this region, with 4 mutations rendering HlyB defective in secretion. The Pro624 mutation, close to the Walker B-site for ATP binding in the cytoplasmic domain is identical to a mutation in HisP that leads to uncoupling of ATP hydrolysis from the transport of histidine. The expression of a fully functional haemolysin translocation system comprising HlyC,A,B and D increases the sensitivity of E. coli to vancomycin 2.5-fold, compared with cells expressing HlyB and HlyD alone. Thus, active translocation of HlyA renders the cells hyperpermeable to the drug. Mutations in hlyB affecting secretion could be assigned to two classes: those that restore the level of vancomycin resistance to that of E. coli not secreting HlyA and those that still confer hypersensitivity to the drug in the presence of HlyA. We propose that mutations that promote vancomycin resistance will include mutations affecting initial recognition of the secretion signal and therefore activation of a functional transport channel. Mutations that do not alter HlyA-dependent vancomycin sensitivity may, in contrast, affect later steps in the transport process.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of acyl carrier protein (ACP) reveals amino acid residues involved in ACP structure and acyl-ACP synthetase activity.

Acyl carrier protein (ACP) interacts with many different enzymes during the synthesis of fatty acids, phospholipids, and other specialized products in bacteria. To examine the structural and functional roles of amino acids previously implicated in interactions between the ACP polypeptide and fatty acids attached to the phosphopantetheine prosthetic group, recombinant Vibrio harveyi ACP and mutant derivatives of conserved residues Phe-50, Ile-54, Ala-59, and Tyr-71 were prepared from glutathione S-transferase fusion proteins. Circular dichroism revealed that, unlike Escherichia coli ACP, V. harveyi-derived ACPs are unfolded at neutral pH in the absence of divalent cations; all except F50A and I54A recovered native conformation upon addition of MgCl(2). Mutant I54A was not processed to the holo form by ACP synthase. Some mutations significantly decreased catalytic efficiency of ACP fatty acylation by V. harveyi acyl-ACP synthetase relative to recombinant ACP, e.g. F50A (4%), I54L (20%), and I54V (31%), whereas others (V12G, Y71A, and A59G) had less effect. By contrast, all myristoylated ACPs examined were effective substrates for the luminescence-specific V. harveyi myristoyl-ACP thioesterase. Conformationally sensitive gel electrophoresis at pH 9 indicated that fatty acid attachment stabilizes mutant ACPs in a chain length-dependent manner, although stabilization was decreased for mutants F50A and A59G. Our results indicate that (i) residues Ile-54 and Phe-50 are important in maintaining native ACP conformation, (ii) residue Ala-59 may be directly involved in stabilization of ACP structure by acyl chain binding, and (iii) acyl-ACP synthetase requires native ACP conformation and involves interaction with fatty acid binding pocket residues, whereas myristoyl-ACP thioesterase is insensitive to acyl donor structure.     

Identification and preliminary characterization of temperature-sensitive mutations affecting HlyB, the translocator required for the secretion of haemolysin (HlyA) from Escherichia coli

We have carried out a genetic analysis of Escherichia coli HlyB using in vitro(hydroxylamine) mutagenesis and regionally directed mutagenesis. From random mutagenesis, three mutants, temperature sensitive (Ts) for secretion, were isolated and the DNA sequenced: Glyl0Arg close to the N-terminus, Gly408Asp in a highly conserved small periplasmic loop region PIV, and Pro624Leu in another highly conserved region, within the ATP-binding region. Despite the Ts character of the Gly10 substitution, a derivative of HlyB, in which the first 25 amino acids were replaced by 21 amino acids of the Cro protein, was still active in secretion of HlyA. This indicates that this region of HlyB is dispensable for function. Interestingly, the Gly408Asp substitution was toxic at high temperature and this is the first reported example of a conditional lethal mutation in HlyB. We have isolated 4 additional mutations in PIV by directed mutagenesis, giving a total of 5 out of 12 residues substituted in this region, with 4 mutations rendering HlyB defective in secretion. The Pro624 mutation, close to the Walker B-site for ATP binding in the cytoplasmic domain is identical to a mutation in HisP that leads to uncoupling of ATP hydrolysis from the transport of histidine. The expression of a fully functional haemolysin translocation system comprising HlyC,A,B and D increases the sensitivity of E. coli to vancomycin 2.5-fold, compared with cells expressing HlyB and HlyD alone. Thus, active translocation of HlyA renders the cells hyperpermeable to the drug. Mutations in hlyB affecting secretion could be assigned to two classes: those that restore the level of vancomycin resistance to that of E. coli not secreting HlyA and those that still confer hypersensitivity to the drug in the presence of HlyA. We propose that mutations that promote vancomycin resistance will include mutations affecting initial recognition of the secretion signal and therefore activation of a functional transport channel. Mutations that do not alter HlyA-dependent vancomycin sensitivity may, in contrast, affect later steps in the transport process.     

Specific arginine and threonine residues control anion binding and transport in the light-driven chloride pump halorhodopsin.

The light-driven chloride pump halorhodopsin (HR), a halobacterial retinal protein, was studied by comparing wild type with specific mutants. Changes of conserved arginine and threonine residues in the transmembrane regions could be classified in two categories: in the extracellular half of the molecule, mutations influence anion uptake and binding. R108 mutations abolish all anion effects previously attributed to two distinct binding sites and change the characteristic photochemistry. Neutral residues at position 108 completely inactivate the pump. T111 increases the affinity of this anion binding site without being essentially important. In the photochemical cycles of the mutants T111V and Q105E, a red-shifted absorbing intermediate is enriched indicating retarded anion uptake. On the cytoplasmic side, mutations do not change anion binding properties of the unphotolyzed protein, but slow down anion release thereby reducing the chloride transport activity and the photocycling rate. The lowest activity is found for T203V, while R200 mutations have weaker effects. Thus, in the symmetrically arranged pairs R108/T111 and T203/R200, threonine and arginine play different roles, reflecting high affinity anion uptake by the former and effective anion release catalyzed by the latter residues. A model for the anion transport mechanism in HR is suggested comprising the specific functions of channel-lining residues.