SLE血清中抗-DNA抗体分离和性质的研究

本文用国产高分子树脂(T)接枝小牛胸腺DNA,通过亲合层析从系统性红斑狼疮SLE患者血清中纯化出抗-ds DNA抗体和抗-ss DNA抗体。酶联免疫吸附分析(ELISA)的研究表明:SLE抗-DNA抗体和DNA结合的差异性很大,是高度非均一性的。抗-ss DNA抗体不仅组成成分比抗-ds DNA抗体复杂,ss DNA/抗-ssDNA亲合能力也明显高于ds DNA/抗-ds DNA。纯化的抗-DNA抗体以IgG类抗体占主导,同时也有其它类型抗体存在(例如IgM等)。抗-ds DNA抗体有较抗-ss DNA抗体高的IgG含量(两者的IgG/IgM分别是7.0和4.0),说明IgG抗-DNA抗体更倾向于同dsDNA结合。     

Characterization of warm-reactive IgG anti-lymphocyte antibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus. Relative specificity for mitogen-activated T cells and their soluble products

In addition to previously described cold-reactive IgM anti-lymphocyte antibodies maximally cytotoxic for resting cells at 15 degrees C, sera from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) were found to contain a new type of antibody preferentially reactive at physiologic temperatures with mitogen-activated lymphocytes. This antibody lacked specificity for unstimulated lymphocytes, and was shown to be of the IgG class both by indirect immunofluorescence and in immunochemical experiments. Certain SLE sera also contained IgG antibodies with the capacity to develop plaques with mitogen-activated T lymphocyte preparations used in a reverse hemolytic plaque assay, indicating reactivity with products released by activated cells. The elimination of the ability of SLE sera to develop plaques after absorption with viable mitogen-stimulated lymphocytes, but not with resting cells, suggested that these antibodies were directed toward activation "neoantigen(s)" shed from the cell surface membrane. Surface membrane phenotype analyses performed by using a variety of monoclonal antibody reagents indicated that the plaque-forming cells (PFC) detected with SLE sera were activated T lymphocytes not restricted to single OKT4+, OKT8+, or Ia antigen+ subpopulations. Essentially all PFC expressed transferrin receptors. The present data raise the possibility that certain of the interesting effects of anti-lymphocyte antibodies on immunologic function in SLE may be mediated by interactions of these new type(s) of antibodies with activated lymphocytes or their products, rather than through blocking or depletion effects on resting precursor cells.     

Role of T cells in regulating expression of the B cell repertoire. Anti-ssDNA precursor frequency of DBA/2 B cells is increased in the presence of T cells from NZB mice

Splenic B cells from DBA/2 and NZB mice were compared with regard to precursor frequency of anti-ssDNA-producing cells. Using a modification of the splenic fragment assay, we show that NZB T cells are capable of increasing the frequency of expression of anti-ssDNA precursors in DBA/2 splenic B cells. When limiting numbers of splenic B cells of DBA/2 origin were adoptively transferred into an irradiated (1200 rad) recipient, the co-transfer of NZB T cells markedly increased the frequency of anti-ssDNA precursors in cultured splenic fragments. The anti-ssDNA produced under these conditions was exclusively IgM and exhibited a high degree of cross-reactivity with TNP and fluorescein. Thus, the increase in anti-ssDNA precursor frequency reflected an expansion of the B cell repertoire to include precursors of polyspecific antibody-producing cells that under normal circumstances are not expressed. The ability of NZB T cells to increase the anti-ssDNA precursor frequency was further defined by the CBA/N immunodeficiency gene xid, in that B cells from DBA/2.xid donors did not exhibit increased anti-ssDNA precursor frequency in the presence of NZB T cells. When NZB splenic B cells were co-transferred with DBA/2 T cells, the anti-DNA precursor frequency of the NZB B cells was not reduced. This study demonstrates that T cells can influence the emergency of B cell clones in an Ag-nonspecific manner. The well documented in vivo spontaneous polyclonal activation of NZB B cells may be secondary to T cell-mediated expansion of the B cell repertoire.     

In vitro manipulation of human anti-DNA antibody production by anti-idiotypic antibodies conjugated with neocarzinostatin

Anti-DNA Id, 0-81, consist of 5 to 51% of Id in human anti-ssDNA antibodies; NE-1-Id shares 2 to 20% of those in anti-dsDNA antibodies. Thus, both 0-81-Id and NE-1-Id are of the cross-reactive Id that are commonly present among anti-DNA antibodies. In order to manipulate the production of anti-DNA antibodies by human PBL, we used mouse antiidiotypic mAb or those conjugated with a cytotoxic agent, neocarzinostatin. Treatment with the conjugates caused profound suppression of anti-ssDNA and anti-dsDNA antibody synthesis related to 0-81- and NE-1-Id. This was attributed to the specific killing of the clones bearing anti-DNA Id among the lymphocytes, evidenced by the indirect rosette formation tests. The Id-mediated suppression was not solely due to selective elimination of Id-positive B cells, because 50 to 92% of anti-DNA antibodies were suppressed by treatment with the conjugates. This was supported by flow cytometry analysis that showed a decrease of anti-Id-reactive cells when T cells were treated with the conjugates. This method, then, will permit an analysis of the question as to whether T cells reactive to anti-idiotypic antibodies might participate in the regulatory mechanism for anti-DNA production and, in addition, may lead to a new therapy for SLE.     

Regulation of an in vitro anti-DNA antibody response by thymocytes and T cells from NZB/W and normal mice

The spontaneous in vitro anti-DNA antibody response generated by preautoimmune and many normal mouse spleen cells was suppressed by the addition of syngeneic thymocytes or splenic T cells. Suppressive activity was found in normal mice (DBA/2J) and to an equivalent degree in the autoimmune (New Zealand Black X New Zealand White)F1 (B/W) strain. The suppressor cells were cortisone-resistant, radiosensitive and carried Lyt 1 and Lyt 2 markers. Nonspecific suppression was not involved since the primary and primed in vitro anti-sheep erythrocyte (anti-SRBC) responses were unaffected. Both spontaneous and lipopolysaccharide-stimulated anti-DNA antibody responses could be suppressed. There was no difference in the suppressive activity of cells from young or old, normal or autoimmune mice. These T cells may therefore play a role in preventing the anti-DNA antibody response in normal and young B/W mice, but evidently fail to influence the development of in vivo anti-DNA autoimmune responses in the old B/W mice.     

The relationship between circulating CD5+ B lymphocytes and in vitro autoantibody synthesis in normal individuals.

Recent observations suggest that a subpopulation of B lymphocytes bearing the phenotype CD5+ may be enriched for cells committed to the synthesis and secretion of autoantibodies. We had previously shown that a subset of normal individuals has an expanded subpopulation of B lymphocytes committed to the synthesis of IgM and IgM-rheumatoid factor (RF), and that this condition was associated with HLA-DR4 (4). In these studies, we performed simultaneous quantitation of the size of the circulating CD5+ B lymphocyte subpopulation in a group of 20 normal donors, and of the pokeweed mitogen-induced in vitro synthesis of a panel of autoantibodies by the same peripheral blood cells depleted of CD8+ suppressor lymphocytes in 18 of the 20 individuals. The culture supernatants were assayed for total IgM and IgG, RF, IgM, and IgG anti-single-stranded DNA, anti-human thyroglobulin, and anti-tetanus toxoid. The mean percentage CD5+ B cells was 13.5 +/- 2.5%. There was no significant correlation between total B lymphocytes and CD5+ B cells (R = 0.25, P greater than 0.20. Positive correlations were found between the proportion of circulating CD5+ B lymphocytes and synthesis of RF (R = 0.73, P less than 0.001), and IgM anti-DNA (R = 0.58, P less than 0.03). Significant correlations were not found between CD5+ B cells and secreted IgM or IgG antibodies against the exogenous antigen tetanus toxoid, measured in the same supernatants. The antibodies produced in vitro by T cell-dependent B cell activation appear to have limited or no polyspecificity. These results indicate that the size of the circulating CD5+ B cell subpopulation in any given individual contributes importantly to the magnitude of autoantibody synthesis in cultures where T cell-mediated B lymphocyte activation takes place in the absence of suppressor signals.     

Pregnancy-associated growth factor. II. A T-dependent polyclonal activator of human adult peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL)

This study examined the ability of pregnancy-associated growth factor (PAGF), a substance found in crude human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), to induce plaque-forming cells (PFC) in cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). PAGF, 0.25 to 1 mg/ml, induced maximal PFC at 6 to 7 days as measured by the staphylococcal protein A-coupled SRBC reverse hemolytic plaque assay with a rabbit anti-human Ig antiserum. PAGF-induced PFC/culture ranged from 1800 to 39,000 with a mean of 11,524 in unfractionated PBL (N = 24), as compared to 540 to 77,840 with a mean of 17,303 for pokeweed (PWM) (N = 22). Comparison of PAGF- and PWM-induced PFC showed that both induced specific IgG, IgA, and IgM PFC. In most individuals, PAGF induced more IgM and PWM more IgG PFC. The kappa: lambda ratio was 1.5 for unstimulated PBL, and approximately 3.5 for PAGF and PWM. To see if PAGF was a T-dependent polyclonal activator of B cells, T and non-T populations were obtained by SRBC rosettes and negatively selected T4 and T8 cells by complement-mediated lysis of SRBC+(T) cells. Only the recombined subsets which included T4 cells and non-T cells supported PAGF- and PWM-induced PFC. These data indicate that PAGF, a substance derived from commercial extracts of pregnancy urine, is a T4-dependent polyclonal activator of normal human B cells.     

Isotypes of spontaneous and mitogen-induced autoantibodies in SLE-prone mice

A common cellular abnormality of all murine strains prone to systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an increased spontaneous polyclonal expansion of B cells. Our findings support the existence of this SLE-associated abnormality because the numbers of B lymphocytes secreting all the different IgG subclasses and IgM in spleens of all lupus-prone mice are elevated, compared to levels of normal splenic immunoglobulin-producing cells. We also report that 1) spontaneous polyclonal stimulation of immunoglobulin in autoimmune mice is preferential for subclass, and that the preferentially stimulated isotypes in each SLE strain consistently dominate both circulating and kidney-deposited immune complexes; 2) distinct patterns of isotype preference exist among the autoimmune strains determined by inherent B cell proliferative abnormalities or by B cell proliferation affected by thymus-derived lymphocytes; and 3) chronic administration of the TI B cell mitogen Lipid A in late-life SLE-prone mice induces an early-life glomerulonephritis with auto-antibodies of an isotype composition characteristic of those spontaneously produced by inherently abnormal B cells of early-life lupus mice.     

Factors determining the effects of chronic protein-deficiency on antibody responses to sheep red blood cells and Brucella abortus vaccine in mice.

Chronic protein-deficiency in weanling mice caused variable suppression of the humoral plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses to sheep erythrocytes. This was most prominent at high antigen doses and did not increase when mice were maintained on the diets for longer periods. Antibody responses produced by deficient mice were often short-lived and involved high levels of IgM. Total PFC counts were depressed slightly more than were circulating antibodies. Antibody responses to Brucella abortus were slightly decreased by protein-deficiency at high antigen doses but were normal or elevated at lower doses, the proportion of IgM produced was increased and the splenomegaly response to B. abortus was severely depressed. These results suggest that the depression of antibody production by protein-deficiency is not simply due to an impairment of helper T cell function, but a reduction in the availability or effectiveness of macrophage and regulatory or suppressor T cells may be important.     

Mechanisms of T and B cell collaboration in the in vitro production of anti-DNA antibodies in the NZB/NZW F1 murine SLE model

B/W mice spontaneously develop IgG antibodies to DNA that cause lethal immune nephritis. T and B cell interactions in the in vitro anti-DNA antibody response of B/W mice were investigated, and two distinct families of helper T cells that drive these responses were defined. First, the anti-DNA antibody-forming cell (AFC) response was found to be increased in B/W mice with nephritis and was inhibited with the monoclonal antibody anti-L3T4, suggesting a major role for helper T cells. Purified splenic T cells from mice with nephritis were able to augment both the IgG and the IgM anti-DNA AFC response of young B/W B cells. T helper cells were cloned from spleens of NZB/W F female mice with high titer anti-DNA antibodies and nephritis. The cloned T cells augmented both IgG and IgM anti-DNA AFC responses of young B/W B cells. Four clones--27.9, 30.7, 30.8, and 30.10--were selected for further study. These cells proliferated, in the context of syngeneic (H2d/z) antigen-presenting cells (APC) but not to allogeneic APC. Analysis of the mechanism of T helper cell clone-mediated augmentation of anti-DNA AFC revealed two populations: "cognate" T helper cells, which specifically augment anti-DNA AFC (30.7 and 30.10), and non-antigen-specific T helper cells (27.9 and 30.8), which augment the response of B cells of differing specificity by a bystander mechanism, probably through increased release of B cell growth and differentiation factors.     

Specificity analysis of human anti-DNA antibodies

Human hybrids producing anti-DNA antibodies were generated by the fusion of pokeweed mitogen-stimulated splenic lymphocytes from a child with sickle cell anemia to GM4672. Of 19 hybrids, three (15%) produced anti-DNA antibody as detected by an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay. One subclone from each of these three hybrids was then characterized. All produced IgM antibody in large amounts ranging from 22 to 266 micrograms/ml per million cells per 24 hr. All three antibodies bound both double- and single-stranded DNA. Competitive inhibition assays revealed the greatest inhibition of DNA binding with the ribohomopolymers polyinosinic and polyguanylic acid. A complex pattern of cross-reactivity with various other polynucleotides and with some phospholipids was observed. Subtle differences were found among the three antibodies in light chain class and some of the binding specificities. By using a modified Farr assay, all three monoclonals were found to be of low to intermediate affinity. These results confirm that anti-DNA antibodies apparently equivalent to those seen in patients with SLE can be derived from "normal" nonautoimmune individuals.     

High-affinity antibodies to ssDNA are produced by CD-B cells in systemic lupus erythematosus patients

It was previously shown that human CD5+B cells are committed to the production of polyreactive "autoantibodies" that bind different self-Ag, including ssDNA, IgG Fc fragment, thyroglobulin, and insulin, as well as exogenous Ag, e.g., tetanus toxoid and other bacterial components. To define the contribution of the CD5+B cell subset to the production of antibodies to ssDNA in SLE, we quantitated, purified, and functionally characterized circulating CD5+ and CD5-B cells in patients and in healthy subjects. We found that in SLE patients circulating CD5+B cells were not increased in number, and both CD5+ and C5-B cells spontaneously secreted antibodies to ssDNA. Studies of the mAb we generated using CD5+ and CD5-B cells revealed that two types of antibody to ssDNA are produced in SLE. The first type, of the IgM class, is produced mainly by CD5+B cells and displays a moderate affinity for ssDNA (Kd, 10(-6) to 10(-7) mol/liter) and is polyreactive, not dissimilar to the autoantibodies inducible in the normal human B cell repertoire by polyclonal activation. The second type, mostly of the IgG and IgA class, is produced mainly by CD5-B cells and displays a higher affinity (Kd, 10(-8) mol/liter) for and reacts only with ssDNA. The functional features of the high affinity anti-ssDNA antibodies and the phenotype of their producing B cells mimic those characteristic of a "mature" Ag-driven response, such as that to tetanus toxoid in tetanus toxoid-vaccinated subjects.     

Anti-immunoglobulin autoantibodies are not preferentially induced in polyclonal activation of human and mouse lymphocytes, and more anti-DNA and anti-erythrocyte autoantibodies are induced in polyclonal activation of mouse than human lymphocytes

Using a plaque assay with immunoglobulin (Ig)-coated SRBC, we and others have previously reported that the majority of polyclonally activated mouse lymphocytes secreted antibodies that appeared to be IgM anti-IgG autoantibodies. Careful reexamination of this assay, with application of several highly purified mouse serum and myeloma IgG and IgM preparations, revealed that IgM, which was a minor contaminant of Ig preparations, rather than IgG, was responsible for the formation of these plaques. High numbers of plaques could also be detected in assays with polyclonally activated human lymphocytes, Ig-coated SRBC, and anti-Ig developing sera. Of all IgG-, IgM- or IgA-secreting cells, 40 to 100% were detected with SRBC coated with gamma-globulin or Ig of the same isotype as the isotype to which the developing serum was specific; in general, low proportions of all PFC were detected with SRBC coated with Ig of a different isotype. Studies on the sequence of events leading to the formation of plaques with Ig-sensitized SRBC (both in humans and mice) revealed that antibodies detected in these assays were not able to bind to the Ig-coated SRBC (without the presence of developing serum), and therefore were not anti-Ig autoantibodies. It is our conclusion that the plaque assays with Ig-coated SRBC represent another type of a reverse hemolytic PFC assay that detects cells secreting antibodies regardless of their specificity, and these plaques are formed due to the cross-linking by the anti-Ig developing serum of the Ig coated on SRBC and the Ig secreted by lymphocytes. Our results confirmed preferential induction of anti-DNA antibody secreting cells in mice by showing that these antibodies indeed bind to DNA coated on SRBC. In cultures of polyclonally activated human lymphocytes, anti-DNA and anti-erythrocyte autoantibody-secreting cells were over 10 to 100 times less frequent than in mice. These results, therefore, disprove the concept of preferential induction of anti-Ig autoantibodies in the polyclonal activation of mouse and human lymphocytes, and show that anti-DNA and anti-erythrocyte autoantibodies are easily induced in the polyclonal activation of mouse, but not human, lymphocytes.     

Class-specific regulation of anti-DNA antibody synthesis and the age-associated changes in (NZB x NZW)F1 hybrid mice

Investigations of regulatory helper and suppressor T cells in the in vitro anti-DNA antibody synthesis in NZB x NZW (B/W) F1 hybrid mice were initiated by the development of an in vitro system in which G10-passed B cells from B/W F1 mice were cocultured with mitomycin C-treated T cells in the presence of Con A and either in the presence or in the absence of LPS. It was revealed that each IgG and IgM anti-DNA antibody synthesis was under the regulation of separate L3T4+ helper and Ly-2+ suppressor T cells. The function of these class-specific regulatory T cells was age-dependent. Although the helper effect of L3T4+ T cells on IgG antibody synthesis increased, the effect of L3T4+ T cells on IgM antibody production decreased in B/W F1 mice with aging. The IgG anti-DNA antibody production in the cocultures of L3T4+ T cells and B cells was suppressed by addition of Ly-2+ T cells from young but not aged B/W F1 mice, whereas the production of IgM anti-DNA antibodies was suppressed by Ly-2+ T cells from aged but not young B/W F1 mice. We also found that although IgM anti-DNA antibody-producing B cells were already present in 2-mo-old mice, B cells producing IgG antibodies under the influence of L3T4+ T cells appeared in mice at 7 mo of age. These data clearly indicate that separate class-specific regulatory T cells are involved in the production of IgM and IgG anti-DNA antibodies and that the total serum level of the antibodies is reflected by both their age-associated changes and the generation of antibody-forming B cells in B/W F1 mice.     

Epstein-Barr virus induces normal B cell responses but defective suppressor T cell responses in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) is a polyclonal B cell activator, independent of helper T cells, which induces the generation of suppressor T cells in vivo and in vitro. Given the complexity of the immunologic abnormalities in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), we used EBV as a tool to examine the following questions: a). Are SLE B cells primarily defective? and b). Does EBV stimulate the generation of suppressor activity from SLE T cells? It was found that B cells from SLE patients infected with EBV in vitro generate plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses that are similar to those raised by normal B cells infected with EBV within the first 14 days of culture. T cells from SLE patients, in contrast to T cells from normal individuals, cultured with autologous B cells plus EBV fail to develop the expected normal decrement of PFC during the late phase of the in vitro culture (day 14). However, B cells from SLE patients are susceptible to suppression as mixed cultures of SLE B cells and normal allogeneic T cells showed a pattern of PFC response to EBV similar to that of the co-culture of normal B cells with normal T cells. T cells from SLE patients, in analogous mixed cell cultures, failed to suppress either normal B cells or allogeneic SLE B cells. The above experiments indicate that the B cells are not intrinsically defective in SLE patients; rather, a specific T cell abnormality contributes to the lack of normal immunoregulation of certain B cell responses in SLE.     

The regulatory role of NZB T lymphocytes in the production of anti-DNA antibodies in vitro

Murine lupus is characterized by the production of numerous autoantibodies and immune complex glomerulonephritis. Anti-DNA antibodies are the hallmark of this disorder and may be associated pathogenetically with the glomerulonephritis. The cellular mechanisms underlying the regulation of the production of anti-DNA antibodies may prove to be the fundamental abnormalities responsible for the lupus syndrome seen in these mice. By using a system of spontaneous anti-DNA antibody production in vitro, we have determined that such production is characteristic of autoimmune NZB and MRL-lpr/lpr mice but not of the nonautoimmune control strains. Additional examination of the cellular mechanisms involved in the regulation of this response in NZB mice revealed: 1) this response is markedly T cell dependent, 2) NZB T cells are essential for maximal production of this autoantibody, and 3) NZB T cells actively interfere with normal immune regulatory mechanisms that lead to the production of anti-DNA antibodies spontaneously in vitro by nonautoimmune syngeneic B lymphocytes. Although these studies of anti-DNA antibody production in vitro disagree with previous work by others they successfully reproduce the results obtained earlier in experiments performed in vivo.     

Reactivity of autoantibodies and DNA/anti-DNA complexes with a novel 110-kilodalton phosphoprotein in systemic lupus erythematosus and other diseases.

Utilizing nonionic detergent lysates of human lymphoid and non-lymphoid cells as substrate, IgM and/or IgG antibodies to a 110-kDa/isoelectric point 5.4 phosphoprotein (110K) was demonstrated in serum from patients with SLE or certain other systemic autoimmune disorders by immunoblotting and immunoprecipitation. Ig of this specificity was not demonstrable in serum from normal individuals, but, in a limited survey, was detected in serum from patients with acute hepatitis A or infectious mononucleosis. 110K shares a number of properties with nucleolin, i.e., identical Mr and isoelectric point, localization in both the nucleus and the cytosol, increased expression in rapidly dividing cells, and shown to be distinct from already defined autoantigens of similar size, i.e., topoisomerase I, PM-Scl, and RNA polymerase I. Because 110K could bind denatured DNA, as demonstrated by its specific absorption by DNA-cellulose and by its reactivity with monoclonal anti-ssDNA antibody in the presence of denatured DNA, special efforts were made to distinguish reactivity of pre-formed DNA/anti-DNA complexes in SLE serum from that due to specific anti-110K autoantibodies. Although binding to 110K could be mediated by DNA and anti-DNA in some SLE sera, the accumulated evidence supports the existence of a major new autoantibody system in SLE, other autoimmune diseases, and certain virus infections.     

Expression of idiotype on the surface of human B cells producing anti-DNA antibody

We analyzed the idiotype (Id) expression on the surface of human anti-DNA antibody-producing cells. Murine monoclonal anti-Id antibodies with a specificity for determinants associated with the antigen-binding sites of human monoclonal anti-DNA autoantibodies were prepared. One anti-Id antibody reacted only with surface Id on anti-ssDNA-producing cells, but not with those on anti-dsDNA-producing B cell clones. Another anti-Id antibody did bind the surface Id on anti-dsDNA clones, but not those on anti-ssDNA clones. The interaction between anti-Id and surface Id was inhibited by pretreatment of the clones with DNA or appropriate polynucleotide antigens, or by preabsorption of anti-Id antibodies with free anti-DNA antibodies. Surface IgM and IgD expressed the same Id as the antibody secreted from the clones. The treatment of Id-positive clones by anti-Id antibody induced the redistribution of surface Id on the cells, indicating that these cells serve as targets for the regulatory action of anti-Id antibody.     

Differential regulation of activation, clonal expansion, and antibody secretion in human B cells

Limiting dilution analysis, hemolytic plaque assay, and ELISA procedures were used to study the recruitment, clonal expansion, and antibody secretion in human TNP-specific B cells activated in the presence of TNP-ovalbumin (TNP-OA), pokeweed mitogen (PWM), or regulatory T cells. TNP-OA-responsive, hapten-specific PFC precursor cells occupy approximately 0.5% of all sIgM+/sIgD+ B cells in cord blood, bone marrow, peripheral blood, and tonsil. The PWM-responsive, hapten-specific PFC precursor pool is 70 to 90% smaller and does not express sIgD. Antigen-reactive B cells go through a minimum of three divisions in culture (six to nine PFC per clone), and antibody secretory rates of about 10(4) molecules IgM/cell/hr are achieved. In contrast, PWM-induced clone sizes were at least 60 PFC per clone, with antibody secretory rates of approximately 6 to 7 X 10(4) molecules IgM/cell/hr. Addition of high-dose carrier-primed suppressor T cells to limit dilution cultures reduced PFC precursor cell recruitment by up to 99%. However, in the few clones escaping from suppression, both clonal expansion and antibody secretory rates were much higher than in suppressor cell-free cultures, generating 30 to 60% of the antibody secreted in controls but with consequently much more restricted clonal diversity. When limiting dilution cultures were compared with standard microcultures of 2 X 10(5) cells, both clonal expansion and antibody secretory rates were much lower than expected, with a culture efficiency calculated to be 10 to 20% of that in low-density cultures. Our data suggest that the B cell subsets activated by antigen and by mitogen differ in their abilities for clonal expansion and antibody secretion. The hapten-specific and -responsive B cell family is expressed early in ontogeny, and in adults it is distributed evenly throughout the body. These limiting dilution experiments revealed that the primary effect of regulatory T cells is a drastic reduction in clonal diversity, and much less a mere reduction in overall response magnitude.     

Generation of human plaque-forming cells in culture: tissue distribution, antigenic and cellular requirements.

A system for the induction of specific, hemolytic plaque-forming cells from normal human lymphocytes in vitro (HcPFC) has been established and cells from various normal lymphoid tissues have been investigated. Normal values for anti-SRBC HcPFC responses in cultures of 107 Ficoll-Hypaque separated lymphocytes range from 2000 (bone marrow) to 7000 (spleen) and 15,000 (tonsillar and peripheral blood lymphocytes). HcPFC responses to ovalbumin were lower by factor of 2 to 4. Anti-SRBC as well as anti-ovalbumin responses required the cooperation of T lymphocytes and IgM-bearing B lymphocytes and the magnitude of the response was antigen dose dependent. Addition of adherent cells as well as of 2-mercaptoethanol enhanced the response. On the basis of the data obtained in experiments examining the role of B and T lymphocytes, a tentative model of cellular interaction has been postulated, suggesting a major role for antigen concentration in the modulation of the response via reactive T lymphocytes.