Flow cytometric analysis of DNA aneuploidy in primary and metastatic human solid tumors

DNA histograms were measured by flow cytometry for 656 human solid tumors (365 primary and 291 metastatic). The proportion of aneuploid cells in cell suspensions obtained by mechanical disaggregation was significantly higher than those obtained after enzymatic disaggregation (collagenase + DNAse) of the same tumor. A strong correlation was observed between the values of DNA-indices measured after staining with propidium iodide and with 4',-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (r = 0.97). Aneuploid cells were observed in 430 tumors (66%); 30 of these had two aneuploid stemlines, and two had three aneuploid stemlines. The overall frequency of aneuploidy was 61% among primary and 71% among metastatic tumors. The median value of the DNA index was 1.67 for 224 primary aneuploid tumors and 1.68 for 206 metastatic aneuploid tumors. For most diseases, the largest proportion of aneuploid primary and metastatic tumors had DNA-indices in the hypertriploid region. No major differences in frequency and degree of aneuploidy was observed between primary and metastatic tumors. For carcinomas of the bladder and prostate, frequency of aneuploidy was higher among poorly differentiated, than among moderately and well-differentiated tumors. For carcinomas of the breast and for sarcomas, tumors with DNA-indices of greater than 2.0 were observed mostly in the poorly differentiated group. For patients with carcinomas of the bladder and prostate most tumors at earlier stages of disease were diploid; whereas most tumors at later stages of disease were aneuploid. For patients with carcinomas of the ovary, colon, and kidney, no relationship between stage of disease and aneuploidy was evident.     

Heterogeneity of DNA ploidy in gastric cancer.

Heterogeneity of DNA content was analyzed in 389 samples from 65 resected gastric cancers. Analysis of the samples revealed that there were 14 homogeneously diploid tumours. Six tumours were uniformly DNA aneuploid, each tissue block containing the same DNA index. The other 45 tumours (69%) varied in DNA content heterogeneity. In 39 of 45 tumours, there was a mixture of diploid and aneuploid samples, and 25 of the 39 tumours had a single aneuploid stemline. In 14 out of 39 tumours, there was also a mixture of diploid and aneuploid samples having two or more DNA aneuploid stemlines. In the remaining six tumours, different DNA aneuploid stemlines were contained in different samples without evidence of diploidy. When four or fewer samples were analyzed, only 50% of the tumours were diagnosed as having DNA content heterogeneity. On the other hand, 78% of the tumours showed DNA heterogeneity when 5 or more samples were analyzed. If the tumours had not been widely sampled, about a quarter of the tumours would have been mislabeled as diploid. The patients with tumours showing homogeneous diploidy survived longer than those with tumours showing a mixture of diploid and aneuploid stemlines. The survival rate was lowest for the patients with tumours having a mixture of diploid and multiple aneuploid stemlines, compared with those showing homogeneous diploid or a mixture of diploid and single aneuploid stemlines. The data from the current study clearly demonstrate the importance of adequate sampling in assessing the ploidy status of gastric cancers to identify groups of patients running different clinical course and prognosis.     

DNA distribution in non-small-cell lung carcinomas and its relationship to clinical behavior

A study of 187 surgical specimens of tumors of patients with non-small-cell lung carcinomas was carried out by means of flow cytometry. Eighty-four percent of the tumors were classified as tumors with abnormal DNA stemlines (DNA aneuploidy). Patients with tumors demonstrating DNA aneuploidy had significantly shorter survival times than those with tumors demonstrating DNA diploidy (p = .009). Cell cycle analysis was possible in 122 tumors. Patients whose tumors had 0-8% S-phase cells died later than patients whose tumors had 9-16% S-phase cells (p = .018). In addition, patients with tumors with a low fraction of labeled S-phase cells (autoradiography) had a better prognosis than patients with tumors with a high proportion of labeled S-phase cells (p = .041).     

Comparison of the intratumor DNA ploidy distribution pattern between differentiated and undifferentiated gastric carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To compare the differences in intratumor DNA ploidy distribution pattern between differentiated and undifferentiated carcinoma of the stomach. STUDY DESIGN: Two hundred five cases of surgically resected gastric carcinoma were studied, comprising 125 differentiated and 80 undifferentiated carcinomas. DNA ploidy was determined by means of flow cytometry in stepwise sections of the entire tumor. The intratumor DNA ploidy distribution pattern was compared between these two histologic types. RESULTS: Differentiated carcinomas comprised 35 cases of predominantly diploid (28%) and 90 cases of predominantly aneuploid (72%) tumors, while undifferentiated carcinomas comprised 46 cases of predominantly diploid (57.5%) and 34 cases of predominantly aneuploid (42.5%) (P < .01). The frequency of cases showing predominantly aneuploidy among the differentiated carcinomas was significantly higher than among the undifferentiated carcinomas at stages IA and IIIA. The rate of cases showing heterogeneity was lower among the early-stage cases than among the advanced-stage cases in both histologic types. Among the differentiated carcinomas, there were 22 cases that had more than six DNA stemlines in each tumor, whereas among undifferentiated carcinomas, there were six such cases (P < .05). CONCLUSION: There were more cases with high malignant potential among the differentiated carcinoma cases than among the undifferentiated carcinoma cases in the present series.     

Flow cytometric analysis of DNA stemline heterogeneity in primary and metastatic breast cancer.

Flow cytometric DNA-ploidy analysis was used to investigate intratumor DNA stemline heterogeneity in primary breast carcinomas and lymph node metastases (LNM). The study was done in tumor specimens from 44 patients 35 of whom had LNM. In all, measurements were done in 214 different samples of primary tumors and 211 lymph nodes. Sixty-one percent (27/44) of the primary tumors were found to have multiple DNA aneuploid stemlines when the data of the separate samples per tumor (mean 4.9) were compared. Only five of 44 (11%) primary tumors were DNA diploid; two of these had DNA aneuploid metastases. Statistical analysis of these results indicated that, on average, four samples are needed for reliable determination of the DNA ploidy status of primary tumors by flow cytometry. In the majority of the cases (26/35), distinct tumor DNA stemlines found in LNM were also present in the primary tumor, which suggests that the generation of DNA ploidy diversity may have taken place prior to metastasis. Multiploidy was not related to tumor size but, particularly for LNM, was significantly correlated with age (r = 0.40, P = 0.02). The results of this study support the view that breast cancer is an extremely heterogeneous disease and that underestimation of this factor might account for the disagreement in literature about the prognostic value of DNA ploidy determinations.     

Analysis of the physical state of different human papillomavirus DNAs in intraepithelial and invasive cervical neoplasm.

The integration of human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA into the human genome has been generally accepted as a characteristic of malignant lesions. To gain a better understanding of this phenomenon, genomic DNA from 181 cervical biopsy specimens was isolated and analyzed for HPV type and physical state of the HPV genome. These specimens represented the full spectrum of cervical disease, from condyloma to invasive carcinoma. Discrimination between integrated and episomal HPV DNA was accomplished by the detection of HPV-human DNA junction fragments on Southern blots. In most cases in which ambiguous Southern blot results were obtained, the specimens were reanalyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Of the 100 biopsy specimens of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia analyzed, only 3 showed integrated HPV DNA, in contrast to 56 (81%) of 69 cervical carcinomas (P less than 0.001) showing integrated HPV DNA. Of the 40 carcinomas containing HPV 16 DNA, 29 (72%) had integrated HPV DNA, of which 8 (20%) also had episomal HPV DNA. In 11 (27%) cancers, only episomal HPV 16 DNA was detected. All 23 HPV 18-containing carcinomas had integrated HPV DNA, and 1 also had episomal HPV 18 DNA. The difference between HPV types 16 and 18 with respect to frequency of integration was statistically significant (P less than 0.01). The results of this study indicate that detectable integration of HPV DNA, regardless of type, occurs infrequently in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. The absence of HPV 16 DNA integration in some carcinomas implies that integration is not always required for malignant progression. In contrast, the consistent integration of HPV 18 DNA in all cervical cancers examined may be related to its greater transforming efficiency in vitro and its reported clinical association with more aggressive cervical cancers.     

DNA ploidy in soft tissue sarcoma: comparison of flow and image cytometry with clinical follow-up in 93 patients

In soft tissue sarcoma, the prognostic importance of DNA ploidy status is limited. One possible explanation may be technical; small non-diploid stemlines will be diluted in relation to the presence of normal diploid cells and may not be detected by flow cytometry (FCM). We assessed DNA ploidy status in 93 tumors with both FCM and image cytometry (ICM). ICM may permit the exclusion of non-relevant cells. The ability of the two methods to detect non-diploid stemlines was compared, as were the prognostic consequences. The patients (54 males) had a median age of 69 years. Surgical procedures were performed on all patients. None of the patients had received preoperative radiotherapy or chemotherapy. FCM and ICM were performed with standard methods. The prognostic value was assessed with univariate and multivariate analysis. In 82 of the 93 tumors, a concordant ploidy status by FCM and ICM was found. In 5 FCM type 1-2 tumors (diploid), the identification of non-diploid stemlines by ICM did not influence the metastatic rates. Increasing tumor size, histotype other than liposarcoma, increasing malignancy grade, tumor necrosis, and ICM non-diploidy were univariate prognostic factors for metastasis. In a multivariate analysis, only tumor size larger than 9 cm was a prognostic factor. In about 10% of the tumors, a discrepancy between FCM and ICM ploidy status was found, but we could not find a consistent prognostic consequence of this. Neither FCM nor ICM ploidy status was an independent prognostic factor.     

Dry mass, DNA and non-histone protein determinations in lung cancer cells

Summary Cell nuclei from two biopsies of bronchial mucosa, seven squamous-cell carcinomas and six small-cell carcinomas of the lung were investigated. DNA and non-histone protein (NHP) content were simultaneously determined in Feulgen—Naphthol Yellow S-stained smears by means of multiple plug cytophotometry. In addition, the nuclear dry mass of cells originating from the same populations was measured by interference microscopy.DNA histograms of carcinomas were characterized by DNA stemlines being situated in the diploid range in four out of six small-cell carcinomas and in the hyperdiploid to hypertetraploid range in six out of seven squamous-cell carcinomas.Polyploid values (up to 8 c) were seldom found in small-cell carcinomas whereas squamous-cell carcinomas showed a broader dispersion approaching the 16 c level.The similarity of the NHP distributions with the DNA histograms was more marked in small-cell carcinomas than in the squamous-cell carcinomas. In comparison with the NHP distributions of normal bronchial epithelial cells, those of carcinomas were shifted to higher values. The increased NHP content was found to be a more prominent sign of malignancy in small-cell carcinomas than the DNA mass. The increase in nuclear dry mass in carcinomas was mainly caused by the accumulation of NHP in tumour cell nuclei.     

Cytophotomeric DNA-analysis of aspirated cells from prostatic carcinoma.

In the present study material obtained from prostatic lesions by transrectal aspiration biopsy was subjected to a comparative morphologic and cytophotometric DNA analysis. Based on the morphologic pattern, the clinical material was divided into benign lesions (prostatic hyperplasia), suspected prostatic malignancy and highly, moderately and poorly differentiated prostatic carcinoma. The cytochemical analysis, based on quantitative cytophotometric measurements of Feulgen stained nuclei, showed that cell nuclei from benign lesions (prostatic hyperplasia) exhibited the normal diploid amount of DNA. Contrary to this, cell populations from prostatic malignancies, were characterized by various degrees of heteroploidy, i.e. the existence of cells with nuclear DNA quantities increased above the normal diploid level. A general correlation between degree of heteroploidy (frequency of heteroploid cells) and degree of clinical malignancy seemed to exist; high grade malignant prostatic carcinoma (poorly differentiated) exhibited a pronounced degree of heteroploidy with more or less distinct aneuploid stemlines, whereas low-grade prostatic carcinomas (highly differentiated) were more similar to benign cell populations, in showing a large proportion of cells with a diploid DNA quantity suggesting the existence of diploid or near diploid stemlines. Cases morphologically classified as moderately differentiated prostatic carcinoma, which previously have been shown to exhibit individual variations in degree of clinical malignancy, also showed large individual variations in degree of hetyroploidy. Approximately half of these cases had cytochemical DNA characteristics similar to that of highly differentiated prostatic carcinoma in showing a modal DNA value in the diploid region, while the other half showed cytochemical characteristics similar to that of poorly differentiated prostatic carcinoma, i.e. aneuploid DNA distributions. However, no morphologiifferentiated prostatic carcinoma. In conclusion it can be stated that the present investigation suggests the possibility that quantitative cytochemical DNA analysis may be used in combination with, and offer additional information to, morphologic analysis in the malignancy grading of prostatic carcinoma. A future clinical follow-up, now in progress, will hopefully give a more definite answer to that idea.     

Predictive value of DNA cytometry in CIN 1 and 2. Image analysis of 193 cases

OBJECTIVE: To investigate DNA image cytometry for predicting the prognosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). STUDY DESIGN: Smears from 151 women affected by CIN 1 or 2 on cytology with minimal follow-up of three years were included. Sixty-seven showed progression, with histologically confirmed carcinoma in situ or invasive cancer. Eighty-four cases showed regression of the disease, which was cytologically, histologically and colposcopically confirmed. Papanicolaou-stained smears were destained, and the Feulgen reaction was performed with consecutive image DNA cytometry of suspicious cells using an image analysis system (Cires, Zeiss, Germany). The DNA index of the greatest stemline and the number of single aneuploid cells, using 9c exceeding events, were computed. RESULTS: In the group with progression, an aneuploid DNA stemline was found in 25 smears (26.9%). In 64 cases (66.7%) more than one aneuploid event was detected. The total number of aneuploid cases in this group was 76 (81%). In the group without progression, the number of aneuploid stemlines was 2 (2%). Single aneuploid cells could be found in five cases (5%). The overall number of aneuploid cases in that group was five. The sensitivity was 74.3%, positive predictive value 85.2% and negative predictive value 77%. CONCLUSION: Aneuploidy is a marker for prospective malignancy in cervical Papanicolaou smears. DNA image cytometry, as an additional method, can be used to predict outcome in patients with CIN 1 and 2 of the cervix. DNA cytometry is not a screening method but can add further information for a treatment decision in doubtful cases.     

Comparative cytofluorometric DNA analysis of pleomorphic adenoma and adenoid cystic carcinoma of the salivary glands.

The nuclear DNA content in the tumor cells of 17 pleomorphic adenomas (PA) and 26 adenoid cystic carcinomas (ACC) was assayed by cytofluorometry to clarify the etiology of the differences in their biological nature. Aneuploidy was found in only two solid-pattern ACC samples; all the other samples had diploid stemlines. With respect to the polyploid cell rate and the S + G2M fraction, the differences between the four histological patterns of PA were not significant. In the ACC, the S + G2M fraction was significantly higher in solid pattern than in cribriform or trabecular pattern tumors, which may indicate that proliferative activity is higher in the solid pattern than in the other two. The polyploid cell rate in ACC was significantly higher in the solid pattern than in the cribriform pattern carcinomas. There was no significant difference in the mean polyploid cell rate between PAs and ACCs. The mean S + G2M fraction was significantly higher in all histological patterns of ACCs than in PAs. These results suggest that proliferative activity is greater in any one of the histological patterns of ACC than in PA. These findings may largely explain the biological differences between the two tumors.     

DNA ploidy analysis and cytologic examination of sorted cell populations from human breast tumors

Two different flow cytometric procedures were applied on cell samples from human breast tumors. One procedure involved DNA ploidy analysis on suspensions of isolated nuclei. The mean ploidy ratios of 27 benign breast lesions to chicken erythrocytes and rainbow trout erythrocytes were found to be 2.66 +/- 0.03 and 1.25 +/- 0.02, respectively. From the 45 stemlines found in a series of 43 carcinomas, 12 were diploid, 13 hyperdiploid and 20 near-tetraploid. No association was found between the lymph node status and the DNA ploidy level. The second procedure involved sorting fixed cells from DNA "windows" for the preparation of permanent cytologic specimens. The sorted cells appeared to be shrunken, but the morphologic quality was similar to that of imprint specimens from the same tumors, permitting discrimination between various types of normal cells and tumor cells. The combined use of both flow cytometric procedures may lead to greater insight into the relationship between the cytologic and cytogenetic heterogeneity of breast carcinomas.     

Detection of human papillomavirus in cervical smears. A comparison of in situ hybridization, immunocytochemistry and cytopathology

A comparison of different methods for the detection of cervical human papillomavirus (HPV) infection was made on patients attending the cervical dysplasia clinic. Cytomorphology, immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization were compared for their ability to detect HPV. Separate cervicovaginal smears from 50 patients were tested for HPV types 6/11, 16 and 18 by in situ hybridization using 35S-labeled DNA probes. Duplicate smears from the same patients were Papanicolaou stained and evaluated for evidence of condylomatous and dysplastic changes. Twenty-five matching cervical biopsies were immunostained for HPV capsid antigen and tested by in situ hybridization for HPV DNA. The cytologic smears of 20 patients (40%) were positive for HPV DNA. Six patients had HPV 6/11, ten had HPV 16, three had HPV 18, and one had both HPV 6/11 and HPV 16. There was a high correlation between condylomatous cytopathology and antigen and DNA detection. One-third of the specimens with condylomatous changes were DNA negative by the tested probes, suggesting the presence of other HPV types in the genital tract.     

膀胱肿瘤DNA含量、核形态学特点与AgNORs计数的研究

应用图像分析技术对４３例膀胱肿瘤细胞ＤＮＡ含量和核形态参数进行了定量测定,同时进行核仁组成区（ＡｇＮＯＲｓ）计数研究,结果表明：肿瘤细胞的ＤＮＡ含量及干系水平与组织学分级基本一致,ＤＮＡ含量及干系水平越高,则恶性程度越高,ＤＮＡ含量与核面积及核最短直径的变化里正相关性,与ＡｇＮＯＲｓ的计数无明显相关性。这三项检测方法对肿瘤生物学行为判断均有重要的参考价值。     

Review of negative and low‐grade cervical smears in women with invasive cervical cancer after the first 3 years of the national cervical screening programme in Slovenia

A. Repše‐Fokter, A. Pogačnik, V. Snoj, M. Primic‐Žakelj and M. S. Fležar
Review of negative and low‐grade cervical smears in women with invasive cervical cancer after the first 3 years of the national cervical screening programme in Slovenia Objective: The purpose of the study was to perform a national review of negative, low‐grade and inadequate smears reported during the latest screening period before cervical cancer diagnosis in 2006, after the first 3 years of the screening programme. Methods: Among 162 new cervical cancer cases there were 47 (29%) without previous cytology, 47 (29%) with one high‐grade smear prior to diagnosis and 68 (42.0%) with at least one previous negative, low‐grade, atypical or inadequate smear 1–40 months before diagnosis. Of the latter 68 cases, 37 patients with 59 smears (together with 118 control slides) were included in the review as 31 had smears reported at laboratories no longer operating. Findings were related to the last cytology report before diagnosis as well as to histological type and stage of the cancer. Results: In our study group, 19 (51%) of 37 patients had squamous cell carcinoma, 15 (41%) adenocarcinoma and 3 (8%) adenosquamous carcinoma, compared with 121 (75%), 26 (16%), 12 (7%), respectively, and 3 (2%) other types, for all carcinomas. Twenty‐one of 37 women also had high‐grade cytology prior to diagnosis of cancer. Women with previous cytology (with or without recent high‐grade smears) were more likely to have stage I cancers than those without cytology (P < 0.0001). The expert group upgraded 17/33 smears in the patients with squamous carcinomas, which was more than in those with adeno‐ and adenosquamous carcinomas (5/24, P < 0.05). Conclusion: As expected, a higher proportion of smears preceding adenocarcinomas were true negative. Under‐diagnosed smears were not related to cancer stage or last cytology report before diagnosis.     

The reliability of microspectrophotometric and flow cytometric nuclear DNA measurements in adenocarcinomas of the breast

The reliability of microspectrophotometric (MSP) and flow cytometric (FCM) nuclear DNA measurements has been studied in 50 human breast adenocarcinomas. The tumor material was obtained by means of fine-needle aspiration biopsy, and all samples except one were found to be highly representative. The results confirm earlier observations that a good correlation exists between modal value (MV) determined by MSP and DNA index (DI) determined by FCM. However, when tumors were classified into low and high malignant variants according to FCM/DI, FCM/S-phase percentages, and MSP histogram types, the concordance was less pronounced. This was found to be due mainly to the fact that in near-diploid tumors a discrepancy exists between MSP and FCM ploidy, as well as between MSP distribution pattern and the estimated percentages of cells in the S-phase region. Another source of discrepancy was observed in tumors with stemlines in the normal tetraploid region, including cells with highly scattered aneuploid DNA values. These tumors were judged by MSP as aneuploid/high malignant and by FCM as euploid/low malignant. In view of this discrepancy, we conclude that the simple determination of the stemline position by MSP/MV or FCM/DI is not sufficient for adequate cytochemical malignancy grading of breast carcinomas. We suggest that a combination of ploidy and percentage of cells scattered outside the modal peaks is a more sensitive method for optimal cytochemical malignancy grading in breast carcinomas.     

Evaluation of heterogeneity of DNA ploidy in early gastric cancers.

DNA ploidy has been shown to be a predictive parameter for prognosis in various solid tumours. The prognostic value of DNA-ploidy in gastric cancers is still a matter of controversy. A possible explanation for the discrepant results reported in the literature could be sampling error in tumours with multiple stemlines differing in DNA-ploidy. In order to determine whether or not such heterogeneity exists in early gastric carcinoma, we have performed DNA cytophotometry on multiple samples of a group of 17 early gastric carcinomas, of which 8 were pure intramucosal and 9 were infiltrating into the submucosa. We found an aneuploid DNA-stemline in 8 (47%) early gastric cancers, more often in tumours invading into the submucosa (5/9) than in purely mucosal tumours (3/8). Multiple DNA-stemlines were found more frequently in submucosally infiltrating tumours (4/5). These results confirm the presence of DNA-aneuploid early gastric carcinoma which are frequently heterogeneous and suggest that heterogeneity occurs more frequently in tumours invading the submucosa. This heterogeneity is best detected by analysing multiple samples of tumours for DNA-ploidy.     

Comparison of breast carcinomas diagnosed in the 1980s with those diagnosed in the 1940s to 1960s.

OBJECTIVE--To find out if breast carcinomas diagnosed in the 1980s differ from those diagnosed a few decades ago. DESIGN--Retrospective comparative cohort study. SETTING--City of Turku, south western Finland. PATIENTS--439 patients with breast carcinoma diagnosed in 1945-65 with a median follow up of 27 years (95% of all those histologically diagnosed in Turku); and 370 patients with breast carcinoma diagnosed in 1980-4 with a median follow up of 6 years (94% of all those histologically diagnosed in Turku). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Breast cancer incidence, mortality from breast cancer, age at diagnosis, stage of cancer, seven histological factors, DNA ploidy. RESULTS--Age adjusted incidence of breast cancer increased from 30.8/100,000 person years in 1953-7 to 62.2/100,000 in 1983-7; mortality in breast cancer increased from 16.7 to 17.2/100,000 person years. Survival of patients with stages II to IV (but not with stage I) improved. The mean age at diagnosis increased from 55.5 years in 1945-55 to 62.5 years in 1980-4 (p less than 0.0001); the proportion of patients with T0-1 carcinomas increased from 13% to 41% (p less than 0.0001) and with pN0 carcinomas from 43% to 55% (p = 0.003) from 1945-65 to 1980-4. There was no change in histological type or DNA ploidy of breast cancer, but in the 1980-4 cohort carcinomas were more often well differentiated, had lower mitotic counts and less nuclear pleomorphism, more often had a well defined tumour margin, and had less tumour necrosis. There was, however, no difference between the two cohorts in these histological characteristics except for tumour necrosis when they were compared in a multivariate log linear model at a given size of primary tumour. CONCLUSION--Improved survival with breast cancer can at least partially be explained by detection of increased numbers of small carcinomas with favourable histological characteristics.     

Combined Pap smear, cervicography and HPV DNA testing in the detection of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia and cancer

OBJECTIVE: The sensitivity of the Pap smear (PAP) continues to be the subject of debate. During the past several years, cervicography (CER) and HPV DNA testing have been suggested as optional tools in the screening of cervical cancer precursors. STUDY DESIGN: The performance characteristics of PAP, CER and HPV DNA testing (hybrid capture test [HCT]) in all potential combinations were evaluated in a series of 1,030 women (aged 16-70, median, 33), subjected to colposcopy (COLPO) as the reference tool. RESULTS: Of the 992 evaluable cases, 402/992 (41%) had positive COLPO (i.e., an abnormal transformation zone). Of them, 298 women underwent directed punch biopsy, while of the COLPO negative patients, 18/93 positive by at least one of the three tests had endocervical curettage. Of the 402 COLPO positive women, 146 (36%) remained negative on all tests, whereas 256 (64%) had at least one positive test. There were 84 cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2 and 3 lesions and 6 invasive carcinomas. Of the former, 10 were detected by PAP alone, 4 by CER alone and 3 by HCT alone. Three of the 6 carcinomas were HCT negative. The predictive value (PPV) of a positive test was 45% for PAP, 51% for CER and 48% for HCT. The combinations of PAP with CER (for PAP negative cases) and PAP with HCT were more sensitive for CIN 2 and 3 (95% and 94%, respectively) as compared with PAP alone but were associated with a significant decrease in specificity (44% and 46% vs. 57%, respectively). However, both combinations retained a PPV (43%) similar to that of PAP alone (45%). CONCLUSION: The potential combinations of PAP with CER and with HCT were more sensitive in detecting CIN 2 and 3 as compared with PAP alone and retained a PPV similar to that of PAP.     

Age at time of first intercourse v. chronologic age as a basis for Pap smear screening.

The Walton Report on cervical cancer screening programs recently recommended a new program for screening for cervical cancer based on chronologic age, calling for 3- and 5-year intervals between examinations. It recommended that such examinations be discontinued after 60 years of age. In a group of 232 routinely examined women (aged 18 to 47 years) in whom cervical intraepithelial neoplasia developed the timing of onset of the disease and the implications for screening were studied. The average age at the time of diagnosis was 30 years; in 20% of the patients the diagnosis had been made after age 35. The screening program recommended in the Walton Report would have been effective in diagnosing most cases (80%) in this sample by age 35 and all by age 60. However, when the patients were grouped according to age at the time of first intercourse, the diagnosis had been made after age 35 in only 13% of those who started having intercourse at age 15 to 17 years, 20% of those who started at age 18 to 19 years and 33% of those who started at age 20 years of later. When the times of diagnosis were expressed by number of years of intercourse the distributions became uniform in the same three groups; in 72% of all the patients the diagnosis had been made within the first 15 years of intercourse, in 88% it had been made within 20 years and in 100% it had been made by 30 years. These data suggest that a program based on number of years of intercourse may be more uniform and more efficient than one based on chronologic age, and that cytologic examinations should be concentrated during the time when most cases develop -- 6 to 20 years after the time of first intercourse.