Lateral gene transfer: when will adolescence end?

The scope and impact of horizontal gene transfer (HGT) in Bacteria and Archaea has grown from a topic largely ignored by the microbiological community to a hot-button issue gaining staunch supporters (on particular points of view) at a seemingly ever-increasing rate. Opinions range from HGT being a phenomenon with minor impact on overall microbial evolution and diversification to HGT being so rampant as to obfuscate any opportunities for elucidating microbial evolution - especially organismal phylogeny - from sequence comparisons. This contentious issue has been fuelled by the influx of complete genome sequences, which has allowed for a more detailed examination of this question than previously afforded. We propose that the lack of common ground upon which to formulate consensus viewpoints probably stems from the absence of answers to four critical questions. If addressed, they could clarify concepts, reject tenuous speculation and solidify a robust foundation for the integration of HGT into a framework for long-term microbial evolution, regardless of the intellectual camp in which you reside. Here, we examine these issues, why their answers shape the outcome of this debate and the progress being made to address them.     

Bacteriophage-associated gene transfer in pneumococcus: transduction or pseudotransduction?

Lysates of pneumococcal phage PG24 transferred genes from one host to another in a process with many of the properties of generalized transduction, in that the host genes were packaged in DNase-resistant particles that closely resembled infectious phage in physical properties, adsorbed to the recipient cells like phage, and were inhibited by antisera to the phage and by trypsin. However, phage processes did not complete the transfer of host DNA as they did phage DNA. Instead, gene transfer required development of competence and entry of the host DNA by the endonuclease-dependent pathway used for transforming and transfecting DNA. This process often occurred on the assay plate hours after adsorption of the particles to the cells, and the transfer was DNase sensitive if challenged at this time. Phenotypic expression was therefore also delayed. The product of entry was like that in transformation, a single strand of DNA that integrates by formation of a hex-sensitive donor-recipient heteroduplex. Whether this gene transfer process is unique to this system or is only the first one described is not clear. The term "pseudotransduction" may be useful in calling attention to its unexpected features. The DNA of PG24 phage has anomalous physical properties reflecting unusual bases.     

Function of the phosphatidylinositol transfer protein gene family: is phosphatidylinositol transfer the mechanism of action?

Phosphatidylinositol transfer proteins (PITPs) bind and facilitate the transport of phosphatidylinositol (PI) and phosphatidylcholine between membrane compartments. They are highly conserved proteins, are found in both unicellular and multicellular organisms, and can be present as a single domain or as part of a larger, multi-domain protein. The hallmark of PITP proteins is their ability to sequester PI in their hydrophobic pocket. Ablation or knockdown of specific isoforms in vivo has wide ranging effects such as defects in signal transduction via phospholipase C and phosphoinositide 3-kinase, membrane trafficking, stem cell viability, Drosophila phototransduction, neurite outgrowth, and cytokinesis. In this review, we identify the common mechanism underlying each of these phenotypes as the cooperation between PITP proteins and lipid kinases through the provision of PI for phosphorylation. We propose that recruitment and concentration of PITP proteins at specific membrane sites are required for PITP proteins to execute their function rather than lipid transfer.     

Horizontal gene transfer in nematodes: a catalyst for plant parasitism?

The origin of plant parasitism within the phylum Nematoda is intriguing. The ability to parasitize plants has originated independently at least three times during nematode evolution and, as more molecular data has emerged, it has become clear that multiple instances of horizontal gene transfer (HGT) from bacteria and fungi have played a crucial role in the nematode's adaptation to this new lifestyle. The first reported HGT cases in plant-parasitic nematodes were genes encoding plant cell wall-degrading enzymes. Other putative examples of HGT were subsequently described, including genes that may be involved in the modulation of the plant's defense system, the establishment of a nematode feeding site, and the synthesis or processing of nutrients. Although, in many cases, it is difficult to pinpoint the donor organism, candidate donors are usually soil dwelling and are either plant-pathogenic or plant-associated microorganisms, hence occupying the same ecological niche as the nematodes. The exact mechanisms of transfer are unknown, although close contacts with donor microorganisms, such as symbiotic or trophic interactions, are a possibility. The widespread occurrence of horizontally transferred genes in evolutionarily independent plant-parasitic nematode lineages suggests that HGT may be a prerequisite for successful plant parasitism in nematodes.     

Plastocyanin–ferredoxin oxidoreduction and endosymbiotic gene transfer

Sequence similarities of proteins associated with plastocyanin-ferredoxin oxidoreduction (PcFdOR) activity of Photosystem I (PSI) were grouped and compared. PsaA, psaB, psaC, and petG represent genes that have been retained in the chloroplasts of both green- and red-lineage species. PsaD, psaE, psaF, and petF represent genes that have been retained in the chloroplast of red-lineage species, but have been transferred to the nuclear genome of green-lineage species. Translated sequences from red- and green-lineage proteins were compared to that of contemporary cyanobacteria, Synechocystis PCC 6803, and Gloeobacter violaceus PCC 7421. Within the green lineage, a lower level of sequence conservation coincided with gene transfer to the nuclear genome. Surprisingly, a similar pattern of sequence conservation existed for the same set of genes found in the red lineage even though all those genes were retained in their chloroplast genomes. This discrepancy between green and red lineage is discussed in terms of endosymbiotic gene transfer.     

Virus-mediated gene transfer to induce therapeutic angiogenesis: Where do we stand?

The potential to induce therapeutic angiogenesis through gene transfer has engendered much excitement as a possible treatment for tissue ischemia. After 10 years of clinical experimentation, however, it now appears clear that several crucial issues are still to be resolved prior to achieving clinical success. These include the understanding of whether functional blood vessels might arise as a result of the delivery of a single angiogenic factor or require more complex cytokine combinations, the identification of the proper timing of therapeutic gene expression and, most notably, the development of more efficacious gene delivery tools. Viral vectors based on the adeno-associated virus (AAV) appear particularly suitable to address the last requirement, since they display a specific tropism for skeletal muscle cells and cardiomyocytes, and drive expression of the therapeutic genes in these cells for indefinite periods of time. In this review, I discuss the current applications of gene therapy for cardiovascular disorders, with particular attention to the possible improvements in the technologies involved in virus-mediated gene transfer.     

Sperm‐mediated gene transfer: advances in sperm cell research and applications

Transgenic Research -     

Recent fungal diseases of crop plants: is lateral gene transfer a common theme?

A cursory glance at old textbooks of plant pathology reveals that the diseases which are the current scourge of agriculture in many parts of the world are a different set from those that were prominent 50 or 100 years ago. Why have these new diseases arisen? The traditional explanations subscribe to the "nature abhors a vacuum" principle-that control of one disease creates the condition for the emergence of a replacement-but does little to explain why the new pathogen succeeds. The emergence of a new disease requires a series of conditions and steps, including the enhanced fecundity of the new pathogen, enhanced survival from season to season, and spread around the world. Recently, evidence was obtained that wheat tan spot emerged through a lateral gene transfer event some time prior to 1941. Although there have been sporadic and persistent reports of lateral gene transfer between and into fungal plant pathogens, most examples have been dismissed through incomplete evidence. The completion of whole genome sequences of an increasing number of fungal pathogens no longer allows such proposed cases of lateral gene transfer to be dismissed so easily. How frequent are lateral gene transfers involving fungal plant pathogens, and can this process explain the emergence of many of the new diseases of the recent past? Many of the apparently new diseases are dependant on the expression of host-specific toxins. These are enigmatic molecules whose action requires the presence of plant genes with products that specifically encode sensitivity to the toxin and susceptibility to the disease. It is also notable that many new diseases belong to the fungal taxon dothideomycetes. This review explores the coincidence of new diseases, interspecific gene transfer, host-specific toxins, and the dothideomycete class.     

Anchoring cytokines to cancer cells using diphtheria toxin: better than immunotherapy by gene transfer?

Many cytokines are able to stimulate the antitumor immune response. However, in order to avoid the toxic effects due to systemic injection, it is necessary to concentrate the cytokines in the tumor microenvironment. Current methods, based on the transfer of cytokine genes into tumor cells, still suffer drawbacks. We describe an alternative approach using recombinant cytokines genetically conjugated to a membrane anchor derived from diphtheria toxin. Interleukin-2 anchored to lymphoma and melanoma cells remained displayed on their surface and were not internalized. Injection of these cell preparations to mice led to an immune response able to prevent or slow tumor growth following tumor challenge.     

Copper/Zinc superoxide dismutase: How likely is gene transfer from ponyfish toPhotobacterium leiognathi?

Summary The proposed transfer of the gene for Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase from the ponyfish to its symbiotic bacteriumPhotobacterium leiognathi has been evaluated by an extensive analysis of all available Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase sequences. By the use of four different computer programs, phylogenetic trees were constructed from the sequences of the superoxide dismutases of human, ox, pig, horse, swordfish, fruit fly, yeast, andNeurospora crassa to find out whether superoxide dismutase sequences can reliably be used for the reconstruction of genealogical relationships. All programs arrived at the same most parsimonious tree (one requiring 232 amino acid replacements), the topology of which conformed to established opinions about the phylogenetic relations among these eukaryotes, except that it placed humans closer to the artiodactyls ox and pig than it placed horses. This could be corrected at the cost of two amino acid replacements. The sequence ofP. leiognathi superoxide dismutase was then connected at all possible positions to the corrected eukaryotic tree. It was slighly more parsimonious to link the bacterial sequence to the root of the tree than to the fish branch: The former required 316 (or 317) amino acid replacements, versus 319 for the latter. This relative lack of discrimination between such distinct alternative topologies may be a general complication in the comparison of prokaryotic and eukaryotic proteins: Bacterial cytochrome c sequences also were found to be connected as parsimoniously to the root of the eukaryotic tree as to any terminal or ancestral branch. It was calculated that the rate of evolution of the bacterial superoxide dismutase gene, if transfer occurred 30 million years (Myr) ago, must have amounted to 487 amino acid replacements per 100 residues per 100 Myr. This is more than 5 times the highest rate observed in any protein (that found for fibrinopeptides), and even much higher than the maximum rate of protein evolution that can be deduced from the neutral mutation rate of unconstrained DNA. Also, no significant evidence that shared derived amino acid replacements are present in swordfish andP. leiognathi superoxide dismutase, as might be expected had gene transfer occurred, was found. On the basis of the available data it seems more reasonable to ascribe the isolated occurrence of Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase inP. leiognathi (as well as inCaulobacter crescentus) to irregular patterns of gene expression and inactivation in the course of divergent evolution than to undocumented processes of gene transfer from eukaryotes to prokaryotes.     

Lateral gene transfer in eukaryotes: tip of the iceberg or of the ice cube?

Lateral gene transfer (LGT) is the transmission of genes, sometimes across species barriers, outwith the classic vertical inheritance from parent to offspring. LGT is recognized as an important phenomenon that has shaped the genomes and biology of prokaryotes. Whether LGT in eukaryotes is important and widespread remains controversial. A study in BMC Biology concludes that LGT in eukaryotes is neither continuous nor prevalent and suggests a rule of thumb for judging when apparent LGT may reflect contamination.See research article: http://bmcbiol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12915-016-0315-9.     

Is Saccharomyces cerevisiae apoptotic cell death associated with gene transfer?

Programmed cell death in unicellular organisms is difficult to account for in evolutionary terms. In the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, existence of several morphological and biochemical features of apoptosis has been described, and genes responsible for execution of the death program have been identified. It is here suggested that apoptosis of yeast cells could provide direct benefit to the genes of the dying cells, by facilitating DNA transfer to surrounding cells. The biochemical details of yeast apoptotic death are considered in light of a gene transfer hypothesis.