Amplified fragment length polymorphism analysis of genetic diversity of Haemonchus contortus during selection for drug resistance.

For the first time we used amplified fragment length polymorphism on individual nematode parasites to analyse the genetic diversity between and within isolates during consecutive stages of increased benzimidazole resistance and of increased levamisole resistance of Haemonchus contortus. The genetic diversity of the H. contortus genome turned out to be unusually high, within and between the isolates. The difference between individuals of an isolate could be as high as between individuals of two different mammalian species that do not interbreed. During benzimidazole selection the genetic constitution of the population was changed, but did not lead to a decrease in the genetic diversity. The selection for levamisole resistance resulted in a limited reduction of the genetic diversity only after the first selection step. The extensive genetic diversity apparently has allowed a fast and flexible response of H. contortus to drug selection as shown by the appearance of drug resistant isolates. This selection however has little or no effect on the extent of the genetic diversity of these resistant isolates. Implications for more sustainable control methods are discussed.     

Levamisole receptors: a second awakening

Levamisole and pyrantel are old (1965) but useful anthelmintics that selectively activate nematode acetylcholine ion channel receptors; they are used to treat roundworm infections in humans and animals. Interest in their actions has surged, giving rise to new knowledge and technical advances, including an ability to reconstitute receptors that reveal more details of modes of action/resistance. We now know that the receptors are plastic and may form diverse species-dependent subtypes of receptor with different sensitivities to individual cholinergic anthelmintics. Understanding the biology of the levamisole receptors is expected to inform other studies on anthelmintics (ivermectin and emodepside) that act on ion channels.     

Molecular basis of the differential sensitivity of nematode and mammalian muscle to the anthelmintic agent levamisole

Levamisole is an anthelmintic agent that exerts its therapeutic effect by acting as a full agonist of the nicotinic receptor (AChR) of nematode muscle. Its action at the mammalian muscle AChR has not been elucidated to date despite its wide use as an anthelmintic in humans and cattle. By single channel and macroscopic current recordings, we investigated the interaction of levamisole with the mammalian muscle AChR. Levamisole activates mammalian AChRs. However, single channel openings are briefer than those activated by acetylcholine (ACh) and do not appear in clusters at high concentrations. The peak current induced by levamisole is about 3% that activated by ACh. Thus, the anthelmintic acts as a weak agonist of the mammalian AChR. Levamisole also produces open channel blockade of the AChR. The apparent affinity for block (190 microm at -70 mV) is similar to that of the nematode AChR, suggesting that differences in channel activation kinetics govern the different sensitivity of nematode and mammalian muscle to anthelmintics. To identify the structural basis of this different sensitivity, we performed mutagenesis targeting residues in the alpha subunit that differ between vertebrates and nematodes. The replacement of the conserved alphaGly-153 with the homologous glutamic acid of nematode AChR significantly increases the efficacy of levamisole to activate channels. Channel activity takes place in clusters having two different kinetic modes. The kinetics of the high open probability mode are almost identical when the agonist is ACh or levamisole. It is concluded that alphaGly-153 is involved in the low efficacy of levamisole to activate mammalian muscle AChRs.     

Investigation of intestinal nematode responses to naphthalophos and pyrantel using a larval development assay.

Responses of several nematode species to naphthalophos and pyrantel/levamisole were examined using a larval development assay in order to determine the potential of this assay for detection of resistance. Haemonchus contortus and Ostertagia circumcincta showed concentration-dependent responses to naphthalophos, however, the assay was unsuitable for Trichostrongylus colubriformis due to the low toxicity of the drug to the larval stages of this nematode. Measurement of concentration-dependent response to pyrantel in susceptible T. colubriformis was limited by a reduced toxicity against larvae at high drug concentrations, resulting in a parabolic response with a development-inhibition maxima of less than 100%. This limits the usefulness of the assay to detect pyrantel resistance in this species as the presence of a small resistant fraction in a field isolate may be indistinguishable from the parabolic susceptible response. On the other hand, responses of susceptible T. colubriformis to levamisole, and susceptible H. contortus to pyrantel and levamisole showed 100% development inhibition over a range of drug concentrations, indicating that the appearance of a resistant fraction in a field population would be readily discernible from the susceptible response, allowing resistance detection for these drug/parasite combinations. This study has highlighted the varied suitability of the larval development assay technique for resistance detection with different combinations of drugs and parasite species.     

Single-channel properties of N- and L-subtypes of acetylcholine receptor in Ascaris suum

We are interested in the properties of the target site of cholinergic anti-nematodal drugs for therapeutic reasons. The target receptors are ligand-gated ion channels that have different subtypes, and each subtype may have a different pharmacology. In a contraction assay using the parasitic nematode Ascaris suum, our laboratory has identified several subtypes, including an N-subtype, preferentially activated by nicotine, and an L-subtype, preferentially activated by levamisole. Here we use patch-clamp recordings to test the hypothesis that the single-channel selectivities of nicotine and levamisole are different. Unitary currents evoked by nicotine in this preparation were characterised for the first time. In some patches, both nicotine and levamisole activated small- and large-conductance channels. In other patches, the agonists activated just one channel amplitude. Discriminant analysis allowed classification of the one-conductance patch channels into the small or large categories, based on sets defined by the two-conductance patch data. The small channels had a conductance of 26.1+/-1.5 pS, n=18 (mean+/-SEM); the large conductance channels had a conductance of 38.8+/-1.2 pS, n=23 (mean+/-SEM). Analysis of amplitude histograms of the two-conductance patches showed that nicotine preferentially activated the small-conductance channels and levamisole preferentially activated the large-conductance channels. Our observations suggest that the N-subtype receptor channel has a conductance of 26 pS channel and the L-subtype receptor channel has a conductance of 39 pS.     

Tribendimidine: Mode of Action and nAChR Subtype Selectivity in Ascaris and Oesophagostomum

The cholinergic class of anthelmintic drugs is used for the control of parasitic nematodes. One of this class of drugs, tribendimidine (a symmetrical diamidine derivative, of amidantel), was developed in China for use in humans in the mid-1980s. It has a broader-spectrum anthelmintic action against soil-transmitted helminthiasis than other cholinergic anthelmintics, and is effective against hookworm, pinworms, roundworms, and Strongyloides and flatworm of humans. Although molecular studies on C. elegans suggest that tribendimidine is a cholinergic agonist that is selective for the same nematode muscle nAChR as levamisole, no direct electrophysiological observations in nematode parasites have been made to test this hypothesis. Also the hypothesis that levamisole and tribendimine act on the same receptor, does not explain why tribendimidine is effective against some nematode parasites when levamisole is not. Here we examine the effects of tribendimidine on the electrophysiology and contraction of Ascaris suum body muscle and show that tribendimidine produces depolarization antagonized by the nicotinic antagonist mecamylamine, and that tribendimidine is an agonist of muscle nAChRs of parasitic nematodes. Further pharmacological characterization of the nAChRs activated by tribendimidine in our Ascaris muscle contraction assay shows that tribendimidine is not selective for the same receptor subtypes as levamisole, and that tribendimidine is more selective for the B-subtype than the L-subtype of nAChR. In addition, larval migration inhibition assays with levamisole-resistant Oesophagostomum dentatum isolates show that tribendimidine is as active on a levamisole-resistant isolate as on a levamisole-sensitive isolate, suggesting that the selectivity for levamisole and tribendimidine is not the same. It is concluded that tribendimidine can activate a different population of nematode parasite nAChRs than levamisole, and is more like bephenium. The different nAChR subtype selectivity of tribendimidine may explain why the spectrum of action of tribendimidine is different to that of other cholinergic anthelmintics like levamisole.     

Investigation of Acetylcholine Receptor Diversity in a Nematode Parasite Leads to Characterization of Tribendimidine- and Derquantel-Sensitive nAChRs

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs) of parasitic nematodes are required for body movement and are targets of important “classical” anthelmintics like levamisole and pyrantel, as well as “novel” anthelmintics like tribendimidine and derquantel. Four biophysical subtypes of nAChR have been observed electrophysiologically in body muscle of the nematode parasite Oesophagostomum dentatum, but their molecular basis was not understood. Additionally, loss of one of these subtypes (G 35 pS) was found to be associated with levamisole resistance. In the present study, we identified and expressed in Xenopus oocytes, four O. dentatum nAChR subunit genes, Ode-unc-38, Ode-unc-63, Ode-unc-29 and Ode-acr-8, to explore the origin of the receptor diversity. When different combinations of subunits were injected in Xenopus oocytes, we reconstituted and characterized four pharmacologically different types of nAChRs with different sensitivities to the cholinergic anthelmintics. Moreover, we demonstrate that the receptor diversity may be affected by the stoichiometric arrangement of the subunits. We show, for the first time, different combinations of subunits from a parasitic nematode that make up receptors sensitive to tribendimidine and derquantel. In addition, we report that the recombinant levamisole-sensitive receptor made up of Ode-UNC-29, Ode-UNC-63, Ode-UNC-38 and Ode-ACR-8 subunits has the same single-channel conductance, 35 pS and 2.4 ms mean open-time properties, as the levamisole-AChR (G35) subtype previously identified in vivo. These data highlight the flexible arrangements of the receptor subunits and their effects on sensitivity and resistance to the cholinergic anthelmintics; pyrantel, tribendimidine and/or derquantel may still be effective on levamisole-resistant worms.     

Development of Selected Tobacco Cyst Nematode Isolates on Resistant and Susceptible Cultivars of Flue-cured Tobacco

Tobacco cyst nematode (Globodera tabacum solanacearum) isolates were collected from 11 locations in Virginia, 3 in North Carolina, and 1 in Maryland. Isolates from each location were maintained and increased on flue-cured tobacco, Nicotiana tabacum cv K326. Plants of flue-cured tobacco cultivars K326 (susceptible) and NC567 (resistant) were each inoculated with 6,000 G. t. solanacearum eggs/plant. Tests were conducted over one (6 weeks) or two (14 weeks) generations of the nematode. Shoot and root weights and the number of nematodes present within a 1-g subsample of feeder roots were recorded at completion of the tests. Nematode counts were categorized by nematode life stage (vermiform, swollen, pyriform, and adult). Although significant differences in nematode development were detected among isolates, differences were not consistent across experiments. Results indicate similar virulence among G. t. solanacearum isolates on resistant and susceptible flue-cured tobacco cultivars. Therefore, plant breeders may effectively use a single G. t. solanacearum isolate when screening tobacco germplasm for resistance.     

Resistance of selected lines of Ostertagia circumcincta to thiabendazole, morantel tartrate and levamisole

Le Jambre I. F., Southcott W. H. and Dash K. M. 1977. Resistance of selected lines of Ostertagia circumcincta to thiabendazole, morantel tartrate and levamisole. International Journal for Parasitology7: 473–479. A strain of Ostertagia circumcincta was isolated from a field in which all sheep had been treated in sequence every 7–10 days from September 1970 to January 1974 with either thiabendazole, morantel tartrate or levamisole. Thiabendazole had not been used after the first 15 months. The LD₉₅ for this strain was 88 mg/kg thiabendazole, 6.9 mg/kg morantel tartrate and 5-4 mg/kg levamisole.Another strain of O. circumcincta isolated from an area where anthelmintics had been used much less frequently was divided into four lines for exposure to selection in the laboratory. The first line was selected with 50 mg/kg thiabendazole, the second with 5 mg/kg morantel tartrate, and the third with 3.2 mg/kg levamisole; the fourth line was not selected for drug resistance. After eight generations the three lines selected with thiabendazole, morantel tartrate and levamisole had (Spld)(in95) of > 200, 5.7 and 6.2 mg/kg for the selecting drugs respectively, compared with corresponding values of 20, 2.9, and 1.8 in the unselected line. That is, the field strain had about the same levels of resistance to morantel tartrate and levamisole as the respective laboratory strains selected with these individual drugs. However, the field strain, which had been exposed to thiabendazole for only 15 months, was less resistant to thiabendazole than the laboratory strain selected with this drug. These results show that giving of several drugs in sequence cannot be relied upon to prevent the development of resistance to the individual drugs.The dose responses of adult worms showed low, but significant resistances to morantel tartrate and levamisole and a relatively high resistance to thiabendazole. Levamisole was found to select for inhibition of development with approx. 8.0% of the inhibited larvae showing no dose response above 1.6 mg/kg. Levamisole was also associated with an increase from 0.1 % to 9.0% in the O. trifurcata component of an Ostertagia population.     

Differentiation of Two New York Isolates of Pratylenchus penetrans Based on Their Reaction on Potato

The behavior of two isolates of Pratylenchus penetrans on six potato clones was assessed to test the hypothesis that these nematode isolates from New York were different. Four potato cultivars (Superior, Russet Burbank, Butte, and Hudson) and two breeding lines (NY85 and L118-2) were inoculated with nematode isolates designated Cornell (CR) and Long Island (LI). Population increase and egression of nematodes from roots were used to distinguish resistance and susceptibility of the potato clones. Based on numbers of eggs, juveniles, and adults in their roots 30 days after inoculation, potato clones Butte, Hudson, and L118-2 were designated resistant to the CR isolate and susceptible to the LI isolate. More eggs were found in the roots of all plants inoculated with the LI isolate than with the CR isolate. The clones NY85 and L118-2 were inoculated with the CR and LI isolates in a 2 x 2 factorial experiment to assess differences in nematode egression. Egression was measured, beginning 3 days after inoculation, for 12 days. The rates of egression were similar for the four treatments and fit linear regression models, but differences were detected in numbers of egressed nematodes. More nematodes of the CR isolate than the LI isolate egressed from L118-2. Differences in egression of females was particularly significant and can be used as an alternative or supplement to reproduction tests to assess resistance in potato to P. penetrans and to distinguish variation in virulence.     

Prevalence of anthelmintic resistance in gastrointestinal nematodes of dairy goats under extensive management conditions in southwestern France

The occurrence of benzimidazole (BZ) and levamisole resistance was investigated in 18 randomly selected dairy goat herds located in southwestern France and characterized by extensive management. On each of the 18 farms, 45 adult goats were randomly allocated into three groups of 15 animals each: an untreated control group, a group that was orally administered fenbendazole (10 mg kg(-1) body weight) and a group that received orally a levamisole drench (12 mg kg(-1) body weight). Individual faecal egg counts and pooled larval cultures were done 10 days after anthelmintic treatment. Naive lambs were infected with larvae obtained from control and fenbendazole treated groups and were necropsied 35 days after infection for worm recovery. Faecal egg count reductions (FERC) were calculated for fenbendazole and levamisole and, when less than 95 per 100, were considered as indicative of anthelmintic resistance. An in vitro egg hatch test (EHT) was conducted with thiabendazole on eggs isolated from pooled faeces of fenbendazole treated goats in nine farms. Faecal egg count reductions indicated the occurrence of benzimidazole resistance in 15 out of 18 farms. Among these farms, nine had EHT values above 0.1 microg thiabendazole ml(-1) confirming the benzimidazole resistance status. Levamisole resistance was detected in two farms through FECR. Based on necropsy results, the prevalence of benzimidazole resistance was higher in Trichostrongylus colubriformis, medium in Haemonchus contortus and lower in Teladorsagia circumcincta. In nine farms the benzimidazole resistance was monospecific whereas multispecific resistance was found in the six remaining farms. A negative relationship was found between FECR for fenbendazole and the average number of anthelmintic treatments given per year on the farm. Despite extensive management including a low number of treatments, the prevalence of benzimidazole resistance was very high suggesting that the repeated and sometimes exclusive use of benzimidazole drugs, even at low frequency, is probably the main cause in developing nematode resistance in dairy goat herds. The importance of other factors such as under-dosing or buying animals already carrying resistant nematodes are discussed.     

QTL associated with horizontal resistance to soybean cyst nematode in Glycine soja PI464925B

Soybean cyst nematode (Heterodera glycines Ichinohe; SCN) is the primary disease responsible for yield loss of soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.]. Resistant cultivars are an effective management tool; however, the sources currently available have common resistant genes. Glycine soja Sieb. and Zucc., the wild ancestor of domesticated soybean, represents a diverse germplasm pool with known SCN resistance. The objectives of this research were to: (1) determine the genetic variation and inheritance of SCN resistance in a G. max (‘S08-80’) × G. soja (PI464925B) F _4:5 recombinant inbred line (RIL) population; and (2) identify and evaluate quantitative trait loci (QTL) associated with SCN resistance. Transgressive segregation for resistance was observed, although neither parent was resistant to the Chatham and Ruthven SCN isolates. Broad sense heritability was 0.81 for the Ruthven and 0.91 for the Chatham isolate. Root dry weight was a significant covariate that influenced cyst counts. One RIL [female index (FI) = 5.2 ± 1.11] was identified as resistant to the Chatham isolate (FI < 10). Seventeen and three RILs infected with Chatham and Ruthven isolates, respectively, had mean adjusted cyst counts of zero. Unique and novel QTL, which derived resistance from G. soja, were identified on linkage groups I, K, and O, and individually explained 8, 7 and 5% (LOD = 2.1–2.7) of the total phenotypic variation, respectively. Significant epistatic interactions were found between pairs of SSR markers that individually may or may not have been associated with SCN resistance, which explained between 10 and 15% of the total phenotypic variation. Best-fit regression models explained 21 and 31% of the total phenotypic variation in the RIL population to the Chatham and Ruthven isolates, respectively. The results of this study help to improve the understanding of the genetic control of SCN resistance in soybean caused by minor genes resulting in horizontal resistance. The incorporation of the novel resistance QTL from G. soja could increase the durability of SCN-resistance in soybean cultivars, especially if major gene resistance breaks down.     

Isofemale Line Analysis of Meloidogyne incognita Virulence to Cowpea Resistance Gene Rk

Isofemale lines (IFL) from single egg masses were studied for genetic variation in Meloidogyne incognita isolates avirulent and virulent to the resistance gene Rk in cowpea (Vigna unguiculata). In parental isolates cultured on susceptible and resistant cowpea, the virulent isolate contained 100% and the avirulent isolate 7% virulent lineages. Virulence was selected from the avirulent isolate within eight generations on resistant cowpea (lineage selection). In addition, virulence was selected from avirulent females (individual selection). Virulence differed (P ≤ 0.05) both within and between cohorts of IFL cultured for up to 27 generations on susceptible or resistant cowpea. Distinct virulence profiles were observed among IFL. Some remained avirulent on susceptible plants and became extinct on resistant plants; some remained virulent on resistant and susceptible plants; some changed from avirulent to virulent on resistant plants; and others changed from virulent to avirulent on susceptible plants. Also, some IFL increased in virulence on susceptible plants. Single descent lines from IFL showed similar patterns of virulence for up to six generations. These results revealed considerable genetic variation in virulence in a mitotic parthenogenetic nematode population. The frequencies of lineages with stable or changeable virulence and avirulence phenotypes determined the overall virulence potential of the population.     

Selection studies on anthelmintic resistant and susceptible populations of Trichostrongylus colubriformis of sheep

Waller P. J., Dobson R. J., Donald A. D., Griffiths D. A. and Smith E.F. 1985. Selection studies on anthelmintic resistant and susceptible populations of Trichostrongylus colubriformis of sheep. International Journal for Parasitology15: 669–676. A T. colubriformis population (BCK), formerly resistant to benzimidazole anthelmintics, but now highly resistant to levamisole after 6 years exposure to this drug alone in the field, was passed through 12 generations in the laboratory in three separate lines exposed either to selection with thiabendazole or levamisole, or to no selection. Another population (McM) not previously exposed to these anthelmintics was treated similarly in two lines, selected with thiabendazole or not selected.Selection with thiabendazole resulted in a return of benzimidazole resistance in the BCK line which occurred faster than in the McM line, but a similar level of resistance was reached in each by the twelfth generation. Resistance ratios in both selected lines compared with the unselected McM line were less than 20: 1, and only 1.5 times the recommended dose rate of thiabendazole was required to remove more than half of the resistant population. This suggests that a polygenic vigour tolerance rather than a specific resistance had been selected.In the case of levamisole resistance, the BCK population was found to contain two distinct subpopulations, one susceptible and the other highly resistant. Resistance ratios for the highly resistant subpopulation were greater than 4000: 1, implying a specific resistance controlled by a major gene. During the 12 generations of levamisole selection, the proportion of resistant phenotypes fluctuated about an average level of 70%, suggesting that susceptibility alleles were being maintained in the population through superior heterozygote fitness. This conclusion is supported by a significant decline in levamisole resistance in the absence of levamisole selection. Moreover, thiabendazole selection hastened the reversion to levamisole suceptibility.The results provide support for the reintroduction of a benzimidazole anthelmintic to control this helminth population, and for a slow rotation in the use of drugs with different modes of action.     

Influence of Soil Temperature on Meloidogyne incognita Resistant and Susceptible Cotton,Gossypium hirsutum

The degree of resistance by a cotton plant to Meloidogyne incognita is affected by soil temperature, particularly in moderately resistant cultivars, The total number of nematodes in the resistant and moderately resistant rools at 35 C was equal to, or greater than, the number in susceptible roots at 20, 25, or 30 C. A shift in numbers to developing and egg-bearing forms of nematodes in the susceptible cultivar as tentperature increased indicates development was affected by temperature rather than by genetic resistance mechanisms. However, the nematode resistant cultivar did not support maturation of nematodes until a soil tempurature of 35 C was attained. This indicated that resistance mechanisms are partially repressed at 35 C and differences in nematode development cannot be explained in terms of accumulated heat units. The moderately resistant cultivar was significantly more sensitive to the effects of high temperature than was the resistant cultivar.     

Effects of cholinergic drugs on longitudinal contraction in levamisole-susceptible and -resistant Haemonchus contortus.

A novel force transducer was used to measure the effects of cholinergic agonists on longitudinal contraction in Haemonchus contortus. Drugs were applied to whole worms or injected via a cannula in the pseudocoelomic cavity. A number of agonists, including nicotine and the anthelmintics m-aminolevamisole, levamisole and morantel, caused contractions in whole worms. Four- to 25-fold increases in concentration of the active compounds were required to cause contractions in each of two levamisole-resistant strains of H. contortus. Of the other compounds tested, bephenium had equivalent activity against susceptible and resistant strains. Anticholinesterase compounds caused contractions after a slight delay in susceptible, but not resistant worms. Numerous cholinergic agonists and other compounds did not cause contraction when applied to whole worms. One of these, acetylcholine, caused contractions in cannulated worms. Compared with the susceptible strain, five- to six-fold higher concentrations of acetylcholine were required to cause equivalent contractions in the resistant strains. Levamisole resistance in adult H. contortus is likely to be due to a change in the characteristics of the cholinergic receptor(s).