An Improved Immunostaining and Imaging Methodology to Determine Cell and Protein Distributions within the Bone Environment

Bone is a dynamic tissue that undergoes multiple changes throughout its lifetime. Its maintenance requires a tight regulation between the cells embedded within the bone matrix, and an imbalance among these cells may lead to bone diseases such as osteoporosis. Identifying cell populations and their proteins within bone is necessary for understanding bone biology. Immunolabeling is one approach used to visualize proteins in tissues. Efficient immunolabeling of bone samples often requires decalcification, which may lead to changes in the structural morphology of the bone. Recently, methyl-methacrylate embedding of non-decalcified tissue followed by heat-induced antigen retrieval has been used to process bone sections for immunolabeling. However, this technique is applicable for bone slices below 50-µm thickness while fixed on slides. Additionally, enhancing epitope exposure for immunolabeling is still a challenge. Moreover, imaging bone cells within the bone environment using standard confocal microscopy is difficult. Here we demonstrate for the first time an improved methodology for immunolabeling non-decalcified bone using a testicular hyaluronidase enzyme-based antigen retrieval technique followed by two-photon fluorescence laser microscopy (TPLM) imaging. This procedure allowed us to image key intracellular proteins in bone cells while preserving the structural morphology of the cells and the bone.     

Fixative-Dependent Increase in Immunogold Labeling following Antigen Retrieval on Acrylic and Epoxy Sections

We examined the increase in immunogold labeling of variably fixed, resin embedded tissue sections following antigen retrieval by heating in citrate solution. Fibrin clots and porcine renal tissue were fixed in glutaraldehyde, paraformaldehyde or ethanol, and specimens were embedded in LR-White or epoxy resin. Immunogold labeling was performed on ultra-thin sections with anti-fibrinogen for the fibrin clots and anti-IgG for the porcine renal tissue. Immunogold labeling increased greatly after heating epoxy sections regardless of the fixative used. The ratio labeling_retrieved/labeling_nonretrieved (L_r/L_n) was 2.8 or higher, and the largest increases were obtained for anti-IgG. Heating induced a large increase of immunolabeling for LR-White sections only when the specimens had been fixed in paraformaldehyde (L_r/L_n = 2.2 for anti-IgG and 1.4 for antifibrinogen). LR-White sections showed decreased, insignificant or weakly increased immunolabeling of ethanol or glutaraldehyde fixed tissues following antigen retrieval. Disruption of aldehyde cross-links is not the only mechanism for antigen retrieval when epoxy sections are heated in citrate solution since large increases in immunolabeling were obtained on ethanol fixed tissue. The large heat-induced increases in immunolabeling on epoxy sections are probably caused by the disruption of chemical bonds between the epoxy resin and side groups of proteins.     

Fixative-Dependent Increase in Immunogold Labeling following Antigen Retrieval on Acrylic and Epoxy Sections

We examined the increase in immunogold labeling of variably fixed, resin embedded tissue sections following antigen retrieval by heating in citrate solution. Fibrin clots and porcine renal tissue were fixed in glutaraldehyde, paraformaldehyde or ethanol, and specimens were embedded in LR-White or epoxy resin. Immunogold labeling was performed on ultra-thin sections with anti-fibrinogen for the fibrin clots and anti-IgG for the porcine renal tissue. Immunogold labeling increased greatly after heating epoxy sections regardless of the fixative used. The ratio labeling_retrieved/labeling_nonretrieved (L_r/L_n) was 2.8 or higher, and the largest increases were obtained for anti-IgG. Heating induced a large increase of immunolabeling for LR-White sections only when the specimens had been fixed in paraformaldehyde (L_r/L_n = 2.2 for anti-IgG and 1.4 for antifibrinogen). LR-White sections showed decreased, insignificant or weakly increased immunolabeling of ethanol or glutaraldehyde fixed tissues following antigen retrieval. Disruption of aldehyde cross-links is not the only mechanism for antigen retrieval when epoxy sections are heated in citrate solution since large increases in immunolabeling were obtained on ethanol fixed tissue. The large heat-induced increases in immunolabeling on epoxy sections are probably caused by the disruption of chemical bonds between the epoxy resin and side groups of proteins.     

An artificial test substrate for evaluating electron microscopic immunocytochemical labeling reactions

We describe an artificial substrate system for optimization of labeling parameters in electron microscope immunocytochemical studies. The system involves use of blocks of glutaraldehyde-polymerized BSA into which a desired antigen is incorporated by a simple soaking procedure. The resulting antigen-impregnated artificial substrate can then be fixed and embedded identically to a piece of tissue. The BSA substrate can also be dried and then sectioned for immunolabeling with or without chemical fixation and without exposing the antigen to dehydrating agents and embedding resins. The effects of various fixation and embedding procedures can thus be evaluated separately. Other parameters affecting immunocytochemical labeling, such as antibody and conjugate concentration, can also be evaluated. We used this system, along with immunogold labeling, to determine quantitatively the optimal fixation and embedding conditions for labeling of hepatitis B surface antigen (HbsAg), human IgG, and horseradish peroxidase. Using unfixed and unembedded HBsAg, we were able to detect antigen concentrations below 20 micrograms/ml. We have shown that it is not possible to label HBsAg within resin-embedded cells using conventional aldehyde fixation protocols and polyclonal antibodies.     

Phenotyping of protein-prion (PrPsc)-accumulating cells in lymphoid and neural tissues of naturally scrapie-affected sheep by double-labeling immunohistochemistry.

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are fatal neurodegenerative diseases characterized by amyloid deposition of protein-prion (PrPsc), the pathogenic isoform of the host cellular protein PrPc, in the immune and central nervous systems. In the absence of definitive data on the nature of the infectious agent, PrPsc immunohistochemistry (IHC) constitutes one of the main methodologies for pathogenesis studies of these diseases. In situ PrPsc immunolabeling requires formalin fixation and paraffin embedding of tissues, followed by post-embedding antigen retrieval steps such as formic acid and hydrated autoclaving treatments. These procedures result in poor cellular antigen preservation, precluding the phenotyping of cells involved in scrapie pathogenesis. Until now, PrPsc-positive cell phenotyping relied mainly on morphological criteria. To identify these cells under the PrPsc IHC conditions, a new, rapid, and highly sensitive PrPsc double-labeling technique was developed, using a panel of screened antibodies that allow specific labeling of most of the cell subsets and structures using paraffin-embedded lymphoid and neural tissues from sheep, leading to an accurate identification of ovine PrPsc-accumulating cells. This technique constitutes a useful tool for IHC investigation of scrapie pathogenesis and may be applicable to the study of other ovine infectious diseases.     

Immunoelectron microscopic labeling of immunoglobulin in plasma cells after osmium fixation and epoxy embedding

Previous studies have found that immunoglobulin cannot be immunolabeled in tissues prepared for electron microscopy by usual methods. To test this conclusion, we used a protein A-gold postembedding immunolabeling method on tissues that were fixed in glutaraldehyde, post-fixed in osmium tetroxide, and embedded in epoxy resin; sections were pretreated with sodium metaperiodate. A variety of common fixation protocols were also used and the most suitable conditions for immunolabeling were determined. This technique permitted the ultrastructural localization of immunoglobulin light chains in optimally preserved and contrasted plasma cells from human tonsil, lymph nodes, plasmacytomas, and a renal biopsy. We were able to demonstrate multiple antigens in the same tissue and label antigens in tissues that had been stored for many years in epoxy resin. The technique allows quantitation of the gold label over plasma cell organelles and therefore gives information about the immunoglobulin secretory pathway in these cells. We found that the protein A-gold procedure compares favorably in technical ease with the immunoperoxidase, avidin-biotin peroxidase, and immunoglobulin-colloidal gold immunolabeling methods, and has added advantages in allowing precise localization and quantitation of the labeled antigen.     

The enhanced reactivity of endogenous biotin-like molecules by antigen retrieval procedures and signal amplification with tyramine

In diagnostic pathology and immunocytochemical research, immunohistochemical techniques using the streptavidin–biotin–peroxidase system have played an extremely valuable role. This system, based on the high affinity of streptavidin for biotin, may, however, provoke false positive results because of endogenous streptavidin-binding sites in human tissues. With the advent of the antigen retrieval procedure and signal amplification method, this problem can be serious enough to cause mistakes in interpreting immunohistochemical staining results. Therefore, we examined the distribution of endogenous biotin-like molecules in various human tissues and the influence of various antigen retrieval procedures with or without signal amplification using biotinylated tyramine to reveal these biotin-like activities. We observed that endogenous biotin-like molecules were present in a wide range of tissues, and their activity was markedly enhanced by employing antigen retrieval procedures or signal amplification. Furthermore, the extent to which the activity of endogenous biotin-like activities was enhanced depended on the kinds of antigen retrieval procedures and signal amplification employed. Pressure cooking and tyramine amplification with microwave heating showed the highest activities. These results show that the antigen retrieval procedures and signal amplification with tyramine can enhance the activity of endogenous biotin or biotin-like molecules as well as antigenicity, which can be a pitfall in the interpretation of immunohistochemical data.     

Antigen retrieval in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues: an enhancement method for immunohistochemical staining based on microwave oven heating of tissue sections.

We describe a new approach for retrieval of antigens from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues and their subsequent staining by immunohistochemical techniques. This method of antigen retrieval is based on microwave heating of tissue sections attached to microscope slides to temperatures up to 100 degrees C in the presence of metal solutions. Among 52 monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies tested by this method, 39 antibodies demonstrated a significant increase in immunostaining, nine antibodies showed no change, and four antibodies showed reduced immunostaining. In particular, excellent immunostaining results were obtained with a monoclonal antibody to vimentin as well as several different keratin antibodies on routine formalin-fixed tissue sections after pre-treatment of the slides with this method. These results showed that after antigen retrieval: (a) enzyme predigestion of tissues could be omitted; (b) incubation times of primary antibodies could be significantly reduced, or dilutions of primary antibodies could be increased; (c) adequate staining could be achieved in long-term formalin-fixed tissues that failed to stain by conventional methods; and (d) certain antibodies which were typically unreactive with formalin-fixed tissues gave excellent staining.     

A technique for retrieving antigens in formalin-fixed, routinely acid-decalcified, celloidin-embedded human temporal bone sections for immunohistochemistry.

The application of immunohistochemistry to routinely decalcified, celloidin-embedded human temporal bone sections has been hampered because of antigen loss during processing of the specimens. To our knowledge, there has been no published report to date describing immunohistochemical staining of such tissues suitable for examination by light microscopy. Here we report a novel antigen retrieval technique which can be successfully used to stain a variety of antigens in routinely formalin-fixed, trichloroacetic acid-decalcified, celloidin-embedded human temporal bone sections. The new procedure reported here for decalcified human temporal bone tissues simply requires immersing slides for 30 min at room temperature in an antigen retrieval solution. A total of 60 decalcified, celloidin-embedded human temporal bone tissues were tested with monoclonal antibodies (MAb) to 15 different antigens. Of these, 12 MAb showed definite positive staining, while three were negative. This technique may prove very useful in studying the expression of various antigens by immunohistochemistry in formalin-fixed, acid-decalcified, celloidin-embedded tissues.     

MAP2 IHC detection: a marker of antigenicity in CNS tissues

Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is used to detect antibody-specific antigens in tissues; the results depend on the ability of the primary antibodies to bind to their antigens. Therefore, results depend on the quality of preservation of the specimen. Many investigators have overcome the deleterious effects of over-fixation on the binding of primary antibodies to specimen antigens using IHC, but if the specimen is under-fixed or fixation is delayed, false negative results could be obtained despite certified laboratory practices. Microtubule-associated protein 2 (MAP2) is an abundant microtubule-associate protein that participates in the outgrowth of neuronal processes and synaptic plasticity; it is localized primarily in cell bodies and dendrites of neurons. MAP2 immunolabeling has been reported to be absent in areas of the entorhinal cortex and hippocampus of Alzheimer’s disease brains that were co-localized with the dense-core type of amyloid plaques. It was hypothesized that the lack of MAP2 immunolabeling in these structures was due to the degradation of the MAP2 antigen by the neuronal proteases that were released as the neurons lysed leading to the formation of these plaques. Because MAP2 is sensitive to proteolysis, we hypothesized that changes in MAP2 immunolabeling may be correlated with the degree of fixation of central nervous system (CNS) tissues. We detected normal MAP2 immunolabeling in fixed rat brain tissues, but MAP2 immunolabeling was decreased or lost in unfixed and delayed-fixed rat brain tissues. By contrast, two ubiquitous CNS-specific markers, myelin basic protein and glial fibrillary acidic protein, were unaffected by the degree of fixation in the same tissues. Our observations suggest that preservation of various CNS-specific antigens differs with the degree of fixation and that the lack of MAP2 immunolabeling in the rat brain may indicate inadequate tissue fixation. We recommend applying MAP2 IHC for all CNS tissues as a pre-screen to assess the quality of the tissue preservation and to avoid potentially false negative IHC results.     

Some improvement in tissue preparation and colloidal-gold immunolabeling for electron microscopy

The application of freeze-substitution (FS) and freeze-drying (FD) techniques and the protein A-gold-antibody complex immunocytochemical methods are described. The two tissue-preparation techniques produced excellent ultrastructure and topographical fixation of antigens when compared with conventional tissue-preparation techniques. In the FS preparation, however, occasional extragranular immunolabeling was recognized. This may suggest the leakage of antigens from the secretory granules. The FD procedure was considered the best, since such labeling was almost negligible. The protein A-gold-antibody complexes are easily prepared and label the antigens clearly. If the protein A-coated gold particles are saturated with antibodies, there is no interaction between gold particles. Thus, multiple antigens can be determined even in single secretory granules. In fact, we demonstrated intragranular colocalization of immunoreactive oxytocin, labeled with 50-nm gold particles, and immunoreactive methionine-enkephalin, labeled with 15-nm gold particles, in the axonal terminals of the FD-prepared rat neurohypophysis. This study demonstrates the value of the use of gold-antibody complexes for immunocytochemical labeling on FS- or FD-treated tissues.     

Simultaneous and successive localization of two antigens in the same tissue section using 3,3'-diaminobenzidine and 1-naphthol basic dye

We describe two procedures for the simultaneous and successive localization of two antigens in the same tissue section. In the simultaneous staining procedure, the first antigen was localized using 3,3'-diaminobenzidine (DAB), while the second antigen was stained using the 1-naphthol basic dye (1-NBD) method. The colour of the second antigen depended on the basic dye used, and no mixing of colours was observed when the two antigens were localized in different cells or structures. However, sequential double staining proved to be more convenient for the demonstration of two antigens in the same cell. In this procedure, the first antigen was stained using 1-NBD, and the interesting microscopic fields were photographed. The basic dye was then completely removed, and the second antigen was stained using DAB.     

Application of antigen retrieval by heating for double-label fluorescent immunohistochemistry with identical species-derived primary antibodies.

Double-label fluorescent immunohistochemistry (IHC) is frequently used to identify cellular and subcellular co-localization of independent antigens. In general, primary antibodies for double labeling should be derived from independent species. However, such convenient pairs of antibodies are not always available. To overcome this problem, several methods for double labeling with primary antibodies from identical species have been proposed. Among them are methods using monovalent secondary antibodies, such as Fab fragments. Soluble immune complexes consisting of primary and monovalent secondary antibodies are first formed. After absorption of the excess secondary antibody with nonspecific immunoglobulin, the immune complexes are applied to sections. By this procedure, unwanted cross-reaction between false pairs of antibodies is avoidable. However, soluble immune complexes often show reduced or no immunoreactivity to antigens on sections. I noted that antigen retrieval (AR) of tissues by heating often but not always showed improved immunoreactivity for soluble immune complexes. Here I demonstrate the examination of conditions for this soluble immune complex method using AR-treated sections and show examples of double-label fluorescent IHC with identical species-derived primary antibodies.     

Streptavidin-based quantitative staining of intracellular antigens for flow cytometric analysis.

A streptavidin-biotin-based three-step immunolabeling protocol for quantitative staining of intracellular antigens for flow cytometric analysis was evaluated using simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen. The concentration as well as the quantity of antibody used required optimization. The optimum labeling conditions varied moderately with cell lines that express T antigen levels over a 40-50-fold range. The procedure resulted in specific fluorescence 2.4 times higher than that using a comparable two-step indirect immunofluorescence technique. The gain in resolution was shown to be greater when staining cells with lower antigen levels. In the analysis of background fluorescence, the principal components were, as for the two-step technique, autofluorescence and propidium spectral overlap. While streptavidin does add to the background, the increase is relatively small. Decreasing the propidium concentration from 50 micrograms/ml to 5 micrograms/ml was found to reduce significantly the level of background from this source. Theoretical aspects of quantitative staining and of resolution versus quantification are discussed.     

Quantitative aspects of immunogold labeling in embedded and in nonembedded sections

We tried to control immunolabeling conditions so that information about antigen concentration could be achieved by quantifying labeling patterns. Working with immunogold labeling procedures in ultrathin cryosections, we observed that differential penetration of immunoreagents causes considerable differences in labeling efficiency between various cell structures. Therefore, in these nonembedded sections, labeling densities can only be used to measure variations in antigen concentration within one cell structure. After embedding the tissue in 30% polyacrylamide (PAA), differences in penetration were negated. The equalizing effect of PAA on the labeling efficiency enabled us to design a simple immunocytochemical method by which concentrations of a protein can be measured in situ at subcellular levels, provided that no variations in the protein's structural conformation occur that would affect its immunoreactivity. In spite of a higher sensitivity observed for Ig-gold, we preferred to use protein A-gold in our system because of the low nonspecific labeling and the more precise antigen detection by the latter immunomarker.     

Post-embedding double-labeling of antigen-retrieved ultrathin sections using a silver enhancement-controlled sequential immunogold (SECSI) technique.

In electron microscopy, the post-embedding immunogold technique provides a high degree of resolution and the possibility of quantitation owing to the intrinsic characteristics of the colloidal gold marker. Application of this technique to the subcellular localization of multiple antigens by differential labeling using gold markers of different sizes, or to double labeling using the same primary antibody isotype with serial silver enhancement, has been reported. We have incorporated this double labeling technique into a modified procedure that produces excellent labeling and ultrastructural preservation, even after exposure of ultrathin sections large enough to cover a 300- micro m-diameter single-hole grid to hot antigen retrieval solutions and prolonged labeling protocols.     

Evaluation of Antigen Retrieval Buffer Systems

The introduction of antigen retrieval (AR) techniques has dramatically improved the sensitivity of immunohistochemical detection of various antigens in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues. The microwave-heating and pressure-cooking procedures are the most effective AR methods reported to date. Although extensive efforts have been made to optimize AR procedures using these two methods, previous studies have not led to a standard protocol applicable to all antibodies derived from different clones. In this study we have investigated the optimal AR buffer conditions for 29 antibodies that are in common use for diagnostic purposes in hospitals worldwide. Borate (pH 8.0) and Tris buffer (pH 9.5) yielded the highest retrieved antigen immunoreactivity against most antibodies as compared to other buffers tested. In addition, the microwave pressure-cooking gave better results than microwave-heating alone. Therefore, borate (pH 8.0) or Tris (pH 9.5) buffer used in conjunction with the pressure-cooking procedure is strongly recommended for standard routine use.     

Neuronal developmental marker FORSE-1 identifies a putative progenitor of the pulmonary neuroendocrine cell lineage during lung development.

The FORSE-1 (forebrain-surface-embryonic) monoclonal antibody (MAb) recognizes a carbohydrate cell surface epitope related to the Lewis-X (LeX) and stage-specific embryonic antigens (SSEAs). In the developing CNS, the FORSE-1 epitope is believed to serve as a marker of progenitor cells. We studied the expression of the FORSE-1 epitope in pulmonary neuroendocrine cells (PNECs) and related neuroepithelial bodies (NEBs), cell types implicated in paracrine regulation of lung development. We used dual immunolabeling to identify PNECs/NEBs in tissue sections from developing rabbit fetal lungs and corresponding primary lung cell cultures. During the early stage (E16), the FORSE-1 MAb labeled primitive airway epithelium, whereas serotonin (5HT) immunoreactivity, a marker of PNEC/NEB differentiation, was negative. After E18, FORSE-1 labeling became restricted to PNECs and NEBs, identified by co-expression with 5HT, then decreased coincident with an increase in 5HT. Expression of the FORSE-1 epitope correlated inversely with 5HT expression in PNEC/NEB cells. FORSE-1 immunoreactivity correlated with cell proliferation assessed by BrdU labeling. Downregulation of the FORSE-1 epitope correlated with maturation of PNECs/NEBs. The presence of few FORSE-1/5HT-positive cells in postnatal lung suggests retention of progenitors. The FORSE-1 epitope was associated with a high molecular weight (286 kD) glycoprotein that decreased with increasing gestational age, as demonstrated by immunoblotting. Overall expression of SSEA-1, -3, and -4 antigens was similar to FORSE-1/5HT, although the former was preferentially localized to neurite-like processes. Because the role of the FORSE-1 epitope in the CNS probably involves cell adhesion and differentiation, we propose a similar function in developing lung. The demonstration of LeX/SSEA antigen expression in the PNEC/NEB cell lineage underscores the importance of these cells in developing lung. Furthermore, the FORSE-1 antigen may identify committed progenitors of the PNEC/NEB cell system.     

Antibodies for immunolabeling by light and electron microscopy: not for the faint hearted

Reliable antibodies represent crucial tools in the arsenal of the cell biologist and using them to localize antigens for immunocytochemistry is one of their most important applications. However, antibody–antigen interactions are much more complex and unpredictable than suggested by the old ‘lock and key’ analogy, and the goal of trying to prove that an antibody is specific is far more difficult than is generally appreciated. Here, we discuss the problems associated with the very complicated issue of trying to establish that an antibody (and the results obtained with it) is specific for the immunolabeling approaches used in light or electron microscopy. We discuss the increasing awareness that significant numbers of commercial antibodies are often not up to the quality required. We provide guidelines for choosing and testing antibodies in immuno-EM. Finally, we describe how quantitative EM methods can be used to identify reproducible patterns of antibody labeling and also extract specific labeling distributions.