Nanotubules on plant surfaces: chemical composition of epicuticular wax crystals on needles of Taxus baccata L

Needles of Taxus baccata L. were covered with tubular epicuticular wax crystals varying in diameters (100 and 250 nm) and lengths (300-500 and 500-1000 nm) on the abaxial and adaxial surfaces, respectively. Various sampling protocols were employed to study the chemical composition of the needle waxes on three different levels of spatial resolution. First, a dipping extraction of whole needles yielded the total cuticular wax mixture consisting of very long chain fatty acids (21%), alkanediols (19%), phenyl esters (15%), and secondary alcohols (9%) together with small amounts of aldehydes, primary alcohols, alkanes, alkyl esters, and tocopherols. Second, waxes from both sides of the needle were sampled separately by brushing with CHCl3-soaked fabric glass. Both sides showed very similar qualitative composition, but differed drastically in quantitative aspects, with nonacosan-10-ol (18%) and alkanediols (33%) dominating the abaxial and adaxial waxes, respectively. Third, the epi- and intracuticular wax layers were selectively sampled by a combination of mechanical wax removal and brushing extraction. This provided direct evidence that the tubular wax crystals contained high percentages of nonacosane-4,10-diol and nonacosane-5,10-diol on the abaxial surface, and nonacosan-10-ol on the adaxial surface of the needles. Together with these compounds, relatively large amounts of fatty acids and smaller percentages of aldehydes, primary alcohols, alkyl esters, and alkanes co-crystallized in the epicuticular layer. In comparison, the intracuticular wax consisted of higher portions of cyclic constituents and aliphatics with relatively high polarity. The formation of the tubular crystals is discussed as a spontaneous physico-chemical process, involving the establishment of gradients between the epi- and intracuticular wax layers and local phase separation.     

In vitro Reconstitution of Epicuticular Wax Crystals: Formation of Tubular Aggregates by Long-Chain Secondary Alkanediols

Cuticles of several plant species are covered by tubular wax aggregates that are known to consist mainly of (S)-nonacosan-10-ol. The present work addresses the question whether minor wax components may additionally contribute to these tubules. Thin layer chromatography was used to prepare secondary alkanediol fractions from leaf cuticular waxes of Nelumbo nucifera and Thalictrum flavum, containing nonacosane-3,10-diol, nonacosane-4,10-diol, nonacosane-5,10-diol, nonacosane-7,10-diol, nonacosane-9,10-diol and nonacosane-10,13-diol. From organic solutions all these compounds crystallized in tubular shapes. Possible crystal structures of relevant alkanediol isomers are proposed, in analogy to the lattice geometries of comparable aliphatic compounds. The resulting structural model shows that nonacosan-10-ol and various secondary alkanediols may join in metastable mixed crystals. According to the structural model proposed the admixture of alkanediols to nonacosan-10-ol aggregates should enhance the stability of their tubular habit.     

Structural analysis of wheat wax (Triticum aestivum, c.v. ‘Naturastar’ L.): from the molecular level to three dimensional crystals

In order to elucidate the self assembly process of plant epicuticular waxes, and the molecular arrangement within the crystals, re-crystallisation of wax platelets was studied on biological and non-biological surfaces. Wax platelets were extracted from the leaf blades of wheat (Triticum aestivum L., c.v. ‘Naturastar’, Poaceae). Waxes were analysed by gas chromatography (GC) and mass spectrometry (MS). Octacosan-1-ol was found to be the most abundant chemical component of the wax mixture (66 m%) and also the determining compound for the shape of the wax platelets. The electron diffraction pattern showed that both the wax mixture and pure octacosan-1-ol are crystalline. The re-crystallisation of the natural wax mixture and the pure octacosan-1-ol were studied by scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Crystallisation of wheat waxes and pure octacosano-1-ol on the non polar highly ordered pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) led to the formation of platelet structures similar to those found on the plant surface. In contrast, irregular wax morphologies and flat lying plates were formed on glass, silicon, salt crystals (NaCl) and mica surfaces. Movement of wheat wax through isolated Convallaria majalis cuticles led to typical wax platelets of wheat, arranged in the complex patterns typical for C. majalis. STM of pure octacosan-1-ol monolayers on HOPG showed that the arrangement of the molecules strictly followed the hexagonal structure of the substrate crystal. Re-crystallisation of wheat waxes on non-polar crystalline HOPG substrate showed that technical surfaces could be used to generate microstructured, biomimetic surfaces. AFM and SEM studies proved that a template effect of the substrate determined the orientation of the re-grown crystals. These effects of the structure and polarity of the substrate on the morphology of the epicuticular waxes are relevant for understanding interactions between biological as well as technical surfaces and waxes.     

Ultrastructure and chemistry of Clarkia elegans leaf wax: A comparative study with brassica leaf waxes

The effect of environmental conditions on the chemistry and morphology of Clarkia elegans leaf wax has been examined using gas liquid chromatography and scanning electron microscopy. Chemically the wax consists of a mixture of hydrocarbons, ketones, alkyl esters, aldehydes, primary alcohols and secondary alcohols of which nonacosane, nonacosan-15-one, hexacosyl hexadecanoate and tetracosyl hexadecanoate are the major co wax occurs in the form of smooth films, tubes, dendrites or plates depending upon the growth temperature. A comparison is drawn with the leaf waxes of Brassica species and the findings discussed in relation to the development of epicuticular wax layers.     

Epicuticular crystals of nonacosan-10-ol: In-vitro reconstitution and factors influencing crystal habits

The primary aerial surfaces of plant species from many families (e.g. Pinaceae, Liliaceae, Ranunculaceae, Papaveraceae) are covered by epicuticular tubules 5–20 μm long and 0.5 μn in diameter. The composition, mechanism of growth and molecular structure of this type of epicuticular aggregates have been studied. Pure nonacosan-10-ol extracted from Picea pungens needle surfaces formed, in vitro, tubular crystals like those occurring in vivo. This crystal habit was obtained irrespective of the type of solvent or substratum, if the solvent was evaporated within minutes. This shows that tubules of nonacosan-10-ol are formed in the kinetic regime of crystallization (limited by the diffusion of molecules from the solution to the crystal surface). Slow evaporation of the solvent or crystallization from the melt resulted in rhombic scales. These planar crystals represent the thermodynamic, stable modification of native nonacosan-10-ol. Homologous impurities in natural nonacosan-10-ol (3–14%) had no effect on the formation of the tubules. However, racemic nonacosan-10-ol invariably crystallized in scales. The phase behaviour of mixtures of natural nonacosan-10-ol and its synthetic racemate as well as synthetic (S)-nonacosan-10-ol provided evidence for the presence of the pure (S)-enantiomer on plant surfaces. The findings are discussed in terms of the mechanisms leading to epicuticular tubules consisting of nonacosan-10-ol and their molecular structure. Crystal structures for the pure enantiomer and the racemate of nonacosan-10-ol are proposed. It is concluded that the principles responsible for the formation of tubules are both the special molecular geometry of the naturally occurring (S)-nonacosan-10-ol and the mobility barrier of the plant cuticle. Further specific biological processes are not necessary for the formation of (S)-nonacosan-10-ol tubules. The alterations of epicuticular structures during ageing or the impact of pollutants are explained as spontaneous transitions between two crystal modifications of (S)-nonacosan-10-ol.     

Elusive but not hypothetical: axillary meristems in Wollemia nobilis

BACKGROUND: The branches of Wollemia nobilis are unbranched; however, it has been noted that new branches can form from the distal end of damaged ones, and branches can grow from axillary structures once a terminal strobilus has fallen. Tomlinson and Huggett (2011, Annals of Botany 107: 909-916) have recently investigated the formation of these reiterative branches and stated in the title of their paper that 'Partial shoot reiteration in Wollemia nobilis (Araucariaceae) does not arise from "axillary meristems"'. They go on to state 'Further research may reveal the presence of these elusive, but still only hypothetical, axillary meristems'. RESPONSE: In this Viewpoint, I argue that Tomlinson and Huggett do not refer to previously published information that indicates that axillary meristems are present in Wollemia nobilis branch leaf axils, and that their anatomical methods were probably not optimal for locating and examining these minute structures. Thus, whilst I would agree that the axillary meristems in branch leaf axils of Wollemia nobilis are elusive, I contend that they are not hypothetical.     

FTIR spectroscopy of synthesized racemic nonacosan-10-ol: a model compound for plant epicuticular waxes

As there are no published graphically presented, detailed IR spectra of nonacosan-10-ol (occurring naturally and widely in plant epicuticular waxes of nanotube form), near IR FTIR spectroscopy (fundamentals, overtones and combinations) has been performed on laboratory synthesized racemic nonacosan-10-ol, as a crystalline solid on Mylar and polypropylene substrates. Room temperature, in vacuo data are presented graphically, in full, and show evidence of extensive hydrogen bonding, an orthorhombic perpendicular subcell, a methylene wagging progression, diagnostic of all-trans conformational order, and Fermi resonance. Moderate or stronger anharmonicity is confirmed. Detailed discussion, quantitative in parts, is given of the observed spectral features, especially as to how they inform crystal structure and molecular conformation, and assignments given for some of the features. The results will serve as a reference for future IR studies of the natural epicuticular wax nanotube form of (S)-nonacosan-10-ol.     

Chemical composition of the epicuticular and intracuticular wax layers on the adaxial side of Ligustrum vulgare leaves

Previous research has shown that cuticular triterpenoids are exclusively found in the intracuticular wax layer of Prunus laurocerasus. To investigate whether this partitioning was species-specific, the intra- and epicuticular waxes were identified and quantified for the glossy leaves of Ligustrum vulgare, an unrelated shrub with similar wax morphology. Epicuticular wax was mechanically stripped from the adaxial leaf surface using the adhesive gum arabic. Subsequently, the organic solvent chloroform was used to extract the intracuticular wax from within the cutin matrix. The isolated waxes were quantified using gas chromatography with flame ionization detection and identified by mass spectrometry. The results were visually confirmed by scanning electron microscopy. The outer wax layer consisted entirely of homologous series of very-long-chain aliphatic compound classes. By contrast, the inner wax layer was dominated (80%) by two cyclic triterpenoids, ursolic and oleanolic acid. The accumulation of triterpenoids in the intracuticular leaf wax of a second, unrelated species suggests that this localization may be a more general phenomenon in smooth cuticles lacking epicuticular wax crystals. The mechanism and possible ecological or physiological reasons for this separation are currently being investigated.     

Studies on the structure of the plant wax nonacosan-10-ol, the main component of epicuticular wax conifers

The main component presents in the epicuticular waxes of needles of Pinus halepensis and the most of conifers, the secondary alcohol nonacosan-10-ol, has been investigated by X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry. The results obtained from these physical techniques permitted to establish a definitive structural model of the molecular arrangement of this wax, basically in good agreement with the model formulated by other authors from theoretical formulations. Biological implications of the proposed structure have been also formulated.     

The impact of epicuticular wax on gas-exchange and photoinhibition in Leucadendron lanigerum (Proteaceae)

This study investigated the seasonal modification of wax deposition, and the impact of epicuticular wax on gas-exchange as well as photoinhibition in Leucadendron lanigerum, a species from the Proteaceae family with wax-covered leaf surfaces and the stomata also partially occluded by wax. The results of this study demonstrated that the deposition of epicuticular wax in L. lanigerum is dependent on the age of the leaf as well as the season, and generation and regeneration of wax occur mostly in spring while transformation and also degeneration of wax crystals occur in winter. Epicuticular waxes decreased cuticular water loss, but had little impact on leaf reflectance. The temperature of leaves without wax was lower than that of wax-covered leaves, indicating that the rate of transpiration impacted more on leaf temperature than reflectance of light in the PAR range in L. lanigerum. The wax coverage at the entrance of stomata in L. lanigerum increased resistance to gas diffusion and as a consequence decreased stomatal conductance, transpiration and photosynthesis. Also, the results indicated that epicuticular waxes do help prevent photodamage in L. lanigerum, and so this property could benefit plants living in arid environments with high solar radiation.     

Movement and regeneration of epicuticular waxes through plant cuticles

Regeneration of plant epicuticular waxes was studied in 24 plant species by high-resolution scanning electron microscopy. According to their regeneration behaviour, four groups could be distinguished: (i) regeneration occurs at all stages of development; (ii) regeneration occurs only during leaf expansion; (iii) regeneration occurs only in fully developed leaves; (iv) plants were not able to regenerate wax. Wax was removed from the leaves with water-based glue and a liquid polymer, i.e. water-based polyurethane dispersion. In young leaves these coverings could not be removed without damaging the leaves. After a few days, waxes appeared on the surface of these polymer films, which still adhered to the leaves. It is concluded that waxes move through the cuticle in a process similar to steam distillation. This hypothesis could be further substantiated in refined in vitro experiments. Wax isolated from Eucalyptus globulus was applied to a filter paper, subsequently covered with a liquid polymer and fixed onto a diffusion chamber filled with water. The diffusion chamber was put into a desiccator. After 8-10 days at room temperature, crystals similar in dimensions and shape to in situ crystals appeared on the surface of the polyurethane film. This indicates that waxes in molecular dimensions move together with the water vapor that permeates through the polymer membrane. Based on these results, we propose a new and simple hypothesis for the mechanism of wax movement: the molecules that finally form the epicuticular wax crystals are moved in the cuticular water current.     

What do microbes encounter at the plant surface? Chemical composition of pea leaf cuticular waxes

In the cuticular wax mixtures from leaves of pea (Pisum sativum) cv Avanta, cv Lincoln, and cv Maiperle, more than 70 individual compounds were identified. The adaxial wax was characterized by very high amounts of primary alcohols (71%), while the abaxial wax consisted mainly of alkanes (73%). An aqueous adhesive of gum arabic was employed to selectively sample the epicuticular wax layer on pea leaves and hence to analyze the composition of epicuticular crystals exposed at the outermost surface of leaves. The epicuticular layer was found to contain 74% and 83% of the total wax on adaxial and abaxial surfaces, respectively. The platelet-shaped crystals on the adaxial leaf surface consisted of a mixture dominated by hexacosanol, accompanied by substantial amounts of octacosanol and hentriacontane. In contrast, the ribbon-shaped wax crystals on the abaxial surface consisted mainly of hentriacontane (63%), with approximately 5% each of hexacosanol and octacosanol being present. Based on this detailed chemical analysis of the wax exposed at the leaf surface, their importance for early events in the interaction with host-specific pathogenic fungi can now be evaluated. On adaxial surfaces, approximately 80% of Erysiphe pisi spores germinated and 70% differentiated appressoria. In contrast, significantly lower germination efficiencies (57%) and appressoria formation rates (49%) were found for abaxial surfaces. In conclusion, the influence of the physical structure and the chemical composition of the host surface, and especially of epicuticular leaf waxes, on the prepenetration processes of biotrophic fungi is discussed.     

Epidermal conductance in different parts of durum wheat grown under Mediterranean conditions: the role of epicuticular waxes and stomata

Abstract. Epidermal (non-stomatally-controlled) conductance from the fourth leaf, first node leaf, flag leaf and ear of durum wheat (Triticum turgidum var durum L.) grown under Mediterranean field conditions has been measured, along with leaf stomatal frequency and the amount and distribution of epicuticular waxes. Measurements were carried out on varieties and land-races from the Middle East, North Africa, ‘Institut National de la Recherche Agricole’ (INRA) and ‘Centra Internacional de Mejora de Maiz y Trigo’ (CIMMYT). Significant differences were observed among genotypes in the epidermal conductances (g_e) of the four organs. For each of the four organs tested, genotypes from the Middle East and CIMMYT showed higher g_e. values than those from North Africa and INRA. Ears showed epidermal conductances that were more than four times higher than those of leaves when g_e. values were expressed per unit dry weight. The amount of epicuticular waxes was higher in the fourth leaves, intermediate in the first node and flag leaves and lower in the ears. For each organ, g_e differences among genotypes were unrelated with the amount of epicuticular waxes. Removal of epicuticular waxes by dipping the organs into chloroform significantly increased the epidermal conductance for the fourth and first node leaves and the ear. However, this did not occur for the flag leaf. For the fourth leaf, g_e of intact leaves and g_e of leaves in which epicuticular waxes were removed were unrelated (r = -0.265). The regression coefficient of this relation for the first node and flag leaves showed values of 0.666 and 0.650 (P > 0.05), respectively, and values were even higher in the ear (r > m 0.892, P > 0.01). Scanning electron microscope analysis showed that wax bloom decreased from the fourth leaf to the flag leaf, whereas the extent of amorphous wax increased. Wax bloom in leaves consisted mainly of deposits of thin wax plates. In the ears and the adaxial surface of flag leaves, fibrillar waxes predominated. In the first node and flag leaves, the wax deposits on the adaxial side cover the surface of the leaf more densely and uniformly than those on the abaxial side. There was no significant correlation between g_e and total stomatal density, or between g_e and either adaxial or abaxial stomatal density for any sample of the three different leaves. The contribution of epicuticular waxes plus total stomatal frequency only explained 42.4, 11.8, 28.3 and 16% of g_e (per unit leaf area) variations for the fourth leaf, first node leaf, flag leaf and the combined variation of the three leaves together, respectively. From these results, it is concluded that complex interrelationship between different morphophysiological characteristics probably control g_e differences among genotypes and that these interrelationships differ for each different plant part.     

Epicuticular wax structures on stems and comparison between stems and leaves – A survey

The cuticle, forming the outermost layer of plant tissues and being in direct contact with the environment, consists of waxes and cutin. Waxes are hydrophobic substances that are divided in two groups: intra- and epicuticular, depending on their localisation. Epicuticular waxes appear as smooth coverings, however, many plants also produce superimposed wax structures of a crystalline nature. While studies of waxes have almost exclusively focused on leaves, here a survey of epicuticular wax structures on stems is presented. The stem surface of 343 higher plant taxa, representing 80 families, was examined using scanning electron microscopy. The adaxial and abaxial surfaces of leaves of 319 taxa were also examined to determine the relationship between wax structures on stems and leaves. Wax structures are classified, described and discussed. The results of the study indicate that stems exhibit the same main wax crystal types that have been described for leaves. Seventy percent of the examined taxa produced wax crystals on their stems. In ∼24% of the taxa, wax crystals were absent on leaves and found only on stems. In plant taxa that produce wax crystals, 40% exhibit the same type on either side of their leaves and on their stem. However, a much stronger morphological similarity exists between crystal shapes present on the adaxial and abaxial surfaces of leaves than between those present on the stem and those on leaves. In general, these observations suggest that stems are quite different than leaves in terms of their epicuticular wax structures.     

Mutants in Arabidopsis thaliana Altered in Epicuticular Wax and Leaf Morphology

We report eight new mutants in Arabidopsis thaliana possessing altered leaf morphology and epicuticular wax. These were isolated from a T-DNA-mutagenized population using a visual screen for altered leaf reflectance, i.e. increased glaucousness or glossiness. The mutants were placed into three distinct classes based on alterations in overall plant morphology: knobhead (knb), bicentifolia (bcf), and wax. The four knb mutants formed callus-like growths in the axillary region of the rosette leaves and apical meristem, the two bcf mutants produced hundreds of narrow leaves, and the two wax mutants had leaves and stems that were more glossy than wild type and organs that fused during early development. Leaves of knb and bcf were more glaucous and abnormally shaped than wild type. Epicuticular wax crystals over knb and bcf leaf surfaces (where none were present on wild type) likely contributed to their more glaucous appearance. In contrast, the glossy appearance of the wax mutants was associated with a reduced epicuticular wax load on both leaves and stems. One representative from each phenotypic class was selected for detailed analyses of epicuticular wax chemistry. All three lines, knb1, bcf1, and wax1, had dramatic alterations in the total amounts and relative proportions of their leaf epicuticular wax constituents.     

Ontogenetic variation in chemical and physical characteristics of adaxial apple leaf surfaces

The reaction of plants to environmental factors often varies with developmental stage. It was hypothesized, that also the cuticle, the outer surface layer of plants is modified during ontogenesis. Apple plantlets, cv. Golden Delicious, were grown under controlled conditions avoiding biotic and abiotic stress factors. The cuticular wax surface of adaxial apple leaves was analyzed for its chemical composition as well as for its micromorphology and hydrophobicity just after unfolding of leaves ending in the seventh leaf insertion. The outer surface of apple leaves was formed by a thin amorphous layer of epicuticular waxes. Epidermal cells of young leaves exhibited a distinctive curvature of the periclinal cell walls resulting in an undulated surface of the cuticle including pronounced lamellae, with the highest density at the centre of cells. As epidermal cells expanded during ontogenesis, the upper surface showed only minor surface sculpturing and a decrease in lamellae. With increasing leaf age the hydrophobicity of adaxial leaf side decreased significantly indicated by a decrease in contact angle. Extracted from plants, the amount of apolar cuticular wax per area unit ranged from only 0.9 microgcm(-2) for the oldest studied leaf to 1.5 microgcm(-2) for the youngest studied leaf. Differences in the total amount of cuticular waxes per leaf were not significant for older leaves. For young leaves, triterpenes (ursolic acid and oleanolic acid), esters and alcohols were the main wax components. During ontogenesis, the proportion of triterpenes in total mass of apolar waxes decreased from 32% (leaf 1) to 13% (leaf 7); absolute amounts decreased by more than 50%. The proportion of wax alcohols and esters, and alkanes to a lesser degree, increased with leaf age, whereas the proportion of acids decreased. The epicuticular wax layer also contained alpha-tocopherol described for the first time to be present also in the epicuticular wax. The modifications in the chemical composition of cuticular waxes are discussed in relation to the varying physical characteristics of the cuticle during ontogenesis of apple leaves.     

EFFECTS OF FERTILIZATION ON EPICUTICULAR WAX MORPHOLOGY OF NEEDLE LEAVES OF DOUGLAS FIR,PSEUDOTSUGA MENZIESII (PINACEAE)

Fertilized stands of Pseudotsuga menziesii were found to have glaucous needles. We investigated the morphological and quantitative characteristics of the epicuticular waxes of needles of fertilized and control trees. Glaucousness was caused by ornate tubular epicuticular wax. Dipping needles in chloroform, which dissolves waxes, eliminated the glaucous appearance. Based on cryostage scanning electron microscopic observations, the epicuticular waxes in the nonstomatal region were much more ornate on the needles of the fertilized trees (experimental needles) than in unfertilized trees (control needles). The stomatal region in both experimental and control needles showed similarly ornate waxes. Quantities of waxes were similar in experimental and control needles. The glaucousness was not the result of greater quantities of wax; rather, fertilization altered wax morphology in the nonstomatal regions.     

Effect of alterations in cuticular wax biosynthesis on the physicochemical properties and topography of maize leaf surfaces

The leaf surface properties of 11 cuticular wax mutants of maize were characterized, and this information was used to identify the quantitative relations among distinct leaf surface traits. Compared with the wild‐type maize, these mutants were reduced 3–24% in their leaf surface hydrophobicity, 20–88% in the mass of cuticular waxes on their leaves, and 52–94% in the percentage of planar leaf surface area covered with epicuticular crystalline waxes. They also differed in the presence and abundance of the epicuticular crystalline waxes in each of seven structural classes. With the exception of one mutant, the mass of cuticular waxes produced by these mutants was positively correlated with the number of epicuticular crystalline waxes per unit area on their leaves. Furthermore, an increase of 0·4 mg of cuticular wax per gram of leaf (dry weight) was associated with a 1% increase in leaf surface area covered by epicuticular crystalline waxes, and this 1% increase was associated with a 2° increase in the contact angle of a water droplet on the leaf surface. Linear differences in the leaf surface hydrophobicity were associated with exponential differences in the mass of the cuticular waxes produced. Quantitative knowledge of these leaf surface properties is highly relevant to the interactions of leaves with environmental factors such as microbes, insects, agricultural chemicals, and pollutants.     

590. WOLLEMIA NOBILIS

Summary.  Wollemia nobilis W.G. Jones, K.D. Hill & J.M. Allen, ( Araucariaceae ) was recently discovered in Australia. The male and female strobili and a typical shoot are illustrated, and photographs of the trees in habitat are shown.     

甘蓝型油菜叶表皮蜡质组分及结构与菌核病抗性关系

本试验选用6个抗病性不同的甘蓝型油莱品种,研究其叶表皮蜡质组成及结构与菌核病抗性的关系。结果表明,抗病品种在去除叶表皮蜡质后病情指数显著增加;感病品种无显著变化。不同抗性品种（系）间除酯类组分含量无显著差异外,其余蜡质组分含量差异显著。相关分析表明,蜡质组分中酯类含量与病情指数呈显著负相关关系,醇类、酮类含量与病情指数呈显著正相关,其余组分和蜡质总量与病情指数无显著相关关系。抗性品种叶表皮蜡质中烷类及酯类所占比重较高,而易感品种酮类比重较高。扫描电镜结果显示,抗病品种（系）的蜡质晶体主要为颗粒状、杆状、丝状;而感病品种（系）的蜡质晶体中不规则片状晶体所占比例较大。这些结果说明油菜叶表皮蜡质的组分及结构可能是抗病品种抵抗和延迟病原菌侵入的机制之一。