The chick's marginal zone and primitive streak formation. II. Quantification of the marginal zone's potencies--temporal and spatial aspects

When a posterior fragment of the chick's marginal zone (PM) was exchanged with equal sized lateral marginal zone fragment (LM), of the same blastoderm, its capacity to initiate an ectopic primitive streak (PS) was found to be both size and stage dependent. Good correlation was demonstrated between the areas of PM fragments and the number of cells they contained. In stage X blastoderms, PM fragments containing less than 1200 cells were incapable of initiating an ectopic PS. Transplanted PMs containing between 1200 and 1500 cells initiated a lateral ectopic PS in 50% of the cases, while in the other 50% a posterior PS developed from the original posterior side. PMs containing 1500 cells or more in all cases initiating an ectopic PS and inhibited the formation of a posterior PS. At stage XI, laterally transplanted PMs containing less than 1800 cells were not effective. Stage XI PMs containing 1800-2300 cells in some cases succeeded in initiating a lateral ectopic PS, in addition to the posterior one. Stage XI PMs containing 2300 cells or more invariably promoted the development of an ectopic PS, but were unable to suppress the formation of a posterior PS, so that two PSs developed in the same blastoderm, one posterior and one ectopic. When a stage XI PM fragment was laterally transplanted into a younger, stage X blastoderm, the minimal effective cell number needed to initiate an ectopic PS increased to at least 3000 cells, again without inhibiting the formation of a posterior PS. The inductive potential of a stage X PM is therefore at least twice that of a stage XI PM. The marginal zone belt of stage X blastoderms was checked for the decrease in its developmental potential from the posterior to the lateral side by evaluating its effect on the developmental expression of two competing stage X PMs, one located posteriorly and the other inserted laterally. The developmental expression of the laterally inserted PM was consistently inferior to that of the posterior PM. The developmental expression of each PM was not related to absolute size, but depended on the size ratio of lateral PM/posterior PM. When the ratio was 1.2 or less, only posterior PSs developed. When the ratio was 1.3-1.4, three different results were encountered: (1) only a posterior PS, (2) posterior plus lateral, and (3) only lateral PS. When the ratio was 1.5 or more, only a lateral PS developed, which suppressed the posterior PS.     

The chick's marginal zone and primitive streak formation. I. Coordinative effect of induction and inhibition

A variety of transplantation experiments of posterior and lateral marginal zone fragments at stages X, XI, and XII have been carried out in order to test their relevance to the development of a primitive streak (PS). At the stages studied the marginal zone (MZ) was shown to behave as a ring-like gradient field, the maximal value of which was at the posterior end (PM). The PM was found to be capable at the same time of promoting the development of a PS and of suppressing the inductive potential of other regions of the MZ. By systematically evaluating inductive and suppressive capacities of PMs, at different developmental stages, it was found that both features are maximal at stage X. During stages XI and XII, both properties gradually decrease in the MZ and build up in the forming hypoblast.     

States of determination of single cells transplanted between 512-cell Xenopus embryos

Single cells from 512-cell Xenopus embryos, totally labeled with intracellular horseradish peroxidase, were transplanted orthotopically (from either dorsal or lateral marginal zone) or heterotopically (between these two marginal zones) to unlabeled host embryos at the 512-cell stage. At tailbud stage 23 the locations, numbers, and histotypes of labeled cells were recorded. The transplanted cell had divided many times, giving rise to labeled progeny that expressed a wide range of cell types and were located in several different organs. Locations and cell types of progeny derived from orthotopic grafts to the dorsal marginal zone were different from those derived from grafts to the lateral marginal zone. Single cells grafted heterotopically to either dorsal or lateral positions expressed fates that were appropriate to their final grafted positions, and not to their original positions. We conclude that individual cells of the marginal zone at the 512-cell stage have multiple presumptive fates and have not been committed to any single fate.     

Two essential processes in the formation of a dorsal axis during gastrulation ofCynops embryo

The isolated upper marginal zone from the initial stage ofCynops gastrulation is not yet determined to form the dorsal axis mesoderm: notochord and muscle. In this experiment, we will indicate where the dorsal mesoderm-inducing activity is localized in the very early gastrula, and what is an important event for specification of the dorsal axis mesoderm during gastrulation. Recombination experiments showed that dorsal mesoderm-inducing activity was localized definitively in the endodermal epithelium (EE) of the lower marginal zone, with a dorso-ventral gradient; and the EE itself differentiated into endodermal tissues, mainly pharyngeal endoderm. Nevertheless, when dorsal EE alone was transplanted into the ventral region, a secondary axis with dorsal mesoderm was barely formed. However, when dorsal EE was transplanted with the bottle cells which by themselves were incapable of mesoderm induction, a second axis with well-developed dorsal mesoderm was observed. When the animal half with the lower marginal zone was rotated 180° and recombined with the vegetal half, most of the rotated embryos formed only one dorsal axis at the primary blastopore side. The present results suggest that there are at least two essential processes in dorsal axis formation: mesoderm induction of the upper marginal zone by endodermal epithelium of the lower marginal zone, and dorsalization of the upper dorsal marginal zone evoked during involution.     

CyNodal, the Japanese newt nodal-related gene, is expressed in the left side of the lateral plate mesoderm and diencephalon

The nodal and nodal-related genes play fundamental roles during deuterostome left-right axis formation. Several of these genes show left-sided expression in the lateral plate mesoderm and brain region. We have isolated the nodal-related gene, CyNodal, from Cynops pyrrhogaster. CyNodal mRNA is detected at the marginal zone and left side of several tissues. The left-sideness of CyNodal mRNA expression is highly conserved throughout vertebrate evolution. However, CyNodal mRNA expression shows little variation from the Xenopus nodal-related gene 1, in that CyNodal gene expression in the left lateral plate mesoderm shifts from posterior to anterior at least twice.     

Interactions between Wnt and Vg1 signalling pathways initiate primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

The posterior marginal zone (PMZ) of the chick embryo has Nieuwkoop centre-like properties: when transplanted to another part of the marginal zone, it induces a complete embryonic axis, without making a cellular contribution to the induced structures. However, when the PMZ is removed, the embryo can initiate axis formation from another part of the remaining marginal zone. Chick Vg1 can mimic the axis-inducing ability of the PMZ, but only when misexpressed somewhere within the marginal zone. We have investigated the properties that define the marginal zone as a distinct region. We show that the competence of the marginal zone to initiate ectopic primitive streak formation in response to cVg1 is dependent on Wnt activity. First, within the Wnt family, only Wnt8C is expressed in the marginal zone, in a gradient decreasing from posterior to anterior. Second, misexpression of Wnt1 in the area pellucida enables this region to form a primitive streak in response to cVg1. Third, the Wnt antagonists Crescent and Dkk-1 block the primitive streak-inducing ability of cVg1 in the marginal zone. These findings suggest that Wnt activity defines the marginal zone and allows cVg1 to induce an axis. We also present data suggesting some additional complexity: first, the Vg1 and Wnt pathways appear to regulate the expression of downstream components of each other's pathway; and second, misexpression of different Wnt antagonists suggests that different classes of Wnts may cooperate with each other to regulate axis formation in the normal embryo.     

The importance of the posterior midline region for axis initiation at early stages of the avian embryo

The avian blastoderm acts during its early stages of development as an integrative system programmed to form a single embryonic axis. Here, I report the results of a variety of transplantation experiments of the midline region at stages X-XII, which were carried out to study their relevance for axis initiation. The results of the experimental series discussed herein emphasizes the importance of the posterior midline region (including the marginal zone and Koller's sickle) for axis initiation. This ability resides mainly at stage X in the posterior side of a narrow midline region, while at stages XI-XII it is exhibited at the region which is located more anterior and lateral to the posterior midline region. This posterior midline region has developmental abilities which allow it to initiate a single embryonic axis and at the same time to prevent other regions that also have such abilities to do so. Therefore, in normal development only one embryonic axis develops in the avian blastoderm. It is proposed that the cells which are important to initiate the avian embryonic axis are concentrated mainly at the region of the posterior midline region. These cells may have organizer properties which determine the initiation site of the axis in the avian embryo.     

Formation of the avian primitive streak from spatially restricted blastoderm: evidence for polarized cell division in the elongating streak

Gastrulation in the amniote begins with the formation of a primitive streak through which precursors of definitive mesoderm and endoderm ingress and migrate to their embryonic destinations. This organizing center for amniote gastrulation is induced by signal(s) from the posterior margin of the blastodisc. The mode of action of these inductive signal(s) remains unresolved, since various origins and developmental pathways of the primitive streak have been proposed. In the present study, the fate of chicken blastodermal cells was traced for the first time in ovo from prestreak stages XI-XII through HH stage 3, when the primitive streak is initially established and prior to the migration of mesoderm. Using replication-defective retrovirus-mediated gene transfer and vital dye labeling, precursor cells of the stage 3 primitive streak were mapped predominantly to a specific region where the embryonic midline crosses the posterior margin of the epiblast. No significant contribution to the early primitive streak was seen from the anterolateral epiblast. Instead, the precursor cells generated daughter cells that underwent a polarized cell division oriented perpendicular to the anteroposterior embryonic axis. The resulting daughter cell population was arranged in a longitudinal array extending the complete length of the primitive streak. Furthermore, expression of cVg1, a posterior margin-derived signal, at the anterior marginal zone induced adjacent epiblast cells, but not those lateral to or distant from the signal, to form an ectopic primitive streak. The cVg1-induced epiblast cells also exhibited polarized cell divisions during ectopic primitive streak formation. These results suggest that blastoderm cells located immediately anterior to the posterior marginal zone, which secretes an inductive signal, undergo spatially directed cytokineses during early primitive streak formation.     

Anterior patterning by synergistic activity of the early gastrula organizer and the anterior germ layer tissues of the mouse embryo.

Fragments of the germ layer tissues isolated from the early-primitive-streak (early-streak) stage mouse embryos were tested for axis induction activity by transplantation to late-gastrula (late-streak to early-bud) stage host embryos. The posterior epiblast fragment that contains the early gastrula organizer was able to recruit the host tissues to form an ectopic axis. However, the most anterior neural gene that was expressed in the ectopic axis was Krox20 that marks parts of the hindbrain, but markers of the mid- and forebrain (Otx2 and En1) were not expressed. Anterior visceral endoderm or the anterior epiblast alone did not induce any ectopic neural tissue. However, when these two anterior germ layer tissues were transplanted together, they can induce the formation of ectopic host-derived neural tissues but these tissues rarely expressed anterior neural genes and did not show any organization of an ectopic axis. Therefore, although the anterior endoderm and epiblast together may display some inductive activity, they do not act like a classical organizer. Induction of the anterior neural genes in the ectopic axis was achieved only when a combination of the posterior epiblast fragment, anterior visceral endoderm and the anterior epiblast was transplanted to the host embryo. The formation of anterior neural structures therefore requires the synergistic interaction of the early gastrula organizer and anterior germ layer tissues.     

The interaction between the blastema and stump in the establishment of the anterior-posterior and proximal-distal organization of the limb regenerate

Interactions between the limb stump and the developing regenerate were studied in the limbs of adult newts, Notophthalmus viridescens. Forelimb blastemas at various stages were transplanted to the contralateral forelimb such that the anterior-posterior axes of stump and blastema were opposed. The blastemas were transplanted either from a proximal to distal, distal to proximal, proximal to proximal, or distal to distal level limb stump. The results indicate that at the earliest stage studied the anterior-posterior axis of the blastema is established but is not stable. An interection between the stump and blastema at this early stage results in the production of a variety of limbs intermediate in polarity between the graft and the stump. At all later stages, the original anterior-posterior axis of the blastema can be retained, although under certain grafting conditions the stump can still exert considerable influence over the anterior-posterior organization of the final regenerate. In those circumstances in which the blastema retains its original handedness, the interaction between stump and blastema results in the production of separate anterior and posterior supernumerary regenerates.The results of transplanting proximal blastemas to a distal limb level indicate that the proximal boundary of the blastema has been established by the earliest stage studied, leading to the production of limbs with serially duplicated segments. However, irrespective of the stage of a blastema transplanted from a distal to proximal level, there are no deleted structures in the proximal-distal axis of the resulting limb. From both histological examination of transplanted regenerates and the arrangement of skeletal elements of the resulting limbs, it is postulated that the stump plays an important role in the production of the intercalary regenerate.     

Formation of the Neural Plate and the Mesoderm in Normally Developing Embryos of Xenopus laevis

Normally developing embryos of Xenopus were fixed at various stages between the blastula and early tail bud stage, and their serial sections were examined. The marginal belt of the blastula was characterized by abundance of cells with RNA-rich peripheral cytoplasm called mesoplasm. At the early gastrula stage, the marginal belt was folded into two layers giving rise to mesodermal material and marginal ectoderm. During gastrulation, the mesodermal material, which consisted of RNA-rich cells, spread to enclose the blastocoel and the endoderm, and a large part of it was shifted to the dorsal side of the embryo. It gradually established the mesodermal layer. The notochord was formed on the dorsal lip of the blastopore by involution, separately from preformed mesodermal material. The RNA-rich cells in the marginal ectoderm became columnar, forming a broad belt in the marginal zone. This belt was deformed and shifted to the dorsal side during gastrulation, eventually establishing the neural plate showing quantitative differentiation along the head-tail axis. Possible mechanisms involved in the formation of the neural plate and mesoderm were discussed with reference to the organizer and the mesoplasm.     

Prospective Neural Areas and their Morphogenetic Movements during Neural Plate Formation in the Xenopus Embryo. II. Disposition of Transplanted Ectoderm Pieces of X. borealis Animal Cap in Prospective Neural Areas of Albino X. laevis gastrulae.

Small pieces of the animal cap of X. borealis gastrulae were transplanted into various regions of the noninvoluting marginal zone of albino X. laevis gastrulae, and the distribution of the donor cells was analyzed by quinacrine fluorescence staining.
The present study indicated that the prospective central nervous system (CNS) lies as a belt-shaped area in the noninvoluting marginal zone of early gastrulae. This belt-shaped prospective neural area extends as far as 0.7 mm (115° to the vegetal pole) above the blastopore in the dorsal midline and 1.3 mm lateral (130° to the dorsal midline) to the dorsal midline. The ectoderm of the dorsal region extends in the animal-vegetal direction and forms the ventral side of the CNS. The dorsalateral and lateral regions converge toward the dorsal midline and extended in the animal-vegetal direction. The former constitutes the lateral side of the anterior CNS, and the latter the dorso-lateral side of the posterior CNS.
The outer layer of ectoderm which was transplanted onto the inner layer of the host gastrula differentiated into neural tissues.
The prospective areas of the CNS and their morphogenetic movement during Xenopus embryogenesis are also discussed with regard to neural induction.     

Direct evidence of an essential role for extended involution in the specification of a dorsal marginal mesoderm during Cynops gastrulation

It has been indicated that specification of the dorsal marginal mesoderm of the Cynops gastrula is established by vertical interactions with other layers, which occur during its extended involution. In the present study, when the prospective notochordal area of the early gastrula was almost completely removed together with the dorsal mesoderm-inducing endoderm and most of the bottle cells, the D-less gastrulas still formed the dorsal axis with a well-differentiated notochord; in half of them, where the involution occurred bi-laterally, twin axes were observed. On the other hand, when the wound of a D-less gastrula was repaired by transplanting the ventral marginal zone and ectoderm, the formation of the dorsal axis was inhibited if the involution of the lateral marginal zone was prevented by the transplanted piece. The present study suggests that: (i) cells having dorsal mesoderm-forming potency distribute farther laterally than the fate map; and (ii) the extended involution plays an essential role in the specification of the dorsal marginal mesoderm, especially in notochordal differentiation in normal Cynops embryogenesis.     

Inductive activity of the posterior tip of planula in the marine hydroid Dynamena pumila

Activity of organizer regions is required for body plan formation in the developing organism. Transplanting a fragment of such a region to a host organism leads to the formation of a secondary body axis that consists of both the donor's and the host's tissues (Gerhart, 2001). The subject of this study, the White Sea hydroid cnidarian Dynamena pumila L. (Thecaphora, Sertulariidae), forms morphologically advanced colonies in the course of complex metamorphosis of the planula larva. To reveal an organizer region, a series of experiments has been performed in which small fragments of donor planula tissues were transplanted to embryos at the early and late gastrula stage, as well as to planulae. Only transplantations of a posterior tip fragment of a donor planula to a host planula of the same age led, in the course of metamorphosis, to the formation of a secondary shoot, which involved up to 50% of the host's tissues. After transplantations of tissue fragments of the anterior tip and the middle of the planula body, the formation of any ectopic structures was never observed. It was concluded that the posterior tip of the planula has organizer properties in Dynamena.     

Early development of the chick embryo

The ultrastructure of the early chick embryo was investigated, using scanning (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Eggs were obtained from the shell gland by injecting hens intravenously with a synthetic prostaglandin or arginine vasopressin. Embryos were examined during late cleavage (stages IV–VI, Eyal-Giladi and Kochav, '76), formation of the area pellucida (stages VII–XI), and formation of the hypoblast (stages X–XIV). SEM highlighted the reduction in cell number at the underside of the embryo during formation of the area pellucida although it became apparent that the thickness of the embryo is not reduced to a single layer of cells at stage X. In addition, blastomeres at the perimeter of embryos (stages V–VI) project filopodial extensions onto a smooth membrane that separates the sub-embryonic cavity from the yolk. During hypoblast formation, epiblast cells generate stellate projections at their basal aspect, thus providing a meshwork for the advancing secondary hypoblast cells. By stage XII the epiblast was one cell thick and reminiscent of a columnar epithelium when viewed transversely. Cells of the deep portion of the posterior marginal zone were distinguished morphologically in the stage XII embryo by their many cell surface projections and ruffled appearance. Blastomeres at the perimeter of stage V–VI embryos projected filopodial extensions onto a smooth membrane which separates the sub-embryonic cavity from the yolk. This membrane is presumed to be confluent with the cytolemma. Evidence is presented demonstrating the presence of intracellular membrane-bound droplets which are hypothesised to contain sub-embryonic fluid. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Nodal signal is required for morphogenetic movements of epiblast layer in the pre-streak chick blastoderm

During axis formation in amniotes, posterior and lateral epiblast cells in the area pellucida undergo a counter-rotating movement along the midline to form primitive streak (Polonaise movements). Using chick blastoderms, we investigated the signaling involved in this cellular movement in epithelial-epiblast. In cultured posterior blastoderm explants from stage X to XI embryos, either Lefty1 or Cerberus-S inhibited initial migration of the explants on chamber slides. In vivo analysis showed that inhibition of Nodal signaling by Lefty1 affected the movement of DiI-marked epiblast cells prior to the formation of primitive streak. In Lefty1-treated embryos without a primitive streak, Brachyury expression showed a patchy distribution. However, SU5402 did not affect the movement of DiI-marked epiblast cells. Multi-cellular rosette, which is thought to be involved in epithelial morphogenesis, was found predominantly in the posterior half of the epiblast, and Lefty1 inhibited the formation of rosettes. Three-dimensional reconstruction showed two types of rosette, one with a protruding cell, the other with a ventral hollow. Our results suggest that Nodal signaling may have a pivotal role in the morphogenetic movements of epithelial epiblast including Polonaise movements and formation of multi-cellular rosette.     

The marginal zone and its contribution to the hypoblast and primitive streak of the chick embryo

The marginal zone of the chick embryo has been shown to play an important role in the formation of the hypoblast and of the primitive streak. In this study, time-lapse filming, fate mapping, ablation and transplantation experiments were combined to study its contribution to these structures. It was found that the deep (endodermal) portion of the posterior marginal zone contributes to the hypoblast and to the junctional endoblast, while the epiblast portion of the same region contributes to the epiblast of the primitive streak and to the definitive (gut) endoderm derived from it. Within the deep part of the posterior marginal zone, a subpopulation of HNK-1-positive cells contributes to the hypoblast. Removal of the deep part of the marginal zone prevents regeneration of the hypoblast but not the formation of a primitive streak. Removal of both layers of the marginal zone leads to a primitive streak of abnormal morphology but mesendodermal cells nevertheless differentiate. These results show that the two main properties of the posterior marginal zone (contributing to the hypoblast and controlling the site of primitive streak formation) are separable, and reside in different germ layers. This conclusion does not support the idea that the influence of the posterior marginal zone on the development of axial structures is due to it being the source of secondary hypoblast cells.     

Differentiation behavior of the mesodermal germinal sone of differently old pregastrulation stages of Ambystoma mexicanum. Cultivation of untreated and lithium-treated isolates

Isolates from the dorsal, lateral and ventral area of the marginal zone are showing differentiation capacities already in the stage of early morula. The composition of the differentiation pattern alters: ecto- and mesodermal tissues are realized until the late morula. Beyond these, endodermal structures are visible with the stage of early blastula. After a mild Li treatment of the isolates the differentiation pattern of the marginal zone shows significant modifications. Ectodermal organs are registered to a lesser degree. Gut-structures are already visible within the stage of middle morula. The capacity for gut-differentiation is not restricted to only the lateral and ventral areas but is also observed in the dorsal region of the marginal zone. The results of experiments are discussed on the basis of Nieuwkoop's formation of the mesoderm in urodelean amphibians.     

Determination of embryonic polarity in a regulative system: evidence for endogenous inhibitors acting sequentially during primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

Avian embryos have a remarkable capacity to regulate: when a pre-primitive streak stage embryo is cut into fragments, each fragment can spontaneously initiate formation of a complete embryonic axis. We investigate the signalling pathways that initiate primitive streak formation and the mechanisms that ensure that only a single axis normally forms. As reported previously, an ectopic primitive streak can be induced by misexpression of Vg1 in the marginal zone. We now show that Vg1 induces an inhibitor that travels across the embryo (3 mm distance) in less than 6 hours. We provide evidence that this inhibitor acts early in the cascade of events downstream of Vg1. We also show that FGF signalling is required for primitive streak formation, in cooperation with Nodal and Chordin. We suggest that three sequential inhibitory steps ensure that a single axis develops in the normal embryo: an early inhibitor that spreads throughout the embryo (which can be induced by Vg1), a second inhibition by Cerberus from the underlying hypoblast, and finally a late inhibition from Lefty emitted by the primitive streak itself.     

The control of the anteroposterior and dorsoventral axes in embryonic chick limbs constructed of dissociated and reaggregated limb-bud mesoderm

In the 3- to 4-day embryonic avian limb bud, a unique zone of mesodermal tissue is located posteriorly at the junction of bud and body wall. Appropriately grafted to a host limb bud, it induces the formation of a supernumerary limb outgrowth from preaxial tissue and determines that its posterior side will face the graft. It is called the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA).When limb-bud mesoderm is isolated, dissociated, reaggregated centrifugally, jacketed in the mesoderm-free hull of another limb bud, and grown as a graft on a host embryo, the recombinant frequently forms a limb-like structure terminating in digits that fail to show differentiation with respect to the anteroposterior axis. When, however, a bit of ZPA tissue is implanted in the recombinant subjacent to the anterior or posterior margin of the ectoderm, the resulting outgrowth shows a characteristic anteroposterior order of digits that corresponds to the placement of the implant, regardless of its relationship with the anteroposterior axis of the ectoderm or of the host embryo.Dorsoventral differentials have been recognized only in limbs formed from reaggregated leg-bud mesoderm. The direction of the dorsoventral axis always corresponds to the original axis of the ectodermal jacket regardless of the orientation of the recombinant on the host.