A comparative analysis of the immunological evolution of antibody 28B4

In an effort to gain greater insight into the evolution of the redox active, catalytic antibody 28B4, the germline genes used by the mouse to generate this antibody were cloned and expressed, and the X-ray crystal structures of the unliganded and hapten-bound germline Fab of antibody 28B4 were determined. Comparison with the previously determined structures of the unliganded and hapten-bound affinity-matured Fab [Hsieh-Wilson, L. C., Schultz, P. G., and Stevens, R. C. (1996) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93, 5363] shows that the germline antibody binds the p-nitrophenyl ring of hapten 3 in an orientation significantly different from that seen in the affinity-matured antibody, whereas the phosphonate moiety is bound in a similar mode by both antibodies. The affinity-matured antibody 28B4 has more electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions with hapten 3 than the germline antibody and binds the hapten in a lock-and-key fashion. In contrast, significant conformational changes occur in the loops of CDR H3 and CDR L1 upon hapten binding to the germline antibody, consistent with the notion of structural plasticity in the germline antibody-combining site [Wedemayer, G. J., Patten, P. A., Wang, L. H., Schultz, P. G., and Stevens, R. C. (1997) Science 276, 1665]. The structural differences are reflected in the differential binding affinities of the germline Fab (K(d) = 25 microM) and 28B4 Fab (K(d) = 37 nM) to hapten 3. Nine replacement mutations were found to accumulate in the affinity-matured antibody 28B4 compared to its germline precursor. The effects of each mutation on the binding affinity of the antibody to hapten 3 were characterized in detail in the contexts of both the germline and the affinity-matured antibodies. One of the mutations, Asp95(H)Trp, leads to a change in the orientation of the bound hapten, and its presence is a prerequisite for other somatic mutations to enhance the binding affinity of the germline antibody for hapten 3. Thus, the germline antibody of 28B4 acquired functionally important mutations in a stepwise manner, which fits into a multicycle mutation, affinity selection, and clonal expansion model for germline antibody evolution. Two other antibodies, 20-1 and NZA6, with very different antigen specificities were found to be highly homologous to the germline antibody of 28B4, consistent with the notion that certain germline variable-region gene combinations can give rise to polyspecific hapten binding sites [Romesberg, F. E., Spiller, B., Schultz, P. G., and Stevens, R. C. (1998) Science 279, 1929]. The ultimate specificity of the polyspecific germline antibody appears to be defined by CDR H3 variability and subsequent somatic mutation. Insights into the evolution of antibody-combining sites provided by this and other structural studies are discussed.     

Structural basis for a disfavored elimination reaction in catalytic antibody 1D4.

Murine antibody 1D4 selectively catalyzes a highly disfavored beta-elimination reaction. Crystal structures of unliganded 1D4 and 1D4 in complex with a transition-state analog (TSA) have elucidated a possible general base mode of catalysis. The structures of the unliganded and liganded Fabs were determined to 1.80 and 1.85 A resolution, respectively. The structure of the complex reveals a binding pocket with high shape complementarity to the TSA, which is recruited to coerce the substrate into the sterically demanding, eclipsed conformation that is required for catalysis. A histidine residue and two water molecules are likely involved in the catalysis. The structure supports either a concerted E2 or stepwise E1cB-like mechanism for elimination. Finally, the liganded 1D4 structure shows minor conformational rearrangements in CDR H2, indicative of induced-fit binding of the hapten. 1D4 has pushed the boundaries of antibody-mediated catalysis into the realm of disfavored reactions and, hence, represents an important milestone in the development of this technology.     

Structural plasticity and the evolution of antibody affinity and specificity

The germline precursor to the ferrochelatase antibody 7G12 was found to bind the polyether jeffamine in addition to its cognate hapten N-methylmesoporphyrin. A comparison of the X-ray crystal structures of the ligand-free germline Fab and its complex with either hapten or jeffamine reveals that the germline antibody undergoes significant conformational changes upon the binding of these two structurally distinct ligands, which lead to increased antibody-ligand complementarity. The five somatic mutations introduced during affinity maturation lead to enhanced binding affinity for hapten and a loss in affinity for jeffamine. Moreover, a comparison of the crystal structures of the germline and affinity-matured antibodies reveals that somatic mutations not only fix the optimal binding site conformation for the hapten, but also introduce interactions that interfere with the binding of non-hapten molecules. The structural plasticity of this germline antibody and the structural effects of the somatic mutations that result in enhanced affinity and specificity for hapten likely represent general mechanisms used by the immune response, and perhaps primitive proteins, to evolve high affinity, selective receptors for so many distinct chemical structures.     

Thermodynamic and structural basis for transition-state stabilization in antibody-catalyzed hydrolysis

Catalytic antibodies 6D9 and 9C10, which were induced by immunization with a haptenic transition-state analog (TSA), catalyze the hydrolysis of a nonbioactive chloramphenicol monoester derivative to generate a bioactive chloramphenicol. These antibodies stabilize the transition state to catalyze the hydrolysis reaction, strictly according to the theoretical relationship: for 6D9, k(cat)/k(uncat)=895 and K(S)/K(TSA)=900, and for 9C10, k(cat)/k(uncat)=56 and K(S)/K(TSA)=60. To elucidate the molecular basis of the antibody-catalyzed reaction, the crystal structure of 6D9 was determined, and the binding thermodynamics of 6D9 and 9C10 with both the substrate and the TSA were analyzed using isothermal titration calorimetry. The crystal structure of the unliganded 6D9 Fab was determined at 2.25 A resolution and compared with that of the TSA-liganded 6D9 Fab reported previously, showing that the TSA is bound into the hydrophobic pocket of the antigen-combining site in an "induced fit" manner, especially at the L1 and H3 CDR loops. Thermodynamic analyses showed that 6D9 binds the substrate of the TSA with a positive DeltaS, differing from general thermodynamic characteristics of antigen-antibody interactions. This positive DeltaS could be due to the hydrophobic interactions between 6D9 and the substrate or the TSA mediated by Trp H100i. The difference in DeltaG between substrate and TSA-binding to 6D9 was larger than that to 9C10, which is in good correlation with the larger k(cat) value of 6D9. Interestingly, the DeltaDeltaG was mainly because of the DeltaDeltaH. The correlation between k(cat) and DeltaDeltaH is suggestive of "enthalpic strain" leading to destabilization of antibody-substrate complexes. Together with X-ray structural analyses, the thermodynamic analyses suggest that upon binding the substrate, the antibody alters the conformation of the ester moiety in the substrate from the planar Z form to a thermodynamically unstable twisted conformation, followed by conversion into the transition state. Enthalpic strain also contributes to the transition-state stabilization by destabilizing the ground state, and its degree is much larger for the more efficient catalytic antibody, 6D9.     

Exploration of specificity in germline monoclonal antibody recognition of a range of natural and synthetic epitopes

To explore the molecular basis of antigen recognition by germline antibodies, we have determined to high resolution the structures of the near-germline monoclonal antibody S25-2 in complex with seven distinct carbohydrate antigens based on the bacterial sugar 3-deoxy-α-d-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo). In contrast to previous findings, the inherited germline Kdo monosaccharide binding site is not restricted to this bacterial sugar but is able to accommodate an array of substitutions and chemical modifications of Kdo, including naturally occurring antigens containing the related monosaccharide d-glycero-α-d-talo-oct-2-ulosonic acid as well as nonterminal Kdo residues. However, we show by surface plasmon resonance and ELISA how antibody S25-2 specificity is so dependent on the context in which the antigen is presented that a free disaccharide displays strong binding while the same lipid-A-bound disaccharide does not bind. These structures provide insight into how inherited germline genes code for immunoglobulins of limited flexibility that are capable of binding a range of epitopes from which affinity-matured antibodies are generated.     

Effects of somatic mutations on CDR loop flexibility during affinity maturation

Prior studies suggest that antibody affinity maturation is achieved, in part, via prearranging the CDRs for binding. The implication is that the entropy cost of binding is reduced and that this rigidification occurs as a consequence of somatic mutations during maturation. However, how these mutations modulate CDR flexibility is unclear. Here, molecular dynamics simulations captured CDR flexibility differences between four mature antibodies (7G12, AZ28, 28B4, and 48G7) and their germline predecessors. Analysis of their trajectories: (1) rationalized how mutations during affinity maturation restrict CDR motility, (2) captured the equilibrium between bound and unbound conformations for the H3 loop of unliganded 7G12, and (3) predicted a set of new mutations that, according to our simulations, should diminish binding by increasing flexibility.     

Putidaredoxin-cytochrome P450cam interaction

Cytochrome P450cam (P450cam) catalyzes the monooxygenation of D-camphor. During the enzymatic reaction, oxyferrous, D-camphor-bound P450cam forms a binary complex with reduced putidaredoxin as an obligatory reaction intermediate. We have found that reduced putidaredoxin undergoes EPR-detectable conformational changes upon formation of the intermediate complex and also upon formation of a binary complex with CO- or NO-ferrous, D-camphor-bound P450cam. The structural changes in putidaredoxin are almost identical irrespective of the ligand bound to P450cam, and distinct from and significantly larger than those induced by unliganded ferrous P450cam. The binary complex formation also induce conformational alterations in the CO- and NO-ferrous, D-camphor-bound P450cam, thereby evoking simultaneous changes in the structure of the two proteins. A molecular basis and roles of such structural changes in the D-camphor monooxygenation are discussed.     

Structural basis of the transition-state stabilization in antibody-catalyzed hydrolysis

The catalytic antibody 6D9, which was raised against a transition-state analogue (TSA), catalyzes the hydrolysis of a non-bioactive chloramphenicol monoester to generate chloramphenicol. It has been shown that 6D9 utilizes the binding affinity in the catalysis; the differential affinity of the TSA relative to the substrate is equal to the rate enhancement. To reveal the recognition mechanism of 6D9 for the TSA and the substrate, we performed NMR analysis of the Fv fragment of 6D9 (6D9-Fv), together with site-directed mutagenesis and stopped-flow kinetic analyses. Among six 6D9-Fv mutants, Y58(H)A and W100i(H)A displayed significant reductions in their affinities to the TSA, while their substrate-binding affinities were identical with that of the wild-type 6D9-Fv. The stopped-flow kinetic studies revealed that the TSA binding to 6D9-Fv occurred by an induced-fit mechanism. In contrast, no induced-fit type of TSA-binding mechanism was observed for Y58(H)A and W100i(H)A. From NMR experiments, we identified the residues with chemical shifts that were perturbed by the ligand-binding. The residues affected by the TSA binding were located on the TSA-binding site determined by the X-ray study, and on the regions far from the binding site. On the other hand, the residues affected by the substrate binding were localized on the TSA-binding site. As for W100i(H)A, no residue other than those in the binding site was affected by the ligand binding. On the basis of these results and the crystal structure, we concluded that the TSA binding induced a conformational change involving the formation of aromatic-aromatic interactions and a hydrogen bond. These interactions can account for the differential affinity for the TSA relative to the substrate. W100i(H) probably plays an important role in inducing the conformational changes. The present NMR studies have enabled us to visualize the concept of transition-state stabilization in enzymatic catalysis, in which the transition-state contacts are better than those of the substrate.     

Crystal structures of threonine synthase from Thermus thermophilus HB8: conformational change,substrate recognition,and mechanism

Threonine synthase, which is a PLP-dependent enzyme, catalyzes the beta,gamma-replacement reaction of l-homoserine phosphate to yield threonine and inorganic phosphate. The three-dimensional structures of the enzyme from Thermus thermophilus HB8 in its unliganded form and complexed with the substrate analogue 2-amino-5-phosphonopentanoic acid have been determined at 2.15 and 2.0 A resolution, respectively. The complexed form, assigned as an enamine, uncovered the interactions of the cofactor-analogue conjugate with the active site residues. The binding of the substrate analogue induces a large conformational change at the domain level. The small domain rotates by about 25 degrees and approaches the large domain to close the active site. The complicated catalytic process of the enzyme has been elucidated based on the complex structure to reveal the stereochemistry of the reaction and to present the released inorganic phosphate as a possible catalyst to carry a proton to the Cgamma atom of the substrate.     

Conformational dynamics of complementarity-determining region H3 of an anti-dansyl Fv fragment in the presence of its hapten

Antigen-induced structural changes in the Fv fragment of an anti-dansyl immunoglobulin G were studied by X-ray crystallography and stopped-flow fluorescence measurement. The crystal structure of the Fv fragment complexed with dansyl-lysine was determined at a resolution of 1.85 A. The dansyl-lysine molecule bound to a narrow cavity formed by the complementarity-determining regions H3 and H1, the N-terminal region of the VH domain and L2 of the VL domain. The structure of the binding site in the crystal structure explained well the results of the previous nuclear magnetic resonance measurements. The hapten binding caused remarkable conformational changes in H3 and its environmental structures, including the hydration structure from those observed in the unliganded state. The tip of H3 moved about 12 A from its position in the unliganded state. In addition, because of the contacts of H3 with the VL domain at the domain interface, the conformational changes of H3 resulted in the relative rotation of the variable domains by 5 degrees from their association observed in the unliganded state. The hydrophobic interactions at the domain interface seemed to be particularly important for the mutual rotation of the domains. The stopped-flow fluorescence measurement monitoring the interaction of the dansyl group and the binding pocket revealed that H3 was in a conformational equilibrium of three consecutive conformational states in the presence of dansyl-lysine in solution; an unliganded state preventing the access of the hapten, another unliganded state able to bind the hapten and the complex. The conformational dynamics of H3 in recognizing and binding the hapten molecule are discussed on the basis of the structural information from the present and previous studies.     

Structural basis for antibody catalysis of a cationic cyclization reaction

Antibody 4C6 efficiently catalyzes a cationic cyclization reaction. Crystal structures of the antibody 4C6 Fab in complex with benzoic acid and in complex with its eliciting hapten were determined to 1.30A and 2.45A resolution, respectively. These crystal structures, together with computational analysis, have elucidated a possible mechanism for the monocyclization reaction. The hapten complex revealed a combining site pocket with high shape complementarity to the hapten. This active site cleft is dominated by aromatic residues that shield the highly reactive carbocation intermediates from solvent and stabilize the carbocation intermediates through cation-pi interactions. Modeling of an acyclic olefinic sulfonate ester substrate and the transition state (TS) structures shows that the chair-like transition state is favored, and trapping by water directly produces trans-2-(dimethylphenylsilyl)-cyclohexanol, whereas the less favored boat-like transition state leads to cyclohexene. The only significant change observed upon hapten binding is a side-chain rotation of Trp(L89), which reorients to form the base of the combining site. Intriguingly, a benzoic acid molecule was sequestered in the combining site of the unliganded antibody. The 4C6 active site was compared to that observed in a previously reported tandem cyclization antibody 19A4 hapten complex. These cationic cyclization antibodies exhibit convergent structural features with terpenoid cyclases that appear to be important for catalysis.     

Affinity maturation to improve human monoclonal antibody neutralization potency and breadth against hepatitis C virus

A potent neutralizing antibody to a conserved hepatitis C virus (HCV) epitope might overcome its extreme variability, allowing immunotherapy. The human monoclonal antibody HC-1 recognizes a conformational epitope on the HCV E2 glycoprotein. Previous studies showed that HC-1 neutralizes most HCV genotypes but has modest potency. To improve neutralization, we affinity-matured HC-1 by constructing a library of yeast-displayed HC-1 single chain Fv (scFv) mutants, using for selection an E2 antigen from one of the poorly neutralized HCVpp. We developed an approach by parallel mutagenesis of the heavy chain variable (VH) and κ-chain variable (Vk) genes separately, then combining the optimized VH and Vk mutants. This resulted in the generation of HC-1-related scFv variants exhibiting improved affinities. The best scFv variant had a 92-fold improved affinity. After conversion to IgG1, some of the antibodies exhibited a 30-fold improvement in neutralization activity. Both surface plasmon resonance and solution kinetic exclusion analysis showed that the increase in affinity was largely due to a lowering of the dissociation rate constant, Koff. Neutralization against a panel of HCV pseudoparticles and infectious 2a HCV virus improved with the affinity-matured IgG1 antibodies. Interestingly, some of these antibodies neutralized a viral isolate that was not neutralized by wild-type HC-1. Moreover, propagating 2a HCVcc under the selective pressure of WT HC-1 or affinity-matured HC-1 antibodies yielded no viral escape mutants and, with the affinity-matured IgG1, needed 100-fold less antibody to achieve complete virus elimination. Taken together, these findings suggest that affinity-matured HC-1 antibodies are excellent candidates for therapeutic development.     

Chemical basis for the affinity maturation of a camel single domain antibody

Affinity maturation of classic antibodies supposedly proceeds through the pre-organization of the reactive germ line conformational isomer. It is less evident to foresee how this can be accomplished by camelid heavy-chain antibodies lacking light chains. Although these antibodies are subjected to somatic hypermutation, their antigen-binding fragment consists of a single domain with restricted flexibility in favor of binding energy. An antigen-binding domain derived from a dromedary heavy-chain antibody, cAb-Lys3, accumulated five amino acid substitutions in CDR1 and CDR2 upon maturation against lysozyme. Three of these residues have hydrophobic side chains, replacing serines, and participate in the hydrophobic core of the CDR1 in the mature antibody, suggesting that conformational rearrangements might occur in this loop during maturation. However, transition state analysis of the binding kinetics of mature cAb-Lys3 and germ line variants show that the maturation of this antibody relies on events late in the reaction pathway. This is reflected by a limited perturbation of k(a) and a significantly decreased k(d) upon maturation. In addition, binding reactions and the maturation event are predominantly enthalpically driven. Therefore, maturation proceeds through the increase of favorable binding interactions, or by the reduction of the enthalpic penalty for desolvation, as opposed to large entropic penalties associated with conformational changes and structural plasticity. Furthermore, the crystal structure of the mutant with a restored germ line CDR2 sequence illustrates that the matured hydrophobic core of CDR1 in cAb-Lys3 might be compensated in the germ line precursor by burying solvent molecules engaged in a stable hydrogen-bonding network with CDR1 and CDR2.     

Crystal structure of Thermus caldophilus phosphoglycerate kinase in the open conformation

Phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) is a key glycolytic enzyme that catalyzes the reversible transfer of a phosphate from 1,3-bisphosphoglycerate to ADP to form 3-phosphoglycerate and ATP in the presence of magnesium. During catalysis, a conformational change occurs that brings the N- and C-domains of PGK closer together. Here we present the 1.8A crystal structure of unliganded PGK from Thermus caldophilus (Tca). Comparison of the structure of TcaPGK (open conformation) with that of Thermotoga maritima (Tma) PGK (closed conformation) revealed that the conformational change reflects a change in the interaction between the domains. We identified Arg148 as a key residue involved in open-to-closed transition. The open conformation of TcaPGK is stabilized by an interdomain salt bridge between Arg148 and Glu375. The binding of 3-PG (or maybe 1,3-BPG) disrupts this salt bridge and, in ternary complex, the formation of new salt bridge between Arg60 and Asp197 stabilizes the closed conformation.     

Regulation by oligomerization in a mycobacterial folate biosynthetic enzyme

Folate derivatives are essential cofactors in the biosynthesis of purines, pyrimidines and amino acids across all forms of life. Mammals uptake folate from their diets, whereas most bacteria must synthesize folate de novo. Therefore, the enzymes in the folate biosynthetic pathway are attractive drug targets against bacterial pathogens such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the cause of the world's most deadly infectious disease, tuberculosis (TB). M.tuberculosis 7,8-dihydroneopterin aldolase (Mtb FolB, DHNA) is the second enzyme in the folate biosynthetic pathway, which catalyzes the conversion of 7,8-dihydroneopterin to 6-hydroxymethyl-7,8-dihydropterin and glycoaldehyde. The 1.6A X-ray crystal structure of Mtb FolB complexed with its product, 6-hydroxymethyl-7,8-dihydropterin, reveals an octameric assembly similar to that seen in crystal structures of other FolB homologs. However, the 2.5A crystal structure of unliganded Mtb FolB reveals a novel tetrameric oligomerization state, with only partially formed active sites. A substrate induced conformational change appears to be necessary to convert the inactive tetramer to the active octamer. Ultracentrifugation confirmed that in solution unliganded Mtb FolB is mainly tetrameric and upon addition of substrate FolB is predominantly octameric. Kinetic analysis of substrate binding gives a Hill coefficient of 2.0, indicating positive cooperativity. We hypothesize that Mtb FolB displays cooperativity in substrate binding to regulate the cellular concentration of 7,8-dihydroneopterin, so that it may function not only as a precursor to folate but also as an antioxidant for the survival of M.tuberculosis against host defenses.     

Kinetic and physical evidence that the diheme enzyme MauG tightly binds to a biosynthetic precursor of methylamine dehydrogenase with incompletely formed tryptophan tryptophylquinone

Methylamine dehydrogenase (MADH) contains the protein-derived cofactor tryptophan tryptophylquinone (TTQ) which is generated by the posttranslational modification of two endogenous tryptophan residues. The modifications are incorporation of two oxygens into one tryptophan side chain and the covalent cross-linking of that side chain to a second tryptophan residue. This process requires at least one accessory gene, mauG. Inactivation of mauG in vivo results in production of an inactive 119 kDa tetrameric alpha 2beta 2 protein precursor of MADH with incompletely synthesized TTQ. This precursor can be converted to active MADH with mature TTQ in vitro by reaction with MauG, a 42 kDa diheme enzyme. Steady-state kinetic analysis of the MauG-dependent conversion of the precursor to mature MADH with completely synthesized TTQ yielded values of k cat of 0.20 +/- 0.01 s (-1) and K m of 6.6 +/- 0.6 microM for the biosynthetic precursor protein in an in vitro assay. In the absence of an electron donor to initiate the reaction it was possible to isolate the MauG-biosynthetic precursor (enzyme-substrate) complex in solution using high-resolution size-exclusion chromatography. This stable complex is noncovalent and could be separated into its component proteins by anion-exchange chromatography. In contrast to the enzyme-substrate complex, a mixture of MauG and its reaction product, mature MADH, did not elute as a complex during size-exclusion chromatography. The differential binding of MauG to its protein substrate and protein product of the reaction indicates that significant conformational changes in one or both of the proteins occur during catalysis which significantly affects the protein-protein interactions.     

Selection and analysis of an optimized anti-VEGF antibody: crystal structure of an affinity-matured Fab in complex with antigen.

The Fab portion of a humanized antibody (Fab-12; IgG form known as rhuMAb VEGF) to vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) has been affinity-matured through complementarity-determining region (CDR) mutation, followed by affinity selection using monovalent phage display. After stringent binding selections at 37 degrees C, with dissociation (off-rate) selection periods of several days, high affinity variants were isolated from CDR-H1, H2, and H3 libraries. Mutations were combined to obtain cumulatively tighter-binding variants. The final variant identified here, Y0317, contained six mutations from the parental antibody. In vitro cell-based assays show that four mutations yielded an improvement of about 100-fold in potency for inhibition of VEGF-dependent cell proliferation by this variant, consistent with the equilibrium binding constant determined from kinetics experiments at 37 degrees C. Using X-ray crystallography, we determined a high-resolution structure of the complex between VEGF and the affinity-matured Fab fragment. The overall features of the binding interface seen previously with wild-type are preserved, and many contact residues are maintained in precise alignment in the superimposed structures. However, locally, we see evidence for improved contacts between antibody and antigen, and two mutations result in increased van der Waals contact and improved hydrogen bonding. Site-directed mutants confirm that the most favorable improvements as judged by examination of the complex structure, in fact, have the greatest impact on free energy of binding. In general, the final antibody has improved affinity for several VEGF variants as compared with the parental antibody; however, some contact residues on VEGF differ in their contribution to the energetics of Fab binding. The results show that small changes even in a large protein-protein binding interface can have significant effects on the energetics of interaction.