Macrophage activity in organ cultures of the avian cochlea: Demonstration of a resident population and recruitment to sites of hair cell lesions

The factors that regulate the repair and regeneration of the sensory hair cells of the inner ear are not understood. Previous studies of hair cell injury in the lateral line sensory organs of amphibians and the cochleae of mammals have demonstrated that macrophages and other leukocytes are recruited to sites of hair cell lesions. The present study examined the distribution and activity of macrophages in organ cultures of the avian cochlea, a system whose regenerative abilities have been widely studied. Cochleae were removed from chicks and placed in organ culture, and precise hair cell lesions were created using a laser microbeam. Macrophages in the cultures were identified using histochemical, immunocytochemical, and morphologic criteria. It was found that (a) cultured cochleae contained a resident population of macrophages, and (b) increased numbers of macrophages were recruited to the sites of hair cell lesions. Furthermore, the latency of macrophage recruitment to lesions is consistent with a suggested role for macrophages in the initiation of hair cell regeneration. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 33: 724–734, 1997     

Depletion of Resident Macrophages Does Not Alter Sensory Regeneration in the Avian Cochlea

Macrophages are the primary effector cells of the innate immune system and are also activated in response to tissue injury. The avian cochlea contains a population of resident macrophages, but the precise function of those cells is not known. The present study characterized the behavior of cochlear macrophages after aminoglycoside ototoxicity and also examined the possible role of macrophages in sensory regeneration. We found that the undamaged chick cochlea contains a large resting population of macrophages that reside in the hyaline cell region, immediately outside the abneural (inferior) border of the sensory epithelium. Following ototoxic injury, macrophages appear to migrate out of the hyaline cell region and towards the basilar membrane, congregating immediately below the lesioned sensory epithelium. In order to determine whether recruited macrophages contribute to the regeneration of sensory receptors, we quantified supporting cell proliferation and hair cell recovery after the elimination of most resident macrophages via application of liposomally-encapsulated clodronate. Examination of macrophage-depleted specimens at two days following ototoxic injury revealed no deficits in hair cell clearance, when compared to normal controls. In addition, we found that elimination of macrophages did not affect either regenerative proliferation of supporting cells or the production of replacement hair cells. However, we did find that macrophage-depleted cochleae contained reduced numbers of proliferative mesothelial cells below the basilar membrane. Our data suggest that macrophages are not required for normal debris clearance and regeneration, but that they may play a role in the maintenance of the basilar membrane.     

Hair cell regeneration in the avian auditory epithelium

Regeneration of sensory hair cells in the mature avian inner ear was first described just over 20 years ago. Since then, it has been shown that many other non-mammalian species either continually produce new hair cells or regenerate them in response to trauma. However, mammals exhibit limited hair cell regeneration, particularly in the auditory epithelium. In birds and other non-mammals, regenerated hair cells arise from adjacent non-sensory (supporting) cells. Hair cell regeneration was initially described as a proliferative response whereby supporting cells re-enter the mitotic cycle, forming daughter cells that differentiate into either hair cells or supporting cells and thereby restore cytoarchitecture and function in the sensory epithelium. However, further analyses of the avian auditory epithelium (and amphibian vestibular epithelium) revealed a second regenerative mechanism, direct transdifferentiation, during which supporting cells change their gene expression and convert into hair cells without dividing. In the chicken auditory epithelium, these two distinct mechanisms show unique spatial and temporal patterns, suggesting they are differentially regulated. Current efforts are aimed at identifying signals that maintain supporting cells in a quiescent state or direct them to undergo direct transdifferentiation or cell division. Here, we review current knowledge about supporting cell properties and discuss candidate signaling molecules for regulating supporting cell behavior, in quiescence and after damage. While significant advances have been made in understanding regeneration in non-mammals over the last 20 years, we have yet to determine why the mammalian auditory epithelium lacks the ability to regenerate hair cells spontaneously and whether it is even capable of significant regeneration under additional circumstances. The continued study of mechanisms controlling regeneration in the avian auditory epithelium may lead to strategies for inducing significant and functional regeneration in mammals.     

Coenzyme Q10 Protects Hair Cells against Aminoglycoside

It is well known that the production of free radicals is associated with sensory cell death induced by an aminoglycoside. Many researchers have reported that antioxidant reagents protect sensory cells in the inner ear, and coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) is an antioxidant that is consumed as a health food in many countries. The purpose of this study was to investigate the role of CoQ10 in mammalian vestibular hair cell death induced by aminoglycoside. Cultured utricles of CBA/CaN mice were divided into three groups (control group, neomycin group, and neomycin + CoQ10 group). In the neomycin group, utricles were cultured with neomycin (1 mM) to induce hair cell death. In the neomycin + CoQ10 group, utricles were cultured with neomycin and water-soluble CoQ10 (30–0.3 µM). Twenty-four hours after exposure to neomycin, the cultured tissues were fixed, and vestibular hair cells were labeled using an anti-calmodulin antibody. Significantly more hair cells survived in the neomycin + CoQ10 group than in the neomycin group. These data indicate that CoQ10 protects sensory hair cells against neomycin-induced death in the mammalian vestibular epithelium; therefore, CoQ10 may be useful as a protective drug in the inner ear.     

Regulated reprogramming in the regeneration of sensory receptor cells

Vision, olfaction, hearing, and balance are mediated by receptors that reside in specialized sensory epithelial organs. Age-related degeneration of the photoreceptors in the retina and the hair cells in the cochlea, caused by macular degeneration and sensorineural hearing loss, respectively, affect a growing number of individuals. Although sensory receptor cells in the mammalian retina and inner ear show only limited or no regeneration, in many nonmammalian vertebrates, these sensory epithelia show remarkable regenerative potential. We summarize the current state of knowledge of regeneration in the specialized sense organs in both nonmammalian vertebrates and mammals and discuss possible areas where new advances in regenerative medicine might provide approaches to successfully stimulate sensory receptor cell regeneration. The field of regenerative medicine is still in its infancy, but new approaches using stem cells and reprogramming suggest ways in which the potential for regeneration may be restored in individuals suffering from sensory loss.     

Identification of Tympanic Border Cells as Slow-Cycling Cells in the Cochlea

Mammalian cochlear sensory epithelial cells are believed to possess minimal regenerative potential because they halt proliferation during late stage of embryogenesis and never regenerate after birth. This means that sensorineural hearing loss caused by the death of cochlear sensory epithelial cells is a permanent condition. However, stem cells were recently identified in neonatal mice following dissociation of their inner ear organs. This suggests that regenerative therapy for sensorineural hearing loss may be possible. Unfortunately, dissociation distorts the microanatomy of the inner ear, making it difficult to determine the precise location of stem cells in unaltered specimens. To develop new therapeutic approaches based on sensory epithelial cell regeneration, the location of these stem cells must be elucidated. Stem cells normally proliferate at a slow rate in adult organs. In fact, so-called label-retaining cells, or slow-cycling cells, of the brain and skin are recognized as stem cells. In this study, using the exogenous proliferation marker, 5′-bromo-2′-deoxyuridine (BrdU) in combination with the endogenous proliferation marker Ki-67, we identified tympanic border cells. These cells, which are located beneath the basilar membrane in vivo, represent slow-cycling cells of the murine cochlea. Immunohistochemically, these cells stained positive for the immature cell marker Nestin. But it will be difficult to achieve regeneration of the cochlear function because these slow-cycling cells disappear in the mature murine cochlea.     

Proliferative Regeneration of Zebrafish Lateral Line Hair Cells after Different Ototoxic Insults

Sensory hair cells in the zebrafish lateral line regenerate rapidly and completely after damage. Previous studies have used a variety of ototoxins to kill lateral line hair cells to study different phenomena including mechanisms of hair cell death and regeneration. We sought to directly compare these ototoxins to determine if they differentially affected the rate and amount of hair cell replacement. In addition, previous studies have found evidence of proliferative hair cell regeneration in zebrafish, but both proliferation and non-mitotic direct transdifferentiation have been observed during hair cell regeneration in the sensory epithelia of birds and amphibians. We sought to test whether a similar combination of regenerative mechanisms exist in the fish. We analyzed the time course of regeneration after treatment with different ototoxic compounds and also labeled dividing hair cell progenitors. Certain treatments, including cisplatin and higher concentrations of dissolved copper, significantly delayed regeneration by one or more days. However, cisplatin did not block all regeneration as observed previously in the chick basilar papilla. The particular ototoxin did not appear to affect the mechanism of regeneration, as we observed evidence of recent proliferation in the majority of new hair cells in all cases. Inhibiting proliferation with flubendazole blocked the production of new hair cells and prevented the accumulation of additional precursors, indicating that proliferation has a dominant role during regeneration of lateral line hair cells.     

Basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-2) protects rat cochlear hair cells in organotypical culture from aminoglycoside injury

Given the evidence that basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-2) can protect neural and retinal cells from degeneration, we evaluated the potential of this growth factor to protect sensory cells in the inner ear. When sensory cells of the organ of Corti are exposed to aminoglycoside antibiotics such as neomycin either in vivo or in vitro, significant ototoxicity is observed. The in vitro cytotoxic effects of neomycin are dose and time dependent. In neonatal rat organ of Corti cultures, complete inner and outer hair cell destruction is observed at high (mM) concentrations of neomycin while inner hair cell survival and severely damaged outer hair cells are noted at moderate (μM) concentrations, with a maximal effect observed after 2 days of culture. Approximately 50% of cochlear outer hair cells are lost at a dose of 35 μM neomycin, and most surviving cells show disorganized stereocilia. Inner hair cells show primarily disorganization of their stereocilia. A significant protective effect is observed when the organ of Corti is pre-treated with FGF-2 (500 ng/ml) for 48 hours, and then FGF-2 is included with neomycin in the culture medium. A greater extent of outer hair cell survival and a significant decrease in stereociliary damage are noted with FGF-2. However, disorganization of inner hair cell stereocilia is unaffected by FGF-2. The protective effect of FGF-2 is specific, since interleukin-1B, nerve growth factor, tumor necrosis factor, and epidermal growth factor are ineffective, while retinoic acid and transforming growth factor alpha show only a moderate protective effect. These results confirm the potential of molecules like FGF-2 for preventing cell death due to a variety of causes. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The molecular basis of neurosensory cell formation in ear development: a blueprint for hair cell and sensory neuron regeneration?

The inner ear of mammals uses neurosensory cells derived from the embryonic ear for mechanoelectric transduction of vestibular and auditory stimuli (the hair cells) and conducts this information to the brain via sensory neurons. As with most other neurons of mammals, lost hair cells and sensory neurons are not spontaneously replaced and result instead in age-dependent progressive hearing loss. We review the molecular basis of neurosensory development in the mouse ear to provide a blueprint for possible enhancement of therapeutically useful transformation of stem cells into lost neurosensory cells. We identify several readily available adult sources of stem cells that express, like the ectoderm-derived ear, genes known to be essential for ear development. Use of these stem cells combined with molecular insights into neurosensory cell specification and proliferation regulation of the ear, might allow for neurosensory regeneration of mammalian ears in the near future.     

Heregulin enhances regenerative proliferation in postnatal rat utricular sensory epithelium after ototoxic damage

Hair cell loss due to acoustic and ototoxic damage often leads to hearing and balance impairments. Although a spontaneous event in chicks and lower vertebrates, hair cell replacement occurs at a much lower frequency in mammals presumably due to a very low rate of supporting cell proliferation following injury. We report here that heregulin, a member of the neuregulin family, dramatically enhances proliferation of supporting cells in postnatal rat utricular epithelial sheet cultures after gentamicin treatment, as revealed by bromo-deoxyuridine (BrdU) immunocytochemistry. A dose-dependent study shows that the maximal effects of heregulin are achieved at 3 nM. The mitogenic effects of heregulin are confirmed in utricular whole mount cultures. Autoradiography of the utricular whole mount cultures shows that heregulin also enhances the number of tritiated thymidine-labeled cells within the hair cell layer. TaqMan quantitative RT-PCR analysis and immunocytochemistry reveal that heregulin and its binding receptors (ErbB-2, ErbB-3 and ErbB-4) are expressed in the inner ear sensory epithelium. Of several ligands activating various ErbB receptors, including heregulin, neuregulin-3, β-cellulin, heparin binding-epidermal growth factor (HB-EGF), transforming growth factor-α (TGF-α) and EGF, heregulin shows the most potent mitogenic effects on supporting cells. Because neuregulin-3 that signals only through ErbB-4 does not show an effect, these data suggest that activation of the ErbB-2-ErbB-3 heterodimeric complexes, rather than ErbB-4, is critical for the proliferative response in the utricular sensory epithelium. In addition, gentamicin treatment induces an upregulation of heregulin mRNA. Considered together, heregulin may play an important role in hair cell regeneration following ototoxic damage.     

Cell Cycle,Differentiation and Regeneration: Where to Begin?

Hair cells, the sensory cells of inner ear, perform essential functions in hearing and balance. However, mammalian hair cells, like most of the CNS neurons, lack the capacity to regenerate. This is in sharp contrast to lower vertebrates in which hair cell regeneration occurs spontaneously through cell division of supporting cells, which leads to hearing restoration. It is believed that the lack of regeneration in mammals is, to a large degree, due to the block of cell cycle re-entry imposed by negative cell growth genes in the inner ear. Recent studies have identified retinoblastoma gene, a well-known tumor suppressor, as the key gene involved in cell cycle exit of inner ear sensory cells. In the inner ear of pRb conditional knockout mice, hair cells undergo continuous cell division, and at the same time differentiate and become functional. Cell division continues in early postnatal cochlea and adult vestibule. Remarkably, the vestibular hair cells without pRb survive, and function at both the cellular and system levels. The time course and effects of pRb inhibition shows that there is a separation between the roles of pRb in cell cycle exit, and subsequent maturation and apoptosis. Those studies reveal distinctly different roles of pRb in the cochlear and vestibular sensory epithelia. The review discusses additional areas to be studied for regeneration of mature hair cells, and highlights the importance of transient and reversible block of pRb function as one of the routes to be explored for regeneration.     

Hair cell regeneration

The mammalian inner ear largely lacks the capacity to regenerate hair cells, the sensory cells required for hearing and balance. Recent studies in both lower vertebrates and mammals have uncovered genes and pathways important in hair cell development and have suggested ways that the sensory epithelia could be manipulated to achieve hair cell regeneration. These approaches include the use of inner ear stem cells, transdifferentiation of nonsensory cells, and induction of a proliferative response in the cells that can become hair cells.     

Applying genomics to the avian inner ear: development of subtractive cDNA resources for exploring sensory function and hair cell regeneration

We applied a micro-cDNA-based subtraction method to identify genes expressed in the regenerating sensory epithelia (SE) of the chicken inner ear. Sensory hair cells in the avian utricle SE are in a constant state of turnover, where dying hair cells are replaced by new ones derived from supporting cells. In contrast, hair cells in the cochlea remain quiescent unless damaged. We used this difference to enrich for utricle-specific genes, using reiterative cDNA subtraction and demonstrate enrichment for utricle-specific sequences. A total of 1710 cDNA sequence reads revealed the presence of many cDNAs encoding known structural components of the SE (for example, Harmonin and beta-tectorin), proteins involved in cellular proliferation, such as P311, HIPK2, and SPALT1, among many others of unknown function. These libraries are the first of their kind and should prove useful for the discovery of candidate genes for hearing disorders, regenerative and apoptotic pathways, and novel chicken ESTs.     

Growth hormone promotes hair cell regeneration in the zebrafish (Danio rerio) inner ear following acoustic trauma

Background

Previous microarray analysis showed that growth hormone (GH) was significantly upregulated following acoustic trauma in the zebrafish (Danio rerio) ear suggesting that GH may play an important role in the process of auditory hair cell regeneration. Our objective was to examine the effects of exogenous and endogenous GH on zebrafish inner ear epithelia following acoustic trauma.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We induced auditory hair cell damage by exposing zebrafish to acoustic overstimulation. Fish were then injected intraperitoneally with either carp GH or buffer, and placed in a recovery tank for either one or two days. Phalloidin-, bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-, and TUNEL-labeling were used to examine hair cell densities, cell proliferation, and apoptosis, respectively. Two days post-trauma, saccular hair cell densities in GH-treated fish were similar to that of baseline controls, whereas buffer-injected fish showed significantly reduced densities of hair cell bundles. Cell proliferation was greater and apoptosis reduced in the saccules, lagenae, and utricles of GH-treated fish one day following trauma compared to controls. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was used to examine the localization of GH mRNA in the zebrafish ear. At one day post-trauma, GH mRNA expression appeared to be localized perinuclearly around erythrocytes in the blood vessels of the inner ear epithelia. In order to examine the effects of endogenous GH on the process of cell proliferation in the ear, a GH antagonist was injected into zebrafish immediately following acoustic trauma, resulting in significantly decreased cell proliferation one day post-trauma in all three zebrafish inner ear end organs.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results show that exogenous GH promotes post-trauma auditory hair cell regeneration in the zebrafish ear through stimulating proliferation and suppressing apoptosis, and that endogenous GH signals are present in the zebrafish ear during the process of auditory hair cell regeneration.     

Effects of retinoid and thyroid receptors during development of the inner ear

The sensory epithelia of the vertebrate inner ear are comprised of a complex pattern of hair cells and supporting cells. Several different families of signaling molecules have been shown to play a role in the development and maintenance of this structure. In particular, the steroid/thyroid receptor superfamily, and specifically retinoid and thyroid receptors appear to influence the determination, differentiation, maintenance, and possibly regeneration, of the sensory epithelia of the vertebrate inner ear. Clinical and experimental evidence demonstrates that changes in the relative availability of retinoic acid and thyroid hormone, the ligands for retinoid and thyroid receptors, result in perturbations in the development of hair cell sensory epithelia. Retinoic acid and retinoid receptors appear to play a role in early developmental events including cellular proliferation and determination whereas thyroid hormone and thyroid receptors appear to play a role in later events including differentiation and maintenance.     

Neurotransmission in the vestibular endorgans--glutamatergic transmission in the afferent synapses of hair cells.

In the sensory pathways the first synapse is that between hair cells and primary afferent neurons and its most likely neurotransmitter candidate has long been thought to be glutamate. A number of pharmacological and electrophysiological studies have lent credence to this theory (reviewed by Bledsoe et al. 1988, Bobbin 1979, Ehrenberger and Felix 1991, Puel et al. 1991; Puel 1995) as has recent neurochemical and immunocytochemical work (reviewed by Ottersen et al. 1998; Usami et al. 2000). These recent studies reveal that the afferent hair cell synapse resembles the central glutamate synapses in many ways. Of the proteins confirmed to be involved in signal transduction and transmitter metabolism at most central synapses, many are also seen in the afferent hair cell synapse, and have an analogous compartmentation. On the other hand, there are also important differences, especially those related to the molecular mechanisms that underlie transmitter release.     

Profiling drug-induced cell death pathways in the zebrafish lateral line

Programmed cell death (PCD) is an important process in development and disease, as it allows the body to rid itself of unwanted or damaged cells. However, PCD pathways can also be activated in otherwise healthy cells. One such case occurs in sensory hair cells of the inner ear following exposure to ototoxic drugs, resulting in hearing loss and/or balance disorders. The intracellular pathways that determine if hair cells die or survive following this or other ototoxic challenges are incompletely understood. We use the larval zebrafish lateral line, an external hair cell-bearing sensory system, as a platform for profiling cell death pathways activated in response to ototoxic stimuli. In this report the importance of each pathway was assessed by screening a custom cell death inhibitor library for instances when pathway inhibition protected hair cells from the aminoglycosides neomycin or gentamicin, or the chemotherapy agent cisplatin. This screen revealed that each ototoxin likely activated a distinct subset of possible cell death pathways. For example, the proteasome inhibitor Z-LLF-CHO protected hair cells from either aminoglycoside or from cisplatin, while d-methionine, an antioxidant, protected hair cells from gentamicin or cisplatin but not from neomycin toxicity. The calpain inhibitor leupeptin primarily protected hair cells from neomycin, as did a Bax channel blocker. Neither caspase inhibition nor protein synthesis inhibition altered the progression of hair cell death. Taken together, these results suggest that ototoxin-treated hair cells die via multiple processes that form an interactive network of cell death signaling cascades.