Conversion of Deletions during Recombination in Pneumococcal Transformation

Genetic analysis of 16 deletions obtained in the amiA locus of pneumococcus is described. When present on donor DNA, all deletions increased drastically the frequency of wild-type recombinants in two-point crosses. This effect was maximal for deletions longer than 200 bases. It was reduced for heterologies shorter than 76 bases and did not exist for very short deletions. In three-point crosses in which the deletion was localized between two point mutations, we demonstrated that this excess of wild-type recombinants was the result of a genetic conversion. This conversion extended over several scores of bases outside the deletion. Conversion takes place during the heteroduplex stage of recombination. Therefore, in pneumococcal transformation, long heterologies participated in this heteroduplex configuration. As this conversion did not require an active DNA polymerase A gene it is proposed that the mechanism of conversion is not a DNA repair synthesis but involves breakage and ligation between DNA molecules. Conversion of deletions did not require the Hex system of correction of mismatched bases. It differs also from localized conversion. It appears that it is a process that evolved to correct errors of replication which lead to long heterologies and which are not eliminated by other systems.     

Effects of DNA Heterologies on Bacteriophage λ Recombination

Previous studies of bacteriophage λ recombination have provided indirect evidence that substantial sequence nonhomologies, such as insertions and deletions, may be included in regions of heteroduplex DNA. However, the direct products of heterology-containing heteroduplex DNA--heterozygous progeny phage--have not been observed. We have constructed a series of small insertion and deletion mutations in the cI gene to examine the possibility that small heterologies might be accommodated in heterozygous progeny phage. Genetic crosses were carried out between λcI(-) Oam29 and λcI(+) Pam80 under replication-restricted conditions. Recombinant O(+)P(+) progeny were selected on mutL hosts and tested for cI heterozygosity. Heterozygous recombinants were readily observed with crosses involving insertions of 4 to 19 base pairs (bp) in the cI gene. Thus, nonhomologies of at least 19 bp can be accommodated in regions of heteroduplex DNA during λ recombination. In contrast, when a cI insertion or deletion mutation of 26 bp was present, few of the selected recombinants were heterozygous for cI. Results using a substitution mutation, involving a 26-bp deletion with a 22-bp insertion, suggest that the low recovery of cI heterozygotes containing heterologies of 26 bp or more is due to a failure to encapsidate DNA containing heterologies of 26 bp or more into viable phage particles.     

Slipped Misalignment Mechanisms of Deletion Formation: In Vivo Susceptibility to Nucleases

Misalignment of repeated sequences during DNA replication can lead to deletions or duplications in genomic DNA. In Escherichia coli, such genetic rearrangements can occur at high frequencies, independent of the RecA-homologous recombination protein, and are sometimes associated with sister chromosome exchange (SCE). Two mechanisms for RecA-independent genetic rearrangements have been proposed: simple replication misalignment of the nascent strand and its template and SCE-associated misalignment involving both nascent strands. We examined the influence of the 3′ exonuclease of DNA polymerase III and exonuclease I on deletion via these mechanisms in vivo. Because mutations in these exonucleases stimulate tandem repeat deletion, we conclude that displaced 3′ ends are a common intermediate in both mechanisms of slipped misalignments. Our results also confirm the notion that two distinct mechanisms contribute to slipped misalignments: simple replication misalignment events are sensitive to DNA polymerase III exonuclease, whereas SCE-associated events are sensitive to exonuclease I. If heterologies are present between repeated sequences, the mismatch repair system dependent on MutS and MutH aborts potential deletion events via both mechanisms. Our results suggest that simple slipped misalignment and SCE-associated misalignment intermediates are similarly susceptible to destruction by the mismatch repair system.     

Large Heterologies Impose Their Gene Conversion Pattern onto Closely Linked Point Mutations

We have studied the meiotic non-Mendelian segregation (NMS) pattern of seven large heterologous combinations located in the b2 ascospore gene of Ascobolus. The NMS patterns of these aberration heterozygotes widely differ from each other and from those of point mutations located in the same genetic region. They give lower gene conversion frequencies than point mutations, no postmeiotic segregations (PMS), and either parity or disparity that favors the wild type allele. Two related deletions, G234 and G40, were studied for their effects on the conversion behavior of closely linked point mutations. We found that, when heterozygous, the deletions impose their own NMS pattern onto close mutations. These effects occur on both sides of the heterologies. The effects upon PMS and disparity of linked point mutations gradually disappear as point mutations become more distant. The effects on NMS frequencies and on aberrant 4:4 are polar. They persist for all mutations located downstream from the high conversion end of the gene. This last effect can reflect a blockage of symmetric hDNA formation by large heterologies, whereas the epistasis of the NMS pattern of large heterologies over that of closely linked point mutations suggests that large heterologies and point mutations undergo conversion by means of distinct pathways.     

Meiotic deletion at the BUF1 locus of the fungus Magnaporthe grisea is controlled by interaction with the homologous chromosome.

The Magnaporthe grisea BUF1 gene suffers high-frequency mutation in certain genetic crosses, resulting in buff-colored progeny. Analysis of 16 buf1 mutants arising from a cross with a mutation frequency of 25% revealed that, in every case, the BUF1 gene was deleted. The deletions occurred in only one of the parental chromosomes and were due to intrachromosomal recombination. Tetrad analysis revealed that deletions occurred in 44% of meioses and usually affected both chromatids of the mutable chromosome. This suggests that they happen before the premeiotic round of DNA synthesis. However, they were also almost entirely restricted to heteroallelic crosses. This, together with the discovery of numerous repetitive elements that were present only in the mutable BUF1 locus, suggests that the deletion process is sensitive to pairing interactions between homologous chromosomes, such that only unpaired loci are subject to deletion. Given that karyogamy is not supposed to occur until after premeiotic DNA replication in Pyrenomycetous fungi such as M. grisea, this latter observation would place the time of deletion during, or after, DNA synthesis. These conflicting results suggest that karyogamy might actually precede DNA replication in Pyrenomycetous fungi or that parts of the genome remain unreplicated until after karyogamy and subsequent chromosome pairing have taken place.     

Genetic mapping and characteristics of the actinophage phi C31 deletion mutants of Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2) incapable of lysogenization

Actinophage phi C31 deletion c mutants with impaired ability to make repressor were genetically studied. Genetic crosses indicate that the c28 deletion mutant is situated with the c-region of the phi C31 genetic map. Based on the results of a qualitive test for recombination between several c mutants, a scheme of their order relative to deletion mutants was presented. The approximate distances between eight c mutants have been represented in units of the physical DNA map estimation. Genetic studies of actinophage lyg deletion mutants which cannot lysogenize sensitive cultures were carried out. Mutants failed to lysogenize upon mixed infection with lyg+ phages. The absence of the effect of lyg+ gene in trans suggests that lyg deletions cause a structural defect in an integration site of the phage. Preliminary data on alignment of lyg positions on physical and genetic maps of phi C31 phage have been obtained. According to evidence from genetic crosses, lyg mutation has been located in the right half of the phi C31 genome.     

Impairment of lagging strand synthesis triggers the formation of a RuvABC substrate at replication forks

The holD gene codes for the psi subunit of the Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, a component of the gamma complex clamp loader. A holD mutant was isolated for the first time in a screen for mutations that increase the frequency of tandem repeat deletions. In contrast to tandem repeat deletions in wild-type strains, deletion events stimulated by the holD mutation require RecA. They do not require RecF, and hence do not result from the recombinational repair of gaps, arguing against uncoupling of the leading and lagging strand polymerases in the holD mutant. The holD recBC combination of mutations is lethal and holD recBts recCts strains suffer DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) at restrictive temperature. DSBs require the presence of the Holliday junction-specific enzymes RuvABC and are prevented in the presence of RecBCD. We propose that impairment of replication due to the holD mutation causes the arrest of the entire replisome; consequently, Holliday junctions are formed by replication fork reversal, and unequal crossing over during RecA- and RecBCD-mediated re-incorporation of reversed forks causes the hyper-recombination phenotype.     

Mitotic gene conversion of large DNA heterologies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Summary Gene conversion of large DNA heterologous fragments has been shown to take place efficiently in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It has been found that a 2.6 kb LEU2 DNA fragment in a multicopy plasmid was replaced by a 3.1 kb PG11 chromosomal DNA fragment, when both fragments were flanked by homologous DNA regions. Gene conversion was asymmetric in a total of 481 recombinants analyzed. In contrast, truncated PG11 or LEU2 genes in multicopy plasmids, gave no recombinants that restored a complete plasmid copy of these genes in a total of 242 recombinants studied, confirming that a conversion tract is disrupted by a heterologous region. The asymmetry of the events detected suggest that gene conversion of large DNA heterologies involves a process whereby a gap first covers one heterologous fragment and then this is followed by new DNA synthesis using the other heterologous fragment as a template. Therefore, it is likely that large DNA heterologies are converted by a double-strand gap repair mechanism.     

Mutants Affecting Processing of DNA in Macronuclear Development in Paramecium

In Paramecium tetraurelia, stock 51, the A surface protein is coded by the wild type A51 gene, present in micronuclei in two copies and in macronuclei in about 1500 copies. DNA processing, comprised of DNA cleavage, copy number amplification and telomere addition occurs at autogamy and conjugation when old macronuclei degrade and new macronuclei are formed from micronuclei. In this paper we characterize mutants with macronuclear A gene deletions. These mutants are notable in three respects. First, the mutants do not appear to be simple micronuclear deletions. Although genetic analysis shows that the d12 mutant d12(-1300) is homozygous for the allele A-1300 and the mutant d12(+1) for A+1, analysis by the polymerase chain reaction indicates that the micronuclei in these two mutants contain intact, but presumably altered, micronuclear A genes. They undergo deletion during DNA processing when new macronuclei are formed. Second, the position of the deletions in these alleles has been shown to change. The deficiency present in the d12 allele A-1300 was originally determined to extend from position -1300 (relative to the start of translation of the A gene) to the end of the chromosome. Later, a derivative of this strain, homozygous for the d12 allele A+1 was isolated in which the start site of the deletion was found to have moved from -1300 to +1. Third, a surprising interaction occurs in crosses between a line homozygous for the d12 allele and one homozygous for the wild-type A51 allele. Previous work on the non-Mendelian d48 mutant (which has intact A51 genes in its micronucleus, but has truncated A51 genes in its macronucleus) has shown that intact A51 alleles must be present in the old macronucleus in order for A51 alleles to undergo proper processing. We find that d12 alleles act on A51 alleles in heterozygotes such that intact macronuclear A genes are no longer required for proper processing of A51. Thus, in crosses of 51 x d12 (either +1 or -1300) d12 exconjugants, as well as 51 exconjugants, give rise to clones carrying both intact A51 and truncated d12 alleles. Remarkably the d12 alleles, which are themselves deleted during processing, are capable in the heterozygote of fostering normal processing of the A51 allele.     

Defining the roles of the N-terminal region and the helicase activity of RECQ4A in DNA repair and homologous recombination in Arabidopsis

RecQ helicases are critical for the maintenance of genomic stability. The Arabidopsis RecQ helicase RECQ4A is the functional counterpart of human BLM, which is mutated in the genetic disorder Bloom’s syndrome. RECQ4A performs critical roles in regulation of homologous recombination (HR) and DNA repair. Loss of RECQ4A leads to elevated HR frequencies and hypersensitivity to genotoxic agents. Through complementation studies, we were now able to demonstrate that the N-terminal region and the helicase activity of RECQ4A are both essential for the cellular response to replicative stress induced by methyl methanesulfonate and cisplatin. In contrast, loss of helicase activity or deletion of the N-terminus only partially complemented the mutant hyper-recombination phenotype. Furthermore, the helicase-deficient protein lacking its N-terminus did not complement the hyper-recombination phenotype at all. Therefore, RECQ4A seems to possess at least two different and independent sub-functions involved in the suppression of HR. By in vitro analysis, we showed that the helicase core was able to regress an artificial replication fork. Swapping of the terminal regions of RECQ4A with the closely related but functionally distinct helicase RECQ4B indicated that in contrast to the C-terminus, the N-terminus of RECQ4A was required for its specific functions in DNA repair and recombination.     

Analysis of eighteen deletion breakpoints in the parkin gene

Parkin mutations are responsible for the pathogenesis of autosomal-recessive juvenile parkinsonism (AR-JP). On initial screening of Japanese patients with AR-JP, we had found that approximately half of the parkin mutations are deletions occurring between exons 2 and 5, forming a deletion hot spot. In this study, we investigated the deletion breakpoints of the parkin mutations in 22 families with AR-JP and examined the possible association between these deletion events and meiotic recombinations. We identified 18 deletion breakpoints at the DNA nucleotide sequence level. Almost all these deletions were different, indicating that the deletion hot spot was generated by recurrent but independent events. We found no association between the deletions and specific DNA elements. Recent copy number variation (CNV) data from various ethnic groups showed that the deletion hot spot is overlapped by a highly polymorphic CNV region, indicating that the recurrent deletion mutation or CNV is observable worldwide. By comparing Marshfield and deCODE linkage maps, we found that the parkin deletion hot spot may be associated with a meiotic recombination hot spot, although such association was not found on comparison with recent high-resolution genetic maps generated from the International HapMap project. Here, we discuss the possible mechanisms for deletion hot spot formation and its effects on human genomes.     

Molecular Genetics of the Brown (B)-Locus Region of Mouse Chromosome 4. II. Complementation Analyses of Lethal Brown Deletions

Numerous new mutations at the brown (b) locus in mouse chromosome 4 have been recovered over the years in germ-cell mutagenesis experiments performed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory. A large series of radiation- and chemical-induced b mutations known to be chromosomal deletions, and also known to be prenatally lethal when homozygous, were analyzed by pairwise complementation crosses as well as by pseudodominance tests involving flanking loci defined by externally visible phenotypes. These crosses were designed to determine the extent of each deletion on the genetic and phenotype map of the chromosomal region surrounding the b locus; the crosses also provided basic data that assigned deletions to complementation groups and defined four new loci associated with aberrancies in normal development. Specifically, the pseudodominance tests identified deletions that include the proximally mapping whirler (wi) and the distally mapping depilated (dep) genes, thereby bracketing these loci defined by visible developmental abnormalities with landmarks (deletion breakpoints) that are easily identified on the physical map. Furthermore, the complementation crosses, which were supplemented with additional crosses that allowed determination of the gross time of lethality of selected deletions, defined four new loci required for normal development. Homozygous deletion of one of these loci (b-associated fitness, baf) results in a runting syndrome evident during postnatal development; deletion of one locus [l(4)2Rn] causes death in the late gestation/neonatal period; and deletion of either of two loci [l(4)1Rn or l(4)3Rn] results in embryonic death, most likely in pre-, peri- or postimplantation stages. The placement of these new functionally defined loci on the evolving molecular map of the b region should be useful for continuing the analysis of the roles played in development by genes in this segment of chromosome 4.     

Incorporation of large heterologies into heteroduplex DNA during double-strand-break repair in mouse cells

In this study, the formation and repair of large (>1 kb) insertion/deletion (I/D) heterologies during double-strand-break repair (DSBR) was investigated using a gene-targeting assay that permits efficient recovery of sequence insertion events at the haploid chromosomal immunoglobulin (Ig) mu-locus in mouse hybridoma cells. The results revealed that (i) large I/D heterologies were generated on one or both sides of the DSB and, in some cases, formed symmetrically in both homology regions; (ii) large I/D heterologies did not negatively affect the gene targeting frequency; and (iii) prior to DNA replication, the large I/D heterologies were rectified.     

Optimizing the design of oligonucleotides for homology directed gene targeting

Background

Gene targeting depends on the ability of cells to use homologous recombination to integrate exogenous DNA into their own genome. A robust mechanistic model of homologous recombination is necessary to fully exploit gene targeting for therapeutic benefit.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this work, our recently developed numerical simulation model for homology search is employed to develop rules for the design of oligonucleotides used in gene targeting. A Metropolis Monte-Carlo algorithm is used to predict the pairing dynamics of an oligonucleotide with the target double-stranded DNA. The model calculates the base-alignment between a long, target double-stranded DNA and a probe nucleoprotein filament comprised of homologous recombination proteins (Rad51 or RecA) polymerized on a single strand DNA. In this study, we considered different sizes of oligonucleotides containing 1 or 3 base heterologies with the target; different positions on the probe were tested to investigate the effect of the mismatch position on the pairing dynamics and stability. We show that the optimal design is a compromise between the mean time to reach a perfect alignment between the two molecules and the stability of the complex.

Conclusion and Significance

A single heterology can be placed anywhere without significantly affecting the stability of the triplex. In the case of three consecutive heterologies, our modeling recommends using long oligonucleotides (at least 35 bases) in which the heterologous sequences are positioned at an intermediate position. Oligonucleotides should not contain more than 10% consecutive heterologies to guarantee a stable pairing with the target dsDNA. Theoretical modeling cannot replace experiments, but we believe that our model can considerably accelerate optimization of oligonucleotides for gene therapy by predicting their pairing dynamics with the target dsDNA.     

Analysis of repeat-mediated deletions in the mitochondrial genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mitochondrial DNA deletions and point mutations accumulate in an age-dependent manner in mammals. The mitochondrial genome in aging humans often displays a 4977-bp deletion flanked by short direct repeats. Additionally, direct repeats flank two-thirds of the reported mitochondrial DNA deletions. The mechanism by which these deletions arise is unknown, but direct-repeat-mediated deletions involving polymerase slippage, homologous recombination, and nonhomologous end joining have been proposed. We have developed a genetic reporter to measure the rate at which direct-repeat-mediated deletions arise in the mitochondrial genome of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here we analyze the effect of repeat size and heterology between repeats on the rate of deletions. We find that the dependence on homology for repeat-mediated deletions is linear down to 33 bp. Heterology between repeats does not affect the deletion rate substantially. Analysis of recombination products suggests that the deletions are produced by at least two different pathways, one that generates only deletions and one that appears to generate both deletions and reciprocal products of recombination. We discuss how this reporter may be used to identify the proteins in yeast that have an impact on the generation of direct-repeat-mediated deletions.     

Roles of double-strand breaks, nicks, and gaps in stimulating deletions of CTG.CAG repeats by intramolecular DNA repair

A series of plasmids harboring CTG.CAG repeats with double-strand breaks (DSB), single-strand nicks, or single-strand gaps (15 or 30 nucleotides) within the repeat regions were used to determine their capacity to induce genetic instabilities. These plasmids were introduced into Escherichia coli in the presence of a second plasmid containing a sequence that could support homologous recombination repair between the two plasmids. The transfer of a point mutation from the second to the first plasmid was used to monitor homologous recombination (gene conversion). Only DSBs increased the overall genetic instability. This instability took place by intramolecular repair, which was not dependent on RuvA. Double-strand break-induced instabilities were partially stabilized by a mutation in recF. Gaps of 30 nt formed a distinct 30 nt deletion product, whereas single strand nicks and gaps of 15 nt did not induce expansions or deletions. Formation of this deletion product required the CTG.CAG repeats to be present in the single-stranded region and was stimulated by E.coli DNA ligase, but was not dependent upon the RecFOR pathway. Models are presented to explain the intramolecular repair-induced instabilities and the formation of the 30 nt deletion product.     

Molecular processes of chromosome 9p21 deletions causing inactivation of the p16 tumor suppressor gene in human cancer: deduction from structural analysis of breakpoints for deletions

Chromosome interstitial deletion (i.e., deletion of a chromosome segment in a chromosome arm) is a critical genetic event for the inactivation of tumor suppressor genes and activation of oncogenes leading to the carcinogenic conversion of human cells. The deletion at chromosome 9p21 removing the p16 tumor suppressor gene is a genetic alteration frequently observed in a variety of human cancers. Thus, structural analyses of breakpoints for p16 deletions in several kinds of human cancers have been performed to elucidate the molecular process of chromosome interstitial deletion consisting of formation of DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) and subsequent joining of DNA ends in human cells. The results indicated that DSBs triggering deletions in lymphoid leukemia are formed at a few defined sites by illegitimate action of the RAG protein complex, while DSBs in solid tumors are formed at unspecific sites by factors unidentified yet. In both types of tumors, the intra-nuclear architecture of chromatin was considered to affect the susceptibility of genomic segments of the p16 locus to DSBs. Broken DNA ends were joined by non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) repair in both types of tumors, however, microhomologies of DNA ends were preferentially utilized in the joining in solid tumors but not in lymphoid leukemia. The configuration of broken DNA ends as well as NHEJ activity in cells was thought to underlie the features of joining. Further structural analysis of other hot spots of chromosomal DNA breaks as well as the evaluation of the activity and specificity of NHEJ in human cells will elucidate the mechanisms of chromosome interstitial deletions in human cells.     

RecA-mediated strand exchange traverses substitutional heterologies more easily than deletions or insertions

RecA protein in bacteria and its eukaryotic homolog Rad51 protein are responsible for initiation of strand exchange between homologous DNA molecules. This process is crucial for homologous recombination, the repair of certain types of DNA damage and for the reinitiation of DNA replication on collapsed replication forks. We show here, using two different types of in vitro assays, that in the absence of ATP hydrolysis RecA-mediated strand exchange traverses small substitutional heterologies between the interacting DNAs, whereas small deletions or insertions block the ongoing strand exchange. We discuss evolutionary implications of RecA selectivity against insertions and deletions and propose a molecular mechanism by which RecA can exert this selectivity.     

Construction and characterization of deletions with defined end points in Drosophila using P elements in trans

We used P-element transposase-mediated "male recombination" between two P elements in trans to create genetic deletions that removed a number of loci, including the gene encoding the neuropeptide crustacean cardioactive peptide (CCAP). Two classes of recombinant chromosomes were produced. Approximately one-quarter were viable when homozygous or hemizygous, whereas the remaining lines caused homozygous and hemizygous lethality. Preliminary analyses using PCR and CCAP immunohistochemistry suggested that, whereas the DNA of the viable lines was largely intact, most lethal lines contained chromosomal deletions that were roughly bounded by the insertion sites of the two P elements used. Southern blot analyses of select lethal lines showed that the DNA flanking the deletion was indeed grossly intact whereas the intervening DNA could not be detected. Sequencing across the deletion in three of these lethal lines identified a single line bearing intact genomic DNA on either side of the deletion separated by 30 bp of P-element DNA. The method described here suggests a simple procedure for creating deletions with defined end points. Importantly, it can use preexisting P-element insertion strains and does not rely on the use of transposable elements that are engineered to cause specific DNA rearrangements.