Frozen F1's amidst a masterpiece of nature: new insights into the rare hybrid origin of gynogenesis in the Amazon molly (Poecilia formosa)

All‐female ‘species’ of fish have been shown to be great models in ecological and evolutionary studies because of the insights they can provide into the origin and evolution of asexuality, the ecology of hybrids, associations between genotype and environment, and the maintenance of sex. Gynogenetic organisms that evolved from sexual ancestors, and combine the disadvantageous traits from sexuality and asexuality, have long baffled evolutionary biologists trying to understand their origin and persistence with their sympatric sexual counterparts. In this issue, a new study using an integrated molecular phylogenetic and classical genetic approach has uncovered compelling evidence regarding the obscure asexual origin of the Amazon molly, Poecilia formosa. By performing an extensive phylogeographic analysis, Stöck et al. (2010) provide evidence that the Amazon molly arose only once within its history, with monophyly being strongly supported by mitochondrial DNA and microsatellite analyses. This result, combined with an elaborate failed attempt to resynthesize the lineage, suggests that vertebrate gynogens such as the Amazon molly are not rare because they are at a disadvantage to their sexual counterparts, but because the genomic conditions under which they arise are rare. Organisms that apparently combine the disadvantages of both sexuality and asexuality remain difficult to understand from both an ecological and an evolutionary perspective, and Stöck et al. (2010) highlight several outstanding important questions. Nonetheless, given that we now have a better knowledge of the origin and history of this unique ‘species’, this should allow researchers to better understand how these frozen F1’s can persist amidst the masterpiece of nature.     

Allozyme analysis and phyletic relationships of two new stick-insects from north-west Sicily: Bacillus grandii benazzii and B. rossius-grandii benazzii (Insecta Phasmatodea)

Two new Sicilian stick-insects have been discovered within the genus Bacillus. Evidence concerning the subspecific differentiation of Bacillus grandii benazzii and the hybrid constitution of B. rossius-grandii benazzii by means of allozyme analysis is given, and is consistent with morphological and karyological data on the differentiation of these two north-west Sicilian morphs from south-eastern B. g. grandii and B. whitei. B. g. benazzii is more polymorphic than B. g. grandii and B. rossius-g. benazzii embodies its genetic variability, thus differing sharply from the south-eastern parallel hybrid B. whitei ( = B. rossius × B. g. grandii). Reproductive mechanisms also appear to be different in the two interspecific hybrids, involving parthenogenesis in the latter and hybridogenesis in the former. Finally, the phyletic relationships among all Sicilian Bacillus taxa are summarized in a revised scheme, which also takes into account new evidence that B. atticus has contributed to hybrid constitution of the triploid B. lynceorum.     

Sex ratio, reproductive mode and genetic diversity in Triops cancriformis

1. Aquatic invertebrates display a wide array of alternative reproductive modes from apomixis to hermaphroditism and cyclical parthenogenesis. These have important effects on genetic diversity and population structure. Populations of the 'living fossil' Triops cancriformis display a range of sex ratios, and various reproductive modes are thought to underlie this variation. Using sex ratio information and histological analyses European populations have been inferred to be gonochoric (with separate males and females), selfing hermaphroditic and androdioecious, a rare reproductive mode in which selfing hermaphrodites coexist with variable proportions of males. In addition, some populations have been described as meiotic parthenogens.
2. Here we use population genetic analysis using microsatellite loci in populations with a range of sex ratios including a gonochoric population, and marker segregation patterns in heterozygote individuals reared in isolation, to clarify the reproductive mode in this species.
3. Our data show that populations in general have very low levels of genetic diversity. Non-gonochoric populations show lower genetic diversity, more heterozygote deficiencies, higher inbreeding coefficients and stronger linkage disequilibria than the gonochoric population. The maintenance of some heterozygosity in populations is consistent with some male influence in T. cancriformis populations, as would be expected from an androdioecious reproductive system. Results of marker segregation in eggs produced in isolation from non-gonochoric populations indicate that meiosis occurs and are consistent with two reproductive modes: selfing hermaphroditism and a type of ameiotic parthenogenesis.
4. Overall, our data indicate that androdioecy and selfing hermaphroditism are the most likely reproductive modes of non-gonochoric European Triops populations. Triops populations are strongly structured, suggesting high genetic drift and low levels of gene flow.     

Automictic parthenogenesis of a geographically parthenogenetic mayfly,Ephoron shigae (Insecta: Ephemeroptera,Polymitarcyidae)

In the geographically parthenogenetic mayfly, Ephoron shigae, egg maturation and counts of chromosome number of unfertilized, parthenogenetic eggs were studied, in comparison with fertilized eggs from a bisexual population. The primary oocyte becomes mature through two successive maturation divisions. The first maturation division (meiotic division) takes place in the primary oocyte to produce a secondary oocyte and a first polar body. The second maturation division soon occurs in the secondary oocyte, in which the nucleus is divided into a mature egg nucleus (female pronucleus) and second polar body nuclei. The first polar body, in some cases, was successively divided into two polar bodies; in other instances, it was not divided. After the successive maturation division, the egg nucleus and the sister second polar body nucleus drew near to fuse into the zygote nucleus. The chromosome number was doubled in the zygote, and this conjugation initiates subsequent embryonic development. This suggests that, in E. shigae, the process of parthenogenetic recovery of diploidy is the automictic type categorized as the ‘terminal fusion’ pattern. © 2009 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2010, 99 , 335–343.     

The evolution of meiotic sex and its alternatives

Meiosis is an ancestral, highly conserved process in eukaryotic life cycles, and for all eukaryotes the shared component of sexual reproduction. The benefits and functions of meiosis, however, are still under discussion, especially considering the costs of meiotic sex. To get a novel view on this old problem, we filter out the most conserved elements of meiosis itself by reviewing the various modifications and alterations of modes of reproduction. Our rationale is that the indispensable steps of meiosis for viability of offspring would be maintained by strong selection, while dispensable steps would be variable. We review evolutionary origin and processes in normal meiosis, restitutional meiosis, polyploidization and the alterations of meiosis in forms of uniparental reproduction (apomixis, apomictic parthenogenesis, automixis, selfing) with a focus on plants and animals. This overview suggests that homologue pairing, double-strand break formation and homologous recombinational repair at prophase I are the least dispensable elements, and they are more likely optimized for repair of oxidative DNA damage rather than for recombination. Segregation, ploidy reduction and also a biparental genome contribution can be skipped for many generations. The evidence supports the theory that the primary function of meiosis is DNA restoration rather than recombination.     

Cytonuclear evidence for hybridogenetic reproduction in natural populations of the Australian carp gudgeon (Hypseleotris: Eleotridae)

Although most vertebrates reproduce sexually, a small number of fishes, amphibians and reptiles are known in which reproduction is asexual, i.e. without meiotic recombination. In fishes, these so-called unisexual lineages usually comprise only females and utilize co-occurring males of a related sexual species to reproduce via gynogenesis or hybridogenesis. Here, we examine patterns of microsatellite and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) variation in a widespread group of freshwater fishes (carp gudgeons; Hypseleotris spp.) to investigate a long-standing proposal that this group includes unisexual forms. We show that the mtDNA genome of most carp gudgeons in tributaries of the Goulburn River belongs to one of two deeply divided clades (～10% cyt b divergence) and that nuclear variation divides the same individuals into four distinct groups. Group 1 exhibits the genotypic proportions of a random mating population and has a 1:1 sex ratio. Two other groups are extremely sex-biased (98% male, 96% female), exhibit excess heterozygosity at most loci and share at least one allele per locus with group 1. We propose that these two groups represent 'unisexual' hybridogenetic lineages and that both utilize co-occurring group 1 as sexual host. Interestingly, the fourth distinct group appears to represent hybrid offspring of the two putative hybridogenetic lineages. The propagation of clonal haploid genomes by both males and females and the ability of these clones to unite and form sexually mature diploid hybrid offspring may represent a novel mechanism that contributes to the dynamics of coexistence between hybridogenetic lineages and their sexual hosts.     

Specific features of early embryogenesis in apomictic <Emphasis Type="Italic">Poa pratensis</Emphasis> L.

We studied the early stages of embryo formation in apomictic Poa pratensis L. It was shown that during transition to parthenogenesis, at least at the initial stages of embryogenesis, the algorithm of development of the sexual embryo is preserved. This could be due to the system of genetic control of embryogenesis, common for amphimixis and apomixis. We described asynchrony of developmental processes both within the efflorescence (asynchronous maturation of seed-buds) and within the seed-bud and even gametophyte (different timing of induction of apoarchesporic initials and oospores). This feature of pseudogamous apomicts allows them to produce simultaneously both sexual and apomictic progenies.     

Evolutionary genetics and ecology of sperm-dependent parthenogenesis

Sperm-dependent (or pseudogamous) forms of parthenogenetic reproduction occur in a wide variety of animals. Inheritance is typically clonal and matroclinous (of female descent), but sperm are needed to initiate normal development. As opposed to true parthenogenesis (i.e., sperm-independent reproduction), pseudogamous parthenogenetic lineages must coexist with a ‘sperm donor’— e.g., males from a conspecific sexual lineage, conspecific hermaphrodites, or males from a closely related sexual species. Such sperm donors do not contribute genetically to the next generation. The parasitic nature of sperm-dependent parthenogenesis raises numerous ecological and evolutionary questions. How do they arise? What factors help stabilize coexistence between the pseudogamous parthenogens and their sperm donors (i.e., ‘sexual hosts’)? Why do males waste sperm on the asexual females? Why does true parthenogenesis not evolve in pseudogamous lineages and free them from their dependency on sperm donors? Does pseudogamous parthenogenesis provide compensatory benefits that outweigh the constraints of sperm-dependence? Herein, we consider some genetic, ecological, and geographical consequences of sperm-dependent parthenogenesis in animals.     

GYNOGENETIC REPRODUCTION IN HYBRID MOLE SALAMANDERS (GENUS AMBYSTOMA)

Ambystoma platineum, a unisexual clonal triploid taxon of mole salamander, originated by hybridization between the Mendelian species A. jeffersonianum and A. laterale. Studies of lampbrush chromosomes indicated that A. platineum reproduces gynogenetically, that is, sperm from a sexual host species is required to activate egg development but makes no genetic contribution to the developing embryo. Nevertheless, electrophoretic diversity in populations of some hybrid Ambystoma suggested continual in situ recreation of unisexual hybrids and bidirectional gene exchange between the parental species and the hybrids. A. platineum usually lives with, and is sexually dependent on, one of its parental species, A. jeffersonianum. In central Indiana, however, A. platineum populations have shifted their host dependency to A. texanum. Such A. texanum-dependent populations of A. platineum provide an almost ideal system for studying reproductive mode in A. platineum, because both replacement of a jeffersonianum or laterale genome of A. platineum by a texanum genome, and movement of genes from A. platineum to the host species, A. texanum, would be readily detected by electrophoretic markers. Our samples of A. texanum provided no evidence for the transfer of jeffersonianum or laterale genes into A. texanum. Similarly, among 32 A. platineum sampled from six localities in east-central Illinois and central Indiana, we find no texanum alleles, and thus no evidence for genome replacement. The one diploid hybrid individual contained only a jeffersonianum and a laterale genome; because of the absence of either parental species from these populations, this hybrid could only have come from a diploid ovum produced by A. platineum. Both morphometric and electrophoretic results for the two tetraploid individuals indicate that they resulted from fertilization of triploid oocytes of A. platineum by sperm of A. texanum. Because genome replacement in A. texanum-dependent populations of A. platineum is irreversible, the persistence of A. platineum in A. texanum-dependent populations demonstrates conclusively that the major mode of reproduction in A. platineum populations is clonal: A. platineum produces mainly triploid eggs that develop gynogenetically.     

Rapid Assessment of Maturation Stage and Reproductive Mode in Centrolecytic Eggs of Stick Insects (Phasmatodea) Using DAPI Stain

A rapid three-step DAPI technique is proposed for detecting meiotic stages and sperm head evolution in yolky, fertilized stick insect eggs, which were difficult to analyze with other methods. Fixed eggs were freed from chorionic envelopes and stained directly in DAPI/PBS solution. After rinsing, eggs were singly squashed in a drop of mounting buffer and examined under a microscope with incident fluorescent illumination. The method was almost uniformly successful, and direct observation of nuclear structures, coupled with fluorometry, allowed easy recognition of bivalents, diads, pronuclei and their DNA content. The DAPI method proposed here appears particularly helpful for investigating unusual reproductive modes in eggs with large amounts of yolk.     

A model for the evolution and control of generative apomixis

A model is presented for the evolution and control of generative apomixis—a collective term for apomixis in animals and diplosporous apomixis in flowering plants. Its development takes into account data obtained from studies of apomictic-like processes in sexual organisms and in non-apomictic parthenogens, as well as data obtained from studies of generative apomicts. This approach provides insights into the evolution and control of generative apomixis that cannot be obtained from studies of generative apomicts alone. It is argued that the control of the avoidance of meiotic reduction during egg production in generative apomicts resides at a single locus, the identity of which can vary between lineages. This variation accounts for the observed variation between taxa in the pattern of avoidance of meiotic reduction. The affected locus contains a wild-type allele that codes for meiotic reduction and excess copies of a mutant allele that codes for its avoidance. The dominance relationship between these is determined by their ratio and by the environment. Environmental differences between female generative cells and somatic cells are such that the phenotypic expression of the mutant allele is favoured in the former, while that of the wild-type allele is favoured in the latter. This is important, for the locus is also involved in the control of mitosis which would be disrupted by the expression of the mutant allele in somatic cells. The requirement to maintain a viable pattern of growth and development explains why the wild-type allele is retained by generative apomicts, and this in turn explains why the ability to produce meiotically reduced eggs is retained by facultative forms and why it appears to be suppressed in, rather than absent from, obligate forms. The requirement for excess copies of the mutant allele in generative cells explains why generative apomicts are typically polyploid, as this condition provides a simple and effective means of generating the correct balance of mutant and wild-type alleles. Environmental effects can also lead to the dominance relationship between wild-type and mutant alleles varying between generative cells. In plants, this can lead to the apomixis gene being expressed, and thus to meiotic reduction being avoided, in only some ovules. Meiotically reduced, as well as meiotically unreduced, eggs are produced when this occurs. If compatible and viable pollen is available the meiotically reduced eggs may be fertilized, resulting in these organisms reproducing as facultative apomicts. It is argued that the control and evolution of parthenogenesis in generative apomicts varies between taxa. In some, the parthenogenetic initiation of embryos may result from the acquisition of a parthenogenesis gene or genes; but there is no reason to believe that this is either a general or a common requirement. Indeed, in some it may be an ancestral trait, these apomicts differing from their sexual ancestors in the ability to mature, rather than in the ability to initiate, embryos from unfertilized eggs; or it may result from physiological or developmental changes induced, for example, by polyploidization, hybridization, or the avoidance of meiotic reduction. In some plants it may be induced by pollination (without fertilization) or by the activity of a developing endosperm. Although it is argued that most generatively apomictic lineages may have acquired this form of reproduction relatively easily, by the acquisition of a mutation at a single locus, it is argued that newly initiated lineages may often be reproductively inefficient. These will begin to accumulate mutations that improve the efficiency of apomictic reproduction. Thus several loci may be involved in the control of generative apomixis in established lineages, even though only a single locus was involved in its initiation in these lineages. Care must be taken to distinguish between these initiator and modifier genes when considering the evolution of generative apomixis. Finally, it is argued that although generatively apomictic lineages have easily acquired this form of reproduction, its evolution in some taxa may be so difficult, requiring the acquisition of mutations simultaneously at two or more loci, that these may never acquire it. Thus, evidence obtained from taxa that have successfully made the transition from sexual reproduction to generative apomixis that its evolution was straightforward should not be used as evidence that its evolution will always be relatively easily achieved. Its uneven taxonomic distribution indicates that it is much more easily evolved by some taxonomic groups than by others.     

Hemiclonal reproduction slows down the speed of Muller's ratchet in the hybridogenetic frog Rana esculenta

Rare recombination in otherwise asexually reproducing organisms is known to beneficially influence the fitness in small populations. In most of the investigated organisms, asexual and rare sexual generations with recombination follow each other sequentially. Here we present a case where clonal reproduction and rare recombination occur simultaneously in the same population. The hybridogenetic water frog Rana esculenta (E), a hybrid between R. lessonae (L) and R. ridibunda (R) produces gametes that only contain the unaltered maternal R part of their genome. New generations of R. esculenta usually arise from E x L matings. Intraspecific E x E matings produce mostly inviable offspring, but in rare cases, female R. ridibunda arise from such matings which are capable of recombination. In the absence of conspecific males, these R females have to mate with E males, which results in further R females, or with L males, which produces new E lineages. This indirect mechanism reintroduces recombination into the otherwise clonally transmitted R genomes in R. esculenta populations. In this study, we show through Monte Carlo simulations that, in most cases, it is sufficient that only between 1 % and 10 % of mixed water frog populations consist of R females to prevent or significantly reduce the fixation and accumulation of deleterious mutations.