Deposition of newly synthesized histones: misinterpretations due to cross-linking density-labeled proteins with Lomant's reagent

We have reinvestigated studies using Lomant's reagent to cross-link newly synthesized density-labeled histones into octameric complexes to determine the nature of histone deposition. The analysis has additionally included procedures for reversal of the cross-link in order to analyze the individual histones in these complexes. These studies indicate that density-labeled, newly synthesized histones form hybrid octameric structures composed of both new and old histones. These studies also suggest that previous interpretations by other investigators for the production of homogeneous complexes (100% dense octamer containing 100% new histones) are misinterpretations due to the presence of non-histone protein that contaminates the preparation, even under conditions where much of this non-histone protein is removed by use of ion-exchange resins. These non-histone proteins can be fractionated on density gradients as un-cross-linked proteins with molecular weights that mimic those of cross-linked histone complexes.     

Deposition of newly synthesized histones: new histones H2A and H2B do not deposit in the same nucleosome with new histones H3 and H4

We have developed procedures to study histone-histone interactions during the deposition of histones in replicating cells. Cells are labeled for 60 min with dense amino acids, and subsequently, the histones within the nucleosomes are cross-linked into an octameric complex with formaldehyde. These complexes are sedimented to equilibrium in density gradients and octamer and dioctamer complexes separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. With reversal of the cross-link, the distribution of the individual density-labeled histones in the octamer is determined. Newly synthesized H3 and H4 deposit as a tetramer and are associated with old H2A and H2B. Newly synthesized H2A and H2B deposit as a dimer associated with old H2A, H2B, H3, and H4. The significance of these results with respect to the dynamics of histone interactions in the nucleus is discussed. Control experiments are presented to test for artifactual formation of these complexes during preparative procedures. In addition, reconstitution experiments were performed to demonstrate that the composition of these octameric complexes can be determined from their distribution on density gradients.     

Formation of hybrid nucleosomes cantaining new and old histones.

5 mM hydroxyurea (HU) inhibits DNA synthesis in mouse P815 cells by 94-97% in less than 1 hr. Nevertheless, histone synthesis continues and newly-synthesised histones are incorporated into non-replicating chromatin at a rate of about 20% of that in control exponentially-growing cells. To study the organization of these histones in chromatin P815 cells were treated with 5 mM HU in medium containing dense (15N, 13C, 2H) - substituted amino acids. After inhibition of DNA synthesis, newly-synthesised histones were labelled with (3H)-arginine. The cells were harvested 90 min later, and mono- and oligonucleosomes were prepared and analysed on metrizamide-triethanolamine (MA-TEA density gradients. Analysis of the distribution of 3H-labelled histones in these gradients shows that they are incorporated into hybrid mononucleosomes containing both new and old histones. It is also shown that these hybrid nucleosomes are not randomly distributed, but show a certain tendency to be clustered in certain chromatin regions.     

Conservative assembly and segregation of nucleosomal histones

The assembly of new histones into nucleosomes and the segregation of old histones during replication were investigated using a density gradient, sedimentation equilibrium analysis of histones labeled in vivo with dense amino acids. After a 1 hr pulse of dense amino acids and 3H-lysine, nucleosomes were isolated from chick myoblast organ cultures, and the histones were cross-linked to octamers. The octamers were purified from DNA and then banded to equilibrium in cesium-formate guanidinium-HCI density gradients. The cross-linked dense octamers have the same density as the noncross-linked dense histones, and both were significantly heavier than histones synthesized in the presence of light amino acids. This experiment shows that new histone does not mix with old histone in the new nucleosomes, since the labeling protocol allows density labeling of only one histone for every seven preexisting unlabeled histones. Thus the assembly of new histone octamers is conservative. Using essentially the same experimental design, but varying the details of the labeling procedures, we also show that the dense histone octamer is stable over 3-4 generations, that neighboring octamers tend to be synthesized at the same time, and that old and new histone octamers segregate conservatively over 2-3 generations.     

Nucleosomes from normal and regenerating rat liver

Micrococcal-nuclease digestion of rat liver nuclei selectively released mononucleosomes associated with ADP-ribosylated [Caplan, Ord & Stocken (1978) Biochem. J.174, 475-483] histone H1. Two classes of mononucleosome were detected, those that leaked out during digestion and those that were subsequently released by 5mm-sodium phosphate buffer (pH6.8)/0.2mm-NaEDTA. The former, from which histone H1 had been dissociated, contained 140-base-pair-length DNA and core histones;the latter contained core particles and mononucleosomes with histone H1 and 200-base-pair-length DNA. When normal liver nuclei were phosphorylated with [gamma-(32)P]ATP, dissociated histone H1, which could be separated from core particles with Sephadex G-200, showed (32)P uptake. (32)P uptake into histones H2A and poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated H3 was appreciable in core particles, but was less evident in nucleosomes still containing histone H1. When [(3)H]-thymidine was given to partially hepatectomized rats in S-phase, 5-10min pulses in animals of over 300g body wt. showed the presence of high-specific-radioactivity DNA in released core particles and mononucleosomes compared with DNA retained in the nuclear pellets. Mononucleosomes from rat livers in S-phase with new, [(3)H]lysine-containing histones, had higher (32)P incorporation in histones H1 and their core histones, than for di- or tri-nucleosomes. Thermal-denaturation properties of control and phosphorylated mononucleosomes and core particles were very similar; removal of histone H1 and non-histone chromosomal proteins in 0.5m-NaCl markedly increased the proportion of DNA ;melting' below 70 degrees C.     

Unfolding of nucleosome cores induced by chemical acetylation of histones

Relative accessibility of nucleosomal histones to acetic anhydride during acetylation has been studied as a function of concentration, pH and ionic strength of the solution using high-resolution gel-electrophoresis. It was shown that about 80% of lysine residues in nucleosomal histones and 100% of the same residues in histone complexes without DNA in 2 M NaCl are accessible to the modification, which is proved by the localization of the majority of lysine residues in nucleosomes near the surface of the histone octamer, by their participation in ionic interactions with DNA and, probably, in histone-histone contacts. Gel-electrophoretic experiments with nucleosomes and studies of the histone resistance to mild trypsinolysis indicated that neither nucleosomes themselves nor histone octamers are affected even though 50% of lysine residues in histones have been acetylated. The process of acetylation is accompanied by the growing tendency of histones to participate in mild trypsinolysis and by a gradual decline in electrophoretic mobility and in the value of the sedimentation constant. The circular dichroism spectra and the microscopic appearance of nucleosomes are also markedly changed. These results suggest that a gradual unfolding of nucleosomes occurs when 5 or more lysine residues in the nucleosomal histones have been acetylated.     

Histone stoichiometry and DNA circularization in archaeal nucleosomes.

Recombinant (r)HMfB (archaealhistone B fromMethanothermusfervidus) formed complexes with increasing stability with DNA molecules increasing in length from 52 to 100 bp, but not with a 39 bp molecule. By using125I-labeled rHMfB-YY (an rHMfB variant with I31Y and M35Y replacements) and32P-labeled 100 bp DNA, these complexes, designated archaeal nucleosomes, have been shown to contain an archaeal histone tetramer. Consistent with DNA bending and wrapping, addition of DNA ligase to archaeal nucleosomes assembled with 88 and 128 bp DNAs resulted in covalently-closed monomeric circular DNAs which, following histone removal, were positively supercoiled based on their electrophoretic mobilities in the presence of ethidium bromide before and after relaxation by calf thymus topoisomerase I. Ligase addition to mixtures of rHMfB with 53 or 30 bp DNA molecules also resulted in circular DNAs but these were circular dimers and trimers. These short DNA molecules apparently had to be ligated into longer linear multimers for assembly into archaeal nucleosomes and ligation into circles. rHMfB assembled into archaeal nucleosomes at lower histone to DNA ratios with the supercoiled, circular ligation product than with the original 88 bp linear version of this molecule. Archaeal histones are most similar to the globular histone fold region of eukaryal histone H4, and the results reported are consistent with archaeal nucleosomes resembling the structure formed by eukaryal histone (H3+H4)2tetramers.     

ACF catalyses chromatosome movements in chromatin fibres

Nucleosome-remodelling factors containing the ATPase ISWI, such as ACF, render DNA in chromatin accessible by promoting the sliding of histone octamers. Although the ATP-dependent repositioning of mononucleosomes is readily observable in vitro, it is unclear to which extent nucleosomes can be moved in physiological chromatin, where neighbouring nucleosomes, linker histones and the folding of the nucleosomal array restrict mobility. We assembled arrays consisting of 12 nucleosomes or 12 chromatosomes (nucleosomes plus linker histone) from defined components and subjected them to remodelling by ACF or the ATPase CHD1. Both factors increased the access to DNA in nucleosome arrays. ACF, but not CHD1, catalysed profound movements of nucleosomes throughout the array, suggesting different remodelling mechanisms. Linker histones inhibited remodelling by CHD1. Surprisingly, ACF catalysed significant repositioning of entire chromatosomes in chromatin containing saturating levels of linker histone H1. H1 inhibited the ATP-dependent generation of DNA accessibility by only about 50%. This first demonstration of catalysed chromatosome movements suggests that the bulk of interphase euchromatin may be rendered dynamic by dedicated nucleosome-remodelling factors.     

Analysis of Histones Associated with Neuronal and Glial Nuclei Exhibiting Divergent DNA Repeat Lengths

Abstract: Total cerebral hemisphere nuclei purified from adult rabbit brain were subfractionated into neuronal and glial populations. Previous studies have shown that chromatin in neuronal nuclei is organized in an unusual nucleosome conformation compared with glial or kidney nuclei, i.e., a short DNA repeat length is present. We now analyze whether this difference in chromatin organization is associated with an alteration in the histone component of nucleosomes. Total histone isolated by acid/urea-protamine extraction of purified neuronal, glial, and kidney nuclei was analyzed by electrophoresis on SDS-polyacrylamide slab gels. Histone H1 that was selectively extracted from nuclei was also examined. Differences were not observed on SDS gels in the electrophoretic mobilities of histones associated with either the nucleosome core particle (histones H2A, H2B, H3, H4) or the nucleosome linker region (histone H1). Total histone and selectively extracted histone H1 were also analyzed on acid/urea slab gels that resolve histones on the basis of both molecular weight and charge differences. When analyzed in this system, differences with respect to electrophoretic mobility were not detected when comparing either selectively extracted histone H1 or total histone from neuronal and glial nuclei. Quantitative analyses were also performed and neuronal nuclei were found to contain less histone H1 per milligram DNA compared with glial or kidney nuclei. Neuronal nuclei also demonstrated a lower ratio of histone H1/core histone. These results suggest that the pronounced difference in chromatin organization in neuronal compared with glial nuclei, which is reflected by a short DNA repeat length in neurons, appears to be associated with quantitative differences in neuronal histone H1.     

Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. I

Chromatin was reconstituted using the four core histones on 359 base-pair nicked and closed rings by salt dialysis and/or at physiological ionic strength by means of polyglutamic acid. The products, which consisted of mono- and dinucleosomes, were characterized by gel electrophoresis, sedimentation in sucrose gradients and high-resolution electron microscopy. The results were as follows. (1) The efficiency of the reconstitution was found first to increase with the negative linking difference of the closed rings relative to their relaxed configuration to reach a maximum for -2 turns, and then to decrease for the largest difference of -3 turns. Discrepancies between topoisomers were also observed with regard to differential formation of mono- and dinucleosomes. Topoisomer -1 reconstituted monomers easily but reconstituted dimers with difficulty, whilst this discrimination was virtually absent in the case of topoisomers -2 and -3. Moreover, mononucleosomes on the nicked ring were, with respect to their electrophoretic mobility, similar to mononucleosomes formed on topoisomer -1 but not to those on the other topoisomers, whose mobilities were greater. These features were interpreted in terms of the linking number change associated with the formation of a nucleosome monomer and dimer, approximately -1 and -2 turns, respectively. (2) Two dinucleosome subtypes were found to form in a sequential manner. Their different electrophoretic mobilities and sedimentation coefficients suggested that the early subtype is lighter, probably because of an incomplete histone complement in the second nucleosome of that subtype as a result of an impaired co-operativity in octamer assembly due to the small ring size. (3) An electron microscopic examination of the chromatin reconstituted on topoisomer -2 revealed that both mono- and dinucleosomes adopt two different, salt-dependent, morphologies each: in type I, entering and exiting DNAs do not cross, whilst they do in type II. Type I configuration is favoured in lower salt, whereas type II is favoured in higher salt. Such behaviour explains why nucleosomes in dimers were found to be always diametrically opposed on the rings rather than sometimes apposed, as would have been expected from a random deposition of the histone cores.     

Nonrandom assembly of chromatin during hydroxyurea inhibition of DNA synthesis

Incubation of MSB-1 chicken lymphoblastoid cells with hydroxyurea leads to a rapid 25-fold decrease in the incorporation of [3H]thymidine into DNA and a 5-fold decrease [3H]lysine into the nucleosome core histones. I have investigated whether the distortion in the normal proportion of histone-DNA synthesis results in alterations in the nucleosome assembly process and find that neither the stoichiometry of new histone synthesis nor the deposition is appreciably changed during hydroxyurea incubation. Protein cross-linking and micrococcal nuclease digestion show that the histones synthesized during hydroxyurea treatment form octamer structures and are assembled into typical nucleosome particles. Minor nucleosome subpopulations are found which exhibit altered sensitivity to nuclease digestion and which are depleted in new histones H3 and H4. When MSB-1 cells incubated in hydroxyurea are pulsed briefly with density-labeled amino acids and [3H]lysine, the radiolabeled core histone octamers formed are as dense as individual monomer histones. These results suggest that the newly synthesized histone octamers are uniformly dense and do not contain mixtures of new and old histones. Thus, histones synthesized during hydroxyurea incubation are deposited nonrandomly and do not exchange with preexisting histones.     

The nuclear basic proteins of human testes and ejaculated spermatozoa

Human testicular nuclei were fractionated into two fractions according to their sedimentation in a sucrose density gradient. The nuclear basic proteins isolated from these two fractions were similar and also resembled electrophoretic mobilities and amino acid composition of the liver histones. Only quantitative differences among histone electrophoretic bands were observed. The nuclear basic proteins of ejaculated spermatozoa differed totally from those of the testes. The proteins could be divided into two categories on the basis of their electrophoretic mobilities, molecular weights and amino acid compositions. One group (SpH) was similar to testicular histones; another (HP) group was smaller, with nearly twice the electrophoretic mobility and a much higher arginine content. These proteins (HP) represent a new type of nuclear basic protein found in human tissues.     

Deposition of newly synthesized histones: hybrid nucleosomes are not tandemly arranged on daughter DNA strands

Density labeling procedures have been utilized to study the dynamics of histone-histone interactions in vivo. Cells were labeled for 60 min with dense amino acids, and the label was chased for up to 22 h (two replication events for these cells). Nuclei were isolated and treated with formaldehyde to stabilize the histone-histone interactions with a covalent cross-link that produces an octameric complex of two each of H3, H2B, H2A, and H4. This complex was then extracted from the DNA and analyzed on density gradients. The results indicate that new H3,H4 deposits as a tetramer and does not dissociate in the subsequent chases. New H2A,H2B deposited as a dimer and also does not dissociate in subsequent chases. These new histones form hybrid octamers with old histones. On the basis of the new:old ratio in the hybrid octamers, we propose that additional old H2A,H2B from elsewhere in the genome interacts with tetramers of new H3,H4 to form the newly synthesized nucleosomes. It is also observed that 5% of the cross-linked complexes produced by formaldehyde are octamer-octamer (dioctamer). Upon analysis of the density of the dioctamer, the hybrid octamers were found adjacent to octamers that were homogeneous with respect to containing normal density histones. Control experiments are presented to demonstrate that the octamer-octamer cross-links are a product of intrastrand and not interstrand interactions between nucleosomes. These same control experiments also indicate that these procedures do not induce histone exchange during the preparative procedure prior to density gradient analysis. The significance of these results with regard to the dynamics of histone-histone interactions at the replication fork and the potential role in the maintenance of differentiation is discussed.     

Interaction of maize chromatin-associated HMG proteins with mononucleosomes: role of core and linker histones

Two groups of plant chromatin-associated high mobility group (HMG) proteins, namely the HMGA family, typically containing four A/T-hook DNA-binding motifs, and the HMGB family, containing a single HMG-box DNA-binding domain, have been identified. We have examined the interaction of recombinant maize HMGA and five different HMGB proteins with mononucleosomes (containing approx. 165 bp of DNA) purified from micrococcal nuclease-digested maize chromatin. The HMGB proteins interacted with the nucleosomes independent of the presence of the linker histone H1, while the binding of HMGA in the presence of H1 differed from that observed in the absence of H1. HMGA and the HMGB proteins bound H1-containing nucleosome particles with similar affinity. The plant HMG proteins could also bind nucleosomes that were briefly treated with trypsin (removing the N-terminal domains of the core histones), suggesting that the histone N-termini are dispensable for HMG protein binding. In the presence of untreated nucleosomes and trypsinised nucleosomes, HMGB1 could be chemically crosslinked with a core histone, which indicates that the trypsin-resistant part of the histones within the nucleosome is the main interaction partner of HMGB1 rather than the histone N-termini. In conclusion, these results indicate that specific nucleosome binding of the plant HMGB proteins requires simultaneous DNA and histone contacts.     

Binding of wheat and chicken high mobility group chromosomal proteins to DNA and to wheat and chicken mononucleosomes

We have used an electrophoretic retardation assay to investigate the interactions of wheat high mobility group (HMG) proteins with DNA and with isolated trimmed mononucleosomes (complexes which contain a histone octamer and approximately 146 base pairs of DNA). In order to characterize these interactions, we have compared the binding of each of the wheat HMG proteins, HMGa, b, c, and d, with those of the low molecular weight chicken HMG proteins HMG14 and 17. These vertebrate animal HMG proteins have previously been shown to occupy two specific binding sites on animal nucleosomes and to have a greater affinity for nucleosomes than for naked DNA (Mardian, J. K. W., Paton, A. E., Bunick, G. J., and Olins, D. E. (1980) Science 209, 1534-1536; Sandeen, G., Wood, W. I., and Felsenfeld, G. (1980) Nucleic Acids Res. 8, 3757-3778). As a criterion for "specific binding," we have used the property of HMG14 and 17 binding of causing a discontinuous shift of nucleosomes to a distinct band of lower electrophoretic mobility. According to this criterion, wheat HMGb, c, and d do not bind nucleosomes specifically. These HMG proteins have approximately the same affinity for nucleosomes and naked DNA. Wheat HMGa does bind nucleosomes specifically by this criterion, but other aspects of the binding are reminiscent of histone H1-nucleosome binding. We present evidence that trimmed mononucleosomes of wheat are conformationally distinct from their animal counterparts. Despite the conformational differences, competition studies indicate that chicken and wheat mononucleosomes have essentially identical affinity for the low molecular weight animal HMG proteins.     

Histones synthesized for use in early development of Xenopus laevis are stored as a complex with antigenic properties similar to those of the octamer core of nucleosomes

Serum of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) contains crossreacting autoantibodies which recognize histones in nucleosomes or when they are induced to form octamers in solution in the presence of 2 M NaCl, but not when they are dissociated free in solution at physiological ionic strength. We have found that histones stored in eggs of Xenopus laevis for use in rapid nuclear synthesis during early development react with this antibody. This reaction has been observed by radioimmunoassay, inhibition of chromatin assembly by the extracts in the presence of antibody, and, in a preliminary result, by identification of a histone-antibody complex bound to protein A- sepharose. Further evidence that the extract antigen corresponds to the stored histone pool comes from sedimentation and charge fractionation experiments where the chromatin assembly activity and antigen (measured by radioimmunoassay) were found to cofractionate. BEcause the extract histones are not bound to DNA, our results suggest that they are stored as a soluble complex in a conformation similar or identical to the octameric core of the nucleosome. Our data suggest that the histones in this complex are bound to an anionic factor or factors which presumably replaces the DNA in shielding the positive charges on the histones.     

Hyper(ADP-ribosyl)ation of histone H1

Nucleosomal chains of various repeat unit lengths were generated by a mild micrococcal nuclease digestion of purified pancreatic nuclei. Maximal nucleosome associated poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase activity was recovered in trimeric to tetrameric chromatin fragments, after which the enzyme activity gradually decreased and stabilized towards oligomeric periodicities of 11 to 16 nucleosomes. Electrophoresis of [32P]ADP-ribosylated histones on first-dimension acid-urea or acid-urea-Triton gels and on second-dimension acid--urea--cetyltriammonium bromide gels revealed that, of all histones, only histone H1 could be significantly poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated while only minimal modification could be recovered with histone H1(0). Furthermore, the extent of ADP-ribosylation present on pancreatic histone H1 is shown to proportionally retard this protein's electrophoretic mobility in all gel systems and to consist of a distinct series of at least 12 modification intermediates which can be evidenced, in nuclei or nucleosomes, and fully recovered along with histone H1 upon its selective extraction with 5% perchloric acid. The generation of these increasingly ADP-ribosylated forms of histone H1 is also demonstrated to be time dependent and the more complex ADP-ribosylated forms of this histone are favored at high NAD+ concentrations. Moreover, the electrophoretic mobilities of all intermediates are unaffected by the presence of the nonionic detergent Triton X-100.     

Preferential association of newly synthesized histones with replicating SV40 DNA.

The assembly of newly synthesized histones into nucleosomes during replication of SV40 minichromosomes in vivo was studied. Infected cells were labeled with 35S-methionine for a time shorter than that required to complete a round of viral DNA replication. Mature and replicating SV40 minichromosomes were extracted and separated by zonal sedimentation, and their histone content was analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS and acidic urea). We show that the pulse-labeled histones associate preferentially with the replicating DNA.     

Laser Raman spectra of calf thymus chromatin and its constituents.

Extensive Raman measurements have been made on calf thymus chromatin, core chromatin, the (H3,H4)/DNA complex, and isolated DNA. The results indicate that the alpha-helical content of the nucleosomal histones gradually increases as they form the heterocomplexes that lead to the formation of the octameric nucleosome core. The secondary structure of the latter is not modified as it binds to DNA. The spectra indicate that the DNA essentially retains its B conformation in nucleosomes, although slight changes probably occur in the ribose-phosphate backbone. No specific interactions between the nucleosomal histones and DNA can be established from the spectra, but histone H1 possibly interacts selectively with the thymine bases.