Mechanism of escape from nonsense-mediated mRNA decay of human beta-globin transcripts with nonsense mutations in the first exon

The degradation of nonsense-mutated β-globin mRNA by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) limits the synthesis of C-terminally truncated dominant negative β-globin chains and thus protects the majority of heterozygotes from symptomatic β-thalassemia. β-globin mRNAs with nonsense mutations in the first exon are known to bypass NMD, although current mechanistic models predict that such mutations should activate NMD. A systematic analysis of this enigma reveals that (1) β-globin exon 1 is bisected by a sharp border that separates NMD-activating from NMD-bypassing nonsense mutations and (2) the ability to bypass NMD depends on the ability to reinitiate translation at a downstream start codon. The data presented here thus reconcile the current mechanistic understanding of NMD with the observed failure of a class of nonsense mutations to activate this important mRNA quality-control pathway. Furthermore, our data uncover a reason why the position of a nonsense mutation alone does not suffice to predict the fate of the affected mRNA and its effect on protein expression.     

Nonsense mutations in close proximity to the initiation codon fail to trigger full nonsense-mediated mRNA decay

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a surveillance mechanism that degrades mRNAs containing premature translation termination codons. In mammalian cells, a termination codon is ordinarily recognized as "premature" if it is located greater than 50-54 nucleotides 5' to the final exon-exon junction. We have described a set of naturally occurring human beta-globin gene mutations that apparently contradict this rule. The corresponding beta-thalassemia genes contain nonsense mutations within exon 1, and yet their encoded mRNAs accumulate to levels approaching wild-type beta-globin (beta(WT)) mRNA. In the present report we demonstrate that the stabilities of these mRNAs with nonsense mutations in exon 1 are intermediate between beta(WT) mRNA and beta-globin mRNA carrying a prototype NMD-sensitive mutation in exon 2 (codon 39 nonsense; beta 39). Functional analyses of these mRNAs with 5'-proximal nonsense mutations demonstrate that their relative resistance to NMD does not reflect abnormal RNA splicing or translation re-initiation and is independent of promoter identity and erythroid specificity. Instead, the proximity of the nonsense codon to the translation initiation AUG constitutes a major determinant of NMD. Positioning a termination mutation at the 5' terminus of the coding region blunts mRNA destabilization, and this effect is dominant to the "50-54 nt boundary rule." These observations impact on current models of NMD.     

mRNA surveillance mitigates genetic dominance in Caenorhabditis elegans

Nonsense mutant mRNAs are unstable in all eucaryotes tested, a phenomenon termed nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) or mRNA surveillance. Functions of the seven smg genes are required for mRNA surveillance in Caenorhabditis elegans. In Smg(+) genetic backgrounds, nonsense-mutant mRNAs are unstable, while in Smg(−) backgrounds such mRNAs are stable. Previous work has demonstrated that the elevated level of nonsense-mutant mRNAs in Smg(−) animals can influence the phenotypic effects of heterozygous nonsense mutations. Certain nonsense alleles of a muscle myosin heavy chain gene are recessive in Smg(+) backgrounds but strongly dominant in Smg(−) backgrounds. Such alleles probably express disruptive myosin polypeptide fragments whose abundance is elevated in smg mutants due to elevation of mRNA levels. We report here that mutations in a variety of C. elegans genes are strongly dominant in Smg(−), but recessive or only weakly dominant in Smg(+) backgrounds. We isolated 32 dominant visible mutations in a Smg(−) genetic background and tested whether their dominance requires a functional NMD system. The dominance of 21 of these mutations is influenced by NMD. We demonstrate, furthermore, that in the case of myosin, the dominant-negative effects of nonsense alleles are likely to be due to expression of N-terminal nonsense-fragment polypeptides, not to mistranslation of the nonsense codons. mRNA surveillance, therefore, may mitigate potentially deleterious effects of many heterozygous germline and somatic nonsense or frameshift mutations. We also provide evidence that smg-6, a gene previously identified as being required for NMD, performs essential function(s) in addition to its role in NMD. Received: 10 June 1998 / Accepted: 21 July 1998     

mRNA surveillance mitigates genetic dominance in Caenorhabditis elegans

Nonsense mutant mRNAs are unstable in all eucaryotes tested, a phenomenon termed nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) or mRNA surveillance. Functions of the seven smg genes are required for mRNA surveillance in Caenorhabditis elegans. In Smg(+) genetic backgrounds, nonsense-mutant mRNAs are unstable, while in Smg(?) backgrounds such mRNAs are stable. Previous work has demonstrated that the elevated level of nonsense-mutant mRNAs in Smg(?) animals can influence the phenotypic effects of heterozygous nonsense mutations. Certain nonsense alleles of a muscle myosin heavy chain gene are recessive in Smg(+) backgrounds but strongly dominant in Smg(?) backgrounds. Such alleles probably express disruptive myosin polypeptide fragments whose abundance is elevated in smg mutants due to elevation of mRNA levels. We report here that mutations in a variety of C. elegans genes are strongly dominant in Smg(?), but recessive or only weakly dominant in Smg(+) backgrounds. We isolated 32 dominant visible mutations in a Smg(?) genetic background and tested whether their dominance requires a functional NMD system. The dominance of 21 of these mutations is influenced by NMD. We demonstrate, furthermore, that in the case of myosin, the dominant-negative effects of nonsense alleles are likely to be due to expression of N-terminal nonsense-fragment polypeptides, not to mistranslation of the nonsense codons. mRNA surveillance, therefore, may mitigate potentially deleterious effects of many heterozygous germline and somatic nonsense or frameshift mutations. We also provide evidence that smg-6, a gene previously identified as being required for NMD, performs essential function(s) in addition to its role in NMD.     

Interaction between Nmd2p and Upf1p is required for activity but not for dominant-negative inhibition of the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay pathway in yeast.

Rapid turnover of nonsense-containing mRNAs in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is dependent on the products of the UPF1 (Upf1p), NMD2/UPF2 (Nmd2p) and UPF3 (Upf3p) genes. Mutations in each of these genes lead to the selective stabilization of mRNAs containing early nonsense mutations without affecting the decay rates of most other mRNAs. NMD2 was recently identified in a two-hybrid screen as a gene that encodes a Upf1p-interacting protein. To identify the amino acids essential to this interaction, we used two-hybrid analysis as well as missense, nonsense, and deletion mutants of NMD2, and mapped the Upf1p-interacting domain of Nmd2p to a 157-amino acid segment at its C-terminus. Mutations in this domain that disrupt interaction with Upf1p also disrupt nonsense-mediated mRNA decay. A dominant-negative deletion allele of NMD2 identified previously includes the Upf1p-interacting domain. However, mutations in the Upf1p-interacting domain do not affect dominant-negative inhibition of mRNA decay caused by this allele, suggesting interaction with yet another factor. These results, and the observation that deletion of a putative nuclear localization signal and a putative transmembrane domain also inactivate nonsense-mediated mRNA decay, suggest that Nmd2p may contain as many as four important functional domains.     

Infrequent translation of a nonsense codon is sufficient to decrease mRNA level

In many organisms nonsense mutations decrease the level of mRNA. In the case of mammalian cells, it is still controversial whether translation is required for this nonsense-mediated RNA decrease (NMD). Although previous analyzes have shown that conditions that impede translation termination at nonsense codons also prevent NMD, the residual level of termination was unknown in these experiments. Moreover, the conditions used to impede termination might also have interfered with NMD in other ways. Because of these uncertainties, we have tested the effects of limiting translation of a nonsense codon in a different way, using two mutations in the immunoglobulin mu heavy chain gene. For this purpose we exploited an exceptional nonsense mutation at codon 3, which efficiently terminates translation but nonetheless maintains a high level of mu mRNA. We have shown 1) that translation of Ter462 in the double mutant occurs at only approximately 4% the normal frequency, and 2) that Ter462 in cis with Ter3 can induce NMD. That is, translation of Ter462 at this low (4%) frequency is sufficient to induce NMD.     

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay in mammalian cells involves decapping, deadenylating, and exonucleolytic activities

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a mechanism by which cells recognize and degrade mRNAs that prematurely terminate translation. To date, the polarity and enzymology of NMD in mammalian cells is unknown. We show here that downregulating the Dcp2 decapping protein or the PM/Scl100 component of the exosome (1) significantly increases the abundance of steady-state nonsense-containing but not nonsense-free mRNAs, and (2) significantly slows the decay rate of transiently induced nonsense-containing but not nonsense-free mRNA. Downregulating poly(A) ribonuclease (PARN) also increases the abundance of nonsense-containing mRNAs. Furthermore, NMD factors Upf1, Upf2, and Upf3X coimmunopurify with the decapping enzyme Dcp2, the putative 5'-->3' exonuclease Rat1, the proven 5'-->3' exonuclease Xrn1, exosomal components PM/Scl100, Rrp4, and Rrp41, and PARN. From these and other data, we conclude that NMD in mammalian cells degrades mRNAs from both 5' and 3' ends by recruiting decapping and 5'-->3' exonuclease activities as well as deadenylating and 3'-->5' exonuclease activities.     

A new function for nonsense-mediated mRNA-decay factors

mRNAs often contain premature-termination (nonsense) codons as a result of mutations and RNA splicing errors. These nonsense codons cause rapid decay of the mRNAs that contain them, a phenomenon called nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). This response is thought to be a quality-control mechanism that protects cells from truncated dominant-negative proteins. Surprisingly, recent evidence strongly suggests that the NMD factors UPF1, UPF2, UPF3B, RNPS1, Y14 and MAGOH also promote translation of normal mRNAs in mammalian cells. This, along with an earlier discovery that NMD factors appear to dictate efficient translation termination, suggests that NMD factors do not merely function in RNA surveillance. These findings lead to the interesting question of why NMD factors evolved; are they for RNA-quality control or to promote efficient translation initiation and termination?     

RNA splicing promotes translation and RNA surveillance

Aberrant mRNAs harboring premature termination codons (PTCs or nonsense codons) are degraded by the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) pathway. mRNAs transcribed from genes that naturally acquire PTCs during lymphocyte development are strongly downregulated by PTCs. Here we show that a signal essential for this robust mRNA downregulatory response is efficient RNA splicing. Strong mRNA downregulation can be conferred on a poor NMD substrate by either strengthening its splicing signals or removing its weak introns. Efficient splicing also strongly promotes translation, providing a molecular explanation for enhanced NMD and suggesting that efficient splicing may have evolved to enhance both protein production and RNA surveillance. Our results suggest simple approaches for increasing protein expression from expression vectors and treating human genetic diseases caused by nonsense and frameshift mutations.