Nonimmunodominant regions are effective as building blocks in a streptococcal fusion protein vaccine

Identification of antigens that elicit protective immunity is essential for effective vaccine development. We investigated the related surface proteins of group B Streptococcus, Rib and alpha, as potential vaccine candidates. Paradoxically, nonimmunodominant regions proved to be of particular interest as vaccine components. Mouse antibodies elicited by Rib and alpha were directed almost exclusively against the C-terminal repeats and not against the N-terminal regions. However, a fusion protein derived from the nonimmunodominant N-terminal regions of Rib and alpha was much more immunogenic than one derived from the repeats and was immunogenic even without adjuvant. Moreover, antibodies to the N-terminal fusion protein protected against infection and inhibited bacterial invasion of epithelial cells. Similarly, the N-terminal region of Streptococcus pyogenes M22 protein, which is targeted by opsonic antibodies, is nonimmunodominant. These data indicate that nonimmunodominant regions of bacterial antigens could be valuable for vaccine development.     

Protectome Analysis: A New Selective Bioinformatics Tool for Bacterial Vaccine Candidate Discovery

New generation vaccines are in demand to include only the key antigens sufficient to confer protective immunity among the plethora of pathogen molecules. In the last decade, large-scale genomics-based technologies have emerged. Among them, the Reverse Vaccinology approach was successfully applied to the development of an innovative vaccine against Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B, now available on the market with the commercial name BEXSERO® (Novartis Vaccines). The limiting step of such approaches is the number of antigens to be tested in in vivo models. Several laboratories have been trying to refine the original approach in order to get to the identification of the relevant antigens straight from the genome. Here we report a new bioinformatics tool that moves a first step in this direction. The tool has been developed by identifying structural/functional features recurring in known bacterial protective antigens, the so called “Protectome space,” and using such “protective signatures” for protective antigen discovery. In particular, we applied this new approach to Staphylococcus aureus and Group B Streptococcus and we show that not only already known protective antigens were re-discovered, but also two new protective antigens were identified.Although vaccines based on attenuated pathogens as pioneered by Luis Pasteur have been shown to be extremely effective, safety and technical reasons recommend that new generation vaccines include few selected pathogen components which, in combination with immunostimulatory molecules, can induce long lasting protective responses. Such approach implies that the key antigens sufficient to confer protective immunity are singled out among the plethora of pathogen molecules. As it turns out, the search for such protective antigens can be extremely complicated.Genomic technologies have opened the way to new strategies in vaccine antigen discovery (1, 2, 3). Among them, Reverse Vaccinology (RV)¹ has proved to be highly effective, as demonstrated by the fact that a new Serogroup B Neisseria meningitidis (MenB) vaccine, incorporating antigens selected by RV, is now available to defeat meningococcal meningitis (4, 5). In essence, RV is based on the simple assumption that cloning all annotated proteins/genes and screening them against a robust and reliable surrogate-of-protection assay must lead to the identification of all protective antigens. Because most of the assays available for protective antigen selection involve animal immunization and challenge, the number of antigens to be tested represents a severe bottleneck of the entire process. For this reason, despite the fact that RV is a brute force, inclusive approach (“test-all-to-lose-nothing” type of approach) in their pioneered work of MenB vaccine discovery, Pizza and co-workers did not test the entire collection of MenB proteins but rather restricted their analysis to the ones predicted to be surface-localized. This was based on the evidence that for an anti-MenB vaccine to be protective bactericidal antibodies must be induced, a property that only surface-exposed antigens have. For the selection of surface antigens Pizza and co-workers mainly used PSORT and other available tools like MOTIFS and FINDPATTERNS to find proteins carrying localization-associated features such as transmembrane domains, leader peptides, and lipobox and outer membrane anchoring motifs. At the end, 570 proteins were selected and entered the still very labor intensive screening phase. Over the last few years, our laboratories have been trying to move to more selective strategies. Our ultimate goal, we like to refer to as the “Holy Grail of Vaccinology,” is to identify protective antigens by “simply” scanning the genome sequence of any given pathogen, thus avoiding time consuming “wet science” and “move straight from genome to the clinic” (6).With this objective in mind, we have developed a series of proteomics-based protocols that, in combination with bioinformatics tools, have substantially reduced the number of antigens to be tested in the surrogate-of-protection assays (7, 8). In particular, we have recently described a three-technology strategy that allows to narrow the number of antigens to be tested in the animal models down to less than ten (9). However, this strategy still requires high throughput experimental activities. Therefore, the availability of in silico tools that selectively and accurately single out relevant categories of antigens among the complexity of pathogen components would greatly facilitate the vaccine discovery process.In the present work, we describe a new bioinformatics approach that brings an additional contribution to our “from genome to clinic” goal. The approach has been developed on the basis of the assumption that protective antigens are protective in that they have specific structural/functional features (“protective signatures”) that distinguish them from immunologically irrelevant pathogen components. These features have been identified by using existing databases and prediction tools, such as PFam and SMART. Our approach focuses on protein biological role rather than its localization: it is completely protein localization unbiased, and lead to the identification of both surface-exposed and secreted antigens (which are the majority in extracellular bacteria) as well as cytoplasmic protective antigens (for instance, antigens that elicit interferon γ producing CD4+ T cells, thus potentiating the killing activity of phagocytic cells toward intracellular pathogens). Should these assumptions be valid, PS could be identified if: (1) all known protective antigens are compiled to create what we refer to as “the Protectome space,” and (2) Protectome is subjected to computer-assisted scrutiny using selected tools. Once signatures are identified, novel protective antigens of a pathogen of interest should be identifiable by scanning its genome sequence in search for proteins that carry one or more protective signatures. A similar attempt has been reported (10), where the discrimination of protective antigens versus nonprotective antigens was tried using statistical methods based on amino acid compositional analysis and auto cross-covariance. This model was implemented in a server for the prediction of vaccine candidates, that is, Vaxijen (www.darrenflower.info/Vaxijen); however, the selection criteria applied are still too general leading to a list of candidates that include ca. 30% of the total genome ORFs very similarly to the number of antigens predicted by classical RV based on the presence of localization signals.Here we show that Protectome analysis unravels specific signatures embedded in protective antigens, most of them related to the biological role/function of the proteins. These signatures narrow down the candidate list to ca. 3% of the total ORFs content and can be exploited for protective antigen discovery. Indeed, the strategy was validated by demonstrating that well characterized vaccine components could be identified by scanning the genome sequence of the corresponding pathogens for the presence of the PS. Furthermore, when the approach was applied to Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus agalactiae (Group B Streptococcus, GBS) not only already known protective antigens were rediscovered, but also two new protective antigens were identified.     

Genetic mapping identifies novel highly protective antigens for an apicomplexan parasite

Apicomplexan parasites are responsible for a myriad of diseases in humans and livestock; yet despite intensive effort, development of effective sub-unit vaccines remains a long-term goal. Antigenic complexity and our inability to identify protective antigens from the pool that induce response are serious challenges in the development of new vaccines. Using a combination of parasite genetics and selective barriers with population-based genetic fingerprinting, we have identified that immunity against the most important apicomplexan parasite of livestock (Eimeria spp.) was targeted against a few discrete regions of the genome. Herein we report the identification of six genomic regions and, within two of those loci, the identification of true protective antigens that confer immunity as sub-unit vaccines. The first of these is an Eimeria maxima homologue of apical membrane antigen-1 (AMA-1) and the second is a previously uncharacterised gene that we have termed 'immune mapped protein-1' (IMP-1). Significantly, homologues of the AMA-1 antigen are protective with a range of apicomplexan parasites including Plasmodium spp., which suggest that there may be some characteristic(s) of protective antigens shared across this diverse group of parasites. Interestingly, homologues of the IMP-1 antigen, which is protective against E. maxima infection, can be identified in Toxoplasma gondii and Neospora caninum. Overall, this study documents the discovery of novel protective antigens using a population-based genetic mapping approach allied with a protection-based screen of candidate genes. The identification of AMA-1 and IMP-1 represents a substantial step towards development of an effective anti-eimerian sub-unit vaccine and raises the possibility of identification of novel antigens for other apicomplexan parasites. Moreover, validation of the parasite genetics approach to identify effective antigens supports its adoption in other parasite systems where legitimate protective antigen identification is difficult.     

Mucosal immunity and optimizing protection with meningococcal serogroup B vaccines

Candidate Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B vaccines that are based on outer-membrane vesicles induce protective immunity in adults but provide neither crossprotection for infants nor long-lasting immunity. We suggest that this lack of vaccine efficacy is not solely because the best antigens are yet to be identified but also results from inappropriate programming of the immune response. Natural carriage of N. meningitidis and related bacteria leads to the development of protective immunity both at the mucosal surface and in the circulation. We propose that vaccine strategies that mimic this natural immunization process would better-optimize vaccine-induced protective immunity. Thus, mucosal immunization before a systemic booster vaccination could provide the solution and reduce the necessity for multiple injections to achieve immunity.     

Structure-based antigen design: a strategy for next generation vaccines

Vaccine design is progressing from empiricism towards the increasingly rational presentation of the targets of protective immunity. Nevertheless, most current vaccine antigens are essentially the native macromolecules of pathogens. These molecules are adapted to evade, not induce, immunity. High resolution structures reveal the electrostatic surfaces recognized by neutralizing antibodies and the architectures underlying these surfaces, thereby identifying which substructures must be left intact and which can be changed to optimize biochemical and immunologic performance. Armed with detailed structural information, we can engineer optimized antigens that are more stable, homogeneous, and efficiently produced, making immunization more practical and affordable. Understanding the structural basis for immunogenicity and immunodominance will allow us to improve vaccine efficacy and broaden the range of vaccine-preventable diseases.     

Vaccines to combat river blindness: expression,selection and formulation of vaccines against infection with Onchocerca volvulus in a mouse model

Human onchocerciasis is a neglected tropical disease caused by Onchocerca volvulus and an important cause of blindness and chronic disability in the developing world. Although mass drug administration of ivermectin has had a profound effect on control of the disease, additional tools are critically needed including the need for a vaccine against onchocerciasis. The objectives of the present study were to: (i) select antigens with known vaccine pedigrees as components of a vaccine; (ii) produce the selected vaccine antigens under controlled conditions, using two expression systems and in one laboratory and (iii) evaluate their vaccine efficacy using a single immunisation protocol in mice. In addition, we tested the hypothesis that joining protective antigens as a fusion protein or in combination, into a multivalent vaccine, would improve the ability of the vaccine to induce protective immunity. Out of eight vaccine candidates tested in this study, Ov-103, Ov-RAL-2 and Ov-CPI-2M were shown to reproducibly induce protective immunity when administered individually, as fusion proteins or in combination. Although there was no increase in the level of protective immunity induced by combining the antigens into one vaccine, these antigens remain strong candidates for inclusion in a vaccine to control onchocerciasis in humans.     

Cellular and molecular mechanisms of vaccine-induced protection against retroviral infections

More than 15 years after the discovery of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), researchers are still struggling to design a protective AIDS vaccine. A remaining problem is a lack of basic knowledge about the immunological requirements for protection against retroviruses. Infection of macaque monkeys with simian immunodeficiency virus is still the best model for HIV vaccine research. However, in this model it remains difficult to determine protective immunological mechanisms because of limited numbers of experimental animals and their genetic heterogeneity. Thus, fundamental concepts in retroviral immunology have to be defined in other ways such as mouse models. This minireview summarizes new findings on cellular and molecular mechanisms in protection of mice against Friend murine retrovirus infection. It has been shown that complex immune responses, including B and T cell responses, are required for efficient protection in this model. Multiple viral antigens are necessary to elicit such broad immune reactivity. Efficacious vaccines must protect not only against acute disease, but also against the establishment of persistent infections or the host is at serious risk of virus reactivation. The minireview closes with a discussion on the relevance of findings from the mouse model on the design of a protective vaccine against HIV.     

保护性病毒抗原的筛选策略及其在新型疫苗研发中的应用

随着疫苗研发技术的发展,新型疫苗在传染病的预防中得到了广泛应用。由于新型疫苗安全性良好,因此其在烈性病疫苗的应用中有着得天独厚的优势,然而研制新型疫苗的前提是筛选出保护性抗原。随着各种组学研究的发展,针对真核生物的多种生物信息学方法代表着最前沿的技术手段。相对于真核细胞,病毒具有更为简单的结构,对应着相对简单的研究方法,未来的保护性抗原筛选策略,需要结合生物信息学和传统分子生物学方法的优势。本文分别从宿主和病毒入手,论述了病毒保护性抗原的筛选策略,列举了一系列基于真核细胞开发的可能用于保护性抗原筛选的生物信息学方法,并总结了应用保护性抗原进行新型疫苗设计的案例,以便加深对病毒保护性抗原筛选策略的认知,为新型疫苗的研发提供借鉴。     

Immunotherapy of cancer with dendritic-cell-based vaccines

 Animal studies have shown that vaccination with genetically modified tumor cells or with dendritic cells (DC) pulsed with tumor antigens are potent strategies to elicit protective immunity in tumor-bearing animals, more potent than “conventional” strategies that have been tested in clinical settings with limited success. While both vaccination strategies are forms of cell therapy requiring complex and costly ex vivo manipulations of the patient’s cells, current protocols using dendritic cells are considerably simpler and would be more widely available. Vaccination with defined tumor antigens presented by DC has obvious appeal. However, in view of the expected emergence of antigen-loss variants as well as natural immunovariation, effective vaccine formulations must contain mixtures of commonly, if not universally, expressed tumor antigens. When, or even if, such common tumor antigens will be identified cannot be, predicted, however. Thus, for the foreseeable future, vaccination with total-tumor-derived material as source of tumor antigens may be preferable to using defined tumor antigens. Vaccination with undefined tumor-derived antigens will be limited, however, by the availability of sufficient tumor tissue for antigen preparation. Because the mRNA content of single cells can be amplified, tumor mRNA, or corresponding cDNA libraries, offer an unlimited source of tumor antigens. DC transfected with tumor RNA were shown to engender potent antitumor immunity in animal studies. Thus, immunotherapy using autologous DC loaded with unfractionated tumor-derived antigens in the form of RNA emerges as a potentially powerful and broadly useful vaccination strategy for cancer patients. Received: 10 October 1997 / Accepted: 12 January 1998     

Progress toward a malaria vaccine: efficient induction of protective anti-malaria immunity

Malaria can be a very severe disease, particularly in young children, pregnant women (mostly in primipara), and malaria na?ve adults, and currently ranks among the most prevalent infections in tropical and subtropical areas throughout the world. The widespread occurrence and the increased incidence of malaria in many countries, caused by drug-resistant parasites (Plasmodium falciparum and P. vivax) and insecticide-resistant vectors (Anopheles mosquitoes), indicate the need to develop new methods of controlling this disease. Experimental vaccination with irradiated sporozoites can protect animals and humans against the disease, demonstrating the feasibility of developing an effective malaria vaccine. However, developing a universally effective, long lasting vaccine against this parasitic disease has been a difficult task, due to several problems. One difficulty stems from the complexity of the parasite's life cycle. During their life cycle, malaria parasites change their residence within the host, thus avoiding being re-exposed to the same immunological environment. These parasites also possess some distinct antigens, present at different life stages of the parasite, the so-called stage-specific antigens. While some of the stage-specific antigens can induce protective immune responses in the host, these responses are usually genetically restricted, this being another reason for delaying the development of a universally effective vaccine. The stage-specific antigens must be used as immunogens and introduced into the host by using a delivery system that should efficiently induce protective responses against the respective stages. Here we review several research approaches aimed at inducing protective anti-malaria immunity, overcoming the difficulties described above.     

Bacterial otitis media: current vaccine development strategies

Otitis media is the most common reason for children less than 5 years of age to visit a medical practitioner. Whilst the disease rarely results in death, there is significant associated morbidity. The most common complication is loss of hearing at a critical stage of the development of speech, language and cognitive abilities in children. The cause and pathogenesis of otitis media is multifactorial. Among the contributing factors, the single most important are viral and bacterial infections. Infection with respiratory syncytial virus, influenza viruses, para-influenza viruses, enteroviruses and adenovirus are most commonly associated with acute and chronic otitis media. Streptococcus pneumoniae, non-typeable Haemophilus influenzae and Moraxella catarrhalis are the most commonly isolated bacteria from the middle ears of children with otitis media. Treatment of otitis media has largely relied on the administration of antimicrobials and surgical intervention. However, attention has recently focused on the development of a vaccine. For a vaccine to be effective against bacterial otitis media, it must, at the very least, contain antigens that induce a protective immune response in the middle ear against the three most common infecting bacteria. Whilst over the past decade there has been significant progress in the development of vaccines against invasive S. pneumoniae disease, these vaccines are less efficacious for otitis media. The search for candidate vaccine antigens for non-typeable H. influenzae are well advanced whilst less progress has been made for M. catarrhalis. No human studies have been conducted for non-typeable H. influenzae or M. catarrhalis and the concept of a tribacterial vaccine remains to be tested in animal models. Only when vaccine antigens are determined and an understanding of the immune responses induced in the middle ear by infection and immunization is gained will the formulation of a tribacterial vaccine against otitis media be possible.     

Prospects of the use of bacteriophage-based virus-like particles in the creation of anthrax vaccines

The profitability of vaccine production is less than that of other pharmaceutical goods worldwide. Thus, the cost of the vaccine substance determines the range of vaccines available for use. This is of particular importance for veterinary vaccines. In this review, we have surveyed the published data on exploited vaccines and concluded that the immunogenicity of antigen substances based on whole virions is higher than that of soluble antigens. The physiological basis of this phenomenon remains unknown; however, it may explain why most of the described recombinant vaccines have not yet been put into practice. All practically implemented antiviral vaccines (except that for hepatitis B) are based on viral substances produced by conventional cultural technologies. In light of this observation, an approach to the development of a universal platform for recombinant vaccines produced in the form of virus-like particles is suggested. To this end, a technique of designing fused bifunctional derivatives of bacteriophage proteins containing antigens of interest should be involved. The approach is depicted with the use of the protective anthrax antigen, a conventional vaccine antigen.     

Plasmodium falciparum: genetic diversity of C-terminal region of MSP-1 in isolates from Indian sub-continent

Malaria parasites exhibit sequence diversity for a number of stage specific antigens. Several studies have proved that merozoite surface protein-1 (MSP-1) is an effective target eliciting a protective immune response. The MSP-1(42) region comprising two EGF-like domains is involved in generating protective immune response in humans and other experimental animals. Searching for point mutations in this region is essential in view of vaccine development. We have investigated the sequence variations in Plasmodium falciparum MSP-1 carboxy terminal region in field isolates from different regions in India. Our study reveals the presence of eight variant types of MSP-1(19) in the Indian sub-continent, which comprise of E-TSR-L, Q-TSR-L, E-TSG-L, Q-KNG-L, Q-KNG-F, E-KNG-L, E-KNG-F, and E-KYG-F. The last named allele is a novel variant being reported for the first time.     

Mycobacterial glycoconjugates as vaccine candidates against tuberculosis

There is an urgent need for an efficient vaccine against tuberculosis. Here, we explore the potential role of carbohydrate antigens as part of a new tuberculosis vaccine. Emphasis is placed on carbohydrate-protein conjugate vaccines, using the arabinomannan portion of lipoarabinomannan, a major structural surface component of Mycobacterium tuberculosis covalently conjugated to (mycobacterial) protein antigens. Such conjugate vaccines show good protective efficacy in mice and guinea pigs in terms of prolonged survival and reduced pathology. Special attention is paid to the immunology underlying their protective capacity. Conjugate vaccines induce both cellular and humoral responses and, although antibody responses have been thought to be the main protective component, cellular responses - possibly through the CD1 pathway - are also likely to be involved.     

Dendritic cell‐targeting DNA‐based nasal adjuvants for protective mucosal immunity to Streptococcus pneumoniae

To develop safe vaccines for inducing mucosal immunity to major pulmonary bacterial infections, appropriate vaccine antigens (Ags), delivery systems and nontoxic molecular adjuvants must be considered. Such vaccine constructs can induce Ag‐specific immune responses that protect against mucosal infections. In particular, it has been shown that simply mixing the adjuvant with the bacterial Ag is a relatively easy means of constructing adjuvant‐based mucosal vaccine preparations; the resulting vaccines can elicit protective immunity. DNA‐based nasal adjuvants targeting mucosal DCs have been studied in order to induce Ag‐specific mucosal and systemic immune responses that provide essential protection against microbial pathogens that invade mucosal surfaces. In this review, initially a plasmid encoding the cDNA of Flt3 ligand (pFL), a molecule that is a growth factor for DCs, as an effective adjuvant for mucosal immunity to pneumococcal infections, is introduced. Next, the potential of adding unmethylated CpG oligodeoxynucleotide and pFL together with a pneumococcal Ag to induce protection from pneumococcal infections is discussed. Pneumococcal surface protein A has been used as vaccine for restoring mucosal immunity in older persons. Further, our nasal pFL adjuvant system with phosphorylcholine‐keyhole limpet hemocyanin (PC‐KLH) has also been used in pneumococcal vaccine development to induce complete protection from nasal carriage by Streptococcus pneumoniae . Finally, the possibility that anti‐PC antibodies induced by nasal delivery of pFL plus PC‐KLH may play a protective role in prevention of atherogenesis and thus block subsequent development of cardiovascular disease is discussed.

     

Immunity to Haemonchus contortus and the cellular response to helminth antigens in the mammary gland of non-lactating sheep.

Cellular exudates induced by infusion with helminth antigens were examined in non-lactating mammary glands of ewes immune to infection with the abomasal nematode, Haemonchus contortus. Secondary immunological responsiveness was expressed in two ways. Firstly, antigens from adult H. contortus elicited larger eosinophil-rich cellular exudates in immune compared to non-immune ewes. In this situation, secondary responsiveness in the mammary gland must have been generated through abomasal infection with the parasite. Secondly, repeated infusion with the antigens from adult H. contortus increased the size of cellular exudates in both immune and non-immune ewes. Eosinophils predominated but numbers of macrophages and lymphocytes were also increased. In this second situation, secondary responsiveness must have been either supplemented in immune ewes or derived completely in non-immune ewes by contact with helminth antigens through the mammary gland. The helminth antigens which induce eosinophil exudates in the mammary gland may not be potently protective against H. contortus. Furthermore, eosinophil exudation may not be an in vivo correlate of immunity which is directly useful for discriminating protective antigens and applicable to vaccine development. Infusion with antigens from adult forms of either H. contortus or Trichostrongylus colubriformis elicited cellular exudates equally well in immune ewes primed by infusion with H. contortus adult antigens 7 days beforehand. In addition, antigens from infective larvae of H. contortus elicited cellular exudates more potently than antigens from adult worms. However, vaccination with irradiated larvae has shown that species-specific protective immunity for H. contortus is stronger than cross-protective immunity conferred by T. colubriformis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Vaccination and the population structure of antigenically diverse pathogens that exchange genetic material.

Populations of antigenically diverse pathogens undergoing genetic exchange may be categorized into strains on the basis of a set of principal protective antigens. The extent to which polyvalent vaccines based on these protective antigens can alter the population structure of the pathogen is determined by the degree of cross-protection between strains. In the case where there is no cross-protection, vaccinating against a particular strain will have no effect on the others. As cross-protection increases, the strains containing the antigenic variants included in the vaccine will be diminished in prevalence, and those that do not will increase in prevalence. The rise in prevalence of the latter will become more and more exaggerated as cross-protection increases. However, beyond a critical level of cross-protection, in the absence of vaccination, the steady state of the system is asymmetric in that a certain subset of strains (with non-overlapping repertoires of antigenic variants) will dominate over the others in terms of prevalence. Under these circumstances, a vaccine consisting of the most immunogenic combinations of antigenic variants can cause a dramatic increase in frequency of a subset of rare strains.     

Progress in vaccine development against Helicobacter pylori

Based on the very high prevalence of diseases caused by Helicobacter pylori, particularly in the developing world, and the rapid emergence of antibiotic resistance among clinical isolates, there is a strong rationale for an effective vaccine against H. pylori. In this review we describe recent promising candidate vaccines and prophylactic or therapeutic immunization strategies for use against H. pylori, as well as studies to identify immune responses that are related to protection in experimental animals. We also describe identification of different types of immune responses that may be related to protection against symptoms based on comparisons of H. pylori-infected patients with duodenal ulcers or gastric cancer and asymptomatic carriers. We conclude that there is still a strong need to clarify the main protective immune mechanisms against H. pylori as well as to identify a cocktail of strong protective antigens, or recombinant bacterial strains that express such antigens, that could be administered by a regimen that gives rise to effective immune responses in humans.