A persulfurated cysteine promotes active site reactivity in Azotobacter vinelandii Rhodanese

Active site reactivity and specificity of RhdA, a thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase (rhodanese) from Azotobacter vinelandii, have been investigated through ligand binding, site-directed mutagenesis, and X-ray crystallographic techniques, in a combined approach. In native RhdA the active site Cys230 is found persulfurated; fluorescence and sulfurtransferase activity measurements show that phosphate anions interact with Cys230 persulfide sulfur atom and modulate activity. Crystallographic analyses confirm that phosphate and hypophosphite anions react with native RhdA, removing the persulfide sulfur atom from the active site pocket. Considering that RhdA and the catalytic subunit of Cdc25 phosphatases share a common three-dimensional fold as well as active site Cys (catalytic) and Arg residues, two RhdA mutants carrying a single amino acid insertion at the active site loop were designed and their phosphatase activity tested. The crystallographic and functional results reported here show that specific sulfurtransferase or phosphatase activities are strictly related to precise tailoring of the catalytic loop structure in RhdA and Cdc25 phosphatase, respectively.     

1H, 13C and 15N resonance assignments of rhodanese GlpE from Escherichia coli

Rhodanese catalyzes the sulfur-transfer reaction in which a sulfur atom is transferred from thiosulfate to cyanide by a double-displacement mechanism. During the reaction, a persulfide-intermediate form of rhodanese is generated by the reaction of a conserved active cysteine residue with thiosulfate. Escherichia coli GlpE is a prototype for the single-domain rhodanese superfamily. Though there are some studies on rhodaneses, the molecular mechanism of the catalytic activity of rhodaneses is still unclear. Herein, we report the resonance assignments of (1)H, (13)C and (15)N atoms of E. coli GlpE, which provides the basis for further structural, dynamic and functional studies of rhodaneses using NMR technique.     

Mutagenic analysis of Thr-232 in rhodanese from Azotobacter vinelandii highlighted the differences of this prokaryotic enzyme from the known sulfurtransferases

Azotobacter vinelandii RhdA uses thiosulfate as the only sulfur donor in vitro, and this apparent selectivity seems to be a unique property among the characterized sulfurtransferases. To investigate the basis of substrate recognition in RhdA, we replaced Thr-232 with either Ala or Lys. Thr-232 was the target of this study since the corresponding Lys-249 in bovine rhodanese has been identified as necessary for catalytic sulfur transfer, and replacement of Lys-249 with Ala fully inactivates bovine rhodanese. Both T232K and T232A mutants of RhdA showed significant increase in thiosulfate-cyanide sulfurtransferase activity, and no detectable activity in the presence of 3-mercaptopyruvate as the sulfur donor substrate. Fluorescence measurements showed that wild-type and mutant RhdAs were overexpressed in the persulfurated form, thus conferring to this enzyme the potential of a persulfide sulfur donor compound. RhdA contains a unique sequence stretch around the catalytic cysteine, and the data here presented suggest a possible divergent physiological function of A. vinelandii sulfurtransferase.     

Molecular recognition between Azotobacter vinelandii rhodanese and a sulfur acceptor protein

The occurrence of rhodanese-like proteins in the major evolutionary phyla, together with the observed abundance of these proteins also within the same genome, suggests that their function cannot be limited to cyanide scavenging. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether Azotobacter vinelandii RhdA, an enzyme possessing unique biochemical and structural features with respect to other members of rhodanese homology superfamily, could recognize a suitable protein as a potential acceptor of the sulfane sulfur held on its catalytic Cys residue. Both the potential sulfur-delivery RhdA-S and the sulfur-deprived RhdA were found to interact with either holo- or apo-adrenodoxin, the 'substrate' protein used in this work. Interaction of RhdA-S with apo-adrenodoxin led to mobilization of RhdA-S sulfane sulfur. Under appropriate conditions, the sulfur released from RhdA-S was productively used for 2Fe-2S cluster reconstitution to yield holo-adrenodoxin from apo-adrenodoxin in the absence of any other sulfur source. A comparison of the reactivity of RhdA-S with protein and non-protein thiols allowed also some insights into the accessibility of the sulfane sulfur carried by RhdA.     

Transfer of persulfide sulfur from thiocystine to rhodanese.

THiocystine (bis-[2-amino-2-carboxyethyl]trisulfide) is a natural substrate for rhodanese (thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase, EC 2.8.1.1). Analogs of thiocystine were prepared by eliminating the carboxyl or amino group or by lengthening the carbon chain. Of these only homothiocystine (bis-[2-amino-2-carboxypropyl]trisulfide) had appreciable activity as a substrate. At pH 8.6, the optimum for rhodanese, transfer of sulfane sulfur to cyanide in the presence of rhodanese was nonspecific. Only the sulfane sulfur of 35S-labeled thiocystine was transferred to rhodanese. Thus, thiocystine and thiosulfate both produce a rhodanese persulfide as a stable intermediate in sulfur transfer.     

The crystal structure of a sulfurtransferase from Azotobacter vinelandii highlights the evolutionary relationship between the rhodanese and phosphatase enzyme families

Rhodanese is an ubiquitous enzyme that in vitro catalyses the transfer of a sulfur atom from suitable donors to nucleophilic acceptors by way of a double displacement mechanism. During the catalytic process the enzyme cycles between a sulfur-free and a persulfide-containing form, via formation of a persulfide linkage to a catalytic Cys residue. In the nitrogen-fixing bacteria Azotobacter vinelandii the rhdA gene has been identified and the encoded protein functionally characterized as a rhodanese. The crystal structure of the A. vinelandii rhodanese has been determined and refined at 1.8 A resolution in the sulfur-free and persulfide-containing forms. Conservation of the overall three-dimensional fold of bovine rhodanese is observed, with substantial modifications of the protein structure in the proximity of the catalytic residue Cys230. Remarkably, the native enzyme is found as the Cys230-persulfide form; in the sulfur-free state the catalytic Cys residue adopts two alternate conformations, reflected by perturbation of the neighboring active-site residues, which is associated with a partly reversible loss of thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase activity. The catalytic mechanism of A. vinelandii rhodanese relies primarily on the main-chain conformation of the 230 to 235 active-site loop and on a surrounding strong positive electrostatic field. Substrate recognition is based on residues which are entirely different in the prokaryotic and eukaryotic enzymes. The active-site loop of A. vinelandii rhodanese displays striking structural similarity to the active-site loop of the similarly folded catalytic domain of dual specific phosphatase Cdc25, suggesting a common evolutionary origin of the two enzyme families.     

The cysteine-desulfurase IscS promotes the production of the rhodanese RhdA in the persulfurated form

After heterologous expression in Escherichia coli, the Azotobacter vinelandii rhodanese RhdA is purified in a persulfurated form (RhdA-SSH). We identified l-cysteine as the most effective sulfur source in producing RhdA-SSH. An E. coli soluble extract was required for in vitro persulfuration of RhdA, and the addition of pyridoxal-5'-phosphate increased RhdA-SSH production, indicating a likely involvement of a cysteine desulfurase. We were able to show the formation of a covalent complex between IscS and RhdA. By combining a time-course fluorescence assay and mass spectrometry analysis, we demonstrated the transfer of sulfur from E. coli IscS to RhdA.     

Solution structures and backbone dynamics of Escherichia coli rhodanese PspE in its sulfur-free and persulfide-intermediate forms: implications for the catalytic mechanism of rhodanese

Rhodanese catalyzes the sulfur-transfer reaction that transfers sulfur from thiosulfate to cyanide by a double-displacement mechanism, in which an active cysteine residue plays a central role. Previous studies indicated that the phage-shock protein E (PspE) from Escherichia coli is a rhodanese composed of a single active domain and is the only accessible rhodanese among the three single-domain rhodaneses in E. coli. To understand the catalytic mechanism of rhodanese at the molecular level, we determined the solution structures of the sulfur-free and persulfide-intermediate forms of PspE by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and identified the active site by NMR titration experiments. To obtain further insights into the catalytic mechanism, we studied backbone dynamics by NMR relaxation experiments. Our results demonstrated that the overall structures in both sulfur-free and persulfide-intermediate forms are highly similar, suggesting that no significant conformational changes occurred during the catalytic reaction. However, the backbone dynamics revealed that the motional properties of PspE in its sulfur-free form are different from the persulfide-intermediate state. The conformational exchanges are largely enhanced in the persulfide-intermediate form of PspE, especially around the active site. The present structural and biochemical studies in combination with backbone dynamics provide further insights in understanding the catalytic mechanism of rhodanese.     

New crystalline derivatives of bovine liver rhodanese

Mitochondrial bovine liver rhodanese (thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase) has been crystallized in the form deprived of the transferable sulfur. The essential condition for crystallization was the removal of oxygen. Crystals of the sulfur-free enzyme are isomorphous with the previously characterized crystals of the sulfur-substituted enzyme. The new crystal species can react with either thiosulfate or selenosulfate to form the catalytic intermediate and, subsequently, with cyanide to form the corresponding product. Furthermore, the enzyme active site can be alkylated by iodoacetic acid.     

The differential functional stability of various forms of bovine liver rhodanese

Bovine liver rhodanese (thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase, EC 2.8.1.1) was prepared in dilute solutions and subjected to conditions that led to a time-dependent loss of enzyme activity. The rate of this activity loss was found to be dependent upon the sulfur substitution state of the enzyme, and the presence or absence of the substrates, thiosulfate and cyanide. In the absence of excess substrates, free enzyme (E), and the covalent intermediate form of the enzyme bearing a divalent sulfur atom in the active site (ES), are of approximately equal functional stability. In comparison, E, in the presence of excess cyanide, was markedly more labile, while ES, supported by 10-50 mM thiosulfate, showed no significant loss of activity under any of the conditions tested. All the enzyme solutions were shown to be losing assayable protein from solution. However, it was demonstrated that, for rhodanese in the E form, the amount of protein lost was insufficient to account for the activity lost, and a marked decline in specific activity was observed. Enzyme in the ES form, whether supported by additional thiosulfate or not, did not decline in the specific activity, though comparable protein loss did occur from these solutions. Intrinsic fluorescence measurements of rhodanese in the ES form, before and after removal of the persulfide sulfur through the addition of cyanide, indicated that loss of enzymic activity was not accompanied by loss of the bound sulfur atom. Therefore, the stabilizing effect observed with thiosulfate could not be explained simply by its ability to maintain enzyme in the sulfur-substituted state. Since the concentration of thiosulfate employed in these experiments was insufficient to maintain all the enzyme in ES.S2O3 form, thiosulfate was acting as a chemical reagent rather than a substrate in stabilizing enzyme activity.     

The structure of bovine liver rhodanese. II. The active site in the sulfur-substituted and the sulfur-free enzyme.

X-ray studies at 2.5 Å resolution show that the active site of bovine liver rhodanese is a depression between the two domains. In sulfur-substituted rhodanese the density of the essential Cys247 corresponds with that of a persulfide. Both sulfur atoms are interacting via hydrogen bonds with several peptide NH and side-chain OH groups. One side of the active site pocket contains mainly hydrophylic, the other side mainly hydrophobic residues. None of these hydrophylic or hydrophobic groups appears to interact strongly with the persulfide.Crystals of the sulfur-substituted enzyme were treated with cyanide, a sulfur acceptor. Subsequent difference Fourier studies show that the extra sulfur atom has been removed. Only minor conformational differences appear to exist between the two rhodanese species studied. These are a movement of the Sγ atom of Cys247 and some rearrangement of solvent molecules near the active site.The combination of these observations with the results of experiments performed by other investigators suggest a mechanism for sulfur transfer by rhodanese in which the thiol group of Cys247 is the essential nucleophile, whereas the positive charges on Arg186 and Lys249 act in various ways as “electrophilic assistants”. The transition state and the persulfide in the sulfur-substituted enzyme are stabilized by several hydrogen bonds.     

Mobilization of sulfane sulfur from cysteine desulfurases to the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Azotobacter vinelandii</Emphasis> sulfurtransferase RhdA

Mobilization of the l-cysteine sulfur for the persulfuration of the rhodanese of Azotobacter vinelandii, RhdA, can be mediated by the A. vinelandii cysteine desulfurases, IscS and NifS. The amount of cysteine was higher in mutant strains lacking rhdA (MV474) than in wild type. The diazotrophic growth of MV474 was impaired. Taking into account the functional results about rhodanese-like proteins and RhdA itself, it is suggested that RhdA-dependent modulation of l-cysteine levels must deal with a redox-related process.     

Evidence that elongation of the catalytic loop of the Azotobacter vinelandii rhodanese changed selectivity from sulfur- to phosphate-containing substrates

Recent investigations have shown that the rhodanese domains, ubiquitous structural modules which might represent an example of conserved structures with possible functional diversity, are structurally related to the catalytic subunit of Cdc25 phosphatase enzymes. The major difference characterizing the active-site of the Azotobacter vinelandii rhodanese RhdA, with respect to the closely related Cdc25s (A, B, C), is that in Cdc25 phosphatases the active site loop [His-Cys-(X)5-Arg] is one residue longer than in RhdA [His-Cys-(X)4-Arg]. According to the hypothesis that the length of the RhdA active-site loop should play a key role in substrate recognition and catalytic activity, RhdA scaffold was the starting point for producing mutants with single-residue insertion to generate the catalytic loop HCQTHAHR (in RhdA-Ala) and HCQTHSHR (in RhdA-Ser). Analyses of the catalytic performances of the engineered RhdAs revealed that elongation of the catalytic loop definitely compromised the ability to catalyze sulfur transfer reactions, while it generated 'phosphatase' enzymes able to interact productively with the artificial substrate 3-O-methylfluorescein phosphate. Although this study is restricted to an example of rhodanese modules (RhdA), it provided experimental evidence of the hypothesis that a specific mutational event (a single-residue insertion or deletion in the active-site loop) could change the selectivity from sulfur- to phosphate-containing substrates (or vice versa).     

Properties of the Escherichia coli rhodanese-like protein SseA: contribution of the active-site residue Ser240 to sulfur donor recognition

The product of Escherichia coli sseA gene (SseA) was the subject of the present investigation aimed to provide a tool for functional classification of the bacterial proteins of the rhodanese family. E. coli SseA contains the motif CGSGVTA around the catalytic cysteine (Cys238). In eukaryotic sulfurtransferases this motif discriminates for 3-mercaptopyruvate:cyanide sulfurtransferase over thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferases (rhodanese). The biochemical characterization of E. coli SseA allowed the identification of the first prokaryotic protein with a preference for 3-mercaptopyruvate as donor substrate. Replacement of Ser240 with Ala showed that the presence of a hydrophobic residue did not affect the binding of 3-mercaptopyruvate, but strongly prevented thiosulfate binding. On the contrary, substitution of Ser240 with an ionizable residue (Lys) increased the affinity for thiosulfate.     

Properties of the Escherichia coli rhodanese-like protein SseA: contribution of the active-site residue Ser240 to sulfur donor recognition.

The product of Escherichia coli sseA gene (SseA) was the subject of the present investigation aimed to provide a tool for functional classification of the bacterial proteins of the rhodanese family. E. coli SseA contains the motif CGSGVTA around the catalytic cysteine (Cys238). In eukaryotic sulfurtransferases this motif discriminates for 3-mercaptopyruvate:cyanide sulfurtransferase over thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferases (rhodanese). The biochemical characterization of E. coli SseA allowed the identification of the first prokaryotic protein with a preference for 3-mercaptopyruvate as donor substrate. Replacement of Ser240 with Ala showed that the presence of a hydrophobic residue did not affect the binding of 3-mercaptopyruvate, but strongly prevented thiosulfate binding. On the contrary, substitution of Ser240 with an ionizable residue (Lys) increased the affinity for thiosulfate.     

Site-directed mutagenesis of the active site loop of the rhodanese-like domain of the human molybdopterin synthase sulfurase MOCS3. Major differences in substrate specificity between eukaryotic and bacterial homologs

Sequence alignments of human molybdopterin synthase sulfurase, MOCS3, showed that the N-terminal domain is homologous to Escherichia coli MoeB, whereas the C-terminal domain is homologous to rhodanese-like proteins. Previous studies showed that the activity of the separately purified rhodanese-like domain of MOCS3 displayed 1000-fold lower activity in comparison to bovine rhodanese with thiosulfate as sulfur source. When the six amino acid active site loop of MOCS3 rhodanese-like domain was exchanged with the loop found in bovine rhodanese, thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase activity was increased 165-fold. Site-directed mutagenesis of each individual residue of the active site loop of the MOCS3 rhodanese-like domain showed that the charge of the last amino acid determines thiosulfate sulfurtransferase activity. Replacing Asp417 by threonine resulted in 90-fold increased activity, whereas replacing it by arginine increased the activity 470-fold. Using a fully defined in vitro system containing precursor Z, MOCS2A, E. coli MoaE, E. coli MoeB, Mg-ATP, MOCS3 rhodanese-like domain, and thiosulfate, it was shown that sulfur transfer to MOCS2A was also affected by the alterations, but not as drastically. Our studies revealed that in humans and most eukaryotes thiosulfate is not the physiologic sulfur donor for MOCS3, whereas in bacterial homologs, which have an arginine at the last position of the active site loop, thiosulfate can be used as a sulfur source for molybdenum cofactor biosynthesis. The phylogenetic analysis of MoeB homologs showed that eukaryotic homologs are of bacterial origin. Furthermore, it could be shown that an MoeB homolog named MoeZ, where the dual CXXC zinc-binding motif of the MoeB domain is not present, arose independently several times during evolution.     

Acceptor substrate-potentiated inactivation of bovine liver rhodanese

The interaction of bovine liver rhodanese (thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase, EC 2.8.1.1) with the acceptor substrates, dithiothreitol or cyanide, was studied. When incubated in the presence of cyanide or dithiothreitol, rhodanese was inactivated in a time-dependent process. This inactivation was detectable only at low enzyme concentrations; the rate and degree of inactivation could be modulated by varying the substrate concentration or the system pH. Activity measurements and fluorescence spectroscopy techniques were used in examining the inactivation phenomenon. Sulfur transfer to dithiothreitol was measured by direct assay and was shown to involve the dequenching of enzymic intrinsic fluorescence that had been previously observed only with cyanide as the acceptor substrate. Substrate-potentiated inactivation of rhodanese (with cyanide) has been reported before, but the cause and nature of this interaction were unexplained. The results presented here are consistent with an explanation invoking oxidation of rhodanese in the course of inactivation.     

Properties of a soluble thiosulfate sulfur transferase (rhodanese) of the marine methanogen Methanosarcina frisia

Abstract: Cell-free extracts of Methanosarcina frisia contain high thiosulfate sulfur transferase (TST) (rhodanese), slight thiosulfate reductase but no thiosulfate: acceptor oxidoreductase activity. Neither adenylylsulfate reductase nor sulfite: acceptor oxidoreductase activity could be detected. TST is an acidic protein with an M _r of 25 000 and was enriched by ion-exchange chromatography and gel filtration. The enzyme has a temperature optimum at 60°C and a pH optimum at pH 11. The K _m values for thiosulfate and cyanide are 0.53 mM and 1.57 mM, respectively. Low concentrations of cysteine, glutathione, dithioerythritol, and dihydrolipoate increase the activity of the enzyme while unphysiological concentrations of these effectors cause a decrease. Sulfite and N -bromosuccinimide inhibit the energy activity extremely.     

Fast conformational exchange between the sulfur-free and persulfide-bound rhodanese domain of E. coli YgaP

Rhodanese domains are abundant structural modules that catalyze the transfer of a sulfur atom from thiolsulfates to cyanide via formation of a covalent persulfide intermediate that is bound to an essential conserved cysteine residue. In this study, the three-dimensional structure of the rhodanese domain of YgaP from Escherichia coli was determined using solution NMR. A typical rhodanese domain fold was observed, as expected from the high homology with the catalytic domain of other sulfur transferases. The initial sulfur-transfer step and formation of the rhodanese persulfide intermediate were monitored by addition of sodium thiosulfate using two-dimensional ¹H–¹⁵N correlation spectroscopy. Discrete sharp signals were observed upon substrate addition, indicting fast exchange between sulfur-free and persulfide-intermediate forms. Residues exhibiting pronounced chemical shift changes were mapped to the structure, and included both substrate binding and surrounding residues.