Disparate contributions of the Fanconi anemia pathway and homologous recombination in preventing spontaneous mutagenesis

Fanconi anemia (FA) is a chromosomal instability disorder in which DNA-damage processing defects are reported for translesion synthesis (TLS), non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR; both increased and decreased). To reconcile these diverse findings, we compared spontaneous mutagenesis in FA and HR mutants of hamster CHO cells. In the fancg mutant we find a reduced mutation rate accompanied by an increased proportion of deletions within the hprt gene. Moreover, in fancg cells gene amplification at the CAD and dhfr loci is elevated, another manifestation of inappropriate processing of damage during DNA replication. In contrast, the rad51d HR mutant has a greatly elevated rate of hprt mutations, >85% of which are deletions. Our analysis supports the concept that HR faithfully restores broken replication forks, whereas the FA pathway acts more globally to ensure chromosome stability by promoting efficient end joining of replication-derived breaks, as well as TLS and HR.     

Requirement for the SRS2 DNA helicase gene in non-homologous end joining in yeast

Mitotic cells experience double-strand breaks (DSBs) from both exogenous and endogenous sources. Since unrepaired DSBs can result in genome rearrangements or cell death, cells mobilize multiple pathways to repair the DNA damage. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, mitotic cells preferentially use a homologous recombination repair pathway. However, when no significant homology to the DSB ends is available, cells utilize a repair process called non-homologous end joining (NHEJ), which can join ends with no homology through resection to uncover microhomologies of a few nucleotides. Although components of the homologous recombination repair system are also involved in NHEJ, the rejoining does not involve all of the homologous recombination repair genes. The SRS2 DNA helicase has been shown to be required for DSB repair when the homologous single-stranded regions are short. Here it is shown that SRS2 is also required for NHEJ, regardless of the cell mating type. Efficient NHEJ of sticky ends requires the Ku70 and Ku80 proteins and the silencing genes SIR2, SIR3 and SIR4. However, NHEJ of blunt ends, while very inefficient, is not further reduced by mutations in YKU70, SIR2, SIR3, SIR4 or SRS2, suggesting that this rejoining process occurs by a different mechanism.     

Analysis of Gene Targeting and Intrachromosomal Homologous Recombination Stimulated by Genomic Double-Strand Breaks in Mouse Embryonic Stem Cells

To investigate the effects of in vivo genomic DNA double-strand breaks on the efficiency and mechanisms of gene targeting in mouse embryonic stem cells, we have used a series of insertion and replacement vectors carrying two, one, or no genomic sites for the rare-cutting endonuclease I-SceI. These vectors were introduced into the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) gene to produce substrates for gene-targeting (plasmid-to-chromosome) or intrachromosomal (direct repeat) homologous recombination. Recombination at the hprt locus is markedly increased following transfection with an I-SceI expression plasmid and a homologous donor plasmid (if needed). The frequency of gene targeting in clones with an I-SceI site attains a value of 1%, 5,000-fold higher than that in clones with no I-SceI site. The use of silent restriction site polymorphisms indicates that the frequencies with which donor plasmid sequences replace the target chromosomal sequences decrease with distance from the genomic break site. The frequency of intrachromosomal recombination reaches a value of 3.1%, 120-fold higher than background spontaneous recombination. Because palindromic insertions were used as polymorphic markers, a significant number of recombinants exhibit distinct genotypic sectoring among daughter cells from a single clone, suggesting the existence of heteroduplex DNA in the original recombination product.     

The Bacillus subtilis chromatin-associated protein Hbsu is involved in DNA repair and recombination

The Bacillus subtilis hbs gene encodes an essential chromatin-associated protein termed Hbsu. Hbsu, the counterpart of the Escherichia coli HU protein, binds DNA in a non-specific way but has a clear preference for bent, kinked or altered DNA sequences. To investigate the role of Hbsu in DNA repair and DNA recombination we have constructed a series of site-directed mutants in the hbs gene and used these mutant genes to substitute the wild-type chromosomal hbs gene. The hbs47 mutation, which codes for a mutant protein in which residue Phe-47 has been replaced by Trp, does not cause any discernible phenotype. Additional substitution of residue Arg-55 by Ala (hbs4755 mutation) rendered cells deficient in DNA repair, homologous recombination and (i protein-mediated site-specific recombination. We have also tested the effect on DNA repair of the hbs4755 mutation in combination with mutations in different functions of homologous DNA recombination (recA, recF, recG, recti and addAB). The hbs4755 mutation did not modify the sensitivity of recH and addAB cells to the DNA-damaging agents methylmethane sulphonate (MMS) or 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide (4NQO), and it only marginally affected recF and recG cells. The hbs4755 mutation blocked intermolecular recombination in recH cells and markedly reduced it (20- to 50-fold) in recF and recG cells, but had no effect on addAB cells. Taken together, these data indicate that the Hbsu protein is required for DNA repair and for homologous DNA recombination.     

RAD51 supports spontaneous non-homologous recombination in mammalian cells, but not the corresponding process induced by topoisomerase inhibitors

The RAD51 protein has been shown to participate in homologous recombination by promoting ATP-dependent homologous pairing and strand transfer reactions. In the present study, we have investigated the possible involvement of RAD51 in non-homologous recombination. We demonstrate that overexpression of CgRAD51 enhances the frequency of spontaneous non-homologous recombination in the hprt gene of Chinese hamster cells. However, the rate of non-homologous recombination induced by the topoisomerase inhibitors campothecin and etoposide was not altered by overexpression of RAD51. These results indicate that the RAD51 protein may perform a function in connection with spontaneous non-homologous recombination that is not essential to or not rate-limiting for non-homologous recombination induced by camptothecin or etoposide. We discuss the possibility that the role played by RAD51 in non-homologous recombination observed here may not be linked to non-homologous end-joining.     

Role for RAD18 in homologous recombination in DT40 cells

RAD18 is an E3 ubiquitin ligase that catalyzes the monoubiquitination of PCNA, a modification central to DNA damage bypass and postreplication repair in both yeast and vertebrates. Although current evidence suggests that homologous recombination provides an essential backup in vertebrate rad18 mutants, we show that in chicken DT40 cells this is not the case and that RAD18 plays a role in the recombination reaction itself. Gene conversion tracts in the immunoglobulin locus of rad18 cells are shorter and are associated with an increased frequency of deletions and duplications. rad18 cells also exhibit reduced efficiency of gene conversion induced by targeted double-strand breaks in a reporter construct. Blocking an early stage of the recombination reaction by disruption of XRCC3 not only suppresses immunoglobulin gene conversion but also prevents the aberrant immunoglobulin gene rearrangements associated with RAD18 deficiency, reverses the elevated sister chromatid exchange of the rad18 mutant, and reduces its sensitivity to DNA damage. Together, these data suggest that homologous recombination is toxic in the absence of RAD18 and show that, in addition to its established role in postreplication repair, RAD18 is also required for the orderly completion of gene conversion.     

Triple-helix formation induces recombination in mammalian cells via a nucleotide excision repair-dependent pathway

The ability to stimulate recombination in a site-specific manner in mammalian cells may provide a useful tool for gene knockout and a valuable strategy for gene therapy. We previously demonstrated that psoralen adducts targeted by triple-helix-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) could induce recombination between tandem repeats of a supF reporter gene in a simian virus 40 vector in monkey COS cells. Based on work showing that triple helices, even in the absence of associated psoralen adducts, are able to provoke DNA repair and cause mutations, we asked whether intermolecular triplexes could stimulate recombination. Here, we report that triple-helix formation itself is capable of promoting recombination and that this effect is dependent on a functional nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway. Transfection of COS cells carrying the dual supF vector with a purine-rich TFO, AG30, designed to bind as a third strand to a region between the two mutant supF genes yielded recombinants at a frequency of 0.37%, fivefold above background, whereas a scrambled sequence control oligomer was ineffective. In human cells deficient in the NER factor XPA, the ability of AG30 to induce recombination was eliminated, but it was restored in a corrected subline expressing the XPA cDNA. In comparison, the ability of triplex-directed psoralen cross-links to induce recombination was only partially reduced in XPA-deficient cells, suggesting that NER is not the only pathway that can metabolize targeted psoralen photoadducts into recombinagenic intermediates. Interestingly, the triplex-induced recombination was unaffected in cells deficient in DNA mismatch repair, challenging our previous model of a heteroduplex intermediate and supporting a model based on end joining. This work demonstrates that oligonucleotide-mediated triplex formation can be recombinagenic, providing the basis for a potential strategy to direct genome modification by using high-affinity DNA binding ligands.     

Role of the nucleotide excision repair gene ERCC1 in formation of recombination-dependent rearrangements in mammalian cells

Spontaneous recombination between direct repeats at the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) locus in ERCC1-deficient cells generates a high frequency of rearrangements that are dependent on the process of homologous recombination, suggesting that rearrangements are formed by misprocessing of recombination intermediates. Given the specificity of the structure-specific Ercc1/Xpf endonuclease, two potential recombination intermediates are substrates for misprocessing in ERCC1^– cells: heteroduplex loops and heteroduplex intermediates with non-homologous 3′ tails. To investigate the roles of each, we constructed repeats that would yield no heteroduplex loops during spontaneous recombination or that would yield two non-homologous 3′ tails after treatment with the rare-cutting endonuclease I-SceI. Our results indicate that misprocessing of heteroduplex loops is not the major source of recombination-dependent rearrangements in ERCC1-deficient cells. Our results also suggest that the Ercc1/Xpf endonuclease is required for efficient removal of non-homologous 3′ tails, like its Rad1/Rad10 counterpart in yeast. Thus, it is likely that misprocessing of non-homologous 3′ tails is the primary source of recombination-dependent rearrangements in mammalian cells. We also find an unexpected effect of ERCC1 deficiency on I-SceI-stimulated rearrangements, which are not dependent on homologous recombination, suggesting that the ERCC1 gene product may play a role in generating the rearrangements that arise after I-SceI-induced double-strand breaks.     

DNA pairing is an important step in the process of targeted nucleotide exchange

Modified single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides can direct the repair of genetic mutations in yeast, plant and mammalian cells. The mechanism by which these molecules exert their effect is being elucidated, but the first phase is likely to involve the homologous alignment of the single strand with its complementary sequence in the target gene. In this study, we establish the importance of such DNA pairing in facilitating the gene repair event. Oligonucleotide-directed repair occurs at a low frequency in an Escherichia coli strain (DH10B) lacking the RECA DNA pairing function. Repair activity can be rescued by using purified RecA protein to catalyze the assimilation of oligonucleotide vectors into a plasmid containing a mutant kanamycin resistance gene in vitro. Electroporation of the preformed complex into DH10B cells results in high levels of gene repair activity, evidenced by the appearance of kanamycin-resistant colonies. Gene repair is dependent on the formation of a double-displacement loop (double-D-loop), a recombination intermediate containing two single-stranded oligonucleotides hybridized to opposite strands of the plasmid at the site of the point mutation. The heightened level of stability of the double-D-loop enables it to serve as an active template for the DNA repair events. The data establish DNA pairing and the formation of the double-D-loop as important first steps in the process of gene repair.     

The type of mutations induced by carbon-ion-beam irradiation of the filamentous fungus Neurospora crassa

Heavy-ion beams are known to cause great damage to cellular components and are particularly renowned for their ability to generate DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). To gain insight into the mutagenic effect of carbon-ion beams and how such damage is repaired by the cell, Neurospora crassa mutants deficient in one of three components involved in the repair of DSBs, nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ), homologous recombination repair (HR), and the Mre11-Rad50-Xrs2 (MRX) complex, were irradiated with a carbon-ion beam and killing effect, mutation frequencies, and the type of mutation incurred by survivors were analysed. The sensitivity of the NHEJ-deficient strain (mus-52) was higher than that of the wild-type and the HR-deficient (mei-3) strains at low doses of radiation, but was little changed as the level increased. As a result both the wild-type and HR-deficient strains were more sensitive than the NHEJ-deficient strain at high radiation levels. In addition, the frequency of forward mutation at the adenine-3 (ad-3) loci of the NHEJ-deficient mutant was lower than that of the wild-type strain at all levels, while the mutation frequency of the HR-deficient strain was consistently ∼3-fold higher than the wild-type. From the comparison of mutation type of each strain, deletions were frequently observed in wild-type strain, whilst base substitution and deletion in the mus-52 and mei-3 strains. These mutations resulting from carbon-ion-beam irradiation depend on the mechanism invoked to cope with DSBs. Furthermore, in wild-type cells, these mechanisms likely compete to repair DSBs.     

Homologous recombination as a mechanism of carcinogenesis

Cancer develops when cells no longer follow their normal pattern of controlled growth. In the absence or disregard of such regulation, resulting from changes in their genetic makeup, these errant cells acquire a growth advantage, expanding into pre-cancerous clones. Over the last decade many studies have revealed the relevance of genomic mutation in this process, be it by misreplication, environmental damage or a deficiency in repairing endogenous and exogenous damage. Here we discuss homologous recombination as another mechanism that can result in loss of heterozygosity or genetic rearrangements. Some of these genetic alterations may play a primary role in carcinogenesis, but they are more likely to be involved in secondary and subsequent steps of carcinogenesis by which recessive oncogenic mutations are revealed. Patients whose cells display an increased frequency of recombination also have an elevated frequency of cancer, further supporting the link between recombination and carcinogenesis. In addition, homologous recombination is induced by a wide variety of carcinogens, many of which are classically considered to be efficiently repaired by other repair pathways. Overall, homologous recombination is a process that has been widely overlooked but may be more central to the process of carcinogenesis than previously described.     

The Role of MRN in the S-Phase DNA Damage Checkpoint Is Independent of Its Ctp1-dependent Roles in Double-Strand Break Repair and Checkpoint Signaling

The Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 (MRN) complex has many biological functions: processing of double-strand breaks in meiosis, homologous recombination, telomere maintenance, S-phase checkpoint, and genome stability during replication. In the S-phase DNA damage checkpoint, MRN acts both in activation of checkpoint signaling and downstream of the checkpoint kinases to slow DNA replication. Mechanistically, MRN, along with its cofactor Ctp1, is involved in 5′ resection to create single-stranded DNA that is required for both signaling and homologous recombination. However, it is unclear whether resection is essential for all of the cellular functions of MRN. To dissect the various roles of MRN, we performed a structure–function analysis of nuclease dead alleles and potential separation-of-function alleles analogous to those found in the human disease ataxia telangiectasia-like disorder, which is caused by mutations in Mre11. We find that several alleles of rad32 (the fission yeast homologue of mre11), along with ctp1Δ, are defective in double-strand break repair and most other functions of the complex, but they maintain an intact S phase DNA damage checkpoint. Thus, the MRN S-phase checkpoint role is separate from its Ctp1- and resection-dependent role in double-strand break repair. This observation leads us to conclude that other functions of MRN, possibly its role in replication fork metabolism, are required for S-phase DNA damage checkpoint function.     

Yeast MPH1 gene functions in an error-free DNA damage bypass pathway that requires genes from Homologous recombination, but not from postreplicative repair

The MPH1 gene from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, encoding a member of the DEAH family of proteins, had been identified by virtue of the spontaneous mutator phenotype of respective deletion mutants. Genetic analysis suggested that MPH1 functions in a previously uncharacterized DNA repair pathway that protects the cells from damage-induced mutations. We have now analyzed genetic interactions of mph1 with a variety of mutants from different repair systems with respect to spontaneous mutation rates and sensitivities to different DNA-damaging agents. The dependence of the mph1 mutator phenotype on REV3 and REV1 and the synergy with mutations in base and nucleotide excision repair suggest an involvement of MPH1 in error-free bypass of lesions. However, although we observed an unexpected partial suppression of the mph1 mutator phenotype by rad5, genetic interactions with other mutations in postreplicative repair imply that MPH1 does not belong to this pathway. Instead, mutations from the homologous recombination pathway were found to be epistatic to mph1 with respect to both spontaneous mutation rates and damage sensitivities. Determination of spontaneous mitotic recombination rates demonstrated that mph1 mutants are not deficient in homologous recombination. On the contrary, in an sgs1 background we found a pronounced hyperrecombination phenotype. Thus, we propose that MPH1 is involved in a branch of homologous recombination that is specifically dedicated to error-free bypass.     

Induction of direct repeat recombination by psoralen–DNA adducts in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: Defects in DNA repair increase gene copy number variation

Psoralen photoreaction produces covalent monoadducts and interstrand crosslinks in DNA. The interstrand DNA crosslinks are complex double strand lesions that require the involvement of multiple pathways for repair. Homologous recombination, which can carry out error-free repair, is a major pathway for crosslink repair; however, some recombination pathways can also produce DNA rearrangements. Psoralen photoreaction-induced recombination in yeast was measured using direct repeat substrates that can detect gene conversions, a form of conservative recombination, as well as deletions and triplications, which generate gene copy number changes. In repair-proficient cells the major products of recombination were gene conversions, along with substantial fractions of deletions. Deficiencies in DNA repair pathways increased non-conservative recombination products. Homologous recombination-deficient rad51, rad54, and rad57 strains had low levels of crosslink-induced recombination, and most products were deletions produced by single strand annealing. Nucleotide excision repair-deficient rad1 and rad2 yeast had increased levels of triplications, and rad1 cells had lower crosslink-induced recombination. Deficiencies in post-replication repair increased crosslink-induced recombination and gene copy number changes. Loss of REV3 function, in the error-prone branch, and of RAD5 and UBC13, in the error-free branch, produced moderate increases in deletions and triplications; rad18 cells, deficient in both post-replication repair sub-pathways, exhibited hyperrecombination, with primarily non-conservative products. Proper functioning of all the DNA repair pathways tested was required to maintain genomic stability and avoid gene copy number variation in response to interstrand crosslinks.     

Endogenous lesions, S-phase-independent spontaneous mutations, and evolutionary strategies for base excision repair

We calculate from published levels of endogenous base lesions that our cells constantly generate and excise during base excision repair (BER) about one million lesions per day. Repair glycosylases may also non-specifically excise an additional number of undamaged bases. The resulting abasic sites are repaired daily by BER. The fidelity of polymerase-beta is 2.4 × 10⁻⁵ and one must postulate additional fidelity mechanisms in the BER complex to explain the low mutation rate of resting cells. Any strategy which constitutively increases glycosylase activity to prevent endogenous lesions from entering S-phase and becoming mutations will also serve to increase the number of mutations per day caused by non-specific excision of normal undamaged bases. The best break-even strategy for reducing endogenous lesion-induced mutations is clearly not one of avid repair. Lower organisms from bacteriophage to fungi have adopted strategies to generate 0.0033 consequential mutations per cell division, no more and no less. Strategies such as down regulating glycosylase activity outside of S-phase to reduce time-dependent mutation frequency while leaving lesion replication-induced mutation frequency unchanged are discussed.     

Rad51p and Rad54p,but not Rad52p,elevate gene repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae directed by modified single-stranded oligonucleotide vectors

Synthetic single-stranded DNA vectors have been used to correct point and frameshift mutations in episomal or chromosomal targets in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Certain parameters, such as the length of the vector and the genetic background of the organism, have a significant impact on the process of targeted gene repair, and point mutations are corrected at a higher frequency than frameshift mutations. Genetic analyses reveal that expression levels of the recombination/repair genes RAD51, RAD52 and RAD54 can affect the frequency of gene repair. Overexpression of RAD51 enhances the frequency 4-fold for correction of an episomal target and 5-fold for correction of a chromosomal target; overexpression of RAD54 is also effective in stimulating gene repair, to the same extent as RAD51 in the chromosomal target. In sharp contrast, RAD52 gene expression serves to reduce gene repair activity in rescue experiments and in experiments where RAD52 is overexpressed in a wild-type strain. This may suggest an antagonist role for Rad52p. Consistent with this notion, the highest level of targeted repair occurs when the RAD51 gene is overexpressed in a strain of yeast deficient in RAD52 gene function.     

Genetic heterogeneity among blue-cone monochromats

Thirty-three unrelated subjects with blue-cone monochromacy or closely related variants of blue-cone monochromacy were examined for rearrangements in the tandem array of genes encoding the red- and green-cone pigments. In 24 subjects, eight genotypes were found that would be predicted to eliminate the function of all of the genes within the array. As observed in an earlier study, the rearrangements involve either deletion of a locus control region adjacent to the gene array or loss of function via homologous recombination and point mutation. One inactivating mutation, Cys²⁰³-to-Arg, was found in 15 probands who carry single genes and in both visual pigment genes in one subject whose array has two genes. This mutation was also found in at least one of the visual pigment genes in 1 subject whose array has multiple genes and in 2 of 321 control subjects, suggesting that preexisting Cys²⁰³-to-Arg mutations constitute a reservoir of chromosomes that are predisposed to generate blue-cone-monochromat genotypes by unequal homologous recombination and/or gene conversion. Two other point mutations were identified: (a) Arg²⁴⁷-to-Ter in one subject with a single red-pigment gene and (b) Pro³⁰⁷-to-Leu in one subject with a single 5' red-3' green hybrid gene. The observed heterogeneity of genotypes points to the existence of multiple one- and two-step mutational pathways to blue-cone monochromacy.     

Studying Age-dependent Genomic Instability using the S. cerevisiae Chronological Lifespan Model

Studies using the Saccharomyces cerevisiae aging model have uncovered life span regulatory pathways that are partially conserved in higher eukaryotes^1-2. The simplicity and power of the yeast aging model can also be explored to study DNA damage and genome maintenance as well as their contributions to diseases during aging. Here, we describe a system to study age-dependent DNA mutations, including base substitutions, frame-shift mutations, gross chromosomal rearrangements, and homologous/homeologous recombination, as well as nuclear DNA repair activity by combining the yeast chronological life span with simple DNA damage and mutation assays. The methods described here should facilitate the identification of genes/pathways that regulate genomic instability and the mechanisms that underlie age-dependent DNA mutations and cancer in mammals.