Cholinergic Neuronotrophic Factors. Concurrent Activities on Certain Nerve Growth Factor-Responsive Neurons

Abstract: We had previously reported that in vitro survival of chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons can be assured by the addition to the culture medium of appropriate amounts of soluble macromolecular agents termed ciliary neuronotrophic factors. Particularly rich sources of one such factor are aqueous extracts from chick embryo intraocular tissues that include the smooth and striated musculature innervated by ciliary ganglionic neurons. We report here that this eye extract also contains agents that we term ganglionic neuronotrophic factors that support the survival of 11-day chick embryo sympathetic and neonatal mouse dorsal root ganglionic neurons, two traditional targets of nerve growth factor (NGF). Using a recently developed microassay procedure we found that these ganglionic activities are not inactivated by rabbit, rat, or guinea pig antisera raised against the 2.5S (beta) subunit of male mouse submaxillary NGF, rabbit antisera against 7S NGF, or quail antisera against cobra venom NGF. Both the ciliary and ganglionic activities can be quantitated simultaneously by using 24-h in vitro microassays, thus permitting a direct comparison of their respective properties. Both activities were found to (a) adsorb to DE52 cellulose and coelute at a similar salt concentration, (b) focus and be recovered from isoelectric polyacrylamide gels at exactly the same pH region, (c) be heat-and partially acid-labile, but base-stable, and (d) be inactivated by exposure to trypsin. These results suggest that the ciliary and ganglionic neuronotrophic activities are associated with the same protein.     

Purification of the Chick Eye Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor

Dissociated 8-day chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons will not survive for even 24 h in culture without the addition of specific supplements. One such supplement is a protein termed the ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) which is present at very high concentrations within intraocular tissues that contain the same muscle cells innervated by ciliary ganglionic neurons in vivo. We describe here the purification of chick eye CNTF by a 2 1/2-day procedure involving the processing of intraocular tissue extract sequentially through DE52 ion-exchange chromatography, membrane ultrafiltration-concentration, sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation, and preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gradient electrophoresis. An aqueous extract of the tissue from 300 eyes will yield about 10-20 micrograms of biologically active, electrophoretically pure CNTF with a specific activity of 7.5 X 10(6) trophic units/mg protein. Purified CNTF has an Mr of 20,400 daltons and an isoelectric point of about 5, as determined by analytical gel electrophoresis. In addition to supporting the survival of ciliary ganglion neurons, purified CNTF also supports the 24-h survival of cultured neurons from certain chick and rodent sensory and sympathetic ganglia. CNTF differs from mouse submaxillary nerve growth factor (NGF) in molecular weight, isoelectric point, inability to be inactivated by antibodies to NGF, ability to support the in vitro survival of the ciliary ganglion neurons, and inability to support that of 8-day chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic neurons. Thus, CNTF represents the first purified neuronotrophic factor which addresses parasympathetic cholinergic neurons.     

Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor Stimulates Choline Acetyltransferase Activity in Cultured Chicken Retina Neurons

It has been demonstrated that cultured cholinergic retinal neurons from 8-day-old chicken embryos respond to a polypeptide factor present in retinal cell-conditioned medium (RCM) and in retinal extracts. Compared with control cultures, the activity of acetyl-CoA:choline O-acetyltransferase (EC 2.3.1.6; ChAT) is enhanced more than twofold in neuronal retinal cultures grown for 7 days in the presence of RCM. The present study demonstrates that both ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), which is characterized by its trophic activity on parasympathetic ciliary neurons, and RCM exhibit identical stimulatory effects on ChAT activity in retinal monolayer cultures. Similarly, RCM supports the in vitro survival of ciliary neurons to the same extent as CNTF. The active species in RCM has a molecular weight (20,900 +/- 1,000) identical to that of CNTF, as determined by preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis. The results indicate that cholinergic retinal neurons represent a central neuronal target for CNTF or a closely related protein.     

Purified proteins acting on cultured chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons

Chick embryo ciliary ganglion neurons in dissociated monolayer culture have been used to examine molecular requirements for neuronal survival and neurite growth. These neurons will rapidly die in vitro unless supplied with an adequate level of ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), and even in the presence of CNTF they will not vigorously extend neurites on polyornithine substrata unless supplied with appropriate amounts of polyornithine-binding neurite-promoting factors (PNPFs). Recent work on the purification and partial characterization of embryonic chick eye CNTF and rat schwannoma PNPF is reviewed, and in vitro responses of ciliary ganglion neurons to other purified proteins such as laminin, fibronectin, insulin, and nerve growth factor are mentioned.     

Differential Effects of Nerve Growth Factor and Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor on Catecholamine Storage and Catecholamine Synthesizing Enzymes of Cultured Rat Chromaffin Cells

The effects of nerve growth factor (NGF) and ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) on catecholamine content and in vitro activities of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and phenylethanolamine N-methyltransferase (PNMT) were studied in adrenal chromaffin cells cultured from 8-day-old rats. Both NGF and CNTF enhanced chromaffin cell survival and partially prevented losses of adrenaline during the 4-day culture period in a dose-dependent manner. CNTF was more potent, although cellular levels of adrenaline and noradrenaline were not maintained. NGF did not add to the effect of CNTF. The effect of CNTF on catecholamine storage was not accompanied by changes in the activities of TH and PNMT. In contrast, NGF induced TH but not PNMT activity. These data indicate differences between the mechanisms by which NGF and CNTF affect adrenal chromaffin cells.     

Characterization and Partial Purification of a Novel Neuronotrophic Factor from Bovine Seminal Vesicle

Extracts from bovine seminal vesicles have been shown to contain high concentrations of nerve growth factor (NGF)-like biological activity and of the NGF protein with properties corresponding to that of NGF from other sources. We now demonstrate that a second neuronotrophic protein, termed seminal vesicle-derived neuronotrophic factor (SVNF), is present in seminal vesicle extracts (SVEs), which could not be distinguished from NGF on the basis of biological activity. SVNF has neuronotrophic activity on NGF target cells like embryonic chicken-sensory and sympathetic neurons, sympathetic neurons, and chromaffin cells from neonatal rats, but it is inactive on embryonic chicken ciliary or neonatal rat nodose ganglion neurons. It also stimulates fiber outgrowth from rat pheochromocytoma (PC 12) cells. In gel filtration chromatography on Biogel A 1.5 m, the activity is eluted with an apparent molecular weight of 40 kilodaltons, and by preparative isoelectric focusing, the isoelectric point was determined to be in the neutral range (6.8-7.8). The biological activity of SVNF, in contrast to that of NGF, is partially retained after preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and can be electrophoretically eluted with an apparent molecular weight of 16-20 kilodaltons. Electrophoretically purified SVNF is not inhibited by antisera to mouse NGF, but its activity is increased greater than 10-fold in the presence of very low concentrations of NGF. For partially purified SVNF, a specific activity of 2.9-5.8 X 10(5) biological units/mg of protein was determined in the presence of subthreshold NGF concentrations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Cholinergic Neuronotrophic Factors: Fractionation Properties of an Extract from Selected Chick Embryonic Eye Tissues

Abstract: An aqueous extract derived from selected intraocular tissues of 15-day chick embryos contains a soluble macromolecular agent which is capable of ensuring the survival of 8-day chick embryonic ciliary ganglionic neurons in monolayer culture. When this ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) was concentrated using ultrafiltration and subjected to Sephadex G100 and G200 chromatography, activity was detected in most of the eluted fractions. A peak of the most active fractions was eluted in a region corresponding to a molecular weight of 35–40 ± 10³ and contained about 20-30% of the applied protein. CNTF activity bound readily to DE-52 cellulose resin at neutral pH and was eluted with NaCl in a narrow region containing about 20-40% of the applied protein. Gel electrophoretic staining profiles of the active DE52 fraction indicated considerable (but still only partial) simplification in protein composition. While significant CNTF activity losses were incurred in response to each of the above treatments, an active material could be conveniently generated in one working day in milligram amounts having a specific activity of 60,000 trophic units/mg protein. This trophic activity is in the same range as that of the only other known neuronotrophic factor, Nerve Growth Factor.     

Inhibition of protein synthesis prevents cell death in sensory and parasympathetic neurons deprived of neurotrophic factor in vitro

Shortly after neurons begin to innervate their targets in the developing vertebrate nervous system they become dependent on the supply of a neurotrophic factor, such as nerve growth factor (NGF) for survival. Recently, Martin et al. (1988) have shown that inhibiting protein synthesis prevents the death of NGF-deprived sympathetic neurons, suggesting that NGF promotes neuronal survival by suppressing an active cell death program. To determine if other neurotrophic factors may regulate neuronal survival by a similar mechanism we examined the effects of inhibiting protein and RNA synthesis in other populations of embryonic neurons that require different neurotrophic factors, namely: 1) trigeminal mesencephalic neurons, a population of proprioceptive neurons that are supported by brain-derived neurotrophic factor; 2) dorsomedial trigeminal ganglion neurons, a population of cutaneous sensory neurons that are supported by NGF; 3) and ciliary ganglion neurons, a population of parasympathetic neurons that are supported by ciliary neuronotrophic factor. Blocking either protein or RNA synthesis rescued all three populations of neurons from cell death induced by neurotrophic factor deprivation in vitro. Thus, at least three different neurotrophic factors appear to promote survival by a similar mechanism that may involve the suppression of an endogenous cell death program.     

Rat sciatic nerve schwann cell microcultures: Responses to mitogens and production of trophic and neurite-promoting factors

During embryonic development and in response to injury, the growing axons of peripheral neurons may influence the migration and proliferation of Schwann cells which, in return, may present neurons with a critical supply of factors required for neuronal survival, growth and differentiation. The identification and characterization of agents influencing the proliferation of Schwann cells as well as Schwann cell production of factors affecting neurons is greatly facilitated by the use of in vitro techniques. We describe here a simplified method of obtaining large numbers of purified neonatal rat sciatic nerve Schwann cells for use in generating large numbers of replicate microcultures. We then illustrate the use of these microcultures to examine Schwann cell: i) morphology and survival; ii) proliferation; and iii) production of neuronotrophic and neurite-promoting activities. We report that rat Schwann cells in microculture proliferate in response to serum, laminin and fibronectin, cholera toxin, and chick embryo parasympathetic ciliary neurons. Also, extracts of Schwann cell microcultures contain independently regulated activities which support the survival and neurite outgrowth of peripheral ganglionic neurons.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Paola S. Timiras     

A ciliary neuronotrophic factor from peripheral nerve and smooth muscle which is not retrogradely transported

We have found that a CNTF-like molecule which supports ciliary and sympathetic neurons is not retrogradely transported in either sympathetic or parasympathetic nerves. The factor has an apparent M_r of 21 kDa, a pI of 4.9, and is present in peripheral nerves and smooth muscle of the chick. Our experiments indicate that CNTF-like activity does not accumulate on the distal side of ligated chickexpansor nerves. In contrast, there is a clear accumulation of NGF. The activity further differs from NGF in that it is not removed from a smooth muscle of the chick wing by innervating sympathetic fibers. Transection of these fibers does not lead to an accumulation of ciliary activity in theexpansor secundariorum muscle, suggesting that neurons do not actively deplete the muscle of factor by retrograde transport. Finally, recombinant CNTF or semi-purified preparations of CNTF-like activity labelled with¹²⁵I were not transported to the ciliary ganglion of chicks following injection of biologically active material into the eye. Our results suggest either that endogenous CNTF does not act as a survival factorin vivo, or that retrograde transport is not a property inherent to all neuronotrophic molecules.Special issue dedicated to Dr. Lawrence Austin     

ras p21 protein promotes survival and fiber outgrowth of cultured embryonic neurons

Although evidence obtained with the PC12 cell line has suggested a role for the ras oncogene proteins in the signal transduction of nerve growth factor-mediated fiber outgrowth, little is known about the signal transduction mechanisms involved in the neuronal response to neurotrophic factors in nontransformed cells. We report here that the oncogene protein T24-ras, when introduced into the cytoplasm of freshly dissociated chick embryonic neurons, promotes the in vitro survival and neurite outgrowth of nerve growth factor-responsive dorsal root ganglion neurons, brain-derived neurotrophic factor-responsive nodose ganglion neurons, and ciliary neuronotrophic factor-responsive ciliary ganglion neurons. The proto-oncogene product c-Ha-ras also promotes neuronal survival, albeit less strongly. No effect could be observed with truncated counterparts of T24-ras and c-Ha-ras lacking the 23 C-terminal amino acids including the membrane-anchoring, palmityl-accepting cysteine. These results suggest a generalized involvement of ras or ras-like proteins in the intracellular signal transduction pathway for neurotrophic factors.     

Nerve growth factor and neuronal cell death

The regulation of neuronal cell death by the neuronotrophic factor, nerve growth factor (NGF), has been described during neural development and following injury to the nervous system. Also, reduced NGF activity has been reported for the aged NGF-responsive neurons of the sympathetic nervous system and cholinergic regions of the central nervous system (CNS) in aged rodents and man. Although there is some knowledge of the molecular structure of the NGF and its receptor, less is known as to the mechanism of action of NGF. Here, a possible role for NGF in the regulation of oxidant--antioxidant balance is discussed as part of a molecular explanation for the known effects of NGF on neuronal survival during development, after injury, and in the aged CNS.     

The in vitro biological effect of nerve growth factor is inhibited by synthetic peptides.

Nerve growth factor (NGF)1 is a neurotrophic polypeptide that acts via specific receptors to promote the survival and growth of neurons. To delineate the NGF domain(s) responsible for eliciting biological activity, we synthesized small peptides corresponding to three regions in NGF that are hydrophilic and highly conserved. Several peptides from mouse NGF region 26-40 inhibited the neurite-promoting effect of NGF on sensory neurons in vitro. Inhibition was sequence-specific and could be overcome by increasing the concentration of NGF. Moreover, peptide actions were specific for NGF-mediated events in that they failed to block the neurotrophic activity of ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) or phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA). In spite of the inhibition of NGF activity, peptides did not affect the binding of radiolabeled NGF. These studies define one region of NGF that may be required for neurotrophic activity.     

Promotion of survival and neurite outgrowth of cultured peripheral neurons by exogenous lipids and detergents

Gangliosides, in particular the monosialoglycosphingolipids Gtet 1 (GM1), have previously been implicated in the mediation of neuronal rescue and restitutional axonal growth, both in vitro and subsequent to brain and peripheral nerve lesions. In the present study it is shown that the bis-sialosyl gangliosides Gtet2b and Gtet3b, but not the gangliosides Gtet2a and Gtet1, promote the survival of dissociated dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons cultured from Embryonic Day (E) 8 chicks (DRG8) almost to the same extent as nerve growth factor (NGF). Ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons from E8 chicks (CG8) and DRG10 neurons were virtually not supported suggesting considerable specificity in terms of neuronal targets and developmental stages being addressed. Moreover, a variety of other lipids including cerebroside (Cb), dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and -serine (DPPS), sulfatide (Sf), and sphingomyelin (Sm) were tested for putative survival promoting activity toward chick CG, DRG, and lumbar sympathetic ganglion (SG11) neurons. At the highest concentration employed (2.5 x 10(-5) M), Sm, DPPC, and DPPS maintained between 45 and 65% of the plateau survival with CG8 (maximally supported by ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF], DRG8, and DRG10 neurons, and 30 to 40% with SG11 neurons. Cb supported CG8 neurons at about 55% of the plateau value achieved with CNTF, but had hardly any effect on the other neuron populations tested. Control experiments using highly enriched neurons and serum-free conditions assured that the effects were unlikely to be mediated by serum components or nonneuronal cells. A variety of detergents, in particular Triton X-100, also promoted the survival of CG8 and DRG10 neurons. Ganglioside Gtet1, Sm, and Triton X-100 shifted the NGF titration curve for DRG10 neurons between 6- and 15-fold in a dose-dependent manner suggesting synergisms between NGF and lipids for neuronal maintenance. These results document the neuronotrophic potency of certain gangliosides, a heterogeneous group of structurally unrelated lipids, and detergents. The mechanisms by which these agents modulate neuronal survival still await clarification.     

Multiple cholinergic differentiation factors are present in footpad extracts: comparison with known cholinergic factors.

Sweat glands in rat footpads contain a neuronal differentiation activity that switches the phenotype of sympathetic neurons from noradrenergic to cholinergic during normal development in vivo. Extracts of developing and adult sweat glands induce changes in neurotransmitter properties in cultured sympathetic neurons that mimic those observed in vivo. We have characterized further the factors present in the extract and compared their properties to those of known cholinergic factors. When assayed on cultured rat sympathetic neurons, the major activities in footpad extracts from postnatal day 21 rat pups that induce choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP) and reduce catecholamines and neuropeptide Y (NPY) are associated with a soluble protein of 22-26 x 10(3) M(r) and a pI of 5.0. These properties are similar to those of ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF). Moreover, the purified fraction from footpads has ciliary neurotrophic activity. Antibodies to CNTF that immunoprecipitate all differentiation activity from sciatic nerve extracts, a rich source of CNTF, immunoprecipitate 80% of the cholinergic activity in the footpad extracts, 50% of the VIP and 20% of the NPY activities. Neither CNTF protein nor CNTF mRNA, however, can be detected in immunoblot and northern analysis of footpads even though both CNTF protein and mRNA are evident in sciatic nerve. CNTF-immunoreactivity is associated with a sparse plexus of sensory fibers in the footpad but not with sweat glands or the Schwann cells associated with them. In addition, in situ hybridization studies with oligonucleotide probes failed to reveal CNTF mRNA in sweat glands. Comparison of the sweat gland differentiation activity with the cholinergic differentiation factor from heart cells (CDF; also known as leukemia inhibitory factor or LIF) suggests that most of the cholinergic activity in foot pads is biochemically distinct from CDF/LIF. Further, antibodies that block the activity of CDF/LIF purified from heart-cell-conditioned medium do not block the ChAT-inducing activity present in footpad extracts of postnatal day 8 animals. A differentiation factor isolated from skeletal muscle did not induce cholinergic properties in sympathetic neuron cultures and therefore is unlikely to be the cholinergic differentiation factor produced by sweat glands. Taken together, our data suggest that there are at least two differentiation molecules present in the extracts and that the major cholinergic activity obtained from footpads is related to, but distinct from, CNTF. The second factor remains to be characterized. In addition, CNTF associated with sensory fibers may make a minor contribution to the cholinergic inducing activity present in the extract.     

Neuronal survival in intact ciliary ganglia in vivo and in vitro: Ciliary neuronotrophic factor as a target surrogate

Ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) requirements for neuronal survival in the intact ciliary ganglion (CG) have been investigated in organ culture. Exogenous CNTF was not essential for neuronal survival until embryonic Day 8. Three-day cultures from 5-day ganglia were similar with or without CNTF, showing numerous neurons and extensive neuritic development. In 3-day cultures from 8-day-old ganglia, however, no neurons survived without CNTF, and the ganglia contained only nonneuronal cells and cell debris. Similar ganglia cultured with CNTF contained many neurons, surrounded by nonneuronal cells, and abundant neuritic processes. Morphologic maturation of the neurons was less advanced in CNTF-supported ganglia than in their in vivo counterparts.     

Preparation and biological properties of native and recombinant ciliary neurotrophic factor

CNTF (ciliary neurotrophic factor), purified from rabbit sciatic nerves by a relatively simple procedure, is bioactive in tissue culture at low picomolar concentration and appears as a doublet on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). In these nerves, CNTF accounts for more than one-half of the survival-promoting activity on ciliary neurons. The concentration of CNTF in rabbit sciatic nerves is estimated to be 5 nmol/kg, more than 1000 times higher than would seem to be required to support neurons if the neurotrophic factor were homogeneously distributed. With recombinant DNA technology, rat CNTF has been synthesized in Escherichia coli, purified without denaturating agents, and found to be bioactive at a slightly lower concentration than CNTF extracted from rabbit sciatic nerves. After radioiodination, CNTF retains biological activity but is not specifically internalized and retrogradely transported in motor and sensory axons. In peripheral nerves, ciliary neurotrophic factor differs biologically from nerve growth factor (NGF) by its much higher tissue concentration and apparent lack of internalization by peripheral nerve axons. © 1992 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Target-derived molecules that influence the development of neurons in the avian ciliary ganglion

The developing avian ciliary ganglion has been a particularly amenable system for the identification, isolation, and characterization of putative target-derived molecules that mediate retrograde interaction. To date a number of biochemically distinct activities that regulate neuronal survival, transmitter phenotype, and chemosensitivity of ciliary ganglion neruons have been identified. Of these, only two survival-promoting molecules have been purified to homogeneity: ciliary neurotrophic factor and a related molecule, growth-promoting activity. A somatostatin-inducing activity found in cultured choroid cells is very likely to be chick activin A. Other molecules that regulate acetylcholine and acetylcholine receptor expression comigrate on a gel filtration column at a molecular weight of 50–60 kD, but they have yet to be isolated. Once molecules that mimic retrorgrade influences are identified, a number of criteria must be met before their physiological significance can be established. These criteria are (1) availability of the molecule from the target at the appropriate time in development: (2) ability of the neurons to respond to the molecule at the appropriate time in development: (3) demonstration that blocking the activity or availability of the molecule is able to block the target-derived developmental change expressed in the neurons. Of the molecules that are thought to retrogradely influence ciliary neuron development, only growth-promoting activity is known to meet criteria 1 and 2, and experiments of growth-promoting activity in vivo will exacerbate normal cell death. 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Peroxidative block of glucose utilization and survival in CNS neuronal cultures

The search for neuronotrophic factors addressing CNS neurons requires CNS neuronal cell cultures to quantitate putative effects on neuronal survival. Investigation of neurons dissociated from several embryonic CNS tissues have shown that their short-term survival requires supplementation of the culture medium with either pyruvate or the enzyme catalase. Pyruvate can be replaced with -ketoglutarate or oxaloacetate, or with amino acids capable to transaminate to these three metabolites in the presence of exogenous -ketoacid acceptors. Experiments were designed to evaluate the ability of cultured CNS neurons to utilized glucose as their primary source. We show that: (1) catalase requires the availability of glucose in the medium in order to exert its neuronal maintenance effect, (2) in the absence of catalase, the cells are unable to metabolize glucose through the tricarboxylic acid cycle, (3) catalase restores the neuronal ability to utilize glucose for oxydative metabolism, and renders redundant the use of other sources such as glutamate conversion to -ketoglutarate, (4) graded concentrations of glucose in the medium affect in parallel these metabolic activities and the viability of the cultured neurons, and (5) anti-oxidant agents other than catalase mimic the catalase effects. We conclude that dissociated embryonic CNS neurons suffer from a block in glucose utilization which results from an imbalance between free radical attack and cellular defenses to it and speculate on a more general involvement of peroxidation damage in the trophic requirements for neuronal survival.Special Issue dedicated to Prof. Holger Hydén.     

Cholinergic neuronal differentiation factors: evidence for the presence of both CNTF-like and non-CNTF-like factors in developing rat footpad.

Catecholaminergic sympathetic neurons are able to change their transmitter phenotype during development and to acquire cholinergic properties. Cholinergic sympathetic differentiation is only observed in fibers innervating specific targets like the sweat glands in the rat footpad. A function for ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) in this process has been implied as it is able to induce cholinergic properties (ChAT, VIP) in cultured chick and rat neurons. We show here that a CNTF-like, VIP-inducing activity is present in rat footpads and that its increases 6-fold during the period of cholinergic sympathetic differentiation. Immunohistochemical analysis of P21 rat footpads demonstrated CNTF-like immunoreactivity in Schwann cells but not in sweat glands, the target tissue of cholinergic sympathetic neurons. The expression of this factor in footpads seems to be dependent on the presence of intact nerve axons, as nerve transection results in a loss of CNTF-like cholinergic activity and immunoreactivity. Immunoprecipitation experiments with rat footpad extracts provided evidence for the presence of ChAT-inducing factors other than CNTF, which may independently or together with CNTF be involved in the determination of sympathetic neuron phenotype.