A comparison of oxygen,nitrate, and sulfate respiration in coastal marine sediments

Aerobic respiration with oxygen and anaerobic respiration with nitrate (denitrification) and sulfate (sulfate reduction) were measured during winter and summer in two coastal marine sediments (Denmark). Both aerobic respiration and denitrification took place in the oxidized surface layer, whereas sulfate reduction was most significant in the deeper, reduced sediment. The low availability of nitrate apparently limited the activity of denitrification during summer to less than 0.2 mmoles NO ₃ ^– m^–2 day^–1, whereas activities of 1.0–3.0 mmoles NO ₃ ^– m^–2 day^–1 were measured during winter. Sulfate reduction, on the contrary, increased from 2.6–7.6 mmoles SO ₄ ^2– m^–2 day^–1 during winter to 9.8–15.1 mmoles SO ₄ ^2– m^–2 day^–1 during summer. The aerobic respiration was high during summer, 135–140 mmoles O₂ m^–2 day^–1, as compared to estimated winter activities of about 30 mmoles O₂ m^–2 day^–1. The little importance of denitrification relative to aerobic respiration and sulfate reduction is discussed in relation to the availability and distribution of oxygen, nitrate, and sulfate in the sediments and to the detritus mineralization.     

Comparative Aspects of Sulfur Mineralization in Sediments of a Eutrophic Lake Basin

The net mineralization of organic sulfur compounds in surface sediments of Wintergreen Lake was estimated from a mass-balance budget of sulfur inputs and sediment sulfur concentrations. The net mineralization of organic sulfur inputs is <50% complete, which is consistent with the dominance of organic sulfur (>80% of total sulfur) in sediment. Although sediment sulfur is predominantly organic, sulfate reduction is the most significant process in terms of the quantities of sulfur transformed in surface sediments. Rates of sulfate reduction in these sediments average 7 mmol/m² per day. On an annual basis, this rate is 19-fold greater than net rates of organic sulfur mineralization and 65-fold greater than sulfate ester hydrolysis.     

Sulfate reduction in fine-grained sediments in the Eastern Scheldt,southwest Netherlands

Sulfate reduction and sulfide accumulation were examined in fine-grained sediments from rapidly accreting abandoned channels and mussel culture areas in the Eastern Scheldt, which covered 4 and 5% of the total surface area, respectively.Reduction rates were measured in batch experiments in which the SO₄ ^2– depletion was measured during anoxic incubation. The reduction rates in summer varied between 14–68 mmol SO₄ ^2– m^–2 day^–1 and were related to the sedimentation rate. In the most rapidly accreting channels, SO₄ ^2– was exhausted below 15–50 cm and methanogenesis became the terminal process of organic carbon oxidationOne-dimensional modelling of sulfate profiles in mussel banks indicated that the subsurface influx of SO₄ ^2– was almost of the same order as the diffusive flux at the sediment-seawater interface, during the initial stages of the mussel bank accretion. The energy dissipation of waves and tidal currents on the mussel bank surface increased the apparent sediment diffusivity up to 3-fold, especially in the winterThe results indicate that acid volatile sulfide (AVS) was the major, in-situ reduced, sulfur compound in the sediment. The sulfidation of easily extractable iron was nearly complete. Pyrite concentrations (40–80 M S cm^–3) were as high as the AVS concentrations, but there was apparently no in-situ transformation of AVS into pyrite. The detrital pyrite originated from eroding marine sediments elsewhere     

Activities of benthic nitrifiers in streams and their role in oxygen consumption

The in situ rates of oxygen consumption by benthic nitrifiers were estimated at 11 study sites in 4 streams. Two methods were used: an in situ respiration chamber method and a method involving conversion of nitrifying potential measurements to in situ rates. Estimates of benthic nitrogenous oxygen consumption (BNOC) rate ranged from 0–380 mmol of O₂ m^–2·day^–1, and BNOC contributed between 0–85% of the total benthic oxygen consumption rate. The activity of nitrifiers residing in the sediments was influenced by O₂ availability, temperature, pH, and substrate. Depending upon site, nitrification could approximate either first-order or zero-order kinetics with respect to ammonium concentration. The source of ammonium for benthic nitrifiers could be either totally from within the sediment or totally from the overlying water. Nitrate produced in the sediments could flux to the water above or be lost within the sediment. The sediments could act as a source (positive flux) or sink (negative flux) for both ammonium (–185 mmol·m^–2·day^–1 to +195 mmol·m^–2·day^–1) and nitrate (–135 mmol·m^–2·day^–1 to +185 mmol·m^–2·day^–1).This study provides evidence to suggest that measurements of down-stream mass flow changes in inorganic nitrogen forms may give poor estimates of in situ rates of nitrification in flowing waters.     

Reduction of Sulfur Compounds in the Sediments of a Eutrophic Lake Basin

Concentrations of various sulfur compounds (SO₄²⁻, H₂S, S⁰, acid-volatile sulfide, and total sulfur) were determined in the profundal sediments and overlying water column of a shallow eutrophic lake. Low concentrations of sulfate relative to those of acid-volatile sulfide and total sulfur and a decrease in total sulfur with sediment depth implied that the contribution of dissimilatory sulfur reduction to H₂S production was relatively minor. Addition of 1.0 mM Na₂³⁵SO₄ to upper sediments in laboratory experiments resulted in the production of H₂³⁵S with no apparent lag. Kinetic experiments with ³⁵S demonstrated an apparent K_m of 0.068 mmol of SO₄²⁻ reduced per liter of sediment per day, whereas tracer experiments with ³⁵S indicated an average turnover time of the sediment sulfate pool of 1.5 h. Total sulfate reduction in a sediment depth profile to 15 cm was 15.3 mmol of sulfate reduced per m² per day, which corresponds to a mineralization of 30% of the particulate organic matter entering the sediment. Reduction of ³⁵S⁰ occurred at a slower rate. These results demonstrated that high rates of sulfate reduction occur in these sediments despite low concentrations of oxidized inorganic compounds and that this reduction can be important in the anaerobic mineralization of organic carbon.     

Sulfate Reduction in Peat from a New Jersey Pinelands Cedar Swamp

Microbial sulfate reduction rates in acidic peat from a New Jersey Pine Barrens cedar swamp in 1986 were similar to sulfate reduction rates in freshwater lake sediments. The rates ranged from a low of 1.0 nmol cm⁻³ day⁻¹ in February at 7.5- to 10.0-cm depth to 173.4 nmol cm⁻³ day⁻¹ in July at 5.0- to 7.5-cm depth. The presence of living Sphagnum moss at the surface generally resulted in reduced rates of sulfate reduction. Pore water sulfate concentrations and water table height also apparently affected the sulfate reduction rate. Concentrations of sulfate in pore water were nearly always higher than those in surface water and groundwater, ranging from 26 to 522 μM. The elevated pore water sulfate levels did not result from the evapotranspiratory concentration of infiltrating stream water or groundwater, but probably resulted from oxidation of reduced sulfur compounds, hydrolysis of ester sulfates present in the peat, or both. The total sulfur content of peat that had no living moss at the surface was 164.64 ± 1.5 and 195.8 ± 21.7 μmol g (dry weight)⁻¹ for peat collected from 2.5 to 5.0 and 7.5 to 10.0 cm, respectively. Organosulfur compounds accounted for 84 to 88% of the total sulfur that was present in the peat. C-bonded sulfur accounted for 91 to 94% of the organic sulfur, with ester sulfate being only a minor constituent. Reduced inorganic sulfur species in peat from 2.5 to 7.5 cm were dominated by H₂S-FeS (68%), while pyritic sulfide was the predominant inorganic sulfur species in the peat from depths of 7.5 to 10.0 cm (75%).     

Large Fraction of Dead and Inactive Bacteria in Coastal Marine Sediments: Comparison of Protocols for Determination and Ecological Significance

It is now universally recognized that only a portion of aquatic bacteria is actively growing, but quantitative information on the fraction of living versus dormant or dead bacteria in marine sediments is completely lacking. We compared different protocols for the determination of the dead, dormant, and active bacterial fractions in two different marine sediments and at different depths into the sediment core. Bacterial counts ranged between (1.5 ± 0.2) × 10⁸ cells g⁻¹ and (53.1 ± 16.0) × 10⁸ cells g⁻¹ in sandy and muddy sediments, respectively. Bacteria displaying intact membrane (live bacterial cells) accounted for 26 to 30% of total bacterial counts, while dead cells represented the most abundant fraction (70 to 74%). Among living bacterial cells, nucleoid-containing cells represented only 4% of total bacterial counts, indicating that only a very limited fraction of bacterial assemblage was actively growing. Nucleoid-containing cells increased with increasing sediment organic content. The number of bacteria responsive to antibiotic treatment (direct viable count; range, 0.3 to 4.8% of the total bacterial number) was significantly lower than nucleoid-containing cell counts. An experiment of nutrient enrichment to stimulate a response of the dormant bacterial fraction determined a significant increase of nucleoid-containing cells. After nutrient enrichment, a large fraction of dormant bacteria (6 to 11% of the total bacterial number) was “reactivated.” Bacterial turnover rates estimated ranged from 0.01 to 0.1 day⁻¹ but were 50 to 80 times higher when only the fraction of active bacteria was considered (on average 3.2 day⁻¹). Our results suggest that the fraction of active bacteria in marine sediments is controlled by nutrient supply and availability and that their turnover rates are at least 1 order of magnitude higher than previously reported.     

Growth kinetics of haloalkaliphilic,sulfur-oxidizing bacterium<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Thioalkalivibrio versutus</Emphasis> strain ALJ 15 in continuous culture

The chemolithoautotrophic, sulfur-oxidizing bacterium Thioalkalivibrio versutus strain ALJ 15, isolated from a soda lake in Kenya, was grown in a continuous culture, with thiosulfate or polysulfide as growth-limiting energy source and oxygen as electron acceptor, at pH 10 and at pH 0.6, 2 M and 4 M total sodium. The end product of the sulfur-compound oxidation was sulfate. Elemental sulfur and a cell-bound, polysulfide-like compound appeared as intermediates during substrate oxidation. In the thiosulfate-limited culture, the biomass yields and maximum specific growth rates decreased two and three times, respectively, with increasing sodium concentration. The apparent affinity constant measured for thiosulfate and polysulfide was in the micromolar range (K_s=6±3 M). The maintenance requirement (m_s=8±5 mmol S₂O₃²/g dry weight h^–1) was in the range of values found for other autotrophic sulfur-oxidizing bacteria. The organism had a comparable maximum specific rate of oxygen uptake with thiosulfate, polysulfide, and sulfide, while elemental sulfur was oxidized at a lower rate. Glycine betaine was the main organic compatible solute. The respiration rates with different species of polysulfides (S_n^2–) were tested. All polysulfide species were completely oxidized at high rates to sulfate. Overall data demonstrated efficient growth and sulfur compounds oxidation of haloalkaliphilic chemolithoautotrophic bacteria from soda lakes.Communicated by W.D. Grant     

Flowthrough Reactor Flasks for Study of Microbial Metabolism in Sediments

Flowthrough reactor flasks are described that allow continuous low-level nutrient input to mixed anoxic sediments without dilution of the sediment. The flasks were tested by simulating sulfate inputs into sediments collected from a freshwater eutrophic lake. After an initial 2-day adaptation within the reactor system, rates of methane production and sulfate consumption were constant for the duration of a 12-day incubation. A sulfate input rate of 0.15 mmol liter of sediment⁻¹ day⁻¹ resulted in an equivalent rate of sulfate removal, which was unaffected by inputs of acetate (1.0 mmol liter of sediment⁻¹ day⁻¹). The rate of methane production in control reactors, 0.18 mmol liter of sediment⁻¹ day⁻¹, was doubled by the addition of acetate, whereas sulfate consumption was only stimulated by additions of high concentrations of sulfate plus acetate (1.5 and 1.0 mmol liter of sediment⁻¹ day⁻¹, respectively). The reactor system appears to be effective in maintaining the balance between sulfate reduction and methane production in freshwater sediments and is potentially useful for study of the response of sediment populations to varying inputs of naturally occurring substrates, selected inhibitors, or xenobiotic compounds.     

Regional variation in eelgrass (Zostera marina) morphology, production and stable sulfur isotopic composition along the Baltic Sea and Skagerrak coasts

Morphology, total sulfur content and stable sulfur isotopic composition of Zostera marina were examined in the Baltic Sea–Skagerrak transition zone through surveys. The seagrass meadows were denser and less productive at the low salinities in the Baltic Sea (salinity 6–7 psu), and total sulfur accumulations in plants were lower and δ³⁴S values were higher compared to the west coast of Sweden (salinity 21–29 psu). The δ³⁴S values of the three plant compartments (leaves, rhizomes, roots) indicated lower sulfide invasion at low salinities, which was mainly due to environmental conditions (e.g. low epiphytic biomass, low sediment organic matter and low sulfate concentration) and plant characteristics (productivity, shoot morphology). Between 13% and 63% of the sulfur in the plants was derived from sediment sulfides with highest percentages in the roots (27–63%) and lower in rhizomes (13–50%) and leaves (14–51%). The high sulfide invasion on the west coast of Sweden was coincident with high sediment organic matter, probably increasing sulfide pressure on the plants, and high epiphytic biomass, probably constraining the oxygen dynamics in the plants and enhancing sulfide invasion. Regional and spatial variability in the δ³⁴S were extensive, emphasizing the need for detailed analysis of local sources when applying stable sulfur isotopes in food web analyses. The observed invasion of sulfides suggests sulfide as a contributing factor to reported declines of Z. marina in the Skagerrak region.     

Sulfate reduction rates and some aspects of the limnology of four lakes and a fjord in the Vestfold Hills,Antarctica

Sulfate reduction rates were measured in waters and sediments from four antarctic lakes and an antarctic fjord basin by a radiometric technique. There was generally a linear correlation between the period of incubation and sulfate reduced; the average of the correlation coefficients was 0.76 ± 0.1. The rates at 6 °C were very low (0.0–1.1 µmol kg^–1 d^–1) when compared to most other marine and non-marine environments for which sulfate reduction rates have been reported. Lactate and acetate did not stimulate sulfate reduction. Temperatures of the sediments selected from the different sites varied from –0.4 to 4.5 °C and the chloride and sulfate concentrations of the sediments varied from 0.19 to 0.83 mol kg^–1 and 0.04 to 41.01 mmol kg^–1 respectively. Sulfate reduction rates did not correlate with the chlorosity of sediment porewaters.     

Sulfte-reduction process in sediments of Lake Kinneret,Israel

Monomictic Lake Kinneret is stratified during summer and autumn, resulting in a hypolimnion rich in H₂S (3–7 mg 1^–1). In winter and spring every year a bloom of dinoflagallate Peridinium gatunense produces an average biomass of 150000 ton wet weight. Part of this biomass sinks to the hypolimnion and sediments where it is decomposed and mineralized, with some of the mineralization due to the activity of sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB). The sulfate-reduction potential of the upper sediment layer at the deepest part of the lake (42 m) was measured. The activity of the enzyme arylsulfatase was also monitored. Rates of sulfate-reduction ranged from a minimum of 12 nmoles SO_f4 ^p2–-reduced cm^–3 day^–1 in December before lake overturn to a maximum of 1673 nmoles SO_f4 ^p2– reduced cm^–3 day^–1 in July during stratification. These rates are considerably higher than those recorded from other freshwater lakes in the world and are probably limited more by the availability of organic matter than by sulfate concentrations.     

Sulfur cycling in the water column of Little Rock Lake, Wisconsin

The S cycle in the water column of a small, soft-water lake was studied for 9 years as part of an experimental study of the effects of acid rain on lakes. The two basins of the lake were artificially separated, and one basin was experimentally acidified with sulfuric acid while the other served as a reference or control. Spatial and seasonal patterns of sulfate uptake by plankton (53–70 mmol m^–2 yr^–1), deposition of sulfur to sediments in settling seston (53 mmol m^–2 yr^–1), and sulfate diffusion (0–39 mmol m^–2 yr^–1) into sediments were examined. Measurements of inputs (12–108 mmol m^–2 yr^–1) and outputs (5.5–25 mmol m^–2 yr^–1) allowed construction of a mass balance that was then compared with rates of S accumulation in sediments cores (10–28 mmol m^–2 yr^–1) and measured fluxes of S into the sediments. Because of the low SO₄ ^2– concentrations (µmole L^–1) in the lake, annual uptake by plankton (53–70 mmol m^–2 yr^–1) represented a large fraction (>50%) of the SO₄ ^2– inventory in the lake. Despite this large flux through the plankton, only small seasonal fluctuations in SO₄ ^2– concentrations (µmole L^–1) were observed; rapid mineralization of organic matter (half-life <3 months) prevented sulfate depletion in the water column. The turnover time for sulfate in the water column is only 1.4 yr; much less than the 11-yr turnover time of a conservative ion in this seepage lake. Sulfate diffusion into and reduction in the sediments (0–160 µmole m^–2 d^–1) caused SO₄ ^2– depletion in the hypolimnion. Modeling of seasonal changes in lake-water SO₄ ^2– concentrations indicated that only 30–50% of the diffusive flux of sulfate to the sediments was permanently incorporated in solid phases, and about 15% of sulfur in settling seston was buried in the sediments. The utility of sulfur mass balances for seepage lakes would be enhanced if uncertainty about the deposition velocity for both sulfate aerosols and SO₂, uncertainty in calculation of a lake-wide rate of S accumulation in sediments, and uncertainty in the measured diffusive fluxes could be further constrained.     

Impact of Different In Vitro Electron Donor/Acceptor Conditions on Potential Chemolithoautotrophic Communities from Marine Pelagic Redoxclines

Anaerobic or microaerophilic chemolithoautotrophic bacteria have been considered to be responsible for CO₂ dark fixation in different pelagic redoxclines worldwide, but their involvement in redox processes is still not fully resolved. We investigated the impact of 17 different electron donor/acceptor combinations in water of pelagic redoxclines from the central Baltic Sea on the stimulation of bacterial CO₂ dark fixation as well as on the development of chemolithoautotrophic populations. In situ, the highest CO₂ dark fixation rates, ranging from 0.7 to 1.4 μmol liter⁻¹ day⁻¹, were measured directly below the redoxcline. In enrichment experiments, chemolithoautotrophic CO₂ dark fixation was maximally stimulated by the addition of thiosulfate, reaching values of up to 9.7 μmol liter⁻¹ CO₂ day⁻¹. Chemolithoautotrophic nitrate reduction proved to be an important process, with rates of up to 33.5 μmol liter⁻¹ NO₃⁻ day⁻¹. Reduction of Fe(III) or Mn(IV) was not detected; nevertheless, the presence of these potential electron acceptors influenced the development of stimulated microbial assemblages. Potential chemolithoautotrophic bacteria in the enrichment experiments were displayed on 16S ribosomal complementary DNA single-strand-conformation polymorphism fingerprints and identified by sequencing of excised bands. Sequences were closely related to chemolithoautotrophic Thiomicrospira psychrophila and Maorithyas hadalis gill symbiont (both Gammaproteobacteria) and to an uncultured nitrate-reducing Helicobacteraceae bacterium (Epsilonproteobacteria). Our data indicate that this Helicobacteraceae bacterium could be of general importance or even a key organism for autotrophic nitrate reduction in pelagic redoxclines.     

Biogeochemical changes in the sediments of Lake Cantara South,a saline lake in South Australia

Biogeochemical studies were undertaken of a 65-cm long sediment core from Lake Cantara South, South Australia. ¹⁴C determinations indicated that the sediments had been deposited over 2000 years. Changes with sediment depth in the concentration or ratio of the following were determined: (i) total organic carbon, total carbonate (inorganic) carbon, total sulfur, total carbon, total inorganic and organic sulfur, atomic C/N, and sulfate/chloride; (ii) n-alkanes; (iii) a highly branched isoprenoid alkane, and (iv) steroids. Interpretation of the changes with sediment depth indicated the nature of changes that took place when the system changed from a protected marine lagoon to an isolated (athalassic) saline lake. This change took place about 1000 years ago.     

Primary production and respiration of the phytoplankton in the Blue and White Niles at Khartoum

Phytoplankton production and respiration in the Blue Nile and White Nile at Khartoum were measured during the period November 1969–January 1971 using the light and dark bottle technique. Maximum rates of production coincided with periods of maximum phytoplankton densities. In the Blue Nile gross production varied between 0.00 gCm^–3d^–1 during the flood season and 2.19 gCm^–3d^–1 (0.49 mgO₂l^–1h^–1) during November 1969. In the White Nile the range was from 0.41 gCm^–3d^–1 (0.09 MgO₂l^–1h^–1) in May to 3.74 gCm^–3d^–1 (0.83 MgO₂l^–1h^–1) in November. The maximum rates of respiration in the Blue Nile and White Nile were 0.10 and 0.63 MgO₂l^–1h^–1 respectively. The ratios net:gross production were generally higher in the White Nile than in the Blue Nile.     

Microbial sulfate-reducing activities in anoxic sediment from Marine Lake Grevelingen: screening of electron donors and acceptors

Sulfate-reducing bacteria in marine sediments mainly utilize sulfate as a terminal electron acceptor with different organic compounds as electron donors. This study investigated microbial sulfate-reducing activity of coastal sediment from Marine Lake Grevelingen (MLG), the Netherlands using different electron donors and electron acceptors. All four electron donors (ethanol, lactate, acetate and methane) showed sulfate-reducing activity with sulfate as electron acceptor, suggesting the presence of an active sulfate-reducing bacterial population in the sediment, even at dissolved sulfide concentrations exceeding 12 mM. Ethanol showed the highest sulfate reduction rate of 55 µmol g _VSS ^?1 day^?1 compared to lactate (32 µmol g _VSS ^?1 day^?1), acetate (26 µmol g _VSS ^?1 day^?1) and methane (4.7 µmol g _VSS ^?1 day^?1). Sulfide production using thiosulfate and elemental sulfur as electron acceptors and methane as the electron donor was observed, however, mainly by disproportionation rather than by anaerobic oxidation of methane coupled to sulfate reduction. This study showed that the MLG sediment is capable of performing sulfate reduction by using diverse electron donors, including the gaseous and cheap electron donor methane.     

The influence of the diel activity pattern of the larvae of Sericostoma personatum (Kirby & Spence) (Trichoptera) on organic matter distribution in stream-bed sediments — a laboratory study

Diel patterns in mobility and feeding behaviour of the larvae of the stream-dwelling trichopteran Sericostoma personatum larvae were investigated. Larvae fed at night on coarse particulate organic matter (CPOM) at the sediment surface. In the daytime they rested a few cm below the sediment surface, during which time their defaecation activity effected a release of fine particulate organic matter (FPOM) into the sediment. The amount of faeces (mean particle size = 0.1 ± 0.044 mm, x ± SD, n = 500) introduced into the sediment by the larvae, evaluated in two experiments, was 0.4–0.56 mg day^–1. This amount did not differ significantly from the organic input resulting from bacterial activity (0.36–0.64 mg day^–1). The presence of S. personatum larvae increased the sediment organic content by 42.9 mg (75.8 %) and 59.8 mg (185.6%) AFDW per 16 cm³ sediment over a 90-day period, as compared with control systems containing no larvae.     

Kinetic Studies of Bacterial Sulfate Reduction in Freshwater Sediments by High-Pressure Liquid Chromatography and Microdistillation

Indirect photometric chromatography and microdistillation enabled a simultaneous measurement of sulfate depletion and sulfide production in the top 3 cm of freshwater sediments to be made. The simultaneous measurement of sulfate depletion and sulfide production rates provided added insight into microbial sulfur metabolism. The lower sulfate reduction rates, as derived from the production of acid-volatile ³⁵S²⁻ only, were explained by a conversion of this pool to an undistillable fraction under acidic conditions during incubation. A mathematical model was applied to calculate sulfate reduction from sulfate gradients at the sediment-water interface. To avoid disturbance of these gradients, the sample volume was reduced to 0.2 g (wet weight) of sediment. Sulfate diffusion coefficients in the model were determined (D_s = 0.3 × 10⁻⁵ cm² s⁻¹ at 6°C). The results of the model were compared with those of radioactive sulfate turnover experiments by assessing the actual turnover rate constants (2 to 5 day⁻¹) and pool sizes of sulfate at different sediment depths.     

Bacterial production in freshwater sediments: Cell specific versus system measures

Estimates of bacterial production based on total trichloroacetic acid (TCA)-precipitable [methyl-³H]thymidine incorporation and frequency of dividing cell (FDC) techniques were compared to sediment respiration rates in Lake George, New York. Bacterial growth rates based on thymidine incorporation ranged from 0.024 to 0.41 day^–1, while rates based on FDC ranged from 1.78 to 2.48 day^–1. Respiration rates ranged from 0.11 to 1.8mol O₂·hour^–1·g dry weight sediment^–1. Thymidine incorporation yielded production estimates which were in reasonable agreement with respiration rates. Production estimates based on FDC were 4- to 190-fold higher than those predicted from respiration rates.