Fc receptors on mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells.

Mouse effector cells mediating natural cytotoxicity against tumor cells have been previously thought to be lymphocytes that lack any detectable cell surface markers. The present study presents evidence for receptors for the Fc portion of IgG on these cells. By adsorption of cytotoxic spleen cells on monolayers of sheep erythrocytes (E) plus IgG antibodies to sheep erythrocytes (EA), 50 to 96% of the total cytotoxic reactivity could be removed. Parallel adsorption of cells on E monolayers or on EA monolayers coated with protein A, to block the Fc portion of IgG, resulted in little or no depletion of cytotoxic activity. The presence of Fc receptors on the NK cells was confirmed by combining EA rosette formation with velocity sedimentation at unit gravity. Peak cytotoxicity occurred at the same sedimentation velocity as the peak of Fc-positive cells. After EA rosette formation, there was a shift to a higher sedimentation velocity in the Fc-positive cells and in the natural cytotoxic activity. The increase in sedimentation velocity of NK activity that was observed in these experiments indicated that most of the cells had only bound a small number (three or four) of antibody-coated erythrocytes. Together, these data indicate that cells with Fc receptors account for most of the total lytic activity of normal mouse spleen cells.     

A reappraisal of the effector cells mediating mitogen induced cellular cytotoxicity.

The ability of mitogens to induce cytotoxic effector reactions in vitro has been studied to investigate basic mechanisms of cell mediated cytotoxicity. The type of mitogen, the source of effector cells, and the nature of the target cell are all critical variables in determining the characteristics of the cytotoxic event in this system. Spleen cells and bone marrow cells from congenitally athymic nude mice as well as from their heterozygous control littermates were capable of mediating lysis of RBC targets in the presence of either PHA or Con A. Removal of macrophages from these effector populations by adherence columns, density gradient centrifugation, and carrageenan treatment failed to abrogate this cytotoxic capacity. However, purified macrophages themselves also were capable of mediating mitogen induced killing of RBC targets, although the kinetics of this cytotoxicity were substantially different from that induced by lymphocytes. In contrast to these observations, the capacity of mitogen stimulated cells to kill metabolically active complex targets like the P815 mastocytoma or cultured L cells appears to be exclusively a T lymphocyte dependent function. In addition, blastogenic transformation of the effector cells with the T cell mitogens PHA and Con A, but not with the B cell mitogen LPS, leads to enhanced killing of these complex targets. These data suggest that mitogen or lectin induced cellular cytotoxicity can detect at least three different active effector cell types (B cells, T cells, and macrophages) acting via at least four different mechanisms.     

Human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity against fetal fibroblasts. III. Morphological and functional characterization of the effector cells

We have isolated and characterized human natural killer cells cytotoxic to human fetal fibroblasts utilizing adsorption-elution of the effector cells from target cell-coated beads. The cell associated with enriched cytotoxicity was slightly larger than small- to medium-sized lymphocytes, the cytoplasm was pale and characteristically granular. In direct surface marker analysis the cell was Fc-receptor-positive, formed E-rosettes, and displayed strong either diffuse or granular ANAE reactivity in the cytoplasm. The ANAE reactivity could not be inhibited with sodium fluoride and in mitogen and antigen stimulation experiments the cell had T-cell characteristicis. The cell type was termed large granular lymphocyte and we suggest that it is the main direct effector cell for natural killer activity against human fetal fibroblasts.     

Expression of Thy 1 thymocyte differentiation antigen in mouse mammary cancer cells in vitro

Allogeneic AKR-anti C3H Thy 1.2 antigen serum and monoclonal anti-Thy 1.2 and anti-Thy 1.1 antigen antibodies were used to study the expression of lymphocyte differentiation antigen in a clonal mammary carcinoma cell line originated from a GR/mt stable cell line. Both allogeneic antiserum and monoclonal anti-Thy 1.2 (but not Thy 1.1) antibody were active with the hormone-treated fixed cells in an indirect immunofluorescence test. However, antigen on the cellular membranes could be detected only with the use of allogeneic (but not with monoclonal antibody) anti-Thy 1.2 serum.     

In vitro natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity against Candida albicans: macrophage precursors as effector cells

Bone marrow cells, cultured in L-929 CSF, consist of cells of granulocyte and macrophage lineages. Cells of the granulocyte lineage are known to be cytotoxic for Candida albicans. In this paper we report that macrophage precursor cells also display strong cell-mediated cytotoxicity against the yeast form of the dimorphic fungus C. albicans. The macrophage precursors responsible for this activity are nylon wool-nonadherent, nonphagocytic cells and lack asialo GM1 surface antigen. A purified population of macrophage precursors (greater than 95%) was obtained by means of Percoll density centrifugation. The interaction of these purified effectors with the target yeast cells was analyzed at a single cell level, and their activity was compared with that displayed by cells of the granulocytic series derived from the same bone marrow culture. Macrophage precursor cells proved to be more effective in binding the target cells and showed the same killing ability as the granulocytes: macrophage precursors were not damaged by contact with the target, in contrast to that which happened with granulocytes. In a long-term colony-forming unit assay, in fact, granulocytic cells showed a decrease over time in their ability to inhibit the growth of C. albicans, probably due to cell damage and death after the interaction with the target. In contrast, no loss of activity was observed with the macrophage precursor fraction. The same macrophage precursor cells also proved able to exert good natural killer activity against YAC-1 lymphoma cells, but not against P815 mastocytoma cells, as reported previously. The macrophage precursor cells, when cultivated in vitro to mature macrophages, lost completely their natural cytotoxicity against C. albicans and YAC-1 cells. The implications of these findings, as well as the possible role in vivo of such a precursor cell population during an infection, are discussed.     

Human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity against fetal fibroblasts. II. Isolation and target cell specificity of the effector cells.

Human peripheral Wood lymphocytes were depleted of natural killer cells cytotoxic against human fetal fibroblasts by allowing them to attack the fibroblast targets grown on plastic beads followed by gravity sedimentation under conditions in which single cells floated but the attacker cells sedimented with the carrier beads. The attacker cells could be released from the bead-grown targets and shown to be greatly enriched in natural cytotoxic activity. The effector cells depleted by fibroblast adsorption were also depleted of cytotoxic activity against other monolayer targets whereas suspension grown lymphoma and leukemia cells (MOLT-4, RAJI, and K-562) were killed as effectively as by non-depleted effector cells. In competition assays other monolayer cells inhibited the natural cytotoxicity against fetal fibroblasts but the suspension-grown cells were unable to compete. The results suggested that different effector cell populations were probably involved when monolayer vs suspension targets were used in assays for human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity. The separation was not, however, functionally complete since in competition assays with suspension-grown target cells also monolayer cells were able to compete. Preliminary morphological characterization of the natural killer cells against fetal fibroblasts is also presented.     

Natural cytotoxicity against mouse hepatitis virus-infected cells. II. A cytotoxic effector cell with a B lymphocyte phenotype

The effector cell in mouse spleen which mediates natural cytotoxicity against mouse hepatitis virus (MHV)-infected target cells was characterized. The target cells were MHV-infected BALB/c 3T3, and the assay time was 3 hr. The effector cell, designated virus killer (VK) cell for the purpose of discussion, had the following phenotype: lymphocyte morphology, plastic-nonadherent, nylon wool-adherent, nonphagocytic, cyclophosphamide-sensitive; by antibody plus complement (C) depletion studies, it was asialo GM1-, NK 1.2 alloantigen-negative, Thy-1.2-, Lyt-5-, and macrophage antigen-negative; by rosetting techniques, it was Fc receptor-positive and surface Fab+; by flow cytometry (FACS) analysis, it was Lyt-2-, MAC-1-, Ia+, IgG (gamma)+, IgM (mu)+, IgD (delta)+, and B cell lineage antibody B-220+. NK cells, measured for cytotoxicity on YAC-1 cells, were similarly tested and were found to differ from the VK cell in the following properties: nylon wool-nonadherent, asialo GM1+, NK alloantigen-positive, Lyt-5+, surface Fab-, MAC-1+, Ia-, IgG-, IgM-, IgD-, and B-220-. The VK effector cell had a phenotype highly distinguishable from NK cells, effectors most commonly associated with antiviral natural cytotoxicity. The VK cell had a phenotype identical to that of a B lymphocyte and was identified as such. Although the effector cells displayed cell surface antibody, the antibody did not appear to be involved in lysis, because lysis could not be blocked by F(ab)'2 directed against Fab, mu, or delta. Cytotoxicity was more likely associated with recognition of the B lymphocyte surface by the MHV glycoprotein E2, as shown in the accompanying companion paper. This is the first demonstration that natural cytotoxicity can be mediated by B lymphocytes.     

Interleukin-1 alpha and tumor necrosis factor-alpha protect cells against natural killer cell-mediated cytotoxicity and natural killer cytotoxic factor

The protective effects of interferons (IFNs) against NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity (NK-CMC) is well established. We report here that both recombinant tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and recombinant interleukin-1 alpha (IL-1 alpha) can also protect some adherent target cells (e.g., the amniotic cells WISH and the cervical epithelial carcinoma cells HeLa-229) from NK-CMC in a dose-dependent manner. Like in the case of IFNs, the level of conjugate formation between target and effector cells (nonadherent peripheral blood lymphocytes) is not affected by pretreatment of the target cells with either TNF-alpha or IL-1 alpha. However, while the main effect of IFNs is to reduce the ability of target cells to stimulate the release of NK cytotoxic factor (NKCF) from effector cells, TNF-alpha and IL-1 alpha do not affect this process but rather reduce the target cell sensitivity to the lytic effect of NKCF. Therefore TNF-alpha and IL-1 alpha induce resistance to NK-CMC by a mechanism that differs from the one attributed to IFNs. The protective effect of TNF-alpha and IL-1 alpha is not mediated by the induction of IFN-beta 2/IL-6.     

Antibody production useful for cytotoxicity against mouse MM2 tumor cells by peritoneal macrophages.

We applied an antibody-dependent macrophage-mediated cytotoxicity (ADMC) test in order to analyze the effector mechanism of the host-mediated antitumor effects induced by OK-432. Adherent peritoneal exudate (PE) cells were obtained from each of high (C3H/He) and low (B10) responder mice treated with OK-432, and 51Cr-labeled MM2 tumor cells were used as target cells. The cytotoxic activity in vitro coincided well with the results obtained in in vivo antitumor experiments. When adherent PE cells from C3H/He mice reacted with anti-MM2 serum from B10 mice, the degree of ADMC was significantly lower than that obtained with the anti-MM2 serum from C3H/He mice. The removal of IgG1 from the anti-MM2 serum induced in B10 mice resulted in the enhancement of ADMC activity. Then mean level of IgG2 in each of anti-MM2 sera from C3H/He and B10 mice was higher than in normal serum, and the IgG1 level in the antiserum from B10 mice was also higher than that in the serum from normal B10 mice. The present work suggested that the active component(s) in anti-MM2 serum participating in ADMC was a specific antibody of the IgG2 subclass, and that the inhibiting factor(s) was the IgG1 subclass.     

In vitro enhancement of natural and antibody-dependent lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity against tumor target cells by interferon.

Interferon derived from virus-infected human leukocytes or fibroblasts was found to enhance spontaneous and antibody-dependent lymphocyte cytotoxicity against human target cell lines in vitro. The greater enhancement occurred with spontaneous lymphocyte cytotoxicity. Interferon exerted its effect directly on lymphocytes; no effect on target cells was seen. The mechanism of enhancement was unclear: It did not reflect antibody production or lymphocyte proliferation. Enhancement appeared to be immunologically nonspecific, but clarification of this effect awaits further study.     

The influence of tumor growth on natural cytotoxicity and activity of some lysosomal enzymes of human effector cells and the C3HA mouse splenocytes

In the course of malignant growth processes in patients with lung cancer, a decrease of natural cytotoxic activity of peripheral blood lymphocytes was observed. This process was accompanied by changes of activities of two lysosomal enzymes, arylsulfatase and acid phosphatase, suggesting participation of these enzymes in manifestation of effector functions of lymphocytes in cancer patients. The level of activity of granular enzyme, beta-glucuronidase, remained unchanged at all stages of disease. A study of natural killer activity of C3HA mice splenocytes after inoculation of transplantable hepatoma 22-a cells revealed a relative stability of the level of their cytotoxicity, and of the activities of lysosomal enzymes--arylsulfatase, acid phosphatase, alpha-mannosidase, acid lipase, N-acetyl-beta-D-glucosidase, and beta-galactosidase, beginning from the 3rd day after hepatoma implantation.     

Monocyte- and natural killer cell-mediated spontaneous cytotoxicity against human noncultured solid tumor cells

Unstimulated human peripheral blood mononuclear cells from healthy donors exhibited spontaneous cytotoxicity against noncultured solid tumor targets in a 12- to 24-hr 51Cr release or 111In release assay. Both purified monocytes (greater than 99% monocytes) and natural killer (NK)-enriched lymphocytes exhibited comparable levels of spontaneous cytotoxicity against fresh melanoma tumor targets. This cytotoxicity was observed under endotoxin-free conditions. NK-depleted lymphocytes did not lyse the melanoma targets. Culture supernatants of monocytes incubated with the melanoma tumor cells did not exhibit cytotoxic activity against these targets. Purified monocytes lacked NK activity against the K562 targets in a 4-hr 51Cr release assay. Treatment of the monocytes with anti-Leu 1 1b and anti-Leu7 monoclonal antibodies plus complement did not reduce monocyte-mediated lysis of the melanoma targets, demonstrating that contaminating NK cells, if any, were not responsible for the lysis of noncultured melanoma targets by monocytes. In contrast, Leu 1 1b+ NK cells were responsible for the lysis of the melanoma targets by NK-enriched lymphocytes. The addition of recombinant interferon-gamma (rIFN-gamma), but not lipopolysaccharide, into the 51Cr release assay or pretreatment of monocytes with rIFN-gamma significantly increased their cytotoxicity against noncultured solid tumor cells. Monocytes cultured for 3 days with medium alone lost their cytotoxic activity. The addition of rIFN-gamma from the beginning of these cultures prevented the loss of the cytotoxic activity of monocytes. In summary, both unstimulated monocytes and NK-enriched lymphocytes exhibit comparable levels of spontaneous cytotoxicity against fresh solid tumor targets.     

Decay-accelerating factor expression on either effector or target cells inhibits cytotoxicity by human natural killer cells.

Previous studies have shown that freshly isolated CD16+ NK cells are deficient in the expression of decay-accelerating factor (DAF), or CD55, a membrane regulator of C3 activation. In this study we investigated the significance, for NK cell-mediated lysis, of DAF expression on the target and effector cells. The effect of DAF expression on the susceptibility of NK cell targets was investigated by several means: first, DAF- cell lines were cloned from K562; second, the cloned DAF- cells were reconstituted with exogenous purified DAF; and third, anti-DAF F(ab')2 was used to block DAF function on the DAF+ K562 cells. Consistently, the presence of DAF in the target cell membrane, either naturally occurring or experimentally incorporated, afforded the target cell protection against lysis, and this protection could be blocked with anti-DAF. Similarly, targets for antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity with exogenous DAF incorporated in their plasma membrane became less sensitive to antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity by NK cells compared with the same target cells without incorporated DAF in their membranes. DAF incorporated in the plasma membranes of the effector NK cells made the NK cells less effective at killing K562 targets. The known function of DAF is to regulate C3 activation, and we were able to demonstrate that the isolated NK cell is capable of releasing C3. It is also possible that the participation of DAF in NK cell function represents a new, noncomplement-dependent function for DAF.     

Density gradient fractionation of effector cells in human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity

In order to separate and characterize cytotoxic effector cells in natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity (NCMC), human lymphocytes were fractionated by Percoll continuous density gradient centrifugation (Pharmacia, Piscataway, N.J.). Lymphocytes from normal donors were fractionated through a 35-ml gradient and 2- or 3-ml aliquots were collected, counted, and grouped into three or more fractions in order to obtain sufficient cells for testing. Fractions of cells were tested for cytotoxicity in a 4-hr chromium release test and/or a 40-hr [³H]proline assay. Cell markers were assessed by testing for cells forming E rosettes, EA rosettes, and for cells with surface membrane immunoglobulin (SMIg). The lightest fraction contained larger cells and also usually contained the highest concentrations of cells with receptors for the Fc portion of IgG (FcR + cells), although slight variations were seen among individual donors. Results of cytotoxicity tests showed that cells from the top portions of the Percoll gradient had consistently greater cytotoxic activity on a per cell basis than the denser cells sedimenting lower. Estimation of cytotoxic activity in lytic units showed that 54–75% of the activity was recovered in the top 26–29% of the cells. This approach to investigating cell-mediated cytotoxicity should yield useful information regarding cellular interaction in, and regulation of, cytotoxic activities.     

Identification of effector cells for TNFalpha-mediated cytotoxicity against WEHI164S cells

WEHI164S cells were found to be very sensitive targets for in vitro killing in a 6-h culture when liver or splenic lymphocytes were used as effector cells in mice. Of particular interest, a limiting cell-dilution analysis showed that effector cells were present in the liver with a high frequency (1/4,300). In contrast to YAC-1 cells as NK targets, perforin-based cytotoxicity was not highly associated with WEHI164S killing. The major killer mechanism for WEHI164S targets was TNFalpha-mediated cytotoxicity. By cell sorting experiments, both NK cells and intermediate T cells (i.e., TCR(int) cells) were found to contain effector cells against WEHI164S cells. However, the killer mechanisms underlying these effector cells were different. Namely, NK cells killed WEHI164S cells by perforin-based cytotoxicity, TNFalpha-mediated cytotoxicity, Fas ligand cytotoxicity, and other mechanisms, whereas intermediate T cells did so mainly by TNFalpha-mediated cytotoxicity. These results suggest that TNFalpha-mediated cytotoxicity mediated by so-called natural cytotoxic (NC) cells comprised events which were performed by both NK and intermediate T cells using somewhat different killer mechanisms. Intermediate T cells which were present in the liver were able to produce TNFalpha if there was appropriate stimulation.     

Identification and separation of Thy-1 positive mouse spleen cells active in natural cytotoxicity and antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity.

The expression of the Thy-1 antigen on mouse spleen cells responsible for NK activity and ADCC was investigated by using a monoclonal IgM anti-Thy-1.2 antibody. Both C-mediated cytotoxicity and the fluorescence-activated cell sorter were used to fractionate cells. The effector cells were found to be heterogeneous in their expression of Thy-1. Effector cells from nude BALB/c mice were predominantly Thy-1 positive; some of the NK cells in CBA spleens appeared to be Thy-1 positive, but at least one-third of the lytic activity was due to Thy-1 negative cells. The effects of treatments on NK cytotoxicity and ADCC were very similar, supporting the hypothesis that the same cells mediate both activities.     

Effect of lentinan on macrophage cytotoxicity against metastatic tumor cells

We studied the effect of lentinan, a fungal polysaccharide immunomodulator, on mouse peritoneal macrophages. The i.p. treatment of mice with 10 mg/kg lentinan affected the number, plastic-adherence, and endogen peroxidase activity of peritoneal cells. The cytotoxicity of lentinan-stimulated peritoneal macrophages was determined against several murine and human metastatic tumor targets: Lewis lung carcinoma (LLT) and two human melanomas, and was found to be significantly higher than that of the macrophages from control animals. However, the highly metastatic variant of LLT (LLT-HH) was resistant to the cytolytic effect of resident and lentinan-activated macrophages as well, indicating that the stimulation for cytotoxicity depends not only on the functional activity of the effector but also on the sensitivity of the target.     

Pharmacogenomic and molecular docking studies on the cytotoxicity of the natural steroid wortmannin against multidrug-resistant tumor cells

Wortmannin is a cytotoxic compound derived from the endophytic fungi Fusarium oxysporum, Penicillium wortmannii and Penicillium funiculosum that occurs in many plants, including medicinal herbs. The rationale to develop novel anticancer drugs is the frequent development of tumor resistance to the existing antineoplasic agents. Therefore, it is mandatory to analyze resistance mechanisms of novel drug candidates such as wortmannin as well to bring effective drugs into the clinic that have the potential to bypass or overcome resistance to established drugs and to substantially increase life span of cancer patients. In the present project, we found that P-glycoprotein-overexpressing tumor cells displaying the classical multidrug resistance phenotype toward standard anticancer drugs were not cross-resistant to wortmannin. Furthermore, three point-mutated PIK3CA protein structures revealed similar binding energies to wortmannin than wild-type PIK3CA. This protein is the primary target of wortmannin and part of the PI3K/AKT/mTOR signaling pathway. PIK3CA mutations are known to be associated with worse response to therapy and shortened its activity toward wild-type and mutant PIK3CA with similar efficacy.     

The nature of the effector cells mediating mitogen-induced cellular cytotoxicity (MICC) and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC).

The nature of the cell types capable of mediating mitogen-induced cellular cytotoxicity (MICC) and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) was investigated utilizing effector cells from athymic nude and euthymic heterozygous control littermate mice as well as Sephadex anti-Fab immunoabsorbent column purified spleen cell populations from normal (CS7BL/6) mice. Chicken erythrocytes (CRBC) and the mouse lymphoma, EL-4, were used as target cells in both cytotoxicity assays. MICC utilizing CRBC targets was mediated by several effector cell types whereas MICC utilizing EL-4 lymphoma targets was T-cell dependent. ADCC against both CRBC and EL-4 lymphoma targets occurred independently of the presence of T-cells. In addition, effector cell populations incapable of mediating MICC against EL-4 lymphoma targets were capable of mediating ADCC against the same EL-4 targets. Thus, utilizing the appropriate target cells, EL-4 but not CRBC, a sharp distinction can be made between the effectors for ADCC and MICC: ADCC is T-cell independent while MICC is dependent on the presence of mature thymus-derived cells. Furthermore these studies demonstrate that the nature of the target cell employed in MICC and ADCC reactions plays a critical role in defining the types of effector cells capable of mediating these cytotoxicity reactions.