Understanding Guyton's venous return curves

Based on observations that as cardiac output (as determined by an artificial pump) was experimentally increased the right atrial pressure decreased, Arthur Guyton and coworkers proposed an interpretation that right atrial pressure represents a back pressure restricting venous return (equal to cardiac output in steady state). The idea that right atrial pressure is a back pressure limiting cardiac output and the associated idea that "venous recoil" does work to produce flow have confused physiologists and clinicians for decades because Guyton's interpretation interchanges independent and dependent variables. Here Guyton's model and data are reanalyzed to clarify the role of arterial and right atrial pressures and cardiac output and to clearly delineate that cardiac output is the independent (causal) variable in the experiments. Guyton's original mathematical model is used with his data to show that a simultaneous increase in arterial pressure and decrease in right atrial pressure with increasing cardiac output is due to a blood volume shift into the systemic arterial circulation from the systemic venous circulation. This is because Guyton's model assumes a constant blood volume in the systemic circulation. The increase in right atrial pressure observed when cardiac output decreases in a closed circulation with constant resistance and capacitance is due to the redistribution of blood volume and not because right atrial pressure limits venous return. Because Guyton's venous return curves have generated much confusion and little clarity, we suggest that the concept and previous interpretations of venous return be removed from educational materials.     

Left ventricular reflex control of venous return and systemic vascular capacitance in dogs

The reflex effects of left ventricular distension on venous return, vascular capacitance, vascular resistance, and sympathetic efferent nerve activity were examined in dogs anesthetized with sodium pentobarbital. In addition, the interaction of left ventricular distension and the carotid sinus baroreflex was examined. Vascular capacitance was assessed by measuring changes in systemic blood volume, using extracorporeal circulation with constant cardiac output and constant central venous pressure. Left ventricular distension produced by balloon inflation caused a transient biphasic change in venous return; an initial small increase was followed by a late relatively large decrease. Left ventricular distension increased systemic blood volume by 3.8 +/- 0.6 mL/kg and decreased systemic blood pressure by 27 +/- 2 mmHg (1 mmHg = 133.3 Pa) at an isolated carotid sinus pressure of 50 mmHg. These changes were accompanied by a simultaneous decrease in sympathetic efferent nerve activity. When the carotid sinus pressure was increased to 125 and 200 mmHg, these responses were attenuated. It is suggested that left ventricular mechanoreceptors and carotid baroreceptors contribute importantly to the control of venous return and vascular capacitance.     

Efficacy of neurogenic and humoral stimuli in venous return in cats

Humoral stimuli (i.v. adrenaline) proved to exert a greater effect on venous return in anesthetized cats than neurogenic those (electrical stimulation of either brain stem or femoral nerve). The part of cardiac output, however, in arterial blood shifts was the same. The latter finding is, probably, due to a discrepancy between changes occurring in the venous return and cardiac output caused by blood detention within the lung circulation as well as by an elevation of the blood pressure.     

Participation of the cava vein blood flow in forming the total venous return under influence of different modality stimuli on the circulation system

Participation of the anterior and posterior veins cava in forming the total venous return under pressor and depressor effects, stimulation of depressing foci of the medulla's ventral part, enhancement of pulmonary ventilation, hypoxia, hypothermia, administration of acetylcholine, histamine, corinfar, was shown to depend on the blood flow shift direction in each of the veins cava, dynamics of shifts' development in time, and intensity of the stimulus. In systemic responses, the blood flow shifts in the vena cava anterior much contribute to the total venous return at the maximum of the systemic arterial pressure rise (r = 0.87) whereas contribution of the vena cava posterior is the greatest during a later occurring increase in the venous return (r = 0.84). Along with increase in the stimulus intensity the vena cava anterior's part in forming the venous return becomes more limited whereas that of the vena cava posterior is enhanced.     

The venous circulation: a piscine perspective

Vascular capacitance describes the pressure–volume relationship of the circulatory system. The venous vasculature, which is the main capacitive region in the circulation, is actively controlled by various neurohumoral systems. In terrestrial animals, vascular capacitance control is crucial to prevent orthostatic blood pooling in dependent limbs, while in aquatic animals like fish, the effects of gravity are cancelled out by hydrostatic forces making orthostatic blood pooling an unlikely concern for these animals. Nevertheless, changes in venous capacitance have important implications on cardiovascular homeostasis in fish since it affects venous return and cardiac filling pressure (i.e. central venous blood pressure), which in turn may affect cardiac output. The mean circulatory filling pressure is used to estimate vascular capacitance. In unanaesthetized animals, it is measured as the central venous plateau pressure during a transient stoppage of cardiac output. So far, most studies of venous function in fish have addressed the situation in teleosts (notably the rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss), while any information on elasmobranchs, cyclostomes and air-breathing fishes is more limited. This review describes venous haemodynamic concepts and neurohumoral control systems in fish. Particular emphasis is placed on venous responses to natural cardiovascular challenges such as exercise, environmental hypoxia and temperature changes.     

Changes in the major circulation vessel capacity and their role in forming the venous return shifts under the effect of catecholamines

The study relates to characteristics of the major circulation vessel capacity and their part in forming the venous return shifts under the effect of catecholamines. In anesthetized cats, using the developed technique of controlled experiment enabling to stabilize the blood flow in the circulation arterial segment, fulfilling of pressor responses to i. v. administration of noradrenaline, adrenaline was found to increase the venous return, on the average, by 40% by means of changes in the major circulation vessel capacity (its venous segment, mainly). About 5% of the blood volume seems to become mobilized in the animal organism.     

Blood volume, the venous system, preload, and cardiac output

Cardiac output is determined by heart rate, by contractility (maximum systolic elastance, Emax) and afterload, and by diastolic ventricular compliance and preload. These relationships are illustrated using the pressure-volume loop. Diastolic compliance and Emax place limits determined by the heart within which the pressure-volume loop must lie. End-diastolic and end-systolic pressures and hence the exact position of the loop within these limits are determined by the peripheral circulation. In the presence of minimal sympathetic tone, some 60% of total blood volume is hemodynamically inactive and constitutes a blood volume reserve (the unstressed volume). The remainder of the blood volume (the stressed volume) and the compliance of the venous system determine the venous pressure. This venous pressure together with venous resistance determines venous return, right atrial pressure, cardiac preload, and hence cardiac output. Venoconstriction causes conversion of unstressed volume to the stressed volume, the blood volume reserve is converted into hemodynamically active blood volume. After hemorrhage this replaces the lost stressed volume, while in other situations where total blood volume is not reduced, it allows a sustained increase in cardiac output. The major blood volume reserve is in the splanchnic bed: the liver and intestine, and in animals but not man, the spleen. A major unsolved problem is how the conversion of unstressed volume to stressed volume by venoconstriction is reflexly controlled.     

Comparative effects of vasodilator drugs on flow distribution and venous return

Systemic vascular effects of hydralazine, prazosin, captopril, and nifedipine were studied in 115 anesthetized dogs. Blood flow (Q) and right atrial pressure (Pra) were independently controlled by a right heart bypass. Transient changes in central blood volume after an acute reduction in Pra at a constant Q showed that blood was draining from two vascular compartments with different time constants, one fast and the other slow. At three dose levels producing comparable reductions in systemic arterial pressure (30-40% at the highest dose), these drugs had different effects on flow distribution and venous return. Hydralazine and prazosin had parallel and balanced effects on arterial resistance of the two vascular compartments, and flow distribution was unaltered. Captopril preferentially reduced arterial resistance of the compartment with a slow time constant for venous return (-26 +/- 6%, -30 +/- 6%, -50 +/- 5% at 0.02, 0.10, and 0.50 mg X kg-1 X h-1, respectively; means +/- SEM) without altering arterial resistance of the fast time-constant compartment. Blood flow to the slow time-constant compartment was increased 43 +/- 14% at the highest dose, and central blood volume was reduced 108 +/- 15 mL. In contrast, nifedipine had a balanced effect on arterial resistance with the lowest dose (0.025 mg/kg) but caused a preferential reduction in arterial resistance of the fast time-constant compartment at higher doses (-38 +/- 4% and -55 +/- 2% at 0.05 and 0.10 mg/kg, respectively). Blood flow to the slow time-constant compartment was reduced 36 +/- 5% at the highest dose of nifedipine, and central blood volume was increased 66 +/- 12 mL. Total systemic venous compliance was unaltered or slightly reduced by each of the four drugs. These results add further evidence to the hypothesis that peripheral blood flow distribution is a major determinant of venous return to the heart.     

The venous circulation: a piscine perspective.

Vascular capacitance describes the pressure-volume relationship of the circulatory system. The venous vasculature, which is the main capacitive region in the circulation, is actively controlled by various neurohumoral systems. In terrestrial animals, vascular capacitance control is crucial to prevent orthostatic blood pooling in dependent limbs, while in aquatic animals like fish, the effects of gravity are cancelled out by hydrostatic forces making orthostatic blood pooling an unlikely concern for these animals. Nevertheless, changes in venous capacitance have important implications on cardiovascular homeostasis in fish since it affects venous return and cardiac filling pressure (i.e. central venous blood pressure), which in turn may affect cardiac output. The mean circulatory filling pressure is used to estimate vascular capacitance. In unanaesthetized animals, it is measured as the central venous plateau pressure during a transient stoppage of cardiac output. So far, most studies of venous function in fish have addressed the situation in teleosts (notably the rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss), while any information on elasmobranchs, cyclostomes and air-breathing fishes is more limited. This review describes venous haemodynamic concepts and neurohumoral control systems in fish. Particular emphasis is placed on venous responses to natural cardiovascular challenges such as exercise, environmental hypoxia and temperature changes.     

Theoretical analysis of rest and exercise hemodynamics in patients with total cavopulmonary connection

The objective of this study was to determine the impact of a total cavopulmonary connection on the main hemodynamic quantities, both at rest and during exercise, when compared with normal biventricular circulation. The analysis was performed by means of a mathematical model of the cardiovascular system. The model incorporates the main parameters of systemic and pulmonary circulation, the pulsating heart, and the action of arterial and cardiopulmonary baroreflex mechanisms. Furthermore, the effect of changes in intrathoracic pressure on venous return is also incorporated. Finally, the response to moderate dynamic exercise is simulated, including the effect of a central command, local metabolic vasodilation, and the "muscle pump" mechanism. Simulations of resting conditions indicate that the action of baroreflex regulatory mechanisms alone can only partially compensate for the absence of the right heart. Cardiac output and mean systemic arterial pressure at rest show a large decrease compared with the normal subject. More acceptable hemodynamic quantity values are obtained by combining the action of regulatory mechanisms with a chronic change in parameters affecting mean filling pressure. With such changes assumed, simulations of the response to moderate exercise show that univentricular circulation exhibits a poor capacity to increase cardiac output and to sustain aerobic metabolism, especially when the oxygen consumption rate is increased above 1.2-1.3 l/min. The model ascribes the poor response to exercise in these patients to the incapacity to sustain venous return caused by the high resistance to venous return and/or to exhaustion of volume compensation reserve.     

Central venous pressure and mean circulatory filling pressure in the dogfish Squalus acanthias: adrenergic control and role of the pericardium

Subambient central venous pressure (Pven) and modulation of venous return through cardiac suction (vis a fronte) characterizes the venous circulation in sharks. Venous capacitance was estimated in the dogfish Squalus acanthias by measuring the mean circulatory filling pressure (MCFP) during transient occlusion of cardiac outflow. We tested the hypothesis that venous return and cardiac preload can be altered additionally through adrenergic changes of venous capacitance. The experiments involved the surgical opening of the pericardium to place a perivascular occluder around the conus arteriosus. Another control group was identically instrumented, but lacked the occluder, and was subjected to the same pharmacological protocol to evaluate how pericardioectomy affected cardiovascular status. Routine Pven was negative (-0.08+/-0.02 kPa) in control fish but positive (0.09+/-0.01 kPa) in the pericardioectomized group. Injections of 5 microg/kg body mass (Mb) of epinephrine and phenylephrine (100 microg/kg Mb) increased Pven and MCFP, whereas isoproterenol (1 microg/kg Mb) decreased both variables. Thus, constriction and relaxation of the venous vasculature were mediated through the respective stimulation of alpha- and beta-adrenergic receptors. Alpha-adrenergic blockade with prazosin (1 mg/kg Mb) attenuated the responses to phenylephrine and decreased resting Pven in pericardioectomized animals. Our results provide convincing evidence for adrenergic control of the venous vasculature in elasmobranchs, although the pericardium is clearly an important component in the modulation of venous function. Thus active changes in venous capacitance have previously been underestimated as an important means of modulating venous return and cardiac performance in this group.     

A critical analysis of the view that right atrial pressure determines venous return.

A. C. Guyton pioneered major advances in understanding cardiovascular equilibrium. He superimposed venous return curves on cardiac output curves to reveal their intersection at the one level of right atrial pressure (Pra) and flow simultaneously consistent with independent properties of the heart and vasculature. He showed how this point would change with altered properties of the heart (e.g., contractility, sensitivity to preload) and/or of the vasculature (e.g., resistance, total volume). In such graphical representations of negative feedback between two subdivisions of a system, one input/output relationship is necessarily plotted backward, i.e., with the input variable on the y-axis (here, the venous return curve). Unfortunately, this format encourages mistaken ideas about the role of Pra as a "back pressure," such as the assertion that elevating Pra to the level of mean systemic pressure would stop venous return. These concepts are reexamined through review of the original experiments on venous return, presentation of a hypothetical alternative way for obtaining the same data, and analysis of a simple model.     

The dynamics of venous return and response to hypervolemia in the toad, Bufo marinus (L.)

Background

Venous return from the posterior region of amphibians travels by either two renal portal veins to the kidney or a central abdominal vein that drains into the hepatic portal system. The relative proportions of blood flow in these vessels has never been measured nor has a modification of flow been determined when venous return increases by changes in blood volume during hypervolemia or during increased volume input from the posterior lymph hearts.

Results

Venous return from the posterior region of Bufo marinus was measured under resting conditions and in response to a systemic hypervolemia. Doppler flow probes were positioned on the renal portal and ventral abdominal veins, and flow was recorded as injections of artificial plasma equaling 100% of the animal's plasma volume were administered through the sciatic artery. Resting flow was found to be 5.54 ± 2.03 ml min^-1 kg^-1 in the paired renal portal veins, and 7.31 ± 0.89 ml min^-1 kg^-1 in the ventral abdominal vein. While renal portal flow was found to increase by a factor of 2.4 times during the first 10 min of hypervolemia, ventral abdominal flow only increased by a factor of 1.3.

Conclusions

Our results quantify the contribution to circulation from posterior venous return in the toad Bufo marinus. A preferential movement of excess fluid through the renal portal pathway was also demonstrated, supporting the possibility of water elimination via the renal portal circulation, especially during periods of high water influx into the animals.     

Theoretical analysis of the noncardiac limits to maximum exercise

When right atrial pressure (Pra) is greater than zero (atmospheric pressure), cardiac output is determined by the intersection of two functions, cardiac function and return function, which is used here to mean the determinants of venous return. When Pra < or = 0, flow is only determined by circuit function. The objective of this analysis was to determine the potential changes in return function that need to occur to allow the maximum cardiac output during exercise when Pra < or = 0 or is constant. The analysis expands on the model of Green and Jackman and includes the effects of changes in circuit parameters, including venous resistance, changes in capacitance, and muscle contractions. The analysis is based on the model of the circulation proposed by Permutt and co-workers, which assumes that the systemic circulation has two lumped compliant regions in parallel with independent inflow and outflow resistances. Changes in total flow in this model can come about by changes in the distribution of flow between the regions, recruitment of unstressed vascular volume, and changes in the regional venous resistances. The data for the analysis are from previous animal studies and are normalized to a 70-kg man. The major conclusions are that, to achieve the high cardiac output that occurs at peak exercise, there need to be marked changes in the distribution of blood flow, recruitment of unstressed volume, and the venous resistance draining vascular beds. A consequence of the increase in peripheral flow is a marked increase in pressure in the veins of the working muscle. Muscle contractions are potentially a very important mechanism for transiently decreasing this pressure and preventing excessive filtration of plasma during exercise.     

Effects of augmented respiratory muscle pressure production on locomotor limb venous return during calf contraction exercise.

We determined effects of augmented inspiratory and expiratory intrathoracic pressure or abdominal pressure (Pab) excursions on within-breath changes in steady-state femoral venous blood flow (Qfv) and net Qfv during tightly controlled (total breath time = 4 s, duty cycle = 0.5) accessory muscle/"rib cage" (DeltaPab <2 cmH2O) or diaphragmatic (DeltaPab >5 cmH2O) breathing. Selectively augmenting inspiratory intrathoracic pressure excursion during rib cage breathing augmented inspiratory facilitation of Qfv from the resting limb (69% and 89% of all flow occurred during nonloaded and loaded inspiration, respectively); however, net Qfv in the steady state was not altered because of slight reductions in femoral venous return during the ensuing expiratory phase of the breath. Selectively augmenting inspiratory esophageal pressure excursion during a predominantly diaphragmatic breath at rest did not alter within-breath changes in Qfv relative to nonloaded conditions (net retrograde flow = -9 +/- 12% and -4 +/- 9% during nonloaded and loaded inspiration, respectively), supporting the notion that the inferior vena cava is completely collapsed by relatively small increases in gastric pressure. Addition of inspiratory + expiratory loading to diaphragmatic breathing at rest resulted in reversal of within-breath changes in Qfv, such that >90% of all anterograde Qfv occurred during inspiration. Inspiratory + expiratory loading also reduced steady-state Qfv during mild- and moderate-intensity calf contractions compared with inspiratory loading alone. We conclude that 1) exaggerated inspiratory pressure excursions may augment within-breath changes in femoral venous return but do not increase net Qfv in the steady state and 2) active expiration during diaphragmatic breathing reduces the steady-state hyperemic response to dynamic exercise by mechanically impeding venous return from the locomotor limb, which may contribute to exercise limitation in health and disease.     

Influence of positive airway pressure on the pressure gradient for venous return in humans.

To study the effect of positive airway pressure (Paw) on the pressure gradient for venous return [the difference between mean systemic filling pressure (Pms) and right atrial pressure (Pra)], we investigated 10 patients during general anesthesia for implantation of defibrillator devices. Paw was varied under apnea from 0 to 15 cmH(2)O, which increased Pra from 7.3 +/- 3.1 to 10.0 +/- 2.3 mmHg and decreased left ventricular stroke volume by 23 +/- 22%. Episodes of ventricular fibrillation, induced for defibrillator testing, were performed during 0- and 15-cmH(2)O Paw to measure Pms (value of Pra 7.5 s after onset of circulatory arrest). Positive Paw increased Pms from 10.2 +/- 3.5 to 12.7 +/- 3.2 mmHg, and thus the pressure gradient for venous return (Pms - Pra) remained unchanged. Echocardiography did not reveal signs of vascular collapse of the inferior and superior vena cava due to lung expansion. In conclusion, we demonstrated that positive Paw equally increases Pra and Pms in humans and alters venous return without changes in the pressure gradient (Pms - Pra).     

Arterial versus venous changes in vascular capacitance during nitroprusside infusion: a vascular modelling study.

The distributions of nitroprusside (NP) induced changes in vascular capacitance, arterial versus venous, are unknown. We measured canine ileal arterial and venous pressures and total (isolated loop) vascular volumes (scintigraphy), before and during NP infusion. NP sufficient to decrease perfusion pressure by 30% increased total vascular volume to 111 +/- 3% (+/- SEM) of control (p < 0.01). Increasing flow to restore perfusion pressure increased volume 4% more (p < 0.01). Assuming a two-compartment model and on the basis of the literature data, changes in venous capacitance were estimated and compared with arterial capacitance. During constant-flow perfusion, NP increased venous volume by 10.0% (vs. 18.1%, arterial). When flow was increased to restore pressure, venous volume increased by another 3.7% (vs. 2.6%, arterial). Assuming an original arterial to venous volume ratio of 133/1033, the final, constant-pressure increase in venous volume was almost 4 times the arterial increase. In conclusion, the increase in vascular volume during NP infusion was due primarily to similar-magnitude, active increases in venous and arterial capacitances (i.e., rightward shifts in pressure-volume relations). However, as venous volume is so much larger than arterial, the NP-induced increase in venous volume was greater.     

Vacuum-assisted perfusion of the dog hindlimb

A method for rapidly changing perfusion pressure to the relatively intact dog hindlimb using vacuum assistance is proposed and demonstrated. The hindlimb of an anesthetized dog is inserted into a rigid sealed enclosure for application of a partial vacuum. The circulation of the hindlimb remains entirely intact except for a single large noncollapsible catheter placed in the femoral vein and connected to a servo-pump. The servo-pump maintains the venous pressure equal to the enclosure pressure even when this pressure is in the partial vacuum state. The automatically adjusted pumping rate of this pump also provides a continuous measure of the blood flow in the limb as it returns the blood via a jugular catheter. In nine dogs the systemic arterial pressure was maintained constant, and the enclosure pressure and venous pressure were set to subatmospheric levels, thus changing the perfusion pressure to any desired value up to 220 mmHg. The procedure had minimal impact on the central circulation, suggesting that the technique may be useful in studying hemodynamics of the hindlimb or other organs at high perfusion pressure, which has always been difficult to achieve experimentally. In the nine dogs, blood flow responses were observed at both elevated and reduced perfusion pressure. The changes in measured blood flow induced by the changes in perfusion pressure were variable but were generally directly proportional to perfusion pressure in the steady state.     

Effects of hypoxia on the venous circulation in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Hypoxia in fish is generally associated with bradycardia while cardiac output (Q) remains unaltered or slightly increased due to a compensatory increase in stroke volume (SV). Rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) were subjected to severe (P(W)O2=7.3+/-0.2 kPa) or mild (P(W)O2=11.5+/-0.2 kPa) hypoxia. Central venous pressure (P(ven)), dorsal aortic pressure (P(da)), heart rate (f(H)) and Q, were recorded in vivo. Both levels of hypoxia triggered a significant increase in P(ven). Severe hypoxia was associated with bradycardia and unaltered Q, whereas mild hypoxia was associated with a small but significant increase in Q and no bradycardia. These findings indicate that an increase in P(ven) promotes an increase in SV during hypoxia. Since mild hypoxia increased P(ven), Q and SV without bradycardia or reduced systemic resistance (R(sys)), we hypothesize that an active increase in venous tone serving to mobilize blood to the central venous compartment in order to increase cardiac preload and consequently SV, is an important cardiovascular trait associated with hypoxia. Pharmacological pre-treatment with prazosin (1 mg kg(-1)) did not conclusively reveal the underlying mechanisms to the observed changes in P(ven). This study discusses the influence of venous pooling, reduced R(sys) and altered venous tone on changes in P(ven) observed during hypoxia.     

RV filling modulates LV function by direct ventricular interaction during mechanical ventilation

During mechanical ventilation, phasic changes in systemic venous return modulate right ventricular output but may also affect left ventricular function by direct ventricular interaction. In 13 anesthetized, closed-chest, normal dogs, we measured inferior vena cava flow and left and right ventricular dimensions and output during mechanical ventilation, during an inspiratory hold, and (during apnea) vena caval constriction and abdominal compression. During a single ventilation cycle preceded by apnea, positive pressure inspiration decreased caval flow and right ventricular dimension; the transseptal pressure gradient increased, the septum shifted rightward, reflecting an increased left ventricular volume (the anteroposterior diameter did not change); and stroke volume increased. The opposite occurred during expiration. Similarly, the maneuvers that decreased venous return shifted the septum rightward, and left ventricular volume and stroke volume increased. Increased venous return had opposite effects. Changes in left ventricular function caused by changes in venous return alone were similar to those during mechanical ventilation except for minor quantitative differences. We conclude that phasic changes in systemic venous return during mechanical ventilation modulate left ventricular function by direct ventricular interaction.