Characterisation of Peptide Microarrays for Studying Antibody-Antigen Binding Using Surface Plasmon Resonance Imagery

Background

Non-specific binding to biosensor surfaces is a major obstacle to quantitative analysis of selective retention of analytes at immobilized target molecules. Although a range of chemical antifouling monolayers has been developed to address this problem, many macromolecular interactions still remain refractory to analysis due to the prevalent high degree of non-specific binding. We describe how we use the dynamic process of the formation of self assembling monolayers and optimise physical and chemical properties thus reducing considerably non-specific binding and allowing analysis of specific binding of analytes to immobilized target molecules.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We illustrate this approach by the production of specific protein arrays for the analysis of interactions between the 65kDa isoform of human glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65) and a human monoclonal antibody. Our data illustrate that we have effectively eliminated non-specific interactions with the surface containing the immobilised GAD65 molecules. The findings have several implications. First, this approach obviates the dubious process of background subtraction and gives access to more accurate kinetic and equilibrium values that are no longer contaminated by multiphase non-specific binding. Second, an enhanced signal to noise ratio increases not only the sensitivity but also confidence in the use of SPR to generate kinetic constants that may then be inserted into van''t Hoff type analyses to provide comparative ΔG, ΔS and ΔH values, making this an efficient, rapid and competitive alternative to ITC measurements used in drug and macromolecular-interaction mechanistic studies. Third, the accuracy of the measurements allows the application of more intricate interaction models than simple Langmuir monophasic binding.

Conclusions

The detection and measurement of antibody binding by the type 1 diabetes autoantigen GAD65 represents an example of an antibody-antigen interaction where good structural, mechanistic and immunological data are available. Using SPRi we were able to characterise the kinetics of the interaction in greater detail than ELISA/RIA methods. Furthermore, our data indicate that SPRi is well suited to a multiplexed immunoassay using GAD65 proteins, and may be applicable to other biomarkers.     

Immobilization of the glutathione by the complementary coordination binding

A simple method for immobilization of biologically imporant molecules with many functional fragments by selective binding of their thiogroups with the surface caroxyl groups by cadmium ions was proposed. Biofunctional properties of these structures were studied by surface plasmon resonance method on the model of the glutathione (GSH), which was immobilized by means of mixed (a:b form 1:100 o 1:700) thiol monolayers with terminal groups of the methyl/hydroxyl (b) and carboxyl (a) type. The maintenance of the biofunctional conformation ofglutathione-S-transferase (GST) after its interaction with GSH was checked by the use of specific anti-GST antibodies. It was shown that CH3 matrix has considerable non-specific binding and is not suitable for the formation of the biofunctional GST layer. At the same time OH-based structures demonstrate specific interaction GST-anti-GST, the stoichiometry of which corresponds to the bidentate binding. Considered simple method of the immobilization can be used to create the functional surface architectures in the analyticasl biochemistry and chemical analysis.     

Surface plasmon resonance for probing quadruplex folding and interactions with proteins and small molecules

Surface plasmon resonance is a technique for detecting binding events at the surface of a thin metal film. Through the commercial availability of instrumentation and sensor chips, the technique has found widespread application for determining the affinity and kinetics of macromolecular interactions. A variety of quadruplex forming oligonucleotides have been immobilized to sensor chips to permit analysis of their binding interactions with both small molecule and protein analytes. The fold of the quadruplex must be maintained through an appropriate choice of buffer, and care must be taken to ensure that data interpretation is not hampered by non-specific binding and adsorption of the analyte to the sensor surface and instrument. Affinity constants determined by surface plasmon resonance for interactions with quadruplexes correlate meaningfully with other methods, such as UV-visible and fluorescence titrations, enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, thermal melting studies and telomerase inhibition. Kinetic measurements of the association and dissociation of duplexes of quadruplex forming oligonucleotides and their complementary strands have enabled calculation of the folding and unfolding rates of the quadruplex itself, and determination of its stability as a function of buffer composition.     

Molecular imprinting in monolayer surfaces

A comprehensive report on molecularly imprinted monolayers (MIMs) is presented, but does not include bulk-polymer thin film coatings on surfaces, inorganic surface imprinting, polymer grafting and layer-by-layer methods. Due to difficulties in imprinting large molecules and obtaining fast binding responses with traditional network polymer materials, MIMs have been developed with the aim of enhancing mass-transfer of analytes in imprinted materials. Three approaches to MIM fabrication have been developed with respect to the formation of the pre-organized template-matrix complex. In the first approach, the molecular binding sites are formed in a monolayer on a glass or gold surface. The second approach uses a template-macromolecule complex to form binding sites in the solution phase that are immobilized onto a surface; and the third approach transfers an imprinted Langmuir film onto a gold surface. Mass transfer in these MIMs in most cases is on the order of minutes, and both small and large molecules (proteins) have been imprinted.     

Affinity capillary electrophoresis: important application areas and some recent developments

Affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) is a broad term referring to the separation by capillary electrophoresis of substances that participate in specific or non-specific affinity interactions during electrophoresis. The interacting molecules can be found free in solution or can be immobilized to a solid support. Every ACE mode has advantages and disadvantages. Each can be used for a wide variety of applications. This paper focuses on applications that include purification and concentration of analytes present in diluted solutions or complex matrices, quantitation of analytes based on calibration curves, and estimation of binding constants from direct and derived binding curves based on quantitation of analytes or on analyte migration shifts. A more recent chemicoaffinity strategy in capillary electrophoresis/capillary electrochromatography (CE/CEC) termed molecular imprinting (`plastic antibodies') is discussed as well. Although most ACE studies are aimed at characterizing small-molecular mass analytes such as drugs, hormones, and peptides, some efforts have been pursued to characterize larger biopolymers including proteins, such as immunoglobulins. Examples of affinity interactions that have been studied are antigen–antibody, hapten–antibody, lectin–sugar, drug–protein, and enzyme–substrate complexes using ultraviolet, laser-induced fluorescence, and mass spectrometer detectors. This paper also addresses the critical issue of background electrolyte selection and quantitation of analytes. Specific examples of bioaffinity applications are presented, and the future of ACE in the biomedical field is discussed.     

Chemical screening by mass spectrometry to identify inhibitors of anthrax lethal factor

Mass spectrometry (MS) analysis is applicable to a broad range of biological analytes and has the important advantage that it does not require analytes to be labeled. A drawback of MS methods, however, is the need for chromatographic steps to prepare the analyte, precluding MS from being used in chemical screening and rapid analysis. Here, we report that surfaces that are chemically tailored for characterization by matrix-assisted laser-desorption ionization time-of-flight MS eliminate the need for sample processing and make this technique adaptable to parallel screening experiments. The tailored substrates are based on self-assembled monolayers that present ligands that interact with target proteins and enzymes. We apply this method to screen a chemical library against protease activity of anthrax lethal factor, and report a compound that inhibits lethal factor activity with a K(i) of 1.1 microM and blocks the cleavage of MEK1 in 293 cells.     

Aptamer-based biosensor arrays for detection and quantification of biological macromolecules

We have developed a chip-based biosensor for multiplex analysis of protein analytes. The biosensor utilizes immobilized DNA and RNA aptamers, selected against several different protein targets, to simultaneously detect and quantify levels of individual proteins in complex biological mixtures. Aptamers were each fluorescently labeled and immobilized on a glass substrate. Fluorescence polarization anisotropy was used for solid- and solution-phase measurements of target protein binding. We show that solid-phase aptamer-protein interactions recapitulate binding interactions seen in solution. Furthermore, we demonstrate specific detection and quantitation of cancer-associated proteins (inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase II, vascular endothelial factor, basic fibroblast growth factor) in the context of human serum and in cellular extracts. It is expected that this technology could speed diagnosis of cancer by enabling direct detection of the expression and modification of proteins closely correlated with disease.     

Capture molecules preconditioned for kinetic analysis of high-affinity antigen-antibody complex in Biacore A100

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is routinely applied on determining association or dissociation constant rates of antigen-antibody complexes. In a SPR system such as Biacore, the capture method is a widely accepted procedure in kinetic analysis for association or dissociation of soluble antigen analytes with antibody ligands initially captured by anti-Fc molecules immobilized on the sensor chip. Appropriate preparations of anti-immunoglobulin G (IgG)-Fc molecules on sensor chips have not been examined yet for stable kinetic analysis of antibodies with several affinities to soluble antigens. Here, we constructed murine monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) with various affinities to hen egg lysozyme (HEL) and performed kinetic analysis of these MoAbs captured by rat MoAbs against mouse IgG-Fc immobilized on the sensor chip. When capture molecules maximally immobilized on the sensor chip, we observed no apparent dissociation of MoAbs with extremely high affinity to soluble HEL antigens. In contrast, on the limited amount (1000-2000 response units) of capture molecule immobilized on the sensor chip, we could perform stable kinetic analysis of MoAbs with highest affinities to the antigen as well as those with lower or moderate binding affinities. Thus, in some cases, accurate kinetic analysis of high-affinity antibodies can be performed by minimization of capture molecule densities on the sensor chip in SPR.     

Chemical proteomics for drug discovery based on compound-immobilized affinity chromatography

Chemical proteomics is an effective approach to focused proteomics, having the potential to find specific interactors in moderate-scale comprehensive analysis. Unlike chemical genetics, chemical proteomics directly and comprehensively identifies proteins that bind specifically to candidate compounds by means of affinity chromatographic purification using the immobilized candidate, combined with mass spectrometric identification of interacting proteins. This is an effective approach for discovering unknown protein functions, identifying the molecular mechanisms of drug action, and obtaining information for optimization of lead compounds. However, immobilized-small molecule affinity chromatography always suffers from the problem of non-specific binders. Although several approaches were reported to reduce non-specific binding proteins, these are mainly focused on the use of low-binding-affinity beads or insertion of a spacer between the bead and the compound. Stable isotope labeling strategies have proven particularly advantageous for the discrimination of true interactors from many non-specific binders, including carrier proteins, such as serum albumin, and are expected to be valuable for drug discovery.     

A portable surface plasmon resonance sensor system for real-time monitoring of small to large analytes

Many environmental applications exist for biosensors capable of providing real-time analyses. One pressing current need is monitoring for agents of chemical- and bio-terrorism. These applications require systems that can rapidly detect small organics including nerve agents, toxic proteins, viruses, spores and whole microbes. A second area of application is monitoring for environmental pollutants. Processing of grab samples through chemical laboratories requires significant time delays in the analyses, preventing the rapid mapping and cleanup of chemical spills. The current state of development of miniaturized, integrated surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor elements has allowed for the development of inexpensive, portable biosensor systems capable of the simultaneous analysis of multiple analytes. Most of the detection protocols make use of antibodies immobilized on the sensor surface. The Spreeta 2000 SPR biosensor elements manufactured by Texas Instruments provide three channels for each sensor element in the system. A temperature-controlled two-element system that monitors for six analytes is currently in use, and development of an eight element sensor system capable of monitoring up to 24 different analytes will be completed in the near future. Protein toxins can be directly detected and quantified in the low picomolar range. Elimination of false positives and increased sensitivity is provided by secondary antibodies with specificity for different target epitopes, and by sensor element redundancy. Inclusion of more than a single amplification step can push the sensitivity of toxic protein detection to femtomolar levels. The same types of direct detection and amplification protocols are used to monitor for viruses and whole bacteria or spores. Special protocols are required for the detection of small molecules. Either a competition type assay where the presence of analyte inhibits the binding of antibodies to surface-immobilized analyte, or a displacement assay, where antibodies bound to analyte on the sensor surface are displaced by free analyte, can be used. The small molecule detection assays vary in sensitivity from the low micromolar range to the high picomolar.

     

A portable surface plasmon resonance sensor system for real-time monitoring of small to large analytes

Many environmental applications exist for biosensors capable of providing real-time analyses. One pressing current need is monitoring for agents of chemical- and bio-terrorism. These applications require systems that can rapidly detect small organics including nerve agents, toxic proteins, viruses, spores and whole microbes. A second area of application is monitoring for environmental pollutants. Processing of grab samples through chemical laboratories requires significant time delays in the analyses, preventing the rapid mapping and cleanup of chemical spills. The current state of development of miniaturized, integrated surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor elements has allowed for the development of inexpensive, portable biosensor systems capable of the simultaneous analysis of multiple analytes. Most of the detection protocols make use of antibodies immobilized on the sensor surface. The Spreeta 2000 SPR biosensor elements manufactured by Texas Instruments provide three channels for each sensor element in the system. A temperature-controlled two-element system that monitors for six analytes is currently in use, and development of an eight element sensor system capable of monitoring up to 24 different analytes will be completed in the near future. Protein toxins can be directly detected and quantified in the low picomolar range. Elimination of false positives and increased sensitivity is provided by secondary antibodies with specificity for different target epitopes, and by sensor element redundancy. Inclusion of more than a single amplification step can push the sensitivity of toxic protein detection to femtomolar levels. The same types of direct detection and amplification protocols are used to monitor for viruses and whole bacteria or spores. Special protocols are required for the detection of small molecules. Either a competition type assay where the presence of analyte inhibits the binding of antibodies to surface-immobilized analyte, or a displacement assay, where antibodies bound to analyte on the sensor surface are displaced by free analyte, can be used. The small molecule detection assays vary in sensitivity from the low micromolar range to the high picomolar.     

Preparation of aptamer-linked gold nanoparticle purple aggregates for colorimetric sensing of analytes

Aptamers are single-stranded DNA or RNA molecules that can bind target molecules with high affinity and specificity. The conformation of an aptamer usually changes upon binding to its target analyte, and this property has been used in a wide variety of sensing applications, including detection based on fluorescence intensity, polarization, energy transfer, electrochemistry or color change. Colorimetric sensors are particularly important because they minimize or eliminate the necessity of using expensive and complicated instruments. Among the many colorimetric sensing strategies, metallic nanoparticle-based detection is desirable because of the high extinction coefficients and strong distance-dependent optical properties of the nanoparticles. Here, we describe a protocol for the preparation of aptamer-linked gold nanoparticle purple aggregates that undergo fast disassembly into red dispersed nanoparticles upon binding of target analytes. This method has proved to be generally applicable for colorimetric sensing of a broad range of analytes. The time range for the entire protocol is approximately 5 d, including synthesis and functionalization of nanoparticles, preparation of nanoparticle aggregates and sensing.     

AFM and electroanalytical studies of synthetic oligonucleotide hybridization

The first and most important step in the development and manufacture of a sensitive DNA-biosensor for hybridization detection is the immobilization procedure of the nucleic acid probe on the transducer surface, maintaining its mobility and conformational flexibility. MAC Mode AFM images were used to demonstrate that oligonucleotide (ODN) molecules adsorb spontaneously at the electrode surface. After adsorption, the ODN layers were formed by molecules with restricted mobility, as well as by superposed molecules, which can lead to reduced hybridization efficiency. The images also showed the existence of pores in the adsorbed ODN film that revealed large parts of the electrode surface, and enabled non-specific adsorption of other ODNs on the uncovered areas. Electrostatic immobilization onto a clean glassy carbon electrode surface was followed by hybridization with complementary sequences and by control experiments with non-complementary sequences, studied using differential pulse voltammetry. The data obtained showed that non-specific adsorption strongly influenced the results, which depended on the sequence of the ODNs. In order to reduce the contribution of non-specific adsorbed ODNs during hybridization experiments, the carbon electrode surface was modified. After modification, the AFM images showed an electrode completely covered by the ODN probe film, which prevented the undesirable binding of target ODN molecules to the electrode surface. The changes of interfacial capacitance that took place after hybridization or control experiments showed the formation of a mixed multilayer that strongly depended on the local environment of the immobilized ODN.     

Enhanced immobilization of hexa-arginine-tagged esterase on gold nanoparticles using mixed self-assembled monolayers

Mixed self-assembled monolayers (MSAMs) composed of diverse ligands offer a mechanism for the specific binding of biomolecules onto solid surfaces. In this study, we examined the formation of MSAMs on gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) and the immobilization of hexa-arginine-tagged esterase (Arg₆-esterase) on the surfaces of the resulting particles. The functionalization of AuNPs with MSAMs was achieved by introducing a mixture of tethering and shielding ligands into an AuNP solution. The formation of self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) on the AuNP surface was characterized by UV/visible spectroscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. Arg₆-esterase was immobilized in a highly specific manner onto AuNPs treated with mixed SAMs (MSAM–AuNPs) by providing a shielding ligand which reduce the non-specific adsorption of enzymes caused by hydrophobic interaction compared to AuNPs treated with single-component SAMs (SSAM–AuNPs). Moreover, Arg₆-esterase immobilized on MSAM–AuNPs showed substantially enhanced catalytic activity up to an original activity compared to that on SSAM–AuNPs (58%).     

Theoretical analysis of ''addressed'' chemical modification of DNA.

Chemical "addressed" modification of DNA involves treatment of single-stranded DNA with oligonucleotides complementary to certain target sequences in this DNA and bearing a groupings reactive towards DNA bases. The binding of oligonucleotides can occur both at completely (specific) and incompletely (nonspecific) complementary sites. We analyse the modification of a fragment that is flanked by two target sequences complementary to a given oligonucleotide address, contains no more such targets and has some randomly distributed sites for nonspecific binding. Conditions for the maximum ratio between specific and non-specific modification are determined. We find the probability of both target termini being specifically modified without any non-specific modification occurring within the fragment up to a given moment in time. Quantitative analysis is based on the use of known features of the specific and non-specific binding of an oligonucleotide to DNA sites. This analysis shows the possibility of specific cutting of DNA based on addressed modification.     

Sensing with electro-switchable biosurfaces

The conformation of charged molecules tethered to conducting substrates can be controlled efficiently through the application of external voltages. Biomolecules like DNA or oligopeptides can be forced to stretch away from??or fold onto??surfaces biased at moderate potentials of merely hundreds of millivolts. These externally controlled conformation changes can be used to switch the biological function of molecular monolayers on and off, by revealing or concealing molecular recognition sites at will. Moreover, the electrical actuation of biomolecular surface probes bears great potential as a novel, label-free, yet highly sensitive measurement modality for the analysis of molecular interactions. The binding of target molecules to an oscillating probe layer significantly alters the layer??s switching behavior in terms of the conformation switching amplitude and, most remarkably, with respect to the molecular switching dynamics. Analyzing the switching response of target?Cprobe complexes from the low- to the high-frequency regime reveals a wealth of previously inaccessible information. Besides ??classical?? interaction parameters like binding affinities and kinetic rate constants, information on the size, shape, bending flexibility, and elasticity of the target molecule may be obtained in a single assay. This review describes the advent of electrically switchable biosurfaces, focusing on DNA monolayers. The preparation of self-assembled switchable oligonucleotide monolayers and their electrical interactions with charged substrates are highlighted. Special attention is paid to the merits of evaluating the dynamic response of charged biolayers which are operated at high driving frequencies. Several applications of biosensors based on electrically manipulated molecules are exemplified. It is emphasized that the electrical actuation of biomolecules bears many advantages over passive sensor surfaces.     

Multi-analyte surface plasmon resonance biosensing

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors are affinity sensing devices exploiting a special mode of electromagnetic field-surface plasmon-polariton-to detect the binding of analyte molecules from a liquid sample to biomolecular recognition elements immobilized on the surface of the sensor. In this paper, we review advances of SPR biosensor technology towards detection systems for the simultaneous detection of multiple analytes (multi-analyte detection). In addition, we report application of a recently developed multichannel SPR sensor based on spectroscopy of surface plasmons and wavelength division multiplexing of sensing channels to multi-analyte detection.     

Diazo coupling method for covalent attachment of proteins to solid substrates

We describe a process for covalently linking proteins to glass microscope slides and microbeads in a manner that optimizes the reactivity of the immobilized proteins and that is suitable for high-throughput microarray and flow cytometry analysis. The method involves the diazo coupling of proteins onto activated self-assembled monolayers formed from p-aminophenyl trimethoxysilane. Proteins immobilized by this method maintained bioactivity and produced enhanced levels of protein-protein interaction, low background fluorescence, and high selectivity. The binding of immobilized proteins to their specific binding partner was analyzed quantitatively and successfully correlated with solution concentrations. Diazotized surfaces bound more efficiently to proteins containing a hexahistidine tag than those without a his-tag. Moreover, significantly higher reactivity of the immobilized his-tagged proteins was observed on diazotized surfaces than on amine-terminated surfaces. Results suggest that his-tagged proteins are immobilized by reaction of the his-tag with the diazotized surface, thus offering the possibility for preferential orientation of covalently bound proteins.     

Antibody-antigenic peptide interactions monitored by SPR and QCM-D. A model for SPR detection of IA-2 autoantibodies in human serum

This work reports on a complementary use of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) technologies to study interactions between a peptide antigen and polyclonal antibodies, in an experimental format suitable for diagnostic assays of autoimmune diseases. In the chosen model, a synthetic peptide from the juxtamembrane region of IA-2 (a type 1 diabetes associated antigen) was immobilized by an optimized chemical protocol applicable to both BIACORE and QCM-D sensors. A thorough study of the peptide immobilization was performed to optimize the signal-to-noise ratio using mixed self-assembled monolayers (SAM) on a gold surface. Introduction of polyethylene glycol (EG₆) chains into mixed SAM layers and addition of an anionic surfactant to the human serum reduced non-specific binding without modifying the viscoelasticity properties of the layer. Under our conditions, the antibody SPR detection limit was determined to be 0.2 nM in diluted human serum. This value is in agreement with the reported rank distribution of IA-2 antibodies in diabetic patient sera. Label-free and real-time technologies such as SPR and/or QCM-D could be precious tools in future diagnostic assays.     

Measuring the Binding Stoichiometry of HIV-1 Gag to Very-Low-Density Oligonucleotide Surfaces Using Surface Plasmon Resonance Spectroscopy

The interaction of the HIV Gag polyprotein with nucleic acid is a critical step in the assembly of viral particles. The Gag polyprotein is composed of the matrix (MA), capsid (CA), and nucleocapsid (NC) domains. The NC domain is required for nucleic acid interactions, and the CA domain is required for Gag-Gag interactions. Previously, we have investigated the binding of the NC protein to d(TG)(n) oligonucleotides using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy. We found a single NC protein is able to bind to more than one immobilized oligonucleotide, provided that the oligonucleotides are close enough together. As NC is believed to be the nucleic acid binding domain of Gag, we might expect Gag to show the same complex behavior. We wished to analyze the stoichiometry of Gag binding to oligonucleotides without this complication due to tertiary complex formation. We have therefore analyzed Gag binding to extremely low oligonucleotide density on SPR chips. Such low densities of oligonucleotides are difficult to accurately quantitate. We have determined by Fourier transform ion cyclotron (FTICR) mass spectrometry that four molecules of NC bind to d(TG)(10) (a 20-base oligonucleotide). We developed a method of calibrating low-density surfaces using NC calibration injections. Knowing the maximal response and the stoichiometry of binding, we can precisely determine the amount of oligonucleotide immobilized at these very-low-density surfaces (<1 Response Unit). Using this approach, we have measured the binding of Gag to d(TG)(10). Gag binds to a 20-mer with a stoichiometry of greater than 4. This suggests that once Gag is bound to the immobilized oligonucleotide, additional Gag molecules can bind to this complex.